In this episode, Andrew and Graceson talk about the film adaptations of two Broadway musicals, which once were films, which once were books. The Color Purple directed by Blitz Bazawule and Mean Girls directed by Samantha Jayne and Arturo Perez Jr... Read More
From the show: Token Theatre Friends
Featured Shows
About
In this episode, Andrew and Graceson talk about the film adaptations of two Broadway musicals, which once were films, which once were books. The Color Purple directed by Blitz Bazawule and Mean Girls directed by Samantha Jayne and Arturo Perez Jr. The friends discuss the changes that were made from the stage versions to the films, the reluctance of studios to commit to selling movie musicals, and how Purple epitomizes the meaning of "ensemble film."
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:11] Andrew Pendle: Welcome to another episode of Token Theatre Friends.
[0:14] Graceson Abreu Nunez: I am Andrew Pendle, a film analyst, professor, and critic.
[0:20] Andrew Pendle: My name is Grayson Abreu Nunez, and I am a theater maker, dramaturg, and critic.
[0:28] Andrew Pendle: Welcome to the podcast indeed.
[0:30] Andrew Pendle: So Grayson, you seem like the excellent person to do this podcast with me.
[0:36] Andrew Pendle: We're talking about two movies that are based on plays that are based on movies and based on books.
[0:36] Graceson Abreu Nunez: That are based on books, exactly.
[0:47] Andrew Pendle: So we are looking at Mean Girls 2024 and The Color Purple 2023.
[0:53] Andrew Pendle: Two fairly successful Broadway musicals.
[0:57] Graceson Abreu Nunez: I mean, one more than the other, but it's kind of interesting having them both come up at the same time with that one-to-one to one-to-one kind of trajectory.
[1:08] Andrew Pendle: Right.
[1:09] Graceson Abreu Nunez: No, it's very, it makes me think of Plato a lot in the sense of like these movie adaptations of musicals that are adaptations of movies that are adaptations of books of books.
[1:24] Andrew Pendle: It's like what is the real thing? What is the source?
[1:27] Graceson Abreu Nunez: But yeah, and I mean, it's always kind of fun watching different ways that film or theater comes to being, you know, like movies based on comic books, plays based on paintings, but it's interesting having these films pop up, especially when so much of the conversation is about what's going on in Hollywood. Are we making new movies? Are we recycling old things? So I think that it's kind of an interesting time having them come up, whether or not they're good. There's that long history attached to them.
[2:02] Andrew Pendle: That is true. I would for some might consider some of these movies cult classics or their prior iterations cult classics, like Mean Girls is definitely a cult classic for those of the early 2000s, and then The Color Purple was just an actual classic, just an actual classic, and what's so surprising is that I think they both coming out at the times that they've come out now is they're very much in dialogue with each other.
[2:39] Graceson Abreu Nunez: It's so beautiful what you've written about like what do these plays mean about feminism now? I think when we think of Mean Girls and how of women reclaiming power and of people reclaiming their power, as well as The Color Purple, whose book that it's based off, Alice Walker, she even coins the term womanism, which separates itself from feminism, and I think that's so lovely because both of these works try to uplift women and try to examine the complexities of their relationships.
[2:47] Andrew Pendle: And when we think about what Hollywood is trying to say and how Hollywood is trying to step into the times, yeah, and I think of course, even beyond the themes. I mean, the first thing that you think about when you hear these movies is they're both musicals, and I mean, even though musicals are as old as Hollywood is, I feel like there's still this weirdness about them.
[3:49] Graceson Abreu Nunez: I mean, like currently in film social media, there's a conversation about the new film Joker 2 with Lady Gaga, Carly Quinn, which we have heard is a musical. But then there was a release today from someone in the, I think it was a director or the cinematographer, saying that it's not a musical, it's just a movie with music. And I keep on thinking about how weird people are about musicals.
[4:14] Graceson Abreu Nunez: I feel like you are going to find people who are happy and even like indignant about saying, you know, they won't watch a musical, or you know, they can't stand musicals, even though there's no one thing to define the musical, and especially for a lot of people coming to these movies with no context of Broadway. Like there are a number of persons I know who went to these movies and said it didn't have as a musical. You kind of think, how did they miss the advertising or anything? But like the people who genuinely are thinking, why did you make this great movie into a musical? Not realizing that an entire theater world out there exists and people are doing things with the musicals.
[4:53] Andrew Pendle: I mean, for you as somebody who's a theater maker, do you find movie musical people sometimes resistant to what you might do with the theater or like the power of any kind of drama?
[5:04] Graceson Abreu Nunez: I think in general, there's an issue about accessibility. People's accessibility to musicals and even theater and drama in general is very limited. I'm from, I was born and raised in New York, and so having Broadway a few stops on the subway away from me is one thing, but to someone who doesn't necessarily have a big regional theater or doesn't have a commercial theater nearby, their idea of musical theater can often come from education.
[5:39] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Our first point of contact with musicals or plays are like in middle school or in high school, where there's a theater club and someone's putting on a production of West Side Story or The Pajama Game or these musicals that don't feel necessarily connected that these kids might or students might not necessarily connect with.
[6:31] Andrew Pendle: And that's a good point to bring into the question of accessibility, because we've got these two fairly popular, I mean they're not quite IP movies, but they have a branded name. So for those of you who are unfamiliar and need to jog your memory, Mean Girls is a musical based on the play, based on the movie, based on a nonfiction text, actually, about, I think it's called Queen Bees and Wannabes.
