On this week’s 100th and final regular episode of the series, Jamie and Rob cap off their season-long theme of “our favorite things” by recounting and celebrating some of the great performances by great performers that they’ve been fortunate enough to see over a lifetime of theatergoing... Read More
From the show: The Fabulous Invalid
Guests
Featured Shows
About
On this week’s 100th and final regular episode of the series, Jamie and Rob cap off their season-long theme of “our favorite things” by recounting and celebrating some of the great performances by great performers that they’ve been fortunate enough to see over a lifetime of theatergoing. Joining them in sharing their personal remembrances for this special milestone episode is a roster of former guests including Joel Grey, Donna Murphy, Betty Buckley, and more! Tune in for one final episode as live theatre begins again in New York and we celebrate theatre itself: the fabulous invalid.
This week’s music: “Dream Ballet”, from “Oklahoma! 2019 Broadway Cast Recording”, “Today”, and “Writing A Gospel Play”, from “A Strange Loop”. “Star and Slave”, from “Here Lies Love: Original Cast Recording”, “Audition”, from “42nd Street: 2001 Broadway Cast". “Too Much Exposition”, and “I See A River”, both from “Urinetown”, “Back to Before”, from “Ragtime, Original Broadway Cast”, “Party, Party”, from “Dreamgirls: In Concert”, “I Do Miracles”, from “Kiss of the Spiderwoman 1994 Cast Recording,”. “Parade In Town”, from “Anyone Can Whistle”, “Rose’s Turn”, from “Betty Buckley An Evening At Carnegie Hall”, “Rose’s Turn” from “Gypsy, 2008 Broadway Cast Recording”, “Betrayed”, from “The Producers”, “Together”, from “Gypsy, Broadway Cast Recording" (Tyne Daly), “Lot’s Wife” from “Caroline or Change”, “Hard to Say Goodbye”, from “Dreamgirls Original Cast Recording”.
Find us on Twitter & Instagram: @fabulousinvalid
Facebook: www.facebook.com/fabulousinvalid
Rob’s reviews: www.stageleft.nyc
Email us at: office@fabulousinvalid.com
Jamie DuMont
Twitter: @jamiedumont
Instagram: @troutinnyc
Rob Russo
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jamie DuMont: All right.
[0:01] Rob Russo: We are.
[0:02] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, I'm recording.
[0:03] Rob Russo: We're recording.
[0:03] Jamie DuMont: Wow.
[0:04] Rob Russo: Last recording.
[0:05] Jamie DuMont: It's the last recording.
[0:07] Rob Russo: It's the last recording.
[0:10] Jamie DuMont: I like it when you sing.
[0:11] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[0:12] Jamie DuMont: Thank you.
[0:12] Rob Russo: Okay.
[0:13] Jamie DuMont: Don't make me sing.
[0:14] Rob Russo: We're gonna do this, huh?
[0:15] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[0:16] Rob Russo: I'm a little nervous.
[0:17] Jamie DuMont: Nothing to it but to do it.
[0:38] Jamie DuMont: Welcome to the Fabulous Invalid, Broadway's podcast where we present essential conversations with a curated roster of the best, most important, and innovative theater makers working today.
[0:47] Rob Russo: From actors to writers, directors, designers, and everyone in between.
[0:51] Jamie DuMont: We took our name from the title of a 1938 play by Kaufman and Hart that has since become a loving nickname for Broadway itself.
[0:57] Rob Russo: Always deemed on the verge of decline, yet always bouncing back, The Fabulous Invalid.
[1:01] Jamie DuMont: I'm Theater Savant, Jamie DuMont.
[1:04] Rob Russo: And I'm Rob Russo, writer and theater critic with Staged Left.nyc and Stage Left the Podcast.
[1:09] Jamie DuMont: Rob Russo.
[1:10] Rob Russo: Jamie DuMont.
[1:13] Jamie DuMont: I'm almost speechless, but I'm not speechless because I clearly have words. But um I can't believe it. This is our 100th episode.
[1:22] Rob Russo: Yes. After three years, a hundred episodes, and a hundred and twenty-eight guests, we're going out with a bang today.
[1:28] Jamie DuMont: As we mentioned a couple weeks back.
[1:31] Rob Russo: Well, this is our last episode. We're not going away entirely, don't worry. Uh Jamie and I are pivoting to producing theater through our production company, also named the Fabulous Invalid.
[1:39] Jamie DuMont: So while we won't be doing weekly episodes of this podcast anymore, we will be back with some deep dives and exclusive interviews related to our future projects.
[1:48] Rob Russo: Yes, and I'm so excited about all of the projects that we have, and we have a few in the hopper, um, which you'll hear about as um as when the time is right. But I'm very excited about our first project as theater producers.
[2:01] Jamie DuMont: It's a solo piece written and performed by Mimi Quillen, a former guest of the show.
[2:06] Rob Russo: We love Mimi.
[2:07] Jamie DuMont: We love Mimi.
[2:08] Rob Russo: You may hear her voice a little bit later.
[2:10] Jamie DuMont: Yes. The play is called Fosse at the Min Scuff, and it's an incredible story of how Mimi was handpicked by Gwen Verdon and Bob Fosse.
[2:18] Rob Russo: I mean, just right there. Right? You have me. I'm hooked.
[2:21] Jamie DuMont: These two fellas, Jamie and Rob, were hooked immediately.
[2:28] Rob Russo: But she was handpicked by Bob and Gwen to reconstruct Fosse's choreography for the 1986 revival of Sweet Charity.
[2:35] Jamie DuMont: But of course, you know, the play is also like so much more than that, right? It's about her time doing that. But, you know, our director, Michael Berez, another past guest of the show, calls it a middle-aged coming of age story, which yeah, like sums up so much about what makes this play special, because here you have Mimi looking back on her life and her work, um, you know, from the vantage point of her current age.
[2:54] Rob Russo: And you know, it's a great backstage story, but it's also just a great story for anybody who loves theater or has ever, you know, dared to do something on the high wire of their profession, whether it's, you know, any industry, um, ours just happens to be the theater.
[3:07] Jamie DuMont: And it also gives you a really unique look into how Bob and Gwen worked together as artists.
[3:17] Rob Russo: Right. Which I think, you know, there's so much is made of their marriage and their this and they're that, but like this is you're literally in the room with them while it's happening.
[3:28] Jamie DuMont: And it's later in their careers. So they're, you know, they're different people too.
[3:33] Rob Russo: I think you'll all really like it. It captures a real moment in time and a real piece of theater history, which, after all, if you've picked up anything from the first hundred episodes of this series, that's what we're all about here, right? It's the fabulous invalid celebrating the vicissitudes of the theater, the good, the bad, the challenges, the triumphs, um, and the history of it all, which we've aimed to capture a little bit in this show.
[3:54] Jamie DuMont: And I think we've done a pretty good job. Um so stay tuned for more information uh on Call Fosse at the Mince Golf.
[4:01] Rob Russo: For now, you can follow the show on Twitter. Uh the handle is at Call Fosse or online at uh callfossi at the Mince Golf.com.
[4:09] Jamie DuMont: And if you happen to be in the area, we're actually going to be doing two uh performances this fall at the Mahewee Performing Arts Center in Great Barrington, Massachusetts, October 15th and 16th.
[4:19] Rob Russo: You can find out more information online, um, including how to buy tickets at the show's website or at uh mahewee.org. That's M-A-H-A-I-W-E.org.
[4:29] Jamie DuMont: It's all real.
[4:31] Rob Russo: Yeah, it's happening.
[4:32] Jamie DuMont: It's happening.
[4:33] Rob Russo: Well, the other thing that's happening is uh our 100th episode.
[4:38] Jamie DuMont: We're doing it.
[4:39] Rob Russo: Um Wow, you know, since uh Broadway and live performances across New York and the country really are ramping up. We thought we'd mark the special milestone episode by capping off our season-long theme of our favorite things and recording some of our personal favorite performances we've seen over the last, well, our whole lives.
[4:59] Jamie DuMont: Yes, our lifetime of theater going. Um as we get ready to go back uh into the audience, uh, which I cannot wait to do. I've done it a couple times uh before this date, but we're really gonna get into the swing pretty soon.
[5:10] Rob Russo: Um on this episode, we'll each share personal lists that we've compiled of 15 great performances by 15 great performers uh that we've loved seeing and that have stayed with us over the years.
[5:20] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[5:22] Rob Russo: I think everybody now knows I love a list. I love a list show.
[5:22] Jamie DuMont: I love a list show.
[5:26] Rob Russo: I now I will say that a thing I don't like is comparing, you know, pick your pick your favorite when it's binary, when it's this or that.
[5:38] Jamie DuMont: One's gotta go.
[5:39] Rob Russo: That's what I hate.
[5:39] Jamie DuMont: The one's gotta go.
[5:41] Rob Russo: You know, five kids.
[5:43] Jamie DuMont: Why? Why can't we have all of the things?
[5:46] Rob Russo: Which is what we're well, and I guess we've narrowed the we've narrowed these down to 15. But you know, otherwise we I mean, we could do this for the next 16 hours.
[5:56] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, this is what theater people do. We sit around and we talk about performances that we loved, right? Did you see this show? Did you see that show? Did you see this person in that show?
[6:03] Rob Russo: Right. I mean, it feels like the perfect way to cap off this incredible series and this incredible podcast experience that we've had by doing just that, right?
[6:11] Jamie DuMont: And some folks might be wondering, why 15? To which I say, why not 15? You know?
[6:15] Rob Russo: Well, I mean, uh I think if you've listened to one of our list shows, you know that if Rob tells me to come up with 10, then I do five three-way ties.
[6:26] Jamie DuMont: Right.
[6:27] Rob Russo: So I think Rob was very smart to actually come up with 15 because it gave me the allowance to go beyond the the I like to break a rule. I also really like to follow rules. So this was good. 15 felt like a good number.
[6:39] Jamie DuMont: Well, as we've learned over the last three years, one of the fun things about doing a podcast is that you get to make your own rules.
[6:43] Rob Russo: So we got to make our own rules and break our own rules.
[6:46] Jamie DuMont: Which was pretty fun.
[6:47] Rob Russo: All right.
[6:48] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[6:48] Rob Russo: And also what's gonna be fun today, I think for you, is that we're gonna have some surprise former guests.
[6:55] Jamie DuMont: I sort of alluded to Mimi Quillen a little bit. I gave the I gave the whatever away. So you'll hear from some of our past guests, uh, people that are very dear to our hearts, people that I think are dear to your hearts.
[7:06] Rob Russo: So um it's gonna be fun.
[7:08] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, and we you know we gave them the same prompt that we gave ourselves, right? Which was to share a uh a favorite performance. Um so it's gonna be really fun. Um but before we dive in, I have to say, you know, the usual caveats uh apply. Uh, you know, we chose 15 performances that we saw by individual performers.
[7:22] Rob Russo: So it's not 15 shows, it's it's it's performers, right, that we want to celebrate.
[7:27] Jamie DuMont: No list is exhaustive, of course. I'm sure we each forgot, you know, amazing performances that we saw that, you know, in hindsight we'd say, oh no, you know, we should have included that.
[7:35] Rob Russo: Um and the list could change any any given day, right? Like these are the 15 we have today, right?
[7:40] Jamie DuMont: I might change my list mid-show.
[7:42] Rob Russo: Oh no, Jamie.
[7:43] Jamie DuMont: I got an email from you last night, kind of late, and I was like, oh, he's up. I'm gonna text him and tell him I have to switch out for switch out. And then I was like, not allowed.
[7:51] Rob Russo: Now, I knew you were gonna say that. I I knew that's why I didn't do it.
[7:54] Jamie DuMont: Well, the bottom line though is that these are our favorite performances. So it's not even like the best, right? Because the best might not be the favorite, right? It's a different metric.
[8:03] Rob Russo: I don't know how what's the best. Why don't how do I know what's the best?
[8:06] Jamie DuMont: That's true.
[8:07] Rob Russo: Um you are a theater savant, Jamie DuMont, though, right? Let's not let's not forget.
[8:10] Jamie DuMont: Thank you, Playbill. I am milking that for all I can.
[8:14] Rob Russo: Yes. But the point of this whole exercise is just to spread some love around and to bask in our shared adoration of the theater one last time.
[8:21] Jamie DuMont: So to kick us off, let's hear from Raymond J. Lee.
[8:24] Raymond J. Lee: Hey, this is Raymond J. Lee, and happy hundredth episode to the Fabulous Invalid Podcast. It was an honor to be a guest, and I just love y'all. You are amazing. Um a memorable performance that I saw was the National Tour of Rent in DC. For me, Rent was the musical that showed me or told me that there was room for people like me in this business. I love the diversity of the show. I loved everyone wailing. I grew up a pop singer, and to hear these voices just singing their faces off meant the world and has stuck with me because if I could see people like that on stage, I knew there was room for me. So that's my one of my most memorable performances I've ever seen. Cool, y'all. And congratulations.
[9:10] Sammy Cannold: My name is Sammy Cannold, and I'm having a very hard time choosing a memorable moment because there are so many. But one that randomly immediately came to mind in a sort of roundabout way is Patti LuPone in the West End production of Company. Because there are all these scenes where she's sort of in the background and you can't quite tell it's her, and she's there as a member of the ensemble, but kind of hidden. And then you go, oh my god, it's Patti LuPone, and it just hits you that like musical theater is about team playing and community, and if Patti can do it, we can all do it. And I just find that to be uh incredible and inspiring.
[9:44] Jennifer Simard: Hi, this is Jennifer Simard. One of the performances that stood out for me and has stayed with me my entire life was a performance I saw in 1987 in Portsmouth, New Hampshire. It was the first time this show was premiered. It was a one-man show written by Noel Harrison, son of famed Rex Harrison. It was called Adieu Jacques. Noel Harrison, the late Noel Harrison, was a fan of Jacques Brel, as was I and my entire family. It was basically in a warehouse, and it was the first time I really realized sometimes it's not about the most commercial thing in the world that provides you with the most artistically satisfying experience. It was an incredible, impassioned evening. It also taught me that art can happen anywhere as long as you're open to finding it.
[10:38] Mimi Quillin: Katrina Link singing Um Khartum and Omar Sharif. I could definitely see Cleopatra and the pharaoh of romance. And then the black and white television on Friday night transported me to my own childhood. And she speaks about the TV set becomes a fountain and the living room becomes a garden. And it just makes me think of how our childhood fantasies just take us into adulthood, and it's very moving.
[11:09] Jamie DuMont: Okay, let's do it.
[11:10] Rob Russo: Oh my gosh.
[11:11] Jamie DuMont: Here we go.
[11:12] Rob Russo: Um all right, I'm starting.
[11:13] Jamie DuMont: Right.
