Skip to main content
BPN Logo
We Love Company, Matt Doyle and Another Vodka Stinger

This week we're talking Dan's favorite musical, COMPANY, with one of Joe's best friends, Matt Doyle. Matt is currently playing the gender-swapped role of "Jamie," in the revival of COMPANY on Broadway... Read More

From the show: Guys Who Like Musicals

1 h 18 mins
8/7/20

Guests

Featured Shows

About

This week we're talking Dan's favorite musical, COMPANY, with one of Joe's best friends, Matt Doyle. Matt is currently playing the gender-swapped role of "Jamie," in the revival of COMPANY on Broadway. He shares with us his mad dash to learn "Not Getting Married Today" 16 hours before the final callback, and the utter generosity that Mr. Sondheim shares with all his collaborators. Put some vodka on ice, sit back in your recliner, and treat yourself to the 2006 Revival...just maybe don't invite your spouse.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Joe Carroll: So an actor is saying his lines, and then out of nowhere, he just starts singing.

[0:07] Dan Tracy: Fox Exity.

[0:11] Joe Carroll: With the song Jimmy.

[0:15] Dan Tracy: Don't cry for me.

[0:24] Joe Carroll: My birthday.

[0:26] Dan Tracy: It's my birthday.

[0:28] Joe Carroll: Do you know you had me scared to death? I was just about to run out of this place like nobody's business.

[0:32] Dan Tracy: I was. I mean, I didn't know. I mean, what kind of friends would surprise you on your 35th birthday?

[0:40] Joe Carroll: Mine.

[0:42] Dan Tracy: Then again, how many times do you get to be 35?

[0:47] Joe Carroll: 11.

[0:50] Dan Tracy: Okay, come on, say it. Get it over with. It's embarrassing quick. I can't stand it.

[0:57] Joe Carroll: Pinnacle of joy.

[1:01] Dan Tracy: Boy unites with boy.

[1:03] Joe Carroll: Oh my god. Matt Doyle's here.

[1:05] Matt Doyle: Hi!

[1:06] Dan Tracy: How are ya? Welcome to Guys Who Like Musicals, Matt Doyle.

[1:09] Matt Doyle: Welcome to Guys Who Like Musicals.

[1:11] Joe Carroll: Uh, and guys who like guys who like musicals.

[1:15] Dan Tracy: That's right. Guys, there you go. We were gonna put that on a t-shirt.

[1:18] Joe Carroll: We do have that on a t-shirt.

[1:20] Dan Tracy: We do?

[1:20] Joe Carroll: I think we do, yeah.

[1:21] Dan Tracy: Alright, we'll go back out the movie. I can't wait.

[1:25] Joe Carroll: So this week we're talking about Company.

[1:28] Dan Tracy: We love Company.

[1:30] Joe Carroll: Holy shit, do we love Company?

[1:32] Dan Tracy: Yes. Um, and we thought that we would bug one of my best friends, uh, and one of my wife's nemesis, uh, nemeses, uh, Matt Doyle.

[1:40] Joe Carroll: Matt Doyle played opposite my wife in the most recent revival of Sweeney Todd at the Barrow Street Theater.

[1:46] Dan Tracy: Yeah, he made his Broadway debut in Spring Awakening, Little Bye Bye Birdie, Little War Horse, Elder Price in The Book of Mormon, Clockwork Orange, which I absolutely loved.

[1:56] Matt Doyle: That was one of the weirdest things I've ever seen.

[1:58] Dan Tracy: It is the weirdest thing I've ever done.

[2:00] Joe Carroll: So there you go. It was so cool. You've been developing, he's been developing The Heart of Rock and Roll.

[2:05] Dan Tracy: But today we're talking about Jamie's latest job.

[2:11] Joe Carroll: The latest job that it will hopefully come back on the other side of this madness.

[2:16] Dan Tracy: Um, the dream job that I've always wanted that I never thought global pandemic would be, you know, what obstacles, right?

[2:25] Joe Carroll: Yeah, exactly. How is that? How's everything going with that? Do you have any information you can share?

[2:32] Matt Doyle: Yeah, absolutely. So Company's in a really good place. A lot of shows now at this point, what's kind of become a good thing about this pandemic taking so long and being so much worse than we thought is that now shows they've all basically been released from their rent. Like no one is paying rent to these theaters anymore. And shows now have time to reinvest, they have time to get their insurance payments and figure out how to mount on the other side of this. And I think if we had all actually come back in July, you would have seen 60% of the shows closing because they just didn't have the time to pull together those resources. And now most of the season that was there before this madness will probably at least try to figure out how to come back.

Their set is there, ready, waiting to go. Everything is in place, and there are people waiting to get their jobs back. So Company is actually in a really good place for that because we never opened and our set is built, everyone is ready to go. We never had our press night, so we just get to open on the other side of this, and we're planning on it. I know that the dream would be to open on Sondheim's 91st birthday, because we were supposed to open on his 90th, which would be in March. But I'm guessing that we'll probably be opening in April or May, maybe if all goes well with the vaccines and the treatments. Look, no matter what, what I keep saying to everyone, and I truly mean this, to be a part of the reopening will be the most profound moment of my life, no matter what happens with the production and how well it does.

I can't even imagine bringing Broadway back with a piece like Company, which is about the human connection and about being together and learning from one another, and Company, you know, after what we've been through and the isolation that we've been through.

[4:27] Joe Carroll: Totally, it's amazing.

[4:29] Matt Doyle: So I'm just—

[4:31] Dan Tracy: Love so real.

[4:32] Joe Carroll: That's—and I was exactly I was gonna say that. I mean, there was a—I’ve been obsessed the last few days reading, um, finishing a hat, and looking at Sondheim's books as we were kind of preparing for, you know, to talk about Company. But one of the things he says is, you know, it's a show about maintaining relationships in a society that is becoming increasingly depersonalized, and like that is so exact, you know. Can you imagine to come back after—I mean, and that's what made this revival so profound to begin with, and what the approach was based off of that quote alone. I mean, that was something that we realized that it was more than relevant now. But, um, yeah, after this, my God.

[5:10] Matt Doyle: Yeah.

[5:11] Dan Tracy: Just because—just got goosebumps again.

[5:13] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[5:13] Dan Tracy: So stoked for you guys. That's awesome.

[5:15] Joe Carroll: Yeah. Joe, what do you say? Should we jump in here?

[5:17] Matt Doyle: Yeah.

[5:17] Joe Carroll: Let's do it. Let's let nerd alert, nerd alert. Let's jump in here. Um, we're gonna do a little reading for a second. There's been a bunch of productions of this show, and we're gonna get into this. For those of you who are listening at home and don't really know the history of the show, we're gonna get into it, and we're gonna try and cover most of the productions, but we're gonna focus our area of expertise on the original, the Doyle production and then on Matt's production, obviously, because he's here.

[5:45] Dan Tracy: Expertise or lack thereof.

[5:47] Joe Carroll: Right, or the research that—the quick research we did in our very fancy podcast with, uh—

[5:47] Dan Tracy: Yeah, exactly, exactly. So Company opened in 1970, uh, written by Stephen Sondheim and George Firth. The original production was nominated for 12 Tony Awards, question mark. It says 12 in some places, and then in others it says 14. I think it's 12. It won six, and it was directed and produced by Hal Prince. Revolves, um, the plot revolves around Bobby, or Robert, who's a single guy committed to basically perpetually single, perpetually single guy, right? And his five married couple friends and his three girlfriends. It's a bunch of short vignettes and it's presented in a nonlinear order, which we'll get into, and it all kind of goes around Bobby's 35th birthday. How'd I do, Matt?

[6:36] Matt Doyle: That's amazing.

[6:37] Dan Tracy: Yeah, that's great.

[6:37] Joe Carroll: Awesome. Yeah, well, and there's a lot of cool cultural relevance to that, just as far as the form itself. We talk a lot about like the integrated book musical that was—that was that how, you know, sort of burst onto the scene with Oklahoma, and you know, some would say Show Boat, but really with Oklahoma. And then all of a sudden in 1970 came this concept musical that just kind of, uh, you know, Broadway was like, What is happening?

[7:01] Matt Doyle: Yep.

[7:01] Joe Carroll: You know, there it isn't a really plot based, it's experience based, and it all takes place basically, uh, you know, as Sondheim said, it basically takes place not over a period of time, but in an instant in Robert's mind, you know, perhaps in a psychiatrist's couch or something, which I think is fantastic. It's just so bizarre. Um, and there were some shows that had a similar concept musical form. Obviously, Cabaret had come before that, and Hair were in that similar category, but this was the first one that was like gonna be sold to mainstream Broadway and sold to the kind of traditional Broadway audience and was a big commercial success that was in this form. So it really like set up what a—that the integrated book musical wasn't the only thing that a musical could be on Broadway.

[7:45] Matt Doyle: Yep.

