It's time again for our monthly GLIVESTREAM! Matt joins me again this week to Glacket alongside Gleeks: Jenna, Andrew, and Stephanie! Want a chance to come on the pod and vote in Glacket decisions? We do them once a month.... Read More
From the show: Gleek of the Week - A Glee Podcast
Featured Shows
About
It's time again for our monthly GLIVESTREAM! Matt joins me again this week to Glacket alongside Gleeks: Jenna, Andrew, and Stephanie! Want a chance to come on the pod and vote in Glacket decisions? We do them once a month.. to find out more, go to patreon.com/gleekoftheweekpod!
Songs this episode include:
- Be Okay
- Don't Stop Believin' (S1 V1)
- Forget You
- Highway to Hell
- I Won't Give Up
- Not While I'm Around
- Become a Patron for exclusive bonus episodes, guest announcements, and access to live episode recordings @ patreon.com/gleekoftheweekpod
- Rate us five stars on Spotify and Apple Podcasts
- Buy our Merch!
- Leave us a voicemail @ (732)955-4098
- Follow us on Instagram @gleekoftheweekpod
- Follow us on Tiktok @gleekoftheweekpod
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Andrew McGuire: We've got a mission to find the best song that's ever been on Glee. There's no remote to it. So don't get mad at me. We got Andrew and Alison Show. The clique of the week who's the head on show. Glack it by Glackett. We'll rank everyone. Closer to spot number one. Click of the week. Click, click, click of the week. It's click, click of the week. Oh my god. Wow. Oh my god, even. Um, real fans will know that that's how I started off the first episode of Gleek of the Week podcast by saying, oh my god. Um anyway. Um here I am, it's Andrew McGuire, and guess what? We're gonna find, we're gonna continue the search. We're gonna continue the search for the best song on Glee tonight. Um with the help of last week's guests, uh Matt from the choir room. Matt, how is everything going?
[1:12] Matt: It's going so well. Um we are gonna find it. Like sooner or later, we're gonna find it. I mean, like we will. I I I literally I I'm a completionist. Yeah. I'm like, I I need to see this through. No, like we we won't do anything else until we f I mean we might do things in between episodes of finding the best song right now. I would hope so I mean I have been. I I I hope that's okay with everybody.
[1:33] Andrew McGuire: It's okay. Um I've been doing other things. Um, but uh, you know, Hell or High Water, we will find the best song on Glee, but last week there was a competition that I was correct in saying, predicting that it would not sit right with um the glisteners, the beautiful girls reading this. Um Hit Me Baby One More Time versus Spotlight. I was the sole vote, of course. Too long don't read if you weren't there. Um I was the sole vote for that. But you and Alison Alamoad voted for the Rolo. Um, you know, over a week later, how are you feeling about the decision?
[2:08] Matt: Um, well, you know, the the feelings uh get bad when uh you have more access to the fellow glapinions uh out there. So seeing uh that there are people, I mean, it started with the express yourself uh of it all, to be quite frank. Um once entering the new glistener group chat, uh, which has been a lot of fun seeing that there was a lot of people looking for express yourself uh to have gone through still a chance, still a chance. We haven't yet found out what's uh coming back. I'm gonna reveal it in a moment.
[2:38] Andrew McGuire: Okay, great. And uh so yeah, there was uh some upsetness going on there. And then uh yeah, with uh Spotlight, I was like, oh, I just I didn't expect it. You called it, so I mean, correct on your end of things for sure, but it was just not one that I even predicted uh in my own head for a second that that would have gotten that type of response. I do apologize. Um, and I've told Andrew this, I do sympathize with him that he has been doing this for hundreds of episodes at this point, sending home people's favorites.
[3:06] Matt: Over a hundred. We're not in the hundreds. Over a hundred. But yeah, yeah, yeah. Um, we will get there one day. Um, but yeah, um do you would you say this is such an appropriate question to ask, but would you say that you regret the decision made?
[3:21] Andrew McGuire: No.
[3:22] Matt: Okay. Not at all. Um just like Alison who responded in the chat as well, uh, standing ten toes down on it. Just I don't know. It's it's not um, you know, what I was saying last week, and you even called out uh once you were editing the episode, was that I was like, we need to be careful when sending Mercedes solos out. Uh we can't just do it without thinking. Um, and I thought about it and I still made the decision that I made. It was unfortunate for those that affected.
[3:50] Andrew McGuire: I've I've spent some time to myself as well thinking about Mercolo's as they relate to the Glackett, and you know, I think that we're actually falling prey to what the Glee writers are kind of um inflicting upon us that it's like, oh, Rachel is the star and Mercedes can kind of get the scraps. And I think I I we need to retrain our mind a little bit, um, because it's it's not good.
[4:18] Matt: No, it's not yeah. But see, so after uh after that all happened, and I realized how many people were looking for spotlights that have gone through, I was wondering because again, I was like sympathizing with you, you've done this how many times. I'm like, I want to know what other people's like like what some of people's favorite songs that have gone home uh in the Glackett already are. And I asked this as well in the chat. Um, and uh a couple of people answered uh Selma who said that uh theirs is a Kurt song, um, but didn't specify which, which I'm so intrigued by uh because it could just be any Kurt song that is Selma's favorite song, but it is still in.
[4:40] Andrew McGuire: It is still in. I would assume then, because I think gosh, I always do this specifically with like Kolos that I get the facts wrong. And I don't think I don't think I saw Amelia in the chat yet. Amelia might be on her way. Um, but uh I believe that at this given time that Rose's turn is seeing round three, all like we had like as if we never said goodbye earlier. Um, that's not seeing round three, and I believe like uh what's it called? Um a house is not a home is yet to be pulled, and also being alive, which I was thinking about that girl today and I think being alive it might be the second colour the second of two colos seeing round three so you're gonna you're gonna not pull that in this episode I think that we will I think that we will we will pull being alive and we will send it through.
[5:47] Matt: Oh so you're just very sure that the guest is gonna send it through oh so you are not a being alive stand I no I know I know um wait so I'm trying now I'm scrolling up now in the glack it myself to see if my favorite colo has gone through and it uh it has not it didn't even make it out of round one can I do I do I know this colour I'm sure I mean I do do you know this colour do I know this colour uh season two episode three oh that's a that's a I want to hold your hand yeah sorry about that that's that was um I'll stand by you Finn version yeah I um that's that's mine but okay all right so other uh songs that were sent away that are uh favorites of some glisteners Sonia said take me to church is in her top five and it's gone right okay it's very interesting though to like like just for as as that song is an example of like Take Me to Church is obviously a fantastic uh cover but um I just never would have considered it as possibly being in someone's top five.
[7:01] Matt: Um, but I can't like the the more that I can like sit with that as if it was my own, like if it was my own baby, my own top five baby, I can get it it. It's just yeah you know, we all have different lived experiences. I think it's I think it's the season six that's bringing it down a little bit.
[7:17] Andrew McGuire: Yeah. Yeah. But I mean, like, I've said it before, I've said it again, Take Me to Church um was murdered on site by um Cherish Cherish, which is in round two, yet to be pulled. I love that girl so damn much. I listened to it a lot in particular this past week. I really do love her to death. Do you are you a cherished cherish Gleek?
[7:40] Matt: I'm not as much uh anywhere near as much as Amon is. Aman will go up for Cherish.
[7:45] Andrew McGuire: Oh, okay, okay. Interesting. See me and Amon. We're we're linked in that way. Um, well, there is um a song I do want to announce that is going to be back for round three. Um, you know, glisteners voted. If you want to vote on these uh opinions of these uh these decisions, you can go to Patreon.com slash Gleek of the Week Pod, become a Cheerio tier, and every 21 competitions, um, one song will be brought back from round two that lost, and it will be competing again in round three.
[8:21] Matt: And I wanted to go through some little stats um of all 21 of these um songs that were possible to bring back. Um so songs that didn't get a single damn vote. These include Popular, People, Feliz Navidad, Sway, Yesterday, Ding Dong, The Witch Is Dead, Billionaire, You're the One That I Won, Jukebox Hero, and Don't You Forget About Me.
[8:47] Andrew McGuire: That's a lot of songs. Everybody gets one vote.
[8:50] Matt: Uh, everybody gets oh, yeah, it's only one vote. Wow, okay. Well, I guess that makes sense. I mean, of all of those songs, um, or of of the remaining songs, you know, I I'm not surprised that others rose to the top. I guess if there was like a some kind of tier system where people got like two or three votes, some of those might have gotten some love, but um no major surprises.
[9:08] Andrew McGuire: No major there was no surprises for you in these 10 songs. Uh I I I wish I had like the full list in front of me because I kind of forgot everything you just said besides Ding Dong the Witch is dead, but wait, I can put it in the I'll put it in the chat really quick. Okay, here it is.
[9:24] Matt: Okay. Um some uh Rolos just getting no love in addition to the one that we got uh roasted for sending through last time.
[9:35] Andrew McGuire: Yes. Um billionaire getting no love is a billionaire surprise. Really? I'm glad. I'm so overheard. I would have thought there'd be like one, you know.
[9:45] Matt: Okay, sure. But I mean, like I have expressed to the Glaytrons that, you know, I I I don't think it's wise to just throw um a vote at a song that you are seeing is not getting any um attention. I think it would be much more wise you were allowed to do what you with your vote, whatever you want. I'm not telling you who to vote for, but um I feel as though, you know, it would be wiser if like you're joining a union, um a gluonion. Gather up the support for sure.
[10:18] Andrew McGuire: Right. Yeah, but I um I, you know, I'm seeing that Andrew in the chat, my namesake, um, is bringing attention to the fact that past click of the week, Charlie really tried his best to get people on his side with Ding Dong the Witch is Dead, but no one voted for Ding Dong the Witch's Dead. Not even him. Not even Charlie. Not even I see a zero, a zero percent next to Ding Dong the Witch is Dead. Charlie, I don't think that you're here right now in the live stream, but um when you are listening to this, please if if you feel comfortable sharing who you voted for, please let me know. I'm curious who you did vote for if it wasn't Ding Dong.
[10:57] Matt: Um okay, so the next four songs each got two percent. Okay. Um that is Ben, I saw her standing there, I will always love you, and sweet Caroline.
[11:10] Andrew McGuire: So you voted for Ben.
[11:13] Matt: I don't know if I even voted. I feel like I can vote as like the person that creates the poll. I don't know if I did, but um I think two percent is one vote, which it has to be. Um so uh that's just why I imagine that you were the Ben vote um after your impassioned plea. I'll never forget. I was putting together a uh a rocking chair when I was listening to that episode, and uh it was I was having a hard time with the chair, and you were having a hard time with your pitch.
[11:40] Andrew McGuire: It was all happening. Yeah, it was kind of like cinematic parallels.
[11:43] Matt: Yeah, exactly. Yeah, so um, yeah, so I know that that that people have been like standing behind um I will always love you, and yet only one of you got behind that vote. Interesting, interesting. Um, and then the next three got four percent. [12:02] I would assume that's two votes. That is We Found Love, Boy's Boyfriend, and Dreams.
[12:08] Andrew McGuire: Wow, boys boyfriend only getting uh such a small percent. Uh so that must have been like two votes. But yeah, yeah. I mean, I can't quite fully remember, you know, what songs are left. At the moment in time, of all the songs that I've heard so far, I I think I would have gone boy's boyfriend.
[12:25] Matt: Really?
[12:26] Andrew McGuire: Yeah. Hmm. Yeah. No, I mean, like you said, I'm a Ben Stan, but I think I'm happy with the decision made. I feel like I probably would have actually voted for the decision made over all of these.
[12:40] Matt: Okay.
[12:40] Andrew McGuire: Um, so I'm happy with the decision. Uh next up, six percent. I'm assuming that's three votes. Um that is Fire and Rain, which then we have the top three were uh run the world with 14%, misery with 24, and oh, do you want to say something about misery before?
[13:06] Matt: That's a lot higher than I would have hoped for.
[13:09] Andrew McGuire: Oh, really? You're not a misery head?
[13:11] Matt: No, I am.
[13:13] Andrew McGuire: I like um I like it, but I don't know, just we passed by a bunch of other songs that I would have hoped would have had this spot. But also I can totally understand, especially if there was a world that support was being gathered, uh, you know, for certain songs. I can see someone pitching their wagon to misery.
[13:33] Matt: Yeah. I mean, I think that the the um the table banging of misery is really pulling a lot of weight. You know, you know, that's another one where I'm like, I'm not sure if I like this this song as much as I would actually when it's right in front of me.
[13:48] Andrew McGuire: When it's right in front of me, I'm like, oh, this is actually quality. You know, I but wait, but one more I realized recently, I just need to share this with the class, um, that I am pretty much beyond happy to remove uh so many Maroon 5 songs from my phone. Um because well, so many. Was it like two or three that were done on Glee? Because each one is outdone by the Glee Cast version that is done on the show.
[14:14] Matt: Are you talking even about "Moves Like Jagger"?
[14:17] Andrew McGuire: Mm-hmm.
[14:18] Matt: Wow.
[14:19] Andrew McGuire: Yeah. Okay, that's that's a song that I listened to, and I'm like, wow, I hated that.
[14:23] Matt: Oh really? You didn't you like that? You actually prefer that.
[14:27] Andrew McGuire: I love a Kevin McHale vocal uh on any given number, and I kind of like the arrangement there. Um, I feel like they're they're missing, I mean, they they are missing the Christina Aguilera feature.
[14:44] Matt: That's true, but also like after a couple of times, that feature would start to get a little tiring for me. It was fun the first, you know, when it first came out, I'm like, oh, this is good. Like, yeah, like doing her Christina thing. Um, but then like just as the listens would go on, uh it it fell out of favor for me.
[15:03] Andrew McGuire: That is I it's a complete opposite effect on me. I am so sorry. I I love that feature. That might be one of my top three features of all time. When I think about features, I'm thinking about "Moves Like Jagger" featuring Christina Aguilera. People don't know that about me.