[11:14] Rob Russo: Okay. It's a lot of pressure.
[11:15] Jamie DuMont: Well, you know, okay.
[11:18] Rob Russo: My number 15.
[11:19] Jamie DuMont: Yes.
[11:19] Rob Russo: Julie White, The Little Dog Laughed.
[11:22] Jamie DuMont: Oh, I I don't know that play at all.
[11:24] Rob Russo: Court Theater.
[11:25] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[11:25] Rob Russo: Uh didn't run as long as it should have. She won the Tony Award that year. Um, and it was uh 2006 to 2007, was the run of the play. I think it I think it started in LA or then did a very successful run in LA. But the one thing everyone agreed upon, including the Tony voters, was that Julie White was spectacular.
[11:46] Jamie DuMont: And it's a play about uh an agent who's trying to manage a client who is in the closet, an actor. He's a famous, you know, like a Tom Cruise type. Not that I'm drawing any parallels.
[11:56] Rob Russo: But he's like, sued Jamie on our last episode.
[11:59] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, no, no, no. But he's like a heartthrob, whatever, and he um and he's in the closet, and I believe he falls in love with a callboy.
[12:06] Rob Russo: Oh.
[12:06] Jamie DuMont: Um, and it's just who among us. But what is so great about this and what how it I think one of the reasons that it affected me so much was it was a series of really monologues of Julie White just talking to the audience. Even though she's talking about Hollywood, and she's, you know, it's in a lot of like, you know, winks to the audience. There was something about the way she did it and the humor and then the just the bite the edge to her character you loved her and you hated her right and and and nobody does that better than Julie White right because she's such a charming performer and such an incredible actress. I will never I saw it so as shock I saw it several times in its short run and I every time I I was you know sometimes when you he when you when you see something multiple times and the humor goes yeah that never happened that that's that's a mark of a great performance huh?
[13:03] Rob Russo: Yeah okay well my number 15 is Gabrielle Hamilton in Oklahoma. The uh Daniel Fish production that um you know I first saw in October 2018 at St. Ann's Warehouse in Brooklyn and then of course amazingly came to Broadway in spring of 2019 won all the awards won your heart just an amazing revival of Oklahoma sort of a reimagining of it but in particular for me what really made it I mean that was a show that was full of moments that took your breath away was the dream ballet right and and I don't know if you recall Jamie your first experience seeing it you saw it at Bard when it was still in in in development right I saw it at Bard yeah a couple of years before they even got it but they what they did is they they instead of the ballet ending act one, they had it begin act two.
[14:02] Rob Russo: And I remember finishing act one and thinking, oh, okay, they cut the ballet. I mean, it was a radical re-reimagining of the show. So I was like, oh, okay, fine. They cut the ballet, whatever. We had some chili, you know, that was intermission. And cornbread. And cornbread. And then we came back, we sat down, and that dream ballet started, and it was like, holy shit, this is incredible. It was so different from the rest of the show. Um, you could tell that Daniel Fish really gave choreographer John Higginbotham real license to, you know, sort of reimagine this piece and have it feel different from the rest of the show. What I love about her performance in particular is that it's the first dream ballet I've ever seen that actually felt like a dream.
And that was not just the choreography, and it was not just the staging and the lighting and all that. It was her performance, right? There was a quality to it that was so terrifying and visceral and psychological, right? And that's the point of a dream ballet. It's supposed to, you know, reveal the inner, you know, mind at work of the character. And it was just stunning, absolutely stunning. I still think about it, I still know those boots. The boots. If you saw it, you know exactly what I mean when I say the boots. The boots. The thing for me, I love that you chose this, of course, as you know. The thing for me, there are people that get this dream ballet and people that don't. Totally, 100%.
I think we both know where we fall on that spectrum. The other thing I want to say is that at Bard, my memory is that the ballet was very, very different. Yeah, it changed every version, right? But it could be very different at Bard. At Bard, I seemed to remember they were lined up and the music just played and they kind of stared each other down in this. And then it did something else. I can't quite remember what that was. And it didn't really work, yeah. Right. It was, you could tell there was an idea there. And so the fact that they figured it out so beautifully. Well, and you know, at St. Anne's, there was a chorus of other dancers who flew in and flew out, and it was like, wait, did that just happen?
You know, forgotten about that. And they were cut for Broadway, probably for budget reasons, but I don't know. But on Broadway, you know, Gabrielle Hamilton got to anchor that piece, you know, solo for 13 minutes, which is an incredible feat. Um, and I remember turning to you after we saw the first preview vocal home and saying, okay, they nailed this. Remember that again? Absolutely nailed this. That's my number 15.
[16:50] Jamie DuMont: Of course, you out there listening can't see the look on Rob's face, but it's the same grin that he had when he turned to me at that point. Of course, that light. The circle and the square, yeah. Oh god. And I'm so happy to just, you know, as we wrap up this iteration of the podcast, to be able to shout out again to that brilliant production. Oh my gosh. Yeah. Daniel Fish is a genius, that entire cast, Mary Testa, everyone, Mary Testa, Mary Tesla. Allie Stroker, everyone. Everyone every production. And the ballet. I'm so glad that you're giving that the love that it deserves. Gabrielle Hamilton. I think they call her Gabby, but I don't know her, so I'm gonna say Gabrielle. Okay. Okay. All right. So 14. Yes.
[17:34] Rob Russo: Now, my 14 is Vicky Frederick in A Chorus Line. Now I saw A Chorus Line many, many times before this. I saw it in the 70s in Chicago growing up. This production was sometime in the 80s. I was in high school, I want to say 83 or 84, just based on the fact that I don't think I was driving. I went with my mother. It was a matinee. It was at the Wilshire Theater in Beverly Hills. And I knew who Vicky Frederick was because I had seen her in Dancing. And I remember, as you do, you look at your program and all of that. But my memory of her was not as strong from Dancing. My memory of that was more about just the scope of that piece. Yeah. But in A Chorus Line, with her Cassie, even though I think I might get into trouble for this, she's not exactly the perfect Cassie on paper, right?
Like I think she's a Sheila, right? She certainly is. She is a Sheila. But I can to this day see her bending back in the music in the mirror and extending that leg and the slip coming down. And it was just power, sex. Yeah. All of it was there. And I remember obviously I was gay and not attracted to women, but in that moment, I remember thinking, this is the most attractive, fantastic human being I've ever seen in my life. And I cannot tell you the impression that it made on me. It was powerful.
[19:13] Jamie DuMont: Well, and that role, as we've talked about when we had Donna on the show, and also in our Showstopper's episode, you know, that role is a real marathon for a performer. And it kind of is on reflection, like the greatest musical theater role of all time, because you've gotta be a triple threat in the truest sense of the word. You have to be a really good actor to nail those scenes with Zach. Obviously, you have to kill that number, and you have to sing your face off. As Donna McKechney has told us on this show, that is a hard song. Yeah, so hat tip of the hat to Vicky Frederick.
[19:51] Rob Russo: Yeah, and before we move on, I just have to say again, I fell down this rabbit hole of looking up, you know, productions and, you know, because I did see that show so many times in so many different theaters in both LA and Chicago. And some of the dancers I may or may not have seen. Bebe Neuwirth, Lori Gamachi, Jerry Mitchell. I did see Jerry Mitchell full out, um, Murphy Cross, who I love dearly, Alison Reed, who was the film Cassie, right? And then, of course, Chorus Line, you know, regulars or originals, Pam Susa and Pamela Blair. So, you know, and that's just to name a few. Right. Yeah. Right? Like, I didn't even know, I mean, talk about going back to old playbills and looking at casts, right? The casts of A Chorus Line, that original production are just teeming with these incredible performers that would go on to do other work that we all, you know, love and cherish. Absolutely.
[20:46] Jamie DuMont: Well, speaking of loving and cherishing, right? My number 14 is Larry Owens, um, playing Usher in A Strange Loop. I am a Disney usher. I'm barely scraping by. My discontentment comes in many shapes and sizes when I wake up each morning. I tell myself to try. I tell myself that I will make no compromises today. I feel like my list has a sort of a presentist bias, which you'll notice as we go through. But, um, Larry, I mean that was just a star-making performance. Um, Michael R. Jackson's Pulitzer Prize winning, that's so fun to say, musical. We had Michael on the show to talk about his incredible self-referential musical that is just dramaturgically mind-blowing and brilliant, and I can't wait for it to come to Broadway, which it will, you know, someday soon, we hope.
But Larry Owens, you know, originating this role. What was so special to me about it was not only, you know, getting to see a great performance, but you know, I think Larry has talked about this candidly in other settings. But, you know, people who look like him, all right, meaning are black and, um, you know, plus size, rarely, if ever, get to anchor a musical, right? They're never cast as the lead. And he said that when he started doing this show, he was like, oh wow, for the first time, I was suddenly the lead. I had to carry a whole show. And usually I'm the comic relief, or I'm, you know, I have one scene in act two or whatever, right? And that's what was so amazing to me about his performance, in addition to it just being technically incredible, was how powerful it was to see someone of his, you know, his talent, but also of his skin color and size, get to stand center stage and say, this is a story about me.
And, you know, forever now the show exists in the musical theater canon. Other actors will get to step into the role of Usher. They'll get to, you know, have that moment center stage and, you know, get to tell this story, which will be so amazing. But as André De Shields said about Hermes, um, you know, he injected that role with his DNA. I have a feeling that whatever happens in the future, the role of Usher will always bear Larry Owens' DNA. And it's captured on that amazing cast album. If you haven't listened to it, do yourself a favor, listen to that cast album. You'll get, you'll understand immediately what I mean when I say his performance was incredible. But also, we talked to Michael R. Jackson about this.
They recorded um sort of a scene monologue, you know, that is set to music called Writing a Gospel Play. And that's where you really get to see Larry, you know, show off his sort of his comedic chops. Um, and he plays, you know, I don't know, five, six characters who were all in conversation with each other, and he just slips effortlessly back and forth between each one, and you know, with such specificity, you know exactly which character is talking at which time. And it's, you know, you obviously when you're watching it, there's a physicality to it, but you know, in an audio format, it all reads, and that's just, you know, that's a mark of an incredible performer. It's so crystal clear, it's so brilliant that it does read beautifully when you're listening to it.
[23:53] Rob Russo: When is the last time you listened to A Strange Loop?
[23:56] Jamie DuMont: Like yesterday.
[23:57] Rob Russo: You know, me too.
[23:59] Jamie DuMont: Come now.
[24:00] Rob Russo: Come on.
[24:01] Jamie DuMont: That is no surprise.
[24:03] Rob Russo: Shale!
[24:04] Jamie DuMont: What wrong, baby?
[24:06] Rob Russo: You ain't eating up your tater salad.
[24:09] Jamie DuMont: Oh, ain't Patty, how can I eat tater salad when there's no ring on my finger?
[24:16] Rob Russo: Michelle, girl, you better forget about that ring and learn how to drop it like this. Ha!
[24:21] Jamie DuMont: Fix it, Jesus. I did everything I was supposed to. I stayed in school. I kept my legs closed. I was faithful and paid my tithes and offering. Because Mark 12 and 17 says, Render unto Caesar what is Caesar's, and render unto God what is God's. Go and say, bitch, better have my money right cheer. Girl, if you don't sell down, I'ma pop you in the face with one of my world-famous patty pies. The Sunday say Patty Pie, because I'm hungry as Caesar.
[24:55] Rob Russo: Alright, number 13.
[24:57] Jamie DuMont: Ruthie Ann Miles, Here Lies Love.
[24:59] Rob Russo: You have me at Ruthie.
[25:00] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, well, I'm obsessed with her. I think she's such an incredible performer, actor, human being. The thing about this that really struck me, she was able to take a deeply unsympathetic character and make you root for them. And but not root for the terrible things that they did in their life, but she found sympathy and she found a way of making you relate to her, to Imelda, which is the mark of an incredible actor. I really have nothing else to say, but I will never forget. I mean that production, Jose Llana, Conrad Ricamora, that whole company was so, the dude, everything about that. It's a great experience.
[25:56] Rob Russo: Yeah, such a great experience. But it was all anchored with Ruthie, and it all started with her, the just not only the truth about the ugly side of the character, but the ability to make that character sympathetic and relatable.
[26:12] Jamie DuMont: I don't know another actor that could have done that in that role.
[26:15] Rob Russo: Let me be started.
[26:15] Jamie DuMont: My personal life.
[26:27] Rob Russo: Let them take it away.
[26:32] Jamie DuMont: I can't be heard anymore by those things that they say.
[26:38] Jamie DuMont: Let it come.
[26:39] Rob Russo: Let it come one day.
[26:41] Rob Russo: Let it come.
[26:41] Jamie DuMont: Let me be star.
[27:00] Rob Russo: Well, my number 13 is a bit of a cheat. Sorry, Jamie.
[27:02] Jamie DuMont: Uh oh.
[27:05] Rob Russo: I know, I know. We made the rules, but we can break the rules.
[27:08] Jamie DuMont: Rob Russo doesn't cheat, he doesn't lie, he doesn't steal. He is basically the best human being on the planet.
[27:14] Rob Russo: I'd make a good Mormon except for, you know, one big problem.
[27:17] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[27:18] Rob Russo: Whoops.
[27:20] Rob Russo: We don't need to scratch that too deeply. It's a little obvious. Um, okay. But um my number 13 is the ensemble.
[27:28] Jamie DuMont: Oh, here we go.
[27:29] Rob Russo: I know. Of 42nd Street. Um, in that 2001 revival. Um, I was not a well, I was alive when the original was running, but I was like one, so you know, I can't claim to have seen the original Gower Champion. But I did see in May 2001 the uh first revival of 42nd. I say first, because someday we're gonna get the second revival on Broadway. And specifically the moment that I will just never forget, and it will always live big in my in my mind, was the very beginning of the show. It's iconic, right? That curtain slowly raises on the audition scene, and you've got what feels like a hundred people on stage tap dancing. And I had never experienced an ensemble tap dancing before, ever in my entire life. I will never forget the thrill of experiencing that for the first time. My jaw dropped, and I was like, I was just so madly in love with the show, and we were 30 seconds into it.
[28:20] Jamie DuMont: Hey! Did you see this? Julian Marsh is doing a show! It's in Variety! Julian Marsh is doing a show!
[28:28] Rob Russo: Yes! We're gonna work again!
[28:30] Jamie DuMont: Get out! You tap shoes, Francis! Julie Marsh is doing a show! First audition, 10 a.m. tomorrow!
[28:54] Rob Russo: I actually looked this up, you know, because it did feel like a hundred people. Um, but it was 36, which for a musical to have a 36 member ensemble, and those are just people who have ensemble next to the name. There are other, you know, named characters who were dancing in that opening number as well. Um, you know, that's incredible. And it's very special. And I always say this, and I will say this one more time while I still have this platform. Um there's not enough tap on Broadway.
