Broadway and TV favorite Claybourne Elder is stepping into a whole new spotlight with his debut album If The Stars Were Mine, out now on Center Stage Records... Read More
From the show: The Roundtable with Robert Bannon
Guests
Featured Shows
About
Broadway and TV favorite Claybourne Elder is stepping into a whole new spotlight with his debut album If The Stars Were Mine, out now on Center Stage Records. Known for his standout work in Company and on HBO’s The Gilded Age, Elder brings his full self to this deeply personal collection—blending Broadway classics, pop favorites, and jazz standards into something that feels like a musical journal.
In this conversation, Elder opens up about creating a project that explores identity, fatherhood, sexuality, and faith—all while reimagining songs from Into the Woods, Floyd Collins, and even icons like Whitney Houston and Eartha Kitt. The album is not just a showcase of his voice—it’s a statement of who he is right now as an artist and a man. It’s vulnerable, bold, and yes… a little bit chaotic in the best way.
🎧 Listen to The Roundtable with Robert Bannon on Broadway Podcast Network, YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, iHeartRadio & more!
🌐 Visit: RobertBannon.com
📲 Follow on Instagram: @RobertBannon
#ClaybourneElder #IfTheStarsWereMine #CenterStageRecords #Broadway #TheGildedAge #CompanyBroadway #NewMusic #TheRoundtableWithRobertBannon
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:09] Robert Bannon: Well, everybody, welcome to the round table. My name is Robert Bannon. You're listening to us on Broadway World over here on the Broadway Podcast Network, iHeart and Spotify. I've seen our next guest besides seeing him on TV, I've seen him on stage. Okay. He's a Broadway star. Now he's a big TV star. Now he's back on the stage. He is just big booked. He's out here working, a big old star. And we're excited. His album is coming out. It's going to be streaming, then it's going to be a CD. Later in the year, it's going to be a vinyl. And you could go to my favorite place to see a show. You can go to 54 Below in April and also see him with three nights of an album release party. I'm so excited. Claybourne Elder, welcome to the show.
[0:46] Claybourne Elder: Thank you so much for having me. That was one of the best introductions of my life. Thank you.
[0:52] Robert Bannon: No, thank you for the work. You have a crazy—before we get to the album, your story is a wild ride.
[1:01] Claybourne Elder: It's a wild ride.
[1:03] Robert Bannon: Yeah, you know, you are a Utah born and raised person. And then after—can I—am I allowed to ask? You had to leave. Like, you decided to come out.
[1:14] Claybourne Elder: I don't just anyone ever told I'm gay, and I think you may be too.
[1:20] Claybourne Elder: Yes, yes, it's true.
[1:21] Robert Bannon: So I'm very, very—
[1:27] Claybourne Elder: Yeah, you know, I mean, I grew up in Utah. I grew up in a very small little town. I didn't know anybody who lived in New York or was an artist professionally or anything like that. And you know, I decided to kind of take a chance on it and showed up in New York without knowing anybody. And very kind people saw something in me and took big chances on me. And that's, you know, I think that it takes a lot. I think that it takes a person who's very confident in themselves, an artist that's very confident in themselves to take a chance on somebody else. And I'm so blessed to have those little angels in my life who took chances on me. So I feel very lucky.
[2:05] Claybourne Elder: I think it takes a really brave artist to be able to pack up and move across the country and work hard every single day and make a career. Do you take moments and think like, oh hot damn, we did—like I'm making a life as an actor. Like it was the right decision.
[2:17] Claybourne Elder: Like every day.
[2:20] Robert Bannon: Was it the right decision?
[2:22] Claybourne Elder: It is. I think it was. No, I can't—I'm yes, I do. I, you know, it is. I feel very lucky at these, especially these times, you know, like that the—I think that the key to having a successful career is buoyancy. You know, you have to be able to deal with the ups and downs of it all very well. And I think that the fact that the chances of me making it were so small to begin with that it has always made me very thankful. And in those down times in between things, I feel just lucky that any of it happened at all.
[2:53] Claybourne Elder: So, yes, thank you. I'm excited. Right now, I think you're backstage at City Center.
[3:00] Claybourne Elder: I mean my dressing room at City Center, yeah.
[3:02] Robert Bannon: Which I've been so distracted while you're talking because all I keep thinking is who is the thief at the wild party? Because you see the safe behind you. That means somebody is robbed. Who is robbing from Claybourne? That's a good thing.
[3:13] Claybourne Elder: I think they all have to have a safe in them. There's always a safe in the dressing room. That's how you can tell he books around the theater.
[3:20] Robert Bannon: And I live on Zoom, not booking theater, because I didn't know that. So when you decided at some point after Broadway television shows and all of this, that going back and jumping in the studio was something that you wanted to do. When did you decide you had an album concept or an idea?