[7:45] Joe Carroll: Yeah. Did Matt, did you guys get to work with Steve at all throughout this? Has he been around to talk about this process?

[7:53] Matt Doyle: Yeah, no, he's been around, uh, or he was around a lot, and that was something that was just so incredible. Stephen Sondheim, I have to say, one of the most amazing things about working with him twice now, uh, with Sweeney in this, is watching this unbelievable genius that we all respect and worship and treat like a god, um, so open to new ideas with his work and like just so, so incredibly adventurous and, uh, still creating and still creative. Um, he wants to change, uh, hepatitis to coronavirus on the other side of this, somehow make that scan in "Getting Married Today," you know. Like he doesn't care, you know. Anyone that's like—I think he finds it very, very funny that there are people out there that call themselves Sondheim purists because I don't even think he considers himself a Sondheim purist, you know.

It's about continuing to grow and allowing other people to explore your work and make it new again. And he's been so open to that. So he's been really involved in the creative process. And I, you know, I would get emails from him myself, which was utterly surreal.

[9:06] Joe Carroll: But you have his email?

[9:08] Matt Doyle: I do.

[9:09] Joe Carroll: Please tell me it's literally like, you know, Stevie dot Sondhi at Hotmail.com.

[9:17] Matt Doyle: No, no, but it is like some like something very, very simple and abridged. And the first time it popped up, I was like, who is this?

[9:28] Joe Carroll: Yeah, exactly.

[9:29] Matt Doyle: It's actually just like, yeah, move on. Um, no, he's amazing. He's so receptive towards new ideas. And, um, talk about an honor. Like, I can't even believe it. Um, but yeah, he was around, that's for sure. So many lyrics had to change, so many things had to change. So we'll get into that in a little bit, but yes, Dan's gonna hit us with some more history.

[9:54] Dan Tracy: Alright. Yeah, so, so, uh, the original production ran for 705 performances, which today is like, we're like only 705 performances. That's not even a hit. But at the time, shows weren't running that long. At the time, the longest running show had just, uh, Fiddler on the Roof had just become the longest running show, also, um, uh, produced by Hal Prince. And it was in like the 2000 performance range when it became the longest running show. So at the time, 705 was a lot. They did a production in '72 in London, where, um, so we'll get into this, but Larry Kurt, who played Tony in the original West Side Story, replaced Dean Jones pretty quickly after opening Company and then opened the show in London with a lot of the, uh, the same cast, um, also directed by Hal.

Then there was a '95 revival in 1995 directed by Scott Ellis and Rob Marshall that ran for only 60 performances. And there's a highlight reel on YouTube. You guys, you gotta check it out. We're not here to bash anything, but it's a very different, yeah, it's a fan show for sure, but it's a very different look, uh, in my opinion. And, um, really some sick cast members in there, Jane Krakowski as Amy, which is pretty sick. Then Sam Mendes directed a revival in London, uh, in '95, and they had their first Black Bobby there. Then there was the 2006 revival directed by John Doyle, which ran for 245 performances, just under a year.

[11:22] Matt Doyle: Which we're gonna get to.

[11:23] Dan Tracy: Which we're gonna get to because I love—I mean, that's what I—the version that I knew first and grew up on. Uh, and I will never forget that Tony performance. And then now here we are in the 2020 revival, which was set to open March 22nd.

[11:38] Joe Carroll: And here we are, will open March 22nd, 21.

[11:42] Matt Doyle: 21.

[11:42] Joe Carroll: Yeah, which is really entirely possible. Honestly, I, you know, I really do think that things are looking good in the vaccine range. I'm staying positive, you guys. I said this to—I said this on a Zoom call the other day with Patti LuPone, and she said, "Oh god, Matt, your positivity is just heartbreaking," which is my favorite quote from Patti.

[12:08] Matt Doyle: And I was like, "Oh, thanks, Patti."

[12:11] Dan Tracy: Man, oh my god. I'm obsessed with that. Um, Dan, you have this note here about the—this is something that I thought was super duper interesting that you found about like Governor Ronald Reagan signing this divorce, this no-fault divorce thing. I thought this was super interesting in 1969.

[12:25] Joe Carroll: Yeah, I remember when we talked about Brett, obviously our department chair of Michigan, Brent Wagner, loved—loves Sondheim, who doesn't, and loved Company specifically. And when we talked about it in class, he was like, you didn't see divorce on a Broadway stage before this.

[12:40] Dan Tracy: So this was like the thing. Um, not that the whole show is about divorce. There's one couple that gets divorced, there's another couple that should get divorced. It's like kind of all about like what happens in marriages, happy or not happy, and whether or not you want to like go down that road as a person. In 1969, Ronald Reagan, the then governor of California, signed the first no-fault divorce bill.

[13:03] Dan Tracy: And that allowed of course it was an actor that did that.

[13:06] Joe Carroll: Right.

[13:07] Dan Tracy: Which he then like rated, he later writes about it in his book, saying it was the greatest mistake he's ever made because obviously he's like a huge, I think he's Catholic, but he was a huge, like sort of religious forward politician, and this obviously went against a lot of those religious practices at the time.

[13:23] Joe Carroll: So in the 70s, um was when we first saw the numbers of divorce really spike, and like 50% of kids born in the 1970s, their parents um got divorced, and as opposed to people who are going to see Broadway shows now too, which is like the crazy thing.

[13:41] Dan Tracy: Right, right. You know, so um there was just a huge stigma around divorce at that time, and then this show was kind of the all these married couples going to see this show are like, wow, here we are.

[13:54] Joe Carroll: This is right in our face.

[13:55] Dan Tracy: And Sondheim has some good quotes here about, well, I mean, he this was one that I I like, he said, you know, the Broadway theater has for many years supported upper middle class people with upper middle class problems. These people really want to escape the world when they go to the theater, and then here they are with Company talking about how we're going to bring it right back in their faces.

[14:11] Joe Carroll: You know, it it was one of these things that like, you know, he I actively, I mean, I can't really imagine sort of, you know, what they must have been thinking about, like sort of, you know, writing it. I mean, one of the uh one of the another quote that he had was it made a lot of grown-ups who had disdained musicals take them seriously, and it not incidentally gave uh me my first good notices.

[14:30] Dan Tracy: So like he started to get actually good reviews for a show that is kind of like, hey, look at you know, here's all your problems, and I'm gonna, you know, talk about why you should or shouldn't be married.

[14:43] Joe Carroll: You two are, he said with envy, just beautiful together.

[14:47] Dan Tracy: Really?

[14:48] Joe Carroll: A terrific pair.

[14:49] Dan Tracy: And Peter, if you ever decide to leave her, I want to be the first to know.

[14:53] Joe Carroll: Well, you're the first to know.

[14:59] Dan Tracy: We're getting divorced.

[15:02] Joe Carroll: We haven't told anyone yet.

[15:12] Dan Tracy: Oh.

[15:13] Joe Carroll: I'm so surprised.

[15:15] Dan Tracy: Maybe it'll work it out.

[15:18] Joe Carroll: Well, and it was really like one of the first musicals, especially mainstream musicals, to do that to make people face their problems rather than bring joy and be an escape.

[15:30] Dan Tracy: Right.

[15:30] Joe Carroll: When did Cabaret open?

[15:32] Dan Tracy: 68.

[15:33] Joe Carroll: I'm just 68.

[15:34] Dan Tracy: Because that is like like another one of these that like ripe the you know, the precursor to like, hey, we're going to, we're gonna, we're gonna give you something to think about.

[15:42] Joe Carroll: Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Totally.

[15:44] Dan Tracy: You know, in a really kind of remarkable way.

[15:46] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[15:46] Dan Tracy: And that was like how Prince's thing. He was like, I'm here to tell stories that matter. He wasn't necessarily providing an escape.

[15:51] Joe Carroll: Sondheim is is the same, well, at least described in the same way that like he writes dark shows. I don't know if that's really like what his intention was, or if he was like, the musical form shouldn't just be about escapism. He kind of like forced us to think about um, and that led the way for so many of the shows that exist now. Like you wouldn't have had a Dear Evan Hansen. You know what I mean? Like these shows that aren't about just happy things.

[16:16] Dan Tracy: Right.

[16:16] Joe Carroll: So uh you know, uh somebody that I grew up with uh in theater said to me recently that Sondheim shows are joyless, and I was like, Oh my god. I was like, what a way to put it.

[16:29] Dan Tracy: And they were like, no, they're they're joyless, they're jo joyless, you know, musicals. And I was like, I I I said I was like, they're they're Shakespeare. Like they make you think, they make you question things, they make you question everything about the way that you're living your life. And I was like, if that's joyless, then I just feel like we are dumbing it down to a very, very useless word here.

[16:54] Joe Carroll: Absolutely.

