We sit down with David Armstrong — lifelong theater-maker, educator, and author of Broadway Nation: How Immigrant, Jewish, Queer, and Black Artists Invented the Broadway Musical... Read More
From the show: Was It Chance?
Guests
Featured Shows
About
We sit down with David Armstrong — lifelong theater-maker, educator, and author of Broadway Nation: How Immigrant, Jewish, Queer, and Black Artists Invented the Broadway Musical. David’s 40-year career as a director, producer, choreographer, and writer has been steeped in creative risk, from his 18 years leading Seattle’s Fifth Avenue Theatre (where Hairspray began!) to hosting the Broadway Nation podcast and now teaching Broadway history at the University of Washington. His passion for illuminating the overlooked creators of America’s most iconic art form is both inspiring and overdue.
We talk about the evolution of Broadway through marginalized voices, the political power of art that doesn’t look political, and how risk-taking theaters like the Fifth Avenue became incubators for some of Broadway’s greatest hits. David shares the creative leap that led to Hairspray, how collaboration with an audience shapes a show’s success, and the “legacy chains” connecting generations of musical theater creators — from Otto Harbach to Lin-Manuel Miranda. He also gets candid about failure, what it really feels like when a show “almost” works, and why he still sees risk as essential to the creative process.
🎧 Connect with David Armstrong: 📚 Broadway Nation: How Immigrant, Jewish, Queer, and Black Artists Invented the Broadway Musical — available everywhere books are sold (or through Bloomsbury for a discount!)
🎙️ Listen to Broadway Nation on the Broadway Podcast Network and all major podcast platforms
🌐 Learn more: Broadway Nation Podcast
Connect With Us:
- 📩 Email us at wasitchancepodcast@gmail.com
- 🎧 Follow Was It Chance? on your favorite podcast platform
- 📱 Connect with us on TikTok and LinkedIn
- ✨ More about Heather at her website, subscribe to her Substack and on LinkedIn, YouTube, and more
EPISODE TAKEAWAYS
- Art created by outsiders has always shaped the mainstream.
- Theaters that take risks on new work keep Broadway alive.
- “Shows aren’t written — they’re rewritten.”
- Legacy and mentorship sustain creative evolution.
- Risk and failure are inseparable parts of artistic success.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] David Armstrong: You can't take risks without confronting failure at times.
[0:04] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[0:05] David Armstrong: Looking back, I often think about, especially in terms of shows that I've either developed or directed or been involved with in some way, the shows that didn't quite get there, that never, the ones that got away is the way I think of them. It's like that should have been a great show, and we just didn't quite crack that little 10%, which is really the difference between success and failure.
[0:41] Heather Vickery: Hi everyone, welcome to Was It Chance. This is the podcast about embracing opportunity and taking intentional risk for your creative life. I'm Heather Vickery.
[0:48] Alan Seales: And this guy is Alan Seales.
[0:52] Heather Vickery: Heather and I started off as two perfect strangers who met by chance and embraced opportunity. So now you, the listener, get to listen in, see how that works. As we chat with other successful people about the risks they've taken to put themselves on a path to creative success. Heather, our guest today is so freaking cool.
[1:05] Alan Seales: I'm so excited.
[1:09] Heather Vickery: So excited. Tell everybody who's with us today.
[1:13] Alan Seales: So well, first before, I mean, like, how are you doing?
[1:16] Heather Vickery: I'm okay. You know, pre-show banter.
[1:18] Alan Seales: Pre-show banter.
[1:19] Heather Vickery: Yeah. How you doing?
[1:20] Alan Seales: I'm good.
[1:21] Heather Vickery: I'm good.
[1:22] Alan Seales: My schedule is off today. My timing, I'm confused. I've got I thought one thing started at 11:30 and it was eleven fifteen. And I thought this interview was at 12:30 and it was at 12. So I'm a little discombobulated, but we're working with it.
[1:34] Heather Vickery: We're rolling with it. It's Friday.
[1:36] Alan Seales: Thank goodness.
[1:37] Heather Vickery: Usually you're the first one here. And like, hey, where's Alan?
[1:39] Alan Seales: And I'm showing up exactly on start time.
[1:42] Heather Vickery: And I showed up two minutes early today.
[1:44] Alan Seales: Yeah.
[1:44] Heather Vickery: Just for five minutes late.
[1:46] Alan Seales: And you were five minutes late.
[1:47] Heather Vickery: And I was like, what's up?
[1:48] Alan Seales: What's up? All right. Here we go.
[1:49] Heather Vickery: Here we go. Well, our guest. So I apologize to our awesome guest. Our awesome guest is David Armstrong.
[1:55] Alan Seales: And I've known this dude for a couple of years. Impressed with everything he has ever done or produced, just knows his shit. He is a theater lifer and author of the groundbreaking new book, Broadway Nation: How Immigrant, Jewish, Queer, and Black Artists Invented the Broadway Musical, which I have right here in front of me.
[2:12] Heather Vickery: This thing is a beast of information. Also, usually my role. I'm usually the one holding up the book. And David sent me one, but it hasn't come yet, and I can't wait to read it.
[2:21] Alan Seales: Yes, it's a sweeping and inclusive retelling of Broadway's history that spotlights the vital roles of historically marginalized communities in the invention of America's signature art form. But David, well, wait, there's more. This is QVC right now. This is the longest intro you've ever done. Usually you're like, keep it short, keep it short.
[2:36] Heather Vickery: I know, but this dude's doing so much.
[2:39] Alan Seales: Okay. He's the creator and host of the widely acclaimed Broadway Nation podcast, which has reached nearly 300,000 listeners across more than 180 episodes. He has been the affiliate lecturer at the University of Washington School of Drama.
[2:57] Heather Vickery: Hey, that's where my daughter goes to school.
[2:58] Alan Seales: Ooh! University of Washington. And let's see, his course on Broadway history directly inspired both the podcast and the book. He's got a professional, a 40-year professional career that we let's let's just get into it with the question. I'm like, dude. My gut, David, welcome to Was It Chance.
[3:14] David Armstrong: It's my pleasure to be here, and our time is up. I'm sorry.
[3:19] Alan Seales: Heather was late and I introduced for too long, so now we're done. Everyone go get the book. It's really good. Say hi to Heather's daughter at University of Washington, and we're good.
[3:29] Heather Vickery: All right. Wait, so are you in Washington?
[3:32] David Armstrong: I am in Washington right at this moment. I'm on Vashon Island, which is just a little beautiful island, just less than 45 minutes away from downtown Seattle.
[3:42] Heather Vickery: I love it. I love Seattle. I know not everybody loves it anymore. There's some issues, but I love it.
[3:49] Alan Seales: And my girl chose to spend the summer. She stayed and did summer quarter at UW. So she's there right now, not too far from you.
[3:57] David Armstrong: I love that.
[3:59] Heather Vickery: She's a film major, film and history.
[4:01] Alan Seales: I was gonna say, would she be taking David's class at any point?
[4:04] Heather Vickery: You know, an earlier iteration of her would have been she was a theater girl. And then I think in an effort to be as different from me as she could possibly be, she has rejected theater in every possible way. But you know, that acting like she's a film major. She wants to write, direct, produce.
[4:24] David Armstrong: Um she wants to make some money.
[4:26] Heather Vickery: Oh, I hope so.
[4:28] Alan Seales: I don't know, right? Do film majors make money?
[4:34] David Armstrong: Well, David, when did you get into theater?
[4:37] Heather Vickery: I started out by saying you're a theater lifer, but I mean you've got a 40-year professional career, which you know, you've been a director, producer, a playwright, a choreographer, which I didn't even know until recently.
[4:47] David Armstrong: That's how I started out.
[4:48] Heather Vickery: Yeah. Oh, really? So, but like what got you into that when you were like a little kid?
[4:53] David Armstrong: Little David, you were telling me before we started recording up in the 70s. Very weird, strange children who knew from the beginning, was just entranced with theater, with all things theatrical from five years old on, probably before that. I love it. Mostly through film and television. But I grew up in Cincinnati, which is a great arts town. And so there was lots of theater and lots of, although most of the theater I saw as a kid was high school musicals and things like that that I would go see. But I was just entranced from the beginning, and then I was one of those, again, a weird child who would organize the whole neighborhood into doing shows.
[5:32] Heather Vickery: I love that.
[5:33] David Armstrong: I would see my kids. I didn't know what these words were then. I would produce and direct and write and star in.
[5:39] Heather Vickery: That's so cool.
[5:41] David Armstrong: And you know, there'd be 20 kids doing a review on the patio kind of thing. Or sometimes a book I wrote, I'm sure I would get sued for this today, even as a 10-year-old. Especially if it was Disney, which you're with enough Disney. But was Charlie Brown, so it's probably almost as bad. I was obsessed with You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown, which was, you know, was a brand new show. I didn't see it on Broadway, but I saw the national tour when it came to Cincinnati as a young kid, because I was so obsessed with all things to do with peanuts, and fell in love with that show and then wrote my own show called Snoopy the All American Dog, which I just adapted and wrote some of the songs for, which I can't believe because I don't write songs anymore, but I did that at that time and produced this show in the auditorium of the grade school that I went to, like over the summer.
[6:38] Heather Vickery: That is so cool. You're right, though, you couldn't get away with that now because your parents would have put it on social media to brag about you, and then it would have been everywhere, and I was like, well done a minute.
[6:49] David Armstrong: Charles Schultz would have come down and like he's either the greatest or we're suing him.
[6:55] Heather Vickery: Yeah, yeah.
[6:56] David Armstrong: Probably exactly, but I love it. I often say what I have done for my whole career, I started doing when I was 10.
[7:06] Heather Vickery: Wow. Was there any theater, made theater from the beginning. Was there any other quest possible career path, or were you just like, I gotta be involved with this somehow, some way?
[7:18] David Armstrong: And then so you were you started to write, but you know, at any point were you ever considering anything else?
[7:23] David Armstrong: There were things I thought about. Archaeology was something that always interested me.
[7:29] Heather Vickery: Cool.
[7:29] David Armstrong: It's interesting because I think the things actually all kind of relate to one other, especially in terms of research and that kind of thing. I was about to say that makes so much sense, yeah. So that's the one that pops to mind as something I considered and not I don't know considered as too strong a word but that I was attracted to that I was, you know, drew my attention but really it was show business from the very beginning and all along and I didn't come from a show business family at all. There was no sort of that did was not something I saw or knew how to do or had seen anybody do except on you know in on television basically.
[8:08] Heather Vickery: Were your parents supportive?
[8:10] David Armstrong: Yes, my mother was very supportive. My father died when I was 16.
[8:13] Heather Vickery: Oh, I'm so sorry.
[8:13] David Armstrong: He was but he was supportive prior to that to a, you know, a minor he wasn't obstructive, let's put it that way. But yeah, I lobbied to go to dancing school. I started dancing school when I was six years old and then went, you know, through the rest of into high school to and was again went to theater camps and theater school and stuff like that as a kid outside of then things that were done at the in you know, at the grade school or the high schools that I went to.
[8:48] Heather Vickery: Yeah. That's very cool and and were you, I mean, at any point like worried that that going down the artistic path was too much of a risk or did you ever like second guess any of this or were you just whole hog all the way in, I'm gonna do this and find a way to make it work?
[9:05] David Armstrong: Yeah, I don't I was probably just an idiot and didn't think about any of that stuff.
[9:09] Heather Vickery: Well you had a passion and a drive.
[9:11] David Armstrong: Yeah. And looking back now, I think I mean I moved to New York when I was 19. I had gone, I'd gotten my equity card that summer at the Pittsburgh Civic Light Opera dancing in the chorus of six shows there that year. And somebody else who was working there needed a roommate. And so I dropped out of college and went to moved to New York with $300 maybe in my pocket.
[9:37] Heather Vickery: And your mom wasn't like don't drop out of college.
[9:40] David Armstrong: I mean it worked out for you but it yeah I didn't get a lot of resistance to it. I don't know whether I allowed a lot of I it's hard for me to journey back in time to that moment. So this is like you know the late the late 70s 1979 ish. I can't really imagine how I did it or why anybody let me do it.
[10:00] Heather Vickery: But it worked out.
[10:01] David Armstrong: But you did it I mean talk about was it chance like taking that risk and saying yeah okay I'll drop out of school.
[10:01] Heather Vickery: Where were you going to school?
[10:10] David Armstrong: Uh University of Cincinnati.
[10:10] Heather Vickery: Okay.
[10:10] David Armstrong: Or yeah for theater there?
[10:12] Heather Vickery: Yeah I was in the theater program and working with the musical theater program at CCM. I was basically I was enrolled in theater but did all my classes at CCM and part of what you know led me down the path of leaving is by I would ended up teaching some of the classes there when the instructors didn't show up too advanced for the teachers so I went I kept going back and forth between Cincinnati and New York because I had a lot of opportunity to work there. That's where I first started working professionally as a choreographer.
[10:48] David Armstrong: And I'm so grateful the dedication in my book. I thought about who am I going to dedicate this book to? And I ended up thinking I need to dedicate it to this group of people that who took a chance on me, who believed in me before they had any right to do so. Who gave me opportunities to and just saw that there was something in me that would that was there, but I didn't there's no reason they should have seen it at that time or or taken the chance that they took on me.
[11:24] Heather Vickery: And I think that's an important thing. Especially in terms of your the theme of your podcast, it's sometimes you have to take a chance on somebody who you just have to take a little leap of faith. You see something in them, and you go, I think this person can do this, and I'm going to give them the chance to do it.
[11:41] David Armstrong: What did they give you the chance to do? Was it teaching or performing?
[11:43] David Armstrong: Initially for a lot of the it depends. It was a variety of things. It was some was performed, but mostly was letting me run things, most letting me direct, letting me choreograph, letting me w tell the whisper in their ear what I thought they should be doing, how they should be directing the show, things like that. It was giving me opportunities to leadership opportunities, really that I was not that were well before I probably was age appropriate to have those leadership opportunities.
[12:14] Heather Vickery: I think that's so cool. And I'm actually curious. So you spent, well, I think I have this right, 18 years at the Fifth Avenue Theater.
[12:21] David Armstrong: Yes.
[12:22] Heather Vickery: And and as to to play off of what you just said, like taking these risks, taking these chances, giving people opportunities, what creative risks are you most proud of, or were you the most surprised by in that 18-year tenure?
[12:40] David Armstrong: I mean, I think the thing that stands out the most would be the emphasis that I was placed and was able to place on new musicals, on developing new new musicals. And taking a big organization like that down that path is a very challenging thing to do. Creating new work is expensive and challenging, but when you're doing it on a Broadway scale, which is what the Fifth Avenue Theater is and has to be because of the scale of the building, the scale of the organization, all that kind of stuff. People often think, and I write about this in the book, that before I when I got the job to go to here to Seattle to the Fifth Avenue Theater from New York, I had only been to Seattle one time before that to direct a show at the Fifth Avenue Theater.
And then that's when I threw my hat in this ring to be the first on-site living in Seattle artistic leader of the organization. Before that, it had been run, the artistic wing of it had been run out of Houston very successfully. Huh. But they wanted to change to a more full-time in-house leader in Seattle. So I got this job, and before I there was about six months between the time I got the job and the time I came to Seattle. And so every time I would run into anybody, any producers in New York that I knew, I would say, I'm going to Seattle. I think it'd be a great place to try out new shows. Yeah. Keep us in mind, all that kind of stuff. And about six months after I got to Seattle, I got a call from the producers of the show that turned out to be Hairspray.
And but what I talk about in the book is that this was a big giant risk for everybody involved at the time. There was no belief that Hairspray would be what Hairspray turned out to be, or even the concept that it could be that. This was a movie, not a very well-known, sort of a fringe, you know, cult movie written by John Waters, whose entire work was about offending middle-class values. I met John Waters once, just the same in person as he is on TV. Hilarious. A hilarious person. I remember him standing in my office. This is a side note, but it's a funny story, and talking about he had just been with Roseanne in Los Angeles, and he said, She has a new face. I said, John, what do you mean? He says her she has an entirely new face.
And she what she wanted was all any essence of her parents to be removed from her face. Wow. And fascinating. And now knowing what we know about her now. Exactly. You can understand why that sticks in my mind after 25 years. Yeah. Wow. But he was hilarious. He was it was great. But my point is that that's not somebody that you think is going to write a or who's going to be the source material for a mainstream musical theater hit. None of the writers had ever written a Broadway show before, except for Tom Meehan, but the, you know, Mark and Scott had not ever, they had very successful careers, but not on Broadway, not as Broadway songwriters. It was a new untried team, and even Harvey was not really a very big star, especially in Seattle at that time for people in Seattle.
You would say his name, and it would be you'd get sort of who's that kind of thing. So this was an unknown quantity in every aspect. And to make that decision to devote the resources that a theater company needs to devote to any kind of new work, and especially for the first time, more or less, that the Fifth Avenue was going to do that, was just a giant leap of faith that, you know, looking back, I understand why we made it, and it was clear we needed to make it. But I remember going to the reading in New York where the show was just sensational. And I remember calling my partner who was the managing director at that time, and she said, Well, how is it? How is it? I said, Well, if they don't fuck it up, this will be the greatest show ever.
And but again, there's no guarantee that they're not gonna screw it up. Yeah, you know, somewhere along the way, shows are so hard, so difficult to bring all the pieces together. But, you know, nine times out of ten, they don't come together. They don't work. And just this show ended up being magic, and of course, was an incredible thing for the theater and for the Fifth Avenue to have this first jump in the pool of this kind of thing be so successful. But there was just no, and it didn't, you know, people say, Oh, you must have made a lot of money. No, we over 20 years we made a lot of money. But on that, it didn't even pay for itself. Because nobody knew then. Because nobody knew. Nobody came until the reviews came out, and then the last week it was sold out. We're gonna take a quick break. Stay tuned for more of the episode.
[17:45] Heather Vickery: And now we're back. I mean, your entire career has been about taking intentional risk for creative success and embracing opportunity. And as I, you know, I'm not as close to Broadway as Alan is. I'm a theater kid, I'm like you, like I felt it from the beginning. I have a theater degree, but I don't I use all those skills, but I don't work in the theater. Um the time that's spent, the heart that's given to doing these things before they're big, that that's where the real artistry is. That's where the real real creativity is and and so exciting and so much joy. And we wouldn't have people forget we wouldn't have Broadway as Broadway exists if we didn't have the Fifth Avenue Theater. Like in those kinds of things, not necessarily specific that, right?
But the other theaters in other towns that try things and explore and play and rework and that was where I was gonna ask next is just like what what makes a theater a good place to develop something out of town? Like, why did Fifth Avenue get this reputation? Why does La Jolla have it? Why does the Muni have it? Like there are specific theaters I think about Chicago, we do it. Chicago, right? Then I think about like you know, the Huntington in Boston, right? Like there are there are theaters that I'm like, all right, if you're gonna go out of town, there's a there's 10 that I would pick from. Well, how did they get there? Is it because of people like you? Just have a conversation.
[19:10] David Armstrong: It's the audience. You have to have an audience that we uh you have to have a theater town audience. And I used to say that there were three great theater towns in the United States. There was New York, Chicago, and Seattle. Because when I came to Seattle, uh, and I benefited from that, you know, being established before I got there to a great extent, there were five major theater companies. There were, and then a whole host of mid-level and small-scale theater companies, uh, fringe theaters like or similar to Chicago. And there were almost no other cities that had that, that had an audience that would support that of a major size that would support that number one, that that volume of theater, and then because they were, and then you have to have a subset of that audience who's willing to and wants to see something new and wants to experience go on the ride of a new work.
And I think that's it. You know, there are much bigger cities in Seattle that have, you know, in terms of population, but don't have that kind of audience. And it's just the way it does, even San Francisco doesn't support theater in the way that Seattle has.
[20:25] Heather Vickery: What is what is it? What is the ride though? Like, what about the ride? Because if well, yeah. So what do you mean by that? Because as an audience member, if I lived in Seattle, I would have my season tickets, and then I would show up for this new thing I've never heard of called Hairspray, and then I would sit down and I'd enjoy it and be like, oh, that that Harvey guy, he's really got a future, you know. But the ride is not every show is going to be Hairspray. We did 19 new musicals in the time I was there. And I'm, you know, the percentage, this is unbelievable. I never would have predicted this. I it's it's uh it's it's not real, but it is real. Nine of those shows went to Broadway. But even with those nine shows, not every show was Hairspray.
Sometimes you're gonna have to want to go to see something that may not be completely done and may not be entirely successful. I'm happy to say that every single one of those shows had sensational elements to them, but not all of them worked because you don't know if the show's gonna work until it's up in front of people, until you're collaborating with the audience. So you really need to have an audience that's willing to collaborate on a new work. So is the artist. And not everybody is.
[21:34] David Armstrong: The artistic director, you're like the boss of the bosses of like determining what productions happen in a season, right?
[21:41] Heather Vickery: Yes.
[21:41] David Armstrong: Yeah, yeah. So what do you like? Obviously. Uh he didn't say it like that.
[21:49] Heather Vickery: Don't put that on him.
[21:50] David Armstrong: No, that's not true. He was like correct statement. Correct statement. Yes, idiot. It's all my fault. That's the way I used to say it.
[21:56] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[21:58] David Armstrong: Um, but the so are you always looking for a balance? As is an artistic director always looking for the balance of new work, new works versus established IP, so that you can. I mean, you want to keep the theater going. You can't just do things that aren't gonna earn money. It is a business. Yeah, uh like are you what was that kind of discussion process like every season, or where you're evaluating, like, hey, can we bring this in, or should we bring that? Or is there anything you look back on that you're like, damn, we should have brought that in? Like, did you pass on Hamilton?
[22:36] David Armstrong: Uh I didn't pass on Hamilton. Uh, I'm happy to say, but yes, there were things that uh I'm trying to think of the what the biggest one was that we passed up or didn't it didn't usually it's not that we passed it didn't work out. The timing didn't work out, the you know, the uh economics didn't work out, all that kind of stuff. Uh I mean, one I regret that didn't happen was because I think it would have helped the show and it would have been so much better than the show ended up being was we were supposed to do the pre-Broadway of Bombay Dreams. Ooh. And they ended up not doing a pre-Broadway and went straight to New York, and the show never got finished. Never didn't, they didn't do the work that I think could have been done. I flew to London to see it and was so excited about the idea that they were going to come and do it and have this chance to work on it. And so I think that's a real missed opportunity.
[23:28] Heather Vickery: That one. I love hearing you say that because I know that we have a lot of listeners who do different sorts of creative things. And every time we have a really gifted creative on this show who talks about the editing and the reworking process, I just think it's such a gift for people to recognize that you are not supposed to get this right the first time or the second time, or maybe even the tenth time. Like there is a lot of work that goes into making something ready to be consumable by the big audience. Uh and I just think it's really easy to forget that and be hard on yourself.
[24:06] David Armstrong: Well, and uh people always I think there's an old expression that's very true. Shows aren't written, they're rewritten.
[24:12] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[24:13] David Armstrong: And they're never finished. Which means that writing it is just step one. Yeah. Now, and then what I think the great talents really are able to do is you always write something you want to see. You write something you hope an audience is going to want to see it, but you can't write to an audience because you don't have any idea what the audience actually wants, even if they would tell you what they want. It probably means they want to see the thing they saw before, not this new thing. They don't want to see a retread of the thing they saw before. Wow. And so then you've got to then listen to the audience and the great ones sit in the theater and go, oh, I feel what the audience is telling me. Now you can't ask them directly because they'll probably tell you the wrong thing, but you have to be able to get inside their experience of it while you're writing it.
[25:04] David Armstrong: I mean, and the same thing is true now. I know from experience with writing this book that books aren't written, they're rewritten also.
[25:12] David Armstrong: And your editors are worth your weight in gold for sure.
[25:15] David Armstrong: Totally. And my book was totally my editor Dom O'Hanlin at Matthew and Drama was so helpful because after I'd written the book, he came back and said, let's talk about the structure a little bit. I restructured the book substantially based on his input, which made the book infinitely better than it was. The exact same content, just where how that was laid out and presented was what changed. Well, speaking of which, writing the book, Broadway Nation, the podcast and the book, the podcast came first, obviously. That's how we got connected. The podcast is on Broadway Podcast Network with this podcast and many others in the home for everyone who loves theater in Broadway.
[25:54] David Armstrong: Shameless plug. So go listen to Broadway Nation.
[26:00] Heather Vickery: Why, when did you decide to start the podcast and why, but then also why focus it on immigrant, Jewish, queer, and Black artists?
[26:10] David Armstrong: And thank you for that as well. But yes. Well, so this started when I stepped down from my job at the Fifth Avenue Theater in 2018, after 18 years of being there. I got approached by the University of Washington to create a course on the history of the Broadway musical. So that was the first moment that I thought, well, what am I going to teach? What's the focus of this course? I know I can teach a course on the history of the Broadway musical, but what do I think about it? What do I, what's my take on that? And this was something that had been percolating for years, this idea that, and you know, I didn't invent this idea, but what I did was bring collate all these things. There have been books and documentaries about the Jewish influence, the Jewish creators of the Broadway musical.
There are books about the gay creators of the Broadway musical. But it started, it had been occurring to me that this was an art form that was almost entirely created by outsiders, by marginalized people and groups. And I thought, well, how did that happen? Why did that happen? And it happened because at the turn of the century, when show business is actually being created and invented, there was this great opportunity that nice people wouldn't do. Respectable people were not able, would not deign to lower themselves to be in show business.
[27:39] Heather Vickery: Well, you're in the right company here on this podcast.
[27:40] David Armstrong: I know, right? But I'm down at the bottom. I think though, that what that speaks to, and it's been coming up a lot more, I think now, is that art is inherently political.
[27:51] David Armstrong: Totally. Right? Our, I'm queer, Black, Jewish artists. Like our existences are inherently political. And when we can channel that into art, you get Broadway.
[28:07] David Armstrong: Absolutely. And as I started doing the research, it became, it doubled down on how true this was. How absolutely this was not a sort of concept I was putting on the top of something. This is absolutely true. I don't have a dire exact percentage for you, because you'd have to count everyone who ever worked in the Broadway musical, but an overwhelming percentage of the inventors and creators and sustainers of this art form have come from these marginalized groups and are still to this day. And what's so interesting and maybe sort of bizarre about that is what they created then becomes the centerpiece of American culture.
[28:52] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[28:52] David Armstrong: And for the mid of the 20th century, especially, is the prime, is, you know, is a signature American cultural form. And yet it's all coming, there's a, I think there's a subversive element that's in there, which I talk about, especially the last section of the book is about the themes of the Broadway musical, the three ubiquitous themes of Broadway musicals. They're all, it's a very progressive art form, which people do not perceive it that way because it's been so popular.
[29:26] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[29:27] David Armstrong: I mean, I think that's what makes it so cool is it's political, but people don't know it. It was fascinating when Wicked, the first movie came out, the people who inherently had no idea what a political, how can you be that?
[29:44] Heather Vickery: Yeah, did we watch the same movie?
[29:47] David Armstrong: You think Alphabet is Trump? What? Like, I'm like, how? I don't know, I don't know, but it's wild, right? Because people, it will shift those folks aside, it will shift people's perspectives and they don't even know what's happening because it's been so become so mainstream.
[30:06] Heather Vickery: Absolutely.
[30:07] David Armstrong: And that's one of the things that fascinates me. I can't document this, but I wonder what the effect of a hundred years of Broadway musicals that almost entirely promote liberal humanistic values has had on our culture. And it'd be easy to say now, well, not much, apparently. But how much worse would it be if that force weren't in our culture?
[30:35] Heather Vickery: Right.
[30:36] David Armstrong: Well, and so much incredible art is being made right now because, you know, you get a diamond from pressure.
[30:46] Heather Vickery: Absolutely. Just I wanna, I want to go back to something that I meant to ask earlier. Edna Turnblad, the mother character in Hairspray, was that always a man in drag, or did that evolve? Was that John Waters' idea?
[30:57] David Armstrong: That's because in the movie it was Divine. In the original John Waters movie, that role was played by Divine, who was a drag queen and had was the star of many of his movies, sort of John Waters' muse was Divine. And that idea, it was all of the creators of the musical just knew inherently that they needed to, they that needed to be repeated. You know, in the musical, that idea was important somehow. And it's interesting because it adds this sort of subliminal. I mean, that show is about, you know, fat phobia and body image issues and of course racism and segregation and all the things that it's about. It's also about economic imbalance. It's very much a great story actually about economics and the politics of polarization of income, and that having Edna somehow played by a man as a woman, but not in drag, not in drag. This man plays a woman.
[32:11] David Armstrong: Just a woman, yeah. You believe, and the whole audience, a mainstream middle-class conservative audience. Except can you imagine if it was released right now?
[32:22] Heather Vickery: Exactly.
[32:23] David Armstrong: But within five minutes of watching it, if you believe it's a woman, you relate. What's so interesting was to see the audience relate to that character after three laughs of, oh, that's Harvey in a dress, then, oh, that's Edna. And then to invest in that relationship between the two of them is this sort of gay subtext to it without ever stating it, and it's not, you know, it's not linear or logical. And that's happening in every high school in America where Hairspray is being done today.
[32:54] Heather Vickery: Well, that's why I asked that question in this point in our conversation, because we were talking about the political statements and the way that people are expressing themselves because, I mean, it premiered on Broadway August 15th, 2002, at the time that George W. Bush was president. We've got a Republican president. And all of this just goes out there to kind of, I mean, it's a silent protest that's influencing people in a way they're not even realizing and allowing you to see things in a way like, oh yeah, two people that happen to both be assigned male at birth can play like, can have a gay relationship or, you know, whatever the case is, right? Like it's just kind of so beautiful to me how all this comes together.
[33:38] David Armstrong: I agree with you completely. It's a, they become these icons for healthy heterosexual marriage, even though we're watching these two men on stage play this out. So somehow in your mind, you're going, well, there's no difference.
[33:52] Heather Vickery: Right.
[33:53] David Armstrong: There is no difference. It's two people. Yeah, so what's that having a marriage? The creative risk you had going, I don't mean to harp on this. I promise I'll move on. I think it's fascinating though. The creative risk that you and the team had to push yourselves through to be like, all right, we're gonna do this show by the, from written by this guy who is controversial in and of himself about something that is racist, that deals with racism, fat phobia, you know, gay relationships, all the things you said. Was that an easy thing of like, yes, we're gonna take a stand, we're gonna put this on stage, or was it like, whoa, we're gonna like shoot our reputation and shoot ourselves in the foot with, you know, what kind of risk you were taking, potentially?
[34:34] David Armstrong: Yeah, that's a better question. I don't think we thought a lot about the political risk of it. And again, this was a different thing. And it turns out it's even 25 years ago. Yeah, and it was not a political risk. I think the risk we took was will the, will, is there a mainstream audience for this story, given all those things? Do may, will a mainstream audience want to see a wild, crazy musical comedy about very serious issues about what's happening in our world every day? And there, that the friction between that, between those elements work or not work. So to me, it was more of an economic risk. Will, will, can we get enough people to show up? And that was what I lived with for 25 years. People would always say to me, what's the hardest part of your job as the artistic director, producing artistic director? I'd say paying for everything. That's the hardest part of my job. Making sure enough people buy tickets. We get the grants. We get or donate money or do whatever they need to do.
[35:37] David Armstrong: Yeah. I mean, that's, I don't know what caused me to Google this. I was just looking up the don't ask, don't tell policy dates. Like it was created in, Bill Clinton did it.
[35:47] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[35:48] David Armstrong: Yeah. It was created, created in '94, right? Is that what we were just looking at?
[35:53] Heather Vickery: Yeah, '93 is November '93 is when it went into effect, repealed not until 2010. So again, yeah, this is 2000. This is 2001 when we're doing Hairspray.
[36:03] David Armstrong: Yeah. Well, and what I did, so I want to pull the through line, right? You got hired at UW to teach this class.
[36:11] David Armstrong: Oh, yeah, like working on it. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[36:13] Heather Vickery: My bad.
[36:13] David Armstrong: Certainly I can teach this class, but what do I really think about it? And what's, what do I want the takeaway to be? And that leads to the podcast, right? So I'd love to hear a little bit about that journey and then how you turn that over.
[36:34] David Armstrong: Yeah, maybe it was into 2019, somewhere in that period. I can't remember exactly which quarter I started in. And then what led to the podcast, like so many other things, was the pandemic. Mostly because, and I had the podcast in my head after teaching the course, I thought, well, I should probably take these lectures and do a popular version of these lectures that would make a podcast. These are, this is perfect material for the kind of podcast I like to listen to. I love to listen to the History Chicks. I don't know if you know their podcast, but they have a fantastic women's history podcast, or the Bowery Boys, which have a very fantastic New York history podcast. So those were sort of inspirations for me of, oh, I could do the same thing with musical theater history. And so I didn't, I was sort of thinking about that, sort of researching it, those kind of things. And then it was clear that the pandemic was come, was happening.
[37:31] David Armstrong: And I thought, well, I'm gonna have to, I and I knew then I was gonna have to teach remotely the next time I taught spring quarter of that year. So I thought if I start making these podcasts, then maybe they can be a tool I can actually use to teach with because I we're not gonna I can't give these lectures in person anymore. And so that is really what jump started the podcast. And I don't remember what what exactly year we uh or what month we debuted Broadway Nation on the Broadway Podcast Network, but it was uh You'll know in a minute, Alan can't not look that up.
[38:06] Alan Seales: Exactly.
[38:07] David Armstrong: I'm sure he will. The font of information. So I think that answers.
[38:14] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[38:15] David Armstrong: Okay. So how and then and where I where did the book come from from that? And what was different about teaching the class versus the podcast versus the book?
[38:27] David Armstrong: So the main difference between teaching the class and the podcast is obviously in the course uh you have exams. You have Yeah, of course. Right. Uh the audience has to respond to me in the in the in the course. And I get to grade them.
[38:42] Alan Seales: Oh wow, your first episode, sorry, your first episode came out April 29th, 2020.
[38:46] David Armstrong: Yeah. So like right after COVID shut everything down.
[38:49] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[38:50] David Armstrong: Yeah. It was it was uh that was very interesting. Uh that that the whole timing behind that. So yes, the but and of course the podcast is written is created more for a uh general audience, uh uh theater loving theater. It's it's a very scholarly podcast, but it's not treated in a scholarly manner. But I think that's basically how I teach also.
[39:13] Heather Vickery: Yeah, yeah, just like our show.
[39:15] David Armstrong: Just like it. Very scholarly, but people don't know it.
[39:20] Heather Vickery: They're completely unaware of how scholarly.
[39:22] David Armstrong: Do I do I know it?
[39:25] Heather Vickery: I know it.
[39:25] David Armstrong: Okay, good, so well, so subversive. And then the book came about because uh in the so the first uh season of my podcast was basically a chronological history of the Broadway musical, mostly me uh talking with okay with guests. I have a uh co-host often named Albert Evans, who I've worked with a lot and was a great historian, and then occasionally uh other guest authors and things, but telling this whole story chronologically. So when I got through that, I thought, well, now what am I gonna do for season two? How's this podcast going to continue? But luckily there have been so many other books that have come out about musical theater and musical theater history.
[40:11] David Armstrong: You had resources. It sort of evolved into an interview podcast. So it was the same subject matter, just sort of drilling down on subjects that I talked about chronologically in the first season. And so that's continued through now, you know, 200 episodes. Uh and during that, the Dom O'Hanlon, who was the my editor, I had interviewed a number of authors of books that he had published on the podcast. So he got to know the podcast and got to know what that I was teaching this course through talking about it on the past. And then he approached me about writing the book based on that. Because they uh Matthew and Drama sees this as a thinks there's a need in the in the market, in the textbook market for a new textbook about the history of the Broadway musical that would be that would is different from the ones that have existed before.
[41:08] David Armstrong: And there's some terrific books out there, but because it brings this sort of new uh scope to it, uh they were very interested in that. So that's knock on wood. That is what will happen over the next year, is it uh universities and educational programs across the country will and the world really will adopt this as a textbook.
[41:30] Heather Vickery: We're gonna take a quick break. Stay tuned for more of the episode.
[41:34] David Armstrong: And now we're back.
[41:36] Heather Vickery: Yeah, we have actually had several conversations with authors that come to mind um about revising history, sharing hidden history, shifting the perspective of of who you see in history, what comes to mind.
[41:53] David Armstrong: Actually, the episode that's out on our on our feed right now is Victoria Christopher Murray, who did Harlem Rhapsody, which tells the story of Jesse Fawcett, who was the first female editor of the NAACP's literary magazine, right?
[42:08] Heather Vickery: Nobody knew her name.
[42:09] David Armstrong: Nobody even knew she existed. And I I think this is beautiful because you're doing this for Broadway.
[42:16] Heather Vickery: Uh, and it's not that we don't necessarily know all their names, but you're right in that marginalized people created this phenomenon.
[42:26] David Armstrong: And they did they just haven't, it's it's hidden history. And so bringing this forward is is just such a gift.
[42:33] David Armstrong: And for me, that's one of the things that's been so rewarding about doing this, and because I learned so much, you know, beginning with creating the course, is discovering people whose names either I had heard but didn't, you know, didn't really know what they'd done or who they were, and shows the same way, shows that you might have heard mentioned once or twice, but you didn't understand that they were big hit shows that had impact not only on the audience but on the other creators, and just being now able to dem, you know, to uh show people that the significance of these of these artists, and women are very much part of this too.
[43:13] David Armstrong: The other part of the story that's important to me is people say, Well, there weren't any people, there weren't any, you know, uh no one was allowed to be to create art back in those days. And like there were black artists at the center of the Broadway musical from the very beginning, from 1900 on.
[43:30] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[43:30] David Armstrong: There, and they and their story is a complicated one because it ebbs and flows. They get shut out for periods and then they come back. And but there were two decades of black musical theater created by black artists, black writers, black directors, black choreographers, black stars. So between 1900 and 1910, approximately, there's a dozen shows on Broadway, 20, I think almost 20 that are written by black artists that are big hits that I almost had no knowledge of even being immersed in theater for you know 40 years.
[44:07] David Armstrong: And then they unfortunately go away for a decade and that comes back with Shuffle Along, which is a story we do know, at least we we know that, but what people don't know is that Shuffle Along starts a wave of black musical theater that again is another 20 or more shows that happen over the next decade into the 1930s until the depression sort of you know puts an end to that, and it becomes so hard to put anything on Broadway for white artists, much less for black artists to be given the opportunity to do that.
[44:39] David Armstrong: That starts to fade away. And that still happens today.
[44:43] Heather Vickery: It still happens today.
[44:45] David Armstrong: And that's because we need to recognize these patterns and not let them happen again. Because we see a similar thing in the 1970s, where there's black artists totally uh centered in so much of the work that's being done on Broadway. And then by the 1980s or the 90s, really, there that disappears again.
[45:05] Heather Vickery: Thank you, Ronald Reagan.
[45:07] David Armstrong: Yeah. Let me let me ask you a question about that. Uh, because with now 2025, the age of the internet, social media, everything, uh, news cycles, everything just moves so much faster. And so the what you were just describing was coming in waves of decades. But coming out of the pandemic, end of 2020 and then 2021, there were so many black written plays uh that hit that reopened on Broadway first, and everyone was like really praising all of this representation that was that had been lacking for a long time, and now I feel like today, 25, that's kind of just gone already.
[45:38] Heather Vickery: And it's only been four years.
[45:39] David Armstrong: So are we are we just like speeding up? This is a cycle that repeats, and you know, like what are we gonna do about it?
[45:46] David Armstrong: Yeah, I mean, that's a it's a hard question. I think you might be right to a certain extent. I do think that the book almost entirely focuses on shows that were hits, because those are the shows that I think had impact for the most part. You can there once in a while you can say, here's a show that was unsuccessful, there was a flop that had tremendous impact either on other writers, and there are a few of those. But mostly I'm talking about work that had tremendous impact on the culture.
[46:16] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[46:16] David Armstrong: Which you can't really tell until much uh until years later when you look back. So it's hard to know right now, even and it's why the set the last, you know, third of the book or fourth of the book was the hardest part to write because it's we're in the middle of the history of the 21st century.
[46:38] David Armstrong: So for the first, you know, we're 25 years into it. So the first 10 years of that, you can say, yes, hairspray was an important show, the producers was an important show, rent was a rent actually in the 20th century. But uh you can sort of name things that are have established themselves definitely as being part of the history of the Broadway musical. But what's happening in the last five years, it's really hard to tell.
[47:03] David Armstrong: And it's hard to tell what the trends are. Uh and will those artists who didn't quite have their shows succeed eventually. They still make an impact. Still make an impact with the next show and with the shows that are coming up. So I don't know. It's it's but you're right. We have to be aware that this is we run in these patterns, and my students are often completely surprised by this because they just think everything has gone on a path of progressive, maybe a very low grade, but we we're more evolved than we were, you know, 20 years ago or 100 years ago.
[47:39] David Armstrong: And uh Cassine Gaines, who wrote that great book about um called Broadway when Broadway was black, uh, he says that there were more black people on Broadway in 1926 than there are on Broadway today.
[47:52] Heather Vickery: Wow.
[47:53] David Armstrong: So sad.
[47:54] Heather Vickery: That is terrible.
[47:55] David Armstrong: Well, that's so David. I'm curious, what was the thing that surprised you most when you were doing the research to write this book? What fact were you like mind blown about the most?
[48:09] David Armstrong: I think first and foremost was that first decade of black musical theater, which is just completely off everyone's radar. And with significant artists, people like Bob Cole, who's a name nobody knows, who's probably as important as so many white artists that we do know their names from that period, but just and again, part of the reason it's not all racism, although I guess it's elements of racism that we don't know them and we forgot about them.
[48:39] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[48:39] David Armstrong: It's systemic, and it's also uh most of the a lot of those artists died very young, probably because they didn't have access to healthcare and healthcare wasn't very good. Or living in safe communities or whatever. And where most of them were children of or had children or grandchildren of slaves of people who'd been enslaved. And who knows what kind of you know, legacy that would have physically, even on your body.
[49:04] Heather Vickery: Yep.
[49:05] David Armstrong: So almost all of that whole wave of the of first died in their 40s or even younger than that. So and then with the uh with the with the queer artists, the the uh most of them didn't have children, even though they had long lives and long careers. People like Hassard Short, who I think is one of the people I would most want people to think find out who he was. He's a director, quite he's the one who invents Broadway staging, basically.
[49:36] David Armstrong: Holy cow. He is uh, and he does dozens and dozens of shows starting in the teens and going all the way into the 1950s, big giant hit shows that he is is that's it's hard to determine exactly he was a dancer, he but he wasn't he often worked with other choreographers, but he's responsible for the staging of the show for putting it on the stage, and he's one who innovated.
[50:03] David Armstrong: He's supposedly he had the show that did the first turntables, the first double turntables on the stage. He was the one who decided to put lighting on the balcony rail and get rid of footlights. So we still can see standard today. Well, but and just that you didn't have that barrier, that sort of artificial barrier, you now put them on the front of the balcony spotlights there. He invented all this stuff, and we don't know his name, and he didn't have any children, and so his legacy didn't get sustained the way other artists of his caliber did at the time, or to have since then. Somebody should write a book just about him.
[50:46] David Armstrong: Like a historical fiction. I would I'm just thinking like I would love to have I want to read that. I want you to sell the book rights, Broadway Nation to like Steven Spielberg, and I want a five season massive television show, like this arc of just like with all this drama and romance and backstabbing and totally. Has anybody approached you about about movie rights?
[51:11] David Armstrong: Yeah, we're gonna plant that. See, we're manifesting that. Yeah, I it would I there are some incredible stories that I often think as I read, you know, as I was researching this, like, well, that's a Netflix miniseries. Why isn't somebody doing that story, telling that story? Why not? Like if Lynn can do it, you can do it.
[51:29] Heather Vickery: Yeah, why not you, man?
[51:31] David Armstrong: Well, what would you do? What would you want to pick out and make into like a little bit of a what if this is a whole a whole TV show called Broadway Nation and every season, like it's kind of like true detective. Every season's a different arc.
[51:40] David Armstrong: Oh yeah, yeah. It's a different artist. I mean, there I'd probably start with Dorothy Donnelly, which have you ever heard that name?
[51:48] Heather Vickery: Nope.
[51:49] David Armstrong: Okay, so Dorothy Donnelly, among the many Dorothy's that were famous back in that period. It's like there was this whole world of them. But Dorothy Donnelly was The Dorothy Decade. She originally was an actress, a star actress at the turn of the century on Broadway. She then went to playwriting. She then and she created plays and musical. She wrote the music and the lyrics for a dozen or so hit Broadway shows, including The Student Prince. I mean big famous shows, the longest running show of the 1920s is The Student Prince. And she wrote the music and or the book and the lyrics for that.
[52:30] Heather Vickery: Wow.
[52:30] David Armstrong: And many of those shows she directed as well.
[52:35] Heather Vickery: Amazing.
[52:35] David Armstrong: We need to partner you with the people who are doing the Gilded Age.
[52:39] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[52:39] David Armstrong: Because they're doing such a good job on historical.
[52:43] David Armstrong: Well, and that whole black subplot there, there, this black story that they're telling there is so interesting to me because there is this whole world of black theater that's happening in Chicago actually. And in New York at the same time or just after that is a story we just don't know and doesn't matter.
[53:01] Heather Vickery: I feel good about this.
[53:03] David Armstrong: Yeah, you totally need to be a consultant on this on some sort of historical fiction.
[53:08] Heather Vickery: Yeah, yeah. They're doing a good job with that show. I love the Gilded Age.
[53:11] David Armstrong: Yeah, I I've I've this guy it's gotten so much better. I wasn't that I think maybe because I was expecting Downton Abbey, and I was such a big fan of Down Abbey.
[53:19] Heather Vickery: I've never seen Danton Abbey.
[53:21] David Armstrong: So it's the greatest television ever done, as far as I'm concerned. And I I sincerely believe that. I think it's one of the best television series in history.
[53:31] Heather Vickery: That's how I feel about shit screen.
[53:32] David Armstrong: You can't judge it from the movies. The movies are not very good. The movies are just sort of like fan fiction kind of thing.
[53:38] Heather Vickery: But yeah.
[53:39] David Armstrong: But I have a thing for because I listen to a lot of memoirs. I love to learn about people and things that I wouldn't otherwise know about. And I I will do some very obscure ones. My partner's always like, it's really strange that you picked that one. I'm like, yeah, but I love to learn about life experience and where that's why we do this show. It's like literally my dear. Like, what led you here? What's your backstory? Why? And then we impact people we don't even know how.
[54:07] Heather Vickery: And I and I want to ask you that this question, and I know we are getting close to needing to wrap this, but obviously this work you're doing is beautiful and impactful. Can you pinpoint any, like maybe when you were teaching or or something where what you shared, you can like it changed something for somebody else?
[54:25] David Armstrong: I'm trying to think of it trying to pinpoint it into one moment, but I do feel confident that with you know, now after teaching for the last four or five years, this course multiple times, and I have a big it's a big lecture class, it's a hundred students. So I don't have a the downside of that is I don't have a lot of one-on-one interaction with each of those hundred students, like any other lecture class. But I can tell, and I've been seen just people's eyes open, because of course the book and the course I teach is as much about American history as it is about the Broadway music, because the two things are totally intertwined.
[55:08] Heather Vickery: Sure.
[55:08] David Armstrong: So to see that idea that, oh, this is not number one. I think people are not taught a lot of history anymore. And there's some, I think are coming to the class surprised that it's going to be about history, even though it's clearly literally says that.
[55:24] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[55:25] David Armstrong: It literally says this is a history of the Broadway musical. So I think that the can this whole understanding that this is a an art form that has been around for now a hundred and twenty plus years, depending on where you decide to start it, and that it is a continuum. It starts every I I think one of the things most remarkable about the musical, and you can say this about theater in general, but especially the musical theater because it's so collaborative, is that it's a handed down art form, almost like a medieval craft, like you're a stonemason, and you teach this next person who teaches the next person who teaches the next person, and you can trace that those connections throughout the history of the art form.
[56:16] Heather Vickery: That is beautiful.
[56:17] David Armstrong: I love that. The centerpiece of the book, I call these legacy chains. I trace one of those legacy chains, which is starts with Otto Harbach, who is a name a lot of people won't know, but he was a big famous songwriter and librettist back starting in the in the teens. And you would everyone would know he wrote the lyrics to smoke gets in your eyes. So that's that's his probably his most famous lyric. He is the direct mentor of Oscar Hammerstein the second. He's matched up with by Oscar's uncle, who's a producer, Oscar's yeah, uncle who's a producer, to mentor him and to work with him so that Oscar can learn how to write musicals, can learn how to do this. Then Oscar becomes the direct mentor very famously to Steven Sondheim.
What's he done? You know, who then becomes a direct mentor, exactly, to Lynn Manuel Miranda, is the is the example I use in the book, but he mentored several other people, John Melarson, and it goes on he was so giving with his knowledge and his mentorship because of what he experienced with Oscar, probably because of what Oscar had experienced with Otto Harbach. So between those four people, four individuals, you get four degrees of separation, you get the entire history of the Broadway musical.
[57:44] Heather Vickery: Jeez.
[57:45] David Armstrong: That is so cool.
[57:47] David Armstrong: Yeah, that's the center or what I call the intermission aspect of the book. I love history so much. No one's gonna care about this question but me, but I'm just really curious. When you teach this lecture at the University of Washington, do you teach it in the class?
[57:55] Heather Vickery: Shut up, Alan.
[57:55] David Armstrong: Do you teach it in the same building they teach the dinosaur class in?
[58:04] David Armstrong: I do not.
[58:05] Heather Vickery: Oh I do not.
[58:08] David Armstrong: What is the dinosaur class?
[58:09] Heather Vickery: I don't know.
[58:10] David Armstrong: It's their most popular class. The problem is it's only a two-credit class. It's this the history of dinosaurs.
[58:14] Heather Vickery: Well, tell your daughter that my course gives two provides two requirements.
[58:23] David Armstrong: Does it give history? Because that's she's a double maker.
[58:27] David Armstrong: It gives an art an art requirement, she probably doesn't need because she's in the and it also gives a diversity requirement. So part of the reason it's so popular, I can't take all the credit for it, is people want to get two requirements in one course.
[58:42] Heather Vickery: But that's so cool. I'm gonna tell her she's fast tracking again.
[58:46] David Armstrong: Nobody cares about this, but she's gonna graduate a year early.
[58:49] Heather Vickery: I I don't it's not my favorite thing choice that she's making.
[58:53] David Armstrong: But why?
[58:54] Heather Vickery: Oh, we talk about that offline.
[58:56] David Armstrong: But I don't think she actually is thrilled with this choice either, but this is what's happening now. So she's gonna graduate next spring with a double major in film and history.
[59:05] David Armstrong: Wow, graduating early with a double major, that's impressive.
[59:08] Heather Vickery: Wow, yeah, she like just left yesterday.
[59:10] David Armstrong: Wait a second. I'm getting too old for this world.
[59:12] Heather Vickery: That's how I feel too.
[59:13] David Armstrong: But I want to take your class. Can I audit it?
[59:15] Heather Vickery: I'm not saying the bummer.
[59:18] David Armstrong: I often teach it. I didn't do it this summer, but I often teach it remotely during summer quarter.
[59:25] Heather Vickery: I want to do it. I will I will do it. Will you will you let me know if you do it next year?
[59:30] David Armstrong: Yeah.
[59:31] Heather Vickery: Yeah. I would be so into that.
[59:33] David Armstrong: I'm what I'm the weirdo that okay. Years ago, we have to wrap this show. Years ago, somebody said to me, literally like 25 years ago, what would you do if you won the lottery? And my answer was without question, it might be different now, but back then it was I would go and get my PhD. And they're like, why? And what you don't need more education, you won the lottery. And I was like, because I could afford to learn all these things.
[59:56] Heather Vickery: You wouldn't have to work at the same time while you have exactly I totally understand that.
[1:00:02] David Armstrong: No, I would just travel.
[1:00:03] Heather Vickery: That's my answer.
[1:00:04] David Armstrong: Well, I would make, I would give away a lot of money.
[1:00:07] Heather Vickery: Hire a private tutor so you could get your PhD while you're traveling.
[1:00:11] David Armstrong: Exactly.
[1:00:12] David Armstrong: I'm getting my PhD right now in metaphysical science very, very, very slowly over the course of like 10 years.
[1:00:21] Heather Vickery: Well then, all right. We've taken so much of your time. Final question that we love to use to wrap up all these episodes. Just simply, what is your relationship with failure?
[1:00:30] David Armstrong: I mean, yeah, that's a great it's a great question because you can't take risks without confronting failure at times. And having to, and you know, looking back, I often think about, especially in terms of shows that I've either developed or directed or or been involved with in some way, the shows that didn't quite get there, that never that the ones that got away is the way I think of them. Is like that should have been a great show, and we just didn't quite crack that little 10%, which is really the difference between success and failure.
[1:01:10] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[1:01:10] David Armstrong: Oof is, you know. It's a painful truth. No, and I think about that each of those shows had fantastic elements. Show stopping saw songs, incredibly moving numbers or scenes or things like that, as good as any other show. But the and usually it's a story problem, is you can't quite solve the story. You can't quite make it pay off in the way that it needs to pay off for the audience to go out. That difference between, well, I kind of liked it and wow, that was great.
[1:01:44] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[1:01:44] David Armstrong: I've read books like that where I'm like Totally. We we experience it all the time. It was close. And theater's even worse because you can go to a movie and be disappointed by it, and it doesn't affect you physically. Whereas I think when you go to see a show, a play or a musical, and it doesn't work, because you're a participant in it, your whole entire being is physically trying to make it work, to will it to work, to be come on, we gotta make this work. We're in this together. You gotta, you gotta you have to do the thing I need you to do, whatever that is, we don't know what is, and we are exhausted by it. And it's why I think why people who don't like going to the theater is because they'd never seen anything good. They've only been to things where their body exhausted them and their mind exhausted them because they and so that's their experience of the theater.
[1:02:41] David Armstrong: I think it's a visceral disappointment. Mind-blown. It is such a fascinating perspective. And because we all art is up for a personal interpretation and what you love and what you don't love and what you know. But even when you go to something that I there's things I've I attend and see that I don't particularly like, but I understand, but it's well done. You can appreciate it.
[1:03:09] Heather Vickery: Yeah, same.
[1:03:09] David Armstrong: So it doesn't it it doesn't fail me in that regard. It doesn't make I don't I don't come out uh you know having a uh mental and physical crisis response to the failure of the show the way you often do with something that just doesn't work.
[1:03:28] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[1:03:29] David Armstrong: It just and you don't do that in a movie because the people it's not it's not happening in real time. That's really interesting enough. You don't do that with television.
[1:03:39] Heather Vickery: I wonder to turn it off, or you or you read your own.
[1:03:41] David Armstrong: That's true. Or you could get you could you could stay there and leave it on and scroll your phone.
[1:03:47] Heather Vickery: Yeah, you start looking at your phone. I mean, that's a good sign that the TV show is not engaging, is now you're on your phone.
[1:03:52] David Armstrong: Right. But it doesn't uh affect you physically or mentally in the same way. That's what I'm saying. So I don't know if that answered your question, but that failure is really disappointing, really frustrating because you're so close to something working and you can't quite get it to do that.
[1:04:10] Heather Vickery: And if you had more time or more money or more opportunity, you know, you can always look back and go, well, I still think we could have solved that, but we just didn't discover it.
[1:04:22] David Armstrong: And uh, you know, the story of all these authors and all these shows is sometimes they don't find that solution till the very last second. I mean, Sunday in the Park with George is such a great example. He wrote that song that really ties it together. Uh I forget what that's called. It's the it's uh the a number, it's like a I can't think what it is.
[1:04:46] Heather Vickery: Um, in previous, like the day before the show opened at Playwright's Horizons, and the show didn't work. The aunts hated the show until he that song was in there, and then all of a sudden the show was entirely was was so is the show we know today and so moving and successful.
[1:05:03] David Armstrong: So if he hadn't done that, he'd be in one of those situations of like, why did this what how we were so close, but it didn't work.
[1:05:10] Heather Vickery: Well, that's even like we were talking about Aladdin before we started recording, right?
[1:05:14] David Armstrong: Like they were that that came through the Fifth Avenue, the Disney version that that we know now, right? And came through it. It went through many iterations in Seattle and then Toronto, Toronto. They changed a bunch of stuff that didn't work, still took a chance, brought it to Broadway, and they were rewriting rewriting that literally like James and Roy Egelhardt's uh memorizing a new opening monologue the day that the the reviewers start to show up.
[1:05:40] Heather Vickery: Oh wow.
[1:05:41] David Armstrong: Yeah, it it was just like you never know what's going on behind the scenes to make this stuff happen at the last minute. And it it's incredible that you get to like just be all a part of this.
[1:05:52] Heather Vickery: You you've you've got your hand in creating so much of what we now know as our regular Broadway canon. It's it's phenomenal.
[1:05:57] David Armstrong: Well, thank you. It's it is uh I I never could have conceived that that would was going to happen, but it is very very uh gratifying. Just to put one more pin in that um, or one more element to that success the failure idea is how Prince, I think had the great idea, no matter every day, the night, the morning after every show opened, whether it was the biggest flop or the biggest hit, and he had a lot of flops in his career.
[1:06:28] He had a meeting about the next show. He gathered together the team and the work for whatever the next show was supposed to be. The the very the next morning, even if they were still hung over from the opening night.
[1:06:41] Heather Vickery: I was gonna say, he probably didn't drink the night before, though.
[1:06:43] David Armstrong: I love that. I appreciate it. Like as a I'm a transformation coach, and in even in the book, my book that I wrote, one I think a a key way to be successful and take radical responsibility for your success is to practice what I call the three R's reassessment, reframing and resilience.
[1:07:01] Okay, so what happened? Let's look at it. Let's talk about it. Let's what did we learn from it? Reframing. And then what do we want to change so we can show up and do it again differently?
[1:07:09] Heather Vickery: We're gonna take a quick break. Stay tuned for more of the episode.
[1:07:14] David Armstrong: And now we're back.
[1:07:15] Heather Vickery: I love it. David, you're so whole. We could talk forever. Um, I'm gonna take your class, I'm gonna audit your class. I can't wait to get my hands on on the book.
[1:07:29] David Armstrong: So the book is available everywhere books are sold. You may have to ask your local bookstore to order it. I don't know that it'll be easy to be able to do it. But they will everywhere. But they will order it and they can order it. And please do because I supporting local bookshops, of course, is fantastic.
[1:07:45] Heather Vickery: I know you have a great one in Chicago. What's the name of the theater bookshop there?
[1:07:49] David Armstrong: Um gosh. I don’t I didn’t know that we had a theater bookshop here. That’s embarrassing because I love indie bookstores.
[1:07:56] Heather Vickery: You apparently have a fantastic understudy.
[1:08:00] David Armstrong: Understudy. That’s exactly what I’m saying. Where is it, Alan?
[1:08:04] Alan Seales: Uh it is according to Google. It's the best of Shinkan.
[1:08:11] David Armstrong: I just figured you'd already had it pulled up.
[1:08:12] Alan Seales: Five five thirty-one North Clark, Chicago, Illinois.
[1:08:16] David Armstrong: Okay, so here's what I think which should should happen is you should come here, David, and do a reading and a book signing there, and then we can have dinner together.
[1:08:26] David Armstrong: I am let's make that happen. I would love to do that.
[1:08:29] Alan Seales: Let's do it. I'll help you broker the book.