[15:22] Matt: And there there was a tweet, I think maybe like a year or two ago, maybe you saw this, where it was like it was just like they were tweeting the song, and they were like, she came on that song mad as hell. She was broke, hungry, and rent was due. Like she really delivered on this song.
[15:39] Andrew McGuire: And you know what? I might have ghostwritten that tweet.
[15:42] Matt: Oh gosh. Um, but um, our winner of these 21 songs and returning returner of the Glackett for round three is of course "Express Yourself" with a whopping thirty-five percent wow, exactly.
[16:01] Andrew McGuire: "Express Yourself." And you I didn't even realize that I was like going to be because you you helped kill "Express Yourself."
[16:07] Matt: Oh, I did. Correct?
[16:08] Andrew McGuire: I did. Uh-huh. I'm happy for everybody that I hurt in a previous in a previous week. I'm happy for all of you. Um, I can't promise that I'm not gonna do it again, but I am happy for you guys in this moment. Now that I'm thinking about it, I'm like, wow, wait. Why are you here if you're just continuing to make people mad?
[16:31] Matt: You make you make the schedule, not me.
[16:32] Andrew McGuire: I know, I'm making the schedule, and I'm like, wait a minute. Glackett villain, Matt is back to help with the Glackett again. Um, yeah, so "Express Yourself." I'm really happy for you. You know, I was really upset when when it didn't go my way. 35% of you expressed yourself, and you uh you got exactly what you wanted. And you impacted change.
[16:51] Matt: Yeah.
[16:52] Andrew McGuire: And I think that that's like a really beautiful lesson. It's incredible. Um, okay, again, so if you want to uh vote on on these decisions, go to patreon.com slash gully pod. They happen every seven episodes. And so um that's a really easy way to support the podcast and also impact the Glacket. Another thing that you get through being a patron is monthly live stream episodes, which this one is right now. Um, three lucky glatrons um will be brought out of the chat and into the stream and to help with this week's three Glacket competitions.
[17:30] Andrew McGuire: We are starting off with Jenna. Are you here?
[17:34] Jenna: Oh my god, Jenna was ready.
[17:37] Andrew McGuire: I was ready. Oh my god, Jenna, how are you doing?
[17:40] Jenna: I'm great. I'm very excited to be here.
[17:42] Andrew McGuire: Oh my gosh. Well, Jenna, you already know what I'm going to ask. Um, Glackett opinions, hot takes that you would like to bring to light at this very moment.
[17:52] Jenna: Don't have very many, but I went through the entire Glackett and I found a couple that I feel like I didn't want to bring up the obvious ones. My first one is "Don't Speak" versus "Human Nature." I I think Samcedes is cute, but I don't really care for him that much. I they've just never rocked my boat. That's not even the best Samcedes era. Like it's really not. Like season three, every time I rewatch it, I am like, oh yeah, this happened. Just wait a minute. Are people really in favor of this season five?
[18:27] Andrew McGuire: This is like they repeat this storyline every episode in the back half of season five. They're living in in real life. Like they have gone out into the real world and they are living in a new city, falling in love all over again, exploring real adult conversations about things. Uh it's it's not perfect, but it's better.
[18:48] Jenna: Okay. I I I I do like "Human Nature." I uh "Don't Speak" should be seen, I think like round four, but it was an unfortunate mashup.
[18:58] Andrew McGuire: Yeah. What else do you have, Jenna?
[19:00] Jenna: I have uh "We Will Rock You" and "Losing My Religion." Again, "We Will Rock You" does absolutely nothing for me. I I um I'm I I don't even love Finn's vocals as a whole, but this is one of my favorite songs by him, and just I I stream "We Will Rock You," but kind of just like reluctantly almost.
[19:24] Andrew McGuire: Sure. That was uh that was an unfortunate. Um, I think that I've talked about this recently, but like this was um that was an unfortunate episode with sentimental men who I love down bad but they both voted for "We Will Rock You," and so they had uh some precedence I think "Losing My Religion" another one I'm so sad that we lost that religion so surely Allison voted for that no I think that it was one of those episodes in round one where we had two guests on right and we need to if if both of our guests are voting in the favor of what we're voting against we need to honor the guests.
[19:27] Jenna: Yes, yes.
[19:27] Andrew McGuire: So I mean "We Will Rock You" is not bad it's it's I don't like it's it doesn't need to have it doesn't need to see round three uh we haven't pulled it yet right for uh round two I don't know "We Will Rock You."
[19:27] Jenna: Yeah we have "We Will Rock You" died oh in the in the Derek and John episode I damn uh they got rocked they got their shit rocked um "We Will Rock You" lost to like gosh was that like "Call Me Maybe"? I want to say "Call Me Maybe" in round three yeah maybe uh anyway I don't remember yeah we're here um what else do you have Jenna?
[19:27] Jenna: I feel like this one is more of a hot take more than "A Feeling" versus "Homeward Bound."
[19:27] Andrew McGuire: Oh that's so hard to oh god that's sick.
[19:27] Jenna: Yeah I love the reunion of it all and I think they sound great but "Homeward Bound" home just the song I again nothing for me it's just really not even the uh like no so pretty to me.
[21:04] Andrew McGuire: Jenna, are you're breaking the book?
[21:06] Jenna: I can appreciate uh the vocals are great. Every time is that the start of Thanksgiving? Is that right?
[21:11] Andrew McGuire: Yeah.
[21:12] Jenna: Every time I hear it, I'm like, yes, they're all back. The reunion. I'm here for it, absolutely. But just the song itself, nothing for me, but "More Than a Feeling" it's in top ten of my uh like all songs on Glee.
[21:27] Andrew McGuire: That's correct. You know, I have to I have to ask Jenna, are you are you saying this because your your namesake is shared with one Jenna Ushkowitz? Do you stand any allegiance with Jenna's?
[21:39] Jenna: I I'm gonna be honest with you. I always forget her name is Jenna, and so anytime you guys say her name, my ears like perk up.
[21:47] Andrew McGuire: We're talking about you, yeah.
[21:50] Jenna: I know. Playing team is such an honor. But I don't know. Just saying about "More Than a Feeling." I absolutely love it. And just "Homeward Bound," I don't stream.
[22:01] Andrew McGuire: Well, I can't stand for any slander of "Homeward Bound," but I can support you with the "More Than a Feeling." Is it just "More Than a Feeling" from that set list, or is it the whole set list that gets you as well?
[22:10] Jenna: I love "America." And "America" is in I it got killed in the first round, didn't it?
[22:15] Andrew McGuire: I think both Americas.
[22:17] Jenna: So North and South, both of them gone. Yeah. Um yeah, I that was it was I "America" Season Five version, that's a never stream for me.
[22:28] Andrew McGuire: What is it with "America" season five that you like?
[22:31] Jenna: I don't know. I'm a big upbeat song kind of person. I don't know if this is gonna show at all, depending on what songs we picked today. I am not a slow song person at all. And so the up most of my like playlist of Glee songs upbeat I have very little slow songs, and "America" is just one of those upbeat songs that I'm singing that in my car, like every car ride.
[22:53] Andrew McGuire: Kitty, Unique. Both of them get in on that. I feel like there's there's some there's some good stuff in there. I don't know. I think it's silly to me. I it's silly. Uh you know, the rest of the set list is supposed to be like the sentimental uh poll. And then, you know, we're singing on the boats or on "We're Coming to America."
[23:12] Jenna: Yeah.
[23:13] Andrew McGuire: I'm like, what is this? This is a commercial for America.
[23:16] Jenna: Um I I still haven't found what I look I still haven't found what I'm looking for.
[23:22] Andrew McGuire: I do rise for that's my national anthem.
[23:25] Jenna: I drive her.
[23:26] Andrew McGuire: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. No, it's great.
[23:29] Jenna: Yeah, I like that one too. I would say "America" is the bottom for that um that set list though. Do you have one last spicy?
[23:38] Andrew McGuire: Well, I feel like you've given some spicy ones so far. Do you have like one extra spicy one?
[23:43] Jenna: Um looking at my list, uh I don't think any of these are necessarily spicy in my opinion. I only have like three more.
[23:51] Andrew McGuire: Okay, oh yeah, let's go through them. We got it.
[23:53] Jenna: Well, okay, one of them I'll just kill right away because you guys already said it in the beginning of this episode. "Spotlight," "Baby One More Time." Sorry.
[24:00] Andrew McGuire: I was I was gas. Speak on it. Speak on it.
[24:02] Matt: Matt needs to hear it.
[24:03] Jenna: Hold on. I I think my camera's broken. I have to go check on Matt.
[24:08] Andrew McGuire: And he's gone. I think you guys even said it in the episode where it was like Summer Solo versus a Rolo, and Mercedes is literally saying she doesn't like being in Rachel's spotlight. And then she gets killed by a interesting.
[24:24] Jenna: That was like kind of like foreshadowing. I think that was like really beautiful storytelling on our bar. That was us just falling into the trap that the Glee writers set for us, and we said, okay, just tell us where to jump.
[24:36] Andrew McGuire: Right.
[24:36] Jenna: So I don't think I dislike "Baby One More Time" as I've seen other Gleeks, but it's still a bottom tier rollout for me. And that I feel like one of that was one of the main competitions that when I was listening to, I was like, I cannot believe that just happened.
[24:51] Andrew McGuire: Oh right. Everybody will remember where they were.
[24:56] Jenna: So was um was "Spotlight" part of the last vote, or is it part of the the upcoming vote?
[25:01] Andrew McGuire: "Spotlight" will be part of the upcoming vote.
[25:04] Jenna: Alright, so Jenna, get your pitch in for right.
[25:07] Jenna: I probably will, depending on what I'll bring up this last one, and it has to do with a song that just won "Express Yourself" versus "Hit Me with Your Best Shot" one way or another. Amazing song, the girls, amazing. But I think it's probably more just like a personal history I have with "Hit Me with Your Best Shot." That was my favorite song of all time as a kid.
[25:34] Andrew McGuire: And the dodgeball promo of it all, and it's perfection to me.
[25:39] Jenna: It's from my second favorite episode of the entire show.
[25:42] Andrew McGuire: Is it "Mash Off"?
[25:45] Jenna: Yeah. That episode is amazing to me. And I've said this in the chat in the last live stream. My favorite Glee song of all time is "I Can't Go for That." Um, "You Make My Dreams."
[25:57] Andrew McGuire: And "Rumor Has It," "Someone Like You" pulled in the last episode. Amazing. Amazing.
[26:02] Jenna: And I'm obsessed with the fact that like I'm feeling the heat for losing uh for sending "Express Yourself" away in round two. And Jenna's like, it should have been gone in round one.
[26:12] Andrew McGuire: So make no mistake. I voted for "Express Yourself" too, the comeback for round three.
[26:19] Jenna: Well oh, that's a you have a complicated relationship with this song.
[26:25] Andrew McGuire: Yes.
[26:25] Jenna: I think it should have lost in round one.
[26:34] Andrew McGuire: "Here Comes the Sun." I love "Here Comes the Sun." Sounds great. Should have lost.
[26:38] Matt: Right. Right. Right. Exactly, Jenna. You're right.
[26:41] Andrew McGuire: Um, okay. So Jenna, what are we manifesting?
[26:48] Jenna: We're not doing set any, we're not feeling any slow songs.
[26:52] Andrew McGuire: Um particular that we're we're feeling.
[26:56] Jenna: Uh well, I can't go for that. You make my dreams, like I said. Um honestly, anything season one through three, any uh my top three characters are Quinn, Santana, and Sam. Any of that would be great.
[27:12] Andrew McGuire: Okay, okay, good.
[27:13] Jenna: Okay.
[27:14] Andrew McGuire: All right. We'll see if we can make that happen. You're gonna auction this cup off at the end of the uh podcast.
[27:21] Jenna: I know. This beautiful cup. Well, I have Allison's because Allison obviously um turned in in her cup. Did she turn it in in person or did she mail it?
[27:29] Jenna: Oh no, she turned it in in person.
[27:32] Matt: Because that was a that would have been a risky mailing. Like imagine.
[27:34] Jenna: I know.
[27:35] Matt: Yeah, yeah.
[27:36] Jenna: I was like, please, please. And I need this, I need to do the Need the Cup.
[27:40] Matt: The drug deal in person.
[27:42] Jenna: Yeah.
[27:42] Andrew McGuire: Um, okay, so I have our first song. It is a season five song.
[27:48] Jenna: Actually, oh my gosh. Wow, Matt, you were here last time that it was pulled.
[27:53] Matt: I'm getting a repeat.
[27:55] Andrew McGuire: You're getting a repeat. We're getting your your opinions read redux, remix.
[28:00] Jenna: Um it does feature Jenna, one of the characters that you mentioned.
[28:07] Matt: So it's it's Lea Michele's face.
[28:09] Jenna: Do we know what it is?
[28:10] Andrew McGuire: We know what it is. We do have a file name right across the top of the screen.
[28:19] ♪ Musical number: "Be Okay" — performed by Santana and Rachel ♪
[30:19] Andrew McGuire: Santana Rachel, Jenna, the floor is yours with your opinions on that song.
[30:25] Jenna: I think Alison was the first person to say it in the chat. Also, there's nothing for me.
[30:30] Matt: Okay. People are saying this in the chat, and I'm shocked to read this opinion.
[30:35] Andrew McGuire: Wait, why does it not do anything for you?
[30:37] Jenna: It just I feel like there's something in the air in the video that I don't feel like it's okay.
[30:44] Matt: You're saying that it's okay, but I don't know if it is.
[30:48] Jenna: Yeah, I'm I'm like, is it really okay though?
[30:50] Matt: It doesn't seem okay. Might have to talk this through a little bit more.