[16:55] Dan Tracy: And he and he said, you know, one another quote of his was like saying that people people use that to describe his work all the time, and like that they'll say like Bobby is void, or that like you know, there's there's this lack, and it's like it's like I mean, I don't agree with any of those people, so you can turn off the podcast if you do, but it's like that thing that like we're he's trying to trying to mimic life, he's trying to rip life apart a little bit and say that like you know, you're always grateful, you're always sorry, you're always you know, it's not just it's a bright golden haze on the meadow, you know.

[17:26] Joe Carroll: Right, right.

[17:27] Dan Tracy: He says, uh Well, you know, my favorite quote the unexamined life is not worth living. And I think mine is the unlived life is not worth examining, and kind of a a jab back at him, but that's like the whole thing. Is the uh that's one of my favorite, you know, moments in the whole show.

[17:41] Joe Carroll: Totally.

[17:47] Dan Tracy: Because that's one of the ultimate relationships, too.

[17:49] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[17:49] Dan Tracy: Right. It's palpable. It's like he's got everything going on. He's got like, I want it, but I don't, all at the same time, you know?

[17:56] Joe Carroll: Right.

[17:57] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[17:57] Joe Carroll: Yeah, which is the great sort of juxtaposition of marriage and relationships in general. And we'll get into we'll get into like watch, you know, the the John Doyle revival, but Alex and I sat down and watched it last night, and it was the first time that I'd seen it as a married person. So like we're sitting there, we're sitting there as married people being like, huh.

[18:10] Dan Tracy: Yep.

[18:15] Joe Carroll: And and I and I leaned toward at one point, and I'm like, you know, it it has not, you know, like we'll get into the lyric section, but it's sorry, grateful. Yeah, sorry, no, literally, like the end, that you know, it has everything to do with and nothing to do with her. And I was like, oh my gosh, I love that. And so, and so she turns to me and goes, So are you sorry, grateful?

[18:34] Dan Tracy: And you're you're like, Yes, and we have to be okay with that.

[18:39] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[18:40] Dan Tracy: Right. But it was oh my god, it's so it's just remarkable. Um, one of the things I thought was cool to just touch on briefly is is the connection to Allegro. That that like Allegro was his musical written by Rogerson Hammerstein. Obviously, Oscar Hammerstein was um uh Steven Sondheim's mentor. Um, that you know, Allegro kind of had no form. Allegro was this kind of formless musical that that Steven Sondheim was an assistant on, he was like Oscar's assistant on it, and got to see sort of like all of the flaws, all of the good, all of the bad, and all out of this man who had basically invented the integrated book musical.

[19:16] Joe Carroll: And so, you know, that's kind of, you know, one of those things that everybody's trying to fix Allegro. I think that like they've tried to revive it a thousand times and like they can't totally get it right. So maybe we should just revive Company over and over again because of the company they got right.

[19:29] Dan Tracy: Perfect.

[19:29] Joe Carroll: Exactly. Yeah, settle on the one that worked. Um in the development of the show, um, it was originally written to be 11 one act plays that George Firth wrote for Kim Stanley, and Anthony Perkins, the guy who played Norman Bates in the Psycho film, was interested in directing it. And he asked Sondheim to read the material. I don't know what their connection was, Matt. You might know, but I do not know the Anthony Perkins connection at all.

[19:59] Matt Doyle: I've actually not heard that before.

[20:00] Dan Tracy: Oh, okay, cool. Well, that hopefully this is true. It uh I forget where I found it. Um, after Sondheim read the shows, he said he asked Harold Prince for his opinion. And anyway, uh Hal was like, this would be a great musical, and then the rest is history. So that's what we have as far as the development, the original. But I'm curious, Matt, how if you know anything about the development of how the London production came about and why they decided to flip genders and how that all came about with Mary and Elliott at the helm.

[20:30] Matt Doyle: Yeah, absolutely. So um Chris Harper, uh, who uh runs Harper Elliott Productions with Mary Ann, and it's a newer production company. They met doing Warhorse together, and um he was actually our lead producer on Warhorse, so I got to know him then. Um he always always loved Company, and he was having uh a bit of a you know life changing moment one day, listening to the Company soundtrack and listening to Being Alive, and the words just completely haunted him for the rest of the week. And he said to Mary Ann, I, you know, I want to do a musical with you, and we need to do Sondheim. Uh, the Brits get Sondheim, you know, it's it like I said before, it's very Shakespearean. And that's why they they love that everything is informed through the writing and the music, and that everything is written for a reason. It's all text-based, like it's very smart and intricate in that way. And it's it's familiar to them, you know. It's like I said, almost like uh written in prose.

[21:34] Joe Carroll: Um she responded with, yes, sure, I like Company too. Obviously, it's one of my favorite musicals, but I just cannot wrap my head around the idea of selling to an audience that a successful 35-year-old man would be so gripped with anxiety over not being married and settled in New York in this day and age.

[22:04] Matt Doyle: And she was like, I just don't know how to sell that story right now. And she goes, I would sit in that audience rolling my eyes, you know, like he's got everything. And I know a million guys like that that are certainly not even thinking about marriage right now and think that they're still a young bachelor, and that's fine. And then she realized, but what might be interesting is what if we made it a woman? Because if you make it a woman, all of a sudden, it's absolutely contemporary. We have so many successful women in New York turning 35 that are still faced with the societal pressures that they need to be settled, married, uh living the way that their parents did, that they are not allowed to be successful and sexy and confident and you know, not allowed to be uh live a bachelor lifestyle, you know, that that is something that is still still taboo in in uh to a lot of different people.

[23:06] Joe Carroll: So she was like, that's that could be something interesting. And she was like, but Sondheim will never go for it. So they reached out to Steven Sondheim, and uh she I think she had dinner with him and tried to sell him the idea. And he said, Look, why don't you do a reading? Film the reading. If I like it, then we can move forward with it. And they did a workshop out in London, and uh Amy was still a character. Jamie had not happened yet. Um, so Amy was still a woman, and uh Bobby was the only one that changed genders in that production, but they did obviously have to move around different genders because some things just do not work when you only change Bobby. So they had to like the character names would stay the same, but they had to switch the roles of Jenny and David, because it doesn't make sense for Bobby to have that very uncomfortable discussion at the end of the scene with David. She has to have it with Jenny now, talking about David.

[24:04] Dan Tracy: Um it's it's amazing the flips that happened. Uh so they did a lot of that work then. And they uh they presented it to Sondheim and he called and said, Let's go, let's move forward with it. I'm I'm absolutely on board. And the last piece of the puzzle was Jamie, and that was Chris Harper, again, really, really pushing the fact that he would like to see the debate of um a gay man in uh 20 and 18, 19 at the time, uh wrestling over the idea of marriage, you know, just the and they even added a line into the show, just because we can doesn't mean we should, which has become, I think, a very, very real issue for a lot of gay couples um that are rushing to the altar right now. Uh why necessarily? Like why am I making this commitment to you?

[24:55] Matt Doyle: Um, so that was the last piece of the puzzle. And Marianne was absolutely opposed to it, hated the idea, lost sleep over it for weeks, and uh finally, finally gave into it. And now she thinks it's one of the best decisions she's made. She was just so worried to lose another amazing female character, you know, as as a director who was trying to bring to life uh and a new incredible female lead that she would lose this like brilliant uh character role for another woman.

[25:27] Joe Carroll: But I'm grateful.

[25:30] Matt Doyle: Yeah.

[25:31] Joe Carroll: Totally.

[25:32] Dan Tracy: Well, we are too.

[25:33] Joe Carroll: And it expands the representation of the show too.

[25:35] Matt Doyle: Absolutely.

[25:35] Joe Carroll: Which I think is really cool.

[25:37] Matt Doyle: I think that's what she did uh come to appreciate about it.

[25:40] Matt Doyle: Yeah, that's awesome.

[25:41] Joe Carroll: And like you said, I mean, Stephen Sondheim, I'm just desperately, you know, he is totally good to just mix things up for the time, you know, to change things for the time, to change lyrics for the time, to just, you know, like you said, they're so like Sondheim purists, but like he's not.

[25:56] Matt Doyle: And so many people are precious about their work, and especially composers that have only been around for like five to ten years are so precious about their work.

[26:04] Dan Tracy: And I'm like, you have to let people explore it. And yes, sometimes it's gonna be a train wreck, and that's okay, you know, they'll get blamed for it, not you.

[26:13] Joe Carroll: Right.

[26:14] Dan Tracy: Well, I'm so glad you're here to give us that insight because it seems so obvious now that you say it, why you would flip the gender. You know, you look at it and it's like, oh, this is just another way for them to, you know, revive the show and let's just, you know, be crazy and this is a good marketing ploy or whatever. But when you see when you think about it in the context of the actual story, as Sondheim always does with every single note and rhythm and everything, it really does make the story better. I mean, and it's more relevant now, I guess. Everything and it makes everything more relevant and and it immediately removes the issue of sexism in almost every scene. I mean, uh, let's be completely frank about Company now.