[3:38] Claybourne Elder: You know, as I've been getting older and as I've had a child and things, I've been thinking a lot about the things we make and what we leave behind. And, you know, I've been alive and working long enough that there are songs to me that are very deeply personal that I've been living with for a lot of my life. And I sing a lot of them when I sing in shows or in concerts and things. And some people had asked me about making an album, and I was like, I don't know, maybe. And somebody said to me, you know, I bet Claybourne Elder at 22 years old would have loved to listen to your album. And I was like, oh, yeah, yeah, he would have. So that was one big reason. And so, and also just thinking of having something to leave behind for my son, you know.
But I also knew that if I was gonna make it, I wanted to, you know, I didn't want to just like go in and record some songs. I spent a year planning it and doing the arrangements. And I wanted, you know, I wanted—even though I was choosing songs that I loved, I wanted them to—I wanted to tell them in new ways, you know. And so I spent a lot of time with arrangers working on how to explore these songs in different ways without rewriting them or anything, but just making them—making you hear them differently.
[4:54] Robert Bannon: Well, April 3rd, you can stream the album. April 10th, you can order a copy of the CD and then the vinyl will be out later this year. You can go to Center Stage Records, you could click the link below to find Claybourne's Instagram and information so you can get the information, I'm sure on there. And you can go to Center Stage or wherever you listen to music, you can stream it. So what I was—when I was reading the track listing, which is so fun, and I see that some of the songs like "I Wanna Dance with Somebody," you arranged. So when did you decide to throw? Because arranging is such an art form, it is a—I love an arrangement. So how was that for you?
[5:29] Claybourne Elder: Well, I really wanted, like I said, I wanted there—I had very specific ideas about some of them. And even songs like I sing "Finishing the Hat." I've played George in Sunday in the Park with George four different times. It's like I've sung that song in front of people more than anything else, you know. And I was like, okay, but I want to hear it differently slightly, you know. And so we like we arranged it for strings and it was a very small, like a kind of string quartet. And then "I Wanna Dance with Somebody," like I had very specific thoughts about that because to me, that song, I remember being a little gay kid in Utah and thinking, listening to that song and thinking how sad it was. Because I remember thinking, like, I want to dance with somebody, but thinking kind of—there was knowing that I was gay, thinking, I don't know that I will ever have anybody or will fall in love.
And so to me, there was a lot of longing in that, you know, and so I was like, well, let's slow it down. And you know, all of these songs. So like I went to the arrangers and was like, let's sit down and talk about what it means and why we're doing it and let that inform what it was. You know, I sing "Moments in the Woods," which to me is a little like—God, I loved—I would do anything to play the Baker's Wife, but I'll never play the Baker's Wife. But I get to on this album. I was like, and I want to sing it like a pop song. I want a guitar, I want it to have a guitar and I want it to be like a pop song because it is like—it's a song about—it's this unrequited love, but it's also about like the thrill of a first kiss and things like that.
And so I was like, let's bring that into it and sat down with the guitarist and was like, what does it sound like on the guitar? And so I spent a lot of time planning and thinking about it because I wanted to make something that was really personal and I felt like a reflection of me.
[7:14] Claybourne Elder: I think you got to listen to the whole thing from beginning to end and hear the story, and don't just pick and cherry pick a song or two. Listen to the journey because I know you take time and energy to have it flow and have a certain track listing and space, and it's telling a story that you've created. These songs have to be personal too. I know some of them you've sung, some are your songs from stage, but then other ones I'm sure that in your life they mean something to you and someone.
[7:37] Claybourne Elder: Yeah, yeah. There are a couple of them that are lullabies that I sing to my son that I've been singing to him almost his whole life. There's a great song—there's a song called "Paving the Runway" that is about kind of this idea of like believing in someone, and it's a lullaby that I sing to him, but I also—I love to sing it at my shows because I would sing it to anybody because I feel like it's—I think one of the best gifts you can give to anybody is just to believe in them a little bit. And so that song is very meaningful to me for that reason.
[8:06] Robert Bannon: Well, we'll be playing it in our house. We're gonna play the whole album in our house. We're gonna read—so you're coming to 54 Below too. So now you're taking the album, it's in a release party. There's three days. I want people to be able to—you can get your tickets right now. The dates for these are April 3rd, April 4th, and April 15th. Go to 54below.org. So, what's a live—what's your live show gonna be like?
[8:25] Claybourne Elder: Well, and also just I should say if you can't make it to New York, it's live streaming on the 15th. So if you want to watch the live stream on the 15th, you can as well get a ticket at the same website. They do such a good job with their live stream, by the way. They have multiple cameras, it's got great HD, the sound is perfect. It's not like a little, you know, camcorder bootleg here. It's the real deal.