[30:53] Jenna: It is a little cute. I don't know if it's the Naya and Lea of it all, but I'm watching this, I'm like, I don't believe it's okay.
[30:54] Matt: I don't.
[31:01] Jenna: Oh.
[31:02] Matt: No.
[31:03] Jenna: That's a really good point.
[31:04] Matt: I'm a little curious. So, Andrew, generally this hits for you, no?
[31:07] Andrew McGuire: Or no? I do like it. So you know, I think that I like the MP3 a little bit more than the MP4.
[31:14] Jenna: I'm I'm picking up what you're putting down, Jenna.
[31:18] Matt: Is you know, Broadway baby may be the most uh gay song on Glee, but I wonder if this is like in the same category of just like, is this just a song?
[31:29] Jenna: For us.
[31:31] Matt: Um a gay song. You know, women women saying that it's okay, but it it's not right, but it's okay.
[31:39] Jenna: Right.
[31:39] Matt: But we're just like, we believe you.
[31:41] Jenna: Right, right.
[31:43] Matt: Um, yeah, I think that it it might be a gay man thing. Are there hey, are there any gay men in the moment tonight?
[31:49] Andrew McGuire: But so um you like this. My question to Jenna is uh what were your thoughts on the uh storyline of of all of this?
[31:57] Jenna: How you know there were some thoughts in the chat about how this uh feud between the two of them gets wrapped up so quickly when they come back to New York, which is a very valid criticism. Um but what say you about all that?
[32:08] Jenna: Um I like it. I I don't I think you said this in a previous episode, Andrew, or someone did, where it was one of like it kept me going with season five. I think it's one of the best storylines of season five, but I agree it was wrapped up way too quickly because I don't know if it was this episode or the previous one, whatever the 100 and what's the next one?
[32:31] Matt: New directions.
[32:32] Jenna: New directions, yeah. They kind of merge in the one for me. And it was either that episode or the previous one where Santana had that whole rant about how Rachel is the most horrible human being on the planet, and then in the next episode, it's perfectly fine. I think it was wrapped up way too quick quickly, but I do think it was the best storyline of season five.
[32:58] Matt: It wrapped up in a way that I'm like, it felt like um they were doing the hundredth episode celebration. Um, I think, you know, I'm not usually in favor of like giving um screen time to like Marley Jake writer in in company, but I feel like they should have had a much more uh thought out, you know, exit that I think could have used this time in the hundredth episode. Um, and then hey, we could have picked up once we got back to New York, we could have like picked up and been like, then we could have had a more thought out ending to this feud.
[33:35] Jenna: But don't Britney and Santana like disappear if they go off to Lesbos Island.
[33:39] Matt: Brittany, yeah, exactly. It's it's dumb. It's so it's it's so stupid. They were like, we gotta wrap this shit up because you guys need to leave.
[33:45] Jenna: Yeah.
[33:46] Matt: Um see, it's tough. Uh a lot of a lot of negative thoughts about it in the chat, but um, like I'm already, you know, mourning the loss of love song, and I'm just feeling there's so few opportunities remaining where we get the uh Santana Rachel vocals together in such a way. Um, so I'm like, am I specifically holding on to this one because of how well I uh enjoy their voices together and and the performances where they're uh you know just in sync. I don't know.
[34:18] Jenna: Yeah, and we did do we did get rid of um we found love like a month or two back. Um, same vocalist.
[34:26] Matt: Yeah, like is I don't know if I kissed a girl is still in, but even if it was, that wouldn't do much for me.
[34:30] Jenna: I guess I guess the girl, yeah, exactly.
[34:31] Matt: Yeah, I guess the girl is still around. She could be here at any moment.
[34:35] Jenna: Yeah.
[34:36] Matt: Um I'm I'm terrified of her, frankly. Um, but I do have some, I have a legal note um to share about this, about this song. Um, I remember when they announced that um Be Okay would be covered in this episode that originally Glee Wiki reported that it would be the Ingrid Michaelson um song Be Okay. It's spelled B E space O K. Like the letters O and K. Um, whereas this song by Oh Honey is B space O K A Y. Um, and so unfortunately I think that I would have much rather, I don't know if y'all know this song by Ingrid Michaelson. I just want to be okay, be okay, be okay. I just want to be Yes, it's cute. I think I you know, I like this, and this was like a I think this was like an unknown-ish artist that they brought to light uh with this cover, and I do like it, but I think I would have much rather the Ingrid Michaelson be okay.
[35:40] Jenna: I guess so, yeah.
[35:42] Matt: Yeah.
[35:43] Andrew McGuire: Um and also I want to bring up uh I mentioned before we uh watched this song that Matt, you were here last time that it was on the Glacket. Do you recall what it won against Loser Like Me?
[35:57] Matt: Loser Like Me season two version.
[35:57] Andrew McGuire: Yeah.
[35:58] Matt: I stand by it.
[36:00] Jenna: Yeah. I mean Jenna, you're Jenna's looking at it.
[36:04] Jenna: I was like, wait a minute. I don't even like Loser Like Me season two at all. And I think that should have been without looking at a list. I think this is my least favorite uh Rachel Santana duet.
[36:15] Matt: Okay. You're saying that when we just mentioned I Kissed a Girl.
[36:22] Jenna: That's okay. No, I'll keep that at the bottom. I kiss a girl can be second bottom.
[36:28] Matt: Okay, okay, okay. They're down there together, but I have an interesting history with Loser Like Me season two. I was I am a young clique. I um I just finished my first year of college, but congratulations. Last year, like last year I was uh senior in high school, and um we did Glee uh for our spring concert, just like a a compilation of like season one songs and then compilation of season two and season three, and we did loser like me and my choir teacher, like he's like, Does anyone know what this song is? The me, of course, being the only clique in the room. I was this is the origin this is an original song, and someone in my class said, Well, oh, that's why it sucks.
[37:10] Andrew McGuire: Okay.
[37:11] Jenna: The actual writing of it. Let me tell you, like, this is horrible. Don't miss high school.
[37:17] Matt: Wow, wait, but loser like, and I think Matt, you and I might agree on this. The Loser Like Me season five version from the same episode is Be Okay.
[37:27] Andrew McGuire: I like it more. Jenna, do you what where where do you stand with the season five version of it all?
[37:33] Jenna: Um, I think I prefer season two, but I'll stream season five. I'm I'm a loser like me defender for the for the most part, but I wasn't ready to defend it against Be Okay in full. I think that they needed the groundwork for me personally. Loser Like Me, like the season two version, for it to like not land for them to do it three seasons later in a stripped down kind of like funny, like poking fun at how like kind of stupid these lyrics are. Um, and just like being very um being real. I don't know, treating them like authentic seriously.
[38:13] Matt: Right. I think it's stupid. I think it's fun. Um okay, any final words on Be Okay before we see what it's against?
[38:21] Jenna: Um yeah, I uh I'm scared for what it's against. Uh the momentum is not leaning in this girl's favor, but I know people in the chat are really hating on Be Okay. Shout out to Joey, who's at least uh standing up for her.
[38:39] Andrew McGuire: Okay. This this makes for a fun competition. It's season one. Um where is it? Here it is. Anticipation. Here we go. We can see it.
[38:56] Matt: That's hmm. That's not vocal adrenaline, is it?
[38:59] Andrew McGuire: It is vocal adrenaline. It's highway to hell.
[39:11] ♪ Musical number: "Highway to Hell" — performed by Vocal Adrenaline ♪
[39:50] Andrew McGuire: Okay, that was 49 seconds.
[39:53] Matt: I was gonna say, I was much shorted. I remembered it easy.
[39:56] Jenna: That's a quick one.
[39:57] Matt: We got Borderdo says Andrew, fast forward this.
[40:02] Andrew McGuire: Um Jenna, what do you think about a highway to hell?
[40:06] Jenna: The 49 seconds that we saw. I don't even know what to think of it, because it was so quick in and out. Is that it? No, that's not Jonathan Groff's first song, is it? Is it his second?
[40:17] Matt: Ooh.
[40:18] Jenna: I don't think it's what comes first. It's like, is it because it's this is his first episode. This is hello. But does he sing hello before in the episode?
[40:29] Matt: Love is his first scene.
[40:30] Jenna: Is it let's look let's look.
[40:32] Matt: Oh hello you're I think you're right, Jenna. Uh that would make sense. Hell hello they meet in the wherever they were the music store, whatever it was.
[40:43] Jenna: Yeah.
[40:43] Matt: Hello is first, then Highway to Hell and he's not in Hello Goodbye. That's just the Glee Club.
[40:49] Jenna: He's not there yet.
[40:49] Matt: He's not there yet. You know, that's a I am glad that you brought this up because I think that's actually kind of like deducting points for Highway to Hell for me. That I'm like I if if Highway to Hell was like Jesse debut, then I would be like, okay we gotta we gotta give it up for him. But um I mean you could fit like three crushes in this performance.
[41:11] Jenna: That's oh the carousel slide was just made in my head where it's like you highway to hell can fit three crushes um and then what's what's like the longest uh like being alive can fit like no you okay we're sleeping on literally Jonathan Groff is standing right in front of you Bohemian Rhapsody okay bohemian rhapsody you can fit how many uh highway to hell is in being alive probably like six right that's glee math yeah glee math um I don't have much to say about this I did have to look up what um this was against in round one that it won and then when I saw it it did make sense it was against girls just wanna have fun um which that's fair I do I do hear people out in public say they really do like it.
[42:07] Jenna: Well, so Jenna, you were sad that "Losing My Religion" lost. Were you sad that "Girls Just Want to Have Fun" lost?
[42:16] Jenna: Nope. Big no. My recent rewatch, I was watching it with my parents. My dad hated when that came up. He's like, is this actually happening? This is absolutely ridiculous. And I'm like, I stand that song. And you know what? Like it makes me crazy because like the behind the scenes of that episode, Naya is like talking about like, yeah, and then like Corey sings like this really beautiful rendition of "Girls Just Wanna Have Fun." And it's just like, oh my god. And I'm like, actress of the generation or of our generation. Friend of a generation. Like, oh my god, like girl, you can't tell me that you actually bought that shit.
[42:55] Matt: No, uh yeah. Sick.
[42:57] Jenna: Um bad.
[43:00] Matt: "Highway to Hell."
[43:03] Jenna: I'm really empty brain about it. I don't even know what to say.
[43:07] Matt: Well, so now Jenna, I'm so intrigued as to what you're gonna pick because you said "Be Okay" does nothing for you, but we haven't had a whole lot more to say about "Highway to Hell."
[43:15] Jenna: Good point. I really don't have much to say about either of these, but I do think I know my vote.
[43:22] Jenna: Okay. Um I feel like let's do we I feel like going to the chat before we vote. Do do people like "Highway to Hell"? Where we stand with this highway?
[43:37] Matt: I so we had uh, you know, I'm trying to think of like what else was going on there. We had some cool, you know, pyro going on with uh you know in the background of the stage. Uh Will shows up, he's got some, you know, jaw drop, so Will enjoyed it.
[43:52] Jenna: Right.
[43:52] Matt: Eduardo is saying that it belongs in hell, but then Becca is saying that it's a win, it's a win for her. And Alison's saying it's entertaining.
[44:02] Jenna: It literally is a highway to hell. I guess I never realized before this vocal adrenaline girl that's like doing the like the like backup, but she's like she has some vocal standout moments in this performance. Who's that girl?
[44:15] Matt: Right.
[44:19] Jenna: Wait, was that you, Matt?
[44:20] Matt: No, that was her.
[44:21] Jenna: She's here.
[44:23] Matt: Oh wow. Hey.
[44:24] Jenna: How was your time?
[44:27] Matt: She said no.
[44:28] Jenna: Hey.
[44:28] Matt: Oh, she didn't, she doesn't want to talk.
[44:29] Jenna: No, she's camera shy. We're talking about your song, girl.
[44:31] Matt: Yeah.
[44:32] Jenna: So Jenna, we've put it off as much as we could. Um, where does your vote stand?
[44:40] Jenna: I think I'm gonna have to go with "Be Okay," because I mean it has the Rachel and Santana. And there's some of my favorite vocalists. I mean, it's a bottom tier duet for me from them, but at least it has that going for them.
[44:54] Jenna: And I wanted to say this, but I completely forgot. The season one vocal adrenaline performances. This is without looking at a list, first one, or at least favorite one, because was it "Rehab," this one, another one by C and "Bohemian Rhapsody"? Is that it? Just those five?
[45:14] Matt: That feels correct.
[45:16] Jenna: Yeah. Well, yeah, they kind of like stay away from them while Jesse's with the New Directions, right? So he stays busy over there.
[45:27] Matt: Um yeah, I wasn't sure again, Jenna, what you were gonna say, because uh I really uh felt like the "Be Okay" reaction was like, Ugh, not this. Um, and I was like, all right, well, that was surprising to me as well. I was like, I imagine anything could come along and get the win, but then we got you know, uh 40 something seconds of uh Jesse St. James, which usually is enough for people, but maybe not just really do much for me.
[45:53] Jenna: Maybe not this either.
[45:54] Matt: Yeah, it just a lot of things don't do a lot for me, clearly. Jesse St. James, Jesse Saint sucks.
[46:00] Jenna: Are you saying that?
[46:00] Matt: Maybe I should take that back because for this performance, Jesse does Saint suck.
[46:05] Jenna: But "Another One Bites the Dust," "Bohemian Rhapsody," absolutely love those.
[46:10] Matt: So someone asked earlier, I'm trying to find it. Um, if if this was oh uh Joe was asking if this was in your comp uh compilation for choir.
[46:18] Jenna: I saw that. It was not, it was songs like "Don't Stop Believin'," "Somebody to Love," "Physical," "Any Way You Want It," "Loving, Touching, Squeezing."
[46:29] Jenna: Um I wish I had a list because we did a lot. There were some cuts that were in this compilation. Like season two had "Pure Imagination."
