In this episode, Ben and Daniel discuss the 1992 concert, Sondheim: A Celebration at Carnegie Hall... Read More
From the show: Cast Offs with Ben and Daniel
Featured Artists
Featured Shows
About
In this episode, Ben and Daniel discuss the 1992 concert, Sondheim: A Celebration at Carnegie Hall. This legendary night featured performances by Patti LuPone, Liza Minnelli, Glenn Close, Madeline Kahn, Bernadette Peters, Betty Buckley, Dorothy Loudon, Billy Stritch, Jerry Hadley, Eugene Perry, Herbert Perry, Harolyn Blackwell, Daisy Eagan, Patrick Cassidy, Victor Garber, Bill Irwin, and Karen Ziemba. It was directed by Scott Ellis, with music direction by Paul Gemigniani.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:01] Ben Rimalower: Broken records, the albums you wouldn't shut up about.
[0:06] Daniel Nolen: Broken records.
[0:07] Ben Rimalower: The music our guests can't live without Black Judy.
[0:10] Daniel Nolen: Barbara, Liza, Bent, Batty, Audra Bernadette.
[0:14] Ben Rimalower: We broadcast this podcast with hopes that someday we might get Patti LuPone.
[0:36] Ben Rimalower: I am the aforementioned Ben Rimalower, and I am remotely podcasting with my lovely co-host Daniel Nolen.
[0:44] Daniel Nolen: Hey y'all.
[0:46] Daniel Nolen: Happy um Saturday, Monday.
[0:51] Daniel Nolen: Whatever day it is when you're listening to this.
[0:54] Ben Rimalower: Yes, exactly. Um today we are happy to be discussing another Sondheim concert after our um beloved Sondheim 90th birthday celebration that we talked about last week, which you can find and which I'm sure you loved as well.
[1:11] Ben Rimalower: This week we are talking about Sondheim: A Celebration at Carnegie Hall.
[1:16] Daniel Nolen: Is that correct?
[1:17] Ben Rimalower: That's correct. Um, and what a celebration it has been just across the interwebs this week of uh Stephen Sondheim and his music and all of the uh lovely performers who came to interpret his music this past uh week.
[1:36] Ben Rimalower: Have you ever heard uh the bootleg tapes of Elaine Stritch's Sondheim show that she did at The Carlisle?
[1:44] Daniel Nolen: Um I think I've heard them from you, yes.
[1:47] Ben Rimalower: Sing Elaine Stritch singing Sondheim one song at a time. Unfortunately, I did not see it in its heyday. I saw her second engagement when she really couldn't remember any words and it was like a little little messed up.
[2:03] Ben Rimalower: Um and I think had a lot to do with her deciding to like move to Michigan.
[2:09] Daniel Nolen: Um move to Michigan sounds like a euphemism.
[2:13] Ben Rimalower: Right. Now she moved to Michigan.
[2:14] Daniel Nolen: Now she's really moved to Michigan.
[2:16] Ben Rimalower: But I have the record I have a recording of the first time around, and I love it so much.
[2:21] Daniel Nolen: Oh, it's the one we always talk about when I say how much I love her "Send in the Clowns."
[2:25] Ben Rimalower: Um I always think about it when I say Sondheim, because there's a way that she says his name on that tape where she's like, she's like, Sondheim.
[2:36] Daniel Nolen: Yes, she doesn't quite say all the letters.
[2:39] Ben Rimalower: Sondheim!
[2:40] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, Sondheim, one song at a time.
[2:44] Ben Rimalower: Why not? That's totally what I was doing. And she even says like it's almost like a you sound. It's like Sun Sondheim, Stephen Sondheim.
[2:52] Daniel Nolen: Totally.
[2:53] Ben Rimalower: Sondheim.
[2:56] Daniel Nolen: It's almost as good as her calling Alec Baldwin Alex on his podcast.
[3:03] Ben Rimalower: She's like, here's the thing, Alex. When we eventually have um Scott Ellis on the pod to talk about my favorite Broadway, the leading ladies.
[3:12] Daniel Nolen: Yes.
[3:13] Ben Rimalower: Um obviously, despite his like Tony Awards and career, uh that's obviously his main career accomplishment is my favorite Broadway: The Leading Ladies.
[3:23] Ben Rimalower: Um we also need to talk to him about his other main career accomplishment, which is Sondheim: A Celebration at Carnegie Hall. Um and one of the questions I have is like, why wasn't Elaine or Angela or Barbara Cook involved?
[3:39] Daniel Nolen: Mmm.
[3:40] Ben Rimalower: Right. Why wasn't Mandy Patinkin involved?
[3:44] Daniel Nolen: Right. I mean although I do seem to remember um I I we should have asked Betty this story, but I didn't get the chance. But um I uh I'm I believe I heard somewhere that Betty Buckley, who's of course sings "Children Will Listen," so memorably was not originally supposed to be part of it, and that she was a last minute substitute for somebody else.
[4:07] Ben Rimalower: And I want to say that that was Mandy Patinkin.
[4:11] Daniel Nolen: That was Elaine.
[4:13] Ben Rimalower: Can you imagine?
[4:15] Daniel Nolen: Yes, I can.
[4:18] Ben Rimalower: Where Betty's like, girl follow that tale, you tell.
[4:22] Daniel Nolen: It would be like, careful that tale you tell.
[4:26] Ben Rimalower: Just like Martini sloshing on those kids.
[4:29] Daniel Nolen: Just angrier and angrier.
[4:31] Ben Rimalower: You can sort of imagine Mandy doing it too. Um that's it is strange though to imagine like um of all the things that they had to like last minute substitute, like one that involved the entire Harlem Boys Choir.
[4:46] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally.
[4:47] Ben Rimalower: It would have been so easy to just like take out Patti or Bernadette and plug somebody else in. Like it was just like, you know, by themselves.
[4:54] Daniel Nolen: But like it was a lot of rehearsal to get two different songs mashed up like that with the boys and the whole thing.
[5:00] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah, totally. But Benny's the pro.
[5:04] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, and it ended up being one of the best moments of the show.
[5:04] Ben Rimalower: One of the best. Um, so shall we get into it?
[5:11] Daniel Nolen: Yes.
[5:11] Ben Rimalower: Well, I'll say I just want to say that I remember so well when this concert happened because uh there was a um well, I don't remember when it happened in 1992, and I actually don't remember. But it was on TV in 1993, and I remember um before it aired, there was a um review of it in Newsweek.
[5:37] Ben Rimalower: Newsweek or Time? One of those. We had those magazines in my house growing up. And you know, it was rare that there was anything Broadway related in them.
[5:46] Ben Rimalower: Um so I was very excited to see it, and um the review for the concert was very good, but it was not a good review for Patti LuPone.
[5:55] Ben Rimalower: Um what they said was um she sings "Being Alive," but it should have been called "Being Allowed."
[6:03] Ben Rimalower: Oh but I just remember thinking like that sounds like my kind of performance, you know?
[6:09] Daniel Nolen: Right, right.
[6:10] Ben Rimalower: Um she did not disappoint. Um and then I think I think even before it actually aired, the double CD was released, and I remember getting it and just being so obsessed and then being disappointed when so many things from the album were not on the video.
[6:26] Daniel Nolen: Um but uh but the main most important things were there.
[6:32] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. What are some other of the uh highlights that aren't on the video?
[6:38] Daniel Nolen: Uh well, uh Billy Stritch singing "Anyone Can Whistle" is not on the video.
[6:44] Daniel Nolen: Um Betty, the like, you know, performance art jazz lesbian song troupe. I don't know what to call them. Um they do "I Never Do Anything Twice," but that's not on the video.
[6:59] Daniel Nolen: Um, and uh Liza singing "Water Under the Bridge" is not on the video.
[7:05] Ben Rimalower: Mmm, interesting.
[7:06] Daniel Nolen: And um, oh, there's a bunch, like a lot of those guys' songs, like what is it? Uh "Love," Jerry, is it Jerry Hadley singing "Love I Hear" from Forum?
[7:16] Ben Rimalower: Oh, I love that song.
[7:17] Daniel Nolen: James Naughton singing "Live Alone and Like It," and I'm forgetting, but there's a bunch that's not on the video.
[7:26] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[7:27] Daniel Nolen: Um it's worth listening to the whole thing.
[7:29] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, for sure. Um, but uh, well, I have to say, starting the video, uh something that grabbed me right away, because you know, I've been working this job um as a caretaker for this man with mild dementia.
[7:43] Ben Rimalower: And um I’m actually home now, but his apartment is on 56th, between 6th and 7th. So I have spent the last uh you know, six weeks of this quarantine life that I'd been staying there.
[7:57] Ben Rimalower: I would go out every day for my walks, or honestly, even if I just went to the pharmacy or the supermarket, because he's right there, I would walk by this eerie, ghostly, deserted Carnegie Hall.
[8:11] Ben Rimalower: Walking up the entire block of 7th Avenue from 56th to 57th, and walking down 57th Street from 7th Avenue to 6th Avenue. It's a huge building.
[8:23] Ben Rimalower: And I would walk by the deserted, ghostly Carnegie Hall. And so it was so crazy to put this video on, which I've I've watched this video a hundred times, you know.
[8:34] Ben Rimalower: I know it so well. And yet it was like seeing it for the first time to hear that like scary Sweeney Todd uh that starts from that thrilling suite from Sweeney Todd.
[8:50] Ben Rimalower: And it's this beautiful camera work of Carnegie Hall from the outside with this like dim lighting looking very eerie and ghost-like to match the music.
[9:03] Ben Rimalower: And it's so weird because it really felt like my reality, like watching this video last time.
[9:09] Daniel Nolen: Totally.
[9:09] Ben Rimalower: Oh, it's so funny. But it is a thrilling piece of music. And honestly, I think when I was a kid listening to it, I didn't appreciate it as much because I didn't know Sweeney Todd that well.
[9:21] Ben Rimalower: Um so to me, it was sort of like who cares about that song, you know.
[9:28] Ben Rimalower: Um, and now I'm just like so I I'm so into Sweeney Todd, and I know the score so well and I worked on it and like seen so many productions and videos, and so I I just love hearing it played so thrillingly by that huge orchestra conducted by once again our guy, the one and only Paul Gemigniani.
[9:49] Daniel Nolen: That's right, honey.
[9:51] Ben Rimalower: Maybe on his most Paul Gemignani-esque ever.
[9:54] Daniel Nolen: Totally, totally just giving it to you every day.
[9:59] Ben Rimalower: Giving it to you. Um so uh starts out with the Sweeney thing, and then Jerry Hadley comes on opening up the show with "Joanna" and then Eugene singing "Pretty Women."
[10:12] Ben Rimalower: You kids might not understand like exactly like what Jerry Hadley was like back in the 90s.
[10:19] Ben Rimalower: Um, because he was some opera star, like obviously I don't know him except as like this random opera star, but for some reason he had like major crossover success, which is hard when you look at it now with his like 90s like uh mullet and stuff, you know.
[10:33] Daniel Nolen: Right, right.
[10:34] Ben Rimalower: And he's not particularly attractive. I mean, he looks like he should be like working in the kitchen at an Italian restaurant or something, you know?
[10:43] Daniel Nolen: But um, but he was for some reason like so huge.
[10:48] Ben Rimalower: Like, like there was like did the words like BMG and like Columbia House like record club mean anything to you?
[10:58] Daniel Nolen: Uh no, I mean I know what those I've heard of those uh terms, but I don't know what they are.
[11:04] Ben Rimalower: There were these things that you would see these ads like in all these magazines and like like everywhere you looked, they were advertising, and it was like sign up now and get 10 CDs for one cent.
[11:18] Daniel Nolen: Oh, yeah.
[11:18] Ben Rimalower: And then there was like a monthly thing where they'd send you two CDs and you had a chance to um accept the CDs they were gonna send you, or to choose different ones from their catalog.
[11:30] Ben Rimalower: But those CDs that they'd be sending you then in the regular commitment were charged at a high retail price. Like instead of the like 11.99 you'd spend at your local store, they were like 17.99 or something, you know.
[11:44] Daniel Nolen: And it was kind of a scam, and people were always getting tripped up.
[11:47] Ben Rimalower: Somehow I always managed to just like run away with the fork and the spoon on this. I seemed to just always get the free CDs and never send them a dime.
[11:57] Daniel Nolen: And my parents would be like, this is gonna affect your credit, and I would just never pay.
[12:02] Ben Rimalower: And like for all the bad shit that happened to my credit, I don't think I've ever seen that on one of my credit reports. Jokes on them.
[12:10] Daniel Nolen: But it was actually kind of annoying because you'd be whether you were a normal person trying to like make the most of your like 10 CDs for a cent, or whether you were like me just taking the record company for a ride for months on end, you would still have to look through their catalog and like choose.
[12:27] Ben Rimalower: And for some reason, there was always an endless supply of these, like Jerry Hadley sings Broadway, Jerry Hadley sings like pop favorites, all these Jerry Hadley albums.
[12:38] Daniel Nolen: So I had the whole collection and I never liked it.