[8:46] Claybourne Elder: It's a real deal, it's really, really a nice thing. You know, the show is somewhere between a stand-up comedy special and my TED Talk because it's a little bit like, you know, it's not um—it's not like the story of my—it's not like I was born and here's a song about me, like it's thematic. I talk about—it's about all of us, you know. And I do talk, I do tell personal stories and things, but really I sat down and wrote something first and then chose the songs, and it's sort of about the nature of goodness, it's about growing up and becoming a father, and so I'm very proud of the writing of it, you know. It's something that I sat down and worked very hard to put together, and I've been performing it now for about two years, and I'm really excited to bring it to New York. I did it at Joe's Pub two and a half years ago, but that was a sort of trial version of it. Now, like the fully fleshed thing is out, and I'm very excited to share it with everyone.
[9:47] Robert Bannon: We are excited. You gotta get your tickets, everybody. I always say there's not a better place. You get a drink, you get a Caesar salad, you sit down, he's gonna be 15 feet away from you, spitting and singing right at you. And that is what makes 54 Below the best place to go see, you know, go see a show there and go see this show in particular.
[10:11] Claybourne Elder: Yeah, well, you know, I was in, I was on a show called The Carrie Diaries. That was like my first time on TV, and um, and I loved it. I had such a great time doing it, but it was my first experience out the gate, you know, like, and so I learned so much from doing it and then did little things and some movies and things like that. But then my next real time, like being on a show was The Gilded Age, and to get to do the first three seasons of it was thrilling and so fun, and everyone is wonderful, and like it's like theater camp. It's like all the Broadway people I love are there every day, and it was very, very fun to be a part of. I've loved it very much. Just out here spilling John Adams secrets, secret gay relatives in the class.
[10:51] Robert Bannon: That sounds like a perfect dream. That's a dream job to me.
[10:56] Claybourne Elder: It was a great job. I love, I love it. So how do you? I know you got a you we talked before you're in a show, you're putting out the album. There's more things. How do you balance your dad? You have a family, you have a life, and and you have a career. You gotta, you know, there's pressure to pay bills and keep doing work and the artist's life. So, what is the advice to balance it all?
[11:13] Claybourne Elder: You know, like anybody, I find that the quality of the time I get to spend is more important sometimes than the quantity. And like when I am with my son, my phone is across the room, and I am on the floor, and we are playing with Legos, you know, like it's like he gets my full attention. And I had a wonderful father who I love very, very much. And this is I don't mean this as a reflection, but like I spend more time with him than I spent with my dad, and you know, like, but I'm gone every single night doing this show right now. I'm doing and um, and it's hard, but also he knows that I'm doing something I really love, and that it's very important to me, and is also the way we make money, and that you know, that it's a special thing, and um, and he comes to see me in most things. He's not gonna see me in Wild Party, um, because it is not a kid's show, but he does come and to see me in most things and really really gets it and enjoys it, you know.
[12:10] Robert Bannon: I think that's you can have it all if you get to figure it out and you can have do it, and and you're definitely showing us that you can do it. Um, you have launched and and have had you you've created this idea that um has gotten a lot of attention called City of Strangers and giving free tickets to Broadway shows. Why I speak to a lot of people, my thousandth episode is coming up. Where have you been? Congratulations.
[12:36] Claybourne Elder: Thank you. A thousand since COVID because I'm uh OCD and crazy. And um, and uh I we talk a lot about the accessibility of Broadway because a lot of people who are off Broadway or doing shows at Theater Row or doing shows downtown will say, I'm doing shows for $40, $25 a ticket. I I know not everyone could afford that $500, $400,000, $300,000, $200 ticket. So where did the idea come that you needed to give some tickets away?
[13:02] Claybourne Elder: So this crazy thing happened to me, which is when I was young uh in college and was feeling particularly lost in my life. I came to New York on a visit, and a man walked up to me outside a theater where I'd seen a show standing room, and he was like, Hey, you seemed like I could see you in the standing room. It seemed like you were enjoying the show more than the people sitting down in the expensive seats. Here's $200. Go buy yourself a ticket to Sweeney Todd tomorrow, it'll change your life. And it was the John Doyle revival of Sweeney Todd. And I didn't know what to do, so I took a picture with him, and he went off on his way, and I had no money at that time in my life, and $200 was a lot of money, you know.
But I did, I went and bought a ticket to the show, and it had a really, really big impact on my life um for a long time. And um, and cut to years later, I was in Company on Broadway and I decided to give away a couple of tickets to the show. And um I got reconnected with that man because I posted the picture of us and and somebody who knew him reached out to me and said, I can connect you with this guy. And so we reconnected.