[46:38] Matt: Uh-huh.
[46:40] Jenna: I can't remember it all right now, but that was a hard time. I loved doing it, but I was only the only Gleek in the room, and people kept asking me for the context of every single song that we did.
[46:51] Matt: My heart goes out to you, Jenna.
[46:54] Jenna: My choir teacher literally asked us, does it has anyone watched Glee?
[46:54] Matt: The Soul Hand?
[47:01] Jenna: The Soul Hand, that's you understand that that's like kind of crazy, right?
[47:04] Matt: Like to ask.
[47:04] Jenna: Wait, if people are willingly there, like choir in choir.
[47:09] Matt: Yeah, yeah, you have to like sign.
[47:12] Jenna: Or something.
[47:13] Matt: Okay.
[47:13] Jenna: So this isn't like a, it's not like a mandatory thing. Because if it was a mandatory thing, I would understand if they didn't care for the hit show Glee. But no, it I mean, it wasn't an audition, but it was just like sign up for the class and you're in. I was a horrible singer, but I just like to sing. But yeah, he just asked before we started doing it, has anyone watched the show? Only hand in the room. It was very embarrassing. There were like 50 kids in there.
[47:38] Matt: Wow.
[47:38] Jenna: And now here you are on a Glee podcast, airing that out. And I think that's really beautiful.
[47:43] Matt: And Gleek stories matter.
[47:45] Jenna: Yeah. You know where the rest of those people from that class are or that choir teacher?
[47:49] Matt: Not here.
[47:49] Jenna: So not on a Glee podcast.
[47:51] Matt: No.
[47:51] Jenna: For better or for worse.
[47:55] Matt: I think she started listening to the pod.
[47:57] Jenna: Um, kind of terrified that she's gonna find this.
[48:00] Matt: Wait.
[48:00] Jenna: Glee is a partial guilty pleasure because like I'm not embarrassed to like say that I enjoy watching the show, but also I'm like, I kind of am.
[48:12] Matt: It's it's a guilty pleasure, but not. If I was in the guilty pleasure episode, I'd be singing something from Glee, kind of just that metaverse.
[48:19] Jenna: From "Loser Like Me," because you already know how to do it.
[48:22] Matt: Right.
[48:22] Jenna: Um, I feel like this is the most prolonged um voting that we've ever done in the middle of the voting process to have a full conversation in the middle of it, I think is a really beautiful thing.
[48:33] Matt: Um, Matt, I feel like I already know what you're gonna be voting for, but I know what you're voting for too.
[48:39] Matt: Uh yeah, "Be Okay."
[48:41] Jenna: URCing round uh three, and uh everything is gonna be okay for those of us who may not be happy about that.
[48:48] Matt: Uh it's going to be okay.
[48:50] Jenna: You're really um putting the cart before the glories here.
[48:54] Matt: That it it's a you it's typical to do that at the end of the episode, but I'm going to take that and save it for the end of this episode. So thank you.
[49:01] Jenna: Sorry.
[49:02] Matt: Um for me.
[49:04] Matt: It's okay, it's okay enough for this competition.
[49:08] Jenna: Um, do I want to do a I kind of want to do a pity vote if that's okay?
[49:12] Matt: Get out of here with your pity votes.
[49:14] Jenna: I'll do a pity vote.
[49:15] Matt: I'm looking "Highway" uh "Highway" to like there like you literally in your Zoom window right now, Matt. You have the girl that is doing the bashing.
[49:24] Matt: She's over there.
[49:25] Jenna: Oh, she's over.
[49:25] Matt: Oh, oh, I thought I saw her leg, but I thought that's my cat.
[49:28] Jenna: Oh, okay.
[49:29] Jenna: Um well if you know I I just want her to know you can tell her after this recording is over that um, you know, she she did a good thing.
[49:38] Matt: Andrew says you're great.
[49:41] Jenna: Oh, what are the highlights of performance for me on?
[49:46] Matt: Um great.
[49:48] Jenna: I'm I'm she says thanks okay. I'm I'm glad, if nothing else. After that lackluster competition, Jenna, I'm so sorry that that that felt like a lackluster competition. You will be back right determined for it.
[50:04] Jenna: Um you'll be back um by jumping Groff off of the Hamilton soundtrack, even exactly.
[50:09] Matt: Exactly.
[50:10] Jenna: Okay, well, thank you so much, Jenna. For having helping and uh yeah.
[50:15] Matt: Um okay, so up next is my namesake, Andrew.
[50:23] Matt: Um I saw him in the chat earlier. Are you still here?
[50:28] Andrew McGuire: Huh?
[50:29] Matt: Hello.
[50:30] Andrew McGuire: Hello?
[50:31] Matt: Wait, you're a black screen right now.
[50:33] Andrew McGuire: Oh, there you are.
[50:35] Matt: Hello.
[50:36] Andrew McGuire: Hi, how are you doing?
[50:37] Matt: I'm doing great. I'm so excited to be here.
[50:40] Andrew McGuire: Oh my gosh. We are so excited to have you.
[50:43] Matt: Um okay. Do you have any thoughts about the competition that literally just happened?
[50:49] Andrew McGuire: Um I definitely think I would have went with "Highway to Hell."
[50:53] Matt: Oh.
[50:55] Andrew McGuire: Just for the choreography of the all, I love the when you get all those dancers together and they really get to show off. Um I kind of wish it was longer, but um, I think that's one of the great things about this bracket is that you know one of these songs is moving on to round three, whether they should or not, they are.
[51:15] Matt: And Andrew, it just goes to show. I mean, if those two songs got pulled with you, Andrew McGuire gave a pity vote, and maybe you could have gotten him on your side in order to send "Highway to Hell" for the nature of the cup.
[51:27] Andrew McGuire: That's weird.
[51:29] Matt: Nature of the competition.
[51:31] Andrew McGuire: The human nature of the cup.
[51:33] Matt: I hate that.
[51:35] Andrew McGuire: Sorry.
[51:35] Matt: Um Andrew, other Andrew, do you have um that's so rude?
[51:41] Andrew McGuire: Andrew. You're just we just share you can call me Drew.
[51:44] Matt: I do go by Drew as well.
[51:45] Andrew McGuire: Do you go by Drew?
[51:46] Matt: Okay, I feel like it doesn't feel normal to be like Andrew.
[51:49] Andrew McGuire: Um, Drew, do you have um other uh competitions that you would like to bring light to that did not sit well with you?
[51:59] Andrew McGuire: Um I think I'm a black jurist, so like I don't really have any qualms with any competitions.
[52:06] Matt: That's beautiful.
[52:06] Andrew McGuire: Um it's the nature of a bracket style competition.
[52:10] Matt: Uh that's the best thing about like Cinderella stories going further than they should.
[52:15] Andrew McGuire: Um, but that's the whole fun of it, right?
[52:18] Matt: Um wait, what do you what do you what are the Cinderella? What do you mean?
[52:20] Andrew McGuire: The Cinderella stories.
[52:22] Matt: Well, like um "Crush" going on to like speak on it third or not. Like, I mean, so many things had to align just right for that song to be going on to where it is, right?
[52:36] Andrew McGuire: When you said Cinderella stories, I was like, does someone have a Cinderella bracket that like that they're like they're competing all of these Cinderella stories to find the best interpretation of this story?
[52:49] Andrew McGuire: Oh my god.
[52:50] Matt: That's a great idea.
[52:51] Andrew McGuire: Um I don't I don't know how I don't think it would be nearly as lengthy as the Glacket.
[52:56] Andrew McGuire: I just can't wait till "Crush" is the ultimate winner of the entire competition, and Andrew goes, that's beautiful.
[53:02] Matt: That is that is beautiful deserved winner.
[53:06] Andrew McGuire: Hey, it's a possibility, and that's the best thing about it.
[53:10] Andrew McGuire: She did a lot with 17 seconds, okay?
[53:12] Matt: Yeah.
[53:13] Andrew McGuire: Um wait, so you don't you're there you had there has to be like one or two competitions.
[53:19] Andrew McGuire: I mean, I think I have more like just hot takes on like Glee songs as a grouping.
[53:26] Matt: Okay.
[53:26] Andrew McGuire: Like um, I think one of my hottest takes would probably be I think the Warblers were so much better once Blaine left them.
[53:36] Matt: Oh, that is a hot take.
[53:38] Andrew McGuire: Wait, why do you say that?
[53:39] Andrew McGuire: I just a lot of when Blaine was part of the Warblers, it was you know just him featured with some background singers. But I think like the background vocals like stepped up a lot more um once he left and became a lot more crisper.
[53:55] Andrew McGuire: Um I think one of my favorite songs from the Warblers is "Whistle."
[53:59] Matt: Um definitely in my top 10 uh Glee songs list.
[54:04] Andrew McGuire: Which I think "Whistle" is still around somehow.
[54:08] Matt: I think it's still in.
[54:10] Andrew McGuire: I think it's still here.
[54:11] Matt: "Whistle," are you in the room with us right now?
[54:13] Andrew McGuire: That's offensive.
[54:14] Andrew McGuire: Um, but um Andrew, well, so I know Andrew McGuire saw this tweet. Andrew uh S. Um, have you noticed the same thing that I've noticed recently that every like couple of months uh in some capacity on the internet. Uh some I I tweeted this out from the choir room account. Just I feel like somebody will be watching the credits of Glee and they'll see um the the really gay warbler, super gay warbler, gayest warbler of all time, and then they'll screenshot it and it goes viral.
[54:43] Andrew McGuire: It's it's insane to me how often I see this kind of thing going around, whether it's on I don't know, Reddit, Twitter, uh, you know, whatever form of social media. It's just it's people are rediscovering it for the first time.
[54:54] Andrew McGuire: Yeah. Um it's like one of those cycle things that like come back um every like five, ten years that people uh forget about it and then they rediscover it.
[55:04] Andrew McGuire: Because these super gay warblers are the ones that are shining when Blaine's gone.
[55:08] Jenna: That's true.
[55:09] Andrew McGuire: They all have girlfriends.
[55:11] Jenna: Yeah.
[55:11] Andrew McGuire: I forget about that.
[55:14] Matt: Um yeah, I feel like that's just an easy that's an easy like um what what is it called? Like data, not data farming, but just like uh, you know, uh getting engagement?
[55:26] Andrew McGuire: Engagement farming where it's uh where it's like you you could just tweet. I can send that tweet out every couple of months and it would get a reaction.
[55:34] Matt: The easy way.
[55:35] Andrew McGuire: Easy way to get some retweet.
[55:36] Jenna: Yeah.
[55:37] Matt: Other hot takes that you have.
[55:40] Andrew McGuire: Um I think the best competitions set for new directions is actually the my uh the Jackson tribute from Hold On to 17.
[55:50] Jenna: Oh, okay.
[55:51] Andrew McGuire: So like people bring that up a lot, and that's another like engagement farming where it's like new directions should have lost for that set list against the Troubletones.
[56:02] Matt: I don't agree.
[56:03] Andrew McGuire: I do not agree.
[56:05] Matt: I definitely think they should have won.
[56:06] Andrew McGuire: Okay, and they did.
[56:08] Matt: I think they had the best flow from song to song um out of all their set lists.
[56:14] Andrew McGuire: Um, even like one of my biggest peas with um uh the national set list that they actually won was that the each section didn't flow together correctly.
[56:25] Jenna: Like if I was watching that back to back to back, it it just would seem off to me.
[56:31] Andrew McGuire: Especially like when like on um uh Leah's song, like she abruptly she ends that song very in an odd spot in that song, um and then they continue on to um was it paradise by the dashboard light?
[56:47] Jenna: And it's like that's the transition didn't work for me.
[56:51] Matt: That's a really good point that I've never actually considered that it needs to like properly transform into the next song.
[56:59] Andrew McGuire: Yeah, I totally agree with what you're saying about the national season three set list. I mean, the the set list, well, obviously, you know, banger after banger.
[57:07] Jenna: Um, I can definitely agree, like there's no flow for sure.
[57:12] Matt: But yeah, yeah.
[57:14] Andrew McGuire: Um, well, Drew, you were here to Glackett. You're going to see two songs that you will be voting on which one is better.
[57:23] Jenna: Um, is there a type of song that you are manifesting, rooting for, etc.?
[57:30] Andrew McGuire: Uh I do love group numbers. I love when voices are layered upon each other.
[57:36] Matt: Um I think uh Friday is in my top ten uh list.
[57:42] Andrew McGuire: I know that's not going to be coming up, but um, I think it's those layering of voices um that I really love in uh Glee covers.
[57:51] Jenna: You know what? I love a Friday. Friday came up on shuffle last week, and I was I was having a good time.
[57:56] Andrew McGuire: Friday's good.
[57:58] Matt: Well, okay, so here's the question. Way better than the original.
[58:01] Andrew McGuire: Yeah, I'm saying the original's on your phone in your in your music library, the glee version's on your phone. You have to get rid of one. What are you doing?
[58:07] Jenna: The iconic original or keeping glee's.
[58:10] Andrew McGuire: Oh, definitely the cover. I think actually I never have the original on my phone.
[58:15] Jenna: I actually disliked the original so much when it initially came out, but when Glee covered it, I actually started really liking the style.
[58:24] Andrew McGuire: Tanger.
[58:25] Jenna: I totally you yeah, I agree that like the way that they layer the voices on Friday specifically.
[58:34] Andrew McGuire: These are some really fun opinions. I always knew that Andrews always had the best opinions.
[58:40] Jenna: Um and this is just proving it.
[58:42] Andrew McGuire: Yeah, I really I'm gonna I'm I'm gonna stream Friday a little bit more often. I'm inspired by this conversation.
[58:48] Jenna: Kevin McHale like ad libs in the background that if you really listen to it are like fantastic.
[58:53] Andrew McGuire: Yeah.
