We sit down with documentary filmmaker Katy Scoggin to unpack the decade-long journey behind her deeply personal film Flood. What begins as a curiosity about science, faith, and her upbringing as a young earth creationist evolves into a profound exploration of family, identity, and the limits of belief... Read More
From the show: Was It Chance?
About
We sit down with documentary filmmaker Katy Scoggin to unpack the decade-long journey behind her deeply personal film Flood. What begins as a curiosity about science, faith, and her upbringing as a young earth creationist evolves into a profound exploration of family, identity, and the limits of belief. Katy shares how a chance opportunity to work in documentary filmmaking, along with a simple ask to a mentor, set her on a path that would ultimately lead her back home with a camera, confronting the most complicated relationship in her life, the one with her father.
As Katy traces her evolution from art student to award-winning filmmaker, we explore the risks she took both professionally and personally. She embedded herself in her family’s world, documented their dynamics, and wrestled with the tension between love and ideological divide. The conversation dives into her experience working alongside acclaimed documentarian Laura Poitras, the challenges of sustaining a creative career, and the emotional toll of turning the lens on your own life.
At its core, this episode is about connection in the face of difference. Katy opens up about coming out later in life, the shifting dynamics with her deeply religious father, and the surprising ways filmmaking became a bridge between them. Through Flood, she asks a powerful question. Even when we fundamentally disagree, is it still possible to find moments of understanding and even love?
Connect with Katy and learn more about Flood:
- IG: @flooddoc
Connect With Us:
- 📩 Email us at wasitchancepodcast@gmail.com
- 🎧 Follow Was It Chance? on your favorite podcast platform
- 📱 Connect with us on TikTok and LinkedIn
- ✨ More about Heather at her website, subscribe to her Substack and on LinkedIn, YouTube, and more
- Visit Heather's Bookshop
- Visit The Reading Well
EPISODE TAKEAWAYS
- Creative breakthroughs often come from discomfort and dissatisfaction, not clarity
- Asking for help at the right moment can completely change your career trajectory
- The stories closest to home are often the hardest but most meaningful to tell
- Documentary filmmaking can become a tool for connection, not just observation
- You do not need someone’s approval to live authentically or tell your truth
- It is possible to maintain some level of connection with people you fundamentally disagree with
- Long-term creative projects require choosing stories that will stay meaningful for years
- Collaboration and trusted creative relationships are essential in filmmaking
- Letting go of expectations can reduce disappointment in complicated family relationships
- Failure is a necessary and valuable part of growth and creative development
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Katy Scoggin: Close family, there can still be some channel of communication or laughter or connection.
[0:11] Katy Scoggin: It is humanly possible. Fucking hard, but it is humanly possible to find some connectivity between yourself and the folks that you would otherwise disagree with on everything under the sun.
[0:36] Katy Scoggin: Yeah, I finally got my debit cards in the mail. I had to get them expedited because they kept getting stolen through USPS.
[0:44] Katy Scoggin: Don't have anything sent through the regular mail in Brooklyn. Someone activated it and went to two different ATMs to take out a thousand dollars each.
[0:54] Katy Scoggin: What? And it worked. And they wait it worked. I don't know how.
[0:59] Katy Scoggin: So if you anyway, so now I will pay up and get anything I'm expecting credit or debit to come expedited through UPS or FedEx, so it will never touch the public mail system.
[1:12] Katy Scoggin: Wow. So now I have a 45-day fraud investigation. And they will determine if it was me or fraud that went to the ATM, even though I never got my cards.
[1:26] Katy Scoggin: Well, they will, but they have to like prove it anyway. This is not uncommon.
[1:30] Heather Vickery: Hey, hey everyone.
[1:32] Heather Vickery: Hey. Welcome to Was It Chance? The podcast about having your mail stolen and embracing opportunity and taking intentional risk for your creative life and always using a secured delivery system for credit cards.
[1:45] Alan Seales: That's right. I have a lot to say about mail theft.
[1:49] Heather Vickery: Oh, okay. Well, I'm Heather Vickery.
[1:52] Alan Seales: And I'm Alan Seales, and we started off with two perfect strangers stealing each other's mail who met by chance in a done that.
[1:58] Heather Vickery: That's illegal.
[1:59] Alan Seales: That's right. That was a that was that was satire.
[2:02] Alan Seales: We embraced opportunity. Listen in as we chat with other successful people about the risks they've taken to put themselves on a path to creative success and stop mail fraud.
[2:10] Heather Vickery: There you go. We're not gonna tell everybody who you are yet, secret guest, but what's your mail fraud story?
[2:16] Katy Scoggin: Well, somebody took out, I think it was a Best Buy credit card in my name.
[2:21] Heather Vickery: What?
[2:22] Katy Scoggin: I just had some identity theft that happened, and I think it maybe had something to do in Brooklyn with my trash and how I was recycling things with.
[2:33] Heather Vickery: Oh, I shred I shredded junk mail.
[2:35] Katy Scoggin: I shred junk mail now.
[2:36] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[2:37] Katy Scoggin: I shred anything with my name and address on it.
[2:39] Heather Vickery: Yep, yep. Or like prescription bags when I go to the pharmacy and bring them back.
[2:44] Katy Scoggin: Anything with any of that identifiable information, I shred.
[2:48] Heather Vickery: It's like getting your wallet stolen these days. It's just a lot of paperwork and time.
[2:52] Heather Vickery: So the first question we ask on the podcast is usually what is your social security number? Can you help us out with that?
[3:00] Katy Scoggin: Uh no.
[3:01] Heather Vickery: Okay. Alan, how you been?
[3:03] Alan Seales: I've been okay.
[3:04] Alan Seales: Running a nature roller coaster here in Chicago. It goes from 60 degrees to 20 degrees. Today it's 45 degrees.
[3:13] Alan Seales: Fahrenheit. We did not get the storm that you guys got.
[3:15] Heather Vickery: Oh my gosh, that storm, that blizzard was insane.
[3:18] Alan Seales: The second one was absolutely insane.
[3:21] Heather Vickery: Yeah. We got like two feet out on Long Island, and we got like a foot and a half in Brooklyn here, and it yeah, everything just shuts down, including trash pickup, and that's what stinks.
[3:33] Alan Seales: In addition to mail fraud, that's what No, no, not literally, because it's frozen.
[3:38] Alan Seales: There's frozen, it's like a giant freezer outside. So, but when it starts thawing right now today, when it's 46 degrees, now it's starting to dislike all the animal poop that melted into the snow and all the trash that was sitting under it.
[3:50] Heather Vickery: Welcome to New York City, y'all. I don't like winter. I don't want to move somewhere warm because I don't want to live in the south, but I don't like the winter.
[3:59] Heather Vickery: Maybe I could go to the Maldives or the coast of Spain.
[4:03] Alan Seales: Both very cheap places to live comparatively.
[4:06] Heather Vickery: Okay, so do you know what? Both, yeah. Well, whatever. You know what I'm most excited about for this week as a 51-year-old woman.
[4:13] Alan Seales: You are not 51, you are 25.
[4:15] Heather Vickery: I am 25.
[4:16] Alan Seales: What?
[4:17] Heather Vickery: Uh Harry Styles' new album, Kiss All the Time Disco occasionally, drops at midnight on Friday, March 6th, which is gonna be before this episode actually airs.
[4:26] Alan Seales: But you guys, we are legit excited around you.
[4:30] Heather Vickery: So, how was it? Through the magic of time trip. I'm just gonna assume it was fucking fantastic because I'm obsessed with aperture.
[4:36] Alan Seales: And it's my happy story.
[4:38] Heather Vickery: You're taking your daughter, right? One of your daughters.
[4:39] Alan Seales: Uh yeah, she doesn't know that yet.
[4:41] Heather Vickery: Oh, so it's good that we're talking about it.
[4:43] Alan Seales: So it's okay. I'm taking her to Mexico City to see the show.
[4:47] Heather Vickery: Because the tickets in New York are outrageous, even though I got a place to stay with my pal, my podcast pal.
[4:55] Alan Seales: Uh, getting there, flights to New York are just as expensive as flights to Mexico City. And the tickets were a hundred and forty dollars instead of five hundred to a thousand dollars.
[5:05] Heather Vickery: That's crazy.
[5:06] Alan Seales: Oh my god. Yeah, the garden.
[5:08] Heather Vickery: I'm so excited with the garden here. But I'm excited for the album. Like the the word, like literally, when I say to you that the world is on fire today, as the date that we're recording, which is March 4th, it actually fucking is on fire because we started a war with Iran.
[5:22] Heather Vickery: So there's actual fire everywhere, and I need a little hope core. And Harry Styles gives me hope core.
[5:28] Alan Seales: Yeah. Well, I don't know what hope core means, but I'm glad that he gives it to you.
[5:33] Heather Vickery: I don't know what gives me hope core. I just listened, I listen to podcasts now. You know what, you know what gives me hope core? I love our podcast, number one. Leave a reading and review. Tell your friends.
[5:43] Heather Vickery: Uh but also the Lonely Island Seth Myers podcast. That shit's funny.
[5:48] Alan Seales: Okay. Because it's okay. It's like real best friends, just bantering, talking it.