[12:43] Ben Rimalower: But uh, but he was BMG, which is like what this uh who produced the like um Sondheim: A Celebration at Carnegie Hall uh album and video and everything.
[12:53] Daniel Nolen: Um so it's so weird because I forgot that he existed, but watching this, I was very much like, whoa, it was like seeing an ex, you know.
[13:01] Daniel Nolen: What does BMG stand for?
[13:04] Ben Rimalower: I don't know, it was like a record company, like RCA BMG, I think were one company.
[13:08] Ben Rimalower: Um, and then they did produce a lot of Broadway stuff, including Patti LuPone Live, girlfriend's first album that came out the same year.
[13:17] Daniel Nolen: That's right.
[13:19] Ben Rimalower: But uh, but anyway, he is great singing "Joanna." I mean, you know, it's an easy song for an opera singer for a tenor to sing, and then you get the Barack Obama twins doing uh "Pretty Women" so beautifully.
[13:33] Daniel Nolen: Um yeah, and I have to say, uh "Joanna" and "Pretty Women," I love both of these songs so much, and I really realize about myself in the past, you know, especially in the past week or so, I love the romantic Sondheim songs, you know.
[13:49] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I mean, there is you know, there's the comedic ones and there's the the patter songs, and he's just such a genius across all different uh you know uh sub uh genres, types of songs, but the romantic ones are the ones that truly reach down and and grab my little heart, and and these two have always been favorites.
[14:11] Ben Rimalower: Um it's funny because like I think like for years, like up until Passion, Sondheim really only gave the romantic songs to the dummies.
[14:21] Ben Rimalower: Like, you know, in like a funny thing happened in the way to the forum, like Hero, like sings Love I Hear that he sings here. But it's like, you know, it was always for the sort of like nitwits. And like, you know, even Anthony and Joanna, they're not really the like leads of Sweeney Todd. I mean, right, you know, they're it they're the romantic characters, but they're much more akin to like if you go in stock types of musical theater, they're more like an 80 Annie and a Will Parker than like a Laurie and a curly, you know. Um but uh but I will say, I mean, I just think Joanna is the most beautiful song, and I always go back to it as just um when I did my son top 10 Sondheim songs for Playbill, I proudly put Joanna very high up because I Oh that's good.
What could be more gorgeous? And you just especially with a big orchestra when you hear that like that's I'm so bad at singing those things, but um I took this quiz online this week of like, do you have perfect pitch? Um my pitch is so bad, it's only better than five percent of the population's deaf people. Seriously. Um anyway, um, so but yeah, it's so beautiful, and and pretty women. I definitely like am still on the high of pretty women that you and I were on when we watched my uh the showstoppers, The Best of Brothers. Yes, yes, yes. And these twin brothers, Herbert and Eugene Perry, in addition to being really hot and both looking like Barack Obama, I thought that they really um they really delivered uh a beautiful version of Pretty Women.
[16:05] Daniel Nolen: Yes, totally, totally. Um, I loved it. And then after this, I wrote down Sweeney Overture, is that right?
[16:12] Ben Rimalower: I can't remember.
[16:13] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, well, because well, there is no Sweeney Overture, but this Sweeney Todd suite that opens it, it's very long and it includes their songs. So it's like first you hear like the ballad of Sweeney Todd played by the orchestra in this very dramatic, full symphonic way. Then Jerry Hadley comes out and sings Joanna, no applause break. The Perry brothers sing Pretty Women, No Applause Break. The three of them sing it together, and then it goes back into the ballad of Sweeney Todd for a huge symphonic finish for a great big show stopping uh ovation before we get on with the concert proper. And that's another thing you have to give to Scott Ellis, that like it's such a brilliant and so Sondheim way to open this show.
It's like I feel like if I were like, okay, I've got this cast, Dorothy Loudon, Liza Minnelli, Patti LuPone, and I'm gonna do this, you know, Sondheim concert at Carnegie Hall. I guess I want to open with Liza doing, you know, like I would just think in terms of that. And the fact is they found something that was so dark and so beautiful and so deep, yeah, befitting Stephen Sondheim, and yet also is so showstoppingly theatrical and goosebump inducing. I mean, you it's so thrilling. I mean, even though it's not something showbusy and rasmataz, it really is a showstopper and it really kicks the concert off on such a high level.
[17:45] Ben Rimalower: Totally, totally. Um, yeah, and it's you know, they talk about Sondheim, he some of his shows are so mature and adult, you know, and I feel like that kind of setting the tone for the concert in that way was so nice to see, you know.
[18:01] Daniel Nolen: Totally were not being talked down to.
[18:03] Ben Rimalower: No, no, no. You know that you are at a piece of art, yes, and you know that you are at something classy. I mean actually, it's everything that that showstopper's the best of Broadway is. It's so classy, it's so artful, and it's so eventful. I mean, that yeah, you just feel like you're like on cocaine, like doing triple backflips at the Met Gala in a tuxedo with the Obamas. It's like it's the Oscars, it's like it's everything. You just feel like nothing going on in the entire universe, including parallel universes, could possibly be more important.
[18:47] Daniel Nolen: You sure have the Obamas on the brain today.
[18:50] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I do. I sure do. Um, so then we have Bill Irwin coming on, giving his like fake Angela Lansbury intro.
[19:00] Daniel Nolen: So brilliant.
[19:01] Ben Rimalower: Just committing to the bit where he and which he comes back and does several more times um in his little comedic way, which is great. And then I think he did a show on Broadway, him and um his uh like comedy slash performance art slash mime partner, um David Shiner.
[19:22] Daniel Nolen: Uh-huh.
[19:22] Ben Rimalower: They did a show on Broadway around this time called Fool Moon.
[19:26] Daniel Nolen: Fool.
[19:27] Ben Rimalower: And Fool.
[19:28] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[19:29] Ben Rimalower: Uh-huh. Okay. And it was a big success. I saw it when they toured to LA. And then they did a couple more things like that over the years. And Bill Irwin's gone on to have a pretty successful career, including he was um what's his name? Opposite Kathleen Turner in the world.
[19:49] Daniel Nolen: Who's afraid of the wolf?
[19:50] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. But I mean he's done many, many things in film and television. But I really feel like the beautiful showing that he made here absolutely was like a huge career step for him. I have to think this put him on the map in a national way in a big sense. I mean, he's so funny and it's so creative. And I mean, I was uh 16 years old watching this, and I didn't know who the fuck he was. I thought there was a techie coming out, you know? And when he's like, when he's like, good evening, my name is Angela Lansbury. Like with his like headset and his like weird clothes. Like, I just like I was going with it, but I was taking it on face value, you know.
[20:32] Daniel Nolen: Mm-hmm.
[20:34] Ben Rimalower: Um anyway, and something he said that I don't think I knew this was that uh Sondheim wrote Mrs. Lovett for Angela.
[20:43] Daniel Nolen: Yes, very cool, right?
[20:45] Ben Rimalower: So cool. I don't think I knew that at all. Um, and I have to say, I mean, we keep talking about Sweeney, but um the older I get, you know, the more, of course, as so many people said in the um in their little intros before their songs on the 90th birthday thing. Um, it takes you a while, you know, you have to get older, whatever, to understand some of these songs. And I feel like uh night music and Sweeney are both Sondheim shows that I've just recently, within the past three or four years, I've really kind of settled into and I've really started to get a little more than I used to.
[21:25] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[21:26] Ben Rimalower: Well, I do think Night Music and Sweeney Todd are his most perfect musicals. Um, you know, like Sweeney Todd might not be for everybody because it's very dark, and a little night music might not be for some people because it's very sort of sophisticated, and in a way the stakes are less high. I mean, you know, it's where Into the Woods, you know, for example, has more sort of like life statements songs that you know, sort of like apply to our own lives. A little night music is very contained, it really just feels like it applies to itself and its characters, you know. But I think that like they both just are perfection. There's not one ounce of fat on either of those.
[22:10] Daniel Nolen: Totally.
[22:11] Ben Rimalower: Totally. Yeah, that's right. I keep um talking about Sondheim writing Sweeney for Angela. I keep coming back to that because um I keep getting these fights with people where I'm like, yeah, yes. Emma Thompson can't sing well enough to be Mrs. Lovett, you know. Um Amelda Staunton can't sing well enough to be Mrs. Lovett. Christine Baranski can't sing well enough to be Mrs. Lovett. Bernadette Peters, I would love to see her as Mrs. Lovett, yes, and but I wish she would have done it before. I'm nervous that she can't still sing well enough to be Mrs. Lovett, you know?
[22:50] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[22:51] Ben Rimalower: Um, I saw her huffing her and puffing her way from Hello Dolly, you know. Um so, so and people are like, What are you talking about? Mrs. Lovett is so easy to sing, you know, you just think that because Patti LuPone belted it, but like nobody else has ever done that, and you don't have to do that. That's not what it's meant to be, you know. And I think the reason that I need to agree to disagree with those people is because I think Angela's singing of that score is deceptively simple.
[23:28] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, she makes it seem easy.
[23:30] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. Because it's like people are like, it's so easy. She's just like, oh, Mr. Todd, I'm so happy. I could eat you up. I really could, you know. And people are like, she's just squeaking. I'm like, she's squeaking in E flat, you know. She's squeaking on pitch, yeah. Um, but I think it's, but I've heard Sondheim talk about writing that for her. It's in um, I forget which book, but some of the books I used to obsessively read in like junior high and high school. There's a great book by the late great movie producer Craig Zadan, uh, called Sondheim and Company that he wrote in the 70s when he was still like a Sondheim nerd. Um, you know, when he was just a Sondheim nerd.
[24:09] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[24:10] Ben Rimalower: And um he has a lot of quotes from Sondheim, and he talks, Sondheim talks about how I think there's some funny, like pure Sondheim quote, like Angela has a decent chest voice and a serviceable head voice. Maybe no, maybe he said she has a strong chest voice and a decent head voice. I don't know. It was something that was like almost a compliment, you know.
[24:38] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah, totally.
[24:39] Ben Rimalower: Um, but I think like when Sondheim said that, you know, he really well said that, you know, he really um he meant it. And I think he really kind of in the way that Scott Frankel did such a great job writing um War Paint, just to like, you know, it's like people talk about tailoring something for somebody's voice, meaning like for their vocal range. But Scott Frankel, when he wrote War Paint for Patti LuPone and Christine Ebersole, it's not just that he wrote their vocal range. He didn't just know the top and the bottom. I think he tailored it to the nooks and crannies. I think he was like, here is where the passaggio between head voice and chest voice is. So I know these kinds of notes will mean sound like this, and these kind of notes will sound like this.
Even more so, I think he thought, oh, the passaggio is here on an E vowel, but it's here on an O vowel, and it's here on an A vowel. I mean, I really think that score for Patty and Christine, especially, especially for Patty, who sounded better in War Paint than she had in 20 years. It really was tailor-made. And I think that Sondheim did that in a sense with Angela, you know. He knew her very well. She had done um anyone can whistle years before, but then the big hit revival of Gypsy in London and on Broadway. And it I, you know, I think that um I think that explains the discrepancy in my fights with people about Mrs. Lovett.
[26:15] Daniel Nolen: Totally, totally.
[26:16] Ben Rimalower: Um, so then we get after the Bill Irwin thing, we get Loveland from Follies.
[26:24] Daniel Nolen: Which again is just such like a strange but also really satisfying choice for the beginning of the show.
[26:31] Ben Rimalower: Yes. I mean it's funny because I can I now to me that song is like Loveland from Follies. But when I was a kid watching it and I really didn't know Follies, I mean I s maybe I had no, I think when I first saw this in 1993, I didn't even know Follies at all. Like I might have known Broadway Baby because like Patty sang it on Life Goes On, you know, but I really didn't know it. This show this concert actually was my gateway to Sondheim. Like really all I knew was Into the Woods.
[27:01] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[27:02] Ben Rimalower: And I think I had just started getting into Sunday in the Park with George.
[27:06] Daniel Nolen: Oh, interesting.
[27:07] Ben Rimalower: But but I really because they were on video, you know, and and Bernadette was somebody that I cared about because I'd seen her in a million movies, and especially Annie. Like I felt like that was like a real, you know, I felt and and into the woods, of course, was so accessible to me as a kid. Um and they but anyway, they had those great original cast videos, but but I really didn't know Follies, and so it's like I think I might have even thought that Loveland was a wedding song that was connected to getting married today. You know, I don't know what I thought. Maybe happen on my taking on its own terms on at face value for me at 16, that just made perfect sense.
[27:50] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[27:51] Ben Rimalower: That that scans. Um then more importantly, it provides a star entrance for Madeline Kahn.
[27:57] Daniel Nolen: Madeline, yes.
[27:59] Ben Rimalower: Madeline motherfucking Kahn coming in to sing not getting married, which I mean, is this like the definitive version of this song?
[28:06] Daniel Nolen: The definitive performance.