[6:43] Graceson Abreu Nunez: So it's a 2004 comedy written by Tina Fey, and you know, back when Lindsay Lohan was the leading teen girl actress, and it's about a girl who's been homeschooled her entire life adapting to the dog-eat-dog culture of high school girl cliques, you know.
[7:19] Andrew Pendle: I mean, I think for people my age, you know, early 30s, like Mean Girls is one of those essential teen movies, it's like the previous generation's Heathers, for example.
[7:32] Graceson Abreu Nunez: So there's definitely that fun thing about talking about accessibility because most persons weren't able to see the fairly successful Broadway play, which closed just before COVID. So, you know, they've kind of updated the movie, there's a lot of referenced things like Instagram and current culture, and so we've got that kind of updated version of the musical for the century.
[7:57] Andrew Pendle: The question is, do these audiences want a musical? And our second film is of course The Excellent The Color Purple, which follows Celie, who is an abused woman with a very basic husband who has been separated from her sister, and who is able to find herself, her sexuality, and her identity over a decades-long saga of strength and resilience of Black women.
[8:27] Graceson Abreu Nunez: And so, yeah, and like one thing I was thinking is that even though it's not, we've seen many Black musicals, there is that sense also that they are generally quite rare to have like a major, what's the last Black musical you can think of?
[8:45] Andrew Pendle: Dreamgirls.
[8:46] Graceson Abreu Nunez: That was a movie, exactly. Dreamgirls, that's almost 20 years ago, it's 18 years ago. That's a very long time, but they have been musicals before seen that.
[8:56] Andrew Pendle: So I think that in both cases, you're seeing properties that don't really get the movie musical treatment as much. Like what's the last thing musical you can think of?
[9:06] Graceson Abreu Nunez: I can't think of any on the top of my head.
[9:08] Andrew Pendle: So we're kind of feeling Prom.
[9:12] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Yeah.
[9:13] Andrew Pendle: Okay.
[9:14] Graceson Abreu Nunez: The Prom, yeah, sorry. I mean, of course, it wasn't a cinema release. It wasn't a box office success. It hasn't gone very far.
[9:24] Andrew Pendle: But I think within the theater community and with young theatergoers and young artists, Prom or young teens.
[9:32] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Yeah.
[9:34] Graceson Abreu Nunez: They were like something that I can now add to my book, something that I can now use as material that relates to me.
[9:42] Andrew Pendle: I think it's again that's sort of a really great jumping-off point, though, because I mean, I think one thing that kind of the question of what does streaming mean for cinema is a really big conversation. But do you think that the Prom was kind of hampered by being on Netflix and not being a theater phenomenon? Like would it have benefited, do you think, from being released in cinemas or not so much?
[10:10] Graceson Abreu Nunez: I think what works on streaming also has to do with the buzz, the marketing, and also what it comes with. With Prom, it was beloved by theatergoers and people who were already familiar with it, and that's also a property in a good idea.
[10:33] Andrew Pendle: Yeah, exactly.
[10:35] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Whereas let's say Hamilton, which didn't have a theatrical release, it went straight to Disney, but Hamilton already had a buzz. Everyone was going to see Hamilton. The Obamas were going to see Hamilton. Everyone's dying to get a ticket.
[10:51] Andrew Pendle: And so when they announced that it was coming to streaming, I think it not only encouraged people to like get a Disney Plus subscription, because I don't think before that people were getting Disney Plus subscriptions, but that was definitely an incentive.
[11:08] Graceson Abreu Nunez: I don't know, you know, just around the time we were getting into the pandemic, so there was a lot of incentive to be at home.
[11:15] Andrew Pendle: So different time also.
[11:18] Graceson Abreu Nunez: It was a missed opportunity, I think. Or maybe not a missed opportunity for Prom, but it wasn't a pop culture phenomenon, as it were, it was a theatrical phenomenon.
[11:34] Andrew Pendle: So now we have a film like Mean Girls, which is based on a film that was a phenomenon. I mean, Mean Girls is in the pop culture, like "So fetch" has become part of...
[11:39] Graceson Abreu Nunez: You go get Coco. Exactly. So I mean, in one way this new Mean Girls is sort of coming in with a built-in audience, and yet I started to feel that the actual development and film that we get kind of feels like it sort of drops the ball a little bit with, I don't know, like all of that goodwill, and I mean for me, it's coming to like one of the initial points of comparison between the two movies, which is the leads, and I feel like for me, Mean Girls immediately is fighting a difficult battle because we don't have Lindsay Lohan in the lead in it.
[12:32] Andrew Pendle: And I think the people really undervalue how much work she's doing in the original film.
[12:39] Graceson Abreu Nunez: I mean, Katie is not the most interesting character, she's a straight man among the more interesting, you know, Regina's, you know, this Ice Queen, Janice's, you know, very Mercurial.
[12:52] Andrew Pendle: But Lindsay Lohan is charming to watch.
[12:54] Graceson Abreu Nunez: She she is, she is she like I can't. She's America's sweetheart.
[12:59] Andrew Pendle: Yeah, she was, and we don't, and we don't have a Lindsay Lohan of this generation.
[13:04] Graceson Abreu Nunez: We just don't.
[13:05] Andrew Pendle: We don't have somebody in that teen bracket with that kind of goodwill, I think.
[13:10] Graceson Abreu Nunez: And if we do, it's definitely not Angourie Rice who's playing her in Mean Girls, and who is it's just not working for me.
[13:19] Andrew Pendle: I mean, like, what are your thoughts on Angourie Rice in Mean Girls?
[13:24] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Angourie Rice had big shoes to fill. Not gonna lie, not I'm gonna not gonna hold you. She had big shoes to fill.
