When Susan and Laura were invited to intro a NYC showing of The Philadelphia Story recently, they challenged themselves to find sparks related to the movie -- and they didn't have to look very far!.. Read More
From the show: The Spark File with Susan Blackwell and Laura Camien
Guests
Featured Shows
About
When Susan and Laura were invited to intro a NYC showing of The Philadelphia Story recently, they challenged themselves to find sparks related to the movie -- and they didn't have to look very far! The incredible self-orchestrated career turnaround of Katherine Hepburn, plus Scotty Bowers and the Secret History of Hollywood. Buckle up, it's gonna be a bumpy ride!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:37] Laura Camien: Welcome to the Sparks File, your one-stop editing bay for creative inspiration.
[0:41] Susan Blackwell: I'm Susan Blackwell.
[0:42] Laura Camien: And I'm Laura Camien.
[0:43] Susan Blackwell: If you're joining us again, welcome back.
[0:46] Laura Camien: But if you're joining us for the first time, welcome.
[0:48] Susan Blackwell: You may be asking yourself, what exactly is a spark file?
[0:52] Laura Camien: Where do I get one?
[0:53] Susan Blackwell: What do I file in it?
[0:54] Laura Camien: These are good questions, and we have got answers.
[0:56] Susan Blackwell: A spark file is a place where you consistently collect all of your inspirations and fascinations.
[1:02] Laura Camien: Here's the deal.
[1:03] Susan Blackwell: We're makers who make all kinds of things.
[1:05] Laura Camien: If you're like us and making stuff all the time, or want to be making stuff all the time, you know the wellspring of inspiration can run a little dry.
[1:13] Susan Blackwell: So we're on the lookout for fresh ideas, images, and inspiration that spark our creativity and pique our curiosity, things that inspire us to get up off of our asses and make things like this podcast.
[1:25] Laura Camien: Or a life-changing career-changing risky effing decision.
[1:31] Susan Blackwell: Or a counter narrative to the picture perfect propaganda of Hollywood.
[1:36] Laura Camien: Every episode, we're gonna reach into the spark file and exchange some sparks.
[1:41] Susan Blackwell: And from time to time, we're gonna talk to some folks who spark us too.
[1:44] Laura Camien: And if you're not careful, you might hear the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.
[1:48] Susan Blackwell: So without further ado, let's open up the spark file.
[1:55] Laura Camien: Oh, I can't wait to hear what you were saying.
[1:58] Susan Blackwell: Likewise, likewise.
[2:00] Laura Camien: Oh my gosh.
[2:01] Susan Blackwell: Camps, we're running a little experiment this episode of the Sparks.
[2:07] Laura Camien: We are.
[2:08] Susan Blackwell: Yeah, it's fun.
[2:09] Laura Camien: Do you want to tell the people what it is?
[2:10] Susan Blackwell: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[2:11] Laura Camien: I'm super.
[2:14] Susan Blackwell: I'm excited because what happened was.
[2:17] Laura Camien: So what happened was what happened was we got invited to do a live little mini episode at United Palace in New York City.
[2:27] Susan Blackwell: Yes.
[2:27] Laura Camien: Which is freaking gorgeous, beautiful historic theater.
[2:32] Susan Blackwell: It is the most beautiful, ornate well-preserved theater.
[2:39] Laura Camien: Art Deco.
[2:40] Susan Blackwell: It's 1930s.
[2:42] Laura Camien: And thanks to Lin-Manuel Miranda, they have a beautiful new digital movie projector.
[2:49] Susan Blackwell: And then they fundraised for this gigantic movie screen.
[2:55] Laura Camien: And then they also have a new sound system.
[2:58] Susan Blackwell: So it is an extraordinary place to see movies.
[3:01] Laura Camien: And that was its history.
[3:02] Susan Blackwell: It was a vaudeville house where you got a vaudeville show, you got some pre-show shorts, and then you got to watch a movie.
[3:10] Laura Camien: Beautiful movie.
[3:11] Susan Blackwell: So we're gonna be the pre-show.
[3:13] Laura Camien: That's what we're doing.
[3:14] Susan Blackwell: We're gonna do the vaudeville.
[3:15] Laura Camien: That's right.
[3:15] Susan Blackwell: Before the movie, the entertainment.
[3:18] Laura Camien: Um, we're gonna interview the beautiful Kelli O'Hara.
[3:20] Susan Blackwell: That's right, and then they're gonna show The Philadelphia Story.
[3:24] Laura Camien: And that movie, so this was our challenge for the week.
[3:27] Susan Blackwell: Here's our shaker, okay, okay, okay.
[3:29] Laura Camien: Um, The Philadelphia Story.
[3:31] Susan Blackwell: Could we each watch it and find a spark?
[3:36] Laura Camien: That was the risk.
[3:37] Susan Blackwell: That was the risk.
[3:38] Laura Camien: And I don't know about you, but I definitely was sparked in a bunch of ways.
[3:42] Susan Blackwell: Some dark sparks, yeah, and some not so dark sparks.
[3:46] Laura Camien: Well, totes, my goats.
[3:48] Susan Blackwell: And I was a little nervous because I was like, will I be able?
[3:55] Laura Camien: We always say things like sparks are everywhere.
[3:58] Susan Blackwell: And we do.
[3:59] Laura Camien: And other things like sparks are everywhere.
[4:01] Susan Blackwell: And I was just like, will I be able to make good on this?
[4:05] Laura Camien: And I was nervous.
[4:07] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[4:07] Laura Camien: Until I got onto something.
[4:09] Susan Blackwell: And then once I was onto something, yeah.
[4:11] Laura Camien: I was not nervous.
[4:12] Susan Blackwell: I was super sparked.
[4:14] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[4:15] Susan Blackwell: I think I told you I was like my very, the first watch.
[4:19] Laura Camien: Okay.
[4:19] Susan Blackwell: I watched it twice.
[4:20] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[4:20] Susan Blackwell: So my first watch, I was like onto something almost immediately, but it was a very dark spark.
[4:25] Laura Camien: And I was like, oh, okay.
[4:28] Susan Blackwell: Maybe I'm doing a dark spark this week.
[4:29] Laura Camien: We'll see.
[4:30] Susan Blackwell: Um, but then I watched it again, and something else struck me, and I decided to go with that.
[4:36] Laura Camien: But maybe one day I will reach back into this file and say, remember The Philadelphia Story?
[4:42] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[4:42] Laura Camien: I've got a dark spark.
[4:43] Susan Blackwell: You got more there.
[4:44] Laura Camien: Yeah, there I found more than one spark where I could have just rested and dug deeper.
[4:49] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[4:49] Laura Camien: But I'm glad I kept following that spark because I really, really like my spark.
[4:55] Susan Blackwell: I'm so excited.
[4:56] Laura Camien: Do you want to go first?
[4:57] Susan Blackwell: Okay, okay.
[4:58] Laura Camien: I'll go first.
[4:58] Susan Blackwell: Okay.
[4:59] Laura Camien: I'm super excited.
[5:00] Susan Blackwell: Like I said, there was a really dark spark in mine, but today I ended up going with something a little more central to the movie itself.
[5:08] Laura Camien: Oh, good.
[5:09] Susan Blackwell: You know?
[5:10] Laura Camien: All right.
[5:10] Susan Blackwell: So I got my information from an article in Vanity Fair by Barbara Lemming, Film School Rejects by Anna Swanson, San Francisco Gate by Edward Guthman, The New Yorker by Claudia Roth Pierpont, and Katherine Hepburn's autobiography, Me.
[5:10] Laura Camien: Claudia Roth Pierpont.
[5:30] Susan Blackwell: I was very impressed with that name.
[5:32] Laura Camien: That sounds like a mainline name.
[5:36] Susan Blackwell: Sounds like a, and of course Claudia works for The New Yorker.
[5:39] Laura Camien: Because it's a serious journalist, it's a serious writer name.
[5:43] Susan Blackwell: She sounds like she comes from a family of the stuff.
[5:45] Laura Camien: When Katharine Hepburn, perhaps.
[5:48] Susan Blackwell: Oh, it could be.
[5:50] Laura Camien: Okay.
[5:51] Susan Blackwell: So I think obviously we all know Katherine Hepburn as a screen legend and old Hollywood royalty.
[6:01] Laura Camien: Her sound was unique.
[6:02] Susan Blackwell: Her personal style was unique.
[6:04] Laura Camien: She's one of the most accomplished actresses of all time.
[6:08] Susan Blackwell: I don't know if you know, but she's won more Academy Awards than anyone in history.
[6:12] Laura Camien: You're kidding.
[6:13] Susan Blackwell: I'm kidding.
[6:14] Laura Camien: Including Meryl Streep.
[6:15] Susan Blackwell: Katharine has four Oscar wins, only 12 nominations, but four wins.
[6:20] Laura Camien: Uh-huh.
[6:21] Susan Blackwell: Meryl has her beat on the nominations.
[6:23] Laura Camien: She has 21 nominations, three wins.
[6:27] Susan Blackwell: So, and Katherine Hepburn did that while snubbing the entire academy herself.
[6:33] Laura Camien: Yes.
[6:33] Susan Blackwell: She never attended a single ceremony.
[6:35] Laura Camien: Never picked up any one of those awards.
[6:37] Susan Blackwell: Ah.
[6:38] Laura Camien: Only she, you know, can get away with that.
[6:41] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[6:42] Laura Camien: And the American Film Institute ranks her as the number one female star of all time.
[6:42] Susan Blackwell: Wow.
[6:42] Laura Camien: All time.
[6:50] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[6:51] Laura Camien: What I learned through this process is that, as it turns out, The Philadelphia Story, this film is the reason why we know so much about Katherine Hepburn.
[7:02] Susan Blackwell: If she hadn't done this film, her career was in a nosedive, and she was not like 40 more films to come would not have happened with Katherine Hepburn.
[7:14] Laura Camien: The Philadelphia Story is the turning point.
[7:18] Susan Blackwell: So yeah, her career was in free fall.
[7:22] Laura Camien: Essentially, she had a very short career prior to this.
[7:26] Susan Blackwell: Um, I wouldn't say very short, but she had been doing a little bit of Broadway, and then Hollywood, you know, scooped her up.
[7:35] Laura Camien: She had one Academy Award nomination already, but then it followed with a slew of just box office bombs.
[7:46] Susan Blackwell: But with this movie, she single-handedly turned her own career around and she masterminded it herself with The Philadelphia Story.
[7:55] Laura Camien: That much all you have.
[7:56] Susan Blackwell: Wow.
[7:57] Laura Camien: It's as you're talking, I'm realizing I have to fight my urge to just do a Katherine Hepburn impression through this whole—
[7:57] Susan Blackwell: Do it.
[8:04] Laura Camien: And I'll just get to say when I was in one of my first jobs out of school was at the Guthrie Theater, and my former roommate Thomas J. Ryan.
[8:15] Susan Blackwell: Hi, Tom.
[8:16] Laura Camien: Who's now in West Side Story on Broadway?
[8:18] Susan Blackwell: He um, he and I started doing a Katherine Hepburn impression, and we got so addicted to doing it that people were like, please stop.
[8:18] Laura Camien: And we got so addicted to doing it that and it was we kept saying, and I think it was this is I think this is stolen from an old SNL sketch, like something about well, there's no shame in a sandwich.
[8:39] Susan Blackwell: Like we could not, and so you specifically have like an older Katherine Hepburn in mind, like you go on Golden Pond.
[8:47] Laura Camien: On Golden Pond, as opposed to the younger Katherine Hepburn.