[28:08] Ben Rimalower: You know, it's so hard for me because I feel like I know this song so fucking well, and I've seen so many people do it that I feel like I'm desensitized to it. Like it's very like I feel like in order to experience this song, you know, it comedy is so different than other kinds of like performance because like I feel like comedy a little bit relies upon you being surprised.
[28:37] Ben Rimalower: Totally element of surprise. And so it's like it's too hard for me to feel that way because I feel like I just always know the jokes that are coming. So it's like it's like, you know, no matter how many times I see Bernadette sing "Not a Day Goes By," I can still like get hard a little and like feel emotionally moved by her.
[29:00] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[29:00] Ben Rimalower: But I just like I can't get surprised by this song. But I will say it's the first version that I ever knew.
[29:09] Daniel Nolen: Yes, same.
[29:10] Ben Rimalower: And no matter how many brilliant people I've seen do it, including The Ann Cox and Um Katie Finneran. I feel like there's something about like when Madeline Kahn says, "I'm not well, but I'm not getting married," like, yeah, the way she says that is there's something about that lyric that is so I mean, it's so like the layers of sound time. Like, I feel like I'm gonna get tired and faint trying to like unpack the brilliance of this. But it's like it's so in context of like smart, sophisticated, like New Yorkers who are like all in therapy, you know?
[29:52] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[29:52] Ben Rimalower: And she says, and she really leans in on that. The way she says, "I'm not well," it's like you guys know we're all neurotic, we all have problems. You know, we're friends. I've been talking about my emotional problems with you guys since we first met in college when I was still seeing that analyst who lived on the east side. You know, it's like it immediately like just like cuts through so much to like just take you to something specific and meaningful.
[30:21] Daniel Nolen: And I feel like the it's just that you know, it's not that she's proud that she's not well, but it's like but it's a but it is that it's a little bit of pride. It's almost like you're like, okay, Ben, I really need you to like come over and like help me like clean my apartment because like they're coming to film the podcast next week and like we're in this together, you know, and I'm like, I have COVID, I can't help you clean. Like there's a little bit of like "I'm not well, so I'm not getting married." That's almost like using it, you know.
[30:55] Ben Rimalower: Um, totally. I mean, that's what I love so much about her about her thing is that it's like she's like it seems like she's white knuckling it, you know, but she's like maintaining her composure because it's her wedding day. She's like a control freak, like an upper west side, you know, neurotic New Yorker talking about floating in the Hudson with the garbage and um that's what I love so much about her performance because it's very like as as uh we've uh talked about uh watching it, her performance as Eunice Burns in "What's Up Doc," it's like it's very that.
[31:28] Daniel Nolen: It's so that.
[31:28] Ben Rimalower: It's also like about to lose my mind, but like I'm holding on by a thread. I mean, Madeline Kahn, it's safe to say is the worst belter in the history of ever.
[31:38] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, not literally belts.
[31:40] Ben Rimalower: Like, she can't even belt when she's talking. Like, she literally speaks in head voice, you know?
[31:47] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally, totally.
[31:48] Ben Rimalower: And it's like part of what makes her so funny in those movies. And like, it's so brilliant in this song because it's like she's just like, you just always feel that she is just like in like this sort of like, she's just like grasping at straws, trying to control chaos and losing the battle.
[32:10] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally.
[32:11] Ben Rimalower: And there's still that um it's you know, it's from her mix, if you want to call it that, up to her like head head voice, there's like that break. And then when she continues to just like use the head voice, just like going full force with with the upper register, it's so funny because it's all it's like um, you know, it's like she's uh regressing or like um, you know, it's it's like she's in the shrink chair, like uh channeling like her inner damage or something.
[32:41] Daniel Nolen: Totally.
[32:41] Ben Rimalower: And it's and you hear that break so strong. I mean, it's it's funny. The first person I thought of, and it's so fitting is do you know who um uh God what's her name? Uh Beth Howland is.
[32:55] Daniel Nolen: Yes, yes.
[32:56] Ben Rimalower: Well, didn't she sing it on the on the original?
[32:59] Daniel Nolen: Yes, she was the original.
[33:00] Ben Rimalower: And she was the reason she was like famous to me growing up is because she was Vera on Mel's Diner or Alice, as it was called.
[33:07] Daniel Nolen: Alice, yeah.
[33:08] Ben Rimalower: Um, and um she uh similarly, she is someone whose speaking voice always sounds like it's about to crack.
[33:19] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah.
[33:21] Ben Rimalower: It's like, you know, there's never even like five seconds of her looking. You know, it's the opposite of Patti LuPone, who has so much bravado and just like always seems like she just like won three Oscars and is fucking your dad.
[33:36] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[33:38] Ben Rimalower: You know, if there's just like so much like getting fucked from behind by your dad as in the Hollywood. Hardy's voice is just like just like brand burnished with this like shining ego. And Madeline Kahn and Beth Howland are just like the opposite. It just their voice is just like the purest expression of just like just like just ripped open insecurity and just zero confidence.
[34:06] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[34:07] Ben Rimalower: Totally. I mean, it's like it's like the vocal um representation of like that scene in "What's Up Doc" where Eunice puts on her wig, askew, and goes and like bangs on the hotel door.
[34:21] Daniel Nolen: Yes, one thousand percent.
[34:24] Ben Rimalower: Um, and just like the way, I mean, I remember in in uh music theater school, um, they uh one of my teachers would tell us to, you know, because a lot of times we didn't know what to do with our hands, as many performers don't know what to do with their hands. And he was like, go on YouTube and watch Madeline doing "Not Getting Married Today," because every bit of performing she does is with her face.
[34:50] Daniel Nolen: You know, it's literally her face and her voice.
[34:53] Ben Rimalower: She's holding, you know, uh presumably just like gripping that bouquet of flowers. That poor McKay. And then at the end, she, you know, kind of uh puts her arm down to her side. But it's it's such a good lesson in like less is more and just like using the the colors of your voice and kind of your own um uh personality or or how you see the character in telling the story and not uh worrying about the the physicality.
[35:25] Daniel Nolen: Totally.
[35:26] Ben Rimalower: I mean, and also well the confidence of her that she can just stand there, you know, and just be so um, you know, just one of the highlights of the whole thing, and you know, it you know, very arguably the best version of this song ever.
[35:40] Daniel Nolen: Um we saw it in London when we saw "Company" in London.
[35:44] Ben Rimalower: I remember the the guy, the very beautiful guy who played Jamie.
[35:49] Daniel Nolen: That is so rude. Don't do that.
[35:51] Ben Rimalower: The gay guy.
[35:52] Daniel Nolen: Well, no, I'm just saying, like, he's his performance was very um This guy won an Olivier Award.
[35:57] Ben Rimalower: Yes, was the toast of the season, is one of the few performances besides Patti LuPone's that people were clamoring to be brought to Broadway.
[36:07] Daniel Nolen: He's also a British television star.
[36:09] Ben Rimalower: But Daniel calls him the guy who was very beautiful, uh he the very gay guy.
[36:15] Daniel Nolen: That's how Daniel describes him.
[36:17] Ben Rimalower: Well, what's his what's his name?
[36:18] Daniel Nolen: What's his name?
[36:19] Ben Rimalower: Like Jonathan um cake, uh something cake.
[36:23] Daniel Nolen: Um Jonathan Beefcake.
[36:25] Ben Rimalower: No, it's like, oh god. Wait, I can look it up.
[36:30] Daniel Nolen: Anyway, but um yeah, he's on that show, "Broadchurch."
[36:32] Ben Rimalower: Um he's on that show I love with Phoebe Waller S uh what what is it?
[36:37] Daniel Nolen: Waller Snow.
[36:38] Ben Rimalower: Um Phoebe Waller Bridge.
[36:41] Daniel Nolen: Phoebe Snow is somebody else.
[36:42] Ben Rimalower: Phoebe Waller Bridge "Crashing" is so good.
[36:45] Daniel Nolen: He's like that.
[36:46] Ben Rimalower: Um but I would say he did a totally different interpretation that worked, um, but it was like a very physical, outwardly panicked, um, out of breath take on the song.
[37:00] Daniel Nolen: Jonathan Bailey.
[37:01] Ben Rimalower: Jonathan Bailey.
[37:03] Daniel Nolen: And um, so I don't know. It was just interesting to see both of those kind of opposing takes on it, both of which worked.
[37:11] Ben Rimalower: Um anyway, so another something we could all agree on is the next performance.
[37:16] Daniel Nolen: Yes, we do.
[37:17] Ben Rimalower: Liza Minnelli back in business.
[37:20] Daniel Nolen: What I wrote was, because I my last note on Madeline was the almost controlled madness. So my first note for Liza was speaking of madness.
[37:30] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally. Again, peak Liza. Like I just saw a picture that someone like um, I don't know who posted it on Instagram, but it was a photo that Liza had done um for like a magazine or something, and she is wearing the the exact same dress that she wore in this number.
[37:47] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[37:48] Ben Rimalower: Um just like peak Liza looking great, legs by the way, like I mean, it's you know, at the time it would have seemed absurd, but now looking back on this era with like the distance of decades, there's almost something Madonna-ish. It's like, you know, or at least Cher. It's like, you know, where all these like Broadway slobs, you know, Patty and Bernadette, you know, just these tacky like theater actresses with their sequins and their fancy gowns and their baubles, and you know, Liza is in like a cotton dress, you know, with like with like some sort of like like slutty like hooker thing around her waist, you know.
[38:31] Daniel Nolen: Like she like she's almost like casual, like, oh darling, it's just Sondheim in Carnegie.
[38:35] Ben Rimalower: Oh, it's not the Oscars.
[38:37] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, it's like from like Charlotte Russe or somewhere in the mall.
[38:40] Ben Rimalower: Totally. She's just like, I just have to be comfortable when I'm dancing on top of a piano.
[38:46] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, which that part was making me so nervous, even though I knew she, you know, had the skill to do it. Like, I was so nervous the whole time that she was gonna fall off or like damage the piano.
[38:58] Ben Rimalower: I was like, that was a strong choice. Okay, first of all, I just have to give proper shout out because this arrangement is by Billy Stritch, who also duets with her on it in addition to accompanying her. And it is the most magical arrangement of any song that's ever been arranged ever.
[39:16] Daniel Nolen: Ever, totally, totally.
[39:17] Ben Rimalower: I mean, when I like listen to like uh "I'm Breathless," Madonna's like basically the movie soundtrack of "Dick Tracy." I don't give a fuck about this song "Back in Business."
[39:26] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah.
[39:37] Ben Rimalower: But this version is like my favorite song that ever was written.
[39:42] Daniel Nolen: Totally, totally.
[39:44] Ben Rimalower: Um, and Liza, I mean, we talked about this kind of in the uh the leading ladies concert, but she's so good at uh telling the story.
[39:53] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, you know, she Oh my god, yes.
[39:56] Ben Rimalower: When she's like, "Yesterday, things it looked as if things were about to end."
[40:01] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah, and the way she does those little didn't it's where she looks at Billy and she looks at the audience, she didn't it I mean it's it's such a joke now because we would do that about Liza doing anything, you know, like do Liza singing "Jesus Christ Superstar." She's like, "I have to know, I have to know, my god, but you tell me," you know, like you always want to put it into that like inappropriately conversational tone that like interrupts the melodic flow of the line.
[40:28] Ben Rimalower: Because she's done it over the years as a crutch sometimes instead of singing and whatever.
[40:32] Daniel Nolen: You know, right.
[40:33] Ben Rimalower: But this is just such a beautiful, beautiful like iteration of it.
[40:39] Daniel Nolen: Totally.
[40:39] Ben Rimalower: I mean, I feel I've watched it, I was like, I feel like we're all like little kids going to like the public library for like drag queen story time, and we're all sitting around in a semicircle, and Liza is just like, you know, bringing out the book that is her voice and dress and performance and hair and makeup.
[40:58] Daniel Nolen: And this beautiful song by shh Steven Sondheim.
[41:04] Ben Rimalower: I mean, I used to make fun of her in this concert, like when I was in high school. Like one of my first impressions was Liza going, "Hey, oh, fret."
[41:14] Daniel Nolen: Wow, sick.
[41:18] Ben Rimalower: Because it's so staccato, and there's just like so staccato.
[41:21] Daniel Nolen: I mean, you certainly couldn't accuse her of over-singing the melody.
[41:26] Ben Rimalower: Right, right.
[41:27] Daniel Nolen: And now it's like seems churlish to complain these years later because like we would give anything for Liza to be well, at this point, we'd give anything for Liza just to do like, you know, a zoom cast of just being like, "Happy birthday, Sheep."
[41:42] Ben Rimalower: You know, totally.
[41:43] Daniel Nolen: But you know, certainly we would give anything for her to sing at all.
[41:47] Ben Rimalower: But it's because I watch this now, and to me, she just sounds thrilling.
[41:53] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, amazing.
[41:55] Ben Rimalower: Amazing. I mean, it's like it's like I said, peak Liza. And then, in addition to the song, it's thrilling because we get to see her leading a fucking dance break.
[42:05] Daniel Nolen: It's 12 dance breaks.