[13:32] Andrew Pendle: But I think it's hard because of the way social media has evolved and the idea of celebrity has evolved.
[13:43] Graceson Abreu Nunez: We don't have uh we don't have any Lindsay Lohan's, we don't have Ashley Tisdale, we don't have Vanessa Hudgens, we don't have these, we have well, I don't want to say that because I think a great example of a modern day one who is still kind of like in this sort of like Disney uh Disney Channel profile, is oh the this musician, what is her name? She was in the high school musical, the musical series.
[14:12] Andrew Pendle: Olivia Rodrigo, yes there we go yes but I mean I'm sorry she doesn't do as much acting she's you know I mean it's a good point though like I'd forgotten that Olivia Rodrigo actually started in acting and she would have been like an obvious person to be in Mean Girls thinking about it now actually like I mean she can sing you know she has the name recognition because I mean like when Mean Girls came on 2004 Lindsay Lohan was already famous like that that was one of her last like you know important roles and I feel that this Mean Girls is already kind of working with a demerit because it doesn't have anybody of that level to like immediately buy in like we buy Katie's journey because we like Lindsay Lohan, so like immediately we're we're there, we're sold, and I feel like it it's there's so much time in the new Mean Girls, which doesn't even open with Katie, which we'll get to, that I feel like it just kind of sets her up to not be as interesting, especially considering how the rest of the film kind of like you know looks at the dynamics of the girls, yeah.
[15:27] Graceson Abreu Nunez: I think what happened, I think there are two there are so many battles that Mean Girls has to or that this uh adaptation of Mean Girls has to face Katie not having a uh necessarily uh well known star is the lesser battles, if you know what I if if well no fair fair notion.
[15:49] Andrew Pendle: There's so many other things to deal with.
[15:52] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Because when we think about the Mean Girls that we know from 2004, um, and we think about it in today in 2024, it is white girls battling for power in a rigid social hierarchy to young audience and to teen audiences who are this is like going towards they're not. I think if they try to replicate something like that, or if they try to not continue with a more conscious casting that they chose, I feel like the casting that they chose is a bit more conscious of what a high school looks like versus what America and what producers sold high school to be as in early in the early 2000s, and so within that fight, Katie is not interesting. Unfortunately.
[17:26] Andrew Pendle: Not as the original cast member, but as a replacement.
[17:29] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Like Fantasia Barrino who plays Celie in Color Purple was a replacement for LaChanze in the original production of Color Purple, like in early 2000. That seems happened with the newer version, and Renee Rapp, you know, replaced um I can't remember the name of the lovely girl. She was on Bring It On, but she replaced her in Mean Girls. So I thought it was interesting having both leads in both movies kind of be women who'd actually played the role on stage as well as playing it on the movies. And like when you look at Fantasia versus Renee, like how do you think they hold up in terms of you know balancing that you know weight of the transition on their shoulders?
[18:08] Andrew Pendle: I think well, when we think of when Fantasia stepped into the role of Color Purple, she was a well, she was an interesting choice, and she was a great choice for the role uh when it was on Broadway because she had just gotten from American Idol. She sort of had this sort of attention garnered around her, so it was like a very easy buy to get tickets and audience sales to like come see this show when we already sort of see, and even like in the theater world, shows that are majority black uh casted or shows that feature a black ensemble do not sell the way other uh other shows do. Um and so I think she held that she took on that way and she did it so beautifully then. And to see her reprise this role uh was a sort of another reason to go see this show because not only did she reprise this role, this role this show had was a star-studded ensemble.
Like it's her, it's um Danielle Brooks, it's Coleman Domingo, it's Taraji, um, it's Halle and Sierra, it's her. Louis Gossett Jr., it's her. I mean, there, it's just it's a David Alan Greer. It's a strong list goes on. So who like I think the pressure was on, I think the pressure was on not just because she was reprising this role, but because who's around her? Who's like who are who is the ensemble? And I think this ensemble worked, this ensemble worked beautifully.
[19:50] Graceson Abreu Nunez: And when we think about the ensemble of Mean Girls, what is also kind of lovely and refreshing is like while Renee Rapp um was uh had uh had already done this role before, I think this brought Renee Rapp to new audiences. Um because most people who don't know from theater might know her from Mindy Kaling's uh show on her music, yeah.
[20:15] Andrew Pendle: Exactly.
[20:16] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Um not to mention the the entire cast as well. They are besides the cameos from original members of the movie, like Tina Fey, Tim Meadows. They're multiple like they're not as named person as the Color Purple cast. They're they're they're now developing I mean Angourie Rice is probably the most famous one, and she's not very famous. So I think it was interesting having you know these now developing stars, you know, showing their talents to the world. And I want to give a shout out to the casting director for Mean Girls because it gave a lot of people opportunities, or it gave a lot of people uh people opportunities to be seen by new audiences, which is something that especially with movie musicals, we don't often get the chance to see because musicals are such a hard sell, I think, to the general public.
[21:11] Andrew Pendle: Um my friends, when I told them that being the re that they that I went to go see the re-release of Mean Girls, they were just like, why would you go see that? The origin, it's the original, like you have to love the original. And not to mention when I told them that it was a musical, they were so appalled. They were like, What? I will never step into the theater to see a musical. And I was and what's so funny is that you gotta mention so many of these songs were cut. And also this new ver this the in the trailers, it's very lightly touched upon and hardly even mentioned that it is a musical. And I think, and that was a and that was a very smart choice on parts of if it was marketed as a musical, people would be very apprehensive about going to see.