If you have it with a male lead, there are some really uncomfortable moments uh looking at that material now and some of these scenes towards women, especially David and Bobby's aside at the end of that scene towards Jenny. You know, it's just very there's a lot of sexism. And when you flip it, you remove and lift so much of that sexism. And it was, yeah, it just opens the piece up and makes it completely contemporary, just in one simple move.

[27:33] ♪ Musical number: "Marry Me a Little" — performed by Matt Doyle ♪

[27:54] Dan Tracy: I was watching the um original Broadway cast documentary, which is on the Criterion channel. If anyone hasn't seen it. And you guys, it's amazing that the Criterion Channel has released this because for years you could only watch it on YouTube or buy like a $70 DVD where it was in a collection of documentaries on eBay somewhere in the depths of some musical gay man's basement. Like this is um incredible that they've re-released this, and it is so unbelievable. Elaine Stritch in this documentary, there's just there's nothing better. You have to watch it. There's no, I definitely recommend watching that and then watching the John Doyle, which is how I did it, and it was really awesome. I would love to hear um so obviously it's a critical success.

It ran for a long time. Um it was one of the first shows that Sondheim got really good reviews for, obviously, which set him up for a while until um he is no longer set up when Merrill came around, right? But um, I would love to hear what you guys um how you guys came to love the show and uh specifically Matt, kind of what your experience is with Company before I throw in my hat as well.

[29:14] Matt Doyle: Yeah, Company is one of those shows that uh you have to grow into. I mean, it was something that I think I was exposed to when I was younger and discovering Sondheim, and it was the piece that I was like, I don't know that one, I don't get that, you know. Like as a as a kid and as a teenager, there were songs in it that I was like, wow, "Being Alive" is an amazing song. I recognize that, but the actual content was something that I even knew then, like, well, this is an acquired taste. Like, I have to I have to live more to discover this show. And I didn't revisit Company until the 2006 revival with um Raul. And um I loved it, I thought it was amazing, but I do remember that revival being so dark and the delivery of it being so serious.

And um so I even then didn't really recognize even though I I loved the show and Raul was so powerful and gave just such a mind-blowing performance, I still didn't recognize the show as a comedy. I recognized it as drama, you know, as one of Sondheim's more dramatic pieces. And I think what's crazy about getting into it now and doing this 2020 production is like I've never laughed so hard or heard such loud laughter in a theater from, you know, than this very, very comedic version and very contemporary version that we're doing now. So it's amazing that just what direction does, you know, and where it leads and and how much it can change the piece um through delivery and aesthetic and uh casting I mean my God.

Chris Fitzgerald I can't wait to see. Oh my god and he's playing essentially he's playing Jenny so because he David but with the Jenny lines and I've never ever seen a like more brilliant stone performance in my entire life. Like it's just such a clown like a literal trained clown he's seen. Infuriated yeah yeah so he's amazing in it and we just have these like comedy legends in this production that I I just sit and stare at baffled by them. You know. Like, how, how does that happen? How does that come out of your mind and out of your head?

[31:37] Dan Tracy: So, um, yeah, I think I think you know, I don't necessarily believe that uh the more comedic direction is the right way at all, but uh it's amazing how much this material can adapt to whoever's taking it on.

[31:49] Joe Carroll: That's awesome. I just love that. And yeah, I'm sure you can hold your own Mr. Elder Price too. I'm sure you're I'm sure you're underplaying yourself as well.

[31:57] Matt Doyle: I mean, I I'm learning every day from these people, that's for sure. We've got like Chris Sieber up there, like, come on. I'm just like, teach me.

[32:05] Joe Carroll: Listen, your your "Kiss Me" opposite Alex Fink was one of the funniest things I've ever seen in my life.

[32:10] Matt Doyle: That's incredibly I have a plan.

[32:14] Joe Carroll: Matt Doyle just like finger in the air, like your goofy, beautiful smile, just like you're a funny, you are funny. And I I know that, like, I hope you know how funny you are.

[32:22] Matt Doyle: I appreciate that so much. You know, honestly, I don't think I would have had a shot in hell uh to get this job if I hadn't done that Sweeney Todd and and worked with uh even in a very, very small way, worked with Steven Sondheim then and had him see me in that because Marion said that when she did present the idea to Steven, he was like, Oh yeah, I know him, great, you know. And I was like, thank God, like thank God. I was waiting for like five days after my audition, and there was no answer. And I my agents weren't telling me anything. They were just like, just hold on, hold on. What I was waiting for was Steven's approval, and thank God they didn't tell me that. Because if I didn't get it after that, I would have been like, he said no. Oh god, I would have like jumped off a bridge. Are you kidding?

[33:10] Dan Tracy: But I guess my I I love this show. I discovered it the same way, you know, through the 2006 revival, and I just remember watching Raul Spars on the Tony Awards sit at the piano and being like, Oh, that's that's cool. He's playing the piano to accompany his own Tony performance. Like, I mean, I was 16, I had no idea what was going on. And and then researching this unbelievably perfect metaphor in my mind that now he is part of the band that actually to sit at the piano and to accompany himself was he now he is he is taking taking control of the you know in that way. And I just I I couldn't believe it. And as a young musician who also obviously loved musicals, was like, oh my god, John Doyle did what?

And who is John Doyle? And he's wait a minute. So it really blew my mind as far as like what an actor musician could be. I didn't even know that was a thing, you know. Yeah, and then that performance just I I remember not then going down the uh the rabbit hole of like Elaine Stritch and that in the behind the scenes and wait a minute, you're always sorry, you're always it was my first in you know introduction to it for sure.

[34:22] Joe Carroll: And it's been one of your favorite shows for a long time, Dan. I mean, you wanted to talk about this show this week more than you know, yeah, like this is one of my favorites. I ended up like having shows that have become tent poles for me, like I will never forget learning Sunday in the Park with George, which I want to talk about here eventually too, because it was like it's another one of those shows that has so many metaphors for what it means to be an artist, what it means to be a person, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And it just struck me. But this was the first time that that happened where a musical like changed the way that I understood what musicals could be, and what you know what I mean?

This idea that I was never into the flashy, showy, old fashioned, for lack of a better word, musical theater style. I was like, I want to be uh acting the way I would in film and TV in a musical. And that's what I saw here. And all of a sudden I was like, whoa, this could this, this is what I want to do. This is the whole, this is kind of became my North Star for like what I really wanted to track in my career. And those are all the shows that I've done, basically, is like the realism based shows is kind of like where I've stuck to. So I'm grateful that I found this show when I did.

[35:34] Dan Tracy: I'm just gonna cover some more of the people who have been involved in this so that we can. I mean, most of us probably understand how important the creative team of this original production were, but I'm just gonna fly through some things for people who don't know. In 1970, the show is directed and produced by Hal Prince. He started as a producer, which is interesting, and then became a more prolific director later in his career. But this started like a slew of shows that he did with Steven Sondheim, which then uh they did Follies, A Little Night Music, Pacific Overtures, Sweeney Todd, and then concluded their relationship of sort of with Merrily We Roll Along, which only ran for 16 performances.

Hal later directed Evita and Phantom of the Opera, which I'm sure you've heard of. And um there's a documentary about Hal Prince that Lonnie Price directed, um, which is called Harold Prince, the Director's Life. And Lonnie Price, which you can find Price, sorry, directed the you were about to say it. Yeah, yeah, and Lonnie Price directed the uh comp the John Doyle Company for TV. The 95 production is directed by Scott Ellis, who recently worked on She Loves Me, Kiss Me Kate, and Tootsie. John Doyle directed the 2006 revival, which came the year after the Sweeney Todd revival that he did, where with which was acting musicians, and John Doyle recently also directed The Color Purple. And now the 2020 production is being directed by Marianne Elliott, who won a Tony Award for Warhorse in 2011, which Matt Doyle was in.

And then she won uh a Tony Award as well for Curious Incident. And she won an Olivier for Curious Incident as well, which just very quickly is one of the most remarkable plays I've ever seen. I didn't get to see Warhorse, unfortunately, but Curious Incident was unreal.

[37:27] Matt Doyle: Yeah.

[37:27] Dan Tracy: Um the show was written by George Firth, who was an actor.

[37:33] Matt Doyle: Mr. E. H. Herman.

[37:34] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[37:35] Matt Doyle: Mr. E. H. Herman of the Union Pacific Railroad.

[37:38] Dan Tracy: That's right.

[37:38] Matt Doyle: He's in Butch Cassidy's Blazing Saturday.

[37:42] Dan Tracy: I was wondering. I'm like, this guy.

[37:44] Matt Doyle: Are you kidding? Yes.

[37:45] Dan Tracy: I did not know.

[37:46] Matt Doyle: He's an actor.

[37:48] Dan Tracy: And then mostly an actor, yeah.