[42:07] Ben Rimalower: I mean, not for nothing. Liza gets on top of the piano two different times within this song.
[42:14] Daniel Nolen: She gets back up.
[42:16] Ben Rimalower: Who does that?
[42:17] Daniel Nolen: And she tap dances on the piano.
[42:20] Ben Rimalower: And I mean, it's like the fact that, like, you know, I guess some of this is sort of a Kay Thompson style kind of thing with the call and response, and they're like, guess who's back? Look who's back? Back in business, back in business, back.
[42:41] Daniel Nolen: I mean, just you know, all the different parts, and the like, you know, uh, you know, get back in business, and Liza going like, let the good times, let the good times roll.
[42:54] Ben Rimalower: Like, all that stuff. It just creates this like counterpoint, this three-way counterpoint between the chorus girls and Liza and Billy. And it's just it gives the song so much texture and just builds and builds and builds. I mean, if anybody thought Scott Ellis was like so classy and fancy, opening with an orchestral suite from Sweeney Todd.
[43:19] Daniel Nolen: Right.
[43:19] Ben Rimalower: Where like the most schmalty thing is having like three opera stars come out in tuxedos and be like, "I see," like, oh no, no, no, no, no, no, no. He and Susan Stroman are waiting in the wings, giving you this. I mean, this is like crazy for you on crack.
[43:40] Daniel Nolen: Totally, totally.
[43:42] Ben Rimalower: Um, yeah, they got Liza in their back pocket, hun. Um. So then, okay, after this wonderful number, then we get the Tonics singing "Good Thing Going," which I, or as I would have said in 1993, and I still say it today, ugh, the fucking Tonics.
[44:01] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally.
[44:02] Ben Rimalower: I was not into this. I've never understood why this happened.
[44:08] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I mean, it's I mean, I guess it's such a product of the time or whatever, but like it's still, I mean, it does. And I think it has something to do with AIDS, maybe.
[44:21] Ben Rimalower: I will say that I don't know. I'm just drawing straws here. Like, um, I will, you know, like people were into like Manhattan Transfer and like a cappella stuff in the 80s and 90s, and it was like how they bonded, you know, but I don't know. But uh, I will say it was exciting to see Jason Robert Brown playing the piano for them.
[44:43] Daniel Nolen: Oh, I didn't even notice.
[44:45] Ben Rimalower: Fun fact. Fun fact. Um, also it as much as I just hate them and wish they were not on the video, it is a particularly pungent moment of 90s fashion.
[44:58] Daniel Nolen: Yes, absolutely, absolutely.
[45:00] Ben Rimalower: I love the fashion in this as well. I mean, that is three men and a lady, all wearing blazers, not one of them wearing a button-down shirt underneath it.
[45:10] Daniel Nolen: Right.
[45:11] Ben Rimalower: It's like an experiment in different things you can pair with a blazer. You can wear a blazer with a dress. You can wear a blazer with a t-shirt. You can wear a blazer with a sweater.
[45:23] Daniel Nolen: Oh my god, I miss the blazer with dress moment in time. That reminds me of just like being a kid going to church and like all the moms in the church just wearing like their little floral Easter dresses with a blazer on it.
[45:36] Ben Rimalower: Um, this song is the Easter of Sondheim is celebrating.
[45:42] Daniel Nolen: Totally. Speaking of moms in church, um, by the way, one more bad thing about the Tonics is that they come out singing "Good Thing Going," which is such a great song, and they really suck. And I, you know, I mean, I guess they don't suck. They're a very good close harmony jazz a cappella.
[46:02] Ben Rimalower: I guess they're not a cappella because they've got Jason Robert Brown. But I mean, like, if you want somebody to do that, if that's the assignment, they certainly do it as well as or better than anyone else. But not for nothing. It took me many years to realize that I actually love the song "Good Thing Going," because this version permanently left a bad taste in my mouth.
[46:24] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[46:25] Ben Rimalower: And just when you think it's finally over, thank God, it then turns out to be what a mashup. I mean, you know, fucking god damn it, Madeline Kahn only gets to sing one song, but the Tonics get a medley of "Good Thing Going" into the title song from Company.
[46:45] Daniel Nolen: You know who sings my favorite "Good Thing Going"?
[46:48] Ben Rimalower: Who?
[46:49] Daniel Nolen: Nancy Lamott.
[46:51] Ben Rimalower: Yes, because it's a medley with "Matay Goes By," so good. Yeah, love, love, love. Um, so next up, Dottie Loudon doing "Miss Loudon if you're nasty."
[46:56] Daniel Nolen: Miss Loudon if you're nasty, um, doing her legendary "Losing My Mind." Um, does she could drive a person crazy. Slash you could drive. Now that's a medley that I am here for.
[47:16] Ben Rimalower: Here and queer for. Is she actually does she actually play piano or is this like Barbara in concert where she like sits down and just like tinkles out a few keys and then like goes on goes about her merry way? Like, does Dottie actually play piano?
[47:30] Daniel Nolen: Do you mean like separate from this? Like if I invited her over to my apartment, could she just like bust out some Rachmaninoff?
[47:36] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah. I mean, like, is she does she have a history of being like a pianist?
[47:40] Daniel Nolen: I do not know. But you're making me realize that I was so into her from this that in addition to getting the cast albums of Annie, well, I guess I already had Annie, but in addition to getting the Ballroom cast album, I got her solo albums. Um, one of which she sings "I Love a Piano."
[47:58] Ben Rimalower: And definitely in my 16-year-old self, I was like, oh, because she plays piano.
[48:03] Daniel Nolen: Oh, interesting.
[48:05] Ben Rimalower: But I don't have any reason to tell you that that your answer to your question is yes. I'm just knowing that if you asked me in 1993, I would have been like, yes, that is correct.
[48:14] Daniel Nolen: Well, seeing her there at the piano, it just seems so right because to me she just strikes me as like a lovely, um, lonely, well, lovely at first glance, and then a lonely old piano teacher who, you know, is drinking a little bit.
[48:30] Ben Rimalower: Oh, or like, or like a saloon entertainer, like she'd be the like, yeah, like she's playing in a lounge somewhere.
[48:36] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, a madam in a saloon.
[48:39] Ben Rimalower: Exactly. And it's just so, I mean, it's really a one-act play. I mean, it's like a short film. Like her journey at that piano, you know, dun dun dun dun, you know, when she's like, thus in her weird little shrill, the way she like just like sort of like precariously perches on those notes.
[49:00] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, and then the fact that she's wearing like this black prom dress almost, it's like it makes such a, it's like very lounge singer. But it's also like, it's like Miss Havisham, or like she's like this scorned lover who's like still living in this, um, I hear the dances, you know, and it's like this, um, it's like a specter of a younger self.
[49:27] Ben Rimalower: I don't know. Um, so just the whole vision and the whole scene that she sets is just perfect. And it and the and this is another, I mean, arrangement that is so genius. And the orchestration, I mean, the way, um, the way that the orchestra swells in when she gets up from the piano, all afternoon. I mean, it's like it's so uplifting. It's just so majestic.
[50:02] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally.
[50:04] Ben Rimalower: Um, I mean, it starts out, it's like it's so brilliant. I don't want to say it's a joke in a way that diminishes it, but there's, you know, it's a novelty, it's gonna be a medley. Yeah, but when that orchestra comes in, it might be the best version of "Losing My Mind" that ever happened. I mean, you know, I don't think that necessarily is true, but one could certainly make a case.
[50:28] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, 100%.
[50:30] Ben Rimalower: And many people do. I mean, many, you know, so many people, this is like their preferred version of "Losing My Mind." Because isn't "You Could Drive a Person Crazy" the subtext of all versions of "Losing My Mind"?
[50:42] Daniel Nolen: Yes, totally, totally.
[50:46] Ben Rimalower: Um, I mean, the moment that it really all is about for me is when she's like, and her voice is so crazy because she has that little like trilling, like precarious mezzo, you know, and then she has her belt that just sounds so frazzled and like out of steam. And yet there's something still kind of like big and fabulous about it, despite all that.
[51:10] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[51:10] Ben Rimalower: You know, but when she gets to that part when she's like, I could understand a person, and the orchestra's like if it wasn't good and fed, doo-doo, doo-doo, doo. I feel like I just want my whole life to just begin and end in that 11 seconds.
[51:30] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, absolutely.
[51:32] Ben Rimalower: It's like, I mean, she's so, it's like so frazzled and so on edge that it's like I wrote down it, it reminds me of like an Ellen Burstyn performance. But like Ellen's Ellen Burstyn, like on drugs.
[51:46] Daniel Nolen: No, it's exact, it's actually a mixture of Ellen Burstyn and Ellen DeGeneres.
[51:50] Ben Rimalower: Ellen DeGeneres?
[51:52] Daniel Nolen: It's like a hilarious Ellen DeGeneres comedy routine that like is completely fused with an Oscar-winning Ellen Burstyn tragic performance.
[52:02] Ben Rimalower: Totally. I'll take it. Um, then of course there's the moment that we talked about, um, oh, drag.
[52:09] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, the drag fad moment.
[52:12] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, because she's seen her find that word. Yes, huge laugh. And I mean, it's so great how it goes back and forth between the songs. It just builds and builds and builds. Um, and what, uh, uh oh, and when she goes into that crazy repeat, um, "Lily, you's your lovely person, you're doing," do you think, no, what is it? It's not that she puts the point where she goes like crazy, crazy, crazy, crazy, crazy, crazy, crazy, crazy, crazy, crazy.
[52:47] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[52:50] Ben Rimalower: And then the music changes and the light changes, and she, her face changes. Or am I just being kind.
[53:00] Daniel Nolen: I mean, that's the one part. I mean, as crazy and over the top as it is, she's so committed and truthful. That is the first time in the whole song that she's kind of steps outside the joke a little bit, just enough to say, or am I just being kind, you know?
[53:20] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah.
[53:20] Daniel Nolen: And the audience gives it to her because she's earned the right. Uh, and then she for the final, or am I losing my mind? And it's just you just feel that she's laid it all on the field, you know.
[53:34] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, absolutely. Um, my note after this song was this concert has aged like a fine wine.
[53:43] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[53:44] Ben Rimalower: It just felt so fresh. Watching this, I felt like we didn't need to live the last 37 years of culture because the 37 years have produced nothing. Not Lin-Manuel Miranda, not Chris Rock, not Michelle Obama, not, you know, nothing that not Broad City. There's nothing that has taken us one millimeter further than the high genius advancement we were at with Dorothy Loudon in 1992.
[54:17] Daniel Nolen: Dorothy was our Lin-Manuel Miranda in '92.
[54:21] Ben Rimalower: Totally. Also, I had to, this is how deeply moved I was. I said the fabulous sound mixing. Because the applause that Dorothy gets, it really is so intense on the video.
[54:35] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[54:36] Ben Rimalower: They really make you feel. I mean, compare that to Showstoppers where they do some like sort of, you know, perfunctory rote shots of the audience giving a standing ovation to Ethel Merman or whoever.
[54:48] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[54:49] Ben Rimalower: But the sound mixing on this video, you feel like the people behind you are screaming in your ear, and the lady next to you stands to her feet so fast there's a whoosh of her dress. Like it's really like being there and supporting Dorothy and her genius.
[55:05] Daniel Nolen: I love that it's officially now like canon in our podcast that we hate Showstoppers.
[55:12] Ben Rimalower: So much.
[55:13] Daniel Nolen: It's like at every opportunity.
[55:15] Ben Rimalower: Well, it's not as bad as Showstoppers.
[55:17] Daniel Nolen: You know what that's like.
[55:17] Ben Rimalower: Showstoppers.
[55:19] Daniel Nolen: Totally. Um. Anyway, so what's not like Showstoppers, but which what is truly, truly magical and epic is the next song, which you don't think it can get better after Ellen Burstyn, aka Dottie Loudon. But it does because the Harlan Boys Choir comes in singing "Our Time," and I gives you a respite that you need after Dorothy.
[55:40] Daniel Nolen: Yes, you do.
[55:41] Ben Rimalower: You are not ready to laugh, and you are not ready to get gay and go crazy about some diva.
[55:47] Daniel Nolen: Right.
[55:47] Ben Rimalower: You need a moment and a bunch of boys in matching sweaters going, something is stirring, shifting wrong. That is what you need. It's just a breather. It's just beautiful, tranquil, so beautiful.
[56:06] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[56:07] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. I mean, like, I definitely, uh, the tears began whenever I heard them singing that because it was just so moving. And then BLB, Betty Lynn Buck coming in hot, singing "Children Will Listen," and it is incredible.
[56:25] Daniel Nolen: I mean, she I love her outfit, first of all. She's wearing like, um, a belt.
[56:30] Ben Rimalower: She listen, honey, belts on belts for this performance because it is giving me life.
[56:36] Daniel Nolen: And then it's like black, is it a skirt or like palazzo?
[56:40] Ben Rimalower: It's palazzo pants, right?