[22:03] Graceson Abreu Nunez: But isn't it? But sometimes I wonder if it's a self-fulfilling prophecy, though. I mean, if you're gonna make a musical, just stand on business and make a fucking musical. Like, I mean, I I I I don't I don't want to see, you know, your trailers with Nary a song. And I don't want to see, I mean, like, it's it's like I I think about this, like do I think about the Oscars, for example, which is a weird from Bright Mills. Like, people are always saying every year that the Oscars don't get viewers, which you know, fair enough. And they keep trying to court people who don't like watching the Oscars to come and watch them. They never come. When they have a built in set of people who like watching award shows, just cater to the people that like your product. There are more weirdos out there, trust me.
[22:49] Andrew Pendle: But I get but it's but it always feels so like half assed when like you want to do the thing, but then you also want to get people who don't like the thing. Because I think I like the thing I'm I'm gonna be like you know why are you embarrassed to you know loudly you know say I'm making a musical this is gonna be big and loud and you know all of these crazy things because I feel like you know build I don't want to go off field of dreams here but if you build it they might come I really think that they might come work I I think they will uh the the musical theater geeks are gonna come out in droves but I think those who are interested in musicals need a need to need a way in and they need to they need a chance and I think Mean Girls is an interesting example of a show that took a chance on cutting back music and not emphasizing the fact that it's a musical to see if musicals can be can open up for a new audience and if new audiences can enjoy a musical because I'm not gonna hold you as a theater lover music uh as I have matured in my and my in my theater going experience musicals give me some cringe I experience a little cringe when I think about musical theaters and um when I think about musical theater and not because I hate musicals. I love a good musical. I'm also so excited. I was looking at what other musicals are coming out that are or movie musicals that are coming out.
[24:39] Graceson Abreu Nunez: And of course, we're all excited about Wicked. Uh, and like the trailer came out. And if you haven't seen the trailer, go see the trailer. Come on now. But go see the trailer. But and then, but I was seeing things that are in pre-production. And so many musicals that aren't necessarily household names, like Bear. The Bear's happening. And that just made my like teen gay heart flutter. I also Spring Awakening, which is going to be another interesting adaptation. It's also a teen musical. Also a teen musical, also interesting to see how that musical has aged because we are in a very different time in how we depict, how we explore issues that might require triggers, like sexual assault, abuse, so on and so forth.
Queerness, with, you know, teen characters, and I think that's one thing that immediately, you know, establishes a difference between The Color Purple and Mean Girls because The Color Purple is a period novel, and the adaptation keeps for that period. Mean Girls doesn't stick to the period, it's the story updated to 2024, and so we've got things like smartphones, we've got things like Instagram, we've got different language, we've got different, like you're mentioning different ideas and responses to triggers and whatnot. So it's not sticking to 2004, which would have been interesting in a way, thinking like what would a 2024 vision of that time look like? But it's doing it no.
[26:38] Andrew Pendle: And I guess the, um, in your point towards musicals and accessibility, how do you think? I mean, we can talk about how it plays for us in a bit, but how do you think this audience today is responding to something like Mean Girls? Do you think the movie is, you know, selling itself enough to that audience? Or does it still feel like it's kept back for whatever reason?
[27:03] Graceson Abreu Nunez: I think it's selling to everyone in a way that when you sort of sell to, or like when you try to sell to a larger audience, um, people from a wider demographic will like bite, but I don't know if people are coming out in droves. So the people who are diehard fans of Mean Girls, they're gonna come out, but the people who are diehard fans of Mean Girls, but who are sort of like purists, um, might not. But it is that sort of, oh, but I have to see it because if I see it and it's bad, I'm gonna hate on it. Because one thing people love to do, people love to critique, people love to give their two cents. So where do you stand in the Mean Girls trajectory? Like, are you a diehard fan of the movie or the original movie or the play? And what do you think of this one? What are your thoughts on this movie? Do you like it? Do you not like it?
[28:11] Andrew Pendle: I thoroughly enjoyed it. I am a diehard fan of the original. Um, I wasn't a teen when the original came out. I was quite young. I was maybe like seven, eight, ten. And I was watching, God, uh, and I was watching it with my older sister who was a teenager. And what's really funny is that it kind of set what I imagine high school to be.
[28:38] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Ah, interesting.
[28:40] Andrew Pendle: Like this is what I imagined high school would be. There would be cliques, there would be the cool girls, there would be the artsy fartsy kids, there would be the theater geeks. And so I prepared for that, but then what I, my reality was a Gen Z world where no one cared about labels. Labels were actually quite uncool. And if you tried to stick to them, it made you question yourself a bit. And so that was actually sort of lovely getting to like have that sort of change, or because I saw Mean Girls, I knew I was not gonna go into high school inside in the closet. I was like, F everyone else, I'm gonna be my queer and proud self that's too gay to function. And then watching the movie or the newest, the 2024 movie or 2023, I loved it because there were some homages to the original film.
We saw Tina Fey, we saw the Principal, Tim Meadows, and yes, we see Lit, we see Lindsay Lohan, and that was, I was, I audibly gasped when I saw Lindsay Lohan as the sort of judge or the proctor to the comic to the math leads contest. And it was heartwarming. And also the music is really great. Like the music is catchy, and everyone has vocals. Like Renee Rapp, there's a reason why they brought her back. Like my name is Regina George. And she had something to say. And Regina George had something to say. And also I think looking at Regina George and Regina George in 2024, I'm so glad that they made her this sort of like tough as nails. Sort of like, yes, she's preppy. Yes, she comes from this wealthy background. She's kind of gritty. She's kind of, oh, um, she's kind of nasty for lack of a better word. She's hot in a way that like 2020, uh, like 2004, Regina George was hot to the early kind of the early.