[29:18] Jamie DuMont: No, we need more tap.
[29:19] Rob Russo: Every season I'm like, where is the tap? Um, and it's because of this moment, right? Um, and it was, you know, the production that was directed by uh Mark Bramble, the original book writer, um, and the choreography by Randy Skinner, um, who uh, you know, re-re-created a lot of the Gower Champion, but also added his own touch, and you know, he did the most recent uh West End revival as well, which maybe will come across the pond. I don't know, someday. But well you can see it. It's amazing.
[29:45] Jamie DuMont: Did a pro shot, yeah. Yeah. Um I don't know if you know this. Yeah, but um I'm a bit of a fan of 42nd Street.
[29:45] Rob Russo: Yeah, yeah.
[29:54] Jamie DuMont: I did see.
[29:55] Rob Russo: Understatement.
[29:56] Jamie DuMont: I did see the original Gower Champions production. And I do agree with you. I I think I, you know, I can't, I can't I can't honestly say I was the biggest fan of that revival, but I think I I think the reason for that is more on me because I was comparing it to something. You can't do that. And I'm older now and I realize that, which is why I loved the exact same production in London when I saw it. And so I can no longer say I didn't like that revival because I did love it.
[30:24] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[30:25] Jamie DuMont: But you're right. There's nothing more thrilling than that moment. And I just need to reiterate this. We need more tap on Broadway. We need more moments like that.
[30:36] Rob Russo: Yes.
[30:37] Jamie DuMont: It's just, it's the perfect combination of brilliance. It's it's what me, it's what you can only do in musical theater. And and it hooked me, you know. So let's keep hooking more more young gay boys in the audience to want to see more musical.
[30:59] Rob Russo: Number 12, Neutra High School. 1977, maybe 78, I can't quite remember. Liz Callaway in Kismet.
[31:08] Jamie DuMont: What? Okay, you're gonna have to unpack all of what you just said.
[31:11] Rob Russo: Right. Well, I don't think I've ever said this on the show before, but I I I well I've said this. I I grew up partly in Chicago and in Los Angeles, and at that time we were living in a suburb of Chicago, and Liz Callaway was in my brother's class at Nuture High School.
[31:26] Jamie DuMont: Stop it.
[31:27] Rob Russo: She was the star of all of the musicals.
[31:30] Jamie DuMont: I would hope so.
[31:31] Rob Russo: As you could imagine. Um, and and I did, you know, it's funny. Her sister Ann, Hampton Callaway, played MAME a few years earlier.
[31:39] Jamie DuMont: Stop it.
[31:39] Rob Russo: I you know, I honestly, so the first the technically the first show I ever saw was Jesus Christ Superstar. But I was a baby, and I I have a memory of being like carried out into the lobby.
[31:51] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[31:51] Rob Russo: It's like one of my early memories.
[31:53] Jamie DuMont: Shock is that.
[31:54] Rob Russo: The crucifixion was too much.
[31:56] Jamie DuMont: I no, I think it was the smoke, it was loud. I mean, I had no, I mean, I was like a toddler. I had no business being in a theater.
[32:02] Rob Russo: Don't take toddlers to the theater.
[32:05] Jamie DuMont: But one I think the first thing I actually saw that I remembered was Ann Hampton Callaway as Mame.
[32:10] Rob Russo: Well, that explains a lot, Jamie.
[32:12] Jamie DuMont: I know.
[32:13] Rob Russo: Wow, you should have led with that.
[32:15] Jamie DuMont: Three years. It took three years for me to share that. And it's, you know, it's it's anyway. So talk about hooking a young gay boy. But well, absolutely. But it was a few years later that I saw her sister in Kismet. And I remember the I rem I remember that. I remember so much about that experience. But I remember when she opened her mouth and started singing. I and she was what, 16, 17? I remember thinking, I've never heard a voice like this.
[32:45] Rob Russo: Wow.
[32:45] Jamie DuMont: I've never like what is happening? Who is that? What is going on?
[32:50] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[32:50] Jamie DuMont: And to this day, I am a lifelong Liz Callaway fan. Her voice has not changed over the years.
[32:58] Rob Russo: I'm gonna say, she probably sounds exactly the same today, right?
[33:01] Jamie DuMont: Well, I saw her. I saw her recently at 54 below.
[33:05] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[33:05] Jamie DuMont: And as she pointed out in her act, she's still singing merrily in the original key. Um which is, you know, not everybody's doing that.
[33:13] Rob Russo: Well, she, you know, she always she records herself in the car singing. See, if you've never seen it on like Twitter or where wherever she shares it, it's incredible. Like she's giving these like, you know, Broadway quality concerts just in her car, driving around her neighborhood. It's it's amazing.
[33:25] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, it's full out. Full out. Yeah. So you know, there were many theater bugs that bit me very early in my life. I I hadn't actually made the meme parallel in that. But come on. It does answer so many questions for all of you out there that know my other fascination in life is just maim. But um, yeah, but Liz, it's it's uh well, and I love that it was like a high school production, right? That's that's what's so fun about doing this, right? Is those those performances that stuck with us or made a big impression or whatever. It's not always Broadway, right?
[33:56] Rob Russo: I mean Well, you had it with Hello Dolly, right?
[33:58] Jamie DuMont: Oh, for sure, yeah. I saw when I was in fifth grade. I went to a dress rehearsal of my local high school's Hello Dolly. I think we've had this conversation before. I think so many of us that love theater the way we do, it that first thing was oftentimes in a high school production.
[34:12] Rob Russo: Yeah, oh, totally, totally amazing. Well, um, I uh it wasn't high school production, but I was in high school when I saw my number 12. Uh, which uh is Jeff McCarthy as officer lockstock in Urin Town the Musical.
[34:26] ♪ Musical number: "Too Much Exposition" — performed by Jeff McCarthy ♪
[35:11] Rob Russo: It was an incredible performance on its own merits, right? Because he's a genius. And in that role, I mean, was there ever a better marriage of actor and part than Jeff McCarthy? No in You're in Town, right? Just from the he you know, he opens the show, and from the very beginning, you're just you're losing it. You're just dying of laughter. Um, but what for me made that performance all the more, you know, just incredible and memorable is that the first time I saw You're in Town, um, the musical was September 14th, 2001. So think about that date. It's three days after 9-11. Um, you know, obviously just a watershed moment in American history. That's an understatement. And, you know, I was 14 years old.
And I'll never, I mean, the weight of that event was something that anyone, I mean, I think all Americans carried with them, you know, uh, I think New Yorkers in particular carried with them. Um, and the depression that just set in, and the fear and the angst and all of it, right? All those emotions that we were feeling as as a country. Um, and Broadway was shut down for two days, you know, but it reopened pretty quickly. I mean, all things considered. And I'll never forget we filed into the the Henry Miller's theater, and the audience was half full, if even. You know, that theater was a dump, which fit the show. You know, it was perfect for this show. But man, you were kind of worried that the mezzanine was going to collapse at any minute.
And before the show started, uh John Rando, the director, came out and he gave a little curtain speech, and I'll never forget the words he said. He said that there were fires still burning downtown at ground zero, and it might feel inappropriate almost for us to be gathered in this theater tonight when there's so much suffering and so much horror going on as a country. But it's also exactly where we need to be. We need to be here together, and we need to remember that you know what was attacked was exactly this, right? Was in you know civilized society coming together and engaging in artistic expression, right? And that curtain speech was it was so generous, and it was, you know, it of course it had to happen.
He had to address the moment before we saw this satirical, you know, rather dark uh musical. And then Jeff McCarthy came out and started the show, and what he did is he gave us permission to laugh, and it was the first time that anyone in that audience had laughed, I guarantee you, in days, and it instantly broke that tension, and it carried us to the end of the show. I'm getting chills now, just thinking about it. It was such a beautiful moment. It's something I will never forget. And of course, then the rest of the show was just was just phenomenal. Uh, I love that show. And someday that'll also get a revival, and you know, people will get to celebrate anew how brilliant it is.
[37:57] Jamie DuMont: Can't we do a happy musical next time?
[37:59] Rob Russo: If there is a next time, I'm sure we can.
[38:03] Jamie DuMont: Well, that's our story.
[38:04] Rob Russo: Hope eventually joined her father in a manner not quite so gentle.
[38:09] Jamie DuMont: As for the people of this town, they did as best they could, but they were prepared for the world they inherited, weaned as they were on the legend born of their founding father's scare tactics.
[38:19] Rob Russo: But when the water dried up, they recognized their town for the first time for what it really was, what it was always waiting to be.
[38:40] Jamie DuMont: Hey, Malthus.
[38:42] Rob Russo: Hey, Balthus.
[38:44] Jamie DuMont: Thank you.
[38:45] Rob Russo: And good night.
[39:00] Jamie DuMont: My number 11. I, you know, I'm just gonna say it. Marin Massey, the world goes round, 1992, Kern Theater, San Francisco. Boom.
[39:10] Rob Russo: I yeah. If you don't get it, you don't get it.
[39:13] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, I mean, uh, Maren. How amazing. How amazing.
[39:18] Rob Russo: Yeah, yeah.
[39:20] Jamie DuMont: Was that a tour? Was that the tour of the city?
[39:22] Rob Russo: It was the it was the national tour. It was, I believe, post-Broadway. I'm pretty sure Karen Ziemba was in it. Pretty sure Jim Walton was in it. I have a thing for statues blondes. I I love an icy blonde. I love a Lee Remick.
[39:35] Jamie DuMont: Who among us?
[39:35] Rob Russo: I love Adina Merrill. I love a Marin Massey. And I remember, you know, being very struck with her throughout all of them. I mean, I, you know, Karen Ziemba was the one that people knew of.
[39:47] Jamie DuMont: Right.
[39:47] Rob Russo: She she had become kind of this this show had given her a name.
[39:52] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, yeah.
[39:52] Rob Russo: Uh to a certain extent. And I knew Jim Walton, of course, because of Marilee.
[39:56] Jamie DuMont: Sure.
[39:56] Rob Russo: And uh, so that was a name I mean. Maren wasn't big yet.
[39:59] Jamie DuMont: No, no, I think this was one of her first things.
[40:01] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[40:02] Jamie DuMont: And and I I was in my favorite seat in the front mezzanine at the current theater, as if you may know, is one of my favorite theaters in the world.
[40:10] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[40:10] Jamie DuMont: And it I it I changed me. I thought, wow, this is who is this person?
[40:17] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[40:18] Jamie DuMont: And uh lo and behold, just a few years later, she would pop in passion. And then in ragtime, and then in the Kiss me kate. And then, and then, and then unfortunately we lost her, right?
[40:32] Rob Russo: Right when this podcast started.
[40:33] Jamie DuMont: Yeah. Right when this in fact, one of our first, our second episode in in in many ways is a tribute to her with the beautiful Donna Murphy, who was her very dear friend.
[40:43] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[40:43] Jamie DuMont: So my gosh. Well, that's amazing.
[40:45] Rob Russo: Yeah, it it's yeah. There it is. You were my sky, my moon, and my stars, and my show.
[41:30] Jamie DuMont: Well, my number 11 is Steven Skybel, uh as Tevye in Fiddler on the Roof in Yiddish, which um, you know, I first saw obviously the summer of 2018 at the Museum of Jewish Heritage downtown. And then, of course, that miraculous production by Joel Gray, guest of the show, friend of the show, uh directed by Joel Gray, uh, came off Broadway in March 2019. It was a runaway hit that kept extending it, kept extending it. Steven Skybel gave uh not only a magnificent performance, but I'm gonna say it, he was the best Tevye I've ever seen. With all due respect to all other Tevyes. What he did, and I think this was, you know, this was partly Joel Gray's vision for the production, um, so we'll credit Joel as well.
But he played uh the role, um, you know, it's typically he's like a harmless teddy bear, right? He's kind of like, you know, uh almost a bit of a cartoon to some degree. And he played the role with this solemnity and this intensity that you know gave it a uh a depth of richness and humanity that that you don't typically get with the show, but also is more true to the source material. If you go back to the original stories by Sholem Aleichem, um, you know, Tevye the Milkman, he's not a bubbly happy guy. He there's a bit of menace there, you know. He is abusive to his wife and daughters. And like, you know, while that obviously is not in the text of the musical, that sort of menace, you know, that is a reflection of the time and place, certainly, the culture, the gender dynamics of uh, you know, this shtetl uh in in Russia.
Um, you know, all of that was so amazingly captured in his performance. Um, you know, he was funny, but he wasn't a clown. And I think that's an important distinction to make with with Fiddler and with his performance in particular. Um, he was stern, he was fearsome. And what Joel did is, you know, nothing was played for laughs. He let the intrinsic humor, because there is intrinsic humor in Joseph Stein's book and in the source material, speak for itself. And and to be that confident of a performer, um, to give that performance stunning. You know, and typically, especially nowadays, that that part is star cast. And, you know, I don't think he would mind if I said it. He's not uh he's not a star, he's not a marquee name, um, but he's a prolific actor. And he's worked everywhere. Uh, and he works, and and you know, he should because he's he's incredible. And I I just I will always love that production, but especially his Tevye.
[43:56] Rob Russo: Yeah, exactly.
[43:58] Jamie DuMont: I'm surprised that's the first time I've said that.
[44:00] Rob Russo: Not the last.
[44:01] Jamie DuMont: No, not the last. But you're right, the menacing, he's sort of he was sort of his Tevye was frightening.
[44:06] Rob Russo: Yeah, there was it to it a little bit.
[44:08] Jamie DuMont: Anger to it.
[44:09] Rob Russo: Yeah, there was an anger.
[44:09] Jamie DuMont: Yes, which is so real. And uh, no, God, what a what a magnificent performer in a magnificent show.
[44:18] Rob Russo: Yeah, I'll put this out in the universe. We could use that back. I mean, seriously, Fiddler is always sadly timely. As we've said on this show, it's the greatest musical ever.
[44:27] Rob Russo: Well, I think I think uh number 10 might actually be your greatest musical.
[44:31] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, number 10, you're number 10. You can't have me talking about theater without going to Dreamgirls.
[44:37] Rob Russo: There we go. Um I'm surprised it took us so long to get there.
[44:41] Jamie DuMont: But uh, my number 10, Lilius White, as Effie in the tour that was, I believe, 1987, the Pantages Theater. She had done it on Broadway, obviously. Um, I had already seen the show. I did not see Jennifer Holliday when she did it in LA. She was gone by the time I saw it the first time around. But boy, uh, that was like, and and I'm not even talking about the big number. I'm talking about from the minute she came out on stage and said, I'm tired, or whatever her first line is. I thought, who is this magnificent? Like, what what is happening? Yeah, she took my breath away from the beginning and and has continued to do so show after show through her entire career. She's been trending on Twitter a little bit with her don't write on my parade.