[58:54] Jenna: See, it's good. Friday's like one of those songs where, and we'll see. Is it still in the competition, Andrew?
[58:59] Andrew McGuire: Uh Friday is gone. Friday, I believe it lost to Gold Digger in round one.
[59:03] Jenna: And now Gold Digger is gone.
[59:04] Andrew McGuire: Oh, well, it should it should have be gold digger.
[59:06] Jenna: Um, but that's besides the point. Um, it's one of those songs that if I listen to it even once, it'll be stuck in my head for the next month.
[59:13] Andrew McGuire: So I have to be very careful with how I listen to Friday.
[59:17] Jenna: So because I I don't necessarily want that. I don't want Friday to be stuck in my head for four weeks.
[59:23] Andrew McGuire: And I will say one final thing about Friday. Friday, I do love you, even though you you were dead on arrival in round one.
[59:30] Jenna: There is a moment in the MP4 Friday. We all know the we all know the moment I'm gonna talk about where it's Santana wearing the red dress, seeing a girl at the prom walking by what wearing that same red dress, and then her just shaking her head.
[59:44] Andrew McGuire: It's just really really iconic. And I really love it.
[59:48] Jenna: Um anyway, okay.
[59:49] Andrew McGuire: So we're manifesting layered voices.
[59:53] Jenna: Yes.
[59:54] Andrew McGuire: Okay. Not Friday, because oh wow.
[1:00:02] Matt: This is Andrew. You have been blessed.
[1:00:04] Andrew McGuire: Also, Matt, you are getting another song that you in your debut episode.
[1:00:11] Matt: What's going on here?
[1:00:12] Andrew McGuire: This is crazy. This is a huge song.
[1:00:15] Matt: Really putting me to the test of, you know, how did you feel about this song the first time? And do you still feel I well?
[1:00:20] Andrew McGuire: It's been like it's been over three years.
[1:00:22] Matt: This is my first episode.
[1:00:24] Andrew McGuire: This is your first episode.
[1:00:26] Matt: Do you do you recall?
[1:00:27] Andrew McGuire: This has to be Don't Stop Believing.
[1:00:31] Matt: It is Don't Stop Believing.
[1:00:34] Andrew McGuire: Wow. And you know what? People in the chat can say that they were there.
[1:00:39] Matt: Just a small town girl.
[1:00:42] Andrew McGuire: Living in a lonely world.
[1:00:47] Matt: She took the midnight train going in.
[1:00:55] Andrew McGuire: Just a city boy.
[1:00:58] Matt: Don't in a race and stuff to try.
[1:01:02] Andrew McGuire: He took the midnight train going in a way.
[1:01:21] Matt: Smell of mine and cheap perfume Forest while they can share the night goes on and on and Strangers waiting Up and down the ball in their shadows Searching in the night Street like people live in just a fine emotion Working hard cannot feel everybody wants a thrill Hang to roll the dice Just one time Some win some we'll lose some won't sing the blues in the wind goes on and all in Hold on to that fill Street Don't self believe Hold on to that fill Street
[1:01:21] Andrew McGuire: Oh wow. Don't stop believing.
[1:03:26] Matt: That's kind of like a hidden gem of the Glee cast.
[1:03:29] Andrew McGuire: Yeah, people don't really know that this happened.
[1:03:30] Matt: Um people don't talk about it a lot.
[1:03:32] Andrew McGuire: Um, when choirs come together to sing Glee songs, they usually leave it out because they're like, eh, not that important.
[1:03:38] Matt: Right, right.
[1:03:40] Andrew McGuire: Um I don't even know where to begin.
[1:03:45] Matt: Like any uh uh initial thoughts of Don't Stop Believing pilot version.
[1:03:51] Andrew McGuire: Um I do like the Rose to Road to Regionals version more.
[1:03:57] Matt: I would say that was my top version of Don't Stop Believing.
[1:04:01] Andrew McGuire: Uh, but I still really like this one too.
[1:04:04] Matt: Um, I think anyone who lives in Michigan, this song holds a special spot in our heart.
[1:04:10] Andrew McGuire: Oh, wait, tell me more, because I just moved to Michigan.
[1:04:13] Matt: Um I think solely for the line that says like um born and raised in South Detroit.
[1:04:20] Andrew McGuire: Uh of course.
[1:04:24] Matt: But um also if you're like you're a hockey fan, this is the song they play every time the Red Wings win.
[1:04:31] Andrew McGuire: So you know like it's a Red Wings victory when this comes on.
[1:04:36] Matt: But that's beautiful.
[1:04:38] Andrew McGuire: Um thing that I wish kind of continued on with Glee was like this performance had a lot of very specific um choreography kind of themes to it that I think like was almost a staple through maybe the first half of season one, but kind of fell off and I kind of wish that they continued with it like the outstretched like reaching arm or like the um heads down at the end of the song I feel like they do I mean they at least do that like four episodes later with like somebody to love like I feel like and then like they do the head down I mean they do it in the series finale and I lived right I think they keep it up a little bit but like they stopped doing that like after like I think season one really you you like knowing that the song is over with yes final done right and and okay that's over Joe is asking an important clarifying question uh about do the Red Wings play the glee cast version uh sadly they don't even though I've requested it before they haven't yeah it's disappointing you you can keep on requesting it I'm sure that one day they'll listen.
[1:05:50] Andrew McGuire: Yeah I will keep trying.
[1:05:53] Matt: Um, I'll also ask ask you as well Andrew but Matt first do you what is your pilot glee introduction to the to the hitbox show like when did I watch it?
[1:06:07] Andrew McGuire: When did you what was your what was your do you have a do you have a fun tale of watching the pilot for the first time.
[1:06:13] Matt: I don't it's um, you know, people ask this question a lot so I'm a big survivor boy and people ask this question a lot and people usually know when they jumped into that show because there's been 400 seasons of it so you usually kind of remember the time and the place.
[1:06:25] Andrew McGuire: I don't remember that for Glee.
[1:06:27] Matt: I just knew that at a certain point all of my friends were gathered up and it was, you know, Thursday, Tuesday, one of those nights.
[1:06:33] Andrew McGuire: Um, and we were gathered up watching it all together, but I don't know if that was day one minute one or if I went back in time.
[1:06:40] Matt: Um, because I can imagine if I was watching in real time and I watched episodes three and four live that I might have just turned around and never came back.
[1:06:48] Andrew McGuire: So it might have been after, but yeah, there's no strong story.
[1:06:51] Matt: Do you have a stronger story?
[1:06:53] Andrew McGuire: I mean, like, I I remember, and I I've shared it before, um, but I'll share it again now.
[1:06:59] Matt: That um my I think my mom was duly informed that I was of the the queer lifestyle.
[1:07:08] Andrew McGuire: And so I think that she was talking with her friends about um about about this hitbox show, Glee, if you're familiar.
[1:07:15] Matt: And um, and so she was like, maybe we should watch it, watch it together.
[1:07:19] Andrew McGuire: And we bought like the season one box set because this was like beginning, like September of 2010, right when I started high school, and so we got this the season one box set, watched it, and I remember because this is right off the heels of Lost Ending that May.
[1:07:36] Matt: And so that was a huge thing.
[1:07:38] Andrew McGuire: It still is for me, that series. That I remember watching the pilot and just being like, I feel like maybe I should like write down like the date that I'm starting this show because I know how I am about television shows, that like maybe this might be a big deal, and I'm like, surely it won't.
[1:07:56] Matt: It's it's a show about showing me planning the podcast.
[1:08:00] Andrew McGuire: I was like, we're in the cup by the next day. What if 11 years later we start a podcast?
[1:08:08] Matt: Podcast is not even like a medium at that point.
[1:08:11] Andrew McGuire: Um, but uh I remember watching it, and obviously, like just like immediately like falling for it and just being like, got it.
[1:08:22] Matt: This is great content.
[1:08:24] Andrew McGuire: And I remember specifically being so entranced by the fact that on the back of the DVD box set, you see the entire Glee Club.
[1:08:32] Matt: I think it's like the picture of them on the bleachers and like Sue is like like yelling at them and Quinn and Puck are there, and I'm like, oh my god, they're gonna join the Glee Club.
[1:08:43] Andrew McGuire: Um and so, yeah. No, I think that I don't remember like distinctly watching like Don't Stop Believin' for the first time, but it obviously had an effect on me that I was like, wait, we gotta we gotta watch episode two. Andrew, do you have a Okay, go wait? I was gonna ask Andrew. Uh we I think talked about this the first time around, you know, favorite versions of this song. And I know you said, Andrew, that you like the regionals version better, but do any of the other versions throughout the rest of the series stand out as in comparison or you know, or in contention for your top spot.
[1:09:15] Jenna: Um the version that she uses for her audition for Funny Girl, I really like too just because of the feeling that is behind it. Um I think that nostalgia and emotion behind it puts it above, I think the hundred episode one. I like the hundred episode one, I really do. Um but the one that you're talking about, the season four, is also very, very sweet. So yeah. And just for those Glackett heads out there, um, the season five version as well as this one, we'll see what it's against, are the ones that are currently left in the Glack, the other two versions, um season four and season one, Journey to Regionals are both they were done in round one, unfortunately. And I want to put a disclaimer, the regionals version, which I know is a fan favorite for so many, including yourself.
Um, that that was against Rose's turn in round one. And so I feel like I need to make that distinction every single time. Um, but I feel like, you know, as much as I would like to co-opt that dis that opinion and be like, I like the regional version the most. There was something about watching it right now that I was like, wait a minute. There is something really, really beautiful about this one.
[1:10:45] Andrew McGuire: Yeah, like it's the first. I mean, what else is, you know, right? It's the next one. I think it's one of those episodes. I think it's one of those Glee songs that people will recognize by like the first second of the song. Like you play the first one or two seconds, they'll know it immediately. Even people who probably don't know much about Glee will be like, oh, that's a Glee song. Even Redwings fans are like, isn't this from Glee? Yeah, exactly. Glee made it. Glee really put it on the charts. Glee really made Journey who it is.
[1:11:15] Matt: So Andrew, the first time that this came up, uh, as you mentioned, was in the, you know, my my first ever podcast. And so now anybody who wants to know what's gonna be in the third competition today, uh, Welcome Christmas will be one of them. Um because Welcome Christmas was your that was my third winner from the first ever episode that Amon and I did. Um but as far as this goes, uh, so Don't Stop Believing came second on that matchup. So when it showed up, we were like, okay, you know, we already know what it's against, and you know, was clear that it's gonna go through. The fear amongst everybody in this chat, I'm sure right now, of what is going to come next and the very likely possibility that what comes next is going to have a big fight against it.
[1:11:57] Andrew McGuire: I hope it does. Oh my gosh, I'm ready to go to bed. Well, I mean, like, I'm going to prolong that even further because I'm like curious to ask both of you like what do you see as like don't in a dream glacket scenario? What is Don't Stop Believing's entire arc? Where does it make it to in your dream glacket?
[1:12:19] Jenna: Probably Elite Eight.
[1:12:21] Matt: Okay. To the top eight songs.
[1:12:23] Andrew McGuire: Yeah. Matt, where do you what is makeup for you?
[1:12:26] Matt: It's such a tough question. Uh, because I can never answer a question directly. I have to, you know, go on a tangent and just say like in my personal, you know, uh, like what are my favorite songs on Glee? It's probably not making, you know, the final two, three, four rounds. But as far as like, you know, we're a bunch of Gleeks sitting on a call here watching the first ever closing episode number, Don't Stop Believin. Like, what more do I need to say about it? It brings back all those feelings. So the longer it goes, it's like nobody can be upset about it, but like there I can certainly see a world where me personally would not bring it all the way to the end. So I don't know. Like, you know, making it past this round, I would imagine that it could, it should, and maybe another round or two, but I'm also, you know, you never know what's gonna come up. I don't know what's gonna be pulled. I'm scared.
[1:13:10] Andrew McGuire: I'm scared. I think everybody is scared.
[1:13:12] Jenna: Terrified.
[1:13:13] Matt: I'm super excited. And so is uh so is my friend over here. She's just she's you know. She's like, I didn't I didn't even make it through the first competition. I'm terrified for Don't Stop Believing.
[1:13:25] Andrew McGuire: Okay. Alright. Okay. I there's three songs that are. Really? None of those songs that are poking out right now. I don't like that. I don't like when that happens. I'm like, I don't know what to do. Okay. We're waiting for just like one singular one to be like, this is the okay. That was more definitive. Okay. Okay. As much as I would like, see, this is what happens. This is what happens. I'm like, I'm scared for a fight, and I'm like, I really hope it's an easy layup for Don't Stop Believing. And then I kind of feel I get the song, and I'm like, okay. I think I I was expecting a fight. And now here it is. And I'm like, I don't, I don't think it will be a fight. I feel very confident in saying that it won't be.
[1:14:13] Matt: We can just make it a fight. We can make it a fight. I actually hate Don't Stop Believing. It's the worst. Okay, so before we even get to the song, Matt, I want you to just like you can just you're gonna continue to be the villain of the Glacket, and um I know what the song is, you don't know what it is, and you are going to play the role of someone who loves this song.
[1:14:33] Matt: Okay. Yep. That's the character. Yep. Um here we go.
[1:14:43] ♪ Musical number: "Not While I'm Around" — performed by Glee Cast ♪
[1:15:55] Andrew McGuire: That was so lackless. Look at Kurt's beautiful face with all of those love marks that he had put on to him. A close personal uh friend he made out in the streets of New York. This is beautiful. Okay. Okay. I like okay. Um okay. What do you really like most about this song, Matt? Like is it where does this rank for you?