[31:02] Graceson Abreu Nunez: I'm, I totally get what you're saying, and I think that that's definitely something I like to see in adaptations like this, where they're thinking about how they approach a new version of the characters. And I don't love everything about Mean Girls, but I do appreciate when it tries to play around with dynamics. Like my favorite aspects of it ended up being the other two Plastics who I found really, I wasn't, I was familiar with one of them, but I didn't know the other.
[31:39] Andrew Pendle: So it was really interesting seeing them. So I did know the girl who plays Gretchen, she's a Baby Wood. I know her from the TV show Love Victor. Um, I've seen her before. I didn't know she, but it was nice seeing, you know, this TV small screen girl on a big screen. So I loved your earlier final, kind of like creating new stars. And I wasn't familiar with Avantica who plays Karen, who I really want to say is my favorite in the movie. Um, we have a South Asian Karen as opposed to her, you know, blonde Karen from 2004. And I think I feel like she has the most interesting song adaptation because they adapt her song. It's kind of like an Instagram post. And so she's prepping for Halloween and she's, and she's, you know, on her lives.
And I really like that particular number because I feel like it was thinking about how I want to adapt the musical for this particular era. It really felt, I didn't get that with all the other numbers, but I really, I really like that entire run-up to that, and then it ends with her little zinger, and it is just, it's just a really fun, exciting bit. So yeah, definitely in with the Plastics and the emendations, you know, to the original film.
[33:00] Graceson Abreu Nunez: And this is the thing: the Plastics had a not a charm, but there was something so much more that you were rooting for these Plastics comparatively to the original film. Whereas like the Plastics were girls that were sort of a bit harder to access, a harder to reach, or especially like for me, I was like, I don't know who these girls are, and like I'm rooting for like KD in the, uh, from the beginning whereas like Avantica and BB, there's a lot more like humanity in them. But I will say definitely something I see in the movie generally, like it's definitely a warmer Mean Girls than the original one.
[33:14] Andrew Pendle: I mean, yeah, it's definitely true. I've, that's like no argument there, which, you know, different times.
[33:14] Graceson Abreu Nunez: True. Also, uh, for a question that I have for you, do you know if Baby Wood is Latina? Because that was something they interestingly slid in there that I was just like, she has, uh, I was wondering that also. Yeah, I was wondering that also, but I mean definitely something, you know, the film is obviously very, uh, you know, intentional about its casting and definitely a lot less white.
[33:14] Andrew Pendle: Um, I was actually thinking though because I think the first thing I text, I actually text Jose, who is, you know, all podcasters, you know who Jose is. Uh, I checked him after the movie actually saying that I actually wish that instead of casting Angourie Rice, they'd actually cast O'Leali who plays Janice as Katie because for one reason the new Mean Girls kind of falls down for me is that I never believe that Angourie Rice is a threat to Renee Rapp. She can't, she doesn't have a strong voice, she she's not as good as an actor, she isn't giving that, um, she just doesn't have that. And I mean, I feel like that's essential to the story. Like when you watched the 2004 Mean Girls, I believe that Lindsay Lohan can overpower Rachel McAdams because those are two bad bitches with equal sleigh. I don't feel that watching this new Mean Girls.
[35:32] Graceson Abreu Nunez: I, I so it's all so I, but I would, I would have believed Janice as Katie. You know, she has pipes, she has that energy, and I could see her doing that. So it really was, I feel like if you're gonna bring in someone like Renee Rapp, who's played the role before, who's so knowledgeable on it, I think you're kind of setting up the Katie in a tough way. Think of it this way: you bring someone like Fantasia from The Color Purple, who's played this role for decades, and then instead of giving her Taraji, you give her, I don't know, her a should. I love her, but it would be a different kind of energy because you know, her doesn't have that.
[36:11] Andrew Pendle: I feel like that's why we needed a Taraji and Sug.
[36:15] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Exactly. Her was perfect for Squeak. Not kind of like, I, and that's why I really like the new Color Purple because I feel like they think a lot about how these actors work with each other. Like, like Taraji and Shug wouldn't work opposite Cynthia Erivo's Celie, they're different kind of performers, you know.
[36:34] Andrew Pendle: Okay, yes, I like, like, like I wouldn't, like it wouldn't work, like they're both great actresses, but the dynamics wouldn't work. Like Cynthia is so short, her voice is pitched differently, like they wouldn't blend. But Fantasia and Taraji makes sense, and I'd like that I could see them thinking about these actors in relation to each other.
[36:56] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Because I mean it's all it's all a nice like cast somebody who's good on a headshot. But are we thinking about how you know these bodies are working with each other or how you know this life melt? And I feel like in musicals, which are so dependent on ensembles, you want to see that energy. But I like The Color Purple a lot, and I'm really happy that it's helped for Screen Actors Guild Awards for Best Tash. Because like I feel the cast of that movie working with each other, which is a true ensemble.
[37:36] Andrew Pendle: Yeah.
[37:38] Graceson Abreu Nunez: I think Mean Girls has lots of powerhouse, uh, actors and actresses, and some standout um people, but what The Color Purple had was an ensemble.
[37:53] Andrew Pendle: Yep.
[37:55] Graceson Abreu Nunez: And it really is important for that. I think. I mean, I what I mean, just like we're talking about Mean Girls. Do you have any kind of deep relationship with the original The Color Purple? Because I know for many people that has kind of been an important kind of distinction. Oh, they come to this new one, which I found really interesting.