There's been a lot of there's been a lot of funny girl stuff out in the world. That clip comes back around. It's so epic, and I have to watch it. That and Betty Buckley singing as if we never said goodbye. Oh, those are two clips, and every time they show up in my feed, I'm like, okay, yeah, I'm gonna take a minute, and I'm gonna watch that. I'm gonna stop.
[45:48] Rob Russo: Yeah, and also Betty doing memory, which is like, yeah, that I mean that's the world comes to a halt.
[45:54] Jamie DuMont: But let's not forget Lilius White was a Grizabella replacement.
[45:57] Rob Russo: She certainly was.
[45:58] Jamie DuMont: I I've actually never heard her memory. I should see if there's a bootleg online.
[46:01] Rob Russo: Oh, you know what? Let's hit pause. But I will say about um Lilius, you can actually listen to her performance because she did um a number of years later. The Actors Fund did a benefit of Dreamgirls. It's the complete original show, to the best of my knowledge. Um, Dina Jones is Audra McDonald.
[46:21] Rob Russo: Wow.
[46:21] Jamie DuMont: Laurel Robinson is Heather Headley, Michelle Morris is Tamara Tooney, Billy Porter.
[46:27] Rob Russo: Wow, it's a who's who.
[46:28] Jamie DuMont: It's a who's who, Norm Lewis. I mean, it just it's the show, Norm Lewis. It goes, I guess of the show goes on and on and on. But you can hear Lilius.
[46:36] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[46:36] Jamie DuMont: Um to my ears, many years later, sounded exactly as she did in 1987 at the Pantages.
[47:00] Rob Russo: Oh hold.
[47:02] Jamie DuMont: It's very serious.
[47:06] Rob Russo: It's serious.
[47:17] Jamie DuMont: Well, we'll talk about mine when we're alone tonight.
[47:36] Rob Russo: All right, little girl.
[47:39] Jamie DuMont: All right.
[47:52] Rob Russo: All right.
[47:53] Jamie DuMont: Well, my number 10, speaking of amazing women, um, is Katrina Lank in The Band's Visit. I know that Mimi Quillin uh also had the same favorite performance, and for good reason.
[48:04] Rob Russo: For very good reasons.
[48:05] Jamie DuMont: Katrina Lank is she defies description. Um talk about, you know, uh mystery and sultry and all the trees, you know. She statuesque, I mean, oh my gosh. Uh, you know, I first saw I got one of the last tickets to see uh The Band's Visit at the Atlantic Theater Company in uh December of 2016. It's blown away by it, and then obviously it came to Broadway, won all the awards, uh, just a perfect, perfect musical. She was seductive but confident. Um, you know, she had that aching heart, that raw strength. She was simply captivating. And you know, obviously her her Tony Award performance of Omar Sharif will be, you know, forever one of the great Tony Award performances. You can go watch it. That cast album captures her performance amazingly.
I I saw that show eight times on Broadway. Once with me, once with you. It's the show tied with Hello, Dolly! that I have seen the most on Broadway. Um, and there's a reason I kept coming back, in addition to the fact that it was a nice 90 minutes, um, was to see Katrina Lank give what will I think always be one of the great Broadway performances. Just a perfect meeting of role with star like Larry Owens in A Strange Loop, you know, just her DNA will forever be in that part. Gosh, we're now at number nine, if you can imagine such a thing.
[49:25] Rob Russo: I can.
[49:26] Jamie DuMont: I really can. This was an easy one for me. Um, what was hard was what number it would get. But having having this next one on the list was from the minute we talked about this, Linda Lavin in The Lions.
[49:38] Rob Russo: Play by Nicky Silver.
[49:40] Jamie DuMont: I was surprised in going doing some research. I had forgotten or didn't know that it was Nicky Silver's Broadway debut.
[49:48] Rob Russo: Yeah, that's right.
[49:49] Jamie DuMont: So, you know, that's something to be said. You know, it started at the Vineyard Theater in uh 2011, and then it came to Broadway in 2012. There's something about Linda Lavin. I would watch her read a phone book. She's such an incredible performer. She is so different in everything she does, and also there's always a little bit of what I pretend is Linda Lavin. I don't know her, so I don't know what she's like as a human being. But there's there's a thread through all of her characters that I think is intrinsically part of who she is, which I find so watchable and fascinating.
[50:22] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[50:22] Jamie DuMont: This character was a classic Jewish mother, her husband is dying, her kids hate her, and a lot of it takes place. I think maybe all of it takes place in a hospital room. Um, interestingly enough, she had done this play at the Vineyard, then I think went on to do Other Desert Cities at Lincoln Center. And then this happened, The Lions, which I think was very and this and this is what I love about her because she clearly loved this role and it was you know written for her. She left Other Desert Cities, didn't go with it to Broadway. She went to Broadway with The Lions. It was unfortunately not successful. Judith Light would go on to win Best Featured Actress in a play for Other Desert Cities in the role that Linda Lavin originated.
And I've heard Linda Lavin talk about this experience after the fact. And she has nothing but love and fondness for this part. And I think that's extraordinary. But it was her performance that I I will never forget how she just took this. It was I liked the play. I thought it was very funny. But she found this humor and this heart in this not very likable lady. And again, I think there's a theme. I think you're sensing a theme here. Um I I tend to be drawn to actors who can take a despicable or terrible person and turn it around.
[51:45] Rob Russo: I thought you were just gonna say strong women.
[51:47] Jamie DuMont: Oh, well, that I mean that goes without it. I mean, that's baked in, right?
[51:49] Rob Russo: That's baked in.
[51:52] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, yeah, exactly. So that's my number nine.
[51:54] Rob Russo: Amazing.
[51:54] Jamie DuMont: Well, my number nine, I've talked about this uh before when we did our best of the decade, uh, was Gideon Glick in Significant Other, the Josh Harmon play that was uh on Broadway in um 2017, uh following uh a run uh in 2015 at Roundabout. Um I remember I saw the second to last performance when it was at Roundabout, and I thought, oh my god, I'm never gonna get to see this play again because you know it closes tomorrow, and then miraculously it came to Broadway in 2017. Um, I guess like The Lions, it was not a hit. It ran only 61 performances, but I saw two of them on Broadway. And um I just loved the play. I thought it was really special, really beautiful. Um, and his performance in particular, you know.
You know, I I've talked about this before, so I don't need to belabor it here. Um, if you're a fan of the show, you've heard my you've heard my say about Gideon Glick, insignificant other, but it was the biggest Tony snub of the decade of the century, uh, that he was not nominated for this performance. That was really just a tour de force. I mean, he never left the stage. And um, you know, his his scene work with Barbara Berry in particular was so beautiful.
[52:57] Rob Russo: Guest of the show.
[52:58] Jamie DuMont: Guest of the show. Uh you were a little name-droppy today, but why not? It's our last, it's our last go-around. Um, so Gideon Glick, he's an amazing performer, and I I just love that play. It really resonated with me personally. You know, it's sort of kind of at times felt like seeing my life played out on stage, which can be hard, but also, you know, uh a really amazing thing that theater can do, right? Is to reflect people's lives and stories on stage in an authentic way that um, you know, will will hit different audience members in a different way, um, depending on, you know, where you stand and where you sit and all that.
[53:28] Rob Russo: Wow.
[53:28] Jamie DuMont: I loved that performance.
[53:30] Rob Russo: Well, many people did.
[53:32] Jamie DuMont: Yeah. And I you know, this is what I find so fascinating about this play is that they did a streaming version of it at the beginning of the pandemic, and it was a big deal.
[53:40] Rob Russo: It was so I watched it too.
[53:42] Jamie DuMont: It was a little reunion too.
[53:43] Rob Russo: That cast.
[53:44] Jamie DuMont: There was a reunion, and but there was so much love for that play. And uh, you know, maybe we'll see another production of it.
[53:51] Rob Russo: Oh, maybe someday.
[53:52] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, it's a great piece. And I'd say he's a great playwright. Admissions at Lincoln Center, which was his follow-up, was a brilliant play. I absolutely loved it. I oh anytime Josh Harmon does something, I'm there.
[54:01] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[54:02] Jamie DuMont: Sign me up.
[54:02] Rob Russo: Yeah, sign me up. He's a clever, talented fella.
[54:06] Jamie DuMont: All right. Number eight.
[54:07] Rob Russo: Yes.
[54:08] Jamie DuMont: Guest of the show.
[54:09] Rob Russo: Guest of the show.
[54:10] Jamie DuMont: Guest of the show.
[54:11] Rob Russo: Um, another person that I may be a little obsessed with.
[54:14] Jamie DuMont: Uh straining water obsessed?
[54:17] Rob Russo: No, and not like Stalker, like very stabby fan.
[54:20] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, you'll always get that line right. I I respect it, I admire that.
[54:25] Jamie DuMont: Thank you. She first came to attention in this country as, uh, Miss America, the first black Miss America. She would hit a few road bumps shortly thereafter, and then she would become a very famous recording artist, and then she would land her first Broadway gig.
[54:39] Jamie DuMont: And that would be Kiss of the Spider Woman.
[54:41] Rob Russo: And of course, if you haven't guessed, by now I'm talking about the one and only Vanessa Williams.
[54:45] Jamie DuMont: Oh my gosh.
[54:46] Rob Russo: You have to imagine, as I'm sure you can, that this role was created by Chita Rivera.
[54:53] Jamie DuMont: And Chita Rivera is one of those actors that you don't, you can't touch that.
[54:57] Rob Russo: No.
[54:57] Jamie DuMont: You can't, not she is she is Rosie from Bye Bye Birdie.
[55:01] Rob Russo: She, I mean, just go on.
[55:03] Jamie DuMont: She is she is Velma from Chicago.
[55:06] Rob Russo: Although Bebe Neuwirth did a pretty good show.
[55:10] Jamie DuMont: Guest of the show.
[55:10] Rob Russo: Guest of the show.
[55:11] Jamie DuMont: But my point is here is this incredible performer, Vanessa Williams, stepping into this legendary Tony-winning performance by legendary Tony.
[55:22] Rob Russo: Ah, musical of the year.
[55:24] Jamie DuMont: One best musical.
[55:25] Rob Russo: I mean, this was a big deal.
[55:26] Jamie DuMont: And man, I I I remember I was a fan, so I wasn't like prove something to me, lady. Like I was there and I was there for it.
[55:34] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[55:37] Jamie DuMont: But I I was so blown away by, and we've talked about this, I think. Her just what what I will never forget is the joy she was having. Just the sheer joy.
[55:47] Rob Russo: When it was appropriate to be showing joy, right? Because her character is complicated.
[55:53] Jamie DuMont: Well, as we learned when we had her on the show, you know, she's a musical theater performer. She's trained. I mean, this is what this is what she has always wanted to do with her life, and obviously has now done. But at the time, this was a real, this was a big moment for her career.
[56:05] Rob Russo: Big moment and a big moment of validation for her, which she also said it's a great episode. I highly recommend if you haven't listened to our Vanessa Williams, please do.
[56:14] Jamie DuMont: That I do recall.
[56:24] Rob Russo: Your breath racks your ribs and you'll throw with pain.
[56:28] Jamie DuMont: There's a juice on my lips for each purple stain.
[56:35] Rob Russo: Um sweeps your chest like a cool.
[57:23] Jamie DuMont: This right here.
[57:24] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[57:25] Jamie DuMont: This perfect.
[57:25] Rob Russo: How lucky we are to be alive right now.
[57:27] Jamie DuMont: How lucky we are to be alive right now, but also just when someone can sing it and dance it and act it and be a star and step into very big shoes and make them her own.
[57:39] Rob Russo: And and make it seem effortless.
[57:42] Jamie DuMont: Uh well, my number eight was uh Philip Seymour Hoffman, that's Willie Lohmann in Death of a Salesman, that 2012 revival, uh directed by Mike Nichols.
[57:50] Rob Russo: Um he performed opposite Linda Emond and Andrew Garfield was in the company making his Broadway debut.
[57:56] Jamie DuMont: Um I mean it's an incredible play, right? So to state the obvious, and it's a Titanic role for any actor who steps into it.
[58:03] Rob Russo: I know for people perhaps 10 years older than me or more.
[58:07] Jamie DuMont: Um the Brian Dennehy uh uh production in 1999 was another touchstone.
[58:13] Rob Russo: He's talking about me, by the way.
[58:14] Jamie DuMont: Well, no, my my my brother saw it, my parents saw it, and that that's their Willie Lohman, right? That you know, but you know, in the 80s it was it was Dustin Hoffman who did it, right?
[58:22] Rob Russo: You know, you can just go down the line, right? Each actor sort of puts their stamp on it.
[58:26] Jamie DuMont: And um I had never seen, and it turned out would never see Philip Seymour Hoffman on stage again. Um to encounter an actor of that caliber in person, which you know you get to do in the theater, um, was staggering.
[58:42] Rob Russo: I I'll just never forget the experience of seeing that play.
[58:45] Jamie DuMont: I also saw it with my dad, and Death of a Salesman is quite a play to see with your dad, you know, um, for all sorts of reasons. If you know the play, you know exactly what I'm talking about.
[58:53] Rob Russo: So I don't have much more to say except that you know, Philip Seymour Hoffman, there it is, right? Like you know exactly what I mean when I say that would be a memorable performance.
[59:00] Jamie DuMont: Fabulous.
[59:01] Rob Russo: Well, we're now halfway through our list, so we've been droning on and on. Let's take a break and listen to some more guest submissions. Uh kicking off with the person who I call the godmother, the fairy godmother of all theater podcasting, the one and only Alana Levine.
[59:16] Alana Levine: Hey everyone, this is Alana Levine from the Little Known Facts Podcast. When the fabulous invalid asked me to think of a performance or a show that really stayed with me, obviously I could think of a million, but the very first one that popped into my head was Elaine May in Waverly Gallery, the Kenneth Lonergan play. Watching Elaine May, I don't know. I don't even know how to describe it except to say that it was like watching a documentary. It was hard to believe that an actress was inhabiting this role. I don't think I've ever seen anything like it. I don't know that I'll ever see anything like it again. She was extraordinary, and I feel so lucky that I got to see her in this performance. And uh thank you to the fabulous Invalid for being an extraordinary podcast that I love to listen to and that I will miss. And luckily there's so many episodes that I can go back and listen to because you're also talented and your guests are phenomenal. Happy birthday to this incredible podcast.