[56:42] Daniel Nolen: I thought it was a skirt, but I didn't look too closely.
[56:44] Ben Rimalower: If it's a skirt, it's very, um, long, floor-length fitted black skirt, and a white silk blouse with the popped collar.
[56:54] Daniel Nolen: Thank you very much.
[56:56] Ben Rimalower: Belted, yes.
[56:57] Daniel Nolen: And a short, like sort of, you know, kind of Sandy Duncan tomboy haircut, very Peter Pan.
[57:06] Ben Rimalower: Maybe that's why I thought she played Peter Pan.
[57:08] Ben Rimalower: Ooh.
[57:10] Daniel Nolen: And she comes out, and it's so subtle at first. She's so like, like, you're almost like, why is she even there? You know, she's just like careful the things you say.
[57:19] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[57:28] Daniel Nolen: Children will like it's so small and like, but not small in like a like children movies. She's not like, ooh, listen to my beautiful, pretty voice. I'm singing this so small. She's just telling the story. That's what she feels like. She feels like a teacher in a classroom reading you a story.
[57:39] Ben Rimalower: Yes.
[57:50] Daniel Nolen: It's very like storytelling. Careful of the things you say. And you suddenly feel like story songs. It's almost like she's playing Mrs. Anna in The King and I, and she's singing, like she's like, there's a true and ancient saying, but a true, but it's but a true and honest thought that if you become a teacher by your pupils, you'll be taught.
[58:10] Ben Rimalower: It's very as a teacher, I've been learning.
[58:14] Daniel Nolen: It's almost it has that Julie Andrews Sound of Music kind of quality to it. It's very storytelling teacher, it's so perfect. And you don't even know how perfect it is because it starts so effortless, and like you just have no idea where it's going.
[58:32] Ben Rimalower: Yes, and it does take the journey. And I mean, by the end of it, her epic belt is so good, and I just love how she's this moment where she like she does that mic pull away, you know, that people do when they're so loud that they have to pull the mic away a bit, and I'm just like, yeah, like living.
[58:53] Daniel Nolen: She pulls the mic, and as the mic gets further away, her voice just gets louder and louder.
[58:59] Ben Rimalower: Yes, and so all you can think is like it would have actually been too loud if she would have actually pulled the mic away.
[59:09] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, we would our eardrums would have been completely damaged.
[59:13] Ben Rimalower: But it's like but the there's her voice is like a built-in reverb. Like when she goes like careful, you tell it's like it's like there's her vibrato has vibrato.
[59:30] Daniel Nolen: I love it. I love it. I mean, honestly, if I had to pick like one note in the history of all singers ever singing every song, that one note that's my favorite note, it's Betty Buckley on the word careful in that final chorus.
[59:53] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I don't know how she does it. I've never heard anybody do anything. The closest I've ever heard to anybody doing anything like that is Betty singing Memory when she says, um, when she sings Touch Me, it's so easy to leave me.
[59:53] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah.
[1:00:13] Ben Rimalower: But even that feels more obvious.
[1:00:18] Daniel Nolen: This feels more special.
[1:00:21] Ben Rimalower: Like, I mean, it's the reason we've talked about this. It's the reason that I hate every version of Children Will Listen.
[1:00:28] Daniel Nolen: Yes, yes.
[1:00:28] Ben Rimalower: Same.
[1:00:31] Daniel Nolen: Um the one that I'm most angry at now that I'm saying it out loud is Ruthie Henschel.
[1:00:40] Ben Rimalower: Whoa, okay. We need to save this for our little uh uh I'll be Patty segment of Tuesday, Thursday April August, because I feel like there's some work to be done.
[1:00:49] Daniel Nolen: Okay, all right. So this will be my next I'll be Patty on this Tuesday is Tuesday, Thursday, April, August. We gotta break that.
[1:00:59] Ben Rimalower: That's appointment television.
[1:01:01] Daniel Nolen: That sure is. Um, so Betty, the Harlan Boys choir and Betty give us a nice respite from Dottie Louden. And then I will say one more one more thing about it that's poetic justice is the fact that Betty had done. I mean, I really want to do like a whole podcast, like, I don't mean an episode of our podcast. I mean I want to create a new podcast about the development of Into the Woods.
[1:01:29] Ben Rimalower: Oh, yeah, that's a great idea.
[1:01:31] Daniel Nolen: And I don't really know the truth. But I think what I've been able to glean is that not necessarily the first reading of Into the Woods, but a early reading of Into the Woods, or a series of early readings of Into the Woods, Betty Buckley played The Witch.
[1:01:50] Ben Rimalower: And then either because they didn't want to keep working with her, or they offered it to her, but she wouldn't do it for the offer. Or I think there's a third possibility, and now it's escaping me. But for some reason, she did not go do it in La Jolla, where they did a workshop with a full production rather, prior to the Broadway production that featured much of what became the Broadway cast.
[1:02:31] Daniel Nolen: But I believe I'm understanding correctly that then there was another reading in New York at Playwrights Horizons after La Jolla, in which Betty again played The Witch. And then I don't know if they offered her The Witch for Broadway and then couldn't come to terms, or if that was when they didn't want to work with her again, or she didn't want to do the part. I mean, I know there was some not seeing eye to eye between her and James Lapine. I can't really get the story straight. But but anyway, regardless, it's safe to say that The Witch is one of Bernadette Peters' great roles on Broadway.
[1:02:31] Ben Rimalower: Yes.
[1:03:11] Daniel Nolen: And if you're a true Betty Buckley fan, you might regret that Betty didn't have that opportunity and having created the role in these readings. So there's something poetic justice about the fact that Betty sings for my money, the definitive, and certainly for everybody's money, the most thrilling version of the witch's big song in this concert.
[1:03:11] Ben Rimalower: Yes, absolutely.
[1:03:40] Daniel Nolen: And it is the most thrilling version. I mean, usually I hate that song. Um I do not hate is the one that comes next. Speaking of most thrilling versions.
[1:03:51] Ben Rimalower: Totally, totally.
[1:03:52] Daniel Nolen: Patti LuPone singing Being Alive. Now, is it just me? Or does that audience go Dorothy Loudon ovation crazy?
[1:04:04] Ben Rimalower: Totally. When Patty walks out on stage.
[1:04:07] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah. Now, in fairness to Betty, that is not the real order of the concert. So it's not like Betty walks off and the applause goes up. It's not like Patty gets more applause for entering than Betty did for singing.
[1:04:07] Ben Rimalower: Yes.
[1:04:25] Daniel Nolen: That that's just the edit. In real life, that didn't happen. But whoever came before Patty in the real concert, their applause was dying. And I I don't know another example of a concert entrance when a star, when the audience goes so crazy for somebody coming out on stage.
[1:04:44] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah, totally. I mean, I wrote thunderous applause. I mean, Patty had not been on a New York stage since Anything Goes.
[1:04:44] Daniel Nolen: Mmm.
[1:04:52] Ben Rimalower: Which was four years earlier.
[1:04:54] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, they're thirsty.
[1:04:56] Ben Rimalower: They sure were. Um, so yeah, show she's showing tits. I mean, uh there's something. Now there's something else before we get into all the magic and genius of Patty's performance of Being Alive. I want to point out a magic that I just discovered watching this video, which is that Patty must have A, a sewing machine, and B a time machine.
[1:05:24] Daniel Nolen: Because she stole her Norma Desmond gold brocade robe.
[1:05:31] Ben Rimalower: She stole two of them, I guess, because she wore one in her basement video where she sings with one look. And the other one, she cut up and sewed into a matching jacket and pants to wear to sing Being Alive at Carnegie Hall the year before Sunset Boulevard.
[1:05:31] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:05:52] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. And Anthony Powell, who designed that fabulous Norma Desmond costume, must be so sad to see how she destroyed it and turned it into this Long Island bat mitzvah nightmare.
[1:06:10] Daniel Nolen: I mean, I did notice I was like, gold. It's so interesting, especially because before this in the concert, it's I thought it was like a black and white theme, you know, like everyone was told to wear black and white because maybe they were.
[1:06:10] Ben Rimalower: Maybe it was.
[1:06:23] Daniel Nolen: And then I saw this gold and I was like, maybe not. Or maybe someone just didn't read the memo.
[1:06:28] Ben Rimalower: But I feel like it's a good one. I mean, it's a gold brocade jacket and gold brocade palazzo pants, which are words that should never appear together in that order.
[1:06:42] Daniel Nolen: And as crazy as all that is by itself, you know that black, stretchy spandex fabric Liza's dress was made out of. You might have an opinion about Liza wearing that dress. Maybe you love it like I do. Maybe you don't. Maybe you're like, it's Carnegie Hall. Come on, Liza, don't wear spandex. What happened to your world famous sequins? But that's your business. I liked it on Liza. But I certainly don't think you take that black spandex cotton fabric and make a tank top to go with your gold brocade suit.
[1:06:42] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah, totally.
[1:07:19] Daniel Nolen: But you know who did do that? Patricia LuPone.
[1:07:25] Ben Rimalower: Oh, and just in case you're thinking, God, that outfit sounds like a real doozy. I'm sure glad I'm listening to Ben and Daniel and not watching her wear that. That's not the whole battle. She also got a hair helmet worthy of my great grandma Gittle.
[1:07:25] Daniel Nolen: Not that.
[1:07:50] Ben Rimalower: I mean, it's literally like she went to an old-fashioned beauty parlor and sat underneath one of those blowout things for three hours smoking cigarettes.
[1:08:00] Daniel Nolen: She went to Truvies.
[1:08:03] Ben Rimalower: I mean, you kind of have to imagine that like Bernadette and Glenn were sitting next to her, and they were like, shh, don't tell Patty, my hairdryer's not on.
[1:08:16] Daniel Nolen: Right. Don't tell her.
[1:08:17] Ben Rimalower: Patty fell asleep reading a magazine in her hair.
[1:08:19] Daniel Nolen: No, I think they just sat there for three hours and let Patty talk. And they were like, and Bernadette was like, Putty, I've heard that the producers on Life Goes On are not always sensitive to your needs as an artist.
[1:08:33] Ben Rimalower: They did then they just let her run.
[1:08:34] Daniel Nolen: And they just let her rip. And every once in a while, Glenn would go, that sucks.
[1:08:40] Ben Rimalower: And Patty would just keep on lighting up another fag.
[1:08:44] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally. Once in a while, once in a while, Bernadette would lean in with a lighter and let Patty keep talking and smoking at the same time.
[1:08:55] Ben Rimalower: Glenn was like, Bernadette, don't you feel bad. It's one thing to make her hair look bad, but I'm worried what we're doing to her voice with all these cigarettes.
[1:09:04] Daniel Nolen: And Bernadette was like, don't worry about that. I've tried. It doesn't seem to affect her.
[1:09:04] Ben Rimalower: I like your Glenn.
[1:09:13] Daniel Nolen: I don't know how in my version of the story today, Glenn is the nice one, but whatever.
[1:09:17] Ben Rimalower: My how things have turned.
[1:09:20] Daniel Nolen: Um that to say. All that to say this. She still kind of looks good if you just completely forgive what she's wearing and how her hair is. And this song, if anything, the performance makes you forgive any flaw.
[1:09:20] Ben Rimalower: Anything.
[1:09:36] Daniel Nolen: She could literally have a gas chamber and six million Jews on that stage.
[1:09:41] Ben Rimalower: Don't, don't.
[1:09:42] Daniel Nolen: And I'd be like, you do you, boo.
[1:09:46] Ben Rimalower: Why are you always gonna take it there?
[1:09:49] Daniel Nolen: You don't know what it's like, my people.
[1:09:51] Ben Rimalower: Oh my god.
[1:09:52] Daniel Nolen: Oh my god.
[1:09:52] Ben Rimalower: Okay.
[1:09:53] Daniel Nolen: Um the point is it's a performance that would earn forgiveness of any sin because it is stratospheric.
[1:09:53] Ben Rimalower: Stratospheric.
[1:10:05] Daniel Nolen: I mean, the way she says put me through how it's very like we say, me to his wow. It's very a classic Patty vowels.
[1:10:14] Ben Rimalower: It might be the first, I you know, it's like it really makes sense that I think about it. You know, I feel like up until this moment, Patty's career starting at Juilliard, when John Houseman gave her grief over her bad diction. You know, all the other kids were early to class that day so they could practice going, unique New York, you need New York. You know you need unique New York. And Patty was like in the hallway gossiping or like sucking Kevin Klein's dick or something, you know.
[1:10:14] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, both.
[1:10:48] Ben Rimalower: Starting that day, all through previews of Evita when the gossip mill was that she was gonna be replaced by Elaine Page, and Hal Prince was giving her notes on her diction, and the bad reviews she got for her diction in Oliver, and in Les Misérables, and of course, famously in Anything Goes when Forbidden Broadway did, you know, um, Patti LuPone. You know, I mean, her legendarily lazy diction.