[5:54] Heather Vickery: It started out as like a rewatch, uh uh uh yeah, a rewatch podcast about all of the digital shorts that they did while at their time at SNL.
[6:03] Alan Seales: And it's devolved into like this behind the scenes, and just like, hey, we're gonna hang out and record it. And it's so funny.
[6:08] Heather Vickery: So the four of them are so funny. It's kind of like movie commentary. I fucking love movie commentaries.
[6:14] Alan Seales: So now I guess you have to get a DVD. I don't know how you do that, but back in the day when we didn't stream everything and we would watch a DVD, you could watch it on commentary.
[6:21] Katy Scoggin: Laser D. Does anybody know? Like, I know you guys probably know this, but like any of our listeners, like this is a real thing, and you could watch the actors watch their movie and talk about what they were doing and thinking, and I loved that.
[6:32] Alan Seales: The director's commentary, the director's cut, all those the extra scenes, the bloopers. I miss bloopers so much.
[6:36] Katy Scoggin: Me too.
[6:40] Alan Seales: Me too. You know what? Probably there aren't any bloopers in our guest documentary. That's pretty serious.
[6:48] Heather Vickery: We're gonna have to find out. So, Alan, who is speaking of filmmaking, who is our guest today?
[6:54] Alan Seales: So our guest today is Katy Scoggin, who is an award-winning documentary filmmaker, producer, and camera person, and her featured directorial debut called Flood, will broadcast on PBS Independent Lens this July 2026.
[7:09] Alan Seales: The film captures a pivotal and deeply personal moment in her family, one that reveals both closeness and profound division. It received a special mention at the international competition at the IDFA and won Best Kansas feature at the Tallgrass Film Festival in 25.
[7:25] Alan Seales: I mean, gosh, Katy. She's an honorary scholar at Washington University. She's a Fulbright Scholar at Berlin. She's a graduate assistant at cinematography at NY.
[7:33] Alan Seales: Oh my God. Dude, like Katy's. That was deep cast. Deep cast.
[7:38] Katy Scoggin: Oh. As I cough my way through the end of that, welcome to Was It Chance?
[7:46] Alan Seales: Deep Cut?
[7:47] Heather Vickery: Okay. Okay, so I have to, Katy. I'm so glad that you're here. And I have to say, for those of you who listen to our show all the time, do you remember back when we did an interview with uh I'm not gonna get her last name right, but Cara Catrusola?
[8:00] Katy Scoggin: Is that her?
[8:01] Heather Vickery: Catrusola. Okay, whatever. They invented a story because they're both from North Carolina. They invented a story that they originally met on a plane coming from North Carolina, moving to New York City.
[8:12] Heather Vickery: But Katy, you and I actually met on a plane coming from New York City back home to Chicago.
[8:18] Katy Scoggin: So there you go. Alan is full of make-believe, and I tell the truth.
[8:23] Alan Seales: Now that wasn't the truth.
[8:26] Katy Scoggin: What?
[8:27] Alan Seales: Yeah. No. You make shit up.
[8:28] Katy Scoggin: Wait, so you guys actually met on a real plane.
[8:30] Alan Seales: A real plane.
[8:31] Katy Scoggin: Yeah. Where are you going to from?
[8:33] Alan Seales: I think New York to Chicago, right?
[8:34] Katy Scoggin: We were going home to Chicago. Friday after Thanksgiving.
[8:37] Alan Seales: Oh, right. Because I you and I didn't see each other because I was out of town. You came in. I remember this.
[8:42] Katy Scoggin: Yes.
[8:42] Alan Seales: Okay. So all right. So then, Katy, you're based out of New York now.
[8:47] Katy Scoggin: Now I'm in Chicago.
[8:48] Alan Seales: You're not listening. He's not listening.
[8:49] Katy Scoggin: I was in New York for a long time, for like 19 years, but I moved here for love.
[8:55] Alan Seales: Moved to Chicago for love.
[8:56] Katy Scoggin: Gotcha.
[8:56] Alan Seales: Gotcha. To Chicago for love. Oh, do you love the city that much?
[9:00] Katy Scoggin: That's really, really nice. I love my girlfriend that much.
[9:04] Alan Seales: Oh, yeah. The city is I'm falling in love with the city more and more every day.
[9:10] Katy Scoggin: When did you actually make the move to Chicago?
[9:15] Katy Scoggin: June of last year.
[9:17] Alan Seales: Okay.
[9:23] Katy Scoggin: No in June. Like maybe. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. We're here for the spring and the fall. I mean, even the summer, but like it can get really hot, of course. But the spring and the fall in Chicago are so good.
[9:37] Alan Seales: So good. Well, I mean, it's gotta be better than New York, right?
[9:41] Katy Scoggin: I'm kind of over New York. I've been here for uh 19 and a half years now. I'm coming up. This August is gonna be 20 years in New York City.
[9:49] Alan Seales: Wow. And I'm angry and jaded enough to be a true New Yorker.
[9:54] Katy Scoggin: So where would you go?
[9:56] Alan Seales: Chicago?
[9:57] Katy Scoggin: Yeah.
[9:57] Alan Seales: Your house?
[10:00] Katy Scoggin: Yeah, come on. I'm sure Crystal would fucking love my little house compared to your fucking gorgeous, perfectly beautifully remodeled brownstone in Brooklyn.
[10:08] Alan Seales: I feel like after 20 years in New York, some New Yorkers will be so salty, they'll just be like, no, you'll never. You're never really a true New Yorker. You need another 10 years, 30 years, and you'll be in New Yorker.
[10:19] Katy Scoggin: And if you move here the next day, they're like, oh, you're a Chicagoan. Welcome to Chicago.
[10:23] Alan Seales: You're a Chicagoan now. Yay. New Yorkers are so protective. It's like coming out.
[10:28] Katy Scoggin: Yeah.
[10:30] Alan Seales: Yeah, basically. You're in. I remember when I well, and actually, this is we're gonna talk about your movie, I promise, and all about you. But I am a little bit curious um to hear if you're willing to share it, to hear kind of your coming out story.
[10:45] Katy Scoggin: But I didn't come out till I was 38. And I remember I came out to our school principal who was married to a woman, and uh I remember them both like cornering me immediately, like Heather, how do you plan to meet women?
[11:00] Katy Scoggin: I was like, whoa, whoa, this is a lot. Like they're like, come on, we're gonna take you to events, we're gonna we're gonna introduce you. They were like my lesbian, older lesbian role models, like instantly as soon as I came out, which I appreciated, but it was a lot of pressure.
[11:12] Katy Scoggin: To meet women in Chicago?
[11:16] Heather Vickery: Well, you know, like I was a mom of four and I was 38, and and these women were like, we're gonna take you under our wing, but it was like intense.
[11:24] Katy Scoggin: The community is like, come on, let's go. We gotta get you in here. We got 28 years of shit to wake up for.
[11:33] Heather Vickery: No, did you not have that experience, Katie?
[11:37] Katy Scoggin: I the the actually my I I have just a ton of bear friends and trans friends, and they have been so incredibly welcoming.
[11:49] Heather Vickery: I love that.
[11:49] Katy Scoggin: And some have been like duh, okay. We we like we knew shocker.
[11:56] Heather Vickery: How old how old were you when you came out?
[11:59] Katy Scoggin: Oh, 43.
[12:01] Heather Vickery: 43? Oh, you got me beat. I thought 38 was late. Good for you.
[12:05] Heather Vickery: Wait, wait, wait, wait. Okay, so is this is this why okay, we're talking here to talk about I mean you're talking about Flood. You have a movie out. Flood is your film, Flood. It's got the religious connotation. Your parents are highly religious. Your dad is still. Or at least your dad.
[12:18] Katy Scoggin: Yeah. Like a very uh love-hate contentious relationship, at least from what I saw in the in the documentary.
[12:26] Heather Vickery: I watched it. And uh were I guess backing uh what was the timeline between deciding to make the documentary and then there's a big family move, like they're moving across country in the documentary, but that coincides with like you trying to reconcile your relationship with him and what so where did the coming out of the move of the documentary deal all laid out timeline wise? What's the timeline here?
[12:49] Katy Scoggin: Well, I I was not out until we were pretty far along in the edit. There was something about telling a personal story and just saying, you know what?
[13:03] Katy Scoggin: Here's my take on the family tale and making that public. You can't take that back. And I did show my dad a couple of cuts of the film before we locked pictures, so before we stopped editing and then the final version as well. And he does not like the way that Christianity is portrayed in the film. Of course he does. Honestly. Truthfully and honestly, sure. In my opinion, yes. He uh he so he's not a fan of that, but there's something about the clarity that I got from that. Here's what I really think about us. I give this to you and the family as a love letter. That's my intent. I want to figure out how to love you and kind of take it or leave it in a way, since it's a film can is like this indelible piece of work.
Yeah. And there's a lot of clarity in the response that comes from that, and that's freeing. And so I get to be me now. There's no, I don't need there's so happy for you. Even if I don't get approval for who I am and how I show up in the world, mic drop. What's the opening right there? Yeah. Like, I don't, I think I don't, I'm not seeking it. I don't need it. I know I'm not gonna get it. And so here I am just being me. Being me anyway. And the movie took like 10 years to make. I was it's like a 75 minute script. Okay, we're gonna have to decade really all the way in there. But I have to say this. I have to say this before I forget. Because I'm with your friends. So I've seen I I've seen the movie, and um you show a video of you in college, and I just assumed that you came out in college.