[8:50] Susan Blackwell: I almost the spark I almost did was Kristen Wiig because her impression of Katherine Hepburn is actually so good.
[8:58] Laura Camien: Oh, that would be amazing.
[9:02] Susan Blackwell: Yes.
[9:03] Laura Camien: It's a glass of water and a walk across the country.
[9:06] Susan Blackwell: Kind of thing.
[9:07] Laura Camien: That's right.
[9:07] Susan Blackwell: She, that even that's a little bit aged.
[9:09] Laura Camien: But um, I'm gonna feel like she was barking at them.
[9:13] Susan Blackwell: Um, like in her younger years.
[9:15] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[9:15] Susan Blackwell: Her voice was, yeah, yes.
[9:18] Laura Camien: When we did, when we were doing that impression and we couldn't stop, we were doing a production of A Christmas Carol.
[9:22] Susan Blackwell: And there was a little tiny kid that played one of the little Fezziwig kids.
[9:27] Laura Camien: And one day, just from being near us and osmosis, he was like, just no shame in a sandwich.
[9:33] Susan Blackwell: This little kid.
[9:35] Laura Camien: I like to think that we made that kid gay.
[9:39] Susan Blackwell: Just with our Katherine Hepburn impression.
[9:41] Laura Camien: I'm gonna resist this urge.
[9:42] Susan Blackwell: Please continue.
[9:44] Laura Camien: Okay.
[9:44] Susan Blackwell: But I, it feels like it's gonna come out.
[9:47] Laura Camien: Okay.
[9:47] Susan Blackwell: Well, I mean, you did.
[9:48] Laura Camien: You already did it.
[9:49] Susan Blackwell: You did have it.
[9:50] Laura Camien: Oh god.
[9:51] Susan Blackwell: Oh no.
[9:52] Laura Camien: Oh no.
[9:53] Susan Blackwell: All right.
[9:53] Laura Camien: Well, maybe Katharine can tell us how she feels now about this turnaround that she did.
[9:58] Susan Blackwell: The bones of Katherine Hepburn.
[10:00] Laura Camien: Clicking a clap.
[10:03] Susan Blackwell: All right.
[10:03] Laura Camien: So this career pivot in the face of public criticism, like literally people hating her, calling her box office poison.
[10:12] Susan Blackwell: Yes, is my spark for today.
[10:15] Laura Camien: Wow.
[10:15] Susan Blackwell: That's my spark.
[10:16] Laura Camien: Oh, that's interesting.
[10:17] Susan Blackwell: So obviously, Katherine Hepburn is a walking tinder box of sparks in and of herself.
[10:23] Laura Camien: And this is not going, she is fascinating.
[10:23] Susan Blackwell: She is.
[10:27] Laura Camien: You quite, you don't think so.
[10:29] Susan Blackwell: Oh no, I know so.
[10:31] Laura Camien: Oh, I'm not sure.
[10:31] Susan Blackwell: And my spark bears an arc at the end of yours.
[10:34] Laura Camien: Oh, period.
[10:35] Susan Blackwell: Exclamation point.
[10:36] Laura Camien: Okay.
[10:36] Susan Blackwell: She is fascinating.
[10:37] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[10:38] Susan Blackwell: And the life that she led and the paradoxes of things.
[10:42] Laura Camien: Um, it's truly, truly worth a deep dive.
[10:47] Susan Blackwell: But my spark is not going to be a full biography on her.
[10:50] Laura Camien: I want to focus on the things that you need to know in order to understand how she turned things around.
[10:55] Susan Blackwell: Love herself.
[10:57] Laura Camien: Um, yeah, and uh she essentially single-handedly put her career on a new track and one that would eventually lead to a repertoire of 50 films over six decades, which would not be the case.
[11:13] Susan Blackwell: So, first of all, we should acknowledge, I think, as she always did, that she was born into privilege.
[11:13] Laura Camien: She was born into an affluent family in New England.
[11:22] Susan Blackwell: Her father was a doctor, her mother, probably a spark in and of herself, was a suffragette.
[11:29] Laura Camien: Didn't know.
[11:30] Susan Blackwell: Go, mom.
[11:31] Laura Camien: Um, so both, yeah, so both of them advocated for women's rights, including birth control, which was quite unusual for the early 1900s.
[11:39] Susan Blackwell: Yes.
[11:40] Laura Camien: Um, but the family was progressive and really not too worried about what others might think.
[11:44] Susan Blackwell: And I think you can see that in Katharine's behavior.
[11:46] Laura Camien: But again, that often comes with privilege when you have enough money and privilege to not care what people think.
[11:52] Susan Blackwell: That's a good point.
[11:53] Laura Camien: So they had that.
[11:54] Susan Blackwell: They had that.
[11:54] Laura Camien: And she weird people that have a lot of money can get away with so much more.
[11:58] Susan Blackwell: That's right.
[11:59] Laura Camien: Yeah, that's right.
[12:00] Susan Blackwell: Um, so she was the second child of six total children.
[12:07] Laura Camien: She was athletic and prone to dressing like a boy.
[12:11] Susan Blackwell: She was encouraged to be opinionated and honest and strong.
[12:15] Laura Camien: She was very close to her older brother Tom, and her father believed in physical activity as a health benefit.
[12:22] Susan Blackwell: She and her brother did everything together, like running and horseback riding and swimming.
[12:26] Laura Camien: This was very, very unusual for a girl.
[12:29] Susan Blackwell: Well, first of all, girls, if they rode horses, rode side saddle.
[12:33] Laura Camien: So they, you know, got to keep your legs together.
[12:36] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[12:36] Laura Camien: And um, just the physical exertion was often, uh women were encouraged to, you know, rest.
[12:44] Susan Blackwell: You're so dainty, you're so delicate.
[12:46] Laura Camien: What years are we talking about here?
[12:48] Susan Blackwell: Well, she was born in 1907.
[12:50] Laura Camien: So, okay.
[12:51] Susan Blackwell: And that was still the case, that it was like, yeah, keep your knees together.
[12:55] Laura Camien: And for sure.
[12:56] Susan Blackwell: But she was running wild.
[12:57] Laura Camien: She was running.
[12:58] Susan Blackwell: Running free.
[12:59] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[12:59] Susan Blackwell: That's I think quite like that really distinguished her.
[13:02] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[13:03] Susan Blackwell: There are stories of her shaving her head at nine years old and dressing in her brother's clothes.
[13:07] Laura Camien: Uh-huh.
[13:09] Susan Blackwell: So we know that the fashion trademark that she was ultimately known for was wearing pants.
[13:15] Laura Camien: Trousers.
[13:16] Susan Blackwell: Trousers.
[13:16] Laura Camien: Trousers.
[13:17] Susan Blackwell: And what I don't think that most of us truly grasp is that this was at a time when women simply did not wear them.
[13:29] Laura Camien: It was illegal to wear pants.
[13:32] Susan Blackwell: What?
[13:33] Laura Camien: So when women were recruited to work during World War II because all the men were fighting, at that time they were gradually introduced to pants.
[13:42] Susan Blackwell: And once they had the joy of wearing pants, obviously, many of them didn't stop.
[13:46] Laura Camien: But that wasn't until, you know, 1940s and beyond.
[13:51] Susan Blackwell: So when the war stopped, the war was over.
[13:53] Laura Camien: It was like, hey ladies, aren't we going back to the kitchen?
[13:56] Susan Blackwell: Aren't we putting those skirts back on?
[13:58] Laura Camien: And some people didn't.
[13:59] Susan Blackwell: But that's like mid-1940s, approaching 1950s.
[14:03] Laura Camien: Katharine's wearing pants through the 1920s, the 1930s.
[14:08] Susan Blackwell: Wow.
[14:09] Laura Camien: So yeah, when she was wearing them, Freud, imagine Sigmund Freud, who we just sort of assume, I think, has always been around and his ideas have always been around, but they were very, they were just being introduced and very popular at that time.
[14:24] Susan Blackwell: So he had the world believing that women wearing pants was all about quote penis envy.
[14:29] Laura Camien: And like clothing back then was very, very tied to gender.
[14:35] Susan Blackwell: And pants were for men, and it was feared that if a woman wore pants, it was a reflection of her perversity.
[14:45] Susan Blackwell: So women could be and were arrested for wearing pants in public, and they were charged with masquerading as men.
[14:53] Laura Camien: Wow.
[14:54] Susan Blackwell: That's right. As late as World War II, women wearing men's pants might be nabbed by police for violating anti-cross-dressing laws.
[15:01] Laura Camien: Oh my God.
[15:03] Susan Blackwell: I just don't think like I think we're all like, yeah, go, Catherine, like or the fashion.
[15:09] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[15:10] Susan Blackwell: Yeah, put those pants on, girl. Um, no. It was a really subversive act. And it angered people too, and I'll get into that. Um, but quick side spark. According to an article in Bust Magazine by Dan and Leslie Langrigan, there's a woman named Emma Snodgrass, who in 1852, right?
[15:31] Laura Camien: Emma Sandy.
[15:31] Susan Blackwell: Emma Snodgrass is a spark. In 1852, she showed up in Boston wearing pants. She was arrested, she was mocked by crowds of people and sent back to New York City, 1852.
[15:43] Laura Camien: Wow.
[15:43] Susan Blackwell: She kept showing up over and over again, and there are all these like newspaper clips of like this woman. Emma Snodgrass strikes again.
[15:50] Laura Camien: Yes, actually.
[15:51] Susan Blackwell: And the press called her the unfeminine freak, among other things. And she shows up in newspaper articles like in Boston and New York City, Washington, DC, Cleveland, on a spree of wearing pants. She got arrested everywhere she went.
[16:06] Laura Camien: Emma Snodgrass, Sidespark.
[16:08] Susan Blackwell: That's just a little side spark.
[16:11] Laura Camien: Amazing side spark.
[16:12] Susan Blackwell: Yeah. Incredible. Wow. Um, but as I mentioned, as late as World War II, women wearing men's pants might be arrested for violating anti-cross-dressing laws.
[16:21] Laura Camien: It's crazy.
[16:22] Susan Blackwell: So nonetheless, Catherine wore them, and it was very effing polarizing. Like some people credit her for starting a fashion trend, but some people were deeply, deeply offended by it.
[16:36] Laura Camien: There was a bit like a whole lot of like how she dare shot.
[16:41] Susan Blackwell: And who does she think she is? And yeah, there's a morality issue that uh I'll get into a little bit later. But in regard to her wearing men's clothing, there is a darker story to her connection of her masculinity and affinity for menswear. And uh there is a trigger warning. So if you're worried at all, you might want to fast forward a little bit. Um the brother that she was so fond of, Tom, just a year and a half older than her, became troubled as he entered his teens.
[17:14] Laura Camien: And there's a story about his father joking about a stunt that he and his friends did when they were younger, and it involved a noose, but sort of a false news, like so they could fake a hanging.
[17:28] Susan Blackwell: Isn't that hilarious?
[17:30] Laura Camien: And this is their father, this is the father talking to Tom.
[17:34] Susan Blackwell: Yeah, and at one point, apparently, Tom was found attempting this quote unquote joke. And his father scolded him and told him not to do it again, and then the entire family literally left it alone, never, you know, checked in with Tom again. But a few years later, when Tom was 15 and Catherine was 13, they traveled to New York City to visit family friends. They went to a movie. They came back to the house that night. Tom played the banjo. Everything seemed like they had a lovely evening as a family. And the next morning, Catherine went to find her brother.
[18:08] Laura Camien: He was sleeping in the attic.
[18:09] Susan Blackwell: And she went upstairs to find that he had tied a bedsheet together and hung himself from the rafter.
[18:17] Laura Camien: And the tragic thing, see if I can get through this, but the tragic thing is that her father tried telling the press and everyone else that it was just a stunt that gone wrong.
[18:29] Susan Blackwell: Like a practical joke. Just kidding. Um, but Catherine knew the truth. The truth was, and this is brutal. But the truth was the sheet had been too long. So Tom's feet could actually touch the floor had he wanted to stand up. But it was actually his sheer will to go through with it. It's tragic. And Catherine was the one who like cut his body loose.
[18:59] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[18:59] Susan Blackwell: Yeah. It's truly like any like after you read this story, I'm like, any sort of hard shell that she might be criticized for having, I I was like, I'm right there with you, Catherine.
[19:14] Laura Camien: Yeah. Wow, I had no idea.
[19:17] Susan Blackwell: Yeah. And do they have any idea why?
[19:22] Laura Camien: I mean, people speculate that, you know, uh any number of things. When you look at his father's um and his mother's quickness to cover it up with it was a stunt, it was a boyish stunt, and we're we're done with it. Um, you have to think that any talk of anything less than perfection or things going on in their life, like they didn't talk about it.
[19:45] Susan Blackwell: Yeah, they didn't deal with it.
[19:46] Laura Camien: So if Tom was struggling with anything, good chance the family was not, you know, there to have a conversation and help him through it. She talks a lot about their sort of chin up mentality, and we don't complain about things and we move on.
[19:58] Susan Blackwell: Wow.
[19:59] Laura Camien: So, um, but there may have been another like reason why the family was unwilling to look at the truth because there was a history of suicide in their family, also not really talked about. But Kate's grandfather, her mother's dad, and his brother both killed themselves.
[20:20] Susan Blackwell: Oh my god.
[20:21] Laura Camien: Her father's brother killed himself.
[20:25] Susan Blackwell: Oh boy.
[20:26] Laura Camien: And this is where like the mind can make up a lot of stories. But two days after Tom's death, another uncle killed himself.
[20:36] Susan Blackwell: Oh yeah.
[20:37] Laura Camien: So it feels like there are some things going on there that we will never know.
[20:43] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[20:43] Laura Camien: Got it. Um, but the family literally never spoke of these things. Um, her father called it a boyish stunt, and then they didn't even talk about Tom anymore.
[20:55] Susan Blackwell: Oh, and she loved him so much.
[20:57] Laura Camien: She loved him so much. So several different articles that I read talked about how Catherine kind of took her brother's place in the family. She became the eldest child. She was in charge of her four younger siblings, and in a way, she became a surrogate son for them.
[21:15] Susan Blackwell: She even changed her.
[21:17] Laura Camien: Catherine became a surrogate son to her parents.
[21:20] Susan Blackwell: To her parents. Wow. Okay. Um, and she changed her birthday. She stopped celebrating it on her birthday, and she started celebrating it on Tom's birthday.
[21:29] Laura Camien: Oh god, that's haunted.
[21:31] Susan Blackwell: So she changed from May 12th to November 8th.
[21:34] Laura Camien: Oh.
[21:35] Susan Blackwell: And many, many, many people in her family remarked that she was just different.
[21:40] Laura Camien: That's an interesting spark.
[21:42] Susan Blackwell: That's an interesting uh that would be an interesting feature. I've never heard anything like that before. To start celebrating your birthday on the birthday of a deceased loved one.
[21:53] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[21:54] Susan Blackwell: There's something that would be an really interesting character.
[21:57] Laura Camien: It would be.
[21:58] Susan Blackwell: And I wondered like, was that her subversive way of we are going to remember Tom? You know what I mean? To insist that you want you don't want to talk about him.
[22:09] Laura Camien: Yeah, but you're gonna make a cake on his birthday.
[22:11] Susan Blackwell: For me.
[22:12] Laura Camien: For me. Oh, interesting. We're gonna be able to do that. I think that's an interesting spark.
[22:16] Susan Blackwell: I do too.
[22:16] Laura Camien: Oh, I had no idea. Uh yeah. I I think her childhood and then the direction that her life took were it's really fascinating. And just the the things I struggle with, like that we will never know.
[22:30] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[22:31] Laura Camien: We will just never know. It's so frustrating. Um, but one of her biographers, William Mann, wrote, She didn't grow up to be her mother's kind of woman. Katherine Hepburn grew up to be her father's kind of man.
[22:46] Susan Blackwell: So to me, that really colors the stories of her being bossy, strong, too masculine. I mean, you can't talk about that without understanding like what she went through.
[22:58] Laura Camien: So interesting in her childhood. I bumped into William Mann in my studies as well.
[23:02] Susan Blackwell: My Sparks studies.
[23:05] Laura Camien: Yes. So he'll be highlighting. And we'll be visiting him too. So in an article in San Francisco Gate, Edward Guffman wrote, Some people crumble under tragedy. Others, like Hepburn, seem to compensate with a fierce strive to master the unknowable, to trick fate in its own cruel path. Stricken by a tragedy that seemed random and capricious, Hepburn sought ways to halt randomness, to create and protect a life that was structured, devoted to family and work, and defined by an unbending set of values.
[23:40] Susan Blackwell: Wow. She was really known for like flexibility, I don't think is a word that like people associated with Katherine Hepburn.
[23:47] Laura Camien: Like she knew what she wanted.
[23:49] Susan Blackwell: Yes, no, you were gonna get this straight deal from her. This starts to remind me of the Philadelphia story. In the book Kate Remembered, A. Scott Berg suggests that Tom's death was the indirect catalyst for Hepburn's acting career. Feeling the stigma of her brother's suicide and the isolation it created, he writes, the teenage Kate sought refuge in role-playing, becoming stronger, prouder, even haughtier. She learned to mask her feelings to create one persona that would greet the world while she hid another that she would fight to keep private.
[24:25] Laura Camien: Wow.
[24:25] Susan Blackwell: She was becoming an actress.
[24:27] Laura Camien: Yeah. Coping mechanisms.
[24:30] Susan Blackwell: Coping mechanisms.
[24:31] Laura Camien: Oh, coping mechanism.
[24:33] Susan Blackwell: Yes. The new version of Kate was focused, driven. She knew what she wanted. She fortified herself with a strict set of values to live by, order, punctuality, moral fiber.
[24:45] Laura Camien: She sounds like a barrel of monkeys.
[24:46] Susan Blackwell: Right and common sense. But that's the that's the like uh drink cold water and I walk 10 miles a day.
[24:53] Laura Camien: That's right.
[24:54] Susan Blackwell: That's the suck it upness. And she was really proud of her, yeah, herself and proud of her family for this sort of chin-up mentality. She really there's a quote I don't have in this spark, but she has a big long rant about people being victims, and she has just no time for it.
[25:13] Laura Camien: How interesting.
[25:14] Susan Blackwell: Yeah. And when you think about, of course, someone who was a victim of something tragic and was not allowed the space to heal from that.
[25:24] Laura Camien: Yeah, she internalized that messaging.
[25:26] Susan Blackwell: That's right. So back to her career. So right out of college, she moves to New York City and she began working on Broadway almost immediately. It's the late 1920s. Positive reviews of her work on Broadway got the attention of Hollywood, and she was called to work in films. She signed a contract with RKO Pictures. She gained success right away. And in her third movie, Morning Glory, she won the Academy Award for Best Actress.
[25:50] Laura Camien: Wow.
[25:51] Susan Blackwell: This is 1933. Okay. And later that year, she starred in Little Women, which was another hit.
[25:57] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[25:58] Susan Blackwell: But after that, whoo boy. The movies she were doing were commercial and critical flops.
[26:06] Laura Camien: Rough.
[26:07] Susan Blackwell: Spitfire, a play called The Lake, Bringing Up Baby, which now is lauded, but at the time was really yes, it was a complete stinker and total stinker.
[26:17] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[26:18] Susan Blackwell: But now people love that movie.
[26:20] Laura Camien: Now people love it. Like it's a classic screwball comedy. But at the time, no.
[26:25] Susan Blackwell: But this is 1934 to 1938. It's four years of films and plays, and it just seemed to get worse with each one. So part of the problem was that in this moment, the movie industry at that time was under the moral guidelines of the motion picture production code.
[26:44] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[26:44] Susan Blackwell: It had been created in 1930, but they really started enforcing it in 1934.
[26:51] Laura Camien: Also known as the Hayes Code.
[26:53] Susan Blackwell: It spells out what was acceptable content for motion pictures. And it was really brought about in reaction to some of Hollywood's scandals, like the murder of William Desmond Taylor, Sparks, the alleged rape of Virginia rep by Fatty Arbuckle, Sparks.
[27:10] Laura Camien: Spark.
[27:23] Susan Blackwell: Which frankly they felt had always been morally questionable. Remember that spark when I uh Patricia Douglas when I talked about like Hollywood was Oh, sure. Yeah, it was basically But for people that didn't listen to that episode. Yeah, that the entire town is a spark. The history of the town of Hollywood, how it was developed from, you know, obviously people who had traveled westward. Um, but that area of town were the artists that people looked at as like lower class, and they built up that entire town.
[27:57] Laura Camien: So from the jump, it was like, you know, artists with moral, you know, questionable morals were running the place.
[28:06] Susan Blackwell: Um it's an awesome uh the history of Hollywood is is really really awesome.
[28:10] Laura Camien: It is rich with sparks, rich with sparks.
[28:12] Susan Blackwell: But then this production code came in to try to like to try to handle it, get some rules around it.
[28:17] Laura Camien: Yes, because they needed people across the country to respect at least the the art that was coming out of Hollywood and spend their money to go see these films.
[28:26] Susan Blackwell: So they could not literally couldn't afford people to write it off as like I don't want to support those people and that trash that they create. So they had to bring back or not bring back, they had to establish a moral code, um, which they did in the 30s, uh, like I said, but they really started enforcing it in 1934.
[28:46] Laura Camien: And the code asserted that you must depict, quote, correct standards of life in movies.
[28:52] Susan Blackwell: You could not wrongly influence those with susceptible minds. Suffice to say, these audiences were not loving our feisty feminist and her forward thinking independence.
[29:03] Laura Camien: Interesting. I always think of the production code about like if there's a scene that takes place in a bedroom on a bed, everybody in the scene has to keep one foot on the floor.
[29:13] Susan Blackwell: That was in the production code. Yeah, like there were all those rules that they had in place to try to just keep the Hayes Code is a spark in and of itself to like really understand obviously, nothing to do with homosexuality, but even like traditional um gender roles needed to be enforced.
[29:34] Susan Blackwell: So when you think about it in this context, it's easy to see why Katherine was maybe not connecting with audiences. She was too brisk, too bossy, too opinionated. According to Film School Rejects, in 1938, she was declared to be Hollywood's most baffling question mark. She was deeply private and abrasive with the press. Like she rarely agreed to be photographed and wouldn't do interviews. Hollywood's most baffling question mark is an amazing phrase, headline, t-shirt, stitch it on a. She's mysterious. But it was very troubling to them. Hollywood's most baffling question mark. I love that. Because who is she? And can we trust her? Like it's essentially because she's wearing pants. I'm suspicious of this.
How interesting. But she also wouldn't do interviews, so she wouldn't clear anything up. She was mysterious. And aloof. She was called Catherine of Arrogance in the media. A modern screen article called her the most maligned woman in Hollywood. Like it gets darker and it gets worse. God. So 1938 was a terrible year. It all came to a head when the independent theater owners of America released a list of actors they believed to be box office poison.
[31:03] Laura Camien: Okay. Box office poison. I also brushed up against this in my research. I didn't realize I thought that was just a phrase. Like, oh, like a casual colloquial phrase.
[31:14] Susan Blackwell: And it's actually a thing.
[31:16] Laura Camien: It's a thing. But before we get into it, the inter the what was it? The independent independent theater owners of America. They took out an ad.
[31:23] Susan Blackwell: They took out an ad to tell the world these people are box office poison.
[31:30] Laura Camien: Am I wrong that the independent theater owners of America were the same people that they were being hosted at that Patricia Douglas party?
[31:38] Susan Blackwell: That is correct. A memory.
[31:40] Laura Camien: That is correct. The theater owners across the country. And no one was more powerful than them because they would decide whether it's a good idea.
[31:49] Susan Blackwell: I am not feeling them.
[31:50] Laura Camien: You're not loving them.
[31:51] Susan Blackwell: I'm not loving them with a Patricia Douglas situation, and I'm not loving them with this sort of like, we don't understand it. It's box office poison.
[32:00] Laura Camien: Oh, yes, but I think there was actually a darker intent behind it.
[32:06] Susan Blackwell: I did not go far enough. Like, again, this is another spark. Someone could really, really dig into box office poison. Interesting.
[32:14] Laura Camien: Because number one, I was fascinated that it was an ad. Why do you take out an ad to say these people suck? That's a hit job. I mean, it really is. Now an interesting use of your energy and your capacity and your money and your power.
[32:28] Susan Blackwell: That's right. Listen to who else was on the list, though. So Katherine Hepburn, Joan Crawford, Greta Garbo.
[32:36] Laura Camien: Oh really interesting that these are all very strong women who played non-traditional roles.
[32:42] Susan Blackwell: I don't think it's a coincidence.
[32:44] Laura Camien: I agree. So they claimed in this ad that then like went everywhere and news stories picked it up and she could not get away from box office poison. The ad claimed that these actors were a burden to studios because their salaries were super high, but they had no box office draw.
[33:04] Susan Blackwell: So is this about this is about it? It's about money, but I think it's also about this heteronormative bullshit.
[33:11] Laura Camien: That's right. I fucking I don't like these people.
[33:15] Susan Blackwell: These what it say their names again?
[33:17] Laura Camien: The independent theater owners of America.
[33:19] Susan Blackwell: The independent theater owners of America. I have not heard anything great yet about them.
[33:26] Laura Camien: Maybe we could try, I could try to do like a positive spark about them because they keep showing up in negative ways.
[33:32] Susan Blackwell: But I don't know. I could dig in further and see maybe they did something good.
[33:37] Laura Camien: You gotta imagine there's a lot of them. So that's you know, this is a good idea. There could be a few bad apples in there.
[33:45] Susan Blackwell: But those bad apples were bad. So the thing was though, they this claim that these actors were box office poison because their salaries were high, but they had no box office draw. What happened was the consequences. So here's Katherine. She's getting literally beat about in the press. But beyond that, thanks to being on that list, RKO Studios and others began to offer lower salaries, lower than the salary she'd been paid when she just started out as an actress.
[34:23] Laura Camien: She's an Academy Award-winning actress at this point.
[34:26] Susan Blackwell: Oh my gosh. Downgraded. Literally like a quarter of her salary.
[34:33] Laura Camien: Wow.
[34:34] Susan Blackwell: So um, and also if you know Katherine, there's plenty of information about like she's very proud of the fact that yes, she came from privilege, but then she made her own money. These theater owners, this was a hit job. They were trying to take her out. 100%. And so they took a big swing and it worked. It's June of 1938. Katherine Hepburn is 31 years old and she's obsessed with her failure.
[34:59] Laura Camien: Oh.
[35:00] Susan Blackwell: She has hit a low. She's not getting any offers of work. The ones she she is getting are not. Like I said, a quarter of the salary. She's being humiliated in the press, and now it was hitting her wallet. Which is where I think she drew the line. Like this is bullshit.
[35:17] Laura Camien: So bullshit.
[35:21] Susan Blackwell: Thanks, Katherine. So honestly, this is the pivotal moment. Like she could have taken a break. She could have slinked away. Like you win. I'm terrible. I suck. No one likes me, clearly. This is an interesting, like perceived failure, right?
[35:38] Laura Camien: What yeah.
[35:38] Susan Blackwell: I mean, we talk so much and to so many people who are like, what if people don't like me? What if people come for me? What if people say mean things? What if they say things like I suck? But then what if you're talking about the same thing? So this is an interesting case study.
[35:55] Laura Camien: Oh my God. Yes.
[35:57] Susan Blackwell: Okay, so here's what Katherine did.
[35:59] Laura Camien: What does she do?
[36:00] Susan Blackwell: So she goes home to her parents' summer home in Connecticut. Of course, I know, even saying that. She goes to the summer. Well, I mean, it's a privilege to say I've got somewhere to go to just chill out for a bit out. So she's nursing her wounds and considering her next steps. As she once famously said, as one goes through life, one learns that if you don't paddle your own canoe, you don't move.
[36:23] Laura Camien: You don't move.
[36:24] Susan Blackwell: Thank you. Thanks. I knew I was like, let me just tee that up. Paddle your own canoe.
[36:32] Laura Camien: Oh, you don't move.
[36:34] Susan Blackwell: No shame in a sandwich. Sorry. Sorry. Sorry. So she gets in touch with her friend Philip Barry, a playwright who has written a role for her. With her he's written a role with her in mind. They meet and they discuss The Philadelphia Story. And for those of you who haven't seen it or need a refresher, The Philadelphia Story is about a wealthy socialite named Tracy Lord, played by Katherine Hepburn, who learns the truth about herself when her ex-husband and a tabloid reporter show up the day before her wedding to a self-made millionaire.
[37:09] Laura Camien: Here's the genius thing. As Katherine and Philip worked on the script for The Philadelphia Story, it's as if they were literally guided by the complaints audiences had of her.
[37:22] Susan Blackwell: Oh that's right. They made the character haughty, full of herself. Oh on a pedestal, too good for her own good, all of it. And then they let the audiences see that people take her down a notch. They show her vulnerability. My she reconnects with her side. All of it leads to her line, and you can do it after I say it.
[37:52] Laura Camien: Okay.
[37:53] Susan Blackwell: I don't want to be worshipped.
[37:55] Laura Camien: I don't want to be worshipped.
[37:56] Susan Blackwell: I want to be loved.
[37:58] Laura Camien: I want to be loved.
[38:00] Susan Blackwell: That's right. Thank you, Susan. I don't want to be worshipped. I want to be loved.
[38:06] Laura Camien: Oh boy. This gives me chills.
[38:09] Susan Blackwell: This is us. This is like a key turning to understand the whole movie, The Philadelphia Story.
[38:15] Laura Camien: It is. And it's also part of that lesson of can we use what we perceive to be our weaknesses as our strengths? Can we turn things on its head, what people are saying about us and make art out of it? Can we lean into it? Interesting.
[38:33] Susan Blackwell: So it's as if she was toying with people. You need to see that I'm human. You need to be reminded that I am a person who wants to be loved just like everyone else. You need to see a man cut me down to size. Here it is. Wow. It's ridiculous that it was needed for sure. But she was so smart to see it and deliver it. Afterwards, like newspapers wrote, All is forgiven, Katherine. We'll take you back.
[39:03] Laura Camien: Yes.
[39:04] Susan Blackwell: Yes. What an amazing tactical pivot. Okay, but I forgot. So a few more things. Yeah. It's an incredible, in fucking incredible pivot. The strategy around this is bananas. But it wasn't easy to do in order for the show. So it was a play first, in order for it to go to Broadway, she had to pay for it herself. She financed the production. Funded it. And the play was a huge success. So for anybody who's like, I don't know about producing my own work. Oh my gosh. Katherine Hepburn had to do it.
[39:21] Laura Camien: Oh my gosh.
[39:21] Susan Blackwell: So it was a huge success. And of course, Hollywood took notice. And there was interest in making a film. But if you can believe it, they were not interested in casting Katherine.
[39:52] Laura Camien: Are you kidding?
[39:54] Susan Blackwell: For the role that was written for her.
[39:57] Laura Camien: Well, that does happen.
[39:58] Susan Blackwell: No joke. Yeah. But Broadway cast, but it doesn't always transfer.
[40:02] Laura Camien: No, but role written for her and paid for by her. Amazing.
[40:06] Susan Blackwell: Right. And so she's, I'm assuming, like uh owned the rights.
[40:11] Laura Camien: No, not the film rights.
[40:13] Susan Blackwell: She didn't own the film rights.
[40:15] Laura Camien: Oh.
[40:16] Susan Blackwell: So she decides she has to buy the film rights for herself.
[40:21] Laura Camien: Yeah, no shit.
[40:22] Susan Blackwell: But she spent a lot of money getting the Broadway show up.
[40:26] Laura Camien: Sure.
[40:26] Susan Blackwell: Right. So lucky for her, she was dating Howard Hughes at the time.
[40:32] Laura Camien: Sure.
[40:33] Susan Blackwell: So Howard bought the rights for her for $30,000. Later, she supposedly told biographer Charlotte Chandler, I slept with Howard Hughes to get The Philadelphia Story. He was a brilliant man. And going to bed with him was very pleasurable. But the pleasure of owning The Philadelphia Story lasted longer.
[40:57] Laura Camien: Thanks, Howard.
[40:59] Susan Blackwell: I haven't heard I think I feel like that's some PR spin. I feel like I haven't heard great things about sleeping with Howard Hughes, but Yeah.
[41:05] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[41:06] Susan Blackwell: And also she dated him a lot longer than that. So I think that's I think that's just a snappy story.
[41:12] Laura Camien: She did.
[41:13] Susan Blackwell: Um, but I think she was using him to yes.
[41:16] Laura Camien: Okay. I mean, it depends on if you're gonna tell a story. Does John Ford play into your story?
[41:22] Susan Blackwell: No. I think she said sparks on sparks. Because there's a whole list of men she supposedly had affairs with. Sure. You know. Um, okay. So she got the rights, thanks to her friend Howard. She got the film rights to The Philadelphia Story, and then she shopped those rights around to studios, and although she could have gotten in a higher price, she sold to the one that would give her something more valuable control.
[41:51] Laura Camien: She sold to MGM for $250,000, including the veto power for the cast, the screenwriter, the producer, and the director.
[42:03] Susan Blackwell: And that was effing huge. So she basically constructed the film version of The Philadelphia Story that she wanted.
[42:11] Laura Camien: She packaged it essentially.
[42:13] Susan Blackwell: Correct. That is correct. That was Jimmy Stewart. And Cary Grant were not her first choices.
[42:20] Laura Camien: They were each her second choice.
[42:21] Susan Blackwell: Oh. She wanted Spencer Tracy for Jimmy Stewart's role. And she wanted Clark Gable for Cary Grant's role.
[42:30] Laura Camien: Really?
[42:31] Susan Blackwell: But they weren't available. And so she was quite happy, obviously, with Cary Grant and Jimmy Stewart. But and Jimmy Stewart ended up winning an Academy Award for his role. Maybe one of the best drunken scenes ever.
[42:44] Laura Camien: He's a really great drunk.
[42:46] Susan Blackwell: Um, there's a scene in there that I I was like, Jimmy Stewart, you don't really get to see him in a role like this very often.
[42:53] Laura Camien: Interesting.
[42:54] Susan Blackwell: So she packaged it all up. She packaged it all up thanks to this enormous risk that she was willing to take. And it was a bet that she took on herself. Bet on yourself, but thankfully she did because she went on to win three more Oscars. She gave us The African Queen, The Lion in Winter, On Golden Pond, Long Day's Journey into Night, and Guess Who's Coming to Dinner, among other things.
[43:19] Laura Camien: Wow.
[43:20] Susan Blackwell: According to Film School Rejects, she once said, without The Philadelphia Story and Phil and Howard, my life would have been very different. It would have gone on, but maybe my career wouldn't have.
[43:32] Laura Camien: Wow.
[43:33] Susan Blackwell: Ultimately, Katherine Hepburn took control of her situation as she always advocated for, and she rewrote the ending of her own story. I was really, really sparked by hearing that story of like self-determined turnaround in the midst of her harshest criticism. And I will add this like seeing headlines like Hepburn deserved that slapping in reference to the hard hits that she took in the press.
[44:00] Laura Camien: There's meant to humble the first shot of the movie.
[44:04] Susan Blackwell: It's the first shot of the movie, she's pushed by her face onto the ground.
[44:08] Laura Camien: That's right. And they talk about her being slapped around or women being slapped around. And this is all about that moment in time where women were taking a step forward.
[44:20] Laura Camien: And literally the whole world, entire culture was like, sit your ass back down.
[44:26] Susan Blackwell: Wow.
[44:27] Laura Camien: Or we will push you back down. But it's so interesting that she, in order to make this pivot, was like the first thing that you'll see in this film.
[44:35] Susan Blackwell: Before I mean the first thing you'll see in this film is me getting comeuppance.
[44:39] Laura Camien: That's right.
[44:40] Susan Blackwell: Physically.
[44:41] Laura Camien: Absolutely right. And then emotionally. That was one of the challenges for me watching this film.
[44:46] Susan Blackwell: I watched it for the first time. And I was like, the first shot of the film is her getting pushed to the ground from a vase palm.
[44:53] Laura Camien: And this is a comedy.
[44:54] Susan Blackwell: And this is a comedy. And I was like, oh no, I don't know how this has aged.
[44:59] Laura Camien: It's fascinating to know that she was strategically driving that because she knew that's what the people wanted.
[45:08] Susan Blackwell: That's exactly right. And the way that they will sit through a film with Katherine Hepburn in this moment is to see, like, oh, she's gonna get what's coming.
[45:18] Laura Camien: Cammy. This spark has helped me to understand this movie. And uh it's that thing where you cannot finally appreciate something because you have all the context around it, especially something that is um maybe not of this time, whether it's Shakespeare or The Philadelphia Story.
[45:37] Susan Blackwell: Yeah, sometimes I need that context. I'm so glad that I dug in a little further because I also was like first very first impression was are we gonna joke about domestic violence? I'm not, I'm not I'm not here for it.
[45:51] Laura Camien: And then um this changed a lot of it. So she has her fat on its side.
[45:57] Susan Blackwell: Um so it all obviously like meant it was meant to humble her, and it feels like misogyny to me. Like all of these women were trying to live authentically in a world that literally would not allow them to be themselves.
[46:10] Laura Camien: Wow. I think she created a persona that helped her cope with the traumas in her childhood and also helped protect her from the forces that frankly would have eaten her alive otherwise.
[46:23] Susan Blackwell: Remember that homosexuality was a perversion and illegal at this time. Remember that no woman, like no one liked a woman who spoke her mind. No one thought like they were even meant to have opinions.
[46:39] Laura Camien: She wasn't even playing the game, like she challenged the gender rules at every turn. In the end, she said, I have not lived as a woman, I have lived as a man, I've done just what I damn well wanted to.
[46:52] Susan Blackwell: And I've made enough money to support myself, and I ain't afraid of being alone.
[46:58] Laura Camien: Wow. So I think we know like what I didn't get into in this spark is she did live a duplicitous life. Like we'll never know the facts about her personal life, her loves, but we know that she was a mix of paradoxes.
[47:12] Susan Blackwell: Like she embodied the most sought after strengths of modern women. And then she habitually got into relationships with broken men who she had to save, or kept hidden relationships of, you know, with people she truly loved.
[47:27] Laura Camien: And like perhaps this all had to do with like her inability to save her brother. And she once said, everyone thought I was bold and fearless and even arrogant.
[47:41] Susan Blackwell: But inside, I was always quaking.
[47:45] Laura Camien: And I just like that just struck me. This like tough outer shell, this soft, vulnerable inside.
[47:51] Laura Camien: It's not so far off from I don't want to be worshipped. I want to be loved. Wow. And don't we all, Catherine? Don't we all? That was a wonderful spot. Thanks, Zeus. That was really helpful. Awesome. I'm so glad. I was just because I was uh, you know, we'll get into it in a second. But like, like sometimes the older films challenging. Yeah. But they are of a different time, and it's helpful to know what was going on. And in this particular case, you see, like she was actually challenging those ideas. You know, like then the reviews of the Philadelphia story. Yes, some of them were like, you know, welcome back, Catherine. And some of them were able to analyze um what she was doing and saying, like how eventually they were able to see like how she turned around this criticism of herself, this high and mighty.
But then, you know, then that what follows from that is the question of like, why did we need to tear her down? Yeah, but I feel like I was gonna say that was the time, but I think this is still happening. We're still fighting. We're still we're still here. We're still here. Um, I agree. And I it makes me love and respect those women who began the battle, frankly. We're still we may still be fighting it and and trying to earn our ability to live authentic lives. Yeah. But uh, I don't know that everyone always gets credit. You know, the people who were willing to fight it before uh, you know, before wearing pants was legal. Oh, what's her name? Who was helping, you know, Emma Snodgrass, Emma Snodgrass getting arrested, paving the way.
That's right. We stand on her panted shoulders. Cam, great spark. Thanks. Should we take a little break? Let's do it. And then we'll s we'll re-spark this spark phone. Awesome. Spark and we're back. Cam's, that was such a good spark. Thank you. It really did unlock an understanding for me that helps me to enjoy that film more. Good. Yeah. I'm so glad.
[50:01] Susan Blackwell: But at least that to me, knowing that she was conscious of those choices and made them very specifically. I mean, I hate that she had to, but um, it was very smart and when I hear that I'm like, ooh, what a smart chess player, right? Um, the other fun thing is that as you were speaking, your spark obviously bumps into my spark in so many interesting ways. My spark tagline today is if I had to do it over again, I'd probably do it over again.
[50:35] Laura Camien: Oh.
[50:35] Susan Blackwell: So as we said at the top, we set this challenge for ourselves in order to celebrate this live podcast we were doing at the United Palace featuring a live interview with Kelly O'Hara. That will precede a screening of the film The Philadelphia Story. We thought, let's see if we can rock creativity sparks in some way, shape, or form that are derived from The Philadelphia Story, even if that spark has traveled a distance. You know, I'm always down to clown, I'm always down to try shit. And we say sparks are everywhere. But I was also like, uh-oh, because that golden age of Hollywood stuff on the surface isn't totally for me. Due respect to people who love old Hollywood. To me, some of that imagery is beautiful, but sometimes the acting feels dated. The timing, like literally, the timing feels dated. The comedy for that reason rarely surprises me. And it's rare for me to be drawn to those stars.
[51:29] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[51:29] Susan Blackwell: And we've lived long enough and we've investigated enough to know that the system was really a system. In the 40s and the 50s, the studios would carefully manicure the images of their stars and fiercely guarded those stars' private lives. And the sparks that we've mentioned in your spark, the sparks we've done on people like Patricia Douglas and Hedy Lamarr showed us how Hollywood was just selling us that perfect image and covering up or discarding anything that wasn't that image.
[52:00] Laura Camien: That is correct.
[52:01] Susan Blackwell: And if I'm honest, I'm just I'm not buying what that system was slash is selling, like the glitz and the glamour and the imagery and the story. The Oscars were just on, and I was just like, I like looking sometimes at the pictures of the people. I like looking at the dresses, the creativity, the creativity, the costume design, and you know, which they essentially are for a night like that.
[52:26] Laura Camien: Yeah, yeah.
[52:27] Susan Blackwell: But sometimes just all the other um surface bullshit.
[52:33] Laura Camien: I hear that.
[52:34] Susan Blackwell: And I, you know, we've talked about how like my fascination lies in exactly that. The PR people were storytelling. The outside yes what it looks like on the outside and what's actually going on on the inside absolutely and I also look at like you the acting styles um the stories all of it it is on a continuum all of it is you know where we are now is only where we are now because of where we were then so I like to look at it as uh an evolution yeah and why that's why your spark is so helpful to me because it gives some context contextualizes it.
[53:10] Susan Blackwell: So as I've said on this podcast before I think I've said this my writing teacher Linda Barry used to say that movie and TV stars and gossip magazines are like dollies for grown-ups. When you're little you play with your dollies you're like I love you I kiss you now I hate you. Now I kiss another dolly. And once you're grown up you can still play with your dollies but now it's like Dolly Brad and Dolly Jennifer we're in love. Now we're out of love. Now we're fighting now Dolly Brad likes another dolly named Angelina that's the way I think a slight not all the media but a slice of the media portrays these people and their lives as if they are not real whole authentic people but as if they are dollies who are perfectly perfect and beautiful and being portrayed in these scenarios for our enjoyment.
That's crap. But this kind of spin and storytelling has been going on in Hollywood for years and I again I'm just not really buying any of it. It's just money making so old Hollywood can be a little bit of a turnoff for me.
[54:09] Laura Camien: But as we were just discussing you know Camps and you sweet sparklers you know that I am obsessed with what it looks like on the outside versus what's actually going on on the inside. And for that reason, I knew if I was going to be truly sparked by something related to The Philadelphia Story, I was going to have to dig deeper and get to something real. So I started to dig a little, and it didn't take long before I landed on the director of The Philadelphia Story, George Cukor. Now, George was a mammoth Hollywood director. In addition to The Philadelphia Story, which was a major hit, he directed Little Women that you just spoke about, starring Katherine Hepburn. That's right. A movie, a wonderful movie that I think actually does a pretty good job of holding up, called Born Yesterday, My Fair Lady, A Star Is Born, not Lady Gaga, Judy Garland, the movie Gaslight, which is why we all use the phrase gaslighting, and um parts of Gone with the Wind, just parts because George Cukor was fired in the early stages of production of Gone with the Wind, but a few of his scenes still remain in the finished film.
[55:13] Susan Blackwell: But why you ask was a world-class film director like George Cukor fired from Gone with the Wind? This is a piece in the Los Angeles Times by Greg Kilday. This is a review of a book that came out in 1991. And what is sure to be its most discussed revelation, Patrick McGilligan reports in his penetrating new biography, George Cukor: A Double Life, that Cukor was fired from Gone with the Wind, the most famous movie ever made, because its star, Clark Gable, exploded on the set. "I won't be directed by a fairy. I have to work with a real man." The story had long circulated within Cukor's social circle that as a young man, Clark Gable was once had a drunken sexual encounter with a silent screen actor turned decorator named William Haynes, one of Cukor's pals, when another of Cukor's intimates began indiscreetly joking that George is directing one of Billy's old tricks, referring to Gable. Gable, who already feared that Cukor might tilt the movie in favor of Vivien Leigh, flew into a rage. So that is from this famous uh biography of George Cukor.
[56:24] Susan Blackwell: So then I started to get really sparked because it felt like shit was getting real, really real. So let's get real, Sparklers. Trigger warning, aka T W A K A T Dubs. I'm going to warn you now, the spark refers to a lot of sex, and some of it is quite graphic. This spark is not safe for work unless you work somewhere really sex positive. And I don't think it's for kids. T Dubs concluded. Sources for my spark include an article in the Hollywood Reporter written by Gary Baum and Chris Gardner, a piece in the Los Angeles Times by Greg Kilday, the Twitter account at Scotty Bowers, an article from the New York Times by Neil Genslinger, a YouTube video posted by Boy Culture, a build series interview conducted by Ethan Alter, the Home Ophelia podcast, and a documentary called Scotty and the Secret History of Hollywood.
[57:18] Laura Camien: Yes.
[57:18] Susan Blackwell: So back to George Cukor. I followed that George Cukor spark from The Philadelphia Story all the way to the corner of Hollywood and Van Ness in Los Angeles, California. At Hollywood and Van Ness, there used to be a service station, the Richfield Oil Station. It's not there now. It's a fire station now. Camps, you have a twinkle in your eye. I know. Do you know where I'm headed? Okay, good. But that doesn't matter. Take the ride. When it was the Richfield Oil Station, there was a guy working as the manager there. And that guy's name was Scotty Bowers.
[57:54] Laura Camien: A bit about Scotty Bowers.
[57:56] Susan Blackwell: George Albert Scotty Bowers was born on July 1st, 1923, in Ottawa, Illinois. He grew up on his family's farm and they weathered the Great Depression in Chicago during the 30s. He said there wasn't a lot of food, but Scotty had a hustle going. Among other things, he'd shine shoes and sell newspapers. He said, I had to sell 10 Chicago tribunes to make a penny in the street. He was also, even at a very young age, doing sex work. When he was old enough, Bowers joined the Marine Corps and fought during World War II for several tours of duty. During the war, Scotty was devastated by the loss of his big brother, who was two years older than him, and by several close friends. And in Matt Turnour's documentary, Scotty and the Secret History of Hollywood, Scotty talks about still in his 90s being haunted by his recollections of the war.
I'm not a doctor, but just by observing him, I would say that Scotty lived through the rest of his life after the war with PTSD. Um he said he thought about the war at night for decades, but Scotty didn't believe in therapy.
[59:02] Susan Blackwell: So there you go.
[59:04] Laura Camien: Um, which just sidebar, side spark. If you have PTSD, there are fantastic, efficient ways. Um it's hard work, but there are ways of working through that so that you can be free of those sort of, you know, night terrors, things like that. Just wanted to have said that. It's another spark, literally for another day, but I wanted to have said that. There are resources out there that can um help you.
[59:33] Susan Blackwell: So upon returning from combat in 1946, Scotty relocated, upgraded, he said, from San Diego to Los Angeles. He was a handsome 23-year-old, and he quickly found work as a gas station attendant. On one of his first days at the gas station, Scotty met an actor named Walter Pigeon. Walter Pigeon was this sort of like, he was one of those grand mustached, sort of older classical actors. He was known for his work on Mrs. Miniver and Madame Curie. Walter Pigeon invited Scotty to take a ride in his car and take a dip in his swimming pool, which Scotty did. The ride, which Bowers said led to paid sex between the men, he made 20 bucks, would change Bowers' life as it kickstarted a side career arranging sexual hookups for people.
According to Scotty, Walter Pigeon spread the word about Scotty's sexual services. And soon other notable Hollywood figures were stopping by the station for sex with Scotty and to be set up with Scotty's growing network of sex workers, both men and women. And he was running this whole business out of the Ridgefield Oil Service Station.
[1:00:40] Laura Camien: To be clear, he was also, he was working double-time. He was the manager of the gas station while also working as a sex worker and acting as something of a male madam. But the gas station seemed like kind of a brilliant place to do it because it was centrally located in this busy hopping location. The streetcar went right by and stopped and dropped people off. Scotty said there was always like a line of cars out of the station. And because it was a gas station, he Scotty was also meeting everyone from every strata of life in Hollywood, from people like George Cukor and other Hollywood stars to the Marines turned gas station attendants, turned sex workers who worked at the service station. So these young men were like coming home from the war looking for work, and some of them landed at the service station.
[1:01:30] Susan Blackwell: Speaking of, in 1947, director of The Philadelphia Story, George Cukor, had just bought a Dodge sedan. And he came into Scotty's gas station and introduced himself to Scotty and said, "It's kind of warm today. Would you like to come up to my place and take a dip in the pool?" And then Scotty ended up at George Cukor's pool, where he said he stayed for years, providing the director with sexual services as well as other sex workers. Plus, Scotty did landscaping, shopping, and other personal assistant type work. Documentary filmmaker Matt Tyrnauer said of Scotty's relationship with Cukor, "When you had to live your life in the shadows, like Cukor, who was gay, but were also prominent, imagine how important someone who could be trusted in all aspects, including the secret aspects of your life, could be."
[1:02:20] Laura Camien: So in order to keep up with the demand at the station, Scotty also started to invite clients into a trailer that was parked behind the service station. The trailer had a central entrance, if you can picture it, like so picture an RV, and it had an entrance in the center of the RV, which Scotty had sectioned off. So there was a king-sized bed curtained off on one end of the trailer, and another king-sized bed curtained off on the other end of the trailer so it could accommodate two sets of people having sex. And there was the washroom. People could be having sex in the washroom. And then Scotty also drilled a peephole in the bathroom, like above the toilet paper dispenser, so that other folks could watch the folks having sex in the washroom.
So he had like a whole, and everything was like $20 a pop. $20 a pop, $20 a pop. He had this whole business going. He was effectively running a full-on brothel out of this very clean, white, pristine service station in the middle of this crazy busy, bustling intersection. And in the film, Scotty gives a little tour of one of his homes, and he says how essentially he earned the money to buy it $20 at a time. Wow. He said those $20 added up fast.
[1:03:35] Susan Blackwell: So in the documentary, Scotty and the Secret Life of Hollywood, his wife describes Scotty as sort of this, by the time she met him, he was like this little twinkly old leprechaun. But as fun and sex positive as Scotty makes all of this seem, there were some serious risks involved in the work he was doing as a younger man. All of the risks normally associated with sex work, but there were other significant risks in addition to those risks. As the director, Doton Briggle, put it in an interview with ABC News in 1999, "Homosexuality was against the law, and they could walk right into your house, right into your very bedroom and arrest you for it." So there was a great fear of that hanging over all of the people, I think, in those days who were gay living in Hollywood and working in Hollywood.
[1:04:21] Laura Camien: For sure. For sure. That was an extreme fear. Extreme fear. Like you're just living trying if you it's we'll get into it. So in a post-screening talk back after the documentary Scotty and the Secret History of Hollywood, Scotty Bowers said, "If word got around that you were gay, you could lose your job." Unless you were, say, a bartender at a gay club. If there was word that you were gay, even if they hadn't seen you do it, you could lose your job. Think about that. Your livelihood. And the documentary points out that there were far worse consequences. You could be institutionalized, you could even be lobotomized. That's right. And this was when the LAPD vice squad was very active, looking to round people up and arrest them for essentially being themselves.
[1:05:08] Susan Blackwell: Which leads me to the next risk: the vice squads. According to Scotty, the Hollywood Vice Squad was essentially an extortion ring. And the police were in on it. There was an attorney named Harry Weiss, whom Scotty knew. And Harry showed Scotty how he would arrange to bring these vice cases in front of a judge that he knew and then pay off the arresting, like out in the hallway, pay off the arresting officers to not appear in court so that the case would be dismissed. And according to Scotty, 10 cases would be dismissed within an hour. It was essentially an extortion ring that would shake down the Douglas innocent people. They had a whole system at gay bars.
[1:05:47] Laura Camien: Yes, the system was a system. The system was a system. Right.
[1:05:56] Susan Blackwell: So exactly. So in the post-documentary screening talk back posted by Boy Culture on YouTube, filmmaker Matt Tyrnauer said that there was a dark rumor that went like this. Attorney Harry Weiss actually owned a string of gay bars. And it was rumored that Harry Weiss would tip off the vice squad to raid his own gay bars so that he could then approach those people who had been arrested whose lives were hanging in the balance and offer to get them off so that they would then have to pay him for his legal services. What an evil man. So he was essentially taking their money, allegedly, taking their money for drinks, then imperiling their lives, and then being paid on the other end to save their lives. So how about that for a Hollywood dark spark for you? How about that?
[1:06:44] Laura Camien: Um during that same talk back after a showing of the documentary, Scotty Bowers told a story about how the Vice Squad would try to muscle in sometimes at the service station. They would like come sniffing around. And apparently a motorcycle cop named Cal lived in a rooming house about a half block up from the gas station, and he would come in every night after his shift at work, and he would polish his bike and keep it all maintained. And if the vice squad would come in and start asking what was going on, Scotty would tell them, "Cal's a cop, ask him." Yeah, so he had a little bit of a built-in protection.
[1:07:21] Susan Blackwell: Scotty also told a story about a time when the trailer was in use, the washroom was in use, and there was no room at the inn. So Scotty, who was an amazing businessman and entrepreneur, he put a couple that wanted to have sex, he put them in a car and lifted it up on the grease rack. Oh my god. So they were up above that's where you lift it up so you can get under the car. They were up above having sex while Cal, the LAPD motorcycle cop, was down on the ground servicing his bike. Way Scotty, I feel like inferred that Cal didn't know.
[1:07:56] Laura Camien: Uh-huh.
[1:07:56] Susan Blackwell: So maybe Cal did know and maybe Cal didn't know. Or Cal was oblivious.
[1:08:00] Laura Camien: Or maybe Cal was oblivious. Wow.
[1:08:02] Susan Blackwell: Um, so to recap the risks, being gay was considered a crime. The Vice Squad was circling and allegedly very corrupt. Another risk, the Hollywood studios, especially in this so-called golden age, were desperately afraid to project anything other than a heteronormative middle America friendly image. So these stars all had morality clauses in their contracts. So if they were gay and if they lived as their authentic selves, they could, as we know, be arrested, but they could also lose their contracts, their livelihood, their star status. This led to things like sham marriages.
[1:08:39] Laura Camien: That's right. So many sham marriages. For instance, uh, one of the most famous cases of this is when Rock Hudson, who was a quintessential leading man was in his 30s. Fans in like fan magazines were like, "It's time for Rock to be married." They were demanding that their, yep. And so, in short order, Rock was married to his agent's assistant, who was a lesbian to satisfy the fans. This is what I'm talking about. It's dollies for grown-ups. And if you're like Rock Hudson, Dolly needs to kiss a lady dolly, then the fans demand it, and then that happens. For those of you who don't know Rock Hudson, he was actually gay. But to live and work in that Hollywood system, he kept the secret until he died of AIDS-related complications in 1985.
[1:09:25] Susan Blackwell: Oh. Yeah. He's another spark. He's another spark. An amazing spark. And what a beautiful human being. Um, another related risk, the tabloids. Magazines like Confidential would come to somebody. They'd come with a complete story, and all you'd have to do to make money is sign off on the story. Scotty Bowers said on three occasions he was brought stories that he knew to be true, and he was offered $1,000 if he'd sign. But Scotty never signed because he knew that it would mean trouble. And it's so interesting to me that there were so many people that did make money. Harry Weiss, that's right. Remember Patricia Douglas's attorney, like that they would take the money, but Scotty never signed. It's so like interesting because capitalism, the world that we live in, like when you look at everything through that lens, anytime you make something illegal, you are creating a black market for money to be made. Because if you couldn't be um uh what's the word for it? Um bought.