[1:00:28] Jose Llana: Hi, this is Jose Llana, and um my memorable theatrical experience uh was was during I had just started rehearsal for my first Broadway show in 1996, The King and I in 96. I was young, I was about 19 years old, and I was feeling very overwhelmed and and kind of unsure about leaving school, and I took my first Broadway paycheck and I went and bought a ticket to go see Master Class. And I sat by myself in the audience and I watched Zoe Caldwell and Audra McDonald um and the subject matter and and about art and about singing and about um just what you sacrificed for your uh your art and for your passion. Um was exactly what I needed to sort of boost me back into um into a good headspace. So uh Master Class in nineteen ninety six and um to a very young young performer uh meant everything so that is my theatrical experience.
[1:01:22] Arian Moyad: This is Arian Moyad and one theater memory that sticks with me is watching Lynn Nottage's Poof! It adapted in Farsi seeing it in a small black box theater in Tehran where these women were telling their stories of freedom through the eyes of Lynn Nottage's Poof! That will stay with me forever the power of theater man.
[1:02:02] Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer: Hi there I am Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer one of my most favorite memorable moments from uh stage performance Amy Morton in August: Osage County on Broadway. Uh there's a moment in the play she plays uh Barbara one of the daughters and there's a moment in the play where I believe it's the end of act two where she's screaming at her mother who's abusive terrible human being and she's screaming at her on the ground and it was so real and so intense and the whole play is just so incredibly crafted by Tracy Letts and with this amazing cast but Amy Morton just I was like yes that's that's why I love theater. This is why because I feel something I I was so I was so blown away by it and so struck physically by it that I when the lights came up I was hysterically sobbing in my seat.
And I can feel the entire audience like I've never felt that kind of energy. And so it was truly it just rocked my world. And every time I think of it, and every time I think of her, I was like, God, I just want to be as good as Amy Morton someday. So Amy, if you're listening to this, um, do you give any coachings? Okay. Love you all.
[1:03:22] Jamie DuMont: Thank you, Leslie.
[1:03:24] Rob Russo: We love Leslie.
[1:03:25] Jamie DuMont: We love it.
[1:03:25] Rob Russo: She's a fritzer.
[1:03:26] Jamie DuMont: You know, sort of guest host.
[1:03:28] Rob Russo: Uh, she popped in a couple episodes.
[1:03:30] Jamie DuMont: We're now at my tie.
[1:03:31] Rob Russo: That sounds funny.
[1:03:33] Jamie DuMont: Which is, well, it's a Harvey Fierstein tie.
[1:03:36] Rob Russo: Let's just say that, right?
[1:03:37] Jamie DuMont: Put it on a t-shirt, you know.
[1:03:39] Rob Russo: I I may do, actually.
[1:03:40] Jamie DuMont: He'd probably wear it.
[1:03:41] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[1:03:42] Jamie DuMont: Um, so Harvey as Edna in Hairspray.
[1:03:46] Rob Russo: Oh my god.
[1:03:46] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:03:46] Rob Russo: Hard to have hard to top.
[1:03:48] Jamie DuMont: Hard to top.
[1:03:49] Rob Russo: That is, you know, there's a you know, it's funny.
[1:03:53] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, you know, everybody, everybody goes on about the the the Tony race that year and how you know Bernadette Peters was robbed and whatnot, and you know, that's an argument I don't want to get yelled at um on Twitter about.
[1:04:05] Rob Russo: But Marissa Jarrett Winokur went out and won.
[1:04:08] Jamie DuMont: No, it was very team Marissa.
[1:04:10] Rob Russo: But that year, the actual race really, if for someone who was there, was really between Harvey and Antonio Banderas.
[1:04:18] Jamie DuMont: That was nine.
[1:04:19] Rob Russo: Yeah, that was really that was more the nail biter. I think anybody who was sort of in the know figured Marissa was gonna take it, right?
[1:04:26] Jamie DuMont: That was her year.
[1:04:27] Rob Russo: That was a nail biter.
[1:04:29] Jamie DuMont: And uh and I both gave great performances, but Harvey and Hairspray was just electric.
[1:04:33] Rob Russo: Well, that's the thing. You look back on it now and you think how and which is why I think people don't remember that or don't know it. You think, how could how could that be a race?
[1:04:43] Jamie DuMont: Harvey as Edna is iconic.
[1:04:45] Rob Russo: Yeah, but it was, and yes, it was one of those perfect, again, you know, perfect storm. The actor meets the moment.
[1:04:54] Jamie DuMont: The actor meets the moment, the actor meets the history of the piece.
[1:04:59] Rob Russo: Yes.
[1:04:59] Jamie DuMont: Right? With Divine originating the role.
[1:05:01] Rob Russo: Yes.
[1:05:02] Jamie DuMont: And Harvey sort of taking that baton forward.
[1:05:07] Rob Russo: Also, you know, Harvey brought a lot of his own humor to that.
[1:05:13] Jamie DuMont: Not only in just the words, but but more so in the inflection and the look.
[1:05:18] Rob Russo: Half of his performance was looks.
[1:05:20] Jamie DuMont: Right.
[1:05:21] Rob Russo: Which you don't get on a cast album.
[1:05:21] Jamie DuMont: On a cast album.
[1:05:25] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[1:05:26] Jamie DuMont: So that's that's Harvey One. And then what's the tie? What's the tie, Jamie?
[1:05:29] Rob Russo: Now it's my fiddler moment, right?
[1:05:32] Jamie DuMont: Harvey went in after Alfred Molina in David Leveaux's uh 2004 revival of Fiddler on the Roof.
[1:05:42] Rob Russo: Harvey went in uh for a year 2005 to 2006. I think he closed the show, but I could be wrong about that.
[1:05:48] Jamie DuMont: But it's a specific moment in that show. I mean, Harvey was wonderful as Tevye and very different and very unexpected, and all those things, and you know, but it was his Havala.
[1:06:02] Rob Russo: His performance of Havala, and you know, we love Harvey.
[1:06:05] Jamie DuMont: He's, you know, he's not John Wright, right?
[1:06:08] Rob Russo: He is well, he would be the first to say that.
[1:06:10] Jamie DuMont: He would be the first to say that.
[1:06:13] Rob Russo: But again, the way he acted that song, I'm getting like emotional thinking about it.
[1:06:20] Jamie DuMont: It was, and talk about, you know, a father, you know, if you just said, you know, seeing uh Death of a Salesman with your dad and just a parent and child moment.
[1:06:30] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[1:06:31] Jamie DuMont: You can't beat Havala and Fiddler in terms of those emotions.
[1:06:35] Rob Russo: And that's what's so brilliant about casting Harvey is he might seem like an unlikely choice at first, obviously, because he's not John Wright.
[1:06:42] Jamie DuMont: Um but but he's an actor.
[1:06:44] Rob Russo: He's an incredible actor.
[1:06:45] Jamie DuMont: And that and what more more importantly, those songs call for someone who can really act them.
[1:06:50] Rob Russo: Right.
[1:06:51] Jamie DuMont: And and boy, did he.
[1:06:52] Rob Russo: You know, this is a window into how gay I am. When when I went when I had my prom in in 2005, you know, all the other kids went out to the Hamptons or got a house in the Poconos or whatever and got drunk and probably had sex. I don't know.
[1:07:05] Jamie DuMont: Me and my friends went back to my parents' house.
[1:07:07] Rob Russo: We had a sleepover.
[1:07:08] Jamie DuMont: And then the next day we went into the city and saw Harvey Fierstein in Fiddler on the Roof.
[1:07:12] Rob Russo: And that was our prom celebration.
[1:07:15] Jamie DuMont: So there you go.
[1:07:16] Rob Russo: Nothing about that story surprises me.
[1:07:18] Jamie DuMont: I was probably in the audience that night.
[1:07:21] Rob Russo: I did see him many, many.
[1:07:23] Jamie DuMont: I took everyone I knew I took to see that.
[1:07:25] Rob Russo: So that's my Harvey tie.
[1:07:28] Jamie DuMont: And I am proud of it.
[1:07:29] Rob Russo: No, you should be proud of it.
[1:07:30] Jamie DuMont: I'm surprised.
[1:07:31] Rob Russo: Sticking with it.
[1:07:31] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:07:32] Rob Russo: Well, my number seven is a performer that no one could ever dispute belongs on.
[1:07:35] Jamie DuMont: This list or any list.
[1:07:37] Rob Russo: And that is Laurie Metcalf in uh A Doll's House, Part 2.
[1:07:41] Jamie DuMont: Which I I think I talked about this on our on our Best of the Decade too, because I I listed this play as one of my favorite of the decade.
[1:07:48] Rob Russo: Um, you know, uh it's a play that, you know, I I remember seeing the announcement and thinking, oh, that's the worst title of a play ever. A Doll's House, Part 2. Like, really, is that what we're doing?
[1:07:56] Jamie DuMont: Um, and man, was I wrong. I I walked into that theater knowing nothing, and 90 minutes later walked out with my head spinning because of the force of that performance in Lucas Hnath's brilliant, brilliant, brilliant play.
[1:08:11] Rob Russo: Um, if you saw it, you know exactly what I mean. If you didn't see it, you just know from me saying Laurie Metcalf.
[1:08:16] Jamie DuMont: Um, she won her first Tony uh after several nominations that year.
[1:08:20] Rob Russo: And then, you know, she was nominated in 2016, won in 2017, nominated in 2018, nominated in 2019. She probably would have been nominated in 2020 too if Virginia Woolf had been able to open. She's just an incredible, incredible, incredible, exhilarating performer to watch. She's one of those people you see on stage. This is so trite, and we say it all the time, but with her, we really mean it. Who is just is not acting, you know, like it's something else. There's another word that hasn't been invented yet to describe what she does on stage. And as we've learned from people who've, you know, who've worked with her and have talked about it, it is the result of an extraordinary training and craft and preparation.
You know, she walks into every rehearsal room fully off book and just ready to go, and every single moment of her performance is so calculated, such that it doesn't feel calculated. And I don't know how you do that. You have to be touched by the gods, and Laurie Metcalf certainly is. You have to be Laurie Metcalf.
[1:09:16] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, I have to be.
[1:09:17] Rob Russo: Would it be Metcalfing?
[1:09:18] Jamie DuMont: Uh sure. I'm happy with that. Let's start a trend here. Um yeah, no, Laurie Metcalf in Adult's House Part 2 is my number seven. Such a great, such a great moment of theater.
[1:09:30] Rob Russo: Oh my gosh. Such a great play. Uh-uh. And Julie White stepped into the play replacing her. And I have to say, you know, again, it's a testament to the strength of that text. She was fantastic. She really was great. Really fantastic. Very different. Very different.
[1:09:43] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, very different.
[1:09:44] Rob Russo: Very different. And um but equally uh uh as fabulous.
[1:09:48] Jamie DuMont: Yep.
[1:09:48] Rob Russo: Alrighty, number six. My number six is another incredibly talented actress.
[1:09:53] Jamie DuMont: For sure.
[1:09:53] Rob Russo: Um, and that would be Edie Falco in Inside Man. Uh huh. Uh, so much so that I can remember the date. It was March 11th, 1998.
[1:10:02] Jamie DuMont: Wow, so specific.
[1:10:03] Rob Russo: At the East 13th Street Theater, which is better known as Classic Stage Company. Ah, such a great space.
[1:10:08] Jamie DuMont: It's a show I worked on.
[1:10:11] Rob Russo: It's a sh probably my proudest moment to date.
[1:10:15] Jamie DuMont: You did work on a string of flops.
[1:10:16] Rob Russo: And this was a hit.
[1:10:17] Jamie DuMont: I worked on all flops.
[1:10:19] Rob Russo: This was a big hit. And oddly, Edie Falco did not open it on Broadway. She had gone, uh, she'd already shot the first season of um The Sopranos, and then it that that came out, and so she had to get and became got picked up, and so she had to leave the company and go do that.
[1:10:37] Jamie DuMont: Did that turn out well?
[1:10:39] Rob Russo: I don't remember.
[1:10:40] Jamie DuMont: Yes, it did.
[1:10:41] Rob Russo: And Wendy McKenna, speaking of Sister Act, um, which we talked about uh uh on our last episode, back in the habit with guest of the show, Cheryl Lee Ralph.
[1:10:41] Jamie DuMont: Guest of the show.
[1:10:51] Rob Russo: Uh Wendy McKenna took over, but and then Edie would come back in at some point in the run. I think when the show moved to the Golden Theater.
[1:10:58] Jamie DuMont: That's right.
[1:10:58] Rob Russo: I have a signed playbill. There is so I if you've ever been to Classic Stage, it's it's uh it's not a proscenium house typically. They typically have people seated either on either side or sort of in a three-quarter um thrust kind of situation.
[1:11:07] Jamie DuMont: Thrust kind of situation.
[1:11:15] Rob Russo: This was I think either side, and the actors played in the center. But and the set in that production was sort of sing songy, right? It was kind of all over the place. And there's a moment where she comes out from behind the house set, let's call it the apartment building set, and she's drunk and horrible and screaming, and she has this moment again where she's like just shouting and having this breakdown. And I had no idea who she was. I'd never heard of her before. I'd seen the show for the first time, and I'm gonna work on it, and it's going to Broadway, and uh all that stuff. And I stopped, my heart stopped, dead in my tracks, and I couldn't the animal sounds coming out of this woman and the raw emotion and the energy and the alcoholism and all of those, it just it just was like nothing I'd ever seen before.
[1:12:11] Jamie DuMont: Wow.
[1:12:12] Rob Russo: And of course, it did work out for her well.
[1:12:14] Jamie DuMont: It did work out.
[1:12:15] Rob Russo: It did work out.
[1:12:16] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:12:16] Rob Russo: But March 11th, 1998. Yeah, I remember the days.
[1:12:21] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:12:21] Rob Russo: Specifically.
[1:12:22] Jamie DuMont: And um cool.
[1:12:23] Rob Russo: Yeah, I don't know what else to say about it.
[1:12:25] Jamie DuMont: Sadly, you never saw it.
[1:12:26] Rob Russo: I never did.
[1:12:27] Jamie DuMont: No, I was in middle school.
[1:12:28] Rob Russo: Yeah. Great show. Probably not appropriate for middle.
[1:12:32] Jamie DuMont: But I'll tell you this. Um we had to do current events, you know, in in social studies class. And I remember when Sideman closed, I I was always pushing the boundaries with my teachers to see like how much theater could I force into this math class, you know, and uh or science class or whatever. And I wrote a I wrote my current event that week about Sideman closing on Broadway. Um and I remember getting a very nice note from my teacher which said, you know, this was this was very nice. You did a good job, but let's let's stick more to national news, news of national importance. And I pushed back a little. I was saying, this is of national importance. This is a great American play that's closing too soon on Broadway.
[1:13:06] Rob Russo: See, this is why we're friends.
[1:13:07] Jamie DuMont: This is why we're business partners.
[1:13:09] Rob Russo: It made my seventh grade current events.