[37:49] Matt Doyle: And then he wrote the book to Merrily, too. And after that flopped, he didn't really get to write much anymore. He tried to write a couple other things that just didn't work.

[37:56] Dan Tracy: Well, and just so I say it here, I mean, more than anything, Sondheim does not consider this his piece. Like he doesn't talk about it in that way. And he's very clear every single time that he talks about the piece. He gets extremely emotional, which is beautiful to see. Um, and talks about this being George's. Like this is George's piece that they were all serving George's work throughout this original process. And and the whole idea was how do we create something around George's genius? Is like the way they treated it originally. So he gets very emotional now watching what's been done with it over the years because he just can't believe that the legacy of what he considers so brilliant is carrying on so much. And um, yeah, I mean, George was just very present in the room with us because Sondheim wanted wanted him honored every day that he was talking about the show.

[38:51] Matt Doyle: So that's awesome. I love that. Obviously, then Sondheim is the is the writer. He's won eight Tony Awards in his life. Um uh plus a lifetime achievement.

[39:00] Dan Tracy: He has eight Grammy Awards, a Pulitzer Prize, an Olivier Award, and he has won the 2015 Presidential Medal of Freedom.

[39:08] Joe Carroll: He just celebrated his 90th birthday.

[39:10] Dan Tracy: He does not have an Emmy, so we gotta figure out how to get the Santa he got.

[39:15] Joe Carroll: Um, good lord.

[39:16] Dan Tracy: He's best known for "Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum," "Company," "Follies," "Night Music," "Sweeney Todd," "Sunday in the Park with George," "Into the Woods," and he wrote the lyrics for "West Side Story" and "Gypsy."

[39:26] Joe Carroll: There's an interesting story in the documentary about how he was supposed to write the music for "Gypsy," but he didn't.

[39:30] Dan Tracy: Yep.

[39:31] Joe Carroll: Because Ethel Merman really wanted an experienced music writer and they didn't trust him.

[39:36] Dan Tracy: So this was his first, unbelievable.

[39:39] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[39:39] Dan Tracy: Not his first music, but this was his first successful musical that he owned.

[39:44] Joe Carroll: Yeah, music and lyrics.

[39:45] Dan Tracy: Yeah, exactly.

[39:46] Joe Carroll: So, um, Michael Bennett did the music staging.

[39:50] Dan Tracy: Michael Bennett is famous, obviously, for conceiving "A Chorus Line," which we should talk about on this show because Joe loves it.

[39:55] Joe Carroll: Michael Bennett also directed and choreographed "Dreamgirls," which we should also talk about on this show.

[40:00] Dan Tracy: Yep.

[40:01] Joe Carroll: Now we're gonna get into some of the people who worked on this show in history.

[40:04] Dan Tracy: Obviously, there's been so many productions, so there's a lot of people here.

[40:07] Joe Carroll: We really want to hear Matt's audition story in this section.

[40:11] Dan Tracy: Yeah, we're gonna—this is the casting part of this.

[40:14] Joe Carroll: I think, you know, there's so, again, like Dan said, there's so many amazing people, but like we gotta talk about Elaine Stritch.

[40:20] Dan Tracy: Yeah, and we gotta talk about, um, Matt Doyle.

[40:23] Joe Carroll: Yeah, I already told her story about, uh, Dean Jones leaving the production and being replaced by Larry Kurt, which according to the Wikipedia article said that it was too nihilistic because he was going through a divorce, so it was really hard for him.

[40:37] Dan Tracy: Is that—and that's the story that's held up for me?

[40:41] Joe Carroll: I mean, that's what I've, uh, what's been continued to be translated to me.

[40:45] Dan Tracy: I don't know how true that is or how unsatisfied they were with him.

[40:50] Joe Carroll: Um, but that's certainly the story they're sticking with, and I guess he was pretty miserable there.

[40:58] Dan Tracy: Crazy.

[40:58] Joe Carroll: Gosh, I can't imagine.

[41:00] Dan Tracy: I like, if like going through that and then having to sing about all of it.

[41:03] Joe Carroll: You know what I mean?

[41:04] Dan Tracy: That's a little too like, too Stritch-like, Lee Strasberg or something.

[41:08] Joe Carroll: Um, the only thing I wanted to hit on before we get into Matt's story is that this New York Philharmonic concert version that there's also a movie of that Neil Patrick Harris was in.

[41:22] Dan Tracy: I saw in the movie theaters.

[41:23] Joe Carroll: I couldn't find a full version of it, but there's so many great cast members in that that are worth mentioning.

[41:30] Dan Tracy: My girl Jill Pace and, um, Stephen Colbert was in it, obviously, and Aaron Lazar and all sorts of other people.

[41:37] Joe Carroll: But also, what I thought is interesting is that Liz Stanley made her Broadway debut in the John Doyle company as April.

[41:44] Dan Tracy: Oh, no kidding.

[41:44] Joe Carroll: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[41:45] Dan Tracy: Also, guys, in that production, the Philharmonic production, Christina Hendricks is so brilliant.

[41:52] Joe Carroll: Yes, like so brilliant.

[41:55] Dan Tracy: I love her in that role so much.

[41:57] Joe Carroll: And if she had gotten to do it on Broadway, she absolutely would have gotten a Tony nomination.

[42:03] Dan Tracy: She's incredible in that role.

[42:05] Joe Carroll: Uh, I love her.

[42:07] Dan Tracy: So funny.

[42:08] Joe Carroll: I found this thing about, you know, talking about Elaine Stritch.

[42:10] Dan Tracy: Um, you know, Joanne was written for Elaine Stritch, and I guess I didn't realize that, but it makes a hundred percent sense.

[42:17] Joe Carroll: Um, yeah, Sondheim says, not only the character of Joanne was not only written for Elaine Stritch, it was based on her, or at least, uh, on her, uh, sort of delivery of self-assessment.

[42:28] Dan Tracy: Um, there's this moment that he references that we're, uh, Elaine Stritch and George Firth walked into a bar, and Elaine Stritch said to the bartender, just give me a bottle of vodka and a floor plan.

[42:39] Joe Carroll: And I was like, that is so, first of all, it's Joanne, second of all, it's like the most Elaine Stritch thing I've ever heard.

[42:45] Dan Tracy: Um, and just like she lives on forever in this performance.

[42:49] Joe Carroll: Give me a bottle of vodka and a floor plan.

[42:51] Dan Tracy: Um, I just, I love—and then the idea that, uh, of, um, "The Ladies Who Lunch" was that he wanted it to be a show-stopping number for her, like he, like they actually for people to rise at the end of that, that, you know, she says rise 18 times or whatever, and that the hope was that people would actually leap out of their chairs and that, you know, maybe in 2020 they're gonna do that for Patti LuPone.

[43:13] Joe Carroll: I—and I don't know, it's awesome.

[43:17] Dan Tracy: Patti's baiting them in the, uh, in the Philharmonic version.

[43:20] Joe Carroll: Yeah, she's just like, like, you know, pacing, like staring at people and basically pointing at them to stand up, which I just love.

[43:29] Dan Tracy: Everybody rise, rise, rise, rise, rise, rise.

[43:56] Joe Carroll: What's amazing about our production, not spoiler alert, but she doesn't even get out of her frickin' chair.

[44:02] Dan Tracy: She sings the entire thing in a chair.

[44:04] Joe Carroll: That's power.

[44:05] Dan Tracy: And people stand.

[44:07] Joe Carroll: I mean, it's just something else.

[44:12] Dan Tracy: I love her so much.

[44:13] Joe Carroll: Oh my god.

[44:14] Dan Tracy: What a—what a—I just love it.

[44:17] Matt Doyle: The Matt Doyle audition story for "Company" also involves the Max Clayton "Moulin Rouge" story.

[44:24] Matt Doyle: And we had Max on the show, and we, you know, we love him to death.

[44:27] Joe Carroll: I—and so just talk to me about this because we're gonna talk about it, and then we're gonna drop in some audio of like what the hell we're actually talking about because it's hilarious.

[44:38] Matt Doyle: Um, so I, you know, I when I was up for it, I had heard that they were auditioning for about a month and that they were seeing people.

[44:48] Joe Carroll: And I have to say, like, at first I was a little hurt because Mary Ann, uh, and I were very close during "War Horse."

[44:55] Matt Doyle: I was like her best bud during that production, and we would drink until three in the morning and be hung over in rehearsal the next day.

[45:02] Joe Carroll: And I was like, how Elaine Stritch of you.

[45:06] Matt Doyle: Yes, very truly.

[45:07] Matt Doyle: And I was thinking to myself, you know, I know Marianne, I know that she absolutely would call me in if she felt I was right for something, and that's fine, so I'm not gonna say anything, but I'm kind of bummed that she doesn't think I'm right for this, you know.

[45:24] Matt Doyle: And, um, at the last minute, she was here for final, the like first round of final callbacks, which was a year ago, last July.