[1:10:31] Laura Camien: Bought, but um bought off blackmail.
[1:10:36] Susan Blackwell: Um same thing happened with like when liquor when they tried to with prohibition. And people like Harry Weiss are like, "Great. What I see is opportunity." Yeah, here's a small business idea. That's right. Yeah. It's so interesting to me though, because Scotty is this sex worker and he's the one. I don't want to, you know, lionize him, but he's the one that's like, because it could be argued the reason why he didn't take the money is because, well, I'd make money in the short term, but in the long term, if it got out that I wasn't trustworthy, then that income stream would dry up. It's not necessarily like, "Oh, what a good guy. He would never tell." It's maybe smart guy. He's a smart businessman.
[1:11:17] Laura Camien: Um, so one of the stories that was brought to him by Confidential Magazine that Scotty did not sign off on, did not take the $1,000, was about Katherine Hepburn, whom Scotty had met through director George Cukor. Yeah. Over their 50-year relationship, Scotty alleges he fixed Hepburn up with about 150 women. Everyone thinks Hepburn and Spencer Tracy were an item until they were parted by death. And I think I've knew that since I was little. Like Hepburn and Tracy, Hepburn and Tracy. But it seems, according to Scotty, that was a fiction.
[1:11:52] Susan Blackwell: Yeah. I don't know. Yeah, I think that there's um there's a lot of evidence and obviously a lot of uh conversation about that. The there's two relationships that she had with men that are perplexing that were more um again, they were like alcoholic and broken men that like needed her help for years. John Ford and then Spencer Tracy.
[1:12:15] Laura Camien: Okay.
[1:12:15] Susan Blackwell: I she never lived with them, she never married them. So I wonder like, was that about something else?
[1:12:20] Laura Camien: I think that was about something else.
[1:12:22] Susan Blackwell: Exactly. Exactly. So both Hepburn, depending on who you believe.
[1:12:23] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[1:12:23] Susan Blackwell: Depending on who you believe. Today, I'm believing Scotty Bowers.
[1:12:29] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[1:12:30] Susan Blackwell: Is it possible though? I mean, that she loved them all, that she loved those men and she loved women. And there's evidence of, you know, she left her will to a lot of money to a woman in her life. And a lot of people speculated at that point, like, well, who's this lady now? Interesting.
[1:12:47] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[1:12:48] Susan Blackwell: So many sparks.
[1:12:49] Laura Camien: So many sparks.
[1:12:50] Susan Blackwell: Um, speaking of, both Hepburn and Tracy lived in cottages on the grounds of George Cukor's house, but they weren't a couple, according to Scotty, even though that's how they positioned themselves in the press. And Spencer Tracy would get drunk, have sex with Scotty, and then behave as if he didn't remember it in the morning. Scotty also claims some of the here's some other he claims to have been punched by Lucille Ball at a party because Scotty had been fixing up Desi, her husband, with other women. And Lucille Ball said, "I've been listening on the phone extension line. I know what you've been doing." Pop, right and kiss her. Wow, yeah. Scotty talks in detail about his sexual relations with Cary Grant and Cary Grant's longtime lover, allegedly, Randolph Scott. Basically, Scotty Bowers was either having sex with or providing sexual partners to all the key players in The Philadelphia Story, George Cukor, Cary Grant, Katherine Hepburn.
[1:13:53] Susan Blackwell: There's a spark.
[1:13:54] Laura Camien: He tells about providing, uh, no shame.
[1:13:58] Susan Blackwell: Dress as a woman, Jay Garhoover.
[1:14:00] Laura Camien: No shame except the shame you feel.
[1:14:02] Susan Blackwell: The shame, but the shame of also like what he did to try to annihilate, uh, people.
[1:14:09] Laura Camien: So yeah, yeah.
[1:14:10] Susan Blackwell: Shame, shame on him for that.
[1:14:12] Laura Camien: But never.
[1:14:12] Susan Blackwell: Yeah, yeah.
[1:14:13] Laura Camien: But not for dressing how you want to dress.
[1:14:15] Susan Blackwell: Dress how you want.
[1:14:16] Laura Camien: In fact, dress how you want freely so you don't take it out sideways on other people because you can't handle how you want to dress.
[1:14:25] Susan Blackwell: That's right.
[1:14:26] Laura Camien: I am not a psychologist or a psychiatrist.
[1:14:29] Susan Blackwell: But that's good therapy advice right there.
[1:14:30] Laura Camien: There you go.
[1:14:31] Susan Blackwell: Um, I think you people, when they don't live their authentic lives, that's when trouble brews.
[1:14:37] Laura Camien: It's that's when trouble brews.
[1:14:38] Susan Blackwell: I think they either hurt themselves or they hurt them.
[1:14:40] Laura Camien: They hurt other people.
[1:14:41] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[1:14:41] Laura Camien: Uh, Scotty tells about providing sexual partners for the Duke and Duchess of Windsor.
[1:14:46] Susan Blackwell: I heard about that.
[1:14:47] Laura Camien: So interesting.
[1:14:48] Susan Blackwell: Obviously, all of this information could have rocked the careers of these people, but until he decided to tell his story, Scotty remained discreet for decades.
[1:15:00] Laura Camien: He didn't have a little black book.
[1:15:01] Susan Blackwell: He would either keep it all in his head, and if he did write anything down, he would destroy the paper immediately after the job was done so that the tabloid magazines couldn't dig anything out of his trash.
[1:15:12] Laura Camien: And something I do like about Scotty is that he never judged these people.
[1:15:18] Susan Blackwell: He never had any judgment for these people.
[1:15:21] Laura Camien: Whatever you're people he was having sex with or people he was arranging sex for.
[1:15:26] Susan Blackwell: Um, this leads to a conversation for me as I was watching it about outing people.
[1:15:31] Laura Camien: There's the argument that you don't out people, dead or living.
[1:15:35] Susan Blackwell: People get to choose what remains private.
[1:15:38] Laura Camien: But here's the counter argument.
[1:15:40] Susan Blackwell: When those people are essentially historical figures, figures who have been straightwashed as heterosexual American apple pie, then I think it becomes at the very least an authentic and at the worst, dangerous, outdated propaganda.
[1:15:56] Laura Camien: A hundred percent.
[1:15:57] Susan Blackwell: But are you talking about people who essentially who are not alive anymore who can, uh, choose or not choose at this point?
[1:16:05] Laura Camien: People who can't speak for themselves now.
[1:16:07] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[1:16:07] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[1:16:08] Susan Blackwell: So it's true.
[1:16:09] Laura Camien: I want to just say that it's a tricky, it's a tricky point counterpoint.
[1:16:14] Susan Blackwell: And there's probably more points.
[1:16:15] Laura Camien: Um, documentary Matt Turnour said, LA is consequential because the studios really conspired to create an image that they sent around the world, and it took.
[1:16:24] Susan Blackwell: So this heteronormative idea, this kind of white picket fence, Andy Hardy, meet cute world of Hollywood was foisted on us, and we took it hook, line, and sinker.
[1:16:34] Laura Camien: Question there, and it's just a spark to be looked into later, but how much of that was also dictated by the Hayes Code because these movie studios, um, at a certain point, like they had gotten riskier and riskier with the content of their films.
[1:16:51] Susan Blackwell: And then they were tightening up.
[1:16:53] Laura Camien: Like we're gonna shut that down real quick.
[1:16:55] Susan Blackwell: I think it all, it's all, yeah, woven into the fabric of this.
[1:16:59] Laura Camien: So Matt Tier Nara went on to say, we can't and shouldn't do that anymore, meaning we can't and shouldn't foist that false narrative on people anymore.
[1:17:10] Susan Blackwell: He went on to say there were these moral clauses in the contracts of the movie stars which prevented them from being publicly anything other than straight.
[1:17:18] Laura Camien: We need to know about the straight washing that occurred in the power corridors of our world.
[1:17:23] Susan Blackwell: Cary Grant, for example, is a person of world importance still.
[1:17:26] Laura Camien: There have been many biographies written about Cary Grant.
[1:17:29] Susan Blackwell: So you could argue that a biographer who writes a biography about Cary Grant's several marriages is profiting off the dead as well.
[1:17:37] Laura Camien: Why?
[1:17:37] Susan Blackwell: Just because he had a homosexual relationship or two or three or twelve, does that mean that you're profiteering off of him?
[1:17:43] Laura Camien: That's homophobia, really.
[1:17:45] Susan Blackwell: It's homophobia masked as pearl clutching and shock at anything abnormal happening.
[1:17:50] Laura Camien: And as Scotty says in the movie, what's wrong with being gay?
[1:17:54] Susan Blackwell: So there's sort of like point counterpoint about that.
[1:17:57] Laura Camien: That's correct.
[1:17:58] Susan Blackwell: I was really fascinated by filmmaker Matt Turnauer.
[1:18:01] Laura Camien: I would love to have him as a guest on the smartphone.
[1:18:03] Susan Blackwell: He directed this documentary, Scotty and the Secret History of Hollywood, which you can watch.
[1:18:07] Laura Camien: It's on stars, it's streaming.
[1:18:09] Susan Blackwell: Matt Turnauer grew up in LA.
[1:18:11] Laura Camien: His dad was a producer and a writer on shows like Columbo and Murder She Wrote.
[1:18:15] Susan Blackwell: And he said, the myth of Hollywood is alluring, even for people in the industry.
[1:18:20] Laura Camien: He said, We all buy into it, I think.
[1:18:22] Susan Blackwell: But when he became a journalist and a filmmaker, he said he was always more interested in exploring alternate histories in his work, that there's more to meets the eye perspective.
[1:18:32] Laura Camien: That's right.
[1:18:32] Susan Blackwell: Which you know I love and you love it.
[1:18:35] Laura Camien: Yes.
[1:18:37] Susan Blackwell: Yeah, he said one of the reasons he's passionate about making this film and bringing Scotty's story to as wide an audience as possible was so that generations that succeeded Scotty's generation would understand that there were very difficult times and that people couldn't live their true authentic lives.
[1:18:54] Laura Camien: They had to live in the shadows.
[1:18:56] Susan Blackwell: Um, the documentary shows a psychologist on CBS News declaring homosexuality a mental illness that had reached epidemiological proportions.
[1:19:07] Laura Camien: This was on CBS News.
[1:19:10] Susan Blackwell: What?
[1:19:11] Laura Camien: Yes.
[1:19:11] Susan Blackwell: Holy shit.
[1:19:12] Laura Camien: Gore Vidal, who was a friend of both the filmmaker and the film's principal subject, Scotty Bowers, called it all a heterosexual dictatorship.
[1:19:22] Susan Blackwell: And so Matt Turnauer feels like it's a political film and that it's important political subject matter.
[1:19:27] Laura Camien: Wow.
[1:19:28] Susan Blackwell: He said he first got the spark to make this documentary when he was doing a profile on Merv Griffin for Vanity Fair.
[1:19:35] Laura Camien: Um, Merv Griffin told him, you know, Merv Griffin had a, he had a bit of a double life.
[1:19:41] Susan Blackwell: He was, you know, a very popular talk show host and also, uh, a gay person who wasn't out.
[1:19:48] Laura Camien: And Merv Griffin told the filmmaker Matt Turnauer that there was a gas station in Hollywood where you used to go to get into trouble was the phrase he used.
[1:19:56] Susan Blackwell: And then on a separate occasion, Gore Vidal said, I want to find Scotty.
[1:20:00] Laura Camien: Scotty was my pimp.