[1:11:24] Ben Rimalower: Legendarily lazy license. Somehow, somebody must have said to her, Patty, you are singing Steven Sondheim songs tonight opposite Bernadette Peters, okay? Dorothy Loudon was an acclaimed Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd on Broadway. The original casts of Assassin and Assassins and the New York City Opera Company of A Little Night Music. You are in Sondheimian Company conducted by Paul Gemigniani. You need to stop sounding like Patti LuPone and start pronouncing the words. And I think this moment was the birth of Patti LuPone saying, Oh yeah? You think I don't have enough diction? I'll give you diction like you never dreamed.
[1:12:18] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I mean, the V's, especially the V's at the end of a phrase. Alive. I mean, she gives you every letter you paid for.
[1:12:32] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally. Like, you know, Vanna White can just take the night off because Patty is giving you every letter in every word.
[1:12:41] Daniel Nolen: Totally. And plenty, plenty of letters that you didn't think needed it. For example, support.
[1:12:49] Ben Rimalower: Support. Totally. I mean, was that her subtly letting us know that her name is pronounced LuPone?
[1:12:58] Daniel Nolen: Right, totally. I mean, you get the support and the in the. Do you think she spells support with a capital P?
[1:13:04] Ben Rimalower: Ooh, like S U, capital P P.
[1:13:07] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally. Or is it S U P and the second P is capitalized, maybe?
[1:13:12] Ben Rimalower: I don't know. Or maybe there's just one P. Maybe it's like S U, capital P O R T.
[1:13:18] Daniel Nolen: Absolutely, that is correct. That's a good, that's a good drag name for you, Suport.
[1:13:23] Ben Rimalower: I mean, she has the nerve in the middle of all this insane diction to cram in one really good acting beat on Very My Days.
[1:13:34] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:13:36] Ben Rimalower: Which is just cheeky of her.
[1:13:39] Daniel Nolen: Cheeky, totally. Because honestly, the level of belting she takes this to.
[1:13:45] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. And I hope, you know, I wish that you were saying this instead of me. Or frankly, I wish that, if not you, then I wish Steven Sondheim were saying this instead of me, because I really want it to be heard. But I believe in my soul that the level of belting Patty gives in this performance supersedes acting.
[1:14:05] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:14:06] Ben Rimalower: Like, you don't need to do any quote-unquote acting when you're belting this hard and this big because this belting is emotional. This belting is saying, no, no, no, no, no. I want you to make me feel being alive much more than Raul Esparza or Dean Jones or Bernadette Peters or Judy Kaye ever dreamed. Obviously, my desire for being alive is stronger than all theirs put together. Measure the decibels. Those came from my lungs. What in fact is the stuff of life, if not breath? The amount of breath that Patty, frankly, if you look at a human being like a plant, taking in one kind of air and putting out another kind of air, Patty makes us all feel being alive when she belts this song so big. So really, there's no need for any cumbersome acting beats.
And yet, she still finds a place to put in this weirdly subtle, very not belty, strange little, like very specific Donna Murphy-esque acting beat of Very My Days, where she almost, you know, she plays the opposites. She plays the Very My Days with a sense of humor with irony. It's so crazy that she shoehorns that in the middle of what is essentially just a race to the moon.
[1:15:42] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, absolutely. And speaking of breath, I mean, we have to mention the straight tone to vibrato on not a lot, you know, no breath, straight in to the final chorus. Um it's so um when she comes back in after that insane note. I mean, so the song starts, right? She's you know, somebody crowd me with love. She's just sort of trying on her diction. It's like watching somebody at a shoe store, you know.
[1:16:19] Daniel Nolen: Yeah. And you know, she's going through that, you know, and when she gets to um uh make me confused, Very My Days, she brings it back again with this crazy acting choice, but alone. She's starting to really belt it now, right?
[1:16:37] Ben Rimalower: And you hear it the way she is that a dip song, the way the way she does, is it a slide? What is it on the second loan?
[1:16:45] Daniel Nolen: But alone is alone.
[1:16:49] Ben Rimalower: That's a good thing. You know, I don't know what Sondheim complains about, but I surely have to believe he's not mad at that.
[1:16:58] Daniel Nolen: No, I live for that shit. Because in that moment, she goes from some time, sometime, sometime, sometime, sometime, sometime. She's like, Sondheim, sonho. And all of a sudden, we're in Carnegie Hall.
[1:17:15] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally. I mean, I think she does the beginning of the song with her eyes closed, but now her eyes are open, her mouth is open, her tits are open, her vagina's open. I feel like she might be spreading her fingers and toes. It's amazing she can hold the microphone. She must have Velcro in her hand, you know, because it opens up on that alone is alone, not alive, and the way her voice goes into that, it's not just a straight tone on that alive. It's, you know, people sometimes talk about shouting when they talk about belting, and they mean it maybe in a negative way because you think of a shout as being not necessarily flat, but flat of tone, not being rich, not being warm.
[1:18:02] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:18:03] Ben Rimalower: And this is not those things. This is so rich and so warm. And it almost makes you feel like all the other belting you've ever heard wasn't really belting.
[1:18:15] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:18:16] Ben Rimalower: You've never really heard belting until Patty gets to that word alive. And so then when it goes from that straight tone into that vibrato, which all by itself is just such an impressive feat, you know. And especially because you have Paul Gemigniani giving this thrilling orchestration behind her. So the passage of time is marked. So you feel very aware of the vocal pyrotechnics that she's delivering, you know?
[1:18:47] Daniel Nolen: Totally. So then to go from there and not breathe and then go into somebody crowd me with love, and it goes into a guttural place in her voice. It's another reason that all that breath and belting feels tantamount with acting. It feels like there's no reason to question the acting because her belting and her acting are one and the same. Because when she goes into that somebody, it makes you realize what a journey she's taking you on emotionally. From the beginning, when she was like, somebody hold me too close. In her weird little like mixy voice of her like weird little like Patty diction, where it was so tentative. This is like somebody crowd me. What's love?
[1:19:35] Ben Rimalower: And there's something, you know. Do you understand the word gushry?
[1:19:40] Daniel Nolen: No, but I think it's a Yiddish word or a German word, you know. But it's like, it's like you feel it's a little bit Ellen Burstyn in like the scary scenes in um uh Requiem for a Dream. It's a little bit Anne Margaret in Tommy. Have you ever seen that movie?
[1:19:57] Ben Rimalower: No.
[1:19:57] Daniel Nolen: Oh Daniel, you need to see the movie Tommy. Oh my god. Anne Margaret in that movie is like Patti LuPone singing Being Alive, slash Vivian Leigh in um Streetcar Named Desire.
[1:20:10] Ben Rimalower: Oh, yeah.
[1:20:11] Daniel Nolen: Like combined. She has this amazing sequence. Do you he uh should I smash the mirror? Basically, Alice Ripley is the epitome of gushry.
[1:20:21] Ben Rimalower: I love it. It's so funny you say Alice, because I was thinking about I want Alice to sing that um that Dorothy Loudon arrangement of the So Too Do I as well, and I feel like we can make that happen. As a matter of fact, it's really irresponsible for us to be even recording this podcast at all. For all we know, she's on Facebook Live doing it right now.
[1:20:39] Daniel Nolen: Totally.
[1:20:40] Ben Rimalower: Totally. But anyway, um, so uh I feel like when she goes into that moment without breath of somebody crowd me with love, we're now in a new normal. It's like it's like that feeling when you've like taken drugs and you're like, Am I feeling it? Are you guys feeling it? I don't know. Wait, touch your face. Okay, wait, like try this. Like, just drink some orange juice. Do you do you get any visuals, you know? And then all of a sudden you're like, oh no, the shit has hit me full tilt boogie. We are on the ride, my friends.
[1:21:10] Daniel Nolen: That's exactly what I'm saying. Patty comes in there, that is the feeling. You almost want her to like make crazy eyes or something to acknowledge the fact.
[1:21:19] Ben Rimalower: Right. Like I've seen her do that sometimes with crazy eyes in Neadalark and in As If We Never Said Goodbye. This moment is that minus the crazy eyes, but it's that level of just intense, like heightened intensity.
[1:21:34] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I mean, it feels like you're on a roller coaster, like you know, you're on Space Mountain and you're going up that first hill, and it's like chugga chugga, chugga chugga, chugga, chugga, and then that moment um into that big belt is like you're going down that first hill, and then the rest of the ride is just you're just carried on the momentum of that.
[1:21:52] Ben Rimalower: All thrills, totally so true. Like, after you've gone on that huge first drop, there might be other times you have to go up again so that you can drop again, but you're no longer in that like chugga chugga slowly building speed. You are now just going faster and faster and fucking faster.
[1:22:12] Daniel Nolen: Yes.
[1:22:12] Ben Rimalower: And um, somebody crowd me with love, somebody forced me to care, somebody make me come through. I'll always be there, as frightened as you. And it's funny about Patty too, because not everybody might agree with me that the belting and the acting are one and the same. Or indeed, as I've posited, that perhaps the belting is so deeply felt that it's even good enough as a substitute for acting at some points. But by this point in the song, you feel like Patty has her sea legs.
[1:22:58] Daniel Nolen: So it almost like it's like now that she's at the most full throttle parts, now she's almost also weirdly more in control than ever.
[1:23:09] Ben Rimalower: Yes.
[1:23:10] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally. It's yeah, yeah. You know, it's yeah. I'm trying to think of an analogy, but I may I don't make sense.
[1:23:16] Ben Rimalower: Uh make me come through, I'll always be there, as frightened as you to help us survive. You know, those lyrics are not big belty lyrics. I mean, she's just kind of spitting them out. It's kind of staccato, you know? But she is so singular of purpose, and every part of her acting and singing is working together so seamlessly here. You forget there was ever a person saying support, you know.
[1:23:43] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, absolutely.
[1:23:46] Ben Rimalower: You know, and make uh uh make uh make me aware, and then when she gets you the being alive, being alive, being alive, and we all know where this is going in terms of that E flat, you know. I'm sure somebody's gonna come for me again, you know. But maybe I believe it's an E flat. Maybe I'm wrong. But you know, we all know she's headed there. And if there's one thing that we have confidence in at this moment, it's that it's gonna be good.
[1:24:11] Daniel Nolen: And sure enough, it is. Patty has belted quite a number of E flats over the course of her career, and this one ranks among the best of them, right?
[1:24:22] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, absolutely. But what's so shocking, even though we've heard her do this already, is that when she did that crazy straight tone to vibrato on the but alone is alone, not alive. You don't think at that moment she's got another one of those. Honestly, and I'm such a greedy little pig bottom when it comes to Patty, you know. Even I am not like more, more. I'm just like, oh yeah, daddy, keep doing what you're doing. You know, in it. I was never like, I hope that happens again. I just I was in the moment. I experienced the blessing on its own terms.
[1:25:03] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, you're just grateful.
[1:25:05] Ben Rimalower: And yet, when Patty gives you that belted E flat, bing, she now goes into a straight tone to vibrato on that last alive that makes you forget the first one ever happened. Mmm, yeah. It's even bigger, yeah, yeah.
[1:25:25] Daniel Nolen: And she does that live. Which is which is the next touch. She and Paul Gemigniani are so perfectly in sync because the orchestra swells and it does not crash until the vibrato.
[1:25:43] Ben Rimalower: That yeah, that's a good point.
[1:25:44] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:25:45] Ben Rimalower: You know, it's what every girl that has ever sung "Don't Rain on My Parade" wishes for at the end of that song. You know, you want to feel like your lungs can outlast the orchestra.
[1:25:58] Daniel Nolen: Uh-huh.
[1:25:59] Ben Rimalower: And it's so rare that that happens perfectly, you know. And part of the problem with Barbara is that it's always perfect, and you get the sense that it's so controlled and planned. It doesn't quite have that reckless abandon, that thrill.
[1:26:16] Daniel Nolen: Thrill.
[1:26:17] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. But Patty's brand is reckless abandon and thrill.
[1:26:21] Daniel Nolen: Is it ever, yes.
[1:26:23] Ben Rimalower: And she just never more than in this moment. She just jizzes all over the thousands of people in that audience and the millions of people watching at home.
[1:26:35] Daniel Nolen: And as Patty's cum just sprays all over your face, you just feel not the Holocaust, but another moment in my people's history when the Hebrews were starving in the desert, and the Lord Jehovah sent them manna from heaven.
[1:26:55] Ben Rimalower: Yes.
[1:26:56] Daniel Nolen: And we don't know what manna was. Was it some kind of a bird? Was it some kind of a carbohydrate? Was it we don't know? Nobody knows. It's a Bible story. It may not be real. Maybe it's just um what's the word? You know, uh a fable. But whatever Patty sprays on us, we throw our heads back in gratitude so that we may be nourished and fed and more than satisfied.
[1:27:27] Ben Rimalower: With this mana from heaven.
[1:27:30] Daniel Nolen: Yes.
[1:27:31] Ben Rimalower: Um.
[1:27:33] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:27:33] Ben Rimalower: And by the way, her face. After her face recovers from all the workout things that it had to do to produce those notes, the expression on her face when she gets that ovation is so adorable. She's so clearly like, I did good.