[1:16:14] Matt: So I mean, look, we know that Blaine loves to just, you know, him and the music. We don't need a piano. We don't we can just do the vocals. Um, and you know, when he lays on that bed with Kurt, and then everybody else leaves the room because it's such a good performance, they can't help but give them the moment alone. And then when he's sitting on it on a chair just thinking about how Kurt was harmed while Blaine wasn't around, um, you know, it's just so beautiful the way that they come back together and he tells them, Well, from now on, nothing's gonna harm you from from this point for right, right. Starting now. Starting right now. Now I'm around you while Blainey boy is in town. No, no, no. Yeah, um it's perfect. Only Blaine can harm Kurt. Right.
[1:16:59] Andrew McGuire: Because I feel like Matt, like a lot of people would point uh point to like don't stop believing as like um one of those like iconic glee numbers that like not a lot of people are like in yeah, I yeah, right, right. In this song, in this song, really is iconic glee status for you.
[1:17:17] Jenna: Jenna's uh choir teacher is actually also here with me in the room and uh they're telling me that um for the latest version of uh the choir singing glee songs, they're starting with this number. Nothing's gonna harm you.
[1:17:28] Matt: I think it's actually worth noting at this point, like uh uh over an hour into the this this episode that Matt, you are actually at it in a in a live studio audience right now, and there's like a there's a bunch of people there.
[1:17:40] Matt: Yes. Yeah, everybody I well, we're we're keeping them quiet for now. They're gonna come in at the end. But yeah, um, we got a lot of people here. We're all uh really excited to uh say goodbye to Don't Stop Believing today.
[1:17:51] Andrew McGuire: Yeah, Don't Stop Believing. You you you're gonna stop tonight. Time time to stop it up.
[1:17:57] Matt: Time to um uh Andrew, um, do you have any rebuttals?
[1:18:02] Andrew McGuire: I I think it's like really difficult to have any possible rebuttals to that statement. But what do you what are your thoughts on that while I'm around Glee Cast version by Glee Cast? Um I don't know about rebuttals, but maybe some things for um I mean, how many times has Glee really gone with no instrument instrumentals whatsoever and just presented a pure raw song? Um I know I said like uh the Warblers are better without Blaine, but I do think Blaine is. Um one of the better male vocalists, definitely not the best, but um for him.
[1:18:40] Matt: Who were you giving that title to?
[1:18:40] Andrew McGuire: Oh, definitely uh Jake. I think Jake best male vocalist on uh the cast. He's the most handsome for sure. Um uh Andrew, uh how um has this come up before? I think this is my first example of this coming up, um, of a song that is vastly different on the show versus uh the version that's released to the rest of the world.
[1:19:05] Matt: Great cool question because I feel like I brought it up in round one, but I I wasn't even thinking about it right now. Because like this version, the MP3 as released on iTunes is like a group number. Blaine, Rachel, Mercedes, Sam, they all get some uh some lyrics in here. Right. But then Blaine in the episode was like, no, you but just stay back. Yeah. This is about me, not while I'm around. And it's not while we're around. Exactly. I can't even I can't even hear it. If I've ever heard this version, which I know that I have once or twice, um, I can't hear their voices here. I can only hear Blaine.
[1:19:39] Andrew McGuire: So I'm gonna say it very crispy audio. I don't know if it was coming through to y'all that like listening to this, and this is me being for real. I'm not I'm no longer playing a bit. Um this is me being for real. This the very crispy audio. If if this wasn't a glackett based on the crispiness, um, I think this would this would win.
[1:20:03] Matt: He sang this one live. You're telling me this isn't gonna win.
[1:20:06] Andrew McGuire: Um, he didn't sing this one live, right? I don't think so. Uh I think that he I thought that he easily could have did I need to go to the Glee. Well, actually, no, so uh trivia, I'm already here, sorry, I beat you. Uh parts of this song are sung live by Darren, parts of this song, making this the third time he sings a song live on the show, Teenage Dream Against All Odds, uh, and suddenly Seymour's then going to come next, which apparently also features live vocals.
[1:20:19] Matt: Okay. Okay. Um, but still, uh I don't know. I I guess like I understand the choice, you know, to make it um just Blaine in the episode, but would have loved to hear everybody else. I'm more confused with the choice to have it as a group number at any point in production. Like how would that sh play out on the show? Like how would you incorporate those characters? Right. That just felt like it kind of, and I'm sure that they sound beautiful on the MP3. Again, I can't really think about what it sounds like right now. But um, it just feels like a waste of their time to record that if it's not actually going to be used proper, use in the episode proper.
[1:21:21] Andrew McGuire: Yeah, yeah. Because none of them are in that hospital room, right?
[1:21:24] Matt: No, they are. They are and then they leave.
[1:21:28] Andrew McGuire: Yeah. They leave him uh the the two of them alone uh for Blaine to fondle Kurt's cuts uh. No, you can sit on that one. Wait, okay, wait. Does anybody have black it open because I wasn't sitting on that? Uh what did not while I'm around win against in That's a good question. Round one.
[1:21:50] Matt: Um, oh, it must have been love, which I know.
[1:21:56] Andrew McGuire: It must have been. Um Missaban Love, which I understand people really like, so I'm sorry that this is kind of opening up the wound again. Um this episode, Bash, um, so much good music in this episode, and also not while I'm around, the best of the episode. Um episode also features No One is Alone, you make me feel like a natural woman, uh the uh aforementioned from a while ago, Broadway Baby, Colorblind, uh, and Kurt, I'm still here. Um yeah, I mean, uh, so my question I was gonna ask Andrew before um, are you pro or anti-this era of the show, the New York season five era?
[1:22:34] Matt: I'm anti. Um I was not a big fan of the whole New York era. Um I think season five is probably the lowest on my season ranking, um, paired with like season four as well, but um like I don't even like remember this episode all too very well. And doesn't like Kurt like have like a speedy recovery too, like he's like back on his face. He's back in his feet never talking about it again.
[1:23:05] Jenna: Yeah.
[1:23:06] Matt: Okay, I need to call the chat out. Eduardo, you are you okay? Um Eduardo was saying my toxic trait is that Kurt should have died and come back as a ghost for the rest of season five. That is on par, Matt. This is your first live stream, if I'm not mistaken. Um that Eduardo, uh this is kind of a on par for Eduardo comments.
[1:23:26] Jenna: Yeah.
[1:23:26] Matt: He says I say stuff.
[1:23:29] Jenna: Just be saying stuff.
[1:23:30] Matt: So other than like Kurt laying in a bed, did he really do much this episode other than like his uh last solo? Um he got in a fight with Rachel at over dinner. Also, why yeah, the way that Kurt then gets into this fight, like he sees so he sees um a fellow gay person being bashed, and rather than staying in safety and calling for help, then now the other man is already bashed, and then now Kurt is also bashed, and everybody that was doing the bashing gets away.
[1:23:58] Jenna: Can I bring this up? Because I watched this episode fairly recently, and I caught something that I never caught before. Toward the end of the episode. Not the people that did the bashing, but okay, continue.
[1:24:11] Matt: They're still at large. Um, Kurt and Clain, Clayne even, Clain visits the memorial memorial of someone that didn't die. Um at the end of the episode again, and there isn't a shot of Blaine saying, like, it's I hear that he's gonna be okay and he should be like making a speedy recovery. There isn't a shot of Darren Chris actually saying that line. And so when I was watching it recently, I was like, wait a minute. Were they editing that episode? And they were like, wait a minute, we need to let the audience know that like he's okay, and we need to have Darren Chris like do this like ADR of like, hey, by the way, listener and listeners, audience, gleeks at home. Um, he's gonna be good. I'm gonna put that little portion in the carousel. Tell me that I'm not crazy because I feel like that's definitely what happened.
[1:25:08] Jenna: Yeah.
[1:25:09] Matt: Anyway. Because um you know, when when it happens at the beginning of the episode, not to say that we're not invested in this person who's obviously unwell, but it's not like it's somebody that we know. So if they did not revisit it, there's a good chance we all would have forgotten. Um, it's crazy. And like because like that opening, like no one is alone happens, and then we have like this like dinner scene of like all of them meeting at Kurt and Rachel's apartment, and Mercedes is like looking at like the prayer card, and she's like, Who's this? And then Rachel so nonchalantly was like, Oh, he got beat up, and I'm like, whoa. It's crazy, it's a jump scare. Um, that episode it doesn't it doesn't really hit for me, but it did hit for Kurt. Isn't that terrible to say?
[1:25:55] Jenna: It's not terrible because we both had the same joke, but um, it is terrible.
[1:25:59] Matt: So um one last pitch for this song to make it through. It is incredible. Um the love between these two characters is just unmatched, and I think we need to consider it. And he and Blaine used the trauma to pass his um Niada exam too. Like he he took that trauma and brought it into his uh solo. Uh-huh.
[1:26:20] Jenna: Or Carmen.
[1:26:21] Matt: Yeah. He took his broken heart and he turned it into art, which I think is so beautiful. Um, Matt, I feel like we can do an end scene right now. We can do a cut. Um and I I feel like I'm gonna ask you your on it do you have any honest opinions about this song that you would like to to share? Um, but we had a good time, didn't we?
[1:26:45] Jenna: Um that was fun.
[1:26:45] Matt: It's it's cute. I uh would love to uh re I and I will revisit the version with all of uh the four of them singing that song that is on uh I love how you still call it iTunes. It hasn't been called iTunes in like 17 years. Um the iTunes, yeah, Apple Music or whatever it's called today. Um but no uh is it vote time or it's vote time.
[1:27:11] Jenna: Okay.
[1:27:12] Matt: Don't don't stop. Congrats. You are seeing round three if I have anything to do with it.
[1:27:17] Jenna: Yeah.
[1:27:17] Matt: Andrew, do you have what it what is your vote here?
[1:27:21] Andrew McGuire: It's it's don't stop. Uh I I'm not I am not a fan of uh whole pity vote vote the way you want. Uh so don't stop.
[1:27:29] Jenna: Mm-hmm.
[1:27:30] Andrew McGuire: Yeah, I don't even I'm not even thinking about doing a pity vote here. Don't stop believing.
[1:27:34] Matt: I'm happy for you. I would I would have liked a a little bit more dramatic of a competition here, but nonetheless, I'm happy that you're seeing round three. Um all right. Well, Andrew, thank you so much for helping with this competition. Thank you for listening, all the things.
[1:27:49] Andrew McGuire: Thank you. I had a lot of fun.
[1:27:51] Matt: Um all right, and our last gliek this week will be Stephanie. Stephanie, are you here?
[1:27:59] Stephanie: Hello.
[1:28:01] Matt: Hi.
[1:28:02] Stephanie: Hi doing.
[1:28:05] Matt: I'm good.
[1:28:05] Stephanie: How are you?
[1:28:06] Matt: I'm doing well. Oh my god, you sound so happy.
[1:28:10] Stephanie: I'm so happy to be here.
[1:28:11] Matt: Oh my god, so so happy to have you. Um, Stephanie, you already know what I'm going to ask. Glacket decisions that keep you up at night.
[1:28:20] Stephanie: W what which competitions are we talking about here for you?
[1:28:23] Matt: I'm glad you asked. Um, I want to talk about round one and I want to talk about Jesse's girl originally loothing to take about.
[1:28:34] Stephanie: Right.
[1:28:35] Matt: I was very, very, very sad about that. Jesse's girl since came back.
[1:28:41] Stephanie: Yes.
[1:28:41] Matt: But yes.
[1:28:43] Stephanie: I'm so sorry. Wait, be you're not a take about girl.
[1:28:47] Matt: Uh I mean it's okay, but Jesse's girl, come on.
[1:28:51] Stephanie: I mean, that is Corey's Don't Random My Parade, in my opinion.
[1:28:55] Matt: His drop, yeah.
[1:28:56] Stephanie: It's great. And I we don't have enough Finn Solos in this show. So I feel like we're limited. The fact that, you know, Jesse's girl was cre or sorry, the character of Jesse was was named Jesse for the song uh should really have given it a lot more weight on that song advancing.
[1:29:12] Matt: Like that's important.
[1:29:15] Stephanie: Totally. I feel I feel like a lot of these competitions get brought up that I'm like, I had nothing to do with this, but this was one of them that I really did have something to do with. Um this was in the Brooke Averick episode. I feel like I get like a message like maybe once a month where like have Brooke Averick on the podcast, and I'm like, literally check the tape. Brooke Averick has been on this podcast. Um and I uh dutifully um brought Brooke into the take about camp. And I think Allison was the only person to vote for Jesse's girl. I'm glad that Jesse's girl is back.
[1:29:43] Matt: Me too.
[1:29:44] Stephanie: I'm glad that both of them are seeing round two. But um, but Stephanie, what what other ones do not sit right with you?
[1:29:50] Stephanie: I loved How to Be a Heartbreaker.
[1:29:53] Matt: Thank you.
[1:29:56] Stephanie: Um I think it's a very underrated song. Um I don't think everybody in the Glee world loves it. But I am a big fan of Marina and the Diamonds, so um yeah, very sad that that one said goodbye. And I voted for that one when it was in the running to come back.
[1:30:13] Matt: So Stephanie, is it better? Is the Glee version better than the original if you're familiar with the original?
[1:30:18] Stephanie: Ooh, uh I wouldn't say it's better, but I think I just appreciated the representation.
[1:30:26] Matt: It happened, yeah.
[1:30:26] Stephanie: And that it happened. And I mean, I I like the the arrangement on Glee, but I I mean I love it. I feel like it's just like when they when he when Brody gets to the because he obviously has like a different version for the MP3 and the MP4 where he gets the at least I think I do, because the MP4, it's like at least I think I do. Um, which is like I don't like, but then in the MP3, it's also not good because he's like, at least I think I do. And I'm like, I don't like that either. So I don't know. But I do like the song. I'm I'm warming up to this one. It's aging like a fine wine.
[1:30:27] Matt: I love it.
[1:30:59] Stephanie: Yeah, but no, Andrew. Come on.
[1:31:03] Andrew McGuire: Sorry.