I mean, you looked queer, you sounded queer. That's right, I love you, but I'm with your friends, like, oh yeah, no, we knew this. I was expressing, I was figuring out my the body was figuring out how Katie wanted to be and express Katie. But in terms of my orientation, my embracing of my sexuality, that was still locked up and buried. Wow. So you you I guess you were burying it. So, like, did you date through date men through all life, high school, college, and whatnot? Pretty much. Yeah, didn't you? My partner and I had a summer fling a long time ago. Oh, and now we've come back together. Yeah. We don't need to make this episode all about your sexuality. I'm just gonna talk about my love life.
And because we we haven't um we've met a couple times, but um, this big deep in-depth conversation. Um, yeah, we'll have to have cocktails and actually have this private conversation. So, okay. But I'll bring your microphone, you can have the private conversation. Ellen is a voyeur. He wants he's into the voyeurist of his life. Um, okay. So I let's go back to like your your filmmaking roots, like you're younger. Like what led you to this? You've done a ton of work on some well-known multiple films and documentaries. And like, let's kind of get the the background of what brought you here. And also, you know, filter in where you want 10 years in the documentary process with flood. Sure. How getting into docs.
Let's see. I I so I I did go to film school in New York City, actually. I went to NYU in the graduate program, and I interned on a fiction feature movie. And that experience showed me that docs, I wanted to get back into documentary. I had I I went into my schooling to become a better documentarian, and I felt like I got spat out, more of a fiction filmmaker. And I went to one of my teachers and said, Can I please, do you know anybody? I'll do anything. And she hooked me up with a filmmaker named Laura Poitras, who needed an intern. And I ended up just staying on working for Laura for about six years. So I went from being an intern during a summer project to helping to finish a movie called The Oath, and then was present and very active in a movie called Citizen Four.
So I kind of cut my teeth working on documentaries about America's war on terror, about the global surveillance machine. Um, learned a lot about encryption and PGP and protecting data and journalists and sources. And after Citizen Four came out in 2015, it also won an Oscar. So I was kind of on the coattails, but also a part of a team of this like really big project. I then wanted to, I wanted to make my own work. I wanted to, I wanted to direct. And the nearest story to me was just the personal story. I wanted to kind of look at creationism versus evolution and science nerd topics. I was raised as a young earth creationist, which is a person who believes that the book of Genesis is to be taken literally and that evolution is not real and the earth was created in six 24-hour days.
Evolution, which kind of blew my mind in college, is is evol is evolution and geologic time. And so I wanted to look at those topics and started writing fiction material initially. Um, but then started calling my dad, doing research and began slowly recording phone calls and then kind of tiptoed my way backwards into this thing that became a personal documentary. But the initial impulse was just to find something that was more personally interesting to me, and then tiptoe forward from there. We're gonna take a quick break. Stay tuned for more of the episode. And now we're back. And so was it at that point in college where you were introduced to evolution that you started to deconstruct from Christianity?
Oh, yeah. Yeah. It it was it, yeah. I didn't see another way to come away from some of the beliefs, but you can't argue once you see geologic time and like the depth of time, you can't unsee it. And once you understand that there's just no way that something like Noah's Flood, I mean, Ellen, you're looking like what? Yeah. It seems crazy. You said something though that fascinates me. And you use the exact terms that believe that the earth was created in six 24-hour days. And that reminds me when I was in high school, I had an earth science teacher who was super Christian. And I remember asking her once, how do you reconcile all of this with your Christian beliefs? And she said, and I remember this really blowing my mind, um, we don't know what a day was to God.
A day to God could have been a million years. Good way to rationalize it. And I'm like, okay, you can make that shit work for yourself there. Like I still am I have a hard time with believing all of this, you know, made up nonsense, but I get that. Like I can I can go with that. But how in God's name? And I don't even believe in God. 24 hours, really, like it's a stretch. Yeah. It's like a it's one, it's one piece of the of the evangelical fundamentalist puzzle. It's all it all has to kind of fit together. And and it's and if you're raised that way, you know, in the 90s, this was kind of mostly pre-internet, no small screens. Yeah, and I was out of college before the iPhone was released. Me too.
Same. I mean, major benefits to that too, right? Oh, of course. Wow. Yeah. But I but in terms of like information and and belief systems, I I really believed, I really believed it. And then at that was deconstructed at university by this awesome lecturer. There was this guy who he was an anthropologist. He taught in an inter to human evolution class. And he would always spend one lecture talking about Noah's flood. I think he knew he had some young earth creationist students in class. And this was also around a time when school boards were suing to teach intelligent design in schools around America. So it was kind of it was a little bit in the news at the time too. Not it's not the dark days that we live in now that way, but it was it was in the news a little bit.
And so he would talk about young earth creationism and approach it. And just hearing someone that I had trusted as this intellectual teacher reframe this concept I had never questioned, like turned my little 20-year-old world upside down. And I went around stumbling around, just being like, wait, the flood could not have happened. And if the flood didn't happen, then there was no Noah. And if there was no Noah, then who was telling him to build the Ark? And if there's no God, then you know. Well, so the reason I look like I was hit by a truck, um because nothing computes. Um I I grew up in the Bible belt of North Carolina as a non religious person myself, and but all the people I I got all my religious um exposure through dating the girls in the area, and to be cool with the parents, I had to go to church with them, and I would sit in these churches like, you fucking hypocrites.
Like I was seventh grade, sixth grade, eighth grade, whatever. And I was like, this doesn't make any sense. You're like, you love all and accept all, unless I'm anywhere different from you. Anyway, so I had I had one girlfriend, I was like, So, where did where do you think dinosaurs came from? Like, like that was a test. It's a test of your faith. God put dinosaur bones there to test your faith. And it there's an answer for everything. Yes. Yeah, there's an answer for everything. And so that goes into like in documentary. You've got some of your in flood, you've got footage of your niece, like just spouting off religious dogma, like it's drink is natural as drinking water. And it it like, like you said, you were in your 20s when you started to question this.
And when you're I get what am I getting at? I'm I'm just I'm I'm talking around the fact that like it doesn't make sense that you can go through that much. It doesn't make sense to me that you can go through that much of your life. I guess, well, I guess it makes sense if you're in an echo chamber. But like, how can you how did you go through that much of your life? Like if everything was just natural, everything was just had uh had an answer, there was a justification for everything, or was there always kind of like a nagging feeling that like something was a little different? Because also the end, the big elephant in the room for me still is how is your father, one of the most religious people we know, also a science teacher?
Yeah, we gotta come back to that. Answer that other question because I have so much I want to ask about this the science component with religion in flood. But sorry, there was a lot to unpack. I think that there was stuff that I questioned. The stuff I took most umbrage with was the gender stuff, the kind of baked in misogyny. I saw it in my parents' marriage. I saw it in the way that women and girls were talked about. That was enraging to me as a young person. And that was my fight. It didn't, it didn't go to the level of questioning whether God was real or not. That was it hadn't even seemed possible. It reminds me of a thing from I've probably mentioned it a gazillion times in the show, because I bring it up a lot from Trevor Noah's book, Born of Crime.
He said you can't dream of things you've never imagined. And if that b concept that God doesn't exist is beyond imagining, like it doesn't have it can't be possible. Yeah. Yeah. Those and those structures and beliefs, I mean, what happened at home behind closed doors and in church, that those were those structures were as powerful as learning how to read and write in school. I would say for me as a young person growing up. There were some of those things I just I didn't question because there was a I was living within some kind of framework. Right. That didn't push back. Well, and you weren't okay. So this is where the science question comes up for me that's interesting. From what I understand, I was not raised in a religious household at all. But from what I understand of this deep evangelical or or any organized religion is that you're really not supposed to question.
[26:08] Katy Scoggin: You're just supposed to trust.
[26:09] Alan Seales: Yeah.
[26:10] Katy Scoggin: But in your movie, you talk, there's a scene, and I don't want to give anything away, y'all gotta watch it, but there's a scene with your nephew and two, I think, scientists.
[26:19] Alan Seales: I thought they were scientists.
[26:20] Katy Scoggin: Oh, that's great. Who were really talking about, well, you gotta do your research on that and you gotta ask your questions.
[26:25] Alan Seales: And I was like, this is so counterfucking intuitive to everything else that you're saying.
[26:30] Katy Scoggin: And he was asking questions and they were like, oh, we don't know. We didn't research it.
[26:36] Alan Seales: I was like, oh my God, good job. Good on you, nephew.
[26:39] Katy Scoggin: Yeah, but your nephew is religious.
[26:43] Alan Seales: He’s, I would say maybe agnostic.
[26:47] Katy Scoggin: I mean, he was a teenager at the time, but he was of that younger generation, much more questioning.
[26:55] Alan Seales: Okay.
[26:56] Katy Scoggin: He was much more questioning, and he had more input coming in from his, especially from his dad, my sister's former husband.
[27:05] Alan Seales: And he was getting more inputs and he was getting a more pluralistic upbringing.