[1:08:31] David Armstrong: It's also available online. It's on Amazon, although it's currently temporarily out of stock, which I'm taking as a very good sign because it means they didn't order enough copies to meet the demand of the last week since it was been released.
[1:08:42] Heather Vickery: Yep.
[1:08:43] David Armstrong: And but I recommend people go to Bloomsbury.com, the publisher's uh Methwind dramas and imprint of Bloomsbury, where you can buy the book at a discount. They're doing a sort of introductory discount.
[1:08:52] Heather Vickery: Uh and I'm so happy that the publishers have priced the book the way they did.
[1:09:01] David Armstrong: They've released both the hardcover and the paperback at the same time, which is unusual.
[1:09:06] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[1:09:06] David Armstrong: And the hardcover is $100. Uh it's a big book. It's you know, it's worth it. But the soft cover, which uh I'm holding up right here with my little notes. You see, I've got uh things uh tag there.
[1:09:19] Heather Vickery: There we go.
[1:09:19] David Armstrong: Is all is $34.95.
[1:09:22] Heather Vickery: Oh, so reasonable.
[1:09:23] David Armstrong: Yeah. I'm really, really happy with that. And you go and get makes it accessible. I was worried that so many books have to be priced, you know, at that is just not accessible for most people.
[1:09:34] Heather Vickery: They're books I want to buy all the time.
[1:09:36] David Armstrong: And I think, well, that's $90. I don't know if I want to do that. This one, I'm I'm really happy about it.
[1:09:41] Heather Vickery: So are you gonna do an audio book?
[1:09:43] David Armstrong: Uh we are in discussions about that, yes.
[1:09:45] Heather Vickery: Yeah, very cool.
[1:09:47] David Armstrong: Very cool. Oh my gosh, this is so fun. I am so grateful that you chose to spend some time with us here today. And I can't wait to start.
[1:09:55] Heather Vickery: Thank you.
[1:09:56] David Armstrong: He's like the perfect guest to blend my my love with Heather's love of Broadway.
[1:10:00] Heather Vickery: That's true.
[1:10:01] David Armstrong: Books and history.
[1:10:02] Heather Vickery: I mean, I love theater, but theater, books, and history. It's the perfect blend.
[1:10:05] David Armstrong: David, thanks, man. This has been a good thing.
[1:10:07] Heather Vickery: Thank you.
[1:10:11] Alan Seales: Dude, again with the amazing guests.
[1:10:16] Heather Vickery: We have the best guests.
[1:10:16] Alan Seales: Like for real. At the end, I was like, oh, it's a perfect combination of theater and books and history and everything.
[1:10:23] Heather Vickery: I mean, like, god, David, it talks about so much.
[1:10:28] Alan Seales: I've known this dude forever. Every time I talk to him, he I learned something new about him.
[1:10:32] Heather Vickery: And this book, I don't know if if you're watching, you can see how thick this book is.
[1:10:38] Alan Seales: It is 400 some some pages here of just the most incredible knowledge about the Broadway industry you could you could think of.
[1:10:47] Heather Vickery: And he was telling me in a in a live event we were doing together uh last week that it it was 500 something, his first draft.
[1:10:54] Alan Seales: Like his editor really helped him cut it down and focus it and everything, but there's so much to tell about everything.
[1:11:00] Heather Vickery: There's so much about meet our country who it is.
[1:11:02] Alan Seales: People have book limits.
[1:11:04] Heather Vickery: And I'll tell you, we have a publicist that we know within the Was It Chance family who sends really great authors our way. She sent me an ARC.
[1:11:15] Alan Seales: It's 700 pages.
[1:11:17] Heather Vickery: I was like, I am not reading a 700 page.
[1:11:20] Alan Seales: Ah, about what?
[1:11:21] Heather Vickery: I'm just it it's it's historical fiction fantasy. There's a lot of trigger warnings, and she warned me there were trigger warnings.
[1:11:30] Alan Seales: And then when I read the back of the book and I saw what they were, and it was 700 pages, I was like, I'm gonna put this in my little free library.
[1:11:36] Heather Vickery: So I'm really sorry if you're listening to this, I'm not gonna say her name. I appreciate it. Please keep keep sending me arcs, but uh no.
[1:11:42] Alan Seales: So I just googled War and Peace. It's 1200 to 1400 pages, depending on the edition, can take roughly 42 hours at an average reading pace.
[1:11:50] Heather Vickery: I mean, it's I right.
[1:11:51] Alan Seales: No.
[1:11:52] Heather Vickery: This isn't War and Peace, folks.
[1:11:53] Alan Seales: This isn't War and Peace.
[1:11:54] Heather Vickery: Um David is amazing.
[1:11:57] Alan Seales: I think it's so fun that he's at UW and Seattle and we have that little the fun connection.
[1:12:02] Heather Vickery: Thanks for humoring uh me with all of that. I just so admire people who bring up hidden history, who make sure that these incredible humans don't go unrecognized and unnoticed in the world.
[1:12:19] Alan Seales: Uh it just changes things.
[1:12:22] Heather Vickery: It shifts our perspective.
[1:12:24] Alan Seales: And it's also just cool as hell.
[1:12:26] Heather Vickery: Like when when you are obsessed with something or you love something, and then you learn one fact of like, oh, did you know that this thing you love was made by or is about something that you didn't that you thought you didn't like so much.
[1:12:40] Alan Seales: And all of a sudden, just like that, your whole per your whole perception changes.
[1:12:46] Heather Vickery: It can shift how you feel about uh a person, a culture, or anything by learning where something you really enjoy and love has come from and what it's gone through to get right into your eyes or ears.
[1:12:59] Alan Seales: Absolutely.
[1:12:59] Heather Vickery: Yeah, yeah.
[1:13:00] Alan Seales: That's really cool.
[1:13:02] Heather Vickery: I love our podcast so much.
[1:13:04] Alan Seales: Yeah, it's pretty cool.
[1:13:05] Heather Vickery: I love it.
[1:13:06] Alan Seales: It's like one of my favorite things in my whole life.
[1:13:08] Heather Vickery: I love it so much.
[1:13:09] Alan Seales: Pretty cool.
[1:13:10] Heather Vickery: Well, if everybody else finds it favoritely fun, where should they where sh where and how should they let us know?
[1:13:16] Alan Seales: Oh, yes, please, please, please let us know. You can email us at was it chance podcast at gmail.com. But what we would really, really, really love you to do is go to your favorite listening platform and rate and review the show and tell us what you like about it so that other people can find us.
[1:13:35] Heather Vickery: And uh you can find us on the socials too. Like share the stuff, comment, tell us how you're out choosing bravely.
[1:13:42] Alan Seales: So we are on almost but not all of the platforms. We are on Instagram and Threads, we are on TikTok, we are on Blue Sky, we are on LinkedIn.
[1:13:53] Heather Vickery: I think that's it.
[1:13:54] Alan Seales: But I'm on Substack.
[1:13:55] Heather Vickery: There you go.
[1:13:56] Alan Seales: You can talk about there.
[1:13:57] Heather Vickery: Yeah.
[1:13:58] Alan Seales: Reach out to Heather on Substack. It's good stuff.
[1:14:00] Heather Vickery: I created a Substack account. I haven't done anything with it yet.
[1:14:03] Alan Seales: I am loving Substack.
[1:14:05] Heather Vickery: I am having a blast over there. It's a really great space for creatives to just be creative without the performativeness of it.
[1:14:12] Alan Seales: Yep.
[1:14:13] Heather Vickery: Yeah, I've heard good things about it.
[1:14:14] Alan Seales: Anyway.
[1:14:15] Heather Vickery: Oh, and we're on YouTube.
[1:14:16] Alan Seales: Oh yeah, we're on YouTube.
[1:14:18] Heather Vickery: We're on YouTube.
[1:14:18] Alan Seales: Yeah.
[1:14:19] Heather Vickery: And we're everywhere you find your quality podcast. Just like you're listening now.
[1:14:22] Alan Seales: Anywho, Heather, thanks for joining me again, as always.
[1:14:26] Heather Vickery: You're so welcome, Alan.
[1:14:27] Alan Seales: I'll join you on our podcast that we co-produce and co-host every time.
[1:14:33] Heather Vickery: Thanks.
[1:14:35] Alan Seales: I appreciate it.
[1:14:37] Heather Vickery: You're such a weirdo.
[1:14:38] Alan Seales: You have been listening to Was It Chance, the podcast about embracing opportunity and taking intentional risk for your creative life.
[1:14:45] Heather Vickery: I'm Heather Vickery.
[1:14:47] Alan Seales: And I'm Alan Seales.
[1:14:48] Heather Vickery: We'll talk to you soon.
[1:14:49] Alan Seales: Bye bye.
[1:14:50] Heather Vickery: Bye.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