[1:13:11] Jamie DuMont: I I love that story. It it reminds me of when in German class I had to do a report on Germany, and I chose Liza Minnelli and Cabaret.
[1:13:19] Rob Russo: Totally.
[1:13:19] Jamie DuMont: Because that's I mean, that reads Germany.
[1:13:22] Rob Russo: It certainly, certainly. Uh we were passionate about the about the subject matter, which is what's most important.
[1:13:27] Jamie DuMont: Yes.
[1:13:27] Rob Russo: Um well, my number six uh is James Corden in One Man, Two Governors, which I saw on June 15th, 2012. I had to look that one up, but it was, and the reason I remember it is because it was right after the Tony Awards. He had just won the Tony. And I bought tickets the day after the Tony Awards. I thought, okay, this guy just won. I don't know who he is, what this play is about, but I'll go. I was living in DC at the time. I came up to New York with a friend of mine. We settled into the music box theater, I believe. Um, and boy did we have the time of our lives. I, to this day, I don't recall ever laughing as much and as hard as I did in that production. And every member of that ensemble was brilliant.
But watching James Corden, who, you know, I hadn't seen The History Boys, he was not someone I had ever seen or heard of before. So to me, you I was watching him become a star. And I think that is that's kind of true if you look at his career trajectory. This is the thing that really catapulted him to the next level.
[1:14:22] Jamie DuMont: Absolutely.
[1:14:22] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[1:14:22] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:14:23] Rob Russo: He had done it at the National Theatre in the UK. Um he got a bit of attention with The History Boys. I mean, that's that's not stuff. But this was catastrophic.
[1:14:32] Jamie DuMont: Oh my god.
[1:14:33] Rob Russo: That's that's the right word. Catastrophic.
[1:14:34] Jamie DuMont: That sounds bad.
[1:14:35] Rob Russo: Negative, yeah. This was uh this was stratospheric.
[1:14:39] Jamie DuMont: Thank you. That's what I was huge.
[1:14:41] Rob Russo: Yeah. That's what I meant to say. Uh the The Guardian called it a triumph of visual and verbal comedy. And I don't know how to top that review. It's pithy and right on on point. He was absolutely hysterical. And if you don't know the show, it's you know, it's like a comedia dell'arte style farce of an Italian play that was uh from the 18th century that was, you know, uh reinterpolated into uh 1960s Brighton in the UK. And um, he was just absolutely hysterical. And you know, it's funny, uh, number uh uh uh eight for me on this list was Philip Seymour Hoffman in Death of a Salesman. And he and and James Corden were up for the Tony that year, and James Corden won. And I think that was a bit of a like, you know, someone winning for a comedy role over, you know, Philip Seymour Hoffman, one of the great actors of our generation, you know, playing Willie Lohman and yet, you know, this this British dude won won one for this comedy.
And I walked in with a little bit of a like, okay, proved to me that you, you know, you deserve this, because I had seen Philip Seymour Hoffman earlier that season. And man, he earned every ounce of that Tony. He was so, so so, so good. And I just lament that his Pseudolus in a funny thing happened on the way to the forum, the Alex Timbers revival was canceled because he uh he booked the late late show. Um, and alas, we were denied that. But maybe someday we'll get his Pseudolus, because I think he'd be a great Pseudolus.
[1:15:53] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, and I think he could do it at any age, right? I mean he probably won't do that television show for the rest of his life.
[1:15:59] Rob Russo: I mean he might, but Carson did it for a while.
[1:16:01] Jamie DuMont: That's true.
[1:16:02] Rob Russo: Um, but that's my number six, James Corden.
[1:16:04] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:16:05] Rob Russo: A lot of fellas on your list.
[1:16:06] Jamie DuMont: A lot of fellas.
[1:16:07] Rob Russo: My list is proudly all ladies.
[1:16:10] Jamie DuMont: Well, speaking of number five.
[1:16:13] Rob Russo: Number five, quite a lady.
[1:16:14] Jamie DuMont: I feel like I'm saying this about every all my ladies, including Harvey, by the way. I would literally watch this next actress do anything. Anything. Anything. Anything. And uh, but what I chose is my number five, Donna Murphy in Anyone Can Whistle. Uh, which to this day, it's the only Sondheim show I've never seen.
[1:16:35] Rob Russo: Well, we I think we've talked about this.
[1:16:38] Jamie DuMont: The the two memorable things about that production.
[1:16:41] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[1:16:41] Jamie DuMont: City Center.
[1:16:42] Rob Russo: City Center at Encores.
[1:16:44] Jamie DuMont: Yeah. Donna Murphy, the most memorable thing. I mean, this is this is a thing that I I think about this a lot, right? And I talk about this a lot. But also the fact that Encores did sort of a concert version of it. Right. It solved a lot of the problems of the show.
[1:17:00] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[1:17:01] Jamie DuMont: Because I I I believe they took out a fair amount of the book.
[1:17:04] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[1:17:04] Jamie DuMont: Which is the problematic thing people say. So it was like a perfect evening in the theater. But again, nobody really saw Angela Lansbury's Cora Hooper, right? Because it ran nine performances.
[1:17:20] Rob Russo: Exactly.
[1:17:20] Jamie DuMont: But everybody knows that album and everybody has an idea of what right, what she did with that part. But we got to see Donna Murphy actually live it.
[1:17:30] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[1:17:31] Jamie DuMont: Actualize that part. Be that. And it's it's everything that Donna Murphy is so perfect at.
[1:17:38] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[1:17:39] Jamie DuMont: She's a song and dance gal. She's a star. She's a diva, and I mean that in the best sense of the word. Like somebody who commands the stage, right? And and and all of that.
[1:17:50] Rob Russo: Absolutely.
[1:17:50] Jamie DuMont: She had a crazy wig on. She had super high heels. She had a gorgeous, what looked like a sort of Chanel suit on. And then she just did her thing.
[1:18:01] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[1:18:01] Jamie DuMont: I don't want to say she chewed up the scenery because again, that sounds negative, but she just she held every single audience member in the palm of her hand for two and a half hours.
[1:18:10] Rob Russo: As only she can.
[1:18:11] Jamie DuMont: As only she can. I've said this before. I went to the Thursday night and I went back and saw every single performance. Um I actually went with Joel Grey for the first night.
[1:18:20] Rob Russo: Guest of the show.
[1:18:21] Jamie DuMont: Guest of the show. I feel very fortunate that I was able to see that.
[1:18:25] Rob Russo: You should, because I think there was probably a lot of people listening who are shaking their fists saying, ah, Jamie, I wish I could have seen that.
[1:18:31] Jamie DuMont: I'm one of them.
[1:18:31] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[1:18:32] Jamie DuMont: We're recording it live. But um yeah, no, I I wish there was a recording of that. I do. I wish that's one they had recorded.
[1:18:41] Rob Russo: It really should have been.
[1:18:42] Jamie DuMont: It should have transferred. I think it would have, I actually think it would have gone.
[1:18:46] Rob Russo: Oh, I mean, that would have been amazing, right?
[1:18:47] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:18:48] Rob Russo: Would have been amazing. Or or to your point, recorded it. There is a tiny bit of it on YouTube. I have watched that.
[1:18:53] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, I've watched that.
[1:18:54] Rob Russo: Shaky mezzanine handheld something or other. I consider myself a devotee.
[1:19:00] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:19:01] Rob Russo: Of Ms. Murphy, guest of the show.
[1:19:03] Jamie DuMont: Guest of the show. Guest of the show.
[1:19:04] Rob Russo: So I have watched that one clip. So thank you for that privilege.
[1:19:08] Jamie DuMont: Yes.
[1:19:08] Rob Russo: And thank you for that performance.
[1:19:10] Jamie DuMont: Yes. Also, shout out to City Center Encores.
[1:19:13] Rob Russo: Yeah. I can't wait for the upcoming season.
[1:19:15] Jamie DuMont: I can't wait for every season I love. It's such a special program.
[1:19:20] Rob Russo: Did you sing?
[1:19:22] Jamie DuMont: It was a parade in time.
[1:19:36] Rob Russo: Have my best and my honor song.
[1:19:42] Jamie DuMont: When I was getting ready.
[1:20:11] Rob Russo: No, but not really. It all makes sense, really, when you think about it. And what was amazing about this, I know John Benjamin Hickey won the Tony, guest of the show.
[1:20:15] Jamie DuMont: Guest of the show.
[1:20:21] Rob Russo: And he was superb. It was an it was a superb ensemble. That production was divine. It's one of the great plays of all time. It was my number one of the decade when we did our countdown. So uh need I say more, but Joe Mantello, it was such a privilege to see him perform because this was his return to Broadway after a 17-year hiatus. The last time he had been on Broadway was as Lewis, was as Lewis Ironson in Angels in America, part two, you know, perestroika. And here he was playing Ned Weeks, right? The one of the other great Titanic, you know, gay male roles in in Broadway history or in theater history, because this this was the play making its Broadway debut. Um, and you know, he's sort of playing uh a version of Larry Kramer, and it will always haunt me.
I mean, the the anger, the righteous rage uh coiled up in that character. I said this before, I I couldn't get up when the play ended. The ushers had to shoot me out, and then I just wept down Eighth Avenue walking back to Penn Station. You know, it it was a highlight in a lifetime of theater going. I know Mark Rylance won the Tony that year for Jerusalem, which I didn't see. And I know people say, you know, Mark Rylance was amazing, and that play was amazing and one of the great performances of all time. Because I didn't see it, Joe Mantello uh earns that spot on my list. Just incredible.
[1:21:34] Jamie DuMont: What a career.
[1:21:35] Rob Russo: What a career.
[1:21:36] Jamie DuMont: What a career.
[1:21:36] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[1:21:37] Jamie DuMont: As an actor, as a director.
[1:21:38] Rob Russo: He does it all.
[1:21:39] Jamie DuMont: He really does.
[1:21:40] Rob Russo: Speaking of amazing careers, number four.
[1:21:42] Jamie DuMont: Well, this will come as both of our number fours.
[1:21:44] Rob Russo: Both of our number fours are kind of epic.
[1:21:47] Jamie DuMont: Um and they go hand in hand.
[1:21:51] Rob Russo: Um I also think it's really funny that we both can cite the dates of many of these performances.
[1:21:58] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, I feel like Rick Ellis, guest of the show.
[1:22:00] Rob Russo: Right, which is I have to be honest about this, which is not a function of the Google machine. I mean, this is this is although we both use Google, of course. This is actually just who we are. So damaged people, damaged people.
[1:22:13] Jamie DuMont: But speak for yourself.
[1:22:14] Rob Russo: Number four.
[1:22:15] Betty Buckley, Carnegie Hall. I have said this before. Uh June 10th, 1996. Betty Buckley gave one of the greatest evenings I've ever had in my life as an as a human being, as an audience member. She gave a concert at Carnegie Hall. It was a benefit for Broadway Keris Equity Fights AIDS. The tickets, I believe at the time were extraordinarily expensive. I was happy to pay it. Andrew Gans of Playbill wrote at the time, the evening surpassed the expectation of the greatest Betty Buckley fans.
[1:22:48] Jamie DuMont: Of which you are.
[1:22:49] Rob Russo: Of course. Me too. The entire. Oh, Joan Rivers and Donna Murphy, guest of the show, were both in attendance that evening. Your boss's husband, former president Bill Clinton, wrote a letter to Betty that got printed in the news outlets where he said, Hillary and I extend our best wishes for a wonderful concert.
[1:23:11] Jamie DuMont: So lovely.
[1:23:12] Rob Russo: But as much as the entire concert, and it was recorded, we've talked about it with Betty. You know, you can listen to it. You can actually hear me. When when the music starts for uh as if we never said goodbye, you can hear someone go, whoop, that's me. I was a residual for that. I don't. I don't, but those that know me and know my whoop can pick it out on the album.
[1:23:34] Jamie DuMont: I do.
[1:23:35] Rob Russo: But what I do want to say is that as much of all of that is a collective, like best of, yeah, it really was the carry stuff, which we talked to Betty about. It was Eve was week that unfortunately didn't make the album because of a technical thing.
[1:23:50] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:23:50] Rob Russo: That was thrilling.
[1:23:52] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:23:52] Rob Russo: Really highlight of my life in terms of, and you know, I don't think we knew that Lindsay was gonna come out. I think the whole audience went crazy because we knew it was gonna come. Um, Betty's talked about what an extraordinary experience that was.
[1:24:06] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, and again, I have to say thank you to Betty Buckley for literally everything. For everything she's for every performance she's ever given and the generous amount of time she's given to us in the show. But that concert, and I'm not alone in saying this was a was a truly extraordinary evening.
[1:24:50] Rob Russo: You mean the god it's ain't and boys, I got it.
[1:25:01] Jamie DuMont: Well, I got it.
[1:25:06] Rob Russo: Some people got it and make it pay. Some people can't even give it away. This people's got it, and this people's spreading it around.
[1:25:28] Jamie DuMont: Well, my number four is Patty Lapone in Gypsy. Um I was living in DC at the time. I managed to have a free afternoon. I caught a matinee in August 2008. Um, and it was my first time seeing Gypsy.
[1:25:40] Rob Russo: You know, that shocks me.
[1:25:44] Jamie DuMont: Yeah. For some reason, Gypsy had always evaded me.
[1:25:46] Rob Russo: Um were you not gay up until that point?
[1:25:48] Jamie DuMont: Well, I I think prior testimony would would suggest otherwise.
[1:25:52] Rob Russo: Okay.
[1:25:53] Jamie DuMont: Uh see my my seventh grade current events.
[1:25:56] Rob Russo: Um true.
[1:25:57] Jamie DuMont: But I sat in the in the mezzanine of the St. James and was just mesmerized. I mean, I loved every minute, obviously that she was on stage, and it was, you know, um just a perfect marriage of character and and performer. But we got to Rose's turn, and that was unlike anything I I had really ever experienced in a theater.
[1:26:14] Rob Russo: I'd never seen someone do that.
[1:26:16] Jamie DuMont: Again, what whatever word there is, there isn't a word to describe what it is that she did in that in that song. Um but Patty the Pone was born to play Rose.
[1:26:25] Rob Russo: Oh, um if nothing else.
[1:26:29] Jamie DuMont: Right, and it almost feels like it was that, you know, her performance was in a way discounted because of that, right? Because of course she's gonna be brilliant in it. Of course she's perfect as a part, you know, but you know, when you're expected to be good, I think you have to work that much harder, right? And she just cr absolutely crushed it.
[1:26:46] Rob Russo: It was it was extraordinary. I I will never forget the feeling I had walking out of that theater. Like I've just witnessed something that is very special and that I'll be talking about for the rest of my life. And lo and behold, you know, all these years later, here I am on a podcast memorializing it. But patty the pone and everything, but that's the one, you know, that really that really stays with me.
[1:27:04] Rob Russo: Well, someone tell me, when is it my turn?
[1:27:07] Jamie DuMont: Don't I get a dream for myself?
[1:27:09] Rob Russo: Starting now, it's gonna be my turn.
[1:27:11] Jamie DuMont: Get way well, get off of my runway.
[1:27:13] Rob Russo: Starting now, I not a thousand this time, boys.
[1:27:16] Jamie DuMont: I'm taking a thousand.
[1:27:20] Rob Russo: Everything's coming up for everything's coming up, roses coming up, roses.
[1:27:57] Jamie DuMont: We're rounded down here.
[1:27:59] Rob Russo: Number three.
[1:28:00] Jamie DuMont: Number three. Well, I share many things with Kritzer. Um, and uh my number three I share with her, and that is Amy Morton in August Osage County.
[1:28:09] Rob Russo: Oh my God.
[1:28:10] Jamie DuMont: I you know, I'm not alone in saying that the the end of the second act where she shouts that immortal line, I'm running things now, and there's a blackout.
[1:28:23] Rob Russo: I watched it this morning.
[1:28:24] Jamie DuMont: I the the the it's on YouTube, shocked to no one. Uh so I watched it several times, uh and it I had the same reaction I did the first time I saw it, the second time I saw it, the third time I saw it. It's it's a great line, it's a great moment in theater, but it's all about her.
[1:28:41] Rob Russo: And I saw Joanna Day, who was fabulous.
[1:28:44] Jamie DuMont: She was spectacular. I love Johanna Day. She, I mean that I mean uh sweat, hello, I can't even go there. What a great performance.
[1:28:52] Rob Russo: But oh my god, Amy Morton, and throughout the whole thing, they eat the fucking fish, all of it.
[1:29:00] Jamie DuMont: Like fucking fish. Everything about her and that role and how beautifully it's written and how she just lives in that so perfectly. I saw her Martha in Virginia Wolf, which was which came close to making my list.
[1:29:14] Rob Russo: And then I was like, well, what do I do with with what do I do with all the other Martha's that I've seen, right?
[1:29:20] Jamie DuMont: I can't, I so I just had to leave it off. Um, but I but I I can't talk about Amy Morton without also talking about her incredible uh Virginia Wolf.
[1:29:28] Rob Russo: But um, so that's it. You know, she said something which I really loved about um doing that play. She said it's emotionally and physically crunchy.
[1:29:40] Jamie DuMont: Help me in the kitchen.
[1:29:41] Rob Russo: Bill, take I need Gene upstairs. You remember how to do this?
[1:29:45] Jamie DuMont: Yes.
[1:29:47] Rob Russo: Everything. Go through everything. Every drawer, every counter, every shoebox. Nothing's too personal. Anything even looks suspicious, you throw it in a box and we sort it out later. You understand?
[1:29:57] Jamie DuMont: What should we do?
[1:30:00] Rob Russo: Get mom some black coffee and a wet towel and listen to her bullshit.
[1:30:04] Jamie DuMont: Karen called up to work.
[1:30:07] Rob Russo: What do you want me to say?
[1:30:08] Jamie DuMont: Tell them we got a sick woman here.
[1:30:09] Rob Russo: You can't give me it!
[1:30:12] Jamie DuMont: You don't get it here.
[1:30:15] Rob Russo: Thanks.
[1:30:22] Jamie DuMont: That character, I mean, the way she just flips back and forth between, you know, just absolutely tearing into people, right?
[1:30:30] Rob Russo: But then also like being so wounded.
[1:30:32] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:30:32] Rob Russo: And oh my gosh. I mean, Tracy Lett's uh as an actor, as a as a writer, is just is it stunning, absolutely stunning. And that play, I think, you know, we'll see what else he writes in his career.
[1:30:43] Jamie DuMont: He's still turning them out, but that I think will will always be his Magnum opus.
[1:30:47] Rob Russo: I mean, that was an extraordinary play. I saw it several times. I saw it in DC. Every time I I had the opportunity to see it, I saw it because and you know, it was what three and a half hours, three hours and forty-five minutes.
[1:30:56] Jamie DuMont: Flew by.
[1:30:57] Rob Russo: Flew flew by it finished, and you wanted to start over again.
[1:31:00] Jamie DuMont: Well, you know me.
[1:31:01] Rob Russo: I want 90 minutes, no intermission, or I want three acts and three hours.
[1:31:05] Jamie DuMont: You want an August Osage County?
[1:31:06] Rob Russo: I I love that play so much. I watched the film repeatedly.
[1:31:09] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, I saw the film, you know.
[1:31:11] Rob Russo: Yeah, yeah.
[1:31:11] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:31:12] Rob Russo: We'll leave it at that.
[1:31:13] Jamie DuMont: Um, but my number three um is someone we've already talked about.
[1:31:18] Rob Russo: Yes, it is.
[1:31:19] Jamie DuMont: Guest of the show, Donna Murphy in Hello Dolly. I, you know, I saw her first performance in June 2017 when she I was there as well.
[1:31:28] Rob Russo: Yes, when she started doing uh the Tuesdays uh at the Schubert, um, which became a bit of a ritual in my life during that time.
[1:31:36] Jamie DuMont: Um, you know, again, perfect marriage of actor and role. She was absolutely sublime as Dolly Levi for all the reasons that she was sublime and anyone can whistle.
[1:31:48] Rob Russo: Um, that perfect integration of acting chops of uh voice, unlike literally anyone else.
[1:31:56] Jamie DuMont: Um and she could dance, you know, she'd have some moves. You know, she was born to play the part, and it was brilliant to cast her, you know, since they had this, you know, the slot to do Tuesday nights.
[1:32:08] Rob Russo: Um, and she was amazing.
[1:32:10] Jamie DuMont: She was absolutely incredible. What I loved about it, and I loved all the women who played the part, I have to say. Obviously, Bet Midler was was uh unbelievable.
[1:32:18] Rob Russo: Um Bernard Peters, you know, invented stairs.
[1:32:21] Jamie DuMont: Um, and you know, we got to see Betty Buckley on tour uh and Carolie Carmelo on tour. We interviewed both of them, and you can go listen to those interviews, they were really wonderful.
[1:32:29] Rob Russo: And each, obviously, as every woman who's ever played the role brings something to it.
[1:32:33] Jamie DuMont: But there was something for me that will just always be so special about Donna Murphy playing that part, especially because I had seen it in after seeing the part played by Bet Midler.
[1:32:40] Rob Russo: And what was so special about it is that in a way, Donna allowed every other member of that company to shine alongside her.
[1:32:48] Jamie DuMont: In a way that was so generous. There was such a generosity in her performance and a playfulness and a joy and a comfortability.
[1:32:57] Rob Russo: I mean, what she was doing was really hard. She was stepping into a show once a week, just picking it up out of nowhere and giving a five-star performance.
[1:33:06] Jamie DuMont: And then, you know, going back into hibernation, you know, for for another week, right?
[1:33:10] Rob Russo: And then she did later on in the run get to do some longer engagements, uh, which believe me, I I checked into.
[1:33:16] Jamie DuMont: Um, so Donna Murphy, uh she's one of my all-time, you know, uh uh favorite performers. I see her do anything.
[1:33:22] Rob Russo: And I have to close this Donna Murphy Love Fest by also just saying, without sounding dramatic, which too late, you know, thinking about the time, the climate in which this show happened, 2017, obviously the early days of the Trump administration, just a really awful time uh for our country, uh kicking off what would be four really awful years.
[1:33:42] Jamie DuMont: And the world was sort of chaos and nothing made sense.
[1:33:45] Rob Russo: And it was like, are we living in an alternate reality? Hillary Clinton's supposed to be president right now. Like, what is going on? We're we're living in the upside down. Nothing made sense, but in that world of chaos, you knew that on Tuesday night you could get a ticket to see Donna Murphy and Hello Dolly, and suddenly everything made sense, right?
[1:34:02] Jamie DuMont: And and that show and her performance in particular were sort of, you know, the solve that got me through uh personally, you know, an emotionally very, very difficult time for me.
[1:34:12] Rob Russo: And I know it was a difficult time for a lot of people.
[1:34:14] Jamie DuMont: Show couldn't have arrived at a better moment. Her performance couldn't have been more perfect. She's my number three, Donna Murphy.
[1:34:21] Rob Russo: I love the word generous about her performance because that's exactly what it was.
[1:34:26] Jamie DuMont: And always is.
[1:34:27] Rob Russo: And yeah, and I was gonna say, and what she is.
[1:34:30] Jamie DuMont: And I I hope I have to imagine that she's having as much fun on that stage as it seems like she is.
[1:34:40] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[1:34:41] Jamie DuMont: Because again, she's one of those performers, she's one of those actors that you can just see the love they have for their craft and for what they do.
[1:34:49] Rob Russo: And for the people that they share the stage with.
[1:34:51] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:34:52] Rob Russo: And that doesn't always, you don't always see that.
[1:34:54] Jamie DuMont: Well, you know, there's nothing more special than seeing someone do what they were meant to do. And when you see Donna Murphy on stage, you know that, and I, you know, I I hope she wouldn't be offended by this, but there's nothing else that she should be doing other than this.
[1:35:06] Rob Russo: Right.
[1:35:07] Jamie DuMont: You know, it's just like someone has found their calling and they are just thriving.
[1:35:12] Rob Russo: And it's so beautiful to witness.
[1:35:14] Jamie DuMont: Uh we love you, Donna.
[1:35:15] Rob Russo: You've she's been such a champion for the show.
[1:35:17] Jamie DuMont: She has.
[1:35:18] Rob Russo: Um, such a good friend to us.
[1:35:20] Jamie DuMont: Um, and um I can't say enough about Donna Murphy's.
[1:35:23] Rob Russo: And I think I said this when he we interviewed her.
[1:35:25] Jamie DuMont: I love her so much that I saw the Star Trek movie that I've no relationship to Star Wars, I'd never seen Star Trek.
[1:35:33] Rob Russo: Yeah, and right, because I watched it.
[1:35:34] Jamie DuMont: You wanted to prepare.
[1:35:35] Rob Russo: Right. No, I saw it when it came out because she was in it.
[1:35:39] Jamie DuMont: Right, of course. And that then I discovered that, oh, that you know, I look I watched a lot of those Star Trek films because they're quite good. Yeah, I didn't I had no idea there was a Star Trek never let's I was a trekkie, right? So I I don't know if I said this to her, but Donna Murphy made me a trekkie. So thanks for that. Okay, among all the things. Among all the things. Okay, number two. We're getting there, people. We're close. Thank you for bearing with us. Yes. We have a lot to say. Lynn Redgrave, Le Laison d'Angel Ruse at the Amundsen Theater in 1988. Oh, okay. Changed my life. Was this a tour or something? No, this is a no, this was a production. The in those days, the Omnisch, Center Theater Group, uh uh Bobby Fryer, Mr. Fryer, as my husband would call him.
My husband's first boss was was Robert Fryer, the theater producer of May and Sweet Charity, and just name a show. Yeah, some credit. Sweeney Todd. Yeah, some credit. But um, yeah, in those days they did some very star-driven um original, not original productions, but but productions. This might have been LA's version of the original Broadway, but with a different cast. I I don't quite remember. It was um Lynn Redgrave and Frank Langella and Kathleen Quinlan, and it was a great cast, but it was Lynn Redgrave. I mean, I knew her, right? I I I'd watched House Calls, her TV show. I knew, you know, I knew who she was. Yeah. The great privilege for me with Lynn Redgrave is that she would, a few years later, I would work on a show with her, and then she would become a lifelong friend.
She and my husband became very close. And um, particularly the last 15 years of her life. We were very close with Lynn. Um, and it was a huge privilege and honor to be a friend of hers. She's a was a lovely, wonderful human being, and I miss her very, very much. And and she was the one who introduced me to the term Dr. Theater because when she got sick with cancer and she was very, very ill, she did an Alan Bennett play called Talking Heads, and it saved her life. It extended her life significantly being in that play. But her performance, there's a moment I ran, I was way in I was in a college student. Yeah, and I was at the back of the balcony, I could barely see, but I remember there's a moment in the play, and I I can't I'm not gonna do it justice, but you're not Lynn Redgrave, no. I'm not Lynn Redgrave, but her character is, you know, this this she's a manipulator and she's a puppet master, and she's you know, she's got everybody doing what she wants them to do.
And there's a thing where she realizes that she's been double crossed by the Frank Langella character. And a spotlight hits her, and she just shouts war. That's typically how it's done. But she just whispered it. And I remember being in the back of that balcony, and I could hear it clearly. And it was the first time I was like, what? What did she just do? She's how can I hear her whispering? Yeah. And I'll never forget it. I've talked to her about it. I've she has great stories, none of which I can share with you today about doing that show and working with the incredible Frank Langella. Yeah. Quite a character. And uh, but there was that moment, that whisper that just hit my soul of like, what is that?
Yeah. Well, we love a choice. Yeah, right. Especially when it's the unexpected choice. Yeah and and someone of that caliber, Lynn Redgrave, pulls it off, right? Yeah. Wow. That sounds magical. It was. One of a kind she was. Yeah. Amazing. Well, my number two is my tie. Um, it's not a it's not a um is this a tie? It's a tie. Well, you know, some might argue that it's not. It's it's my my Bialystock and Bloom tie. And that is Nathan Lane and Matthew Broderick in The Producers uh in 2001. Um I feel like I don't need to say anything more than that, right? It was such uh an iconic historic moment in the American musical theater. Um, you know, these two stepping into the shoes of Zero Mostel and Gene Wilder in those parts um for this this musical version, you know, it's easy to to say now, well, of course it was a hit, of course they were fabulous, but in April 2001, nothing was guaranteed, right?
And I will never forget seeing I saw it as soon as we could get tickets was July. So and we we got them right away, you know, because my parents were you know big fans, obviously, of the film, and you know, um, and we went and we sat in the mezzanine of the St. James again. Um, and just the the alchemy of their performance, the the synergy of that duo and that original cast, really. I mean, if I can stretch my tie to be really that entire, that entire cast, uh, you know, Roger Bart and Gary Beach and Katie Huffman. I mean, just an iconic, iconic original cast, one of the most iconic original casts, I think, of any Broadway musical. Absolutely. So much so that I, you know, I think it was hard to replace all of them.
And the show, you know, didn't run as long as it probably you would have thought it would have in 2001. Although I gotta say, Angie Schwarr was fantastic. She she brought that Zaz. Um, but yes, I mean, 15 Tony nominations, 12 wins. It still holds that record, you know, for most wins in history. And it won every category that was nominated in, was nominated for 50 for 15, but it couldn't win 15 because there were multiple nominations in the acting categories, including Nathan Lane and Matthew Broderick both being nominated. It was just pure magic. I mean, Nathan Lane in particular, his number betrayed in Act Two, uh, tour de force, of course. But I will never forget when I when we saw it, um, you know, talking about generosity, right?
And seeing someone, you know, having fun on stage and just living in the moment in act at some point during the show, I don't remember when, they messed up. And and Matthew Broderick said Nathan Lane's line, and he completely broke character and said, That's my line. And then they both just lost it on stage. It's like SNL, you know, when the when the when the actors break during a scene. There's nothing funnier than watching someone trying to, you know, choke back their laughter. It's like church giggles, right? When you know when you can't laugh, of course, all you want to do is laugh. And the two of them, you know, uh uh broke, the audience went nuts, you know, and then they resumed, right?
And and that ability to break the fourth wall, you know, to pull us out of the moment, but simultaneously hold us in the moment, is such a rare ability that you know only could exist in the theater with that transfer of energy, and you're all in the moment together, um, and you have these two performers at the top of their caliber playing the roles that they were meant to play, just absolutely crushing it in the biggest hit Broadway had seen in you know in years. Um it was incredible. You know, I you knew you were witnessing history as it was happening, and and those don't come along, you know, as much as I know we've said that multiple times, it's because these are you know 15 and a lifetime of theater going.
Um, you know, I don't know who could do it better. Someday we'll get a revival, I just know it. Um I wouldn't mind paying to see Ben Platt and Will Roland do do the show in about 15 years. I think you know it's funny. It would be a good pairing. When you said maybe there'll be a revival, I thought, well, there'll be a revival when there are two people like who could do it. Yeah, Nathan Lane and Matthew Broderick that can do it. And maybe the maybe they could. Yeah, yeah, right. I love that. Oh, but that's my that's my producer's tie. It'll always be just one of the most magical nights I have. You love that show. I love that show. Just like Julius Caesar, who wants betrayed by Brutus, only can account who turn out to be my Judas. I'm so dismayed. Is this how I'm revealed to be trained?
[1:43:13] Jamie DuMont: Before we get to our number ones, yes, let's hear from our number one, our first guest, Joel Gray.
[1:43:20] Joel Gray: Hi, I'm Joel Gray, and uh I want to talk about the most exciting performer of that I s have seen in the past few years. Of course, I'm not the only one. She was highly celebrated and deservedly so Cynthia Erivo, an unusual and beautiful talent in The Color Purple.
[1:43:55] Donna Murphy: I'll never forget it. Hi, it's Donna Murphy. And I will try to say this as quickly as possible. I would have to say the original Broadway production of Sunday in the Park with George, starring the brilliant Bernadette Peters and incomparable Mandy Patinkin, written by the geniuses Stephen Sondheim and James Lapine, who also directed. So this was a moment when I was seriously considering leaving the business as I just didn't seem to fit into certain kinds of casting boxes. And my late husband Sean surprised me with these tickets. I think it was an especially emotionally charged performance as it was what was thought to be Mandy's last performance. He was leaving to work on a film project. And the show just spoke to me in a profound way.
Robert Westenberg, who would be taking over the role of George, and everyone on stage and in the audience just fell apart. It was beyond moving to watch this phenomenal family of artists tell the story of artists and art and humans finding their ways to connect. And it powerfully delivered the message to me that I had to keep trying to do what I believed I was meant to do. It's still an important touchstone for me to this very day.
[1:46:14] Jamie DuMont: Alrighty, number one.
[1:46:26] Rob Russo: Well, here's my gypsy moment.
[1:46:28] Jamie DuMont: Yes, I have a gypsy moment too.
[1:46:30] Rob Russo: Well, I am.
[1:46:32] Jamie DuMont: Which lady will it be, though?
[1:46:34] Rob Russo: I am a thriving gay man. Drum roll. Tyne Daly, June 6th, 1989. The Dorothy Chandler Pavilion. Wow. Uh, it was a pre-Broadway tour.
[1:46:47] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, it was this pre-Broadway.
[1:46:50] Rob Russo: Produced by Barry and Fran Weisler and Barry Brown.
[1:46:55] Jamie DuMont: Guest of the show.
[1:46:56] Rob Russo: Guest of the show. Rob loves a guest of a show. And um, I love this actually that uh Barry Brown had the idea for casting Tyne Daly. Wait for it. Do you know this?
[1:47:05] Jamie DuMont: No.
[1:47:06] Rob Russo: After seeing her sing on a Dolly Parton TV special.
[1:47:10] Jamie DuMont: Really?
[1:47:11] Rob Russo: Yeah. I mean, thank you, Dolly. Yeah. So here's the thing. Um, it was recorded, and again, Tyne Daly will admittedly, you know, she's not a singer. She is can carry a tune, but she doesn't have the quality of like a Patti LuPone.
[1:47:26] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, Donna Murphy or Betty Buckley, yeah.
[1:47:28] Rob Russo: Or any of the other wonderful women who have have played Rose. Yeah. But she was scary, and she was lovable, and she was funny and she was fearless and ferocious. And it was one of those performances that in the theater I've never seen anything like that. And I don't think I ever will see anything like that. And I had the great privilege of, you know, at that time, Tyne Daly was very famous for being on a television show called Cagney and Lacey. It was a very, very popular TV show on CBS, which was famous for getting canceled, and then the fans, including Jamie DuMont, wrote a letter to the studio to CBS, and the fans brought the show back. They brought it back and um and it became very, very successful.
At any rate, she was she was a big TV star. So this is another like big gamble on Barry Brown's part. And uh I the night I saw it, Sharon Gless, her Cagney, Cagney and Lacey sat behind us and was very vocal, cheering her on. So it was this added crazy dimension of seeing this woman on stage who I idolized because I was a big fan of Cagney and Lacey, as I just said, and then the other actor cheering her on, and it was this great moment of because you know, uh I don't know if you know this, but Gypsy's a showbiz story. Yeah, right. So there was this wonderful art mirroring life. But so that's it. You know, Gypsy is gypsy. I mean, it's it's it's iconic in so many ways. And this was a production that was directed by Arthur Lawrence. And it was a big gamble. And Tyne Daly was magnificent.
[1:49:38] Rob Russo: Well, my number one is Tanya Pinkins in Caroline, or Change. I was very fortunate to see it on Mother's Day, 2004. And that's quite a show to see on Mother's Day. It's one of my favorite musicals, if not my favorite musical. Janine Tesori, guest of the show, and Tony Kushner wrote this masterpiece in 2003 at the Public Theater and came to Broadway. Short-lived, but Tanya Pinkins gave one of the all-time great performances of musical theater, certainly my number one. I will never forget the experience of seeing her bring that character, Caroline Thibodeau, to life in the basement of that house in Lake Charles, Louisiana. It's such a poignant story. It's such a heartbreaking story. This character, this woman, what she's been through and what she's experiencing.
The way she expressed the interiority of that character, who is a very closed-off person. You know, there's a contradiction there. How you bring out the emotional life, the inner life of a character who really isn't able to express all that she's feeling, to coil that, you know, is such a feat. And I think that that's a through line of a lot of these performances that we've talked about. You know, actors who've managed to capture the contradiction of being a human being, right? All the conflicting things that make a person a person. And she did it so well. And then just the vocal demand of that role. If you've ever listened to the album or watched her Tony performance, there's a song "Lot's Wife" in Act Two, where she really just wails, and it's such a catharsis and it's so moving and it's so powerful, and it's also just really hard to sing. And I don't know how she did it eight times a week. I don't know how anyone could. You have to be superhuman.
[1:52:00] Rob Russo: That performance will always live tall in my memory. It's one of the ones that I feel very privileged to have seen because the show didn't run very long. And it is captured on that album, which is very special, but there was nothing like seeing that performance at the Eugene O'Neill Theater on Broadway. My brother saw it downtown at the Newman, which I bet was, and you're raising your hand, Jamie.
[1:52:18] Jamie DuMont: So did I.
[1:52:19] Rob Russo: I bet that was unlike anything.
[1:52:22] Jamie DuMont: Unlike it was because that theater's so small. And when she sings "Lot's Wife," I mean, your hair was being blown back by the sheer force of that performance. Just miraculous. And fortunately, the show's getting its first Broadway revival this fall, and I'm very glad that the pandemic didn't cancel that revival. So I'm because I saw it in London before the pandemic, and it's stunning, and it'll, I think, reintroduce the show to audiences in New York and hopefully who travel from all across the country and around the world to see it. Because it's a show that is so prescient. Tony Kushner is, you know, just a genius, and he is a prophet, you know.
[1:52:58] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[1:52:58] Jamie DuMont: As is Janine Tesori. Yes, the two of them, what they wrote was so ahead of its time and so of its time, and now is once again of the moment, and it's just brilliant. I can't wait to see it again. How did Tonya Pinkins not win a Tony Award? I do not understand.
[1:53:10] Rob Russo: No, I know.
[1:53:12] Jamie DuMont: For she has the Tony Award of my heart, and she always will.
[1:53:14] Rob Russo: Same, you know, for that season. And that's number one. Well, to close us out, we have one final word from the incomparable Betty Buckley.
[1:53:24] Betty Buckley: Hi, it's Betty Buckley. So I want to share with you some of my favorite Broadway moments. My first big Broadway musical was Mame, and I saw the incredible Angela Lansbury as Mame, and that left a huge impression to the point that I have a bracelet that says, "What would Angela do?" Whenever I'm in trouble in show business, I think about that. But performances that have left indelible impressions on me include Victoria Mallory, Vicky Mallory, and the original production of A Little Night Music. She sang so incredibly; it was an effortless performance, and her voice was perfectly beautiful. And I went backstage afterwards to get the name of her voice teacher, which she kindly invited me to her lesson, and I was introduced to Paul Gabbart.
And then the original show, the original production of Company just killed me. I thought it was one of the greatest things I've ever seen, which included performances by Pam Myers, the great Pam Myers with another hundred people, and beautiful Susan Browning who sang the Barcelona song. I just thought she was so utterly charming, and then of course the great Donna McKechnie, who danced that incredible piece. It was just an amazing experience seeing that original production, and there are so many performances that have left remarkable imprints on my mind and heart and soul, and Adina Menzel singing in Wicked was like gobsmacked. I couldn't even believe it. I was like, how does she do that? And a couple of my friends were sitting next to me and said, "You used to do that." And I'm like, I don't even remember ever singing like Adina Menzel. But anyway, I love Broadway. I'm so glad it's back.
[1:55:30] Rob Russo: And we love Betty Buckley, but there's one more. There's another performance that I have to mention.
[1:55:37] Betty Buckley: This is Betty Buckley again, and thanks, Jamie and Rob, for inviting me to be a part of your wrap-up of The Fabulous Invalid podcast, which was such a joy to be a part of. I just, one of the best performances I've ever seen on Broadway was Jennifer Simard in the musical Disaster when she played that wild and crazy erotic nun. The whole audience, everyone was insane. Like how just how outrageous her performance and how wonderfully, you know, brilliantly performed and how wonderfully funny and completely hilarious and bizarre that was. She's a genius, that Jennifer.
[1:56:22] Rob Russo: Okay, I just had to add that. Thanks.
[1:56:24] Jamie DuMont: Well, thank you, Betty Buckley. And before we wrap up, we do have a few more quick thank yous to share because we can't end this three-season, hundred-episode podcast series without thanking some people because obviously no one does it alone. First and foremost, our intrepid co-host from seasons one and two, Jennifer Simard, who we just love so dearly. She was our guest on our 90th episode. Check it out if you haven't listened yet. And she will be seen on Broadway in Company this fall. Love you, Jen. And to the team at OM and OM, etc., and especially our co-producer and my husband, Rick Miramontes, press agent extraordinaire, but also real champion and angel of this show from the beginning. And of Broadway.
Nobody loves the theater more than Rick Miramontes. And it's such a pleasure to, you know, be in his glow because after how many years has he been in this industry? I mean, decades, and he still has that same love for it that he probably had when he started out. And that's infectious.
[1:57:23] Rob Russo: Like I said, early 80s, Bobby Fryer, Amundsen Theater.
[1:57:27] Jamie DuMont: There you go. And yep, no, it's true. He's a true believer.
[1:57:30] Rob Russo: True believer, true believer.
[1:57:31] Jamie DuMont: Well, we also have to thank our audio engineers and editors, Aaron Kaufman and Charles Van Kirk, who oddly enough, we're not really theater people, but they jumped right in and they loved doing the show, you know, as much as we did, and it was so fun to share recording sessions with them when we were able to do it in person, and of course, to have them be involved, helping us navigate this very tricky time doing everything remotely. We just loved working with Charlie and Aaron. I think Aaron, when I told Aaron that we were wrapping things up, Aaron's almost sadder than we are, which I loved. It made me very emotional when he got emotional about it.
[1:58:10] Rob Russo: Yes.
[1:58:11] Jamie DuMont: And of course, the incredible Dory Berenstein, Alan Seales, and everyone at the Broadway Podcast Network. And I also have to say one other thank you that you don't know is coming, which is to our parents. Because I know my parents and I know your parents were the ones that helped foster our early love of the theater. And I don't think we'd be sitting here if—I know I wouldn't be sitting here if my parents didn't use theater as a babysitter. But no, but in all seriousness, their love of theater, and they saw it in me, and I know your parents saw it in you, and they helped foster and let us let that grow in us, and it's not lost on me.
[1:58:56] Rob Russo: You're here, and some teachers along the way too, I have to say.
[1:58:59] Jamie DuMont: Oh, absolutely.
[1:59:00] Rob Russo: Yeah, but I think the most important thank you is to you, our listeners. We've loved hearing from you over the years, and we really hope that this show has been a great source of entertainment, information, diversion, whatever, you know, kept you entertained during a commute or at home while you were making dinner or whatever. Wherever you listened, however you listened, we're so grateful to you for listening. And above all else, we hope that you enjoyed listening to it as much as we enjoyed making it.
[1:59:36] Jamie DuMont: Ladies and gentlemen, in their farewell performance, the incredible Dreams.
[1:59:43] ♪ Musical number ♪
[2:00:30] Rob Russo: That's our show. Thanks for listening. Not just this week, but across all 100 episodes.
[2:00:36] Jamie DuMont: Yes. The Fabulous Invalid is and will always be a production of OM, etc. and the Fabulous Invalid LLC, and a proud, proud member of the Broadway Podcast Network. Our theme music is by Lucky Chops. Today's episode was edited and engineered by Aaron Kaufman. You can find us online at thefabulousinvalid.com. Our archive will live in perpetuity, and on social media at Fabulous Invalid, and on iTunes, Spotify, and wherever you find your podcasts. And be sure to stay tuned for future bonus episodes and content.
[2:01:05] Rob Russo: That's it for now.
[2:01:18] ♪ Musical number ♪
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