[1:31:04] Stephanie: Um, Stephanie, what what other ones for you?
[1:31:08] Stephanie: Um I would say I know I have a I have a list here, so um next to me winning over pretending. You guys are recently talking about pretending, I think on the recent episode I was listening to. And I felt like that should have definitely won over next to me. I mean, pretending is an underrated song for Finn and Rachel. Can you tell I'm a Finn fan? I mean, come on.
[1:31:32] Matt: But um, but I I gave it a lot of thought as to why it's so underrated. And I think it's just the actual episode itself. That's the why it gets it gets like forgotten about because of the episode it's in.
[1:31:49] Jenna: Yeah.
[1:31:50] Matt: I I now I need to like a refresher because Matt, that was part of your in Amons episode earlier in round two. Did anybody did do we all vote for Next?
[1:32:01] Andrew McGuire: No, I want to say it was Wait, did you? Did I feel like you might have?
[1:32:07] Matt: I voted for Next to Me, Next to Me One.
[1:32:10] Andrew McGuire: Yeah, I feel like it was two to one. And did you vote for Next?
[1:32:14] Matt: I voted for Next to Me, but like I'm what I was gonna say in response to Stephanie is just like I uh some because uh this has been brought to our attention a couple of times since, and I'm like, I'm having regrets. I'm having post pick regrets uh as far as that competition goes, because I you know when I when I made the decision in the moment, I was like, but pretending has never done much for me. But it's one of those like like maybe Andrew, for you how to be a heartbreaker is of just like it has grown on me as time has gone on. So sure when do you get to the point where you accept that that's a reality and move forward in life with pretending as part of your, you know, just as part of in your mind. I don't know.
[1:32:52] Jenna: Uh I mean Eduardo in the chat is of course bringing attention to the actual scientific term here. It's called post glacket clarity.
[1:32:58] Andrew McGuire: Yeah yeah yeah I mean the more you know.
[1:33:00] Matt: Um um yeah pretending I I'm having post glacket clarity and I'm still sitting by next to me not even like post glut clarity like no no why why would you say that actually um um Stephanie do you have a do you have a a well how uh go continue on your list oh gosh um I did have another one uh and Alison's not here to answer the question I really want to know why is I'm not gonna teach your boyfriend how to dance with you that one does nothing for me personally that's my hot take for the night I don't understand why it's so popular.
[1:33:47] Stephanie: Wait so when when you're watching this when you're even listening to it what are the feelings that you're feeling?
[1:33:47] Matt: Well I'm more focused on the actual scene in the episode which is the fight between Finn and Jesse with Rachel and the songs in the background. I mean it's it's okay but it's it's I don't get the big hype of it all.
[1:34:09] Stephanie: Matt, I'm sorry allow me to glee explain to you why I'm not gonna teach your boyfriend how to dance with you.
[1:34:17] Matt: Wait, before I go any further Matt, what is your opinion on this song?
[1:34:20] Matt: Um I I genuinely feel like Alison and her passion for it has brought me much further in than I otherwise would have been uh on the on the song throughout, you know, the entire course of round one, even past the point that it came up. Uh anytime that I would just be listening to the podcast and I would hear, you are the girl, like that would be a highlight for me. Um so I honestly feel like Alison did her part in, you know, bringing another Gleek into the world of that. Um, you know, if it ever has its day where it leaves the Glackett, I'm not going to cry about it. Um, but in the meantime, I'm happy to see it. I feel as though um I'm not gonna teach a boyfriend how to dance with you. Glee Cast Red from my Glee Cast, a song that like I liked while Glee was airing.
I don't think that I immediately was like, wow, while I was watching it live, I was like, I didn't think anything much of it, but over time I was like, I like this. But in recent years, especially, and I think Alison had a really uh big effect on me as well, that I'm like, wait, actually, this is actually kind of that girl. And, you know, I think that, you know, Stephanie, you're bringing attention to the fact that there's a lot of plot that is happening over the course of this performance. And I went into it thinking, okay, that's a detriment, of course. That's going to be a detriment against the song. But I think that the plot is so good that it's like they're they're it Finn and Jesse are fighting.
Becky is like coming into um Sue's office while Artie is getting a root canal and it's like there's like a code read in the auditorium. I'm like, this is actually it's it's so good. Whereas like I was thinking about like Dinosaur recently, where there's like a conversation during dinosaur, and that conversation doesn't nothing. Stupid. I I don't want it. Send it away.
[1:36:10] Andrew McGuire: Uh but like the I think that the plot during I'm not gonna teach a boyfriend to dance with you is so good that you cannot deny.
[1:36:16] Matt: Yeah.
[1:36:16] Andrew McGuire: That's my thoughts anyway.
[1:36:18] Matt: What did uh what did it uh win against?
[1:36:20] Andrew McGuire: Because does that Stephanie have anything to do with uh the resentment towards it?
[1:36:25] Stephanie: I don't know if we all remember what it's like.
[1:36:27] Matt: Oh, who did lose to it?
[1:36:29] Andrew McGuire: Um it won against another blow low.
[1:36:33] Matt: Um it won against you should be dancing.
[1:36:37] Andrew McGuire: Oh a good blow low.
[1:36:39] Matt: Um some fun stuff there, but yeah, I mean, I'm good with the decision.
[1:36:44] Andrew McGuire: I'm glad.
[1:36:45] Matt: Yeah.
[1:36:46] Stephanie: I'm indifferent about it.
[1:36:49] Andrew McGuire: Stephanie, that's my I love having I love having I like talking to other Greeks be mostly because um difference opinions. I I like that you don't like I'm not gonna teach your boyfriend how to dance because like is this going to make this more fun? Like in Andrew and Allison's heads, it was like, okay, no, everybody is with us on this, which for the most part I would say is is true. But even to have one person be like, come back down to reality, it's not universally beloved. And that goes for any song in this glacket.
[1:37:17] Stephanie: Well, I will say that I feel like the other blow low that Alice Simmon obviously really loved, Somewhere we go sometimes, that like I she did not fully convince me on that one.
[1:37:31] Andrew McGuire: I like it.
[1:37:32] Stephanie: See, I like that one a lot.
[1:37:34] Andrew McGuire: You like that one.
[1:37:35] Stephanie: Okay.
[1:37:36] Andrew McGuire: What is it about that one for you?
[1:37:39] Stephanie: It's that whole episode, um, but also just I think the song's well done. I'm a big Keen fan. So that was very nice to hear. Um yeah, I just I like it a lot more than not gonna teach your boyfriend how to dance with you.
[1:37:55] Andrew McGuire: Okay.
[1:37:56] Stephanie: Both of them still in round two. They could quite literally go up against each other. Um Stephanie, do you have any final things to share? Songs that were manifesting, a type of song that you like? Anything.
[1:38:13] Stephanie: I love I would love a grainful duet, uh, or Finn solo. Um I love Quinn, uh, Quolo, Mercedes. Uh we need more Mercedes, more representation. Obviously, we've already thought about uh Spotlight leaving. So in recent weeks, we have not been doing that girl very good.
[1:38:36] Andrew McGuire: Um okay. Alright, your first oh my god, the lid just came off. Well, we know it's white Christmas, but what's next?
[1:38:44] Matt: Uh wow, the lid.
[1:38:48] Andrew McGuire: Oh, okay.
[1:38:49] Matt: A Rolo.
[1:38:50] Andrew McGuire: Okay.
[1:38:50] Matt: Not what you wanted.
[1:38:52] Andrew McGuire: Half a Finchel.
[1:38:54] Matt: Right.
[1:38:55] Andrew McGuire: Um, I like this rollout. Not having seen the Rolo yet, uh, I feel like I am already predisposed to saying I owe sending a Rolo home. So we'll see if this one can win me over.
[1:39:06] Matt: I th I think this is the hero's journey for you.
[1:39:10] Andrew McGuire: Um, okay, here we go. We're looking first frame, the artist's way, a book on a desk that says the artist's way, a spiritual path to higher creativity by Julia Cameron. Do we know what this rollout?
[1:39:26] Matt: No, but this has to be in her bedroom, right?
[1:39:28] Andrew McGuire: I think I think it's in her bedroom or then in the library.
[1:39:28] Matt: It's in her bedroom.
[1:39:33] Andrew McGuire: So season one.
[1:39:36] Matt: Ooh, it's Jenna in the comments in the in the chat saying I won't give up.
[1:39:42] Andrew McGuire: It is.
[1:39:43] Matt: Okay.
[1:39:44] Andrew McGuire: When I look into your eyes It's like watching the night sky.
[1:39:55] ♪ Musical number: "I Won't Give Up" — performed by Matt ♪
[1:42:08] Andrew McGuire: Okay. Um who wants to start us in the discourse here?
[1:42:17] Stephanie: Yeah, this one uh is probably on the lower end of Rachel Solos for me, honestly. It sounds great. It's beautiful, which Rachel sounds beautiful and everything. But um yeah, this one's uh okay, it's a meh for me.
[1:42:34] Matt: By the way, go ahead.
[1:42:37] Stephanie: Just I just want to shout out Jason Moraz, who should have won dancing with the stars was robbed. Um thank you, Stephanie.
[1:42:45] Andrew McGuire: Are people really talking? Is this like a popular opinion?
[1:42:48] Stephanie: Well, it was the latest season. Um, I I think um, and he was so good, he was every mom's favorites, um, including myself. Um, and just it should have won. Um but that aside, she of course sounds great on this. This is like one of my favorite style of Rachel uh of Rolos. Um, but like when you think wake me up, um, you know, like just something along those lines, but like I was gonna use Wake Me Up as an example of like I think I like that one better.
[1:43:21] Andrew McGuire: Is that still in?
[1:43:22] Stephanie: Oh I don't do you know?
[1:43:22] Andrew McGuire: Uh off the top of the book.
[1:43:23] Stephanie: No, wake me up.
[1:43:24] Andrew McGuire: Wake me up.
[1:43:24] Stephanie: No, we we already put it in the clack.
[1:43:28] Andrew McGuire: Well, um that's unfortunate, but um I don't know. I I feel like you know, before we played it, I was in my head um having an even better uh perception of what I thought about it, and then when it played, I was like, wait, maybe this isn't everything I thought it was, but I still like it.
[1:43:49] Stephanie: I like it. I feel like I had a really come to to to Gleesis um moment while watching I won't give up right now. That I'm like, I because I really do like this, but there was something about it. I was like, what is it about it? And I think I figured it out. This song is giving for all of my Leah Michelle heads out there, her album forever, her what year is this? Her 2021 album, her lullaby album. This feels like it's stripped from that album and just put into an episode of glee. And I think that like during this entire glara of Rachel's storyline of like, oh I didn't do drop well, I didn't drop, I didn't drop my hardest, I I choked. And then she gets like five songs about it over the course of the next few episodes. That I'm like, girl, this is this is getting this is getting extra, but I do really like I won't give up a lot.
[1:44:51] Andrew McGuire: You now have made that Leah Michelle named her child ever just for that album name because we talked about it like Jesse's girl and all, you know, all that.
[1:45:00] Stephanie: I am beyond even just genuinely believing that that is a possibility.
[1:45:07] Andrew McGuire: I I mean, like, okay, wait, so like I feel like we can we can we can even start like a a bet for like what her daughter is going to be named. Like just whatever whatever you can work that into I don't know, some other word like it's not gonna be like for Jessica, but like you know, it'll it'll be something right something similar where they can get a name in there.
[1:45:28] Stephanie: Um you know what? I this is a word to the Geks out there. I saw her like gender reveal announcement for Mother's Day, and like all of the top comments were like it's a mini Rachel, and I'm like, please. This is sick. You guys are fucking weird. I'm so sorry. Please do not spam this woman's comments with a person that does not exist.
[1:45:53] Andrew McGuire: Let me point out yeah, I think what Stephanie's about to say.
[1:45:55] Stephanie: Yeah, people in the comments commenting about her son and saying, hey, name him Corey. I'm like, don't do that.
[1:46:01] Andrew McGuire: Oh my god!
[1:46:02] Stephanie: I was crazy uh uncomfortable by that.
[1:46:04] Andrew McGuire: I was just gonna say in general, like, you know, her comment section could be, you know, usually a lot worse than just Rachel.
[1:46:10] Stephanie: It's true, it's true.
[1:46:12] Andrew McGuire: But like, no, it's Stephanie. I've seen like the Corey comments too, and I'm like, you guys seriously need all the time.
[1:46:19] Stephanie: Yeah.
[1:46:19] Andrew McGuire: What? Like Corey's birthday was the other day, and I guarantee you, if you just like went to some random Leah Michelle post, it was like, why aren't you saying anything? Why would you wish her a happy birthday?
[1:46:27] Stephanie: Weird.
[1:46:28] Andrew McGuire: Weird.
[1:46:29] Stephanie: Um I feel comfortable saying that's weird.
[1:46:31] Andrew McGuire: Um thank you.
[1:46:32] Stephanie: Yeah.
[1:46:33] Andrew McGuire: Uh legal note that I was thinking about during this song. This is the last song from props on the Glackett. Um, I don't know if it will go through, but um that was kind of surprising that I won't give up was like the final contender from this episode, which I really do like. I love that episode. All of the songs from this episode.
[1:46:56] Stephanie: Oh, yeah, absolutely.
[1:46:57] Andrew McGuire: Um, now I have to go check on props and see what else is going on here. But that episode's not for Rachel.
[1:47:03] Stephanie: It's Tina's episode.
[1:47:04] Andrew McGuire: So it's Tina's, yeah.
[1:47:06] Stephanie: I don't care about Rachel's crying so little.
[1:47:09] Andrew McGuire: Um, that's it in that episode.
[1:47:11] Stephanie: Oh my god.
[1:47:12] Andrew McGuire: Um, because you love me and mean are both gone. Flash dance still in no flash dance, no flash dance lost in round two um to cop syrup.
[1:47:25] Stephanie: Oh, well, goodbye.
[1:47:26] Andrew McGuire: Um but okay, wow. Props only hanging on in this glacket through I won't give up.
[1:47:34] Stephanie: Mm-hmm.
[1:47:35] Andrew McGuire: And let's see how far we can push that theory of how far you won't give up.
[1:47:41] Matt: Um I mean, look, no one's going to props for the music in that episode.
[1:47:45] Andrew McGuire: You're actually going to that episode for the storyline unless you're in the world.
[1:47:49] Matt: Oh right, right, right, right.
[1:47:51] Andrew McGuire: I I think you get the best of both worlds though with that episode.
[1:47:55] Stephanie: I I stream I stream mean.
[1:47:57] Andrew McGuire: Stream mean.
[1:47:58] Stephanie: I absolutely um any any final words about I won't give up.
[1:48:05] Andrew McGuire: I feel like she took too many breaths.
[1:48:11] Stephanie: Wow. This is not me saying that that Leah or Rachel should have stopped breathing. Um that's not where we're going with this.
[1:48:19] Andrew McGuire: Um the background vocalists.
[1:48:22] Stephanie: Oh, yeah.
[1:48:22] Andrew McGuire: Eduardo is actually bringing attention to a good point.
[1:48:25] Matt: Thinks that women breathe too much.
[1:48:27] Andrew McGuire: Wow. Get out of here.
[1:48:29] Stephanie: Um I was just getting out of my villain era. Um, it was just like or too many pauses. Maybe it's not specific breadth, but just like I won't give up. Pause on. Like, I don't know. That's the song. What do you want her to do?
[1:48:43] Andrew McGuire: I I wanted it to to flow a little smoother.
[1:48:47] Stephanie: Oh.
[1:48:49] Andrew McGuire: Fine. No. If that's why this song loses the game. We're nitpicking, it's round two. I'm rooting for it. I'm hoping the next contender is hopefully something to knock it out.
[1:49:01] Stephanie: I want to bring attention to the fact that um earlier in the chat, people were bringing attention to the fact that Pompeii lost to I Won't Give Up.
[1:49:11] Andrew McGuire: Which is gross.
[1:49:12] Stephanie: That's sick.
[1:49:13] Andrew McGuire: I I agree.
[1:49:14] Stephanie: That's sick to me.
[1:49:15] Andrew McGuire: Yeah.
[1:49:17] Stephanie: Thanks.
[1:49:18] Andrew McGuire: Thank you all for bringing that to the art.
[1:49:21] Stephanie: If I'm gonna be queasy about it, y'all are too.
[1:49:24] Andrew McGuire: Um okay.
[1:49:27] Stephanie: Okay.
[1:49:28] Andrew McGuire: Okay.
[1:49:30] Matt: We we have a season two.
[1:49:31] Andrew McGuire: A Gwenneth, even.
[1:49:41] Stephanie: I see you drive round town with a guy I look.
[1:49:45] Andrew McGuire: I'm like booked you.
[1:49:48] Stephanie: I guess the change in my pocket wasn't enough.
[1:49:52] Andrew McGuire: I'm like booket shoo.
[1:49:56] ♪ Musical number: "Forget You" — performed by Gwyneth Paltrow ♪
[1:51:59] Stephanie: Just because we ended on the Naya doing like the vocal runs at the end, I feel like I need to bring attention to that first. First, that is that's the reason that I come to this song. For the Naya of it all. She's hardly in this song and yet she's really pulling a lot of weight here. Andrew, what is your opinion of this song?
[1:52:23] Andrew McGuire: This one's just so much fun. It puts me in a good mood. All everyone's dancing together and having a great time. Rachel, of course, is in her corner pouting, but that's the gig with group numbers like this. She always pouts. Everyone else has fun. But I love it. It was the first episode with Gwyneth Paltrow being a part of it and it's great. I love it. I love this song.
[1:52:49] Stephanie: I saw Becca said this is her favorite Gwyneth song. Would you feel similarly off your gut instinct or does anything else come to not looking at the list?
[1:52:57] Andrew McGuire: My personal favorite is "Turning Tables." Yes. I like that one a lot. And I guess this, I wouldn't because I guess it's not a solo but her song "Landslide" with of course Santana and Brittany is well that one's probably my favorite and then for a solo it would be "Turning Tables."
[1:53:16] Stephanie: Yeah, the Glee Wiki does define it as a Gwyneth solo so we I you have taste. "Landslide" is quite literally it's the winner of my Glacket. I love it. It's up there for me too for sure. It's in my top 10 for sure. I think yeah, I depending on the day it's it's between that "Valerie" and "Love Song" R.I.P. that are the winner of my Glacket. But yeah, I unexpectedly had so much fun just now. I don't stream "Forget You" because I don't know, like songs from this era. Like, I'm not gonna like directly line it up with like a "Next to You" or "Next to Me," sorry. But like songs from like that time period in at least I think Andrew and I are almost the same age in our lives. Like I just like I'm like I don't know. I uh they were fun at the time and and they don't hold up very well to me. So like CeeLo's version is not doesn't hold up for me. I don't want to listen to it today. But this version I certainly will keep on my phone, even if I'm not going to stream it too often.
[1:54:22] Andrew McGuire: And then I forg I scroll up a little bit. Someone said yeah, Andrew said the MP4 is way better than the MP3. I mean, absolutely. The reason I didn't expect to have so much fun is because if the MP3 ever comes on, I'm like, okay, this is "Forget You," Gwyneth sounds great, the Naya runs are fantastic, Mercedes and Artie get in there as well. But then watching them all get up and have fun along with the storyline as well of Rachel pouting in the corner, all together gives you a lot of fun. You get a lot here. You get a lot of bang for your buck here.
[1:54:54] Stephanie: Yes. I love "Forget You." For some reason, I feel as though the MP4 I stand by. I'm going to go to the grave with you. However, I feel like this is crazy to say, maybe.
[1:55:09] Andrew McGuire: Do it.
[1:55:10] Stephanie: MP3. I think that the CeeLo version I'm reaching for instead of the Glee version. I think that the CeeLo version, I just remember like that was such a moment. It was a moment. On the radio that I'm like, that if you could put that into a bottle and sell it, I think you would get a lot of profit.
[1:55:32] Andrew McGuire: Well, back um what's that going for today? Right.
[1:55:36] Stephanie: But I just like I that was like it was there was something so euphoric about hearing "Forget You" on the Radio by CeeLo Green that I was like, that was so much fun. Remember that you guys that was good.
[1:55:47] Andrew McGuire: Yeah. It was such a mood back then too.
[1:55:50] Stephanie: It was a mood. And then you kind of feel like kind of like a little dirty, like listening to like the explicit version.
[1:55:56] Andrew McGuire: Yeah.
[1:55:58] Stephanie: Yeah. Um and then like obviously Gwyneth just like this was like one of this is one of the songs that did remarkably well on iTunes. Um that like even like Gwyneth performed this at the Grammys with CeeLo, I feel like everybody too.
[1:56:19] Andrew McGuire: Yeah.
[1:56:20] Stephanie: Like it was just like it was yeah, right. Going on tour, like doing like a few dates, like I think in like New Jersey or something. Um that was yeah, a huge moment. Certainly it must have been in contention, I want to say for episode a hundred, right?
[1:56:34] Andrew McGuire: It doesn't matter.
[1:56:35] Stephanie: Oh like as one of the songs that people like voted.
[1:56:38] Andrew McGuire: Yeah, because you know, Gwyneth Paltrow did return for that time frame, so you know the possibility of her redoing it or do or somebody redoing it, you know, would have been on the table.
[1:56:48] Stephanie: I would have rather her that than "Raise Your Glass" in Theater Five.
[1:56:52] Andrew McGuire: Or "Happy," which I feel like kind of like is trying to like copy paste for you.
[1:56:58] Stephanie: And people say that like well, people say I think it's the Glee Wiki that says this, that like she personally wanted to do that song. To which I of course ask like why, but I don't know. That was also a moment. I uh the "Happy" did not have the chokehold that "Forget You" did on me personally, but I understand to the minion fans out there that that song particularly means a lot to you. Um but yeah, I like "Forget You." I don't want to forget her anytime soon.
[1:57:28] Andrew McGuire: Yeah. You may not have to to just give you some hope and optimism as we get closer and closer to a vote. But it's it is it's so much fun. I mean, everybody's involved. Um we're coming off the heels of what uh like um hello, Rocky Horror. So we're you know, kind of getting back into it with the Glee Club and you know, meeting this iconic character in Holly Holiday, and it's just we're all having like authentic glee fun.
[1:57:59] Stephanie: And winning an Emmy for playing Holly, and also not even Gwyneth not even going to the damn ceremony to receive the award. I feel like that's the most Holly behavior.
[1:58:08] Andrew McGuire: She said I love you.
[1:58:12] Stephanie: She was like, I'm gonna forget this event. Um okay, do we wanna do we want to vote? I feel like it's pretty obvious, but who wants to start us off?
[1:58:21] Stephanie: It's all you.
[1:58:25] Stephanie: I'm going to vote for "Forget You."
[1:58:29] Matt: Uh yes. Would have loved a bit of a battle. Um, and I, you know, I don't know. Uh if I was Andrew and dropping some pity votes, I might have dropped one on uh "I Won't Give Up." But again, uh not only was I looking to uh trying to even out the world uh here and send a Rolo home anyway, uh it was made much easier by the fact that "Forget You" is a lot of fun.
[1:58:55] Andrew McGuire: So wow, do you see this? This is this is learning in process in progress. This is I mean not redemption for Matt.
[1:59:02] Matt: His redemption arc.
[1:59:03] Andrew McGuire: Yeah. Oh gosh, wow. Okay, across the board. It was a it was an easy glacketing episode. Stephanie, thank you so much for helping us glack it this week. Would love to have you back on the show.
[1:59:17] Stephanie: Yes, thanks for having me. I had so much fun. Thank you. Hopefully a harder competition next time.
[1:59:22] Andrew McGuire: Yes. But um thank you to all the Jenna, Andrew, and Stephanie. Um in recap with this episode. "Be Okay" it's gonna be it's gonna be more than okay for "Be Okay" because you're going to round three. Um in "Highway to Hell," you were going to the deep dark uh crevices, the corners of hell.
[1:59:47] Stephanie: My friend would like it to stop rubbing it in.
[1:59:50] Andrew McGuire: Uh she says it's painful enough that it was sent home. I'm sorry, it's part of the bit that we do every episode. It's like kind of like a thing that we do. Um, but uh okay. "Don't Stop Believin'," I'm not gonna we're we're not gonna stop believing just yet. Maybe maybe eventually, but not at least in round two. Um "Not While I'm Around" am I gonna vote for uh "Not While I'm Around." Um "I Won't Give Up." Well, that's exactly what we did. You're also going to hell. Um and "Forget You," we we simply can't. We can't forget all of the the boundaries you pushed, all the um obstacles that you overcame. How can we possibly forget that?
[2:00:34] Matt: Um, thank you so much for helping with all three of these competitions today. Do you have any final words, uh, plugs, anything to share with the Gleeks?
[2:00:47] Matt: Well, uh, thank you as always for having me back, uh, despite becoming somehow a villain in this world of joy and glee. Uh, hate it. Uh but um but it was a lot of fun. It was uh a very interesting thing for me uh being here to revisit songs from round one that I had a part in uh and and see, you know, uh can they do it again? And both of them did. So um excited for possibly having that happen again in round three if I'm not banned by then by uh the audience at large for decisions, but I think today uh the decisions were mostly uh agreed upon, and hopefully nobody's feelings were too hurt. Um overall, yeah, uh you said plugs. I'm on Twitter at Bat Lagory, that's my main place of uh tweeting and being online. Also uh at Choir Room Pod is where I'll occasionally drop a glee tweet. Um, of course, the choir room, the You'll be tweeting about I hear that you're planning on tweeting uh super gay warbler, other gay warbler soon.
[2:01:46] Andrew McGuire: Yeah, and uh in about I don't know, today's the 13th. Oh, is that allowed to say that on the podcast? Uh the date of recording. Um we yeah, so probably I don't know, the 31st at the end of the month, and then we'll just make it monthly from there. Uh I really look forward to that tweet. I think it's like untapped ground, really.
[2:02:01] Matt: Absolutely. So we're gonna get we're gonna get some engagement there and uh and yeah, otherwise, um uh reminder that I do a reality TV podcast called the Free Agents Podcast. If anybody is a fan of shows like The Challenge and Survivor, Big Brother, we have some fun over there. So that's it. Thanks again, Andrew.
[2:02:17] Andrew McGuire: Oh my gosh, of course. And I mean, you mentioned that I mean, we got the okay and also "Don't Stop Believin'," um from your first episode in round one. Um, I think that you know, "Welcome Christmas" is going to fare just as well in round two um as those two songs.
[2:02:35] Matt: That will exactly uh be the case if Amon is back on that episode. "Welcome, Christmas." Uh, you you have a really uh special place in Lake Lacket, and I think it's that number one slot.
[2:02:46] Andrew McGuire: Um, all right. Well, thank you so much for listening. If you want to support the podcast, you can go to Apple Podcasts or Spotify, leave a nice review, five stars, please. Um, and also if you want to partake in these live episode recordings, um you can go to patreon.com slash gleek of the week pod, become a part of the Cheerio tier. All the Gleeks that you heard uh this week are part of that Cheerio tier and can effectively make a change in the Glackett. So um, if you would like to partake in these monthly live stream episodes, you can do that on our Patreon. Thank you so much as always for listening. And oh, we uh no new episode next week, but the following week there will be an episode.
[2:03:31] Andrew McGuire: Okay. Bye.
[2:03:32] All: Bum bum bum.
[2:03:34] All: It's Gleek, click of the week.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