[1:27:54] Daniel Nolen: Yes, yeah.
[1:27:58] Ben Rimalower: Absolutely. God, I love it. It's I mean, I'm assuming many people, most people who are listening to this have seen it, but if not, like, even if you're not gonna watch the whole thing, that is like the bit to watch. And and I still listen to it, you know. Like on my playlist, I have Patty being alive. That's the version of being alive that I go to.
[1:28:16] Daniel Nolen: Um I think my um uh I'll be patty for Thursday just became clear to me.
[1:28:24] Ben Rimalower: Oh, wonderful, wonderful.
[1:28:26] Daniel Nolen: I I should I should I say it?
[1:28:28] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[1:28:29] Daniel Nolen: A little teaser.
[1:28:31] Ben Rimalower: It's all Patty's other versions of being alive.
[1:28:36] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, because don't think don't think we're just giving you know uh bowing down to Patty just freely and without thought, because there are many other versions that aren't up to this uh standard.
[1:28:50] Ben Rimalower: Yes, and there's nothing there's nothing I love to do uh along with complimenting someone as insulting them.
[1:28:59] Daniel Nolen: Right, right. Which is why we have the new I'll be patty segment, which allows this in a in a uh controlled and constructive environment where Daniel really helps me work through some of my issues, like Judy K.
[1:29:13] Daniel Nolen: Judy K and Emma Thompson as Mrs. Lovett.
[1:29:15] Ben Rimalower: Yes.
[1:29:17] Daniel Nolen: Um, so we have I just realized it's uh we have to move this along because I have something else at six.
[1:29:23] Ben Rimalower: Um oh, it's getting late.
[1:29:25] Daniel Nolen: So I thought that was a joke, but it's actually so late that that's yeah.
[1:29:30] Ben Rimalower: I mean, time flies when you're you know talking about Patty's belt notes.
[1:29:34] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:29:35] Ben Rimalower: Uh sooner or later from Dick Tracy is next, uh Bill Irwin, which I found it very funny, his little baton tapping bit when he just taps it all over the the little uh conductor's block or whatever you call that. Because I remember as a kid, like that was something like in those old Looney Tunes cartoons, like Bugs Bunny would get up to conduct and he would like tap his baton, and I always thought that was so funny.
[1:29:58] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:29:58] Ben Rimalower: Um we have Karen Ziemba uh in a red dress, so obviously the black and white motif that I was sensing is not a thing. Um doing a very seductive, very tightly, tightly choreographed number. And you're which I didn't even write down what number it is, but sooner or later. Um it's the bit with uh Bill Irwin. It's just a beautiful moment of Karen Ziemba and um Susan Strowman choreography, and it's so it's just beautifully done. She's so charming.
[1:30:30] Daniel Nolen: I wrote down is she the Meg Ryan of musical theater.
[1:30:34] Ben Rimalower: Oh, that's really that's really good.
[1:30:36] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, that's that scans to me because she has that like girl next door, like uh bubbly quality to her for sure.
[1:30:45] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[1:30:46] Daniel Nolen: Um yeah, I mean I love this. It was like I said, very tightly choreographed, but like in a uh I don't I don't know how to not like a it wasn't like a dance dance, but just like them rolling around on the piano bench and like it was just very well uh constructed and and tight and rehearsed.
[1:31:09] Ben Rimalower: Um then we have Victor Garber and Patrick Cassidy singing the ballad of Booth. This is restaurant quality, original cast members still at their peak, giving you everything you could dream of from this song. And they're you know, it's the final word on it. I mean, there have been great performances of it in other productions, but nothing will ever be better than these two doing it so wonderfully.
[1:31:32] Daniel Nolen: Totally.
[1:31:32] Ben Rimalower: And you really it really sh reminds you how much of a star Victor Garber is, you know, for all of his uh kind of character-y movie roles he has now, like he was such a um a force on the Broadway.
[1:31:47] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:31:49] Ben Rimalower: Um then uh Daisy Eagan singing Broadway Baby, which I love adorable. I mean yeah, so good. And those red tights, it is so 90s. I think my sister, I just have I can picture all these family photographs of my sister wearing those same red tights um as a kid.
[1:32:12] Daniel Nolen: The thing that was so genius about Daisy in this and in the secret garden, and it's why she won the Tony, is that she was so um she could get the jokes and she could sing the notes and she could deliver the show business of it all.
[1:32:28] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, but there was something so real about her, you know, she can really act and it, you know, it was so rare as a kid actor that she was just so real and relatable and brought so much humanity to these performances, you know.
[1:32:46] Daniel Nolen: Totally, totally. Yes, humanity.
[1:32:48] Ben Rimalower: Um so that was that's thrilling. And then I'm assuming, I don't know, like if this was if there was originally a song um between this that they cut out, but Daisy gets huge applause, and then that applause just rolls right on over into Bernadette. Speaking of singing the notes, that's why I'm wondering like if there was another song between this, because none of this is the real order. Cause I did notice I was like, it was like so um alarming because all of a sudden Bernadette was just kind of like in the middle of the stage, and I was like, oh my god, it's so burned that to just like materialize without you know knowing it.
[1:33:28] Daniel Nolen: But well, that's what's sort of magical and beautiful about it, isn't it?
[1:33:31] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally.
[1:33:33] Daniel Nolen: Um so this so Bernadette sings her one of her signature songs, which I think is my number one favorite Sondheim song, Not a Day Goes By.
[1:33:43] Ben Rimalower: I I I could get behind that argument, and and this is you know, this is the moment it became her signature song.
[1:33:52] Daniel Nolen: Really, I love that. I mean, yeah, I mean unlike Patty, who has sung Being Alive a zillion times since then, and very rarely gotten that same magic.
[1:34:07] Ben Rimalower: Uh Bernadette has sung Not a Day Goes By a million times Since then, and always been pretty much exactly the same.
[1:34:15] Daniel Nolen: But yeah, yeah, totally but but never never more beautiful, and maybe it's because she's not wearing a Bob Mackey dress. It just feels so it's just and she's just so young and voluptuous. I mean, her hair is kind of like it's her signature hair, but it does not have any of her signature like styling. It almost just kind of seems like it's just it's just there. And like it's very, I mean, it's like it seems like her hair has been like, you know, it's been scaled up even more because it's there's so much of it, and it's like the most uh wild.
[1:34:56] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, and it's very like the Cola Scola Bernadette wig.
[1:35:02] Daniel Nolen: Yes, it's like truly wild. And just and that dress that she's just sort of spilling out of, but it's just a plain black silk dress. There's almost nothing to it. There's not a lot of like jewelry, she doesn't seem to be wearing a lot of makeup. You just feel like she's like this like beautiful girl, you know. I mean, this woman. She's this gorgeous woman.
[1:35:20] Ben Rimalower: And and that comes in the song, and it's just it's so exquisite. I mean, the way that she floats in and out of her upper register, um, and then into those just big thunderous belt notes.
[1:35:36] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:35:37] Ben Rimalower: I mean, it's yeah, it she takes you on that journey, and the nuance of it, it's like it's like watching a film, you know. It's like it's like um all the small choices she makes are just like I'm tuned into everything.
[1:35:51] Daniel Nolen: Totally.
[1:35:52] Ben Rimalower: Um, so this is a highlight for me as well. And um, yeah, I just wrote down. As much as she was the star of Sunday in the Park and Into the Woods, and she'd been singing Broadway Baby since the 70s. I mean, I think in a way, this is really when people were sort of like, oh, what we need is Bernadette singing all the Sondheim catalog all the time.
[1:36:16] Daniel Nolen: Yes, yes. The Sondheim uh interpreter.
[1:36:20] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[1:36:22] Daniel Nolen: Um.
[1:36:23] Ben Rimalower: Okay, so next up is another one you don't hear that often: Green Finch and Lynet Bird by Harolyn Blackwell.
[1:36:30] Daniel Nolen: That's right.
[1:36:32] Ben Rimalower: And again, it was just so wonderful hearing this song because it's it's so rare. Uh hearing it out of the context of the show. That I all I wrote was that final note, just she flew up.
[1:36:45] Daniel Nolen: Oh my god, the whistle tone.
[1:36:47] Ben Rimalower: It's gorgeous. I mean, she's so impressive. Like, I was thinking about her, like, because she started off in Broadway. Like, she was um, what's her name? Rosalia in the Debbie Allen West Side story in 1980.
[1:37:03] Daniel Nolen: Okay.
[1:37:03] Ben Rimalower: And she was also Kunaganda in Hal Prince's Broadway revival of Candeed in um 2000 or 2003 or whatever that was. Um, or was it the 90s? Whatever. The you know, his not his revival from the 70s, but his his later Broadway revival of it. Um, but she also is a big opera star. I think sh I believe she famously some of the Met broadcasts when Kathleen Battle would have problems, either what I don't even know, the opera gossip, but whatever went wrong where Kathleen Battle would not be in a Met broadcast at the last minute. Um Harilyn Blackwell was who would do it.
[1:37:48] Daniel Nolen: Um, and I was just watching this performance thinking she can really act. I mean, she's good. She's she's she you know, she's not an opera singer slumming in musicals, she's really a versatile performer.
[1:38:01] Ben Rimalower: I I haven't seen her do anything in a long time, and I really want to.
[1:38:05] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, me too. I mean, I I love this this performance so much.
[1:38:09] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[1:38:09] Daniel Nolen: Um, and then after that is our is this our first song from Night Music of the Night?
[1:38:14] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[1:38:15] Daniel Nolen: Um, Weekend in the Country with a lot of people, a lot of 90s hair, a lot of props.
[1:38:20] Ben Rimalower: Well, this is the cast of Scott Ellis' uh Scott Ellis and Susan Strowman's New York City opera revival that had just played the two seasons prior to that. Um the only ones missing are um Sally Ann House as Desiree, Regina Resnick as um Madame Armfeld, and speaking of Into the Woods and Sun in the Park with George, Danielle Ferland as Frederica.
[1:38:45] Daniel Nolen: Oh that production is on uh video uh for the world to see. It's very good.
[1:38:51] Ben Rimalower: And well, I don't know if he did it, and there were just a few different times it came up in the repertoire, repertoire, repertory. But um, in the video of that production, Michael McGuire, who won the Tony for playing Andre Ross that was in that stars in the house thing.
[1:39:08] Daniel Nolen: Yes.
[1:39:09] Ben Rimalower: He was Carl Magnus. But in this number, at least, it's Mark Jacoby, who I love, obviously also.
[1:39:16] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, and I have Go ahead.
[1:39:19] Ben Rimalower: I will have to say, this song, I I've never loved it. And I've really been trying to investigate why, and I I can't really put my finger on it, but I just never really love this song. And I don't know if it's because it just seems like so uber clever, like it's just so clever, it's almost exhausting, or because it's like it never quite I never quite get the release I need from it, or like all the It's so epic at the end. Like I said, the ep at the end it is, but it's it I just spends so much time just like building a building and just like the same like you know clever little witticisms, but then like the stake maybe what you what you said earlier I think resonated because you said the stakes aren't that high.
[1:40:09] Ben Rimalower: I'm like, yeah, why are we getting like this act one finale about like a weekend vacation? Like it just doesn't seem that big to me, like it's not that important, and then that spends this whole time building this song and all these people talking about it from all these different points of view, and I'm like, I don't know. I just I can appreciate it, you know, intellectually, and obviously it's like such you know, such a wonderfully written song, but it just has never hit me right. You know, it's just never really set warmly in my little soul.
[1:40:43] Ben Rimalower: Um guys, can you hear me? Um we're gonna figure this out, okay? Like we're gonna take a journey. I haven't I we're gonna cook something up, but we're gonna take Daniel, we're gonna hold his hand, and we're gonna take him deep into a little night music because I believe that the Didi that I know this is his show. Well, but I and I really haven't gotten into it, Daniel, and we're gonna get him there. I mean, like, I listened to Now Later Soon is like the perfect length for a shower song. So like I listen to Now Later Soon all the time in the shower. I listened to The Miller's Sun all the time. Um Have you seen in the Clowns?
[1:41:24] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I went to well, I've seen like regional productions of it, and I remember they did it at NYU when I was there. Um, but I went to the archives and I watched the Bernadette Elaine Stritch.
[1:41:36] Ben Rimalower: Oh, that was no good.
[1:41:37] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, well, I mean, I s I mean, even the um, and I listened to the um recording all the time, but it's just um I think this city opera video might win you over. First of all, you have this guy, Kevin Anderson, as Henrik, not to be confused with um the Kevin Anderson, the movie actor who also starred opposite Patty and Sunset Boulevard. This Kevin Anderson is an operatic tenor and is so hot.
[1:42:05] Ben Rimalower: And when you have this like beautiful twink that you can like fall for, it will help you, I think, as a way in.
[1:42:12] Daniel Nolen: A gateway, yeah.
[1:42:13] Ben Rimalower: Um, and what and you I think will share my obsession with the two female leads who are not seen here, which is movie stars, chitty chitty bang bang star, Sally Ann House as Desert. And um, the fact that you have a reference point for that already, I think will serve it. And then Regina Resnick, who I know that people that saw Hermione Gingold in the original consider Regina Resnick to be like weak sauce.
[1:42:42] Daniel Nolen: But she's like if Laney Kazan had a love child with an elephant.
[1:42:52] Ben Rimalower: And that and that half Laney, half elephant went to British finishing school. I mean, I am so in. Like, honestly, like no drag queen could approach what I mean, it it's a Peaches Christ performance that Regina Resnick gives, and I'm sure that you will share my enthusiasm for it. And finally, best of all, the great star of musical theater of the last 50 years who is undersung and there's not enough of anywhere, Maureen Moore as Countess Charlotte.
[1:43:30] Daniel Nolen: She is like a mixture of Madeline Kahn and Bernadette Peters.
[1:43:34] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I mean, you're saying all the right words to get me in. I believe, and it might not fly with her weird 90s hairstyle in this strange 90s dress out of context here. But when you see her in a proper Countess Charlotte hat saying lemonade, it would choke me. And singing everyday little death. I mean, she I just want to give one shout out to a choice she makes in this performance here, where there the lyric is um uh a weekend in the country. Uh uh she where the lyric A Weekend in the Country, Peace and Quiet, and her lyric is How I Wish We'd Been Asked.
[1:44:15] Daniel Nolen: She puts a 90s spin on it and goes, How I wish we'd been asked.
[1:44:22] Ben Rimalower: It's like sarcastic. It's so great. Anyway, we're we're not done with Little Night Music. We're gonna take Daniel there.
[1:44:28] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[1:44:29] Ben Rimalower: We'll have a follow-up. Speaking of a little night music.
[1:44:32] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, we really we have five minutes.
[1:44:34] Ben Rimalower: Um speaking of Little Night Music, uh, Glenn Close, but no cigars, sending Send In the Clowns, which is a good song for her, don't you think?
[1:44:45] Daniel Nolen: Uh, vocally, yes.
[1:44:47] Ben Rimalower: Yes. Give me your thoughts, because I think it's fine. You know, this is um I I like her singing this song. I think it's a good choice for her.
[1:44:54] Daniel Nolen: Me too.
[1:44:56] Ben Rimalower: Um, it's not one I watch over and over again. It's not like I'm, you know, one of my like big concert highlights, but it's it doesn't suck.
[1:45:06] Daniel Nolen: Well, I for years I thought it was a great performance because uh I like that, unlike Patty and Bernadette and Donna, you know, Glenn gives you, you know.
[1:45:22] Ben Rimalower: Mm-hmm.
[1:45:24] Daniel Nolen: Um, and I thought obviously she's doing a great job.
[1:45:24] Ben Rimalower: Obviously, she's doing a great job acting it, you know.
[1:45:31] Daniel Nolen: But watching Judy Denchovich.
[1:45:36] Ben Rimalower: And frankly, Donna Murphy.
[1:45:38] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:45:39] Ben Rimalower: Glenn doesn't act it as well as they do. Glenn seems like she learned it that day.
[1:45:43] Daniel Nolen: That's what it seems like to me.
[1:45:45] Ben Rimalower: It seems a little too like on the nose.
[1:45:47] Daniel Nolen: Um yeah, it doesn't have the nuance and the texture of Judy Dench or once again, Donna Murphy, you know.
[1:45:55] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, or Elaine Stritch in that Carlisle recording.
[1:45:57] Daniel Nolen: Sure.
[1:45:57] Ben Rimalower: Well, you know, but I mean Elaine is like Elaine, you know. I mean, like, even though we're only hearing it. But um also, uh, one that I just want to point our our uh viewers or listeners to is there's a video of Diane Carroll singing it.
[1:46:13] Daniel Nolen: Oh, love her.
[1:46:15] Ben Rimalower: It's really glorious.
[1:46:17] Daniel Nolen: I think you see that.
[1:46:18] Ben Rimalower: I'm in a real Diane Carol play.
[1:46:19] Daniel Nolen: It's well acted.
[1:46:20] Ben Rimalower: It's certainly like as well acted as Glenn.
[1:46:24] Daniel Nolen: Um but it's but it but it's gorgeous.
[1:46:29] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I need to I need to hear that. Um, and then finally, um coming on for the finale, Liza May singing old friends, and then uh my favorite moment of the last century is whenever she says, ladies and gentlemen, Steven Shondheim.
[1:46:51] Daniel Nolen: 100%.
[1:46:53] Ben Rimalower: I do want to just give a shout out to Liza because I really appreciate that starting in like 1982, like Merrily was like barely like a the corpse wasn't even cold yet of merrily we roll along flopping on Broadway.
[1:47:09] Daniel Nolen: Uh-huh.
[1:47:10] Ben Rimalower: Liza has been singing old friends in her shows.
[1:47:13] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:47:13] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[1:47:14] Daniel Nolen: It's not a hit show.
[1:47:15] Ben Rimalower: It's not a hit song.
[1:47:17] Daniel Nolen: But Liza has always that has been her Suntime song.
[1:47:21] Ben Rimalower: I don't know.
[1:47:22] Daniel Nolen: And she does great with it.
[1:47:23] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, that's a good point. That is her Suntime song. I actually wish she did the whole thing here instead of just this weird little short intro.
[1:47:30] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:47:31] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[1:47:32] Daniel Nolen: And, you know, if anybody had any doubt who Sondheim loves best, who gets to come out and go, uh Hirmony.
[1:47:47] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally.
[1:47:48] Daniel Nolen: I totally clocked that as well. I was like, all right, we see who the fave is, the teacher's pet.
[1:47:54] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[1:47:56] Daniel Nolen: Um.
[1:47:58] Ben Rimalower: Also, as our friend Sean pointed out when I used the word ostensibly in a group email, I did learn the word ostensibly, hearing Sondheim use it here. When he says his thank you and he comes to the stage and he says, This evening is ostensibly about my work. But what it's really about is a building that's a temple to art and artists, talking about Carnegie Hall.
[1:48:24] Daniel Nolen: And I want to know, what the fuck is he talking about? Why is it about the building?
[1:48:32] Ben Rimalower: Um, well, I think he's I thought I took it as like this about people coming together and having a shared experience, like a religious experience, like we're in church.
[1:48:41] Daniel Nolen: You know, it's about us coming out of the channel.
[1:48:42] Ben Rimalower: But like, wouldn't that be true of every performance anywhere ever?
[1:48:48] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I guess so.
[1:48:49] Ben Rimalower: I mean why is that particular to this particular evening?
[1:48:53] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I guess that's interesting. I mean, it wasn't like like Carnegie Hall is about to go out of business and they did this. What was this like a benefit for the Carnegie Hall something something fund or something?
[1:49:05] Ben Rimalower: Oh yeah, and that's what it sounds like. We have to ask Scott Ellis, because otherwise I'm like, what are you talking about, Sondheim?
[1:49:11] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I mean, yeah.
[1:49:14] Ben Rimalower: Also, a little random, but I was like, um, I mean, he's very spectrum-y here, if that's uh appropriate to say.
[1:49:22] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:49:22] Ben Rimalower: He's definitely giving you Sondheim at his most Asperger's esque, like with his weird, like squinting one eye, like while he's like in a tuxedo, like surrounded by like Bernadette Peters, Liza Minnelli, and the American Theater Orchestra, and he's like still just seems like a weird kid, like at an ADD medication session.
[1:49:42] Daniel Nolen: But I also found him kind of hot.
[1:49:47] Ben Rimalower: Um, I did notice, yeah, he looks very healthy and like um uh vibration. Is that the word? Like full of life, you know.
[1:49:56] Daniel Nolen: I mean, oh sure.
[1:49:58] Ben Rimalower: Well, he's pretty young.
[1:49:59] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:49:59] Ben Rimalower: Well, now he's like he's like he's so old now, but he's like barely 60 here.
[1:50:06] Daniel Nolen: Um, yeah, but he looks so much younger now that we've seen him as 90, you know.
[1:50:10] Ben Rimalower: True that.
[1:50:11] Daniel Nolen: Um, well, isn't that what um uh what's her name? Uh uh the brilliant uh writer who wrote all those movies and she died too young and we love her so much.
[1:50:22] Ben Rimalower: Oh my god, Nora.
[1:50:24] Daniel Nolen: Yes.
[1:50:24] Ben Rimalower: Isn't that what Nora Ephron said? Like uh when you see a picture of yourself two years from now, or was it 20 years from now, you're gonna wish you looked the way you look now, so be grateful.
[1:50:37] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah, totally.
[1:50:39] Ben Rimalower: Also, I'm pretty sure Bernadette's dress for the finale is off the rack.
[1:50:45] Daniel Nolen: Oh, really?
[1:50:45] Ben Rimalower: I didn't even notice.
[1:50:46] Daniel Nolen: And you I don't know, it's just the 90s.
[1:50:48] Ben Rimalower: Who can say?
[1:50:46] Daniel Nolen: The 90s, who can say?
[1:50:50] Ben Rimalower: I mean, everything, I mean, Liza's belt looks like it was purchased at like Claire's in the mall.
[1:50:55] Daniel Nolen: Totally.
[1:50:56] Ben Rimalower: And in case anybody thought that Patty really made her dress out of her Norma Desmond costume, when she wears the exact same thing in black for the finale. She proves that when Patty LaFone gets something wrong, she gets it wrong twice.
[1:51:24] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I remember you saying that, and I was my eyes were peeled the whole time, and I was like, am I just not recognizing her? Like, what's happening?
[1:51:31] Ben Rimalower: But I don't know why or how I got that idea, but it is not correct.
[1:51:36] Daniel Nolen: Um, well, I have to run, but this is I'm just gonna stay here and talk about a little night music with the listeners.
[1:51:44] Ben Rimalower: Um, cool.
[1:51:45] Daniel Nolen: Talk shit.
[1:51:46] Ben Rimalower: So, guys, please tune in next week when we will be covering um K Mr. Producer, fabulous, fabulous television variety concert, salute to Cameron McIntosh, featuring Judy Dench and Bernadette Peters, and Julia McKenzie and Ruthie Henschel and Leia Salonga and Ellen Green and everybody else in the world.
[1:52:09] Daniel Nolen: And we're gonna be covering it with our very special guest, the executive producer of many of those great Cameron McIntosh musicals, including Lame Azarab and Miss Saigon, Richard J. Alexander.
[1:52:20] Ben Rimalower: Yes, the uh the Diva Whisperer himself.
[1:52:25] Daniel Nolen: Yes.
[1:52:26] Ben Rimalower: Daniel will just have to try not to make the entire interview about Barbara Streisand because Richard directs her concerts too.
[1:52:33] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, and I, yeah.
[1:52:35] Ben Rimalower: I mean, we'll have to have a special, like Bottomer segment.
[1:52:39] Daniel Nolen: We have another episode about Barbara for sure.
[1:52:41] Ben Rimalower: Right, right.
[1:52:41] Daniel Nolen: Because I definitely have like my little list.
[1:52:41] Ben Rimalower: Anyway.
[1:52:41] Daniel Nolen: My little list.
[1:52:46] Ben Rimalower: Well, we love you guys. Thanks for listening. Hope you're staying safe and sane.
[1:52:51] Daniel Nolen: And to our.
[1:52:54] Ben Rimalower: Yes, this is this is like therapy for us as well.
[1:52:57] Daniel Nolen: So make sure you tune in to Tuesdays or Thursday, April, August, on Broadway World's Facebook page and the Broadway Podcast Network's YouTube channel every Tuesday and Thursday at 10 30 a.m.
[1:53:10] Ben Rimalower: Uh and available, you know, on the internet thereafter.
[1:53:15] Daniel Nolen: So all right, darling.
[1:53:17] Ben Rimalower: Love you, and uh I'll chat with you then.
[1:53:20] Daniel Nolen: Bye.
[1:53:22] Ben Rimalower: Bye.
[1:53:25] Ben Rimalower: Thanks for listening to Ben Remelauer's Broken Records on Broadway World.
[1:53:29] Daniel Nolen: For more episodes, visit Broadway World, iTunes, Stitcher, or wherever podcasts do be.
[1:53:35] Ben Rimalower: And be sure to check out our new twice weekly live stream video chat, Tuesday, Thursday, April, August.
[1:53:42] Daniel Nolen: Available on the Broadway World Facebook page and the Broadway Podcast Network YouTube channel Tuesdays and Thursdays at 10 30 a.m.
[1:53:49] Ben Rimalower: This episode was edited by me, Daniel Nolen. Thanks to Emmy Winning composer and lyricist Lance Horn for the Broken Records theme song.
[1:53:56] Daniel Nolen: Follow us both, Ben Remelauer and Daniel Nolen on all y'all's socials. That's Ben Remelauer, B-E-N-R-I-M, A-L-O-W-E-R.
[1:54:06] Ben Rimalower: And that's Nolan with an E, not Nolan with an A.
[1:54:08] Daniel Nolen: Because Nolan with an A is an A.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