[38:10] Andrew Pendle: Well, for me, The Color Purple was something introduced to me later. Uh, I had always I had always heard about The Color Purple. Um, it was always on late night on cable, and then once I got into theater, uh, one of my mentors was like, you need to re-watch The Color Purple, and so I sat down and I was like, whoa, what uh what is this move? The sort of even like that back then, this movie with such queer undertones about like black love and also this like relationship between black women and the intricacies of it where was this on my life? Um, but it was also a movie of its time not to say like it was groundbreaking but it didn't talk as much about uh this sort of this aspect of like queer love and queer relationships and uh the intimacy uh between black women as it does now I think.
[38:40] Andrew Pendle: Yeah, and of course, I mean, and for those who've read the book and you should all read Alice Walker's novel which is not I mean that book gets into it's it's yes it's literary detailed and definitely one thing the new The Color Purple does is that at least we see a romantic kiss between Suge and Seely but I have to say that as much as I like the new The Color Purple I was disappointed that it didn't go further because the actual play The Color Purple is a lot more gay than the movie based on the play and I and the play came out in early 2000s you know how are we it felt like a regression to me because like in the adaptation of the novel I mean the novel is really quite queer and obviously at the time people were like okay 1985 nobody's gonna you know support that and so there's just the undertone in the original movie the newer movie does a bit better they get an entire love song but yeah.
[40:15] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Something that I was telling someone who didn't know in the original play, Seely sings I'm here after Suge wants to go off sleeping with a young guy she's taken up with. So Celie's big number is uh is a reaction to the static love. And I feel that the film loses some of that because one thing I kept thinking about watching The Color Purple and thinking about the bear's adaptations. The first adaptation definitely emphasized Sug and Seely as sisters, and that beautiful song that Princey Joan composes from the original movie is in this new movie, which is not in the play. And I feel that having Suge sing the song Sister to Celie after you know the romantic love scene kind of stays down that queer love aspect, and it kind of made me feel like they almost got it just perfect, but then it just felt like they just weren't completely, you know, ready to just completely stand in that.
[41:14] Andrew Pendle: Which so it was sort of a slightly frustrating part of it for me, even though I still appreciated it, you know, doing more than the original film.
[41:23] Graceson Abreu Nunez: No, of course, I think Hollywood has yet to push the gay agenda as much as the queer people think that the people think people think that they are. Everyone thinks they're pushing the agenda, but not hard enough. They're really just stepping their toe in the water, they're like queer. This is a little gay. But I think well, depending on how Bear looks, um when Bear is released, as well as like Spring Awakening, we'll see how, especially in the genre of movie musicals, this will continue and like we see queer relationships on stage and on screen.
[42:05] Andrew Pendle: Um, I think one of the reasons I was so like uh thinking about the queer dynamic in The Color Purple though is that we both know that as much as Hollywood and you know theater at large and film at large might be developing more of a language to deal with queerness on screen black queer women are still very much underrepresented and I feel that it's it is an essential part of the dynamism of The Color Purple to think about what it means to be a queer black woman. I I it the you know thinking about you know the struggles the pain but also the joy and the happiness and even though like I said I feel like the new movie doesn't get as queer enough I am super grateful because that um scene where Seely and Shuge sing their love song and they it's it they imagine themselves as actors in a movie so they're watching themselves on screen I I think it's just a beautiful sequence when they walk down the staircase and they're both you know beautifully dressed and it feels you know it feels magical it feels magical like I really think that that scene gets you know the tenderness and the softness of that in a way that I really appreciated especially because I don't know what it was like for you but I think and people are still I mean they're still weird about queerness and I'm not gonna lie when they kissed on screen in the cinema people bodily were not having it and I was like fuck you like I that's why I kind of wish they went for her just to be like okay let's now let's see some real queer action but I think that even something as tender as that is so important for you know black women, dark skinned black women on screen.
[43:54] Andrew Pendle: Right.
[43:55] Graceson Abreu Nunez: I see, and this is where, and this is why I think even for even showing that kiss, um, it go it goes a bit further than the original film, uh, and even this and that scene, um, and even the sort of like subtleties and the nuances of how we see like when Suge goes off with Mr. and Seely just watches her go with him and she's like heartbroken. And you see them, like you see her heartbreak there. Um, but there's also I think there's also the public and the audiences who are coming to see this film, and the audiences who know that this is like a black classic.
[44:37] Andrew Pendle: Or this well, it's a classic in period, but like to the black community, The Color Purple is a classic for who the original actors were for, for Whoopi Goldberg, for Oprah. And to come back and return to this film, I don't think many, I it's really sad, but I don't think many black audiences would have been ready to see a more radical queer story.
[45:01] Graceson Abreu Nunez: No, that's a good point. I mean, I'm sure audiences listening may have heard that you know the rapper Booty Badass walked out with The Color Purple after the kiss. Like he there was a big Twitter star about this, and I kept thinking like these people are so fragile, they're so fragile. But um I kept thinking of about another musical watching The Color Purple, um, because they both are connected to Steven Spielberg. So Steven Spielberg famously did a new adaptation of West Side Story a few years ago.
[45:33] Andrew Pendle: And because he was kind of like updating that for a new audience, you know.
[45:37] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Uh, and so now we have a movie that was originally done by Stephen Spielberg, a white man, now we're directed by a black man. Um, so there's that kind of updating. And uh I personally preferred the original West Side Story and The Color Purple, but I also think that the new The Color Purple for me does a lot more in terms of presenting its case to the audience in the ways that the new West Side Story didn't.