[1:20:02] Susan Blackwell: He used to have a gas station.
[1:20:04] Laura Camien: And Matt Turnauer connected, he was like, wait, who's that?
[1:20:07] Susan Blackwell: Is this the same guy Merv Griffin had been talking about?
[1:20:10] Laura Camien: So he found Scotty to say.
[1:20:13] Susan Blackwell: So the next time Matt was visiting Gore Vidal, Scotty was there.
[1:20:17] Laura Camien: What?
[1:20:18] Susan Blackwell: Gore Vidal had met Scotty at the service station in 1947.
[1:20:23] Laura Camien: And then the next time Matt was at Gore's house, Scotty was there.
[1:20:27] Susan Blackwell: And having that mutual friend in Gore Vidal made it possible for Scotty and the director Matt Turnauer to jump in almost immediately with mutual trust.
[1:20:37] Laura Camien: Wow.
[1:20:37] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[1:20:38] Laura Camien: I’m fascinated by that.
[1:20:39] Susan Blackwell: And Scotty was ready to tell his story.
[1:20:42] Laura Camien: And he was ready to talk.
[1:20:44] Susan Blackwell: Scotty is a fascinating subject for a documentary.
[1:20:47] Laura Camien: I think Matt Turnauer really keyed into, he caught a spark.
[1:20:51] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[1:20:52] Laura Camien: Scotty had this knack for keying into a person's type.
[1:20:55] Susan Blackwell: He was sort of like a human algorithm.
[1:20:57] Laura Camien: Like if Tinder was a human being, he described himself as a sexual matchmaker.
[1:21:02] Susan Blackwell: And he was also described as the least starstruck person ever.
[1:21:06] Laura Camien: He did not care for movies.
[1:21:07] Susan Blackwell: He said he had seen three movies in his life.
[1:21:10] Laura Camien: Wow.
[1:21:10] Susan Blackwell: He said he wasn't after anything but working.
[1:21:13] Laura Camien: He was a very hard worker, clearly, and making people happy.
[1:21:17] Susan Blackwell: And all of this made him weirdly well suited for this work that he was doing.
[1:21:23] Laura Camien: On the podcast Homophilia with Dave Holmes and Matt McConkie, documentary filmmaker Matt Turnauer told a story of a man whom Scotty approached in the 1950s at the Easton's gym on Beverly.
[1:21:35] Scotty said to the guy, Do you know Anthony Perkins?
[1:21:38] Laura Camien: And the guy said, No.
[1:21:39] Scotty said, You're just his type.
[1:21:41] Laura Camien: Here's his phone number.
[1:21:42] Scotty said, Give him a call.
[1:21:43] Laura Camien: And within 24 hours, the guy was in the Beverly Wilshire Hotel with Anthony Perkins.
[1:21:47] Susan Blackwell: He was like, had this, he was a matchmaker.
[1:21:50] Laura Camien: Wow.
[1:21:51] Susan Blackwell: But here's an interesting twist.
[1:21:53] Laura Camien: When Scotty matched a client up with a sex worker, he didn't take a cut from the sex worker's earnings.
[1:21:59] Susan Blackwell: He only took money for the sex work that he himself engaged in.
[1:22:03] Laura Camien: Wait.
[1:22:04] Susan Blackwell: So that trailer, when people are in each of those rooms in the trailer, he's not getting any money from the...
[1:22:04] Laura Camien: He may get a little rent.
[1:22:11] Susan Blackwell: He may get a little like room fee.
[1:22:14] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[1:22:14] Susan Blackwell: But he wasn't taking a, he wasn't like if he's, if he introduced this guy to Anthony Perkins, he wasn't like, and you need to give me, you know, a cut of that.
[1:22:24] Laura Camien: Wow.
[1:22:24] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[1:22:25] Laura Camien: He also had to be sure that the person he was lining up was also trustworthy.
[1:22:30] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[1:22:30] Laura Camien: You know.
[1:22:31] Susan Blackwell: But he talked about that.
[1:22:32] Laura Camien: He was like, he knew he, they called him like the mayor of Underground Hollywood.
[1:22:36] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[1:22:37] Laura Camien: Um.
[1:22:39] Susan Blackwell: And none of these secrets came out.
[1:22:41] Laura Camien: So he did a good job.
[1:22:42] Susan Blackwell: He did an amazing job.
[1:22:43] Laura Camien: He also was a good reader of people, it seems like, in terms of who was trustworthy.
[1:22:48] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[1:22:48] Laura Camien: He said, My operation, if you want to call it that, was not a prostitution ring.
[1:22:53] Susan Blackwell: I was simply providing a service to those who wanted it.
[1:22:56] Laura Camien: And as recorded history has shown throughout the ages, there has always been a need for good, old-fashioned, high-quality sex.
[1:23:02] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[1:23:02] Laura Camien: Which leads back to your thing.
[1:23:03] Susan Blackwell: When you make something illegal, it, people, and especially something people want, liquor, sex, gam, whatever it is, people will find a way to get it.
[1:23:12] Laura Camien: The filmmaker described Scotty as something of a visionary.
[1:23:15] Susan Blackwell: Now people are into sexual fluidity and aren't into gender labels or sexuality labels.
[1:23:21] Laura Camien: Scotty is 95, or he was at the time that this was quoted, and he was understanding all of this in the 40s.
[1:23:28] Susan Blackwell: I don't get into it.
[1:23:29] Laura Camien: You need to watch the documentary, but he was studied by Kinsey because he, of his pansexuality and his, I mean, the, this he had a sexual drive.
[1:23:39] Susan Blackwell: I mean, so he was, um, Scotty discreetly arranged sexual partners for stars like, get ready, Cary Grant, Tyrone Power, William Holden, Jay Garhoover, the Duke and Duchess of Windsor, Katherine Hepburn, Charles Lawton, so many others.
[1:23:56] Laura Camien: And for nearly 70 years, he did not speak of these liaisons.
[1:24:00] Susan Blackwell: And then in 2012, he told his version of the story in his book entitled Full Service, My Adventures in Hollywood and the Secret Sex Lives of the Stars.
[1:24:10] Laura Camien: And on the dust jacket, Gore Vidal wrote, Scotty doesn't lie and he knows everybody.
[1:24:16] Susan Blackwell: Wow.
[1:24:17] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[1:24:17] Susan Blackwell: I believe him.
[1:24:18] Laura Camien: I will say I know that there's a lot of versions and tellings of the different history of somebody like Katherine Hepburn.
[1:24:24] Susan Blackwell: Sure.
[1:24:25] Laura Camien: And maybe she did have, uh, lovers across the spectrum.
[1:24:30] Susan Blackwell: She might have changed.
[1:24:31] Laura Camien: She might have.
[1:24:32] Susan Blackwell: But I'm, I've, or she, or she might have been a stone.
[1:24:36] Laura Camien: Who knows?
[1:24:37] Susan Blackwell: Or it was not safe for her to be a lesbian.
[1:24:40] Laura Camien: Yeah, who knows?
[1:24:41] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.
[1:24:41] Laura Camien: But I do, but I will say this.
[1:24:43] Susan Blackwell: I do believe Scotty.
[1:24:44] Laura Camien: Um, filmmaker Matt Turnauer described Scotty Bowers' book, Full Service as the perverse part of the greatest generation narrative that the all-American boys left out of their post-war lives.
[1:24:54] Susan Blackwell: Turnauer told the Hollywood Reporter his story, which he waited to tell until he was in his late 90s and for years refused to tell at all, forms an astonishing counter-narrative of Hollywood and exposes the mores of the movie capital in a time when gay men and women were forced to be sexual outlaws and were publicly shunned and often persecuted, or at least forced to live double lives.
[1:25:18] Laura Camien: Scotty was a central figure in the gay underground of Hollywood and served as a trusted protector of his friends and associates' lives when they had no alternatives but to live in the shadows.
[1:25:29] Susan Blackwell: In July 2018, Bowers received a citation from the city of West Hollywood for his role in local LGBTQ history.
[1:25:37] Laura Camien: Wow.
[1:25:38] Susan Blackwell: In an interview on CBS Sunday Morning, journalist Anthony Mason asked Scotty Bowers, any regrets?
[1:25:45] Laura Camien: And Scotty's reply was, no, no, if I had to do it over again, I'd probably do it over again.
[1:25:51] Susan Blackwell: Oh, so that is my spark.
[1:25:54] Laura Camien: Oh, what a good spark!
[1:25:55] Susan Blackwell: But what do we make of it?
[1:25:57] Laura Camien: If you're Matt Turnauer, you make a great documentary.
[1:26:01] Susan Blackwell: And I'm telling you, I have only scritchy scratched the surface.
[1:26:05] Laura Camien: If this is interesting to you, go, go stars or wherever it's streaming now.
[1:26:10] Susan Blackwell: Watch that documentary.
[1:26:11] Laura Camien: Scotty Bowers is, that's a way to pick a subject for a documentary.
[1:26:16] Susan Blackwell: If you're interested in documentary filmmaking, yeah, way to pick a spark.
[1:26:20] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[1:26:21] Susan Blackwell: So good.
[1:26:21] Laura Camien: Someone who has, uh, seven decades of content they've never told.
[1:26:26] Susan Blackwell: I mean, and then is a truth teller.
[1:26:29] Laura Camien: It's a truth teller.
[1:26:31] Susan Blackwell: If you're me, you make a clean house.
[1:26:34] Laura Camien: Scotty Bowers is a hoarder and it's well documented in the film.
[1:26:38] Susan Blackwell: And when I see a hoarder depicted in film and television, man, does it make me clean my house?
[1:26:43] Laura Camien: Nothing will make me clean my house faster than seeing, because as you know, my parents are hoarders.
[1:26:49] Susan Blackwell: So like I come from a hoarder background and it makes me clean my house.
[1:26:53] Laura Camien: Yeah.
[1:26:54] Susan Blackwell: And then pick your spark.
[1:26:55] Laura Camien: That story about Harry Reese.
[1:26:58] Susan Blackwell: Is insane.
[1:26:59] Laura Camien: Oh my god, so many sparks within sparks.
[1:27:03] Susan Blackwell: We hope this put another bunch of sparks in your file.
[1:27:05] Laura Camien: Listen, if there's a spark you'd like us to explore, or if you've taken a spark and fanned it into a creative flame and you'd like to share that, email us at thesparkfile@gmail.com or submit it through our website, thesparkfile.com.
[1:27:18] Susan Blackwell: We'll even take your feedback, but you know the price of admission.
[1:27:21] Laura Camien: First, you gotta share a creative risk that you've taken recently.
[1:27:24] Susan Blackwell: And be sure to subscribe to this podcast wherever you get your podcast.
[1:27:27] Laura Camien: Subscribe, rate, five-star review it.
[1:27:29] Susan Blackwell: If you like this podcast, share it with people you love.
[1:27:32] Laura Camien: If you didn't like it, you really need to find yourself a different podcast.
[1:27:35] Susan Blackwell: If something tickles your fancy and gets your creative juices flowing, we're writing you a forever permission slip to make that thing that's been knocking at your door.
[1:27:43] Laura Camien: It's your turn to take a spark and fan it into a flame.
[1:27:47] Susan Blackwell: You gotta live it, you gotta forgive it, you gotta write your whole life story, then generously give it.
[1:28:10] Laura Camien: Could be something that I wanna make or how I wanna be.
[1:28:15] Susan Blackwell: I pump it in the spark files.
[1:28:20] Laura Camien: I jump into my spark file.
[1:28:24] Susan Blackwell: Let's open up the spark file.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