[27:11] Katy Scoggin: And it was later in time and the like the strictures had been relaxed. My folks, when we were little, they were also part of this organization.
[27:18] Alan Seales: It used to be called Campus Crusade for Christ.
[27:21] Katy Scoggin: So that structure and that community was strong. I mean, there were some loving and beautiful things about it, but boy, the ideology, really, really powerful.
[27:33] Alan Seales: I would say, especially on young people, little kids growing up in it.
[27:37] Katy Scoggin: Your nephew also had iPhones.
[27:39] Alan Seales: I mean, going back to that, like he was of that generation where he could just ask his questions immediately right away and get unbiased answers.
[27:47] Katy Scoggin: Yes.
[27:47] Alan Seales: I quote, quote unquote, unbiased, right?
[27:49] Katy Scoggin: I would not, I yeah, I didn't feel permission to show up that way in the world at that age that he does.
[27:58] Alan Seales: So do you think that's a benefit for younger people growing up in these cult-like religions that they have the access?
[28:05] Katy Scoggin: Cause I don't know. Some of these kids double down.
[28:08] Alan Seales: These young girls trying to start a Turning Point USA organization in our super liberal public high school, like what?
[28:16] Katy Scoggin: You have access to all the information right there.
[28:20] Alan Seales: It's complicated.
[28:21] Katy Scoggin: Yeah.
[28:23] Alan Seales: There can be a lot of doubling down.
[28:25] Katy Scoggin: I think you would have to encounter other viewpoints and be around people that don't see and think and act exactly the way that you do in lockstep.
[28:38] Alan Seales: Folks that are more exposed to other points of view, other ways of life, and see those as legitimate as well, are far more likely to move away from the kind of fundamentalist or, as you say, the cult-like way of being.
[28:55] Katy Scoggin: But you gotta get, which it's totally fine.
[28:59] Alan Seales: Um yeah, it's these groups have power over their members too, and the internet is crazy.
[29:08] Katy Scoggin: So let's, I'm gonna put a pause, let's put a pause in the religion discussion here for a second.
[29:14] Alan Seales: Because I'm gonna bring the conversation back to a little bit earlier and then we'll come back to Flood because it all makes sense.
[29:19] Katy Scoggin: I promise.
[29:20] Alan Seales: We're doing this memoir style where you can just like pick and choose the order.
[29:23] Katy Scoggin: Yeah, yeah.
[29:24] Alan Seales: Um, no, like so.
[29:26] Katy Scoggin: Going back then, growing up in this household, um, uh, when did you, religion aside, family aside, when did you decide to get into filmmaking?
[29:35] Alan Seales: When did you know that that was something you wanted to do?
[29:38] Katy Scoggin: That was in college. I was an art school kid and trying to figure out what's my medium.
[29:46] Alan Seales: You know, am I a painter? Am I a drawer?
[29:49] Katy Scoggin: Is a drawer a thing? Am I a drawer? An artist?
[29:55] Alan Seales: Or am I, yeah, but what kind of artist?
[29:58] Katy Scoggin: Are you a painter? Do you draw like a sketch art?
[29:58] Alan Seales: Yeah, yeah, we are podcast artists.
[29:58] Katy Scoggin: Podcasts? Alan's a podcast artist.
[29:58] Alan Seales: You are.
[29:58] Katy Scoggin: I have fun, so I'm a part of um the, okay, I got into video. I got into video art and then kind of did look back.
[29:58] Alan Seales: Okay, yeah.
[29:58] Katy Scoggin: And then found, eventually found my way toward film, like storytelling, dramatic storytelling and documentary, but with working with real people and just found docs.
[29:58] Alan Seales: I'm just wondering where the Vendigram of this happens.
[29:58] Katy Scoggin: Okay, so you're in art school, which normally is liberals and traditionally more open-minded people and open to new experiences and things, right?
[29:58] Alan Seales: So like coming out of, coming into college again, like I'm just kind of looking for like what it seems like you always just had that little bit of curiosity of like I just want to be around people that see things a little bit bigger, if that makes sense, right?
[29:58] Katy Scoggin: So like you get into college, decide you want to do art, like what is it about that though that made you fall in love with? Was it the people? Was it the expression? Was it the ability to just create whatever you wanted to create instead of being told what to create?
[29:58] Katy Scoggin: Yes, and the idea of uh practice, having an artistic practice.
[29:58] Alan Seales: So going into that studio space, a pretty solitary practice and solitary space and letting the hands do the work.
[29:58] Katy Scoggin: Like as a visual artist, I really love shutting my brain off, shutting out the ideas, including ideology, and just kind of thinking, working in a gut-based level, just with my hands, making stuff and seeing what came.
[31:37] Alan Seales: Or the content that's that you have available to you.
[31:40] Katy Scoggin: Yeah.
[31:41] Alan Seales: Yeah.
[31:42] Katy Scoggin: Yeah. Working through things I'm learning in classes, but using my hands to do so through sculptures and drawings and paintings and stuff like that.
[31:49] Alan Seales: And then eventually like kind of finding my way to the video camera and observing and listening to people and making some kind of art out of that.
[31:59] Katy Scoggin: But the flow that you get into as an artist and also the practice, that kind of padding of your life around your artistic practice.
[32:06] Alan Seales: So you have maybe a space that you go to if you have a studio or, and I did it when I was a major in college.
[32:13] Katy Scoggin: I had an art studio as a sculpture major that was really important.
[32:17] Alan Seales: Having that space and time to just make that work.
[32:22] Katy Scoggin: That was pretty awesome for me.
[32:25] Alan Seales: And now you've had your fingers sort of in, from what I can see, like every element.
[32:33] Katy Scoggin: You've been behind the camera, you've done the editing, you've done the directing.
[32:36] Alan Seales: I don't know if you've done script writing and for a doc, that's not really a thing.
[32:39] Katy Scoggin: But um, what's your favorite?
[32:43] Alan Seales: Ooh, I think the camera work, that's the quickest way into flow.
[32:49] Katy Scoggin: Okay.
[32:53] Alan Seales: Yeah, because you have a tunnel.
[32:56] Katy Scoggin: You're framing stuff.
[32:58] Alan Seales: Yeah.
[32:58] Katy Scoggin: And so you catch yourself doing that like in your life.
[33:01] Alan Seales: Like you're walking around the streets of Chicago and you're like, I'm seeing this through this imaginary camera lens.
[33:07] Katy Scoggin: I think I do, yeah.
[33:08] Alan Seales: Yeah.
[33:09] Katy Scoggin: I don't, well, what I do, what I do here is I'll try to notice.
[33:12] Alan Seales: I'm trying to learn all the trees in my neighborhood.
[33:14] Katy Scoggin: So it's this focus on one individual thing.
[33:17] Alan Seales: Tom, yeah, what's this leaf?
[33:19] Katy Scoggin: Yeah.
[33:19] Alan Seales: Yeah.
[33:20] Katy Scoggin: As opposed to like the lantern seeing everything.
[33:24] Alan Seales: It's a focus.
[33:25] Katy Scoggin: But with film, what I really like about documentary camera work and verite, this kind of cinema verite is this observational filmmaking where you're observing folks and just go through their lives, and you're led by your ears, you listen to what people say, and you're listening for a scene or something that feels like a dramatic moment that could actually be used in a film.
[33:48] Alan Seales: And then you have to frame it properly.
[33:50] Katy Scoggin: So you have to get coverage, what we call coverage, different types of shot sizes, hopefully matching so that if people are in dialogue with each other, an editor or you, if you're editing, can cut that work together and string it into, you know, the kind of the grammar of visual storytelling.
[34:10] Alan Seales: It's just like, it's cool.
[34:12] Katy Scoggin: That is cool.
[34:13] Alan Seales: That's cool.
[34:14] Katy Scoggin: I like that.
[34:14] Alan Seales: Uh, I mean, I'm, I feel the same about like just audio podcasting, creating a world, right?
[34:19] Katy Scoggin: And I totally get that.
[34:22] Alan Seales: And part of why, like me personally, as a straight cis white man, um, I still didn't quite fit in with your jocks and your like let's go vandalize and be stupid and idiotic, kind of like typical, you know, like stereotypical boy stuff, if for lack of a better term.
[34:38] Katy Scoggin: And so I found my home in theater as well, theater and performing, and because it was just people who just like wanted to accept each other.
[34:46] Alan Seales: And then while being accepted just for who you are, you still get to create an influence and make other people happy.
[34:52] Katy Scoggin: So I'm right there with you on that one.
[34:55] Alan Seales: Awesome.
[34:56] Katy Scoggin: I think that it is such an interesting thing to almost train your brain to see things in that way.
[35:04] Alan Seales: I'm not sure.
[35:05] Katy Scoggin: I think I'm a much more bigger picture person.
[35:08] Alan Seales: I don't know that I have that skill, but you know, we can't, we shouldn't all have the same skills.
[35:14] Katy Scoggin: So the premise of this show is, was it chance?
[35:18] Alan Seales: Like take things that um opportunities that you take kind of out of left field that guided you down a path or things that happened that if that hadn't happened, you wouldn't be where you are.
[35:28] Katy Scoggin: Now, obviously, this um science class in school, right, where you learned about evolution was one of one such thing for you, because that changed your the direction of your path.
[35:40] Alan Seales: But as far as actually being in film, being a documentarian, being a filmmaker, what was the thing do you think that was the chance encounter or the opportunity that you took or maybe didn't take that led you down this path?
[35:53] Katy Scoggin: Into film like as a medium and a pathway.
[36:00] Katy Scoggin: It probably started. It started when I picked up a video camera, I think, and just started using that as an artistic medium with video.
[36:11] Alan Seales: I was making weird video art that was non-narrative and like as a kid.
[36:16] Katy Scoggin: As a college kid.
[36:16] Alan Seales: As a college kid.
[36:20] Katy Scoggin: Wasn't till the, because we never had a video camera growing up.
[36:23] Alan Seales: When we, when relatives would visit, they would they would bring theirs and we would use them.
[36:27] Katy Scoggin: But it was figuring out that medium, and then everything kind of led from there.
[36:33] Alan Seales: Then going into documentary and going into like the field that I've been in was more about relationships.
[36:40] Katy Scoggin: That getting an internship with someone who happened to be this incredible filmmaker and basically walking into the apprenticeship of a lifetime with this person who was wise, who knew everything about the field and the craft.
[36:58] Alan Seales: I kind of unlearned a lot of what I'd learned in school when I was working in the field for Laura.
[37:04] Katy Scoggin: So having like a really awesome apprenticeship for years.
[37:08] Alan Seales: The fact that I worked with her was, I would say mostly chance.
[37:13] Katy Scoggin: I just happened to ask a teacher, hey, I I just had this internship on a fiction film.
[37:18] Alan Seales: I was pretty unhappy there.
[37:20] Katy Scoggin: I coiled cables for a month and I wasn't allowed to touch the sandbags because they weren't in my department.
[37:25] Alan Seales: And I want to do more creative.
[37:27] Katy Scoggin: Can you please, like I want to be able to wear more hats?
[37:27] Alan Seales: I want to be able to have an experience that feels more like what I'm doing with my classmates in film school where we actually help each other out and work on each other's movies and it's more collaborative and fun.
[37:40] Katy Scoggin: Is there a way to do this?
[37:41] Alan Seales: And documentaries actually was a way to do that because you're so low budget that you end up having to do five jobs, whether you want to or not.
[37:50] Katy Scoggin: And so it just ends up being more collaborative.
[37:53] Alan Seales: But that was definitely, that was pretty chancy, I would say, just saying, hey, can you give me, do me a solid?
[37:58] Katy Scoggin: And then she's like, okay, I've got something for you, Katie.
[38:01] Alan Seales: Don't screw this up.
[38:03] Katy Scoggin: I had no idea who this person was that she was connecting me to.
[38:06] Alan Seales: So just asking a teacher, like, hey, help here.
[38:10] Katy Scoggin: So that I love that because that comes around a lot for us on this show and in my work in manifestation and creation and taking radical responsibility for your life.
[38:18] Alan Seales: Like, and I say this all like manifestation isn't declaring something, then it magically appears.
[38:23] Katy Scoggin: Manifestation is declaring something and then shifting the way you show up in the world to make it appear.
[38:27] Alan Seales: So that does mean you have to make the ask.
[38:30] Katy Scoggin: You have to be in the places where opportunities present themselves.
[38:34] Alan Seales: Um if I hadn't had a pretty miserable experience working on a film as an intern, I wouldn't have had that ask.
[38:44] Katy Scoggin: I had to, I had to try something, go in a direction, sit with it, understand, man.
[38:54] Alan Seales: I love the practice of film, but what I'm doing right here, I'm like this tiny cog in a wheel.
[39:02] Katy Scoggin: This is not, this doesn't, I'm not suited to this as a person. There's something in my gut that's saying this, this is not a way for you to contribute creatively to the world the way that you want to. Okay, let's try something else. Ask for help. I mean, as a student, you're at a hopefully you have teachers that are kind of looking out for you.
[39:23] Alan Seales: We're gonna take a quick break. Stay tuned for more of the episode.
[39:27] Katy Scoggin: And now we're back. You know, when you're at a crossroads, right? A teacher can kind of make a break or create a sliding doors moment for you. So, like, do you think if you hadn't have worked with her, what do you think you would have done instead?
[39:40] Katy Scoggin: Oh. You know, I honestly, if I hadn't done that, I don't know that I would have stayed in the field. I might have gone into teaching, you know, I might have because that happened to be an opportunity that just took me on this journey making these really awesome works. And there aren't that was a unique filmmaker that I was working for.
[40:11] Katy Scoggin: So maybe I would have started much earlier with my own work. Maybe I would have made my own feature or documentary or short film that was my work at an earlier stage in life. Maybe that would have happened. So my daughter is a film and cinema major at the University of Washington in Seattle. I think you and I might have talked about that on the plane. But um she has done a couple of shorts already and even had a whole big premiere like the whole class did right.
[40:45] Alan Seales: But um that's pretty cool.
[40:47] Katy Scoggin: That's interesting. Yeah. I don't know what advice would you give to a student like my daughter. She's about to graduate. She doesn't know what she's committed to being a filmmaker. Amazing. What the fuck does that even mean? I don't know what part, you know, like she write, direct, produce she doesn't she can be behind the camera but that's not her specialty. That's not what she's focusing on.
[41:05] Katy Scoggin: Um what is hers she she wants to write and direct. That's what she wants to do.
[41:14] Alan Seales: Yeah.
[41:15] Katy Scoggin: Awesome. And she has done a couple of those a couple shorts and um small things like that. But like looking back, I mean I think it's a totally different world now but like what kind of places do people need to be in if they want to make this their career because it feels really pie in the sky and I am a very supportive parent. I like go out and make your dreams come true but also how the fuck do you make this a career?
[41:40] Katy Scoggin: Yeah yeah yeah well it's not yeah it's very challenging I think especially now I think your classmates and your colleagues the people that you actually work and collaborate with well are your best asset. Film is just inherently collaborative and the work gets exponentially better if you work together with other people.
[42:10] Katy Scoggin: If you're a young person and you're inherently low budget, you can barter with your friends. You can do work trades and you can work together. Uming how to get through creative conflicts, come out on the other side and still preserve friendships, I think is worth its weight in gold. That's huge.
[42:30] Katy Scoggin: Um, so kind of finding your people that understand and see you and that you love collaborating with, especially as a writer director, you're gonna want to be able to take and accept feedback that's really tender. And so if you have people that you trust whose feedback you can take and who can give you feedback without bulldozing you and crushing your spirit, that's huge.
[42:53] Katy Scoggin: So finding those people, I think that for a young person telling stories and making art, any theater, film, any kind of art, there's some kind of gut inside of you that knows the story it wants to tell. Like the your gut knows. So trusting and figuring out a way to trust that gut.
[43:18] Katy Scoggin: Like for me, I was as a person who came out very late in life, like there were parts of myself that I probably just wasn't seeing and trusting. And so, as a young person, if you can see and trust your inner creative spirit, that means that you'll be able to make good work right away and trusting that.
[43:39] Katy Scoggin: Um, I think for filmmakers, mise on, I I like to talk about mise en place. You know how chefs will have this kind of prep work that they do in the kitchen where ingredients are chopped and put into bowls or they're sorted or things are prepped. If you can do that as a filmmaker and you have all your tools and your kit organized around you so that when you need to work, you have everything kind of prepped.
[44:06] Katy Scoggin: That can help a lot. I mean, that's for me mostly as a camera person. Like if I'm carrying gear and stuff, I have to know where everything is so I can use it. But as a writer-director, um, that might be setting up your workspace so that when you're using your script writing software or when you're prepping it scenes, you have everything kind of set out for yourself. That kind of mise en place that I think applies to filmmakers and up to here.
[44:30] Alan Seales: Yeah, I like that.
[44:31] Katy Scoggin: Yeah, that's been that's been a good one for me to use. And then in terms of the sustainability part of it, it's not a sustainable field. And it's actually it's cracking open and re-envisioning itself right now as we're as we're seeing increased use of AI, as we're seeing streamers um take a lot of power and money. It becomes more challenging and difficult for the individual artist, but that's where that scrappiness and heart working on projects that can sustain you for a long time.
[45:08] Katy Scoggin: If it takes your daughter six to 10 years to get a feature made, she should make sure that she's telling a story that will sit with her and also be relevant to her and her audience for that long. That's important. Being scrappy and tenacious and getting side gigs for sure. We don't have to work entirely in film.
[45:29] Katy Scoggin: Yeah. Teaching can be a great pathway for a lot of people teaching college or teaching in schools, and then also, and then you have time, you have that baked in time to like make actual work.
[45:42] Alan Seales: Yeah, I love that.
[45:43] Katy Scoggin: During semester breaks and stuff. So you had mentioned thank you for all of that. For those listening, or if you know anybody else, not just not just my kids, she won't listen to my show, but and she also doesn't like to listen to me because I'm a mother, but whatever.
[45:56] Katy Scoggin: Um you mentioned that it took you like uh like 10 years to make Flood. So it started, I I heard we heard you say, like just kind of recording phone calls. At what point were you like, oh, this is a story that I want to tell in some sort of completeness? And you started to pull these pieces together that is now this full completed film.
[46:17] Katy Scoggin: Yeah. That at a certain point it became clear that I just needed to stop avoiding making a project about my relationship to my dad and my family, and just do it. That was pretty that was pretty scary because if you're as an artist who's kind of a behind the camera artist, that's my safe place. Being in front of the camera was not, and I was really reticent to tell something that was so vulnerable and personal, but that just that was where the creative gut was leading me.
[46:59] Katy Scoggin: And so that was where I went. Well, then that probably happened. That happened out in the fossil in the fossil fields when I was talking to these paleontologists who were like, why don't you just call your dad?
[47:10] Katy Scoggin: Like science nerd. Right, right. Well, that's that's how it starts.
[47:14] Alan Seales: That's how it starts out. Like, were you sorry if I missed this? Did did you were you out there for another reason with the paleontologists?
[47:23] Katy Scoggin: I was I was just working on telling the story a different way. I was kind of in the early kind of like research and development phases of let's figure out a way to tell the story about a woman fighting with her dad about the age of the earth.
[47:41] Katy Scoggin: Sure. Is it a fiction project? Is this script research? Is this gonna be a podcast? I don't know. I was just kind of doing research and I had a microphone with me and was recording these guys' voices.
[47:53] Alan Seales: Right.
[47:54] Katy Scoggin: Yeah. I didn't know which direction the project was gonna go. Mostly I wanted to learn well, what is this? Like, how old is this chalk? And why do you find all these giant big ass bony fish fossils here in the middle of Kansas? Like, tell me the actual story. If I was raised to believe, well, of course you find fish fossils in Kansas, the flood. If I no longer believe that, I'm here and we are looking at fish fossils and shark's teeth in the prairie. Tell me the real story of where this stuff came from.
[48:30] Katy Scoggin: So the guys tell me all of this. You walk down one foot, you're going back 10,000 years in time. It's the Cretaceous era. So this is like 60, 120 million years ago.
[48:41] Katy Scoggin: Wow. All of Kansas was a sea. It was like Western interior seaway.
[48:46] Katy Scoggin: So I'm learning all this stuff, and I'm seeing it, and it's so cool. And I just really wish that my dad was there because he's such a freaking science nerd. He would have loved it. Except he wouldn't have believed it.
[48:59] Alan Seales: Well, how wouldn't have believed it?
[49:01] Katy Scoggin: Yeah.
[49:02] Katy Scoggin: How does he it was really fast? Alan and I were both watching the movie simultaneously. And that was by kind of by accident. And so we're texting, and I'm like, wait, wait, wait. Her dad's a fucking science teacher. Like, I'm like, how can you do both of those things?
[49:19] Katy Scoggin: Yeah. Well, he in the public schools in um in San Bernardino where he was teaching. He was a great science teacher. He was teaching math and uh like Newtonian physics and stuff like that, chemistry, and uh, I mean, I I filmed in his class a lot during the year.
[49:40] Katy Scoggin: We didn't use much of the footage, but I learned I I feel like I'm better at uh at simple math now because I spent a year in that classroom. So they were he was teaching stuff that doesn't ask questions about geologic time. He was not teaching climate change, he was teaching engineering, right?
[49:59] Katy Scoggin: He was teaching really great skills to these kids, and he was a gifted teacher, but at that age, you can sideline stuff like evolution. Whereas if he were teaching high school biology, it's in the curriculum.
[50:13] Katy Scoggin: Like you have to you you gotta talk about evolution, you know. I mean, I I'm sure there are plenty of creationist high school biology teachers who sidestep that in America, but in California, you'd have to be teaching evolution, right?
[50:27] Alan Seales: Right.
[50:28] Katy Scoggin: So he's teaching fourth grade.
[50:29] Alan Seales: So then you had to teach evolution.
[50:31] Katy Scoggin: You took a chance to start recording these conversations, figure out what you wanted to tell. Took a chance to turn it inward towards yourself and your family, and uh I guess the biggest chance was just like kind of putting the focus on the patriarch of this family, right?
[50:48] Katy Scoggin: And and did who did you tell first that you were gonna do this?
[50:54] Katy Scoggin: Oh, my friend Karen.
[50:56] Alan Seales: Hey Karen.
[50:57] Katy Scoggin: Now Karen has to listen to the episode. What's up, Karen? Karen was my lifeline.
[51:02] Katy Scoggin: Oh, she was my lifeline. She's uh, she's also an artist. She comes from a Mormon background and is out of, she's no longer Mormon. So she and I had this kind of like shared, alternate, very slightly different, but like very similar background.
[51:19] Katy Scoggin: So we connected a lot. She is a radio journalist. She's a uh a radio producer. And at the time she was freelancing for all the big radio shows.
[51:33] Katy Scoggin: She and I, so I talked to her about it. In fact, she interviewed me a couple of times because we were just working on this creative project together. She was like, let me interview you, Katie, and then maybe you'll be able to get some interesting tape. And who knows, maybe I can pitch like a spec radio show to a show or something.
[51:51] Katy Scoggin: So she became this person that I would tell everything to. And we would record our conversations, and um, she became she became my lifeline.
[52:01] Katy Scoggin: And she was a total because she was this person who got what I was doing, who didn't have any, she wasn't trying to guide me or take anything from me. She was listening. She was a cheerleader, she was my friend, she got me, and she was on the journey, just like this is so curious. Tell me more about what you're going through, tell me what's happening. Oh my god, you're talking to my dad. She has, as so many of us do, like tensions with her own family of origin because of her background. And so maybe she was like experiencing vicariously through me what it's like to like take on the family patriarch, you know?
[52:40] Alan Seales: What was it like to officially tell your family I'm turning this into a doc?
[52:41] Katy Scoggin: Oh, I've used I used a little bit of my mom's audio the, uh, uh, when I pitched the filming it was kind of a it was a bit of a pitch not the way you would pitch a film to an investor more like you have to ask permission you can't just like no right yeah you can't use the photographer's edict with your family of you know it's better to ask for forgiveness than permission because if you're with your family and you have a camera you you have to communicate about it and for me it was on the phone I had been talking to my dad about evolution creationism and also underneath that like I'm mad you know anger was kind of coming out for like a year and after that I at that point I said you know I would like to be really nice to do a little bit of filming with you and then maybe I could come into your classroom and he was hesitant but he said yes pretty quickly my mom was even more hesitant and when I was filming would often be like get that thing away from me but everybody was pretty chill I don't and when you film with your family they may not believe that you're ever going to actually finish the thing but yeah they were actually they don't realize how long it takes to to do all this but uh yeah I guess what I was what I was trying to trying to dig into a little bit earlier was like who's the first person you told in your family uh and and how did they react to it?
[54:16] Alan Seales: Because I I guess did you tell them or what did you tell them it was going to be filmed about?
[54:22] Katy Scoggin: What was the subject that you told them they were going to be in it about? That's a terrible question. You know what I mean?
[54:30] Alan Seales: He's just wanting to good question.
[54:32] Katy Scoggin: It's a good question. It's hard to with dad, it was I want to it was some version of I want to figure out how to love you. I I wanna I wanna I want to be able to um be closer to you somehow. I want to I just wanna see how you teach and I want to watch you in the classroom. Um I want to spend some time together, like do a project together. But that has nothing to do with religion or or dogma or ideology or anything. So like how whether or not you believe in the flood.
[55:12] Alan Seales: Right.
[55:12] Katy Scoggin: So how did I don't think I was asking about that?
[55:14] Alan Seales: Yeah, yeah.
[55:15] Katy Scoggin: Cause I will I knew I knew like I know I was never gonna change him on religion, but I was curious how is it that you what what are you teaching in the classroom? Like how how did I can't wrap my head around it anymore? And like at that stage, it's like, okay, at the time I was like in my mid-30s, so I'm like, I'm so far away from the religious background, I don't even remember what it felt like fully to be that religious, and I've changed in that regard. So, like, what's it like for you? What is it like in the classroom for your students?
[55:50] Alan Seales: So we we didn't have that deep of a conversation either.
[55:54] Katy Scoggin: Right.
[55:54] Alan Seales: So we're like, can I do this?
[55:56] Katy Scoggin: Yeah.
[55:56] Alan Seales: Okay. Well, so that's the question. So at what point did you realize you had all this footage and you you wanted to start editing it together?
[56:03] Katy Scoggin: And because I I'm what I'm hearing is you didn't necessarily know that your focus was gonna be on, for lack of a better term, the flood, right? I mean, that's what the movie is called, flood in this belief system versus science. And um, and then you put this movie together. At what point did you say to him or anyone in your family, this is this is going to be a movie and this is what it's about?
[56:25] Katy Scoggin: Probably, hmm. Well, we didn't have a lot of those conversations. It kind of developed over time. The move took over in the filming. We didn't talk a lot about what it was going to be about. After a certain time, I was almost going back to visit the family on a monthly basis. And it became part of our sort of it became my practice going on monthly trips back home, observing with the camera, going into the classroom, watching life unfold, using the camera as a mechanism to kind of get closer to dad and ask these questions, like on the there were a couple hikes that we took where those were more slightly more formal, kind of almost interview conversation settings. The closest we got to interview, where we're actually in motion on a hike, talking about these tough things like marriage, age of the earth, um, religion, fundamentalism.
Why does religion have to be so fundamental? Why can't like all faiths be chill? Why can't we be chill with this, Dad? Like, why can't you also be an atheist? At that time when I was collecting the footage, until I got into the edit, like the film was about, it was clearly about like the family and our relationships and how the religion, the fundamentalist nature of my dad's beliefs kind of isolate him from the rest of the family. But I wasn't saying that to him. I was asking questions about what are your beliefs so that I can understand them.
[57:57] Alan Seales: Right.
[57:58] Katy Scoggin: So it wasn't until the edit that I sort of figured more like what the film was like in a in a smaller container going to be about. So, like in the practice of going, it was just like, oh, Katie's here. We're going to be filming it. And you know, I would just show up in the classroom and the principal was nice enough to let me in. And we got into this practice of spending time together because I was filming. And it actually gave us this way to spend way more time together than we ever have in my adult life. So there was actually something nice about just, I think he liked the fact that I was just hanging out with him.
[58:31] Alan Seales: Yeah.
[58:32] Katy Scoggin: I'm sure.
[58:32] Alan Seales: And what I'm a parent. When did you show them the finished film? Have you shown them the finished picture yet?
[58:36] Katy Scoggin: Yeah, my mom watched a whole bunch of cuts along during the editing process. She was quite quite the ally. That felt really good to show my mom cuts of the movie as we went along. And dad, I showed my family before we so before you lock picture, it's good to show your participants, just in case anybody is like, you know, have a major issue with it. I think it's a good practice to show folks, because you they don't have a lot of creative control, your participants. And you are telling other people's stories and you're siloing them in a way. You're making them into these characters when life goes on. They might be years older than they were when you filmed with them. They might be changing and evolving daily.
And you have them in this like little crucible when you're editing them into a documentary. So I did show them, and everybody was supportive. Um, dad was very quiet. And I just think it was it was hard for him to watch. And it was like, okay, this is your story. You have your artistic license. I don't see it this way. You're gonna tell your story the way you want to. I kind of give him props for that for not throwing a fit or for not so not the same, but similar vein.
[59:54] Katy Scoggin: Um, my dad is super evangelical. My parents divorced when I was little, and we kind of had a good friendship, but we never really had a child parent relationship ever. Yeah, and when I came out, he actually was more accepting than my mom. He said, Well, my religion tells me this is bad, but you're my daughter and I love you, so whatever, we'll figure it out, right? And he's been very supportive of that. What's been challenging for me? I have not had an actual phone conversation with my dad, probably in about six months, and I have a tremendous amount of guilt about it. We text, but it is because of Trump. My dad's not political. He would never bring it up, ever. He would never bring it up, even though I know he's a three-time Trump voter.
But I can't make myself, I can't be honest about the challenges I feel like I'm facing and the the ways that I'm spending my time and my activism work. And and so I'm like, I don't, I don't want to talk to him and have it be a lie. But I also don't want to not talk to him. So I kind of had my own personal journey watching your movie and like hearing the scientist say, well, just call him. Just tell him you love him. And I'm like, fuck. Like I'm not sure. It's almost impossible.
[01:01:07] Alan Seales: Yeah.
[1:01:07] Katy Scoggin: It feels so like you have to crack your brain.
[1:01:10] Alan Seales: Yeah.
[1:01:10] Katy Scoggin: It's very, especially now. Especially if I hadn't started this project in like pre-Trump won. I mean, that was a chance too. Was the timing of it was before this like collective nightmare that we're all living in. It was before that.
[01:01:31] Alan Seales: Yeah.
[01:01:31] Katy Scoggin: Well, like that makes a lot of sense to me. But I guess what I'm curious is so you've you have done it. And you and your dad don't necessarily agree on the perspective, but he still seems to be a little, you're my daughter and I love you kind of approach to it, right?
[01:01:45] Alan Seales: Like we don't have to agree on this, that we can coexist with it.
[01:01:49] Katy Scoggin: Has it made your relationship with him better? And do you do you have an active? Because you opened the movie by saying, Oh, I don't really have a relationship with my dad. Is that different now?
[01:01:58] Katy Scoggin: It's been very interesting. It I think the closest I ever felt to my dad was while we were filming. Because we had there was this microphone and there was a project, and we were talking, and it was like, well, we have a shoot where we have we need to have a conversation. We're editing the film. Dad, I need to go do these audio pickups. So I, you know, I I've got to go capture more uh recorded audio with you to understand your story a little bit better to use it in the film. That got us, that had us talking. It gave us a project and an excuse to talk, and it kept out the political mayhem, which is life and relationship destroying, because we had this project to work on together.
[01:02:42] Alan Seales: We're gonna take a quick break. Stay tuned for more of the episode.
[01:02:46] Katy Scoggin: And now we're back. When I when I came out, that has put a chill. I mean, I'd just be a bridge too far, you know. It's that's put a chill on us. It's just super, super awkward. I mean, father-daughter relationships, a little awkward anyway, a lot of the time. It's it's it's just awkward.
[01:03:10] Alan Seales: It's awkward.
[01:03:10] Katy Scoggin: So we don't ironically, we're we're not no contact, but we're very low contact. The person who picks up the phone is me.
[01:03:20] Alan Seales: The latest I've gotten to is yeah.
[01:03:23] Katy Scoggin: Pisses me right off as a parent. I mean, I know that you're not, but as a parent, that's my fucking job. And I remember that when my adult kids don't reach out because they're being 20, 21.
[01:03:37] Alan Seales: Yeah.
[01:03:38] Katy Scoggin: That's my job.
[01:03:39] Alan Seales: Yes.
[01:03:40] Katy Scoggin: Yes. I feel that way too. But that, yeah, but so why don't they?
[01:03:46] Alan Seales: It's like, but the way my dad was with his parents was he called them. And I think that's his just baked in expectation of my sister and me too. We talk about this sometimes, like, you know, hell will freeze over. Somebody has to die in order to get it. If I get a text from my dad, I'm like, who died? What happened? You know, it's it's like it's if my dad calls me, I know some somebody is sick or having surgery or dead. Like 100% of the time.
[01:04:15] Katy Scoggin: He doesn't even call me on my birthday.
[01:04:16] Alan Seales: I know a lot of people in that generation that do that, or men, men especially.
[01:04:21] Katy Scoggin: Moobers.
[01:04:22] Alan Seales: The moobers don't like to do that.
[01:04:24] Katy Scoggin: Yeah.
[01:04:25] Alan Seales: The expectation is that we're gonna make the effort to have some kind of emotional connection or just like a relationship at all.
[01:04:33] Katy Scoggin: Um, okay, we have come to a late decision, which is that he so he the last time I talked to him, he told me he had rewatched 2001 Space Odyssey. Because he's he's getting into dystopias. He's reading Orwell for the opposite reasons that I'm reading more well, but we're reading some of the same books, ironically.
[01:04:53] Alan Seales: Fascinating.
[01:04:54] Katy Scoggin: And through the lens of the perspective, how do you manipulate what you're reading to make it work for your narrative?
[1:05:01] Katy Scoggin: Yeah. But he's he recently re-watched uh 2001 Space Odyssey and then read the novel. So I'm like, okay, that'll be our next project. I'll watch the movie. It's a piece of cinema, classic cinema. I'll read the novel. I've never read the novel. He's like, I finally understood the film, and I it wasn't as boring as when I was a teenager. I fell asleep, but now I like it. So I'm gonna that's gonna be our next little project. This like a little book club.
[1:05:27] Heather Vickery: I love that though. That really shows effort and willingness, I think.
[1:05:34] Katy Scoggin: And I did, I will disagree with your dad on probably every point we could ever come up with. But I did have Except Science is cool.
[1:05:40] Heather Vickery: Except science is cool. I think science is very cool. I but I actually believe in science, like all of it. Um I always say that I believe in science too much to be religious because I don't know, I don't know what is true. I know that lots of things can be true and that we're still discovering things all the time. And because I believe in science, I can't believe in quote unquote God. I just they don't work together. But I I did get a sense of willingness to have a tiny olive branch and just go like we're never going to be the same, but I can love you anyway.
[1:06:19] Katy Scoggin: And as somebody who has that type of relationship with my parent, um, I feel really emotional right now. I appreciated that from him. Like, you know, my mom says, I don't know how you forgive your dad. And I said, Because I chose to allow him to be able to give whatever he could, and that would be enough. If I changed my expectations, I was gonna spend my whole life disappointed. And I didn't want that. I'm not choosing that. I don't want to be disappointed all the time. So I'm okay with the small capacity he has, and I just let that be enough for me.
[1:06:54] Heather Vickery: Yeah. And you do that for you.
[1:06:57] Katy Scoggin: For me. I mean, for me, like anger, oh, boiling, this expect like I'll forgive when I get an apology. That was my MO for long, like up until probably you just gone to that hurt all the time. And I go back and forth. I mean, I'm not like I I go back and forth for sure, still, maybe always will, but I do see the benefit of just massive benefit just in like moving on with my own life and being comfortable showing up the way that I do as a human. It's there's there's something great about the practice of letting shit go.