[46:06] Andrew Pendle: Like I know that the general position is that Spielberg's newer West Side Story is better, it's a better movie, or at least a better musical recently.
[46:18] Graceson Abreu Nunez: But for me, I think the new The Color Purple is doing something different in the movie that I can appreciate them both. I get the the logic that a new version of a new movie is somehow erasing the original one. It's still there, it's still we're still able to, you know, watch it and appreciate it.
[46:36] Andrew Pendle: And something that my sister, who's a big fan of the original movie, said when she watched this one with me, is that she said she found the sisterhood theme a lot more emphasized in this newer version.
[46:47] Graceson Abreu Nunez: And I actually agree with her because you said something that I thought about when you said that this movie feels like an ensemble movie. It doesn't feel like a movie about Seely, it feels like a movie about this entire community, and it's different in that way, but I think that there is a space and a value for that.
[47:04] Andrew Pendle: Like I like one of my favorite moments in the new movie is when after Seely is able to, you know, take back the shock from her dead father and she has her store, and it's the image of her and all the women singing out her pants, and it's Shuge, and it's Sophia, and it's Squeak, and it's Seeley, and it and it just feels like a nice moment, you know, in a way that's really kind of like I kick it home.
[47:32] Graceson Abreu Nunez: And it just I it feels a lot less bleak than the first one.
[47:38] Andrew Pendle: So I understand personal like all people who are like, oh, it wasn't hard enough, but we do have that version. This one is doing something different.
[47:46] Graceson Abreu Nunez: You don't need another exactly like it's doing something different, I think.
[47:50] Andrew Pendle: So like I can appreciate that it's not for me. This new movie is best the more it tries to distance itself from that original, right?
[48:01] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Like whenever it tries to retreat moments from the movie, I'm like, no, no, no, do your own thing.
[48:06] Andrew Pendle: Don't try to, you know, don't bring back Sister from that version.
[48:09] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Don't you know change this to fit that?
[48:11] Andrew Pendle: Like, do your own thing. You don't need to be recreating that.
[48:14] Graceson Abreu Nunez: You already have that one, right?
[48:17] Andrew Pendle: It I can definitely see the moments where it was trying to create those iconic moments from the original movie.
[48:24] Graceson Abreu Nunez: But I think, and I think, and I hear what you're saying that it it's I don't, but I wouldn't call it softer.
[48:30] Andrew Pendle: I think it's just there's something more especially as an audience, as someone watching the original movie, there's some sort of separation that like that or a distance that the heart are like the tough and more bleaker moments of the original movie in terms of like sexual assault, in terms of seeing your uh seeing your baby uh in the arms of another family versus like he uh within the the new updated uh movie musical is just like what makes the moments of sexual assault that much more gut or so gut wrenching is the moments of like pure joy because you know how beautiful this world can be and how easily it can take that away and how or like when oh when uh not uh Sophia is in jail and and knowing what Seely did to Sophia and having like Sophia uh having and having Seely tell Harpo beat her uh beat your woman and like and like I see or let me gather myself um seeing how someone can betray someone but then ultimately still like love that person yeah and like also wreck and like having been hurt uh and having um Sophia been hurt by Seely also recognize how much Seely loved so and she's able to change yes that definitely also the way The Color Purple ends is so beautiful ends with a beautiful ensemble number and I feel that that like if you're a musical you're not ending with your entire cast singing then what are you doing like I mean, I mean I I like one of like I think the best movie musical of the century for me is inarguably Rob Marshall's Chicago.
[50:59] Andrew Pendle: And I always reference that because I think that it's changed the face of contemporary musicals for good and for bad because something that he did in that movie that was so, you know, sharp, I mean it was written by Bill Condon, directed by Rob Marshall, and they had this idea that they were going to stage all the musical numbers in Roxy's imagination because everything in Chicago was from a perspective, and it makes sense in Chicago because Roxy is the producer, director. She's everything. She is her own woman. But I feel that since then musicals have been staging musical sequences in imaginary planes for reasons that don't always make sense. Like just have the characters singing normally, don't have somebody imagine them singing, like just let them sing.
I feel like, and I feel like, I feel like Color Purple is able to, they kind of fall into this trap in some ways because a lot of the musical numbers from Seely's mind are imagined. But the reason I'm able to kind of gel with it more is that when Seely finally gets her big "I'm here" number at the end of the movie, it's not in her imagination, it's in her shop, and it's her there alone. So I feel like there's at least an attempt in the Color Purple to kind of like not to reject that, you know. We can't sing in the real world. Like it even opens with the entire, you know, church, you know, singing in the streets and whatnot. And I kind of like that. It's similar again, Mean Girls. Like, I kind of wish some of the musical numbers weren't imagined, but I did like some of the ways that they imagined them.
So like, um, I mentioned earlier the Instagram song for Karen's sexy, and then there's when Katie and her and Janice and Damien are deciding to mess Regina's life up, there's this revenge party song which I can't tell if I like or not, but it's definitely doing something ambitious. Like how did you find the staging of the musical sequences in both of them?
[53:08] Graceson Abreu Nunez: So from a dramaturgical perspective, everything sort of justified. The thing about musical and musical theaters is that when people don't just break into song and dance in real life, which is why I think in the context especially of a like of cinema, it's kind of a crutch to like go into this sort of dream sequence. It's kind of a crutch to like pull out and say, okay, we can start singing and dancing because this is not real, um, and this doesn't happen in real time. But for me, and like you and kind of like you said, for me it's justified in the Color Purple because part of these musical numbers are an escape from the sort of bleak reality that is the storyline, which is also, and I read, and I really feel that they did that well.