[45:31] Matt Doyle: And, um, she was just seeing people, she wanted to cast Jamie and Paul, Bobby, and like a couple other people.

[45:40] Joe Carroll: I think Carrie and, um, uh, maybe it was like Jenny got cast during that as well.

[45:46] Matt Doyle: And so she saw, uh, she wanted me to go in for Paul.

[45:51] Matt Doyle: And I said, okay, thank you so much.

[45:53] Matt Doyle: I'm so excited to come in.

[45:55] Matt Doyle: I'm so excited to see Mary Ann.

[45:57] Matt Doyle: Could you please just ask Mary Ann if she really feels right about that?

[46:01] Matt Doyle: Like, I agree that I can give you a good Paul, but I also—she knows that I have a panic attack disorder, like she knows that like I have terrible anxiety.

[46:01] Matt Doyle: Like she knows that I truly actually am Jamie.

[46:17] Matt Doyle: Like, can you please just ask her if she'll see me for Jamie?

[46:20] Matt Doyle: I know you guys are gonna bring in a name for Jamie, like someone big and famous.

[46:24] Matt Doyle: I hear who you're already looking at, but just I don't want to waste anyone's time.

[46:29] Joe Carroll: And she responded, no, he's a Paul.

[46:32] Matt Doyle: I'm not seeing him for Jamie.

[46:34] Matt Doyle: And I was like, all right, great, whatever.

[46:36] Matt Doyle: I'll go in, I'll take what I can get, sure.

[46:38] Matt Doyle: And, uh, I love Paul, he's a lovely role.

[46:41] Matt Doyle: And so I went in and I sang "Today Is For Jamie."

[46:45] Matt Doyle: And within 30 seconds, she stopped me and she goes, oh god, you're right.

[46:49] Matt Doyle: You are a Jamie.

[46:50] Matt Doyle: Oh god, oh god.

[46:52] Matt Doyle: And I was like, I just stared at her, like, okay, um, I know.

[47:00] Matt Doyle: Uh, I agree.

[47:02] Matt Doyle: You're correct.

[47:02] Matt Doyle: Um, and she was like, could you just learn a bit of "Getting Married"?

[47:07] Matt Doyle: And I was like, oh, absolutely.

[47:08] Matt Doyle: And she was like, great.

[47:09] Matt Doyle: And then I was taken over to the piano in the room to learn a bit of "Getting Married."

[47:15] Matt Doyle: No.

[47:15] Matt Doyle: And I had never learned that song because it's not for men.

[47:19] Matt Doyle: Like, it was not in my, like, repertoire.

[47:22] Matt Doyle: Like I wasn't like, well, of course, I know it, you know, I know the words.

[47:26] Matt Doyle: And, uh, so I stood there mortified, trying to learn the first verse of "Getting Married," just to show that I could do patter, essentially.

[47:35] Matt Doyle: And I got through it and spat it out.

[47:37] Matt Doyle: And she was like, great, great, great.

[47:39] Matt Doyle: And I said, you know, thank you so much for your patience through that.

[47:43] Matt Doyle: Obviously, uh, with more time, I would love to be able to do it.

[47:47] Matt Doyle: And she goes, oh god, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

[47:49] Matt Doyle: So I leave the room and I tell my agents, like, yeah, I think if I get called back, it will probably be for Jamie, which look, I'm not gonna book Jamie.

[47:56] Matt Doyle: So I'm so happy that I got to go in.

[47:59] Matt Doyle: They call and they say, you're going in for Jamie.

[48:02] Matt Doyle: I said, oh, great.

[48:03] Matt Doyle: And I said, well, so like next week, two weeks from now, and they were like, tomorrow.

[48:08] Matt Doyle: They said, you've 24 hours to learn all of the material.

[48:13] Matt Doyle: Let's drop it in right here.

[48:14] Matt Doyle: Pardon me, is everybody there?

[48:15] Matt Doyle: Because if everybody's there, I want to thank you all for coming to the wedding.

[48:17] Matt Doyle: I'd appreciate you going more.

[48:18] Matt Doyle: I mean, you must have lots of better things to do.

[48:19] Matt Doyle: And all the wonder to Paul.

[48:20] Matt Doyle: Remember, Paul, I know the man I'm gonna marry, but I'm not, because I wouldn't ruin anyone as wonderful as he is.

[48:23] Matt Doyle: But I thank you all for the gifts and the flowers.

[48:25] Matt Doyle: Thank you all.

[48:25] Matt Doyle: Now it's back to the showers.

[48:26] Matt Doyle: Don't tell Paul, but I'm not getting married today.

[48:30] Matt Doyle: This song is insane.

[48:32] Matt Doyle: I was like, I—not just the song, you guys, the monologuing that Jamie does in this scene, and she wants the full scene and the full song.

[48:42] Matt Doyle: I was like, what do you—what are you talking about?

[48:45] Matt Doyle: I said, I can't—I can't do that.

[48:46] Matt Doyle: It's five o'clock.

[48:47] Matt Doyle: I have a show tonight.

[48:49] Matt Doyle: I was doing this dance piece, which I wasn't dancing in, um, off, like, off-off Broadway at the Joyce, uh, called "Freddy Falls in Love."

[48:55] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[48:56] Matt Doyle: And I was like, I have a show and it's Max's opening in "Moulin Rouge" tonight.

[49:01] Matt Doyle: Like, I can't miss that.

[49:02] Matt Doyle: I'm supposed to go to his opening night.

[49:04] Matt Doyle: Yeah, I have a ticket.

[49:05] Matt Doyle: And they were like, well, you either go to this callback for Jamie or you don't go in.

[49:11] Matt Doyle: And I was like, that's insane, that's insane.

[49:13] Matt Doyle: And I stayed up until like four in the morning.

[49:16] Matt Doyle: I was crying at one point, just trying to drill.

[49:19] Matt Doyle: Pardon me, is everybody there?

[49:20] Matt Doyle: Because if everybody's there, like over and over and over and over again, every verse.

[49:25] Matt Doyle: I went in the next day and I learned the sides as best as I possibly could.

[49:28] Matt Doyle: Went in the next day, and I looked at Marianne and I said, I'm going to kill you.

[49:35] Matt Doyle: And she laughed and she goes, oh god, I know, I know.

[49:38] Matt Doyle: I'm so sorry.

[49:39] Matt Doyle: And, um, I just like spat it out, and it all fell out of me.

[49:46] Matt Doyle: And I actually didn't miss the lyric the first time through.

[49:49] Matt Doyle: And, uh, she was like, that was insane, and let's now actually work on it.

[49:54] Matt Doyle: And it was the longest audition of my life.

[49:56] Matt Doyle: I thought we were in rehearsal.

[49:58] Matt Doyle: I mean, I was there for, uh, close to an hour of just working on every verse with her, every phrase, and seeing, uh, she just wanted to see if I could take the direction that she wanted to lead it in.

[50:09] Matt Doyle: And, um, wow, and then when I left, I got this email from her that was like, that was so fun, love you.

[50:16] Matt Doyle: And I was like, well, what does that mean?

[50:19] Matt Doyle: You know, is that like, that was so fun?

[50:21] Matt Doyle: Thanks for doing that, you know, like, or was that like, that's so fun?

[50:24] Matt Doyle: See you soon, and I'm freaking out, and my agent's not telling me anything for like five days, and I'm annoying the hell out of him.

[50:31] Matt Doyle: And it was just because when I left, they knew, but they had to get Sondheim to approve, and he like didn't watch the tape for five days, and then finally was like, sure.

[50:41] Joe Carroll: Oh my god.

[50:43] Matt Doyle: Yeah, so I learned "Getting Married Today" in 24 hours, and, uh, well, and because that—the song is insane.

[50:50] Dan Tracy: The scene is also like, I can't believe you had to do that whole thing.

[50:55] Joe Carroll: Much.

[50:56] Dan Tracy: So let's get into some of our favorite parts of this thing because, like, what—there's a million lyrics, there's a million, um, you know, like the things in the book that we just adore.

[51:05] Joe Carroll: Um, and so what if we, uh, let's do—let's do book first.

[51:10] Dan Tracy: You want to do some, like, some scene stuff?

[51:11] Joe Carroll: Because I personally, when I was watching this last night, I was like, honestly, as a 30-year-old, I don't have that many friends.

[51:20] Dan Tracy: Like watching literally watching the "Company" revival and being like, I don't have 12 friends.

[51:25] Joe Carroll: Like I definitely thought the same thing, like being in it.

[51:28] Dan Tracy: I'm like, God, no one would throw a party like this for me.

[51:31] Joe Carroll: Yeah, yeah, I know, I know.

[51:33] Dan Tracy: It's amazing.

[51:34] Joe Carroll: And though one of my—and then one of my favorite, I mean, and you get to say this line, and I didn't choose it because it's—it is one of my favorites, and it's one of the things that Dan and I write about all the time is when, uh, at least Amy says, I hope it's still in the revival.