[1:07:44] Heather Vickery: What do you hope people will walk away from if they had to pick one thing to take away from after watching Flood? What do you want that to be?
[1:07:53] Katy Scoggin: That even with the most intractable divides with folks that are from our families of origin, like really close family, there can still be some channel of communication or laughter or connection. It is humanly possible. Fucking hard, but it is humanly possible to find some connectivity between yourself and the folks that you would otherwise disagree with on everything under the sun.
[1:08:30] Heather Vickery: I love that. I really do. And there's something about, I mean, the if we share genes with people like our parents, our caretakers, there's something, there's so much of my parents in me. And what would that say about me if I loathed, you know, everything about them? Like the what would I think about the parts of me that are like my dad?
[1:08:50] Katy Scoggin: Yeah. If I had nothing but feelings of contempt, let's say, for my dad and disgust. What would that say about how I feel about the parts of me that are there's a lot of self-hate in judging somebody else that completely.
[1:09:05] Heather Vickery: Yeah, I you run the risk of that, you know?
[1:09:09] Katy Scoggin: Yeah. So then ultimately, just to like put a button on it, what is your relationship with failure?
[1:09:16] Katy Scoggin: Me and failure just we're besties. We're growing old together. Yeah.
[1:09:25] Heather Vickery: I like this. I like I love the concept of failure as a pathway to learning, as something that's uh that teaches us lessons. A failed project is something that teaches lessons about, oh, okay, that that didn't work, or that backfired, or that was a step on the learning pathway.
[1:09:45] Katy Scoggin: Yeah. We it's so so reframing it so that it doesn't just carry only this negative connotation that it's like, oh yeah, failure. We need it. How would we learn? Well, how would you and how would you get anywhere if you don't take a risk? I used to have a quote on my website that said, but what if I fall? Oh mama, my darling, but what if you fly?
[1:10:05] Heather Vickery: Yeah. And you won't know, right? If you don't try, you don't do either. But you gotta be willing to fail. Uh, Katie, this has really been great. I we we became pals instantly on an airplane. I was like, we're like, oh, we're each other people. That's cool. We like exchanged phone numbers and we can text, and that's really cool. Um, I I enjoyed the film. It was really an interesting experience for me, as I've shared for a bunch of different reasons. I also think it would be really hard fucking work. And so I have so much admiration for the work that you do. Um, thank you for being here. Will you tell folks how they can and maybe my editor can edit this out, but like when does the premiere?
[1:10:48] Katy Scoggin: Yeah. Yeah. So when can they see it? How can they see it? And if we want to follow you on whatever cool things you're doing, what's the best way to do that?
[1:10:55] Katy Scoggin: Oh, yeah. The film is gonna premiere on PBS Independent Lens on July 13th, and it'll be free to watch anywhere in the United States for three months, starting in the middle of July, and right before that, in June, or on Father's Day weekend, actually, we're gonna do a little theatrical premiere in New York City, and that's at DC TV. It's the Firehouse Cinema. It's a cinema that is for documentaries almost exclusively, and it's downtown and it's in Manhattan, and it's a really fabulous place. So we'll be there for about a week. We're gonna do some events. I'm trying to work with my impact producer to get some organizations involved. So you can stay posted about it by following us on Instagram, um, at flooddock, f L O O D D O C. F-L-O-O-D-D-O-C.
[1:11:49] Heather Vickery: Congratulations.
[1:11:52] Katy Scoggin: Thank you. Really, it's really cool. Uh, I appreciate it. And I look forward to seeing you again in person soon.
[1:11:57] Katy Scoggin: Yay, I can't wait. Thank you so much.
[1:12:00] Heather Vickery: Thank you. Woo! Religious trauma. Religious drama and filmmaking and airplanes and so many things. I um I really enjoyed that conversation. I think poor Katie, this was a stretch for her. She's used to being behind the scenes, and we put her right front and center. Um, but I think that it was such a fun conversation.
[1:12:26] Alan Seales: I think that too. I think that it was cathartic to kind of go through this. You can tell that she's still actively processing so much of this, even though the documentary took 10 years to make and it has still hasn't been released yet. It I, you know, we're kind of, I think, sort of at the cusp of uh uh if this was a wave, it's about to crash and and uh then wash up on the beach, you know what I mean?
[1:12:48] Katy Scoggin: But we're still coming in right now.
[1:12:49] Alan Seales: Yeah. You know what really and I mentioned this in in the interview. Uh I felt very emotional about it because of the relationship I have with my dad. But what I really loved, and I think that this she gets the credit for this. I'm gonna give you all the credit, Katie, is um the willingness to want to keep finding a way to connect with her dad, even though he doesn't necessarily understand or accept or approve, but because when you share DNA, there there is something valuable to take away from connection.
[1:13:21] Katy Scoggin: Yeah. And so, like, okay, well, now the next project's gonna be the movies and the books, and we can talk about this. And um, that takes a lot of effort to do that. And I really admire her for that, because I'm definitely not doing that.
[1:13:36] Heather Vickery: Now, same with some certain parents in my life too. It's hard. It's hard, it's hard to let that go. It's hard to kind of like I don't know. I I think something that she had said too that that resonates, I think, just with the political climate, right? Is like you've got to find some common ground with people you don't agree with.
[1:13:56] Katy Scoggin: Yeah.
[1:13:57] Heather Vickery: Otherwise, we're not gonna get anywhere. Like it's just gonna be a war again if if it's just like, well, I'm right, no, I'm right. Well, there's no compromise. All right, let's fight it out. Like, or or we go no contact. That's not productive.
[1:14:09] Katy Scoggin: No, but sometimes no contact is necessary for personal survival, so I'm not gonna give shit to anybody who does that.
[1:14:17] Heather Vickery: But you know, that's actually i interesting. This has nothing to do with filmmaking and documentary filmmaking or Katie's story, but there's a huge trend right now on TikTok. People who are are deconstructing from MAGA, and they're most often, not always, but most often white women who are like, oh shit, now I see.
[1:14:35] Katy Scoggin: Yeah.
[1:14:36] Heather Vickery: And they come on and they do videos where they're crying and they're sad because the people on the left aren't being nice to them. And I'm reminded of some of the things that I've some of the amazing black women leaders that I've worked with say, which is like, you get to have all your feelings, but I'm not carrying that for you. So get a fucking journal and write all your feelings out and listen really well to the people you want to learn from, and then don't talk very much. Like just learn to shut up and absorb.
[1:15:11] Katy Scoggin: Yeah.
[1:15:11] Heather Vickery: Um, and so this like balance of but don't but don't you have to be nice to me now that I'm seeing things your way. Well, no, not really. I mean, there's a balance, but also what do you want from us? You actively three times made a decision to put us in harm's way, and I don't have a lot of patience for that, but I also I want you to come to our side. So I hear that. And I think that does tie in to Katie's movie.
[1:15:34] Katy Scoggin: Yeah.
[1:15:35] Heather Vickery: Where the line in the movie where she says, I want my mom on my side. Like she she's kind of in the middle of both, and I want her on my side. But if you want someone on your side, then you have to create dialogue with them, and you have to make space for them to learn in your presence.
[1:15:49] Katy Scoggin: Yeah, yeah.
[1:15:51] Alan Seales: Well, shit. Stream this movie, everyone. Starting July 26th on PBS.
[1:15:59] Katy Scoggin: Um, yeah, goodness. It is it's good. PBS independent lens. It's it's good, it's eye-opening, it's personal. You can have an interesting conversation, watch it with somebody else. Just watch it.
[1:16:10] Heather Vickery: Yeah, watch it with somebody you might not agree with. That's a good idea. Interesting. Um, speaking of people who don't agree with us, we're sure that if you're listening, you must agree with us. You must love us. And if you love us, Alan, what should they do?
[1:16:25] Alan Seales: They should email, they should uh what's a chance podcast at gmail.com. We are on social media. You should also tell a friend. You should also leave a rating. Um if you don't like us, this is the Joe Rogan podcast. It's nice to see you. Um reviews, man, they make us so happy. It's cool. Sometimes we get these messages from Spotify. Somebody left a comment on your latest episode. We're like, wait, what?
[1:16:57] Heather Vickery: Hercules, Hercules.
[1:16:57] Alan Seales: Oh, that was a good movie. We are old.
[1:17:01] Heather Vickery: Oh my god. I sent so I went to Costco yesterday and I opened up the app to pull up, you know, my membership. Sure, sure. You don't need your card anymore. And they've added a new banner. There's a little banner next to my face that says 24 years. And I was like, why the fuck is Costco trying to make me feel old?
[1:17:21] Alan Seales: Right?
[1:17:23] Heather Vickery: What?
[1:17:24] Alan Seales: Yeah. I've got moles younger than that.
[1:17:28] Heather Vickery: That's terrible. Um, well, you've been listening to Was It Chance, the podcast about embracing opportunity and taking intentional risk for your creative life. I'm Alan Seales.
[1:17:39] Heather Vickery: And I'm Heather Vickery. That was a fun swap up. Thank you for listening. Come back next time. Tell your friends.
[1:17:46] Alan Seales: Tell your friends.
[1:17:47] Heather Vickery: Bye.
[1:17:48] Alan Seales: See ya.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