I feel like a lot of persons who didn't like the film kind of aren't giving it credit for that. Like, I really feel like what you said is so important. Like, you are correct completely, the film does justify it really and give that the numbers that kind of escape roots really. Whereas with the Color, uh with Mean Girls, I think Mean Girls, it's a harder sell to say it's, uh, it can't be High School Musical all over, it can't be another High School Musical. Like no one is going, if I went to high school and someone started busting out singing and dancing, I'm gonna be that one hater who's gonna be like, why are y'all singing and dancing? Get to class! I have to like this, but isn't that like the responsibility of this film to make me believe that this could happen? Like, like suspend my disbelief. I feel like if they keep using the crutch of the imagination, then you're not doing the hard work of making us believe that this makes sense.
[55:17] Andrew Pendle: True, true. Um, you have a point, and I think the example of Chicago taking on this sort of different lens and this perspective is so true and so great because what's so great about film is that you can really open, you can really explode the box, destroy the box, recreate the box, because you are not confined to a stage. Um, but in our closing moments, what are you anticipating for the future of movie musicals? Do you think that there is a future for music for movie musicals?
[55:57] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Oh, definitely. There's always a, there is always a space for them. I think like zeroing back to my opening when I was talking about standing on business, if you're a musical, I really feel that until people who make musicals are full-throatedly like announcing it, people who love them are all gonna be embarrassed to love them. I feel that it comes from like if like if something is trying to be famous, you need to have a confidence. You can't apologize for your musicality, you can't, you know, try to like contextualize it. And I feel like that comes with casting people who can sing and act and perform. I mean, you know, cast more, you know. I mean, I don't, she's not my favorite in the movie, but cast more Renée, cast more Fantasia.
And one thing I really appreciated from Taraji over the course of the press for the show is talking about how much she worked on training her voice. Like she's, I really appreciated that kind of dedication commitment. Like she didn't take this carelessly. She said, you know, I want to be able to match Fantasia. I don't want to let down my lead. And I think that that's what we need. People who really care about the craft. Once we get that, anything's possible, you know, just get people who like musicals, who want to be in musicals, who want to, you know, do the vocal rest, the warm-ups, do the work of the wife as a muscle and to make the craft. But I think once we've got that, anything can happen.
[57:30] Andrew Pendle: Beautiful. And what musical, what musical would you like to see created?
[57:35] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Uh, like produced as a film or, uh, made for film? Well, in honor of the recently deceased Chita Rivera, I really think that there is a need for an adaptation of The Visit, the really creepy, uh, eerie Ebb and Kander musical that I really wish Chita would have been alive to star in. So rest in peace, Chita, we love you. What about you? What musical are you looking forward to in the next years or so?
[58:05] Andrew Pendle: Hmm. I think, well, a lot of my favorite music or a lot of my favorite musicals have already sort of or are coming up and having their own sort of, um, movie musical adaptation, like Spring Awakening, uh, Wicked, um, Passing Strange, which is another, uh, maybe if I, well no, I think Passing Strange as is it doesn't need another remake. Um, but if I have to think, I would love to see Hadestown. Oh, just because I think Hadestown is so magical. Um, that and the atmosphere that that ensemble also gives to Hadestown of this sort of underworld and, uh, yeah, there's so much cinematic potential. Exactly that I really want to see this sort of like industrial underworld that's being built, and these two characters go on this sort of this journey. Um, so yes, I think.
[59:11] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Oh, you heard it from us here. The Visit and Hadestown, upcoming movie musicals. We have our dramaturgs here, we just need some funding. Come on now, we are talking to you, we are looking for friends. Make this happen, people.
[59:26] Andrew Pendle: And while you're at it, you can catch Mean Girls and The Color Purple, which I think are both in cinemas. And I noticed The Color Purple is coming to streaming at the end of the month. You can also stream their cast recordings. Uh, which cast recording are you listening to immediately after this?
[59:39] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Color Purple or Mean Girls.
[59:46] Andrew Pendle: I am listening to The Color Purple. Actually, I think I'm gonna go watch The Color Purple again because I was bawling. But Renée Rap does have my heart.
[59:56] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Uh, so Renée Rap, basically what we need, we need Renée Rap doing a cover of a Color Purple song for you.
[1:00:10] Andrew Pendle: No.
[1:00:11] Graceson Abreu Nunez: No.
[1:00:12] Andrew Pendle: No.
[1:00:13] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Love you, girl.
[1:00:15] Andrew Pendle: But no.
[1:00:16] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Don't make me cancel you now.
[1:00:20] Andrew Pendle: So thank you guys for listening to another episode of Token Theater Friends. We'd love to hear your thoughts on the current state of movie musicals. And you can catch me on my Darman Twitter account as of a year and a half at the handle departed aviator, or you can catch me in my film column, which is coming back next month. Uh, Real Encounters to Ease with Andrew Kendall.
[1:00:45] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Andrew, where can we find you on the internet?
[1:00:48] Andrew Pendle: You can find me on Instagram at Grayson.rafael.
[1:00:57] Graceson Abreu Nunez: She's quirky.
[1:01:00] Andrew Pendle: To find more about my day-to-day life living in Madrid and trying to navigate the queer and Black POC theater scene and performance scene.
[1:01:14] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Well, thank you for that.
[1:01:16] Andrew Pendle: And everyone listening, have a super musical rest of the week.
[1:01:21] Graceson Abreu Nunez: Bye.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
