Skip to main content
BPN Logo
S4 Ep 12 - Revivals Deep Dive

Join Tori and Gareth for the second Deep Dive of 2023 into the world of Broadway Revivals! Together they discuss the 2023 Tony revival season, the choice around doing revivals, celebrity castings, the Australian revival scene and so much more!.. Read More

From the show: Stage Door Podcast

40 mins
7/21/23

Featured Shows

About

Join Tori and Gareth for the second Deep Dive of 2023 into the world of Broadway Revivals! Together they discuss the 2023 Tony revival season, the choice around doing revivals, celebrity castings, the Australian revival scene and so much more!

To follow the podcast head to our Instagram @ps.stagedoorpod

Or leave us a rate and review below. Let us know what you’d love to hear in our next episode via instagram or our email at ps.stagedoor.podcast@gmail.com.

Created and Produced by Victoria Bullard & Eliza Vine

Edited by Michael Di Guglielmo

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:01] Tori Bullard: You're listening to Stage Door Podcast, the podcast celebrating theatre and creativity from on stage mishaps to career defining moments, hosted by Thespians, myself, Tori, and co-host Eliza.

[0:13] Tori Bullard: Fortnightly, we will bring you industry professional guests, deep dives and more.

[0:19] Tori Bullard: Hello everyone, and welcome back to Stage Door Podcast.

[0:23] Tori Bullard: Before we get started with today's deep dive, I would like to acknowledge that I am on Gadigal Land, the traditional custodians of the land on which we work, live, and record.

[0:33] Tori Bullard: And we recognize sovereignty was never ceded.

[0:35] Tori Bullard: Always was, always will be aboriginal land.

[0:38] Tori Bullard: And I would like to acknowledge that I'm coming to you fresh from Carona Country here in Adelaide, and it's lovely to be back on the record.

[0:44] Tori Bullard: So you're lucky enough today to be joining us for another one of our incredible deep dives, co-hosted by our very own Gareth Hall.

[0:50] Gareth Hall: Hello, Tori.

[0:51] Gareth Hall: Lovely to see you slash hear you.

[0:54] Tori Bullard: Oh, lovely to see and hear you too.

[0:57] Tori Bullard: Greetings from sunny Adelaide.

[1:00] Gareth Hall: Absolutely, where you're currently slaying the stage once again in Poppins.

[1:04] Tori Bullard: Well, once again, continuing in Poppins.

[1:07] Tori Bullard: I feel like we obviously need to acknowledge the lack of Eliza.

[1:11] Tori Bullard: Eliza is still, as I said in last episode, currently killing it in rehearsals for Crybaby at the uh Queensland Griffith University Conservatorium.

[1:20] Tori Bullard: Probably didn't say that correctly at all, but you know, you know where she is.

[1:23] Gareth Hall: She's up north doing the thing.

[1:25] Tori Bullard: Yeah, she's up north doing the thing.

[1:27] Tori Bullard: So she will not be joining us this week, but she will be back for the next episode.

[1:31] Tori Bullard: Obviously, we did take a cheeky little two week hiatus while we got back on our feet because we have been absolutely running around like chickens with our heads cut off.

[1:40] Tori Bullard: But anyway, enough of that.

[1:42] Tori Bullard: Let's jump into the episode.

[1:43] Tori Bullard: And it is an absolute doozy, guys.

[1:46] Tori Bullard: This time around, we are bringing something a little different, a little unusual, a little spicy, one might say.

[1:51] Tori Bullard: Usually, with a deep dive, we'd be tackling a single musical that the audience has voted on, or a show that's currently doing its rounds through the cultural zeitgeist.

[2:01] Tori Bullard: But we've decided today to tackle a much larger topic that, at least in my opinion, doesn't get discussed as much as it should.

[2:09] Tori Bullard: The history and implications of the Broadway musical revival.

[2:14] Tori Bullard: If the recent 2023 Tony Awards have shown us anything, with awards for and performances by the casts of Camelot, Parade, Sweeney Todd, Into the Woods, and Funny Girl, musical theatre revivals are a big hit with the audiences at the moment.

[2:28] Tori Bullard: Not to mention the great number of revivals seen in our local theatres with Mary Poppins, Mamma Mia, and Beauty and the Beast currently playing, and shows like Grease, Chicago and Wicked set to open their doors through 2023 and 2024.

[2:41] Tori Bullard: The history of revivals on Broadway is difficult to track given the opening of theatres there stretches back to the Revolutionary War, and shows were mounted and remounted as the producers saw fit.

[2:51] Tori Bullard: Every second theatre was putting on some variation of the same operas or Shakespearean plays, but records and sources have shown that play revivals far outstretch musical revivals, with Shakespeare's Hamlet being revived a whopping 65 times on the Broadway stage, compared to the Gershwin brothers musical, Porgy and Bess, only being revived seven times.

[3:14] Gareth Hall: Can we talk about that though?

[3:16] Gareth Hall: Porgy and Bess.

[3:17] Gareth Hall: Great show.

[3:18] Tori Bullard: Not a show that I would have imagined to have been revived so many times.

[3:21] Gareth Hall: Yeah, I didn't expect that either, and the research that I dug up showed the reasons that it kept being revived was because no one was ever happy with it.

[3:31] Gareth Hall: Like they were thrilled to keep putting it on and trying to find a way to make it meet their own expectations, which great from an artistic standpoint.

[3:41] Gareth Hall: You can keep bringing the same actors back and trying it again and again and again.

[3:44] Gareth Hall: But also, like, at some point, put it to bed.

[3:47] Tori Bullard: I will say, Porgy and Bess also holds the record for most wins for the Tony Award for Best Revival of a Musical.

[3:55] Gareth Hall: It's got two.

[3:56] Tori Bullard: Oh.

[3:58] Gareth Hall: Well, here's the thing.

[3:59] Gareth Hall: It won for Best Revival in 1977, but until 1994, Best Revival was a combined category of plays and musicals.

[4:08] Gareth Hall: So it holds a record with uh two wins for Anything Goes, Company, The King and I, and La Cage aux Folles.

[4:17] Tori Bullard: Yeah, so a bunch of prestigious shows.

[4:19] Gareth Hall: Interesting.

[4:19] Gareth Hall: Revivals always fascinate me.

[4:22] Gareth Hall: I'm always excited to see what they're going to do with a revival.

[4:26] Gareth Hall: If it's something that I have not had an opportunity to see live, I'll always be excited for a revival.

[4:30] Tori Bullard: But I want to know that they're gonna do something fresh with it.

[4:35] Tori Bullard: I feel like, in my opinion, there's no point bringing back a show that's the exact same show just over and over and over again.

[4:42] Gareth Hall: There's a few different demographics that go and see theatre.

[4:44] Gareth Hall: There's like theatre kids who were in it because they love theatre.

[4:47] Gareth Hall: Um, there's like the general population who, you know, it's it's it's a night out.

[4:52] Gareth Hall: There's a night out on the town, you know.

[4:54] Gareth Hall: But there are many different demographics.

[4:56] Gareth Hall: But when you think of like theatre kids, like there are only certain shows that I will see multiple times.

[5:00] Gareth Hall: Like, for example, Come From Away.

[5:02] Gareth Hall: If that comes back again, I will see it again, because it is a wonderful show and I get something new from it every time.

[5:08] Gareth Hall: However, there are other shows that you know come around that I'm still gonna be excited to see, but it's like if you've not done something different to it, how d what's what's to draw me in to see this show that I I'm just seeing again, just possibly with different actors.

[5:23] Tori Bullard: Yeah, I completely agree.

[5:25] Tori Bullard: Like, from my perspective, as someone who's, you know, in a revival at the moment, if a show is coming back around that has not found a new message or something new to say, something new to show to the audience, then it's in my opinion, kind of a missed opportunity.

[5:43] Tori Bullard: Like we do see a lot of cookie-cutter productions on the amateur and community theatre scene.

[5:47] Tori Bullard: I'm happy for those relics to just reproduce what they have seen and what they love and do the things that they would like to do.

[5:54] Tori Bullard: But when you're pouring that amount of money and that amount of time into producing an entirely new piece of theatre, like well or not producing a new piece of theatre, I should say.

[6:05] Tori Bullard: Like, what are you trying to do?

[6:08] Tori Bullard: There is something to be said for nostalgia and bringing it back, and the the cynic in me is like, it's a cash grab at that point.

[6:16] Gareth Hall: Because let's look at the revivals that have come by in previous years on Broadway.

[6:20] Gareth Hall: Let's look, for example, at Camelot, most recently.

[6:24] Gareth Hall: That has been a reimagining of a classic Lerner and Loewe show that I don't think apparently hasn't done well at all because they have tried to say something new, which is great.

[6:37] Gareth Hall: Like Sorkin's work on the West Wing was phenomenal.

[6:40] Gareth Hall: I love him as a writer.

[6:42] Gareth Hall: But you took the magic out of it, literally.

[6:45] Gareth Hall: Like, it's the Arthurian legend.

[6:47] Gareth Hall: There's supposed to be magic.

[6:48] Gareth Hall: What do you what are you doing?

[6:49] Tori Bullard: Yes, unfortunately it has not done well.

[6:50] Tori Bullard: It is, in fact, closing early, which is sad.

[6:54] Gareth Hall: R.I.P. Camelot.

[6:56] Tori Bullard: But uh see something like that for a Camelot, for example, for me, I've never had an opportunity to see that live.

[7:02] Tori Bullard: So I would absolutely be so keen to see that and have the opportunity to see it, even if it has been reimagined, to get to see and hear the music and the book live for myself with my own eyes is something great.

[7:18] Tori Bullard: That's that's where one of the reasons that I do love revivals, because you know, the opportunity to see shows that I've not had an opportunity to see because they haven't been around in such a long time.

[7:30] Gareth Hall: And I think there's something to be said for revivals that do take a risk and make changes.

[7:35] Gareth Hall: It's either gonna work or it's not gonna work.

[7:38] Gareth Hall: But you've you've taken the risk to make the change, which I think is one for me, one of the most important things with a revival is to keep, you know, the original essence, but to go, okay, how can we make this applicable to now?

[7:38] Gareth Hall: How can we make this connect to a modern audience?

[7:58] Tori Bullard: And on the flip side of that, you do have the shows that remain timeless.

[8:02] Tori Bullard: Like I'm I'm going counterpoint to everything I've just said about saying something new with a revival and finding a new way to connect to an audience.

[8:10] Tori Bullard: Look at something like Parade, like the most recent revival from the Encore stage into uh Broadway now.

[8:17] Tori Bullard: I hate the fact that that show's message is still so relevant.

[8:21] Tori Bullard: Not a lot needed to be changed in that.

[8:23] Tori Bullard: Slap a new coat of paint on the set and put Ben Platt in the lead role, and it's still so painfully obvious how much that show needs to be presented and the message needs to be said again and again.

[8:36] Tori Bullard: Like that's that's terrifying in an aspect where I want to see new artwork, but then the old stuff is still there and still good and still needs saying.

[8:46] Gareth Hall: That's terrifying to me.

[8:48] Gareth Hall: Absolutely, and you take into account as well shows like Cabaret that is currently happening um on the West End.

[8:56] Gareth Hall: It is uh not, you know, they have made changes, as I feel like is capable with a show like Cabaret, where you can bring it into the modern day without, but it still holds its meaning and it continues on throughout.

[9:08] Tori Bullard: And it is, it's horrifying.

[9:09] Tori Bullard: It's really awful when you're sitting in the theater going, oh, wow, this has such impact.

[9:17] Tori Bullard: This shouldn't still have this impact in 2023.

[9:20] Tori Bullard: We shouldn't still be able to relate to a musical about Nazis in 2023.

[9:25] Tori Bullard: We should not be going, well, that reminds me of X, Y, and Z that happened a few weeks ago or last year.

[9:32] Gareth Hall: It's but it's also so amazing to know that people are seeing it and realizing.

[9:39] Tori Bullard: I agree.

[9:40] Tori Bullard: Like there's something to be said about a show that is still bringing people in and still being able to resonate and be heard by crowds.

[9:48] Gareth Hall: But uh on cabaret, West End, this actually brings to light another point that I wanted to bring up with the uh whole concept of a revival is the star pull.

[10:01] Gareth Hall: Like a revival will come along.

[10:03] Tori Bullard: Yeah, yeah, I know where you're going with this.

[10:05] Gareth Hall: Um revival will come along and put a star in one of the roles in order to do bums on seats.

[10:13] Tori Bullard: I think okay, sometimes you gotta do what you gotta do.

[10:16] Tori Bullard: Hell it gave us Milsy and he's going gangbusters now.

[10:19] Gareth Hall: But at the moment, Cabaret, the reimagining, uh has Maud Apatow in the role of Sally Bowles, who, if you don't know, Maud Apatow is the daughter of uh famed actor director Judd Apatow.

[10:33] Gareth Hall: And apparently, not great.

[10:36] Gareth Hall: Not the best part of the production.

[10:39] Tori Bullard: So critics and audiences are questioning the need for her to be there in the first place.

[10:44] Gareth Hall: Conversely, you have a bunch of star casts happening right now on Broadway.

[10:49] Gareth Hall: Like every revival that is currently playing on Broadway has these lead players who are either Broadway heavyweights or TV heavyweights or film heavyweights who are just proving themselves time and time again.

[11:00] Tori Bullard: Our Lord and Savior Josh Groban, for instance.

[11:02] Gareth Hall: Our boy Gaten Matarazzo coming back to his Broadway roots from when he was Gavroche.

[11:07] Gareth Hall: Daniel Radcliffe as a surprise success in Merrily.

[11:11] Tori Bullard: Absolutely fantastic.

[11:13] Gareth Hall: Yeah well even prior to Merrily like his debut was a Broadway revival of How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying.

[11:22] Tori Bullard: And everyone was super skeptical about it.

[11:26] Gareth Hall: Then the Tony's performance happened and he blew the fucking roof off.

[11:29] Tori Bullard: Yeah I think I love I love it when a big star casting can surprise me.

[11:35] Gareth Hall: Even within the world of music theatre performers coming back you know after they've really got the name for themselves I'm always still a little bit like let's let's see let's see what you can do with this.

[11:46] Tori Bullard: And you know when they do well it's really lovely to know okay great like they're not just it wasn't just that one thing that they were able to do.

[11:56] Gareth Hall: And but you know it it doesn't always as you said work.

[12:00] Gareth Hall: Um and I have a controversial opinion with Beanie Feldstein as Fanny Brice in Funny Girl.

[12:08] Tori Bullard: Now I will say I do not believe that she has the most wonderful voice for the role.

[12:15] Tori Bullard: I do think you need to have a powerful voice for that role.

[12:22] Gareth Hall: Um.

[12:23] Tori Bullard: But I really enjoyed what she did with that role, and I enjoyed seeing some diversity on the stage, specifically in relation to myself, body diversity.

[12:37] Tori Bullard: To be able to go, look at that.

[12:40] Tori Bullard: The ingenue.

[12:41] Tori Bullard: The funny, quirky lead role.

[12:44] Tori Bullard: The lead role that every femme actor has always, even if they know it's not their voice type, has always been, I want to be Fanny Brice one day, you know?

[12:54] Tori Bullard: And to be able to actually see it and go, maybe I could.

[12:58] Tori Bullard: If Beanie can do it, maybe I could.

[13:01] Tori Bullard: She made choices that were so so wonderful.

[13:06] Tori Bullard: And I know that she didn't have the best voice for it, which I do think is very important.

[13:11] Gareth Hall: Yes, I completely agree.

[13:13] Gareth Hall: Beanie's voice was not as powerful as you would expect for a Fanny, but I think the recasting with Lea Michele.

[13:23] Tori Bullard: Okay, I get the joke.

[13:25] Gareth Hall: I get the glee gag. We don't need to actually do that, given that she's been proven to not be a great person to work with, as evidenced by one of her Glee co-stars, Jane Lynch, immediately leaving the production when Leah was cast. Like, I can read between the lines on this one. Yes, you can be very talented. Yes, you can be very good for a role, but you can also just be not a good person and a clear, like star plant to get the audience numbers up. When quite frankly, if I can be a completely left of center moron for a second, you had Julie Benko as Fanny cover the whole time. The people's Fanny. She was right there. You could have just bumped her up. The show, I don't think, was doing that badly that you couldn't just have her helm the role.

[14:17] Tori Bullard: No, not at all.

[14:19] Gareth Hall: I think that they made a look. Leah Michelle has a fantastic voice. And she kills it. Don't rain on my parade at the Tonies. Stunning. Every song I've heard her sing for the role, fantastic. But it feels like a gimmick. A what am I trying to think of? It feels like a gimmick. It doesn't feel like an act like a choice that was made with thought of going, this is the story that we're telling, and this is the person that's gonna tell that story best. It was, well, everybody thought it was gonna be Leah Michelle. So we'll just make it Leah Michelle. And I'm like, Julie Benko is right there and is amazing. The amount of clips and things that I've seen of Julie Benko, she is hilarious, and she is this role to a tee.

[15:11] Tori Bullard: I agree.

[15:12] Gareth Hall: Why not just like, yeah, I, and it again brings up the point, why was Funny Girl revived in the first place? Because by all accounts, it's kind of just the same show over again. Like they're trying to recapture lightning in a bottle, I think.

[15:29] Tori Bullard: Yeah, and look, don't get me wrong, it's a classic, and it's one of the ones where, you know, uh so when it comes to like somewhere like Broadway, and you've got such a variety of shows happening at any one time of like new shows, old shows, it's nice to, you know, have something that's kind of feels like, um classic Broadway theatre, you know, because I feel like there can be a lack of that sometimes with a lot of the newer shows or a lot of jukebox musicals happening. Um so I can kind of see it from that point of view. I don't necessarily see it as, for example, Parade where you go, this is there is a reason why this is being put on and it needs to be being put on. Funny Girl feels much more kind of, you know, uh a throwback and going, hey, this is the golden age of music theatre, and I'm not against that, and it's, you know, it's a fun show, it's a fun show with a good heart.

[16:27] Gareth Hall: Well, I do agree, like we have to pay homage to the golden age of Broadway. It's what made the Great White Way the way it is, like these classic shows, and some of them don't want to get lost to time, but again, like the worry that nothing new can be said, or certain shows just can't be done anymore because of like certain elements in the script that need to be rewritten. Like, for example, when I mentioned Camelot, they took all the magic out. Um, like one of the biggest um revivals of shows was South Pacific for a long time, and there's a lot of elements in that show that frankly aren't great anymore, and that was early 2000s. So, you know, it does raise the question classical shows, revivals, what can be said that is new, how do we adapt it for the modern day?

[17:26] Tori Bullard: So it, uh, all this discussion is making me really come to grips with the fact that any revival is an absolute risk.

[17:33] Gareth Hall: Oh, absolutely. Because there is, you know, there is the thing like we've been saying this whole time. Do you take a risk and try something new? Do you keep the original message? Do you try and find a meld? Because we want to see you do new interesting things with these shows. But there's always the risk of if you try something new and it doesn't quite land. You start getting nostalgic for what the show was like this memory of the show that happened the first time around.

[18:01] Tori Bullard: Yeah.

[18:02] Gareth Hall: And so it makes me interested to see with Australia. And we were talking about this before we started recording, Australia does a lot of revivals. They don't often call them revivals, but they do a lot of revivals. And so I'm always curious to see what has changed. Because I feel like I would say what, 80% of the shows that we get in Oz are revivals or new productions of, you know, golden age musicals, for example, Wicked is coming and I'm very curious to see what, if anything, is going to be different.

[18:42] Tori Bullard: I know when I saw Poppins that whilst I don't know if there was necessarily a lot different in terms of the technical aspects of the show or the writing of the show. But there was this whole new magic imbued in the show. I remember seeing it back when it was here last and I couldn't tell you when that was.

[18:57] Gareth Hall: I mean, I mean I can tell you when it was 2011.

[19:06] Tori Bullard: There you go.

[19:06] Gareth Hall: I was sitting right here you could have just could have just said when was it last here Gareth? Utilize the resources you have. I'm sorry. Um, but seeing it this time, I remember not particularly enjoying it last time, but this time it feels like there was just such magic. It was possibly one of the best shows I've seen in Australia in a while. There was this new magic imbued in it, and I feel like it was possibly to do with the way that actors um and performers are, you know, kind of slowly being treated as storytellers and individual storytellers, not just you are a chorus of people, you must do the same, you must act the same. Because there was such magic constantly in that show.

[19:56] Tori Bullard: Yeah, and for a long time that is how a lot of shows that have come to Australia have been treated. Like there have been productions of Chicago where it's like, cool, we did this last time, it worked, let's do it exactly the same again. You're gonna act like this last person who did the role. One thing that surprised me was Phantom of the Opera when we got in one year we had two different productions of that show. And one was a complete ground up reimagining because it was performed on Sydney Harbour, which was great, but the rain was monstrous for both us and the performers. And the second was the new touring production that had hit the UK for a while, that we got that finally over here. We got to see exactly what had changed, the motivations, which alterations in the score, the script, the book, etc. And that was good. I was happy that we got to see all of this new take on the material.

[20:48] Gareth Hall: If we had just got the Hal Prince production, as much as I, you know, worship the ground that he once walked on, rest in power, you beautiful golden god, I think I would have been disappointed because like we had that many, many times. New York had that many, many times. The West End has had that many, many times. It's a tough one. It's a very tough one to approach. I think unless it's a show that hasn't been done in a very long time, you need to make it interesting and different because you need to, I think, not tailor it to the audience that would have already seen it, but you know, take into consideration that a good chunk of your audience are gonna be theatre lovers. And if we just come and see the same thing we've seen again, we'll be like, yeah, it was great, but like the, you know, there wasn't necessarily a whole lot of point in me going other than we're trying to support the arts in Australia. I have just spent 70 to 100 to see something I could have seen ten years ago, and now the drinks are more expensive.

[21:55] Tori Bullard: Yes, oh everything, everything, and I understand why.

[21:58] Gareth Hall: Doesn't mean it's not allowed to frustrate me. I understand why. Theatre is much more expensive in the year 2020.

[22:05] Tori Bullard: The Year of Our Lord 2023 is also how much it costs a theatre ticket, $2,023.

[22:11] Gareth Hall: Um, so we are at that point, that midway point of our record Tori where I've been allowed to cook up a game.

[22:21] Tori Bullard: I don't know why you keep letting me do this.

[22:25] Gareth Hall: It's always, it is, but here's the thing. Last time, I did a one person trivia contest with Eliza, and this time I'm gonna have to do a one person trivia contest with you.

[22:37] Tori Bullard: Like, you know.

[22:40] Gareth Hall: The opposite ends have to meet, and that is what I've done. I have cooked up a Broadway revival multiple choice trivia game.

[22:49] Tori Bullard: Everything you get wrong is a point to me.

[22:51] Gareth Hall: Oh, okay. Like we have to spice it up somehow. I need to feel special.

[22:56] Tori Bullard: Okay, okay, you are.

[22:57] Gareth Hall: Alright, thank you. Okay. Question number one.

[23:02] Gareth Hall: Remember these are multiple choice. Which musical was the first to be revived on Broadway? Was it Carousel, Showboat, or Oklahoma?

[23:13] Tori Bullard: Oh, I've been asked this question before, but it was a long time ago. Carousel, Oklahoma, or Showboat. I wanna, oh, this is hard.

[23:23] Gareth Hall: Yeah, it's a toughie, right?

[23:24] Tori Bullard: I wanna say Carousel.

[23:27] Gareth Hall: You would be incorrect. It was indeed Showboat. Showboat first premiered in 1927 and was revived a stark five years later in 1932.

[23:38] Tori Bullard: Oh.

[23:39] Gareth Hall: They really let that work.

[23:40] Tori Bullard: Yeah, it's a real tight turnaround on that one.

[23:42] Gareth Hall: But unfortunately, that's just the nature.

[23:45] Tori Bullard: Okay.

[23:46] Gareth Hall: We are now moving ahead through time. Who of these actors did not star in the 1992 Broadway revival of Guys and Dolls? Was it J.K. Simmons, Nathan Lane, or Patrick Page?

[24:01] Tori Bullard: Oh, I feel like Patrick Page would have. That feels like the right vibe.

[24:08] Gareth Hall: I mean, up to you. We're trying to figure out who wouldn't, though.

[24:10] Tori Bullard: Yeah, I'm gonna say J.K. Simmons.

[24:13] Gareth Hall: Incorrect. J.K. Simmons, aka J Jonah Jameson from the Spider-Man franchise, Cave Johnson from Portal 2, and Tenzin from Cora, the Legend of Aang, or whatever, whatever the sequel series was called, did appear in the 1992 Guys and Dolls Revival. Patrick Page did not. And Nathan Lane played Nathan Detroit. That's where he got his stage name. There is your fun fact for this one.

[24:35] Gareth Hall: Which of these revivals won the most Tony Awards? Was it Chicago, South Pacific, or Parade?

[24:39] Tori Bullard: Parade.

[24:45] Gareth Hall: You're just coming right out of the gate with an answer?

[24:47] Tori Bullard: Oh, I think so.

[24:48] Gareth Hall: Well, you're wrong again.

[24:50] Tori Bullard: God dang it!

[24:52] Gareth Hall: Yeah, you are really whiffing on this one. Like, I'm throwing you the balls and you're just looking at the sky.

[24:58] Tori Bullard: My brain.

[24:59] Gareth Hall: My brain just went to they won.

[25:03] Tori Bullard: They only won the most recent production.

[25:06] Gareth Hall: Only won two Tony Awards. Chicago won six. But then South Pacific pipped it by winning seven for their early 2000s revival.

[25:18] Tori Bullard: Oh, you know what? I confused myself because in the speech for Parade, when they won Best Revival, they said because they won when they originally did it, and but my brain was like, oh, they said that they had already won.

[25:33] Gareth Hall: Um, you really confused yourself.

[25:36] Tori Bullard: Alright, and our final question, which is talking about my boys Gilbert and Sullivan, my good good sons of the operetta world. And because all their stuff is public domain, people can do whatever the hell they want with it. So they've been revived a lot on Broadway. So my question to you, Tori.

[25:53] Gareth Hall: Which Gilbert and Sullivan operetta has been revived the most? Is it HMS Pinafore, the Pirates of Penzance, or the Mikado?

[26:04] Tori Bullard: Like that's the big three. Ooh. Ooh. Hmm. I wanna say it's hard because I want to say HMS Pinafore because I know that the Hayes did it.

[26:14] Gareth Hall: Um, but that m that doesn't necessarily mean anything.

[26:18] Tori Bullard: Um, we can't just base our entire worldview on what the Hayes did.

[26:23] Gareth Hall: But we can!

[26:24] Tori Bullard: And we will.

[26:26] Gareth Hall: Um, Mikado.

[26:28] Tori Bullard: No.

[26:29] Gareth Hall: Oh, you got five seconds, Tori. Come on.

[26:32] Tori Bullard: Ah, is okay.

[26:39] Gareth Hall: Yes, the Mikado has been revived the most on Broadway with 32 revivals, followed by HMS Pinafore with 28, and my favourite, the Pirates of Penzance, only being revived 25 times.

[26:51] Gareth Hall: So it just goes to show if you write a very racist operetta by modern standards, people will keep doing it.

[26:57] Tori Bullard: Oh Lord, I was gonna say, I feel like I don't see Pirates of Penzance happening very often, and there's a reason.

[27:02] Gareth Hall: No, Pirates of Penzance isn't the racist one.

[27:04] Tori Bullard: The Mikado is.

[27:05] Gareth Hall: It's all about Japanese culture.

[27:07] Tori Bullard: And it's very, it's very, very bad.

[27:09] Gareth Hall: Well, moving swiftly along from my terrible, terrible loss.

[27:13] Tori Bullard: It's all right. Look, you got one out of four, which is not great, but it's good for me because it makes me feel good.

[27:20] Gareth Hall: Um I'm glad it makes you feel good, Gab. Thank you. That's that's what matters. And I tell you what else makes me feel good, talking about the state of Australian theatre. So I would love to hear a viewpoint of yours.

[27:32] Gareth Hall: Right now, I am in a revival of a musical. I am happy to point that out. Like a lot of my friends are currently employed in revivals of musicals in Australia. And our other two big shows at the moment are both jukeboxes. We're looking at Moulin Rouge, we're looking at Anne Juliet. So this raises like, for my observation, there is a sense of nostalgia about the familiar and the revival in general. And I think this is again, I'd love to hear your viewpoint on this. I'm just up on my soapbox spouting nonsense. I think the revivals in Australia at the moment are a sign that people want a bit of comfort after the last few years. You know, the spicy trio of years that has been this pandemic, a lot of theatre goers and indeed a lot of theatre performers lost a lot of hope.

During the pandemic, we saw a lot of our newer musicals, Hamilton, Jagged Little Pill, Frozen, Come From Away, all just suddenly closing their doors, and people were losing money, especially the producers, but everyone who was going to go and see these shows never got the chance until the doors reopened, and even then it was a roll of the dice saying, Cool, are they just gonna are they gonna close up again? So I think at the moment all these familiar shows coming back, Beauty and the Beast, admittedly, with its wonderful design upgrade, Mary Poppins with a few new technical aspects, Mamma Mia's coming back and just being so fucking fun. I think that is what Australia kind of wants at the moment, and I'd love to hear your take.

[29:04] Tori Bullard: A portion of Australia wants that. Not all of us want that. I have nothing against the revivals. I know that also I'm very aware that these companies are trying to recoup their losses from COVID. You know, there's always that double-edged sword of we as performers understand both sides of this, and both sides it hurt it hurts us either way. They're trying to recoup, and the idea of taking a risk on a new show right now when they're still trying to recoup is probably very scary. However, I think all of these shows have been done wonderfully, and the performers in them are fantastic. And being able to work in theatre in the year 2023, after almost two years of not being able to do anything because of COVID is so wonderful.

I want to see something new. If I keep saying the same things over and over and over again, I'm going to go insane. I want to see new stories. I and I've been saying this in general. I think shows like Anne Juliet and Moulin Rouge are wonderful. They're such a spectacle and they draw new people in, which is an entirely other topic of how jukebox musicals draw new audiences in for theatre and create new theatre lovers because it's it's an easy access route to go, oh I know this music, therefore I'll go to this and I it won't be as overwhelming. But I want to see new stories. Like you look at what like absolutely took out the Tonys this year. Kimberly Akimbo. A new story. A new musical that is not a biomusical, it is not a jukebox musical.

I guess it is a biomusical, but it's not a biomusical of Britney Spears or Michael Jackson or Tina Turner. Which is not to say that those shows aren't fantastic, because they're really good. I just I crave, I crave new original theatre. I had the opportunity to see The Lucky Country by Videa Macon only a few weeks ago, and that I was in tears. It was a 60-minute show, and I was in tears, and not only the caliber of the show and the content of the show, but just getting to see new theatre, a new story that I haven't had the opportunity to hear or see before. That's what I crave.

[31:17] Gareth Hall: I completely agree. It'll always annoy me that newer shows take so long to get to Australia because our main producers just like to, you know, have their few shows that they like to bring out of the mothballs every so often. Like, I've heard rumors that Annie's coming back. Why why are we getting Annie? Oh my god! We were so close to having Waitress in 2019. I am sorry. I will be forever mad that that never eventuated. The auditions were happening. They were in their final stages, and then we lost it entirely, and then COVID happened, so all the money dried up. I'm sorry. Give us Waitress, please, for the love of God. Look at look at what happened with Come From Away. How fantastic that was to get some new tasty theatre in Australia.

Something that we haven't seen a hundred times. People loved it, and there are more shows out there like that. I will admit, I think that they've done something with a 90-minute musical. People's attention spans are not what they used to be. People want short and snappy. There is so much opportunity. Like, again, like we've been saying, if you can do something new and fresh with your revival, or there is something happening at the time where you can link it back to what we're experiencing currently, then absolutely. But if it's just for the sake of money. And again, like I said before, double-edged sword, people getting to work, doing the job that they love, their passion, their career. Then I want that.

But I also want new theatre. And just the fact that we don't get to I'm like, if they can I know on Broadway and in the West End and in New York and in America, they have a lot more theatres. Like, we've we've got I can count on both my hands the amount of actual, like, musical capable theatres we have in our country at any given point. And that that's actually something interesting from what I've been hearing. A lot of producers are wanting to put on more and more shows, but they're finding it much harder and harder to find the space to do it now. Which is why I'm I'm really thankful Foundation Theatres in Sydney has bought out a couple new performance venues in the star. So it's making kind of like a miniature theatre district in Pyrmont, which I think is great.

[33:34] Tori Bullard: Okay. Which I love. I absolutely love that. Like I'm I'm tired of going to the star though. Like it it's it's annoying. But that that's on the Sydney transport infrastructure rather than my own personal taste.

[33:43] Gareth Hall: That's why you drive.

[33:46] Tori Bullard: I have a motorbike, leave me alone.

[33:48] Gareth Hall: Yeah, it's you know, it it's this constant thing of I understand the revivals and I understand bringing back shows because they know it's gonna sell, it's gonna keep actors working, you know. Take some take some risks. And I will put all of a massive fo I'll put a massive footnote on all of this. I am never gonna begrudge an actor, particularly in Australia, for taking work when it shows up. Like if they put a piece of paper in front of you that says you're gonna be impersonating Danny DeVito or something for a new musical based on his life, like go for it. Let's just do that. That's the thing, it's all that's that's why I'm saying it's such a double-edged sword, because I want people to be working, I want them to be able to do their job and have the life that they want.

And if that means it's through revivals, then so be it. But I just also want something fresh, something new, something I want representation, I want diversity, and it feels like sometimes with some of these revivals.

[34:49] Gareth Hall: Yeah, it's as if all the older shows are the proverbial round hole, and new actors are not just square pegs, they are complete icosahedron shaped people who could not fit into that hole if you tried. Like, you might be able to hammer a square peg in, but new Australian performers have such a diverse range of talents, body types, faces, shapes. It's beautiful, but it's gonna be harder and harder to find their place in the industry when you know we're trying to cast them in place of an actor from the 70s.

[35:24] Tori Bullard: And that's the thing. Bringing it back to what I was saying before that with Mary Poppins, it felt like seeing individual stories on stage, not just a stick straight ensemble that is all on the exact same wavelength. And I think that that is the thing, is casting for somebody's soul and who they are and who they are as a performer. Um and revivals, that's you know, if they're not doing something fresh and new with a revival, if they're not taking into account our modern world, it just feels stuck in seeing the same thing over and over again. Like I'm always curious, especially within Australia, to see what they're going to do. And especially in the past year with the revivals on Broadway. Yeah. Fantastic. There's so much quality out there. And they're reimagined versions. And I I'd love to see that here, and I'm not at the moment, and I'm I'm worried, but then you know, that's showbiz, baby.

[36:29] Gareth Hall: Yeah. K kind of a bittersweet thing to think about. Let let's brighten it up. We're coming to the end of the record. So let's let's leave it on a positive note. Tori, do you have a favourite revival of a show?

[36:45] Tori Bullard: Oh, a favorite revival of a show. My god. Tell me yours.

[36:51] Gareth Hall: Well, um, obviously the Australian like 90s production of the Pirates of Penzance, John English, Simon Gallagher, phenomenal reimagining, which then went over to the West End. Tim Curry wore the purple pants. Great, brilliant. I am also a real huge sucker for the new Sweeney Todd. Groben and Ashford, doing they thang. And controversially. I love the 2017 Sunday in the Park with George with Jake Gyllenhaal. I think I just have a thing for Ashford, apparently. Although she is getting roasted. I have many, many thoughts as a trained dialect coach, but we're putting it to the side.

[37:30] Tori Bullard: Thank you so much for listening. Oh, it's hard. I have been thoroughly enjoying all the content that has been coming out for Sweeney Todd, this most recent revival. It's or the tale of Sweeney Todd. Oh my god. I listened to that multiple times a day because it just it just rattles your soul. I don't know if I have a favourite revival. I'm trying to I'm trying to think what I've listened to. I just I just love a revival that takes a little bit of a risk and a little bit of a chance. I loved all of the revivals from this year's Tonys were phenomenal. I feel like it's the year where I wanted Parade to win and I did believe Parade would win, but I was like, you know what? This year, compared to previous years, it feels like there's legitimate competition within that category.

Because sometimes it feels like, you know, okay, well, these three have done the exact same thing as they did 20 years ago. This one has taken a chance and has brought it to now and has brought in new listeners as well. So I think it's hard. I don't think I have a favorite, but the Sweeney Todd. It's up there.

[38:50] Gareth Hall: But and then speaking of new musicals that I highly recommend people listening to. I highly recommend New York, New York. I know it's not gonna be everyone's cup of tea, but it feels like we have a and I know it's not entirely new, in that it's been in the works for a very long time. If you want that golden age feel now, absolutely listen to it. The overture for that show made me cry.

[39:16] Tori Bullard: Well, there we go. We're talking about new theater, we're talking about revivals, we've done it all. Weirdly, like New York, New York, technically a revival of Candor and Ebb's like lost work. Yeah, and that's the thing. And it is really nice to have a new show that has the old feel. That is my thoughts and feelings of any of Wicking Gabon for forever. I know. Like when you and I start talking this stuff, it never ends.

[39:39] Gareth Hall: No, it doesn't. And then it trails off into something completely different. Because that is the curse of the Neurodiverse.

[39:45] Tori Bullard: Thank you so much for having me on, Tori.

[39:47] Tori Bullard: Thank you for taking the time to come on and chat to us today, Gareth.

[39:50] Gareth Hall: And shook us for the rest of your season in Adelaide.

[39:54] Gareth Hall: We are here in Adelaide till late August. We are selling so quickly. Adelaide has been really kind to us. We'll be heading to Perth for the end of the year. Very, very exciting.

[40:03] Tori Bullard: Well, trigger's for the rest of your season. And you guys, that is it for our episode today. Uh, until next time, stay happy, healthy, and safe, and we will see you then. Bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred