On this week’s show, Jamie, Jennifer, and Rob are joined by actor and director John Benjamin Hickey... Read More
From the show: The Fabulous Invalid
Guests
Featured Shows
About
On this week’s show, Jamie, Jennifer, and Rob are joined by actor and director John Benjamin Hickey. Everyone checks in on how they’re dealing with the shut down and trying to stay sane, then John discusses his most recent projects: starring in last season’s “The Inheritance” and his Broadway directorial debut with Neil Simon’s “Plaza Suite”, and the group chats about John’s remarkable roles in “Love! Valour! Compassion!”, “Cabaret", and his Tony Award-winning portrayal of Felix Turner in the 2011 revival of “The Normal Heart”. Jamie can’t turn down the opportunity to gush about Laura Linney, then Rob gives us a look at the incredible career of playwright Neil Simon.
This week’s music: “Time After Time” from Glee, “Don’t Tell Mama”, “Tomorrow Belongs To Me,” and “Entr’Acte” from “Cabaret: New Broadway Cast Recording”, and “Young Men” from “The Inheritance”.
DONATE: The Actor’s Fund
Find us on Twitter & Instagram: @fabulousinvalid
Facebook: www.facebook.com/fabulousinvalid
Rob’s reviews: www.stageleft.nyc
Email us at: info@fabulousinvalid.com
Jamie Du Mont
Twitter: @jamiedumont
Instagram: @troutinnyc
Rob Russo
Twitter/Instagram: @StageLeft_NYC
Jennifer Simard
Twitter: @SimardJennifer
Instagram: @thejennifersimard
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] John Benjamin Hickey: I'm John Benjamin Hickey.
[0:01] John Benjamin Hickey: You're listening to The Fabulous Invalid.
[0:16] Jamie DuMont: Welcome to the Fabulous Invalid, Broadway's podcast where we present essential conversations with a curated roster of the best, most important, and innovative theater makers working today, from actors to writers, directors, designers, and everyone in between.
[0:30] Jamie DuMont: We took our name from the title of a 1938 play by Kaufman and Hart that has since become a loving nickname for Broadway itself.
[0:37] Jamie DuMont: Always deemed on the verge of decline, yet always bouncing back, the fabulous invalid.
[0:41] Jamie DuMont: I'm Theater Savant, Jamie DuMont.
[0:43] Rob Russo: I'm Rob Russo, writer and theater critic with StagedLeft.nyc and Stage Left the Podcast.
[0:49] Jennifer Simard: And I'm Sad Clown Jennifer Simard.
[0:52] Jamie DuMont: Oh, sad clown.
[0:55] Jennifer Simard: That is sort of my brand, you know?
[0:58] Rob Russo: Yeah, I mean, there's an argument to be made that it was your brand pre-all of this.
[1:03] Jennifer Simard: You think, yeah.
[1:05] Rob Russo: I think so.
[1:05] Jennifer Simard: And now it's just it's my time to shine.
[1:08] Rob Russo: It is your time to shine.
[1:10] Jennifer Simard: I love it.
[1:11] Jennifer Simard: Shining in a time of COVID.
[1:14] Jamie DuMont: Well, hi guys.
[1:15] Rob Russo: Hi.
[1:16] Jamie DuMont: What's going on?
[1:17] Jennifer Simard: Um, you know, I do know what's going on.
[1:19] Jennifer Simard: We have a very exciting guest today.
[1:21] Jamie DuMont: We have John Benjamin Hickey.
[1:23] Jennifer Simard: Um I'm so I I'm such a fan, and I've heard him speak before, and he's so engaging and charming.
[1:31] Jennifer Simard: I really can't wait to dig in with him.
[1:33] Jennifer Simard: Um, for those of you that the three people in the world that don't know, he's a Texas native, a Juilliard graduate.
[1:38] Jennifer Simard: He can be seen in over 30 films, from my personal favorite, the anniversary party, to The Bone Collector, Pitch Perfect, not to mention his appearance on TV's The Good Fight, Sex in the City, and his Emmy nominated role on The Big C.
[1:52] Jennifer Simard: But we all know and love him for his work in the theater, beginning with Terrence McNally's groundbreaking Love! Valour! Compassion!, and including Sam Mendes's Cabaret, Six Degrees of Separation, his Tony Award winning turn as Felix Turner in Larry Kramer's masterpiece, The Normal Heart.
[2:07] Jennifer Simard: And his part as Henry Wilcox in Matthew Lopez's The Inheritance this past season.
[2:12] Jennifer Simard: And John has also ventured out into directing.
[2:15] Jennifer Simard: And he was slated to direct and is still working on the Broadway-bound revival of Neil Simon's 1968 play, Plaza Suite, starring Sarah Jessica Parker and Matthew Broderick.
[2:26] Rob Russo: Which you and I were lucky enough to see in Boston.
[2:29] Jamie DuMont: Yes, I know.
[2:30] Rob Russo: It's so funny.
[2:31] Rob Russo: We saw it in February, and it feels like it was years ago.
[2:31] Jennifer Simard: Time after time.
[2:31] Jamie DuMont: Time after time.
[2:31] Rob Russo: Time after time.
[2:31] Jennifer Simard: Time after time.
[2:31] Jamie DuMont: It was years ago.
[2:51] Rob Russo: It was a decade ago.
[2:53] Jennifer Simard: Um, and we're all a lot older.
[2:56] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, seriously.
[2:57] Rob Russo: What are you doing to stay sane these days?
[3:00] Jennifer Simard: Well, I'll tell you one thing I'm not doing.
[3:02] Jennifer Simard: Um, the hubs and I are off the sauce.
[3:04] Jennifer Simard: I was really grateful we had some wine to get us through April as we saw those, you know, hospitalizations and deaths keep climbing.
[3:12] Jennifer Simard: And I don't regret a second of every glass of wine I had.
[3:15] Jennifer Simard: But it did reach the point where Brad and I were like, you know, this can actually be a depressant, and you know, it turns into sugar, which turns into fat stores, and which just kind of makes you feel gross.
[3:25] Jennifer Simard: And so we're like, we're just haven't been, and we don't need it anymore.
[3:27] Jennifer Simard: But I there was a time where I was like, I'm really glad that I have this sort of to calm myself down.
[3:32] Jennifer Simard: I'm not gonna lie, you know, but we're not doing that anymore.
[3:35] Jennifer Simard: So that's one thing we're not doing, which feels great.
[3:38] Jennifer Simard: And um, you know, I'm getting on that bike every day, which I think I've mentioned before.
[3:43] Jennifer Simard: My stationary bike is my other than my husband, it's my best friend, you know.
[3:48] Rob Russo: You love that bike.
[3:49] Rob Russo: When I asked you what kind of a bike it was, you said Schwin.
[3:53] Rob Russo: And I thought you were kidding, and I left it alone.
[3:55] Rob Russo: I was like, oh God, she's so funny.
[3:57] Rob Russo: Who would have a stationary Schwin bike?
[3:59] Jennifer Simard: And then I saw a photo of it on Instagram or somewhere.
[4:02] Jennifer Simard: Yeah, it is quite literally a gorgeous Schwin stationary bike.
[4:07] Jennifer Simard: Yeah, I'll be honest, I'm dying for a Peloton bike.
[4:10] Jennifer Simard: I actually want to make that gift to myself.
[4:13] Jennifer Simard: Um, but I also, as someone who's not working, and as someone who's raised from a father who was raised in the depression, I don't want to spend money that I just because I want it when I had a bike in storage.
[4:25] Rob Russo: Jennifer, I think you should treat yourself to a Peloton bike.
[4:28] Rob Russo: I think you I think you I think it's crazy not to, truly.
[4:32] Jennifer Simard: Yeah.
[4:33] Jennifer Simard: Will you will you pay for it?
[4:36] Rob Russo: Yeah, sure.
[4:37] Rob Russo: Yes, yes.
[4:38] Jennifer Simard: Well, John Benjamin Hickey buy me one with that.
[4:40] Rob Russo: That's right.
[4:41] Rob Russo: Let's see how let's see how today goes.
[4:42] Jamie DuMont: So, Rob, what are you doing?
[4:44] Rob Russo: Well, it's funny your downtime.
[4:46] Rob Russo: Yeah, this is sort of unintentionally become a commercial for Peloton.
[4:49] Rob Russo: Um, because in the past couple weeks, um, you know, I I as anyone who listens to this podcast knows I'm a big yoga person, but um, and I'm still doing my yoga at home, but you know, I used to do hot yoga, which really got me, you know, get me going.
[5:01] Rob Russo: Um so I've started to supplement my yoga classes with um Peloton, like workout classes.
[5:08] Rob Russo: Yeah, they have a great app, it's not just for doing stationary bike riding, they have all sorts of exercise classes you can take.
[5:15] Rob Russo: So and the first month is free.
[5:17] Rob Russo: So I'm enjoying my my free month of exercise classes, and that's been like the newest great thing I've done for myself during this uh during this time.
[5:26] Jamie DuMont: So you do the upper body stuff on Peloton.
[5:29] Rob Russo: They have great upper body weight training as one of them.
[5:31] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[5:32] Rob Russo: And I'm I look forward to um the I'm gonna invest in the monthly plan starting next month.
[5:37] Jamie DuMont: It's worth it.
[5:38] Rob Russo: Yeah, yeah, totally.
[5:39] Rob Russo: Today's episode of the Fabulous Invalid is brought to you by Peloton.
[5:44] Jamie DuMont: Thank you, Peloton.
[5:47] Jamie DuMont: Jennifer, what what's doing?
[5:50] Jamie DuMont: What's new in your neck of the woods?
[5:52] Jennifer Simard: Apps of fucking lutely nothing.
[5:55] Jamie DuMont: Um that can't be true.
[5:57] Rob Russo: Come on.
[5:58] Jennifer Simard: It well, I mean, there are new things, but I I'll say this.
[6:02] Jennifer Simard: I have absolutely little ability to consume new media, new books, new anything.
[6:11] Jennifer Simard: I find great comfort in revisiting.
[6:14] Jennifer Simard: I'm rereading, I'm currently rereading Ken Mendelbaum's book Not Since Carrie, which I read before.
[6:20] Jennifer Simard: I'm watching television shows, you know, from the beginning that I hadn't seen in a very long time.
[6:26] Jennifer Simard: I'm revisiting old films.
[6:28] Jennifer Simard: But if I start, I watched it for the first time in a while because I I know I I just can't consume new stuff for whatever reason.
[6:36] Jennifer Simard: I watched a film on Saturday that a new movie that was on the in-demand.
[6:39] Jennifer Simard: It took me four hours to watch this film.
[6:43] Jennifer Simard: I kept stopping it and getting distracted.
[6:45] Jennifer Simard: I just I don't have any capacity for new stuff right now.
[6:49] Jamie DuMont: I don't know what that means, but that's why you like moo, because I'm old stuff.
[6:54] Rob Russo: When we had um Helen Shaw on the show, you know, who is a critic who sees you know seven shows a week.
[7:01] Rob Russo: Um, we talked a little bit about sort of like story burnout, how like you're sometimes your brain can just it can't consume a new story.
[7:09] Jamie DuMont: You and and in and I I can imagine this is a moment where a lot of people are experiencing that.
[7:14] Jennifer Simard: I I've I I've had a similar uh experience.
[7:17] Jennifer Simard: I haven't really been watching a lot of new stuff.
[7:19] Jennifer Simard: Um I've been sort of going back to things, so I can relate.
[7:24] Jamie DuMont: Okay, well, let's get to our interview with John Benjamin Hickey.
[7:35] Jamie DuMont: So, John, thank you for joining us today.
[7:38] Jamie DuMont: We're so excited.
[7:39] Jamie DuMont: Um, I think to kick things off, just how are you doing?
[7:42] John Benjamin Hickey: How is week nine of the quarantine for you?
[7:45] John Benjamin Hickey: Yeah, uh week nine is um you know very much the same as week eight was.
[7:50] John Benjamin Hickey: Uh I came a little late to the party um because I had talked about this before, um, just to launch in.
[7:59] John Benjamin Hickey: Uh the day um I tested positive uh for COVID was the same day they closed Broadway down.
[8:08] John Benjamin Hickey: Oh it was also the night of the invited dress of my Broadway directorial debut.
[8:13] John Benjamin Hickey: So it wasn't one of my best days.
[8:15] John Benjamin Hickey: But we can get into that later.
[8:17] John Benjamin Hickey: But the the week nine for me is probably only like what, week six.
[8:24] John Benjamin Hickey: Um because I got really sick for uh a solid three weeks and was on my own in my apartment.
[8:31] John Benjamin Hickey: My partner was flying in the day I tested, and uh, our doctors very smartly said, Yeah, this you may have it, you may not have it, but just you should he should not see you.
[8:41] John Benjamin Hickey: So I didn't see him, thank goodness.
[8:43] John Benjamin Hickey: But I spent three weeks really sick uh and then got better um slowly.
[8:48] John Benjamin Hickey: So I feel like every just as I was getting well and getting out of town and feeling good again was right about the point that everybody else was losing their fucking minds.
[9:00] John Benjamin Hickey: All of my friends.
[9:02] John Benjamin Hickey: So I didn't really know what they were talking about, all the stir craziness and everything.
[9:06] John Benjamin Hickey: But then I caught up very, very quickly.
[9:09] John Benjamin Hickey: The better I felt, the crazier I started feeling.
[9:12] John Benjamin Hickey: So I guess that's a good sign.
[9:14] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, yeah.
[9:15] Jamie DuMont: Well, we're we're glad that you're that you're feeling so much better now.
[9:18] Jamie DuMont: And uh sorry that you had to go through that.
[9:20] John Benjamin Hickey: Um I've heard it's just you know awful.
[9:22] John Benjamin Hickey: It was it was really horrible.
[9:23] John Benjamin Hickey: Um, but you know, uh the one thing, and and I talked to several friends while I was at my sickest and who said I seemed slightly delirious.
[9:33] John Benjamin Hickey: And I guess when I think back, I I do not remember a whole lot.
[9:38] John Benjamin Hickey: Um, but I do remember being the only thing I really was clear about was I am not so sick that I need to get to a hospital or an ER.
[9:49] John Benjamin Hickey: And and that was just when those stories were starting to happen.
[9:52] John Benjamin Hickey: We didn't, it was right at the beginning of the real madness.
[9:56] John Benjamin Hickey: So I didn't have Danny Burstein's harrowing account of what he went through, and of course, you know, Nick and and I but I knew, even though I didn't have a reference point, I kind of knew somewhere I was okay because I didn't feel like I needed to get to the doctors immediately.
[10:16] John Benjamin Hickey: So that was um that was that that in retrospect, especially.
[10:21] John Benjamin Hickey: I'm like, oh man, I'm glad I had that clarity, you know.
[10:24] Jamie DuMont: So now that you are on the other side of um, you know, the illness and you're just like the rest of us, and you know, just sort of hold up and bored.
[10:31] Jamie DuMont: Um, um, how are you keeping busy or sane for lack of a better word?
[10:35] John Benjamin Hickey: Um I am watching uh a whole I'm catching up on a whole lot of television uh that friends of mine shows that friends of mine are in, you know, like one of my best friends is John Slattery, and I'm finally watching Mad Men.
[10:35] John Benjamin Hickey: I'm catching up on the last two seasons.
[10:53] John Benjamin Hickey: I'm uh I discovering shows that I probably, of course, I would have been in previews and opening a play, so I wouldn't have been able to see any of this stuff.
[11:03] John Benjamin Hickey: Uh watching a lot of great TV, I I I spent the entire sickness watching the show that I'm sure you guys have heard about called Babylon Berlin.
[11:11] John Benjamin Hickey: Uh-huh, I'm obsessed.
[11:12] John Benjamin Hickey: It's it's the craziest, greatest thing I've ever seen.
[11:15] John Benjamin Hickey: Oh my god.
[11:16] John Benjamin Hickey: Two people, we call them the uh dinky detective and the fearless Freudline.
[11:21] John Benjamin Hickey: Yeah, were my best friends during that.
[11:24] John Benjamin Hickey: And I I once I got well, I met up with my partner and I made him watch the whole thing, and I watched it over again.
[11:32] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[11:32] John Benjamin Hickey: So I'm I'm binging a lot of stuff like most people are doing.
[11:36] John Benjamin Hickey: I'm trying my best to catch up on some reading.
[11:39] John Benjamin Hickey: Uh I find myself a little restless, you know, when it comes to reading right now, and I'm usually a really good impatient uh reader.
[11:47] John Benjamin Hickey: Uh, and I'm also like realizing that I'm not nearly as bad a cook as I've always thought I was.
[11:54] John Benjamin Hickey: As long as I have Melissa Clark and all those one-pot wonder recipes from the New York Times cooking, I I feel very uh creative.
[12:02] John Benjamin Hickey: So listen, I mean, I guess the answer to your question is is I'm boring.
[12:05] John Benjamin Hickey: I'm not really doing anything terribly creative.
[12:08] John Benjamin Hickey: I'm very happy to say that where I live in Long Island is not far from uh the stars of Plaza Suite, Matthew and Sarah Jessica, and we're getting together and going through the play every now and then.
[12:22] John Benjamin Hickey: Uh at this point, just for the sake of of just keeping a little sane about it all.
[12:28] John Benjamin Hickey: I don't think any of us are doing it saying, oh, we have to remember our lines because we may be up and running really soon.
[12:34] John Benjamin Hickey: You know, it's just a chance to kind of like remember what a great time we were having before it all went so crazy, you know.
[12:45] Jennifer Simard: I feel like I was in the revival of Company.
[12:49] John Benjamin Hickey: Of course you were playing the role of Sarah and uh yes I know this because A, I'm a big very big fan, but B so is Patti LuPone. And Patti is my partner, Jeff Richmond's best friend of like 45 years. I mean they were in the same house when she got Evita. So there she's like a sister-in-law to me, Patti. And she so I went through her closing or you know premature uh with her and she spoke so highly of you and I was so looking forward to seeing you in that and I am sure I will be able to I'm I'm sure as well and I think as highly of her which is so lovely and and of you.
[13:33] Rob Russo: Well as we've alluded to before the shutdown you were about to start previews for uh Plaza Suite on Broadway and uh Jamie and I were actually lucky enough um to catch the show up in Boston at the Colonial back in February. And uh of course you know the world will get to see it next year uh at the Hudson Theater on Broadway. Um but uh you know, it's a Neil Simon play from 1968 uh three acts which is very rare these days um and you know, we were very struck by the really warm and and enthusiastic response that that that the show got from the audience.
[14:08] John Benjamin Hickey: Yeah. Uh, which to me, to us really proves that Neil Simon's brand of humor still resonates today. And, you know, perhaps when we emerge from this more than ever. Right. Um, so I I'm wondering, what has it been like to step into the world of Neil Simon with this play?
[14:24] John Benjamin Hickey: Yeah, it it um it just felt so right uh from the very um nascent uh uh beginnings, the the the the time we got together at uh Symphony Space and and did a reading of it. I just had to ask those guys, you know, Sarah, Jessica, and Matthew, would you like to do something? And they're like, yeah, we'd love to do a reading, just a reading of something. We haven't worked together in 25 years, why not? So we poked around and we landed on this play, and we were all so struck by just how wonderful the play was and how much truth there was in it. And yes, of course, there were things in it that wouldn't be written about now, you know, and there were you know, Elky Summer jokes that we were like, hmm, I wonder how that's gonna play right now.
Uh but what was essential about it was uh this very uh kind of deep and deeply funny portrait of relationships and marriage and a long-term marriage that might not be coming to an end, and the very beginning of a relationship, and then having to say goodbye to your children once they leave the nest.
[15:46] John Benjamin Hickey: And it, of course, resonated with the Brodericks uh in this huge way because of the you know, meta-ness of it. Um, so I guess the answer to your question is it it really didn't feel so much like oh, we're rediscovering or trying to re-introduce uh Neil, the great Neil Simon. It's like we just found this wonderful play. This play that that is that still seemed like it had so many timely truths in it. Um and then once we started rehearsing, they just started having the time of their lives.
[16:25] John Benjamin Hickey: And I mean, I hope you guys felt that as palpably as as as I did, and the audience is like one of the reasons it working so well is because they're they're clearly enjoying each other on stage.
[16:38] Jennifer Simard: Yes.
[16:39] John Benjamin Hickey: Um that's maybe not always the case. I mean, we were all scared, like, oh boy, is this kind of especially you know, me who was kind of running the thing, like, oh, am I gonna is this friendship gonna last? Is this marriage gonna last? But uh it turned out to be a real um incredible labor of love on so many levels, and that felt very manifest on stage and very uh palpable in the audience.
[17:07] John Benjamin Hickey: You know, I I didn't realize that um I knew that he was a you know huge Broadway star, um, huge star and a draw. Of course, I knew that she was too. I frankly I kind of underestimated the audience's desire and just joy at seeing them together.
[17:29] Jennifer Simard: That's fabulous. I can't wait to see it.
[17:31] John Benjamin Hickey: It's a lot of fun. I was telling the guys when I was 16, I was in one of those community theater productions where they divide it up so everyone has a part, and I was Muriel at 16, because that's appropriate. Um so I can't wait to see this. Um and I also am a New Englander, and as a New Englander, I know and I love the Colonial Theater. It's also where the original production of Plaza Suite tried out. So how was it working there? And did you see any of the ghosts go?
[17:56] John Benjamin Hickey: Uh yeah, we felt the ghosts very uh very palpably. Um, you know, there I always feel like when theaters get renovated, either the ghosts decide to stay or they decide to leave. I think they all decide to leave when you name your theater something corporate. And that's I I adore the American Airlines Theater, but you know, really, it's like couldn't it have just been named the I don't know, Carol Channing Theater or something?
[18:29] John Benjamin Hickey: Um but the Emerson Colonial, which has had this huge renovation, what was it like five, ten years ago, still feels so haunted and so rich in history. And um, and my God, it is I mean, I've been to a lot of theaters uh across the country and uh in Europe, and I I I I don't think I've ever seen and been in a more beautiful theater. And Sarah, Jessica and Matthew and our you know, crack team of designers, John Lee Beatty, Jane Greenwood, Brian McDevitt, Scott Lehrer, Mark Shaman, all felt the same way. They just felt like this is the most beautiful theater we've ever been in.
[19:11] John Benjamin Hickey: And and then it was this essentially two-person play, no disrespect to the other great actors who were in the play, but it's essentially those two people on stage together for the bulk of the play. And that's like what a 16, 1700 seat house, and it played like gangbusters there so it's a it's an incredibly intimate space that space and um I was so excited to get to bring it to the Hudson because the Hudson has that same kind of vibe.
[19:39] Rob Russo: Have you have you guys spent much time in that theater?
[19:44] Jennifer Simard: Yeah it's I agree it's so beautiful.
[19:47] John Benjamin Hickey: Yeah I think it's gonna sit beautifully in the Hudson and and I can't wait to to be able to see it on Broadway because I think going back to your earlier point about just the the two of them together and the audience reaction to to them playing opposite of each other I feel like we're gonna need that level of comfort and I don't want to uh almost nostalgic factor when when the theater returns I think there's going to be something really delicious in being able to watch these two masters of their craft working together and all those added layers on top of the fact that they're married and the play is about couples and I I really think it's gonna it's gonna play beautifully and you know what else too that I I love about them and I feel like there's this is part of the kind of rich tapestry of their association with the play is the play is about New York.
[20:45] John Benjamin Hickey: It's about this aspirational place the Plaza Hotel where these middle class couples go to have their dream New York experience God knows we're gonna be wanting that again as New Yorkers and as theater goers. But I also believe that Sarah Jessica and Matthew are truly great New Yorkers. They've been good for that our city.
[21:08] Jennifer Simard: Yeah.
[21:08] John Benjamin Hickey: And uh in every in every aspect of their career. And I think that kind of wonderfully resonates too. But man, I I agree with you so much. I believe that when we come back, um, it's gonna be like the roaring 20s. I think everything's gonna feel like an acid trip.
[21:28] John Benjamin Hickey: The colors are gonna be so it's like we're all gonna be on MDMA, you know, it's we're gonna be so vivid and vibrant, and we're gonna be so welcoming. I I hope we jennifer, I hope we're going up at the exact same time.
[21:43] Jennifer Simard: I do too. I was just talking to my husband about that last night. Of they were already going nuts during the opening number. I can't imagine what it will be like when we come out and when Katrina sings being alive. I couldn't even say the words last night without starting to cry.
[21:57] John Benjamin Hickey: Of course.
[21:58] Jennifer Simard: Of course. Good luck, everyone.
[22:00] John Benjamin Hickey: Another hundred people.
[22:02] Jennifer Simard: I mean, there's not a song in that show. It's interesting because uh Company and um and Plaza Suite are basically from the same company, what, 71?
[22:14] John Benjamin Hickey: 70, 70.
[22:15] Jennifer Simard: 70, yeah, uh Plaza Suite was 67, 68. So it's that same period of time where New York was becoming kind of like sexy in a new way, in a in a kind of chrome and you know, metallic and mirrored kind of way. It's it's a it's a great period of time to celebrate.
[22:36] John Benjamin Hickey: Um I love that production. I got to see it in London because I was doing The Inheritance at the same time, and it's just a really revelatory production, and I can't wait to see you guys do it.
[22:46] Jennifer Simard: I well, I'll see you around campus, and guess what? I'm gonna hug you. How about that?
[22:49] John Benjamin Hickey: Oh my god, that I cannot wait.
[22:52] John Benjamin Hickey: And there's a lot of hugging that goes on in our plays, too. Like, you know, that's one thing. We're we're not gonna be able to socially distance on the stage. They'll they'll figure that out. Smarter people than I will figure that out.
[23:05] John Benjamin Hickey: We just need a vaccine, and then we can all touch each other as much as we want.
[23:09] Jennifer Simard: Yes, absolutely, which is what we'd like to do anyway.
[23:12] John Benjamin Hickey: I mean, yeah, we're not meant to, we're not meant to be doing what we're doing right now. We're not meant to isolate. That's not a human nature.
[23:20] Jennifer Simard: Totally. There was a great, was it in The New Yorker? There was a great cartoon when they right after they closed Broadway down.
[23:27] John Benjamin Hickey: There's a man and a woman in an apartment, and he and he was reading the paper, and he said, They close Broadway theaters. Where am I supposed to go to cough?
[23:36] Jennifer Simard: That's brilliant.
[23:37] John Benjamin Hickey: Right. I mean, at the best at times, you know, theaters are a pure tradition. So I'll figure it out. That's for sure.
[23:43] Jennifer Simard: That's funny.
[23:45] John Benjamin Hickey: Well, you mentioned uh uh the Broadway of the 70s and the the glittering era that it was, and that made me think of um Broadway in the 90s, and it made me think of uh you starring as Clifford Bradshaw in the Sam Mendes Roundabout revival of Cabaret, which was a huge sensation at the time.
[24:03] John Benjamin Hickey: And it it felt like it that production shaped a whole decade of theater that came after it. Um so I'm wondering what was it like stepping into that iconic show and how it was received in such a revolutionary new take?
[24:17] John Benjamin Hickey: Yeah, it was uh well for me. Uh I mean, you guys have probably a you know a lot of experience in musicals. Jennifer, I know you do. Uh I had, I mean, how lucky am I? I don't really sing. I got to be in one Broadway musical. It was Cabaret, and it was the biggest hit. There was I remember there, that was that year of oh my god, Lion King, um, Ragtime, and and there was a thing in the Post like how many times has Rosie O'Donnell mentioned these Broadway shows? And Cabaret was like in the lead.
[24:52] John Benjamin Hickey: Um, because you know, for the the first six months of its run, it was in the Henry Miller's Theater, which is now the Stephen Sondheim Theater. Two good names for theaters, by the way. Um and uh, and you know, there were only like 500 seats in that theater, and and you couldn't, people were hanging off the rafters trying to get into it. Uh so it was um it was a seminal experience in my life in that it was just changed everything. I think it changed that entire cast.
[25:20] John Benjamin Hickey: It really opened a Pandora's box, and we all, as sexy and as much of a party as it felt like on stage, baby, it didn't have nothing on what we were doing after.
[25:33] John Benjamin Hickey: You wouldn't want to get me in a big ball and have a go and cut me off with a nickel.
[25:41] John Benjamin Hickey: So let's trust one another. Keep this about my mother.
[25:46] John Benjamin Hickey: So I'm still let's be honest and so you can tell my uncle here and now, because he's my agent anyhow. You can tell my grandma switched me fine just yesterday, she joined the live.
[25:46] John Benjamin Hickey: You can tell my father that ain't been because if he squeals on me, I'll squeal on him. If you see my mommy, mom was the word.
[26:24] John Benjamin Hickey: We just had the best time, and you know, I um my best that I met my best friend in that who was Natasha Richardson. It was such a golden experience in my life, and I learned so much from her and from Alan.
[26:39] John Benjamin Hickey: And then Jennifer Jason Leigh replaced Natasha, who is a completely different kind of creature, and that was a glorious experience, too.
[26:49] Jamie DuMont: I saw her do it.
[26:50] John Benjamin Hickey: Yeah, she was amazing. She was magnificent.
[26:53] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, because so so and completely different. You know, it was really interesting. Never really talked about this, but one of the things that made the Natasha first leg of the run so um extraordinary, aside from her just astonishing performance, was she had the last curtain call.
[27:14] John Benjamin Hickey: After she left, Alan had the last curtain call. And nobody ever questioned that because Alan was such a star-making performance. But between Alan and Natasha, there was a very, they loved each other, but there was a very healthy and electric sense of competition as to who the star of that show was.
[27:36] John Benjamin Hickey: And if you know that show, you know, Sally Bowles is really not that big of a part. It's it's it's kind of was always designed to be uh what's her name, Farlene Schneider's show, because it was written for Latalenia. And but it it so there it became this real competitive kind of like, all right, you just did that, and the audience just went that crazy. Watch this.
[27:57] John Benjamin Hickey: So it had this electricity that I've never experienced, you know, before or since, because fucking plays are boring, man. No, just a musical is like you guys all know. It's just different. There's so many more fucking people, and then when you're doing one for a long time, which I did, you go on stage one night and you look at the person who's playing, you know, Bobby, and you're like, who the fuck are you? I've never seen you before in my life, because it's like, you know, there's a an understudy and a cover and a swing and a swing.
[28:30] John Benjamin Hickey: So I learned all of those lessons about how what a what a glorious ant farm a Broadway musical production is. And you know, all of these uh things in the call ants in the colony.
[28:44] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[28:45] John Benjamin Hickey: I love that notion of it being an like an ant farm. That's a perfect image. Yeah, it's very we're right, we're digging out of dirt and you know, right on top of each other. And oh my god, that was fun. And what a what a show, what a score, you know.
[29:27] John Benjamin Hickey: Well, jumping forward into I guess this century, I've told this story before, and I'll I'll share it here real briefly. Um, but I saw the 2011 revival of the normal heart for the first time uh on Broadway, and I was so completely blown away uh by just the the sheer force of of that play that at the end, I I literally couldn't get out of my seat.
[29:51] John Benjamin Hickey: Um an usher had to like come shoe me and be like, okay, get out of the theater. You know, we're closing up. I have to get home. Um, and you, of course, you know, won a Tony Award for your portrayal of Felix Turner. Um, and I I've I've often thought about in the years since I've seen that play, you know, I had that incredible physical reaction to seeing it. Um, what it must have been like for you and all of your colleagues on stage performing it night after night.
[30:20] John Benjamin Hickey: Um I was wondering if you could share a little bit about the experience of uh performing on this play and and what it meant to you personally to get to do such a trailblazing play on Broadway.
[30:32] John Benjamin Hickey: It was something else. You know, I I I realized as you're asking me this, I hadn't really thought about the normal hardness. Like it's you're really count yourself very lucky when every show you mention, you're like, oh no, no, that was my favorite experience at the theater. We, you know, we should all feel that way, you know.
[30:49] John Benjamin Hickey: And and I don't know how you guys feel, but like I'm more uh I feel more affection and and more love and have even stronger memories of the things I've been in that didn't fly, you know, and I do the thing, the things that are glorious hit experiences like cabaret and the normal heart tend to you tend to remember them as a blur. But flops, oh man, you remember every single detail in a good way.
[31:14] John Benjamin Hickey: Uh that normal heart was um was really uh talk about a uh a trip. You know, we were only supp we only rehearsed for eight or nine days. It was supposed to have been like a concert, like a I guess a little bit like a vagina monologues thing, you know, like we were gonna have music stands and scripts, and it was really only going to be a an engagement like that.
[31:40] John Benjamin Hickey: And then, like, people could leave, and then three weeks later, another cast would come in and take it over. It was just basically a celebration of Larry and not meant to scale up to a full production, which it became, even though it was very spare.
[31:57] John Benjamin Hickey: Um, so we only had 10 days of rehearsal. We only had three days of tech before we were in front of an audience. And I remember walking home with Joe Mintello, we lived in the same neighborhood from 890 uh every day, and he'd be like, Well, you know, I mean, maybe you guys are learning your lines and putting your scripts down, but I'm gonna hold my script. I'm gonna have my script. I hope George Wolfe realizes that I'm not gonna learn these lines.
[32:19] John Benjamin Hickey: But you know, of course, Joe learned his lines because there was something about the uh what's the word, just the power of that play. What it did to an audience, what it does to an audience did the exact same thing to us. We realized it was so much bigger than our fears and anxieties about the fact that we only had a short rehearsal time, and we just had to be allow ourselves to be completely shot out of the canon.
[32:50] John Benjamin Hickey: And then, you know, I don't think any of us were aware of the fact that the time, for some reason, the time just seemed really right to do that play again. Where we were as New Yorkers, where we had come from, where we were as gay men, where we were as people who had lived through the crisis. Um, you know, it just was like, oh, we can look at this now, and we can we can unlock a a grief that has been has been locked up deep inside for a long time.
[33:28] John Benjamin Hickey: That was the experience for a lot of people. I mean, I I can't speak for everyone, but you could certainly, the thing you're describing, you could certainly feel that in the audience every night, as soon as the shit really started to hit the fan in the play, and it comes around the time that Lee Pace brilliantly his character has the oh, I can't even talk about it without crying speech where he talks about taking his lover home on the plane.
[33:50] Jamie DuMont: Yes.
[33:51] John Benjamin Hickey: And yeah, yeah, and so harrowing and horrible. And you could hear, like at least once or twice a week, you could hear people not be like certain people not be able to contain their grief, their crying, you know, like it was like you could tell that they didn't want to be sounding that way, but they were sounding that way.
[34:10] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[34:11] John Benjamin Hickey: Um, and it was just this shared, extraordinary experience, and weirdly enough, it was the most fun I've ever had doing anything. It's a really fun play, it's really funny, and we and it's so horrible what happens in that play that we all just drank so much.
[34:31] John Benjamin Hickey: By the end of the run, they would have the stage managers would have they would just make a drink like shots for us. We just walk off stage and have like a new shot of something every night. So, and and we had a you know, terrible gallows humor backstage, you know, when you're doing something like that, you have to have as much lightness to kind of balance out all the darkness you're experiencing.
[34:54] John Benjamin Hickey: So um it was it was an absolute uh joy to get to work on that play. And I'm sorry to gas on about it, but the the other thing that's extraordinary about that play is that it's of course it's about what it's about the beginning of the AIDS crisis in New York, but bigger than that is the Cassandra cry that it is it's about a person who feels disenfranchised and and you know there's not a young person in this country who who uh you know who has a bright mind who probably doesn't feel that way and a lot of people who feel that way right now so that play I think will speak to generations because you know the facts of the play are the AIDS crisis but the the humanity of it is somebody who says I'm not going to not be heard I'm going to stand up on the tallest rock I can find and I'm going to scream bloody murder until my government hears me until my fellow citizens hear me and that is universal that will go on for you know time immemorial.
[35:00] John Benjamin Hickey: I think back in March we lost Terrence McNally due to complications of COVID 19 your first Broadway show was his Lammark play Love Valor Compassion a role you recreated on film do you have any reflections on working with him or his life and legacy that you'd like to share with our listeners?
[35:00] John Benjamin Hickey: Yeah, it was uh you know, it was in his incredible um his incredible warmth and by warmth I mean he was uh he was always just wide open I mean he was he was a he was a sharp you know uh uh funny brilliant edgy. He wasn't like a, you know, like a like just a sweet thing. I mean, he was a complicated man, a very complicated man.
[36:56] John Benjamin Hickey: And he could be very intimidating. But he was open to the possibility of every experience, of every moment. So you never felt like he was resting on any kind of laurel or or accolade or and I'd never met anybody like that before or since.
[37:19] John Benjamin Hickey: And it was made most manifest to me, not when we were doing Love Valor, because I was so you know scared and such a kid, and I couldn't believe I'd stepped in such a wonderful shit, you know, in this play that never in a million years did I we think that would go to Broadway and it had that wonderful success.
[37:38] John Benjamin Hickey: But I did, you know, the love valor of this generation, you could say is is the inheritance, because I think Matthew's writing is so uh similar to Terrence's, and he he says that too. Terrence is his spiritual godfather in in many, many respects. And and Terrence, because Tom Curdy produced it, Terrence's husband, Terrence was around for every opening we had and saw it many times, and he was so excited by this play, and so in love with what Matthew was trying to say, with no cynicism and with and with no, what's that word?
[38:15] John Benjamin Hickey: He was never imperious about it. You know, he never seemed royal, and he is, he was royalty. And so what a that to me is like the the biggest thing gift from him is like, boy, I'd like to, I'd like to try my best to be like that as much as I can, you know, because he brought such open-hearted enthusiasm to whatever anybody was doing and that that's very much in that play isn't it that love valor has got the hugest heart of any play I've ever done. Oh absolutely. Well, you know, Jamie and I had the opportunity to sit down with Matthew Lopez, you know, right before the play closed in March, and he talked about Terrence and you know the profound, you know, impact he had on him as a mentor, and it clearly shows you know in the play and you know just the, as you said, the sort of the spirit of it all.
Terrence will continue to guide Matthew because, you know, Broadway wasn't as kind to the inheritance as the West End was and that's all very complicated but I think, you know, Terrence one of the gifts Terrence gives people like as brilliant as Matthew is like just keep working just keep working. I mean, you know, we all know Terrence's history when his first play got like I there Terrence had a great quote about it he got the kinds of reviews that just you would make a person you know never want to leave the house again and he was he's just such a great example if he just kept working it's it's all about keeping moving forward, you know.
[38:22] Rob Russo: Yeah, yeah, well we talked to Matthew a little bit about that and you know what it's like to bring a piece to Broadway and then you know have the reaction that that the play received. But you know, I will say Jamie and I both completely adored "The Inheritance," and I'm sure if Jennifer wasn't working and had the opportunity to see it, she would have too.
[40:18] Rob Russo: Um, I'm curious. You've talked before about your character, Henry Wilcox, um, who is a gay republican billionaire and you said that it was a really terrific challenge to humanize a gay Republican billionaire on stage. So I'm wondering if you could share a little bit more about that and what it's like, you know, stepping into the shoes of such a complicated character.
[40:41] John Benjamin Hickey: Yeah. Um I know just having watched Succession, it reminded me so much of Henry's world. Um yeah. You know, I the billionaire part, the gay part I understood, the billionaire part I didn't understand, the Republican part I really didn't like. Um I understood the billionaire. Yeah. Even more than I did the Republican part. I just thought that, you know, the key to Henry was the repression, you know, that he had in my partner who's 10 years older than I am, and really, really lived through the plague and lost so many of his friends. And when he would talk about that time, he would say, you know, it was interesting. There were people who couldn't show up, who didn't show up, who couldn't show up, and they were lovers who abandoned their lovers or just friends who just chose their, you know, he said, because that was the thing.
It's like not only were we dealing with this calamity, we were all in our 20s trying to figure out how to build our career in Los Angeles and in New York. He's a television writer. And so he's like, so we were trying to do both things. So you know, you would go home to take care of your friend, but you would try to get somebody to take the shift so you could go in and pitch your script before you went over to nurse somebody to their death. A crazy, you know, experience for a young person to go through. Um, and he said, you know, you would see these people who weren't able to do it, who weren't able to show up through the years. And you forgave them, of course, because why not? But you would never forget.
Like that was a, and that was Henry. You know, Henry couldn't do it. He couldn't, he couldn't deal with what was happening. He did not have the emotional strength. So what did he do? He went out and became the strongest master of the universe, you know, and turns out he deeply, deeply, deeply regrets the decision he made and the choices he made. And so that I loved about him. I loved getting to play somebody that heartbroken who seemingly has the world on a string, you know, but is really the weakest and saddest person in the room.
[43:16] John Benjamin Hickey: So it was always, you know, that the other stuff I couldn't really relate to. I had to I made them give me spanks, not because I'm I mean, God knows I had a belly, but I was like, you know, spanks like a girdle makes you stand up straighter, and billionaires stand up straight. So all the stuff that made him seem powerful physically, I achieved through man spanks. I that's a should be a great lesson to anybody. That might be the title of this episode, man's banks. I love them. I love them. They really are especially with the 10 pounds everyone's gaining at home, right now. Oh my god, yes, yes, exactly. 10? Oh, luckily. But uh, but yeah, he was he was a really rich, complicated character. And then, of course, you know, there's the book of Howard's End that I had loved my whole adult life.
And the movie, the Richard Ivory movie. I mean, Anthony Hopkins' performance. Oh God. Yeah. Talk about like whenever I was in doubt as to how what to do, I just go back and watch the movie. It's like, okay, I'm gonna try to do that. That film is a nearly perfect film.
[44:27] Rob Russo: Agree with you more.
[44:28] John Benjamin Hickey: No question. And I would say that the inheritance is a nearly perfect play. Um, Rob was not mistaken when he said that we both adored that play. And I was, you know, obviously very moved by it. I don't know how you could sit through it and not feel a lot of things. I particularly the moment where Henry shouts, There are no gay men left my age, really resonated with me. And his and also his you touched on this earlier, his like gnawing survivors guilt that just ate at it ate him from the inside out, which is maybe why he needed Spanx to stand up straight. I'm not really sure. Um, but I I don't really have a question here, other than I just feel like it's such an important, there were so many important things that Matthew talks about in that play, but that in particular is I think something that gets glossed over when we look back at the history of the AIDS crisis, and I think people forget that there's a whole generation of people who didn't get to make art and live in this world and have families and all of that stuff. It just was wiped out, and it's staggering when you think about it, and it's so beautifully presented throughout this entire two-part play.
[45:44] John Benjamin Hickey: Yeah, yeah. It really was, you know, never talk about like one one of a kind experiences. The first time we ran through that play at the young Vic in a rehearsal studio, and we just had to do it. We started at 10 a.m. and it was like 10 hours long then. And we were just we just looked at each other afterwards, and Vanessa Redgrave had brought champagne for everybody, thank God. We just sat there staring at each other, like what the hell did we just do? And I love that thing you say about that generation of people who were decimated and who didn't have the chance to do so many things. And you know, one of the things that happens to Henry in that play is he looks at the younger generation and he realizes, oh, when I was their age, I didn't have anybody like me because they were all dying.
Like, you know, there's a whole young, old thing going on in that play that my generation didn't have because we that the people 10, 15 years older than I was were the people who were really being destroyed by it. And so we were afraid of them for lack of a more delicate and you know better way of putting it. There was a fear attached to that generation for the rest of us. And I think there's such great um he meditates on that so beautifully in that play, the generational thing, and how a generation was lost.
[47:06] John Benjamin Hickey: I'm actually speechless right now. It's so hard to form words. When you think about it, it's tragic.
[47:41] Rob Russo: Yeah, it really, it really is.
[47:42] John Benjamin Hickey: It really is like you really realize like, I mean, Jeff, again, my partner, when he would see the inheritance, he would he would say, like, it's you know, it's a really crazy thing for me to be able to sit here and watch this play, and I'm overwhelmed with the fact that 35, 40 years later, I'm like, why am I the one sitting in the theater as a survivor getting to have this experience when so many, like so many of my friends have been gone for so long now, and I get to do this. It's really is something. And it was a great time for that play. I think that it was again one of those perfect periods of time to have a play like that. I was happy to be part of it.
[48:31] Rob Russo: I agree, and I think you know, it also you make me think about what when we were talking about the normal heart and and the audience reaction to that. And I I think with that, having 25 years of time between the the first time the normal heart was done and when it was done in 2011, I think that really helped that that air of time helped audiences receive that play in a totally different way and receive it in a way of looking back historically on what had happened and where we've come, and being able to enjoy the play and be devastated by the play in a totally different way.
[49:11] John Benjamin Hickey: Yeah, completely.
[49:12] Rob Russo: And completely and to realize, oh my God, that anger is still there.
[49:17] John Benjamin Hickey: Yes.
[49:17] Rob Russo: It's still inside of me.
[49:19] John Benjamin Hickey: And it burns. That play burns. That play has great fire in it, as does Larry.
[49:26] Rob Russo: I agree.
[49:27] John Benjamin Hickey: And that anger is necessary, absolutely necessary. You can't let that anger go. I heard um Cleve Jones speak when he was talking about activism. And he said that activism doesn't happen online. Any of you young people that think that you're being an activist by clicking a link, you're fooling yourselves. What you have to do is make noise. That's how change happens. And I think that's it's all kind of part and parcel of the same thing. There's there's a there's an anger, there's an energy that you need to do to move forward and to be heard.
[50:00] Rob Russo: Yeah, you're absolutely right. It'll be so interesting to see, you know, this huge global shift that this has caused. Um, you know, in many ways as big as the I don't I can't compare the epidemics because I'm not smart enough to, but like the fact that it was global overnight, like that overnight we were all the same. We were all exactly the same. Um I just it'll it will be so interesting to see how this what this does to our political future.
[50:40] John Benjamin Hickey: I don't know. It's scary and makes me hope for something different, you know. I keep saying that it's, uh, you know, because I'm in my early 30s. I feel like it's gonna radicalize my generation. If you didn't support universal healthcare before, forget about it. You know, like honey, how do you live through the last year and not emerge from it a socialist?
[51:04] Rob Russo: I'm so happy to hear you say that and your lips to yeah. Thank you, Rob. I'm gonna hold you to that. I'm in my early 20s and I feel the exact same way.
[51:15] John Benjamin Hickey: Fantastic. Well, John, you have been so generous with your time. I cannot believe that nearly 45 plus minutes have gone by and we haven't talked about Laura Linney.
[51:24] John Benjamin Hickey: So we're so we may have to do that another time. Um, I would be my favorite subject.
[51:31] Rob Russo: Yeah, she she's my favorite subject too. Funny. Introduced her once at an awards thing or something that I was at. It was the best introduction ever. They said Laura Linney, a noun we can all agree upon.
[51:49] John Benjamin Hickey: Talking about someone at the very peak of their powers right now. My God, her work in that play this season and her work on Ozark. It's just crazy. It's like, oh, you could get better. You were already so great. I honestly think that that Ozark is the finest work she's done. And we're talking about someone, as you well know, and anyone listening knows that literally everything she does is perfection, right?
[52:13] Rob Russo: She's pretty, she's pretty damn great.
[52:14] John Benjamin Hickey: Yeah. Yeah, I agree with that. And then and and we have one final question before we let you go, but I also can't I can't also sit here for 45 minutes and not mention that last night I had the great pleasure of rewatching one of my favorite films, a film that you are in called The Anniversary Party.
[52:30] John Benjamin Hickey: Oh my God. I love that film with all my heart. And I hadn't seen it in a number of years. How does it hold up?
[52:39] John Benjamin Hickey: It holds up beautifully. Well, first of all, I it's such a smart film. It's such a great script. It's so beautifully shot. Again, talk about a cast of actors at the top of their game. Talk about Jennifer Jason Lee. She's magnificent. Magnificent. And you know, we were all Dennis O'Hare and I were in Cabaret with her at that time.
[52:59] John Benjamin Hickey: Yep. Right. And we'd all done it for six months together. And she and Alan, of course, and they became great friends. And she were like, she was like, Alan and I are writing a movie, and we want you guys to be in it. And I think Dennis and I were both like, yeah, yeah, yeah, I'll believe that when I see it. And then suddenly you're on a set with Gwynneth and Kevin Klein and John C. Reilly and all those amazing people. Phoebe Cates and Marilyn Rice Cub. I mean, it just a crazy cast. And Parker Posey. I mean, it literally just it goes on and on and on.
[53:28] John Benjamin Hickey: Um, I will say, funnily enough, because I think the film came out in what, 2000, 2001. Yeah. Um, the only thing is it looks very 90s. I remember thinking, oh, it's so modern, but when you look back on it, it feels much more late 90s than it does early 2000.
[53:44] Rob Russo: Oh, that's interesting. That's really interesting.
[53:46] John Benjamin Hickey: I I'm I would love to see it again. I hesitate to see that movie because there's a sequence where I'm I'm raging in charades and I'm supposed to be like the angriest man on the planet. And John C. Reilly makes me laugh so hard that I actually think you can maybe see me turn my back to the camera because I'm about to lose my shit. I'm about to start laughing.
[54:06] Rob Russo: No, you you seem very angry.
[54:09] John Benjamin Hickey: Good, good. You scared me off of charades forever. No thanks to John C. Reilly, who's the most brilliant and funniest human being on the although that's a fun at-home game for us all right now to go and see if we can see you perhaps turn your back trying not to laugh.
[54:26] John Benjamin Hickey: I'm you know, that's we're all looking for things to do. So thanks for that hot tip.
[54:28] John Benjamin Hickey: Well before we let you go as I mentioned we do have one final question and that question is what was that show or experience that made you want to be an actor make you want to work in the theater um I loved well you know I mean like a like so many young people and I was from a small small ish town in Texas and you know and I was uh had a huge um class in high school and I was very popular and I was in a lot of different things and a therapist later on said to me I was like why was I involved in so many things and she said I think it's because your your MO was they can't hit a moving target and and I was like oh my God you're absolutely right I never stood still because I didn't want to get caught and whatever that was that we all feel whether it's being gay or being just being a 16 year old you know and feeling so scared about what you're maybe going to turn into whatever that might be.
[55:34] John Benjamin Hickey: And then I found and then I went to the theater department and I was like oh I don't have to I can stand perfectly still here I'm home this is exactly where I I am supposed to be uh and but but you know as as far as work goes um I I I think I have all roads lead back to the great Julie White for me um the great actress who is, you know, Tony Award winner and my oldest friend. And she was at the same college I was in in Texas. And I saw her give a performance. I didn't really know her. She was so amazing. And then she left this college in Texas to come up to Fordham University. And the way people talked about her as an actor, as an artist, as uh somebody with the courage to go to New York. I seriously, this is totally serious.
I started thinking to myself, I want people to think of me the way they think of her. And so the next year I went to Fordham University. I just came home at the Christmas break, and I was like, mom, I want to transfer to New York City. And Fordham University is a is a you know, they don't charge out of state tuition. So if I work all summer, I can afford to help pay my way. And so basically, I just stalked Julie White to New York. And she's the reason I became a New Yorker, and probably the reason I became an actor.
[57:06] Rob Russo: Wow. Well, that I mean, thank you, Julie White, for that. Um, wow, John Benjamin Hickey, moving target. Thank you so much for for joining us today.
[57:18] John Benjamin Hickey: Thank you for showering. We appreciate it.
[57:18] John Benjamin Hickey: I'm so happy I did. I was as soon as I saw your um your graphic, you know, your that is the most who did that design for you. That's the most beautiful thing.
[57:32] Rob Russo: Thank you. Um, yeah, I'm very proud of, I'm very proud of that um that image.
[57:37] John Benjamin Hickey: Yeah, it's great. We did it with um, I did it with a graphic designer and uh she's really an artist um uh from Los Angeles named Liza Nelson, and she's brilliant. And we just, she just, I had this idea, she picked my brain, and that's what came out of it. And it was just, I'm so pleased with it. It's her brain that's green. She's a genius. She's really a genius. Uh well done, you.
[58:00] Rob Russo: Thank you. Well, you have a lovely rest of the day, and thank you so much.
[58:03] John Benjamin Hickey: Thank you. Stay well and safe and healthy, and I'll see you on Broadway.
[58:14] Rob Russo: Rob here with you may be wondering. As we talked about, John is directing the first ever Broadway revival of playwright Neil Simon's 1968 hit comedy, Plaza Suite. Neil Simon passed away in 2018 at the age of 91. Over the course of his singular career as a writer, he wrote more than 30 plays and musicals, in addition to just as many screenplays, including a mix of adaptations of his stage plays and original stories.
[58:40] Rob Russo: After an early start as a TV comedy writer for Phil Silvers and Sid Caesar, alongside the likes of Mel Brooks, Woody Allen, Carl Reiner, and Joseph Stein, Neil Simon's work went on to define an era in the American theater, revolutionizing stage comedy with his focus on the fractious lives of contemporary urban characters and his talent for unspooling intimate family conflicts in poignant and humorous ways.
[59:03] Rob Russo: Simon penned plays that were popular, by which I mean not just successful, but popular in the sense of pertaining to and appealing to the people. As distinct from the wealthy upper class characters of, say, a Noël Coward drawing room comedy, Simon's characters were more likely to resemble people you know, the common man or woman. And as such, his plays found tremendous commercial success because of their accessibility and relatability.
[59:29] Rob Russo: According to Simon's New York Times obituary, from 1965 to 1980, his plays and musicals racked up more than 9,000 performances, a record not even remotely touched by any other playwright of his era. In 1966 alone, he had four Broadway shows running simultaneously. But behind that stunning success is a body of work brimming with craft, intelligence, wit, and heart.
[59:53] Rob Russo: Of course, you likely know The Odd Couple, Barefoot in the Park, and The Sunshine Boys, early plays that have received numerous revivals over the years, and his semi-autobiographical trilogy for the 1980s, Brighton Beach Memoirs, Biloxi Blues, and Broadway Bound. Simon also wrote the books to the hit musicals Sweet Charity, Little Me and Promises Promises, and They're Playing Our Song and The Goodbye Girl. And in 1991, he won the Tony Award and the Pulitzer Prize for his play Lost in Yonkers.
[1:00:22] Rob Russo: As I mentioned, when Plaza Suite finally arrives at the Hudson Theater next season, it will mark the first ever Broadway revival of this 1968 play, and the first Neil Simon play on Broadway in over a decade. You may be wondering, what are some other Neil Simon plays that have yet to receive a revival on Broadway? Well, the list includes his first play, 1961's Come Blow Your Horn, a smash hit, along with The Star Spangled Girl, Last of the Red Hot Lovers, The Gingerbread Lady, The Prisoner of Second Avenue, The Good Doctor, God's Favorite, California Suite, Chapter 2, which he regarded as his favorite play, I Ought to Be in Pictures, Fools, Rumors, Jake's Women, Laughter on the 23rd Floor, Proposals, The Dinner Party, and his last Broadway play, 2001's 45 Seconds from Broadway.
[1:01:10] Rob Russo: In 1983, Neil Simon became the only living playwright ever to have a New York Theater named in his honor, with the Alvin Theater on 52nd Street, rechristened as the Neil Simon Theater. And, for good reason, he was a giant of the theater who sustained Broadway with his prolific body of work while both entertaining and enlightening the so-called masses. No playwright since has come close, or ever likely will, to making the impact Neil Simon made.
[1:01:36] Rob Russo: To see for yourself, snag a ticket for Plaza Suite next season and check out John Benjamin Hickey's latest work as a director.
[1:02:13] Rob Russo: Our theme music is by Lucky Chops. Today's episode was edited and engineered by Charles Van Kirk. Find us online at the Fabulous Invalid.com and on social media at Fabulous Invalid and on iTunes, Spotify, and wherever you find your podcasts. And be sure to tune in next Wednesday.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