[14:21] Claybourne Elder: And through telling that story online, um, of us kind of reconnecting, and also so many people started wanting to give money to get to buy more tickets for people. And so I got so over the course of the next year, we became a registered nonprofit in New York. It's called City of Strangers after the song in Company. And we've given away over 4,000 tickets to shows, and they're not free. They're paid for by someone who wants to do something nice for somebody else. And there's no age restriction. There's no, you know, like we have 70-year-olds, we have college students. Um, it's really about finding the people who truly can't afford it and truly want to be there, you know. And we partner with a lot of community organizations now where we like give away tickets to public school teachers in the area who cannot afford to get in the door, um, unhoused youth, um, people who are studying, people in um people who don't feel comfortable in the theater, you know, it's don't feel welcome in the space. It's now we find all sorts of people to to find to make it more accessible.
[15:25] Claybourne Elder: And we're still giving away tickets on our Instagram as well, um, whenever we can, you know, like it's a we're small, nobody gets paid in the organization. It's just mostly me giving away tickets to people. I'm and you know, and I am like the people, the people who donate the money are the heroes of the story. Like I'm just basically the connecting service of the like giving away the tickets, but um, you know, it's clearly something people feel strongly about. And I think that if you believe in the transformative nature of theater, then it's something that it's easy to believe in, you know. And I I know how I've had a lot of people who four years ago won tickets and then now are donating money to me because they've gone on in their careers and done other things and have money themselves, you know.
And um I count people all the time come up to me and say how that they won tickets for something, you know. Um so it's something we I you know, I keep doing. We're giving if you follow us on Instagram, City of Strangers NYC, you'll find out when our giveaways are. And we I try to get as many tickets as I can from people, but again, we're small, but I try to get it out there, you know. We just ask that you promise us that you're a person who can't afford it. That's all we ask, you know. And we want as many people as we can.
[16:35] Claybourne Elder: That really moved. I I was very lucky that I had parents who I was grew up in Jersey, I was a mile from New York City, and I I begged my parents and they back then, 1990s. I'm 42. So if it's in the 90s, you know, I the tickets were expensive for them, but not as expensive as they are now. My parents really monthly tried to get me and a parent to go see a show. The next generation of theater goers are gonna be priced out, theater goers and theater makers and creators. The next Claybourne Elder is out there and needs to be able to see a show. And it's how can you if you're out here trying to make it, how can you make it if you don't see the top of the game, if you don't see what's happening at the top of the game.
If you if it's that's not accessible to you, you know, and again, that's just one flavor of person we give tickets to, we give them away to everybody. But but it's but that is one one of the big catalysts of it. Is I'm like, God, when I moved to New York, I had 50 cents. Like I, you know, I was working all sorts of crazy jobs. I didn't have, I didn't go see theater. I went unless I won the lottery, you know, but that was even it's a luxury to be able to go wait in line at the lottery. Like you have to have not have a job. And I often had a job, so I couldn't. And now I'm upset I paid full price to see you in Company.
[17:57] Robert Bannon: I did.
[17:58] Claybourne Elder: Well, thank you.
[18:03] Robert Bannon: I want everyone that's watching us right now. Hey, you gotta follow them. You gotta follow Claybourne. You gotta be able to ready the stream. So we're gonna review our homework. Are you ready, people? Here we go. We're gonna listen to the album. The album's gonna be available for streaming on April 3rd. If The Stars Were Mine, the debut album from Claybourne Elder, you're gonna be able to stream it. The CD is coming out on April 10th. You can get it at the website, click below. It's got incredible. Brian Perry is so brilliant. And you gotta listen to all the incredible arrangements that they've created at Rodney Bush and the whole team that has been there. Um, and then you're gonna get your tickets April 3rd, April 14th, and April 15th, no matter where you are in the world, you'll be able to stream it, live stream it from 54below.org. So listen to the album, buy the album, buy your tickets, share it with somebody.
I love playlists with my husband. I think we'll listen to it. If there's a song I love, I stick it in there. It surprises him, it makes me think of him and share it with somebody you care about today.
[18:57] Claybourne Elder: I love I really have a good time with you, Robert. Thank you. I had a great time with you too. You're wonderful. I really appreciate this. I I'm so grateful to be able to spend some time with you. And I want people you have a chance till till the 29th to see the if are there tickets? There's probably no tickets. To Wild Party, I think they're selling, they're filling up pretty fast, but they're but there are some, I think.
[19:17] Robert Bannon: Okay.
[19:18] Claybourne Elder: Yeah. You could, you know, find him and City of Strangers is giving away some tickets right now to Wild Party next week. So you can go to City of Strangers and enter right now to win tickets for next week.
[19:28] Robert Bannon: Perfect. Done. Done. Congratulations. Love to your family. Enjoy your son on your off time.
[19:34] Claybourne Elder: Thank you.
[19:35] Robert Bannon: And my show's yours, so I hope you come on back next time.
[19:37] Claybourne Elder: I would love to.
[19:39] Robert Bannon: Done. Booked. Congratulations. Break legs.
[19:42] Claybourne Elder: Thank you very much.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