[51:47] Joe Carroll: Uh, did I say I like my friends?

[51:49] Matt Doyle: I do not.

[51:52] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[51:52] Matt Doyle: It was one of the lines that would never land in the room just because people had heard it so many times before.

[51:52] Dan Tracy: You guys rehearsing this was torture.

[52:00] Matt Doyle: Just because like talk about rehearsing comedy that everyone has heard and known before.

[52:04] Matt Doyle: I mean, it would be just like so.

[52:07] Matt Doyle: When the audience first laughed at my delivery of that, uh I was like, Oh, thank God, I have not failed. Like, oh thank God.

[52:14] Matt Doyle: I love that. Dan, what about you?

[52:18] Dan Tracy: I wrote too many down, so I'm gonna give three favorite book lines, but I also want to point to back in the book when Jenny and Dave and Bobby get stoned together. Yeah, that's another kind of historically significant moment on a Broadway stage because although we'd seen Hair at that time, I don't think that there was a representation of normal people getting high, and we watch that now and we're like, oh yeah, that's kind of charming. But then it would have been like really kind of crazy. There really wasn't the same representation of pop culture. So I just thought that that was interesting to point out. I knew I wouldn't feel anything though. I don't have that kind of constitution. Why am I talking so much?

[53:05] Matt Doyle: You're stoned.

[53:07] Dan Tracy: Am I? Am I?

[53:08] Matt Doyle: I am not.

[53:10] Dan Tracy: I am this scene, the Bobby and Kathy scene when he's like, um, oh, she's talking about Oh, you just Maddie just pulled out a script.

[53:22] Matt Doyle: Yes.

[53:22] Dan Tracy: I'm like, yes.

[53:24] Dan Tracy: You're like, well.

[53:25] Dan Tracy: So I'm gonna drop the scene in here for the listeners, but it's the section for you guys. Why the hell didn't you ask me? You want to get married? I always knew I was meant to be a wife. And how come we never got married? Why'd you never ask me? Do you want to marry me? I did. What? I honestly did. When did you in the beginning? But then I I don't know. I never I never thought that you would. I would. I never understood why you never asked me. So you wanted to marry me and I wanted to marry you. And how the hell did we ever end up such good friends? Oh, Robert. I never let you know what a good good man I think you are, and how much you meant? I'm serious. I brought you here because I wanted to tell you alone. Moving back up to Cape Cod. I'm getting married.

[54:29] Matt Doyle: Married. Everybody has a past love thing, like where, you know, and then you get to that, that either you or the other person gets into the sad phase and they're like, actually, I could have always been with you. What do you think? You know, watching that moment happen crushes me every time. I love the Amy's joke about uh is it do you still say this about I'm so glad we're not having a Catholic wedding? Oh yeah. Is it I'm so glad we're not having a Catholic wedding because next year when I get a divorce, I won't be a sinner. Genius. Genius.

[55:02] Dan Tracy: Oh great. Oh great.

[55:05] Dan Tracy: And then at the end, Joanne's line. Do you know we are suddenly at an age where we find ourselves too young for the old people and too old for the young ones. We are nowhere. I love it so much.

[55:25] Matt Doyle: Yeah. Yeah. And it just seems to resonate with something that I see people in my parents' generation really like struggle with, where they're like in limbo. And it's really interesting to see that play out. This past week I was teaching like a whole bunch of high school students, and I didn't understand half the the shit that was going on. Like the stuff that was going back and forth. I'm like, oh, I am nowhere. Right. I'm kind of too old to be, you know what I mean? But like, yeah, I don't know. It's so it's such a trip. I guess that could always apply to any kind of part of your life.

[56:01] Matt Doyle: That's genius. Matt, do you have any?

[56:02] Matt Doyle: Oh gosh. You know, I think my favorite scene in the show is um my scene. Uh no. I actually think like a perfect scene in the show, literally from start to finish, and it is so short and sweet is the scene between Bobby and Kathy, which is now Bobby and Theo. And just so you know, all of the boyfriend names in the new production are past lovers or love interests of Stephen Sondheim's himself. So that's why people are like, where did those names come from? Why is that character named this? It's because it was somebody that Stephen Sondheim loved everyone, so get over yourselves. Jeez.

[56:40] Dan Tracy: I love that's amazing.

[56:43] Matt Doyle: So there was a Theo, and uh the Theo is uh the replacement for Kathy, and I just it's perfect. It's so so so gorgeously written from start to finish, and just the way he introduces to her that he's not available or she's not available anymore. Um sorry, I'm talking I'm talking 2020 production, guys. Um and it's just it's so heartbreaking and such an amazing moment in in a show that allows um little for a through line. It's an amazing moment to see growth in Bobby and see a change in Bobby, realizing that it's not gonna be that simple, you know. And I uh so I've always loved that.

[57:31] Matt Doyle: And yes, I actually like I I'm sorry, I just think the the best line in the show is one that I cannot believe that I get to deliver every night, which is uh Bobby, Bobby, Bobby, baby, Bobby, bobby, Bobby. Marry me, and everybody'll leave us alone. Thank you, Bobby. It's just that you have to want to marry somebody, not just somebody. That's one of my favorite.

[58:05] Dan Tracy: Yes. Yes.

[58:07] Matt Doyle: And what's so amazing about this production and what Marianne has done, and what was so controversial and confusing for people, and she couldn't even wrap her head around this at first. Um, but it is something very, very contemporary is a relationship between a woman and a gay man. And everybody's like, why would this woman propose to a gay man? And what we've done is we've made it this suggestion of a marriage of convenience, you know, like why don't we just do that? We'll be married, and we get all the benefits, all the perks, which leads perfectly into marrying me a little, which is essentially what Bobby is asking for. All the benefits of companionship and marriage without being tied down in a way that limits you and and a way that feels suffocating.

And that's exactly what Bobby's asking for. And and to have, I said to Marianne, I was like, that's a very real thing. I lived with a girl for 11 years, and it's the closest thing to marriage that I've ever known in my entire life, you know, and that's just I it's not we the way we define marriage nowadays has completely changed. And when she proposes to me, it's this act of desperation that's so heartbreaking, right? And so tragic that you're looking at this character of like, you are proposing to your gay best friend right now, because which is what we've turned it into that Jamie is her gay bestie. That you would you're that desperate that that's what you're doing right now, and even Jamie is kind of like, oh, honey, oh, it's so heartbreaking. And Katrina Lang every night just shattering in front of me as I say it to her. Oh Lord, I miss it. Oh my god. I love that.

[59:49] Dan Tracy: I love it. And that's actually a perfect sort of segue to marry me a little to this to the music. Favorite songs, songs we love. We started this thing we call it the goosebump test, which is like the time like when you listen to it and you're like, ooh, like it just gets you every time. And I think that for me it's the it's the most classic and sort of silly, but not even like at the end when he when he or she yells, stop. Yeah, what do you get? And then especially into the the chords from the Rawlista Barza revival, because it's just bare piano, yeah, and it's out of time, and you're like, oh my god, someone to hold me too close. Unreal.

[1:01:03] Matt Doyle: Someone to hurt you.

[1:01:05] Dan Tracy: Do you have a favorite, a goosebump test?

[1:01:20] Matt Doyle: Oh gosh. For me, I mean, obviously being alive, it's it's a perfect song. Um every single way. Um but I my goosebum test in this new production, which has never been a goosebumps test for me ever before it um is someone is waiting because of Katrina Link. And there's, you know, Katrina is not what you expect from a normal musical theater performer in terms of like, oh, she's gonna belt the hell out of this, and all the you know, the queens will be thrilled, you know. Like she is an actress first, and she things with songs that are just inhuman and bizarre and incredible and freakish. And uh that is absolutely what she did with this piece, and she makes you feel someone is waiting. You she makes you feel the desperation of Bobby straight off the bat in such a beautiful and vulnerable way in a song that I usually just go, uh-huh, okay, moving on.

Great, and you're you want someone that's great, you know. But it's actually so haunting and and and uh she just opens herself up in such a gorgeous way. So someone is waiting is has become one of my favorites now, and obviously all the lyrics have changed. So yeah, it's not it all the names have changed.

[1:02:36] Matt Doyle: So that was that was his probably the most that's changed throughout the show, is him having to rewrite that song. Funny and charming as Peter Larry, someone is waiting. Cute as Jamie, sassy as Harry and Nintendo as Paul Wood. I know him even if I met him if I missed him. Did I let him go?

[1:03:22] Dan Tracy: I love that. Dan, what about you?

[1:03:25] Dan Tracy: The end of Raul's being alive. Just like the thing about that is that I like that orchestration the most first. Orchestration is always the thing that triggers me, but it cost him so much, but he's not doing anything physically. He's literally, he's he kind of kind of opens his arms up and he looks up to the rafters and he just like kind of screams. And I didn't really appreciate it on the album enough. But then when you watch it in the recording, I'm just like, damn, that is there's something so significant to what is happening there that I can't really put words to, and I guess that's kind of the point. But my arms were just like you know, yeah.

[1:04:09] Matt Doyle: Yeah, absolutely. Do you want to jump into the lyrics real quick? Favorite lyrics, Dan?

[1:04:12] Dan Tracy: Yeah, favorite lyric. Uh let's see. I should just pick one. Um I think that my favorite, I mean, it's kind of, you know, also sitting here and watching it um with my wife. Um, that uh becoming a cliché together, growing old and gray together, withering away together. I was like, come on, man. That's just that's what I want. I mean, there's a million of those, and that's in that tune, but and the gays say uh becoming a cliché together now, which I adore.

[1:04:41] Matt Doyle: Yes. Yes.

[1:04:43] Dan Tracy: There's so many. Uh I'm gonna jump in, I guess. Hold on. Yes. Yes. I have. What do I have? What do I have? Yeah. Well, the big the big one for for me too that that this was from college that that um our professor broke down for like 40 minutes was when a person's personality is personable.

[1:05:03] Matt Doyle: When a person's personality is personable, she should not sit in her butt. It's harder than a matador coercinable to try to get you out of your rut. Coercing a bull bull and personable. Come on, Steve. Internal, it's crazy. Yeah. It's just crazy. This is stupid. It's stupid. Just in terms of just broad ideas that I love in his lyrics too. Like sorry, I'm a sucker for that, but did I know him? Have I waited too long? Maybe so, but maybe so is he. I mean, that's how many times have you thought that, you know, in your life? It's just who missed each other. Which one? You know, was it was it the other person? And have we somehow missed each other through the complications of life? Um yeah, and then uh there's nothing better than and especially if it is gonna maybe change to coronavirus, but change the the lyric.

Um look, I didn't want to have to tell you, but I may be coming down with hepatitis and I'm feeling kind of faint. Um is just uh I it doesn't get any better than that. It really doesn't. It really doesn't. It really doesn't. Um also just like another vodka stinger through the end for me. Just like another vodka stanger! Another reason not to move another vodka singer.

[1:06:35] Matt Doyle: My favorite favorites probably fall in sorry grateful too. Um just because of like the the use of contrast there is just pretty genius. You ever sorry you got married? You're always sorry. You're always wondering what might have been. Then she walks in. And same with marrying me a little in that respect too. Just the conflict of ideas and the indecision, you know, and that's what we feel throughout the entire piece, and that's what makes the piece so uncomfortable for so much of it, because you just want someone to decide and be happy and feel good about their decision. And everyone is indecisive in this piece. Everyone, every character is battling their own demons, Jamie, especially, and especially Bobby.

And to return to that over and over again, it like it almost um fuels your anxiety watching it, and that's what makes the release of being alive, which isn't necessarily this momentous decision at all. And sometimes it is delivered in a very triumphant way. I don't think it's triumphant. I think what's amazing about it is that it's finally Bobby giving him or herself permission to live their own life, you know, to uh define what being alive is for themselves, you know. Um and that's that's the decisiveness that we've been waiting for.

[1:08:15] Matt Doyle: I'll never collect right. Okay, then ready. Most replayed songs. I mean, we've talked about being alive ten thousand times. For me, and it's definitely being alive. Like I probably played that five thousand times on my Spotify. Like no less. Yeah. Yeah. Being alive without question, no matter who's singing it. I it's just so it's such a it's such a perfect piece of music. And then uh beyond that, um, I guess ladies who lunch. Yeah. Yeah, it's iconic. It's iconic. I also got emotional listening to um uh another hundred people last night because I miss New York City, like I miss another hundred people that got off of the train and they're looking at us, you know. Imagine doing that song on the other side of this. You guys, like, come on, talk about the right show to revive after a pandemic. Uh God, it's literally about the togetherness of New York City. I just I can't. I'm gonna be sobbing through the entire show.

[1:09:48] Matt Doyle: That'll work for you. So lucky that you don't have to try and be too funny or anything. You can use it. Oh my gosh. My that's another thing is like finding the comedy of this role because I so many of my icons growing up watching this piece were were female comedians that were so brilliant in this role, and you cannot deliver the role of Jamie in the way a woman would, and so many of those things are sad. Like Marion had to point out some really uncomfortable things that, like, one of the reasons that the audience is laughing so hard at Amy is because there are two men looking at a woman thinking she's insane, you know? And as she spirals out of control in this scene, and it's like, oh, she's nervous on her wedding day.

She'll get there. And you just, it's too aggressive when a man is doing it if he's delivering it in the same sense and just all hysterics, you know. You have to layer in things that uh felt so foreign to me after growing up and watching these genius, genius women play this role. And I was like, I'm doing it wrong. And you know, it's just is such a it's such a uh a remarkable uh oh my gosh, tribute, I guess, to what Marianne does because she's so smart in in terms of getting to know her actors and what they bring to the table and how they can create a role that even if it is something that was created in the 70s for a different sex, she can reinvent it with that person and that that that body that she's been given and and and their their uh you know their tools. So I'm I'm very grateful. And my my mind had to be open every single day on the role in terms of having to recreate it and and play it differently.

[1:11:43] Matt Doyle: We will. I I know, I believe. I believe. Um my God, you're you're amazing. Dan, what else? We got we got anything else? As we wrap up, let's just hit on what we think aged the best and what aged the worst. Yeah, there's a lot of stuff that I feel like I've learned from Matt that I didn't think I realized how well it would age until you've highlighted how this production has helped it age better. So a lot of that is really cool. I think we've covered a lot of that, but I think that's what's so crazy about this production is that there were so many things that uh so many people and directors had started to feel were unsolvable in terms of uh the age of the material, and just by changing genders, you uh you make it contemporary.

And that's what's been like stunning about it is so little of the text has changed in our production. There's a few things that that got cut and a couple of references to 70s products and things that literally no one even knows about anymore. Um but in general, we change very, very little of it. And my scene only has one added line, which is the just because we can doesn't mean we should.

[1:12:54] Matt Doyle: Yeah, that's I that's that's fantastic. And that's the thing with that when we talk about these shows, the things that have aged the best and the worst, that back to what we've said many times in this hour that like Sondheim's gonna change it. I mean, there are a bunch of lyrics in his book that he's like, this was how it was in 1970. We changed it for 95, and we changed it for 2006, and we're gonna change it again. Yep, you know. Um, and so I just I I I love that. And also just back to the scene with um uh the Barcelona scene, watching that, the idea that like, you know, the the flight attendant is leaving, you know, and it's kind of the ditzy female flight attendant, and now it's like the sort of strapping beautiful male flight attendant.

Yep, you know, and she and you know, he's like, Are you, you know, are you angry? I didn't I'm interested to see how that's gonna play because he's super sensitive. He's uh uh like absolutely endearing and adorable, and you've got this big, yes, dumb male in the role instead of a dumb broad that you know got tricked into a night, you know, and it completely changes the dynamic, and it's no longer uncomfortable, which I guess is you know, maybe backward sexism is better, I don't know, but like I'm no longer uncomfortable watching it. I feel like she had so much power in this scenario, and he's a very capable young man, you know, and making his own decisions, you know, and uh yeah, and instead it just allows the comedy of this this person that she's toying with, you know, throughout that entire song, and uh and asking him to stay, and and all of her indecisive qualities are coming through there, and then all of a sudden he says, Great, okay, I'll stay. And just that comedy just landing much more instead of like, oh, so he's uncomfortable with the fact that a woman wants to stay with him, seriously, you know.

[1:14:40] Matt Doyle: This has been amazing. I I love you. Thank you so much for talking to us about all of this. Thank you for the time. Thank you for your your your beauty, and I can't wait to see it happen. Yeah, I can't wait to see it to see you. I love you so much. I can't wait for you guys to see it. It's um it's really fucking special. Man, you're perfect. Thank you for today. And we'll see you very soon. All right. All right, bye. I'm gonna go Twitch screen stream because that's what 2020 is. How depressive go check out his Twitch stream, yeah, go check out Lincoln bio. Yeah, exactly. Some bloody need me too much. Somebody know me too well, somebody pull me up short and put me through hell and give me support or be make me a love. Make me a love. Make me conk me with prayers. Let me be my days. Somebody brought me with a lot. Somebody force me to care. Somebody let me come through. I'll always be there as bright nazi to help us survive being.

[1:16:30] Dan Tracy: Thank you for listening to Guys Who Like Musicals. We are produced by Dan Tracy and Joe Carroll, your hosts. You can find us on Instagram at Guys Who Leg Musicals or on Twitter at Musical Guys. For more information about us or our show, please visit our new website at GuysWhoLikeMusicals.com. You can find our merch store, our Patreon page, and more. Thanks for listening.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred