Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 32: QuaranStreams (Take Me to the World: A Sondheim 90th Birthday Celebration)

In this episode, Ben and Daniel talk about Take Me to the World: A Sondheim 90th Birthday Celebration... Read More

From the show: Cast Offs with Ben and Daniel

1 h 47 mins
4/27/20

Guests

Featured Artists

Featured Shows

About

In this episode, Ben and Daniel talk about Take Me to the World: A Sondheim 90th Birthday Celebration. The online broadcast featured Meryl Streep, Bernadette Peters, Patti LuPone, Audra McDonald, Mandy Patinkin, Christine Baranski, Donna Murphy, Sutton Foster, Brian Stokes Mitchell, Kelli O’Hara, Aaron Tveit, Maria Friedman, Iain Armitage, Katrina Lenk, Michael Cerveris, Brandon Uranowitz, Stephen Schwartz, Elizabeth Stanley, Chip Zien, Alexander Gemignani, Ann Harada, Austin Ku, Kelvin Moon Loh, Thom Sesma, and Raul Esparza. Drama Desk Award winner Mary-Mitchell Campbell was the evening’s music director, with Paul Wontorek serving as director.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:01] Ben Rimalower: Broken records. The albums you wouldn't shut up about. Broken records. The music our guests can't live like Judy, Barbara, Liza, Bet, Daddy, Audra, Bernadette.

[0:14] Ben Rimalower: We broadcast this podcast with hopes that someday we might get Patti LuPone.

[0:33] Ben Rimalower: Well, good morning and welcome to Cast Offs. I'm Ben Rimalower, and I'm here remotely with my lovely co-host Daniel Nolen.

[0:46] Daniel Nolen: Hey y'all.

[0:48] Ben Rimalower: Um, we are coming at you early in the morning after staying up watching Sondheim's 90th on YouTube last night. Right now, I am Patti LuPone's Tony Award getting knocked against the inside of the locker.

[1:07] Daniel Nolen: And I'm that bong.

[1:11] Ben Rimalower: No, I really do feel like so hungover, even though I had like one beer last night while watching.

[1:18] Daniel Nolen: Oh no, I feel like last night was like a major mental and like a lame stretch when like she needed like the Dominican Republic mini bar waiter with the Pepsi.

[1:32] Ben Rimalower: Made me smoke my coffee. I was like I've never been so amped up for anything in my life. Because we were just for our listeners know, the plan was that Daniel and I were going to record this late at night when the live stream was over.

[1:50] Daniel Nolen: Right.

[1:50] Ben Rimalower: Um, and so which would be so I don't know if the thing was supposed to start at eight. I thought it would be over by 10-ish.

[1:58] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I mean, usually these things last like two hours.

[2:00] Ben Rimalower: No, I've been going to bed on the early side, but so yesterday I was like, normally I have like an iced coffee in the morning, and that's all the caffeine I have all day.

[2:09] Daniel Nolen: Uh-huh.

[2:10] Ben Rimalower: Um, and yesterday I had that, plus I had a kombucha, plus I had like four diet Pepsis. So I was like flying high. And then I just like I had taken all this like CBD and the helps of just like really like getting on like the roller coaster journey, you know.

[2:27] Ben Rimalower: Um and uh let me tell you, I was there and like every single second after 8 p.m. that that thing wasn't starting, I was like losing my fucking mind. And then when it got to be after 8:30, I really I didn't know what was going on. I thought it was like a nuclear war.

[2:47] Daniel Nolen: Like for some reason, like I really thought that it was like Trump was was like coming together.

[2:53] Ben Rimalower: Infiltrated the stream. Like it just I was just so freaked out. And it just seemed so crazy to me when it got to be after nine o'clock, like I didn't I mean, I wonder if we'll ever find out what was wrong. Like, I mean, I assumed that it was something to do with like their bandwidth and like too many viewers, right?

[3:16] Daniel Nolen: I guess, because I mean everything was pre-recorded, right? Except for like Raúl Esparza, who like tried to go live at the beginning and then it uh he was on mute and it was chaotic, but like everyone sent in their stuff, right?

[3:29] Ben Rimalower: So it wasn't like they were trying to like connect, you know, after they finally axed Raúl Esparza's intro, like it went smoothly, it seemed.

[3:41] Daniel Nolen: I mean, here's the thing. I mean I if anyone out there is going to do a Zoom with a couple of friends, or they're going to do a major internationally broadcast like live stream of like a Sondheim birthday celebration. I feel like the lesson I will take from these experiences is you need one person who's like a stage manager type that is in constant contact with whoever is actually on screen.

[4:09] Ben Rimalower: Yes.

[4:09] Daniel Nolen: And the person that is the stage manager person has to always have access to a live feed of what the viewers are watching.

[4:18] Ben Rimalower: Yes, 100%. It's like it's like this, you know, it's literally, I mean, at my Seder, like when my mom was like making her little speech and forgot to like unmute herself. And it's like all like because there was like 40 people at our Passover Seder on the Zoom.

[4:32] Daniel Nolen: Uh-huh.

[4:33] Ben Rimalower: They were we everyone, we were like waving violently, flapping our arms at the camera, but my mom was just like not noticing.

[4:40] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[4:40] Ben Rimalower: But it's like you can't just be in your own little world. You're in little, you know, we're together but apart. What are we? We're like, you know, we're not. No one's alone. Like you, so it's just like, and you know, I don't know. I honestly I was like so emotionally like triggered by that whole experience.

[4:58] Ben Rimalower: And like I just because like it's like it reminds me of like how I feel like growing up, like just like invisible, like it's like someone's like not paying attention and like noticing like you know what's going on. Um but uh and I was just so I literally didn't know what to do. Like I was like, obviously, the thing to do is like, I mean, when the Rosie O'Donnell thing was going live and everybody was like live streaming it, um I was just kind of was that the Seder?

[5:27] Daniel Nolen: No, I had some family Zoom that same night, and I didn't watch the Rosie thing live. I was like, What I don't ever I don't watch the Oscars live, I'll watch it later when I watch it, or I'll, you know, I was like, so I was like, why am I so married to the idea of like watching this exactly right? You know.

[5:42] Ben Rimalower: Well, I mean, it's that with uh what was the one that was uh oh Buyer and Seller. It's like this, I I mean I assume the Sondheim thing is gonna be up after to for people to watch, but yeah, it's only plays that the because of the Dramatists Guild, they don't know.

[5:58] Daniel Nolen: Oh, okay.

[5:59] Ben Rimalower: But you know, there is this idea. I mean, especially if like me, you want to be on Twitter and like engage with everyone about every little detail of the night. It's like this idea of appointment uh television viewing that's back and but you know, but I don't like it.

[6:08] Daniel Nolen: I don't like it.

[6:15] Ben Rimalower: I have loved the innovation of the last 20 years. Like, don't make I don't want an appointment. The world is full of appointments. I wanna just, you know, and and I feel like the worst things about me come out with appointments, you know. I w I wanna like walk through the park and smell the flowers.

[6:36] Ben Rimalower: Like I feel like that is the direction we all need to be moving into, you know, and like when I'm home and like I like suddenly like, you know, just I'm like, hey, I feel like watching some Sondheim. Then I, you know, all day long yesterday I had a beautiful day. I was like all Sondheim all day, and all I did was just like go through different Sondheim videos on YouTube, you know?

[7:00] Daniel Nolen: And it was just it was not appointment television. There was like it was crazy, it was reckless. I was like, here's one from 78, here's one from 95, here's 2003, here's 67. It was just like however I felt like it, you know. And this was just so stressful. But all I will say anyway, I mean, all that to say that I couldn't have possibly been more hyped for when it actually did begin.

[7:28] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[7:29] Ben Rimalower: And the Stephen Schwartz uh Follies was the perfect uh do you call it the overture?

[7:36] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, the overture.

[7:37] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah. Follies overture was the perfect thing. And I loved how it was, it was so zen, how beautifully shot that was. And it was just so um so lovely. And then, and now you know, and people that listen to the pod, they know I'm not a huge fan of Sutton's.

[7:59] Daniel Nolen: Well, okay, yes.

[8:01] Ben Rimalower: But I couldn't have loved her more. I felt like she, I knew it wasn't live, but it does that. Oh, this is the thing, you know, there's a darkness in the moment in time that we are in right now, you know, in a sense, like the whatever the fuck went wrong technically last night is such like a uh, you know, perfectly metaphor of like where we are in the universe on earth right now.

[8:30] Daniel Nolen: And and truthfully, truly speak truly, in Sondheim's music, there is this dark brokenness, you know. And uh, and it just it just it really, when it finally started, I could, I was so my heart was right on that crack.

[8:51] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, and yeah, and to have Sutton come in so strong and yet so it was the per it was the perfect Sutton moment because she had her weird, you know, part of what I've always hated about the Sutton Foster and the Kelly O'Hara's compared, you know, Patti LuPone is so like, it's been 28 years. Get him out of the way. Bring them in, you know.

[9:14] Ben Rimalower: It's there's something like so bitchy and diva and entitled about Patti compared to the like humility and like, you know, like uh like, you know, uh down homeness of a Sutton or you know, Kelly and her Tony speech doing that, like I'm a dork, here's my dorky dance, you know.

[9:31] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah.

[9:31] Ben Rimalower: But what I've all but the reason I've always hated them and loved Patti is that that felt bullshit to me. I'm like, no, fuck you, Sutton. You're in a fucking Zac Posen dress, okay? I'm sure you were cunty to 12 assistants on your way to the stage, you know. Don't give me this false like down homeness, you know.

[9:51] Daniel Nolen: Whereas Patti, even though she gives you the grandeur of like a star, uh, you know, I feel like she actually like mooned the boys on the crew, like on her way to the stage, you know.

[10:02] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[10:02] Daniel Nolen: So I've always like, you know, felt sort of alienated by this sort of, you know, uh uh thing with those other girls. But I have to say it was so perfect last night because Sutton's like, you know, I'm just a regular person, like, you know, ah shucks quality, you know, it's so, and she's a television star, you know, and so she was so intimate and real with the camera.

[10:25] Ben Rimalower: You know, when she sings, when she starts like those smug little men with their smug little schemes, you know, she was just giving it to you in like the most like aw shucks, like who means, what am I, you know? And yet I had every confidence, and indeed was given it that she was going to once again be that little bitchy understudy at the La Jolla Playhouse who was like, Oh, I can go on, I can belt a D in full chest voice, you know.

[10:54] Daniel Nolen: And indeed she did, and as if all that weren't enough, you know. I'm I love kids, I'm a sucker for it. And I thought her daughter, like not only sang Stephen Sondheim, but having to correct herself on the pronunciation, like I just thought it was all it was everything I could have dreamed.

[11:10] Daniel Nolen: Like immediately I took a hundred and eighty degree turn from like the depths of despair to just like just like radiating with like joy and exhilaration.

[11:20] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[11:21] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I thought that was such a good song for her as well. Like, um, I was really nervous about what song she was gonna pick, but that one I thought was wonderful. And um, yeah, and her kids, and and that brings us to our next act, which also employed the use of uh child labor.

[11:40] Ben Rimalower: Um Neil.

[11:41] Daniel Nolen: No, no, no, Neil is not a child anymore.

[11:44] Ben Rimalower: No, Neil's now an adult. He's like almost 50.

[11:48] Daniel Nolen: But I have to say, this number, I felt I found it so dare I say disrespectful. Like, I was so mad at him after this song. I was like, how dare you, first of all, sully the good name of Faggotry and read the karaoke track to the witches rap.

[12:12] Ben Rimalower: Like you don't already, and like you're not off book for this. Like, that is so upsetting to me.

[12:17] Daniel Nolen: Wait, wait, was he reading? I didn't realize that.

[12:18] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I mean, he was obviously like reading the lyrics, or like he was staring at something intently the whole time.

[12:26] Daniel Nolen: Like, I'm just gonna be.

[12:26] Ben Rimalower: Maybe he was staring at his kids.

[12:29] Daniel Nolen: No, but it wasn't like a like a character choice. It was like he was focused on something.

[12:36] Ben Rimalower: I mean, it seemed very like carpool karaoke, but like with the lyrics. And I don't know. He just really phoned it in. And I I was just like, come on. Like, this is Sondheim's 90th birthday. This is a bold choice. Like, you really need to sell it.

[12:53] Daniel Nolen: And however, I did enjoy, like, I don't know.

[12:57] Ben Rimalower: The kids.

[12:58] Daniel Nolen: The kid. Well, I did enjoy his little kids are cute, even though I feel for them.

[13:02] Ben Rimalower: And yeah.

[13:03] Daniel Nolen: Um I thought I thought the kids were really cute. I mean, I loved that he chose that number. I really loved it. And I was like, you know, because Sutton's, I feel like in a way, there were kind of two kinds of performances last night, right? There were the ones that were like, you know, the I guess the epitome of one kind would be like Chip Zien, you know, being like, I sang this song in the show.

[13:26] ♪ Musical number: "Signature Song" — performed by Unknown performer ♪

[13:40] Ben Rimalower: Like here I am. Let me just give you my truth, you know. And then the ones that were like, I am doing a musical theater performance. I'm really excited about it. I'm going to like learn it and act it and like have a prop and just like take this journey, you know.

[13:57] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[13:58] Ben Rimalower: And so, and Sutton's sort of goes in both levels in a way, you know. Uh, because she did perform that role at City Center Encores, and I loved her story about falling in love with it in high school, mostly because it was big and belty and how it came to mean something different to her. And you know, the number has that kind of personal identification with her, and it's clearly a song that she knows and does in her own sort of, you know, life throughout, but also it was a little bit like, I mean, Sutton Foster is the ultimate like musical theater 101 kind of performer, you know.

[14:33] Daniel Nolen: So, and then Neil, but still I sort of took it, I guess because of the context and the history as you know, the first kind of category. But then Neil was decidedly in the second camp, you know.

[14:48] Ben Rimalower: And I was here for it, you know. I was kind of like, oh, okay, like, you know, uh I wasn't expecting that kind of thing to happen. Um I was like, I was totally I was I was ready to enjoy that. And I loved Neil taking the witch's song, you know.

[15:08] Daniel Nolen: Um I was really right on board with it, and then you know, I it didn't really do much for me. I mean, I appreciated the idea that he sort of made what's that TV show he has that's like, it's not it's like kind of almost Harry Potter-esque.

[15:24] Ben Rimalower: Now you see me, now you don't, something like that.

[15:26] Daniel Nolen: No, no, no. Isn't it called like Dr. McGoragles or something?

[15:29] Ben Rimalower: I don't know. It's like I feel like he plays like an evil wizard or something, you know.

[15:33] Daniel Nolen: So a series of unfortunate events.

[15:35] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, you know, like I felt like I totally felt like Neil was like, yeah, I'm the witch, but in like a sort of like weird Harry Potter, like, you know, man kind of, you know, I don't I was ready to like let him have that, you know.

[15:49] Daniel Nolen: I was so but he didn't, but I didn't, I just did, but I did not feel taken in by it.

[15:54] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I was so turned off by it. And then, like, I mean, his kids are so cute, but also I don't know if you saw what he did on the Rosie thing.

[16:03] Daniel Nolen: No, I didn't.

[16:04] Ben Rimalower: He also was so happy I didn't.

[16:05] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[16:06] Ben Rimalower: Be happy. And I don't remember what he sang, but he also used his kids, and it just felt very like I mean, they're so sweet and cute, but it did feel very like, um I don't know.

[16:20] Daniel Nolen: Those poor kids, let them be like, I don't want them alone.

[16:23] Ben Rimalower: I don't have those feelings about the kids thing because this it's not normal times, you know. Parents are home with their kids, you know.

[16:31] Daniel Nolen: Yes, that's true.

[16:32] Ben Rimalower: Like there this whole thing is happening at home. And, you know, what better to introduce your kids to than musical theater? It's not like he's using his kids to like record promos for like a product he's selling, you know.

[16:46] Daniel Nolen: It's like, you know, it's Sondheim for God's sakes, and like, you know, and the truth is like I don't know what kind of a father Neil is, and I don't presume to guess, you know, but I guarantee you, based on my knowledge of kids, that like it's not like he's like being like, put down the toy trucks and come on in and help me with this musical theater.

[17:12] Ben Rimalower: You know, Neil, Neil does Broadway musicals and stuff, and I bet that they want to participate in what he's doing, you know.

[17:19] Daniel Nolen: Right, yes.

[17:20] Ben Rimalower: Um that's true. You know, I don't I don't I I don't know. I I I thought both that and who was the and Sutton, you know, I loved I loved the the thing with the kids, and and I thought that the way Neil used it, I thought it was a really cute idea to do the witch and have it an almost, you know, and I I I thought it was staged well with the kids, but you had a sister, and like I, you know, I I love the idea of like the brother as the baker and the sister as the baker's wife, you know I just like I just loved it I love what are their names Gideon and Harper.

[17:23] Daniel Nolen: I thought it was so adorable.

[17:52] Ben Rimalower: So I mean I was fine and honestly I was glad that that was Neil's slot, you know let Sutton be the strong, you know opening I was like she's kind of the Ethel Merman of today in her own weird way, you know I mean for God's sake you all keep reminding me that she did Anything Goes so there you go like let's have it you know but like you know she she is kind of the Ethel Merman of the of her day and uh and then and and so let Neil be the second song that's like a you know a pattern number, you know like I I I thought for what it I was so happy that that was his slot and that he wasn't coming out to sing like no one is alone at the end, you know like right that's true but oh I just I hated it so much um but I did enjoy kind of all the gays coming for him right after on Twitter.

[18:42] Ben Rimalower: Okay so by the way at that point in the show I was so overwhelmed that I I had to take a little short break from Twitter because it was starting to really freak me out like it was too much like being like watching this video and like feeling connected to the people on Twitter watching it and like feeling connected to the people on the screen, you know because like I know Sutton and I know Neil and like I know like the Broadway.com people and like, you know, of course, I know so many of the people that I mean, I guess there are people that I follow on Twitter and follow me back that I don't know, but a lot of the people I talk to on Twitter are like you, you know, or friends of mine.

[19:25] Daniel Nolen: And it started to feel too much like I was living in the singularity, like I'd left my physical body behind, and I was just like existing in this virtual world.

[19:34] Ben Rimalower: The matrix.

[19:35] Daniel Nolen: I like I I and I might I was getting really short of breath. I like thought I was gonna have an anxiety attack.

[19:41] Ben Rimalower: I was like, I literally for one part for one part, like right was Kelly next.

[19:45] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, Kelly.

[19:46] Ben Rimalower: Kelly is next. Like the very beginning of Kelly, I was like in like a yoga position, just being like, okay, like maybe you'll just watch the rest of the concert later. And right now you just breathe and take care of yourself. Like that's where I was.

[19:59] Daniel Nolen: How on brand though, like having a panic attack to Sondheim's 90th.

[20:05] Ben Rimalower: Totally, a hundred percent. Um, but Kelly, I have to say, Kelly really took me back.

[20:12] Daniel Nolen: Like, I and I was sad at first she wasn't singing Take Me to the World because she had done it so beautifully before, you know.

[20:19] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, uh, and I guess some people were posting that they were tired of her singing this song.

[20:25] Daniel Nolen: Although, like, you know, as you know, in my personal journey, I had never heard her sing this song before.

[20:30] Ben Rimalower: Because either.

[20:32] Daniel Nolen: I don't listen to her albums except for like when they come up on shuffle.

[20:36] Ben Rimalower: Um, but uh, but I loved it. I mean, yeah, I just, you know, no one Kelly is such a she's such a wonderful combination of like that kind of like Rebecca Lucre, even more so than Rebecca Lucre in a way, like a soprano voice that is just so natural.

[20:55] Daniel Nolen: There's nothing, there's nothing produced or like her soprano voice feels like she came out of the womb and it just came out of her mouth, you know.

[21:02] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah, yeah. And and and that, and as natural as it is, it's the purest sunshine. It just feels like a ray of light, you know.

[21:10] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, absolutely.

[21:12] Ben Rimalower: And so it's a combination of that, and she's just she's such a real actor, you know.

[21:17] Daniel Nolen: Whatever Kelly just everything that comes out of her seems so authentic and natural.

[21:22] Ben Rimalower: You know, totally.

[21:24] Daniel Nolen: And so it really I couldn't have been more what I needed to hear last night, you know.

[21:29] Ben Rimalower: And and it that song felt, you know, at first I was sad she wasn't doing Take Me to the World, because Take Me to the World obviously is so poignant at this moment in time.

[21:37] Daniel Nolen: But but actually, what more do I need was so poignant in this moment in time because it was exactly that, like all the shit that you normally hate about the city that you long for now, you know?

[21:48] Ben Rimalower: Right, right.

[21:49] Daniel Nolen: Um, and I have to say, I mean, I've known that song since I was in high school.

[21:53] Ben Rimalower: The first version of it that I knew was the Liz Callaway one from that Stephen Sondheim evening where Judy Kuhn tries to belt, and um, uh, and then uh the one that I was really obsessed with was um, uh well now I want to say Rachel York singing it and putting it together.

[22:12] Daniel Nolen: Maybe she didn't.

[22:13] Ben Rimalower: I don't know if I'm making that up or not.

[22:14] Daniel Nolen: But um, but oh, and then there was like the Don Upshaw one, uh, and like and my sister did it in a review in college, and I really loved her version.

[22:22] Ben Rimalower: But and I think other girls sang it in college. I just I feel like that song was like a big part of my life in the 90s that I don't really think about anymore.

[22:29] Daniel Nolen: But watching Kelly sing it for the first time ever, I was like at the end, I was like, oh my god, I'm so excited she's about to hit the high note.

[22:37] Ben Rimalower: And I like truly was like, yes, hit the high note.

[22:42] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I love her.

[22:44] Ben Rimalower: And um next up is another class act professional showing us how it's done, Miss Judy Kuhn, past guest of the pod.

[22:54] Daniel Nolen: I must say, the first person to fulfill my fantasy wish list of what they sang, which was What Can You Lose from Dick Tracy.

[23:05] Ben Rimalower: Just as she did on the absolute must-listen unsung Songtime album from 1993, and equally as gorgeous and perfect as that recording.

[23:19] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[23:20] Ben Rimalower: Yes.

[23:21] Daniel Nolen: Not a day.

[23:21] Ben Rimalower: I mean, her voice is uh as we as we saw and heard on the Seth Rudetsky Stars in the House where she and What's His Face sang, Heart Full of Love, and Francis Rafel.

[23:33] Daniel Nolen: Um her voice is in tip top shape, not a day has passed vocally.

[23:38] Ben Rimalower: Um just so that voice is is otherworldly.

[23:43] Daniel Nolen: And Judy also, you know, it's funny because like what tr what Sutton sang and what Kelly sang were both songs that like the sort of literal meaning of them felt relevant to what we're going through right now, you know?

[23:57] Ben Rimalower: And um, the Judy one, it it was that wasn't so much true, and yet you looked in her eyes and there was tears, you know, and her face, you know, her face was I mean, really, it was a beautifully acted performance.

[24:12] Daniel Nolen: I mean, it was very subtle and low-key, but there was so much emotion and uh and feeling and heart, and and it was such a a testament to how art doesn't have to be about, you know, you can tell your story about something that I don't relate to on the details, you know.

[24:30] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, but but I can feel you, and it's like, you know, uh, Judy took the passion and pathos of this moment in time and infused a uh love song, uh with those feelings, and it made it all the more powerful, you know.

[24:49] Daniel Nolen: Um and I re I I couldn't have been more uh just moved by her.

[24:56] Ben Rimalower: I'm I I think I literally thought to myself, like, she's gonna get a job out of this.

[25:01] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally.

[25:02] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, it was so funny. Throughout the night, these um there were certain highlights for me, and I was like, wow, this is gonna definitely lead to something for them, or some sort of revival, you know, built around them of this show.

[25:15] Daniel Nolen: Or or possibly prevent something for them.

[25:18] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, on the other hand.

[25:20] Daniel Nolen: So uh then we had Katrina Lenk doing an acoustic Joanna, which I was living for, and it definitely it gave Joanna like a lesbian twist that I had never thought of before, and I loved it.

[25:41] Ben Rimalower: Really?

[25:41] Daniel Nolen: You never thought of that, even when Bernadette sang Joanna, and Bernadette's an actual lesbian.

[25:47] Ben Rimalower: Um, no, I never really thought of that because you know, Bernadette uh how do I say this?

[25:53] Daniel Nolen: Like Bernadette in those moments she presents as like so femme with her tits out and her hair done.

[26:00] Ben Rimalower: I mean, Katrina has like that kind of folksy like silver lake lesbian vibe, you know, and silver lake, you know, it's like the silver.

[26:10] Daniel Nolen: Silver lake is what Bernadette calls her, never mind anyway.

[26:20] Ben Rimalower: So I I loved uh Katrina's, and I thought that was a good song for her.

[26:25] Daniel Nolen: I was so glad she did not sing Being Alive, um, even though that's probably what a lot of people wanted her to sing.

[26:31] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I mean, I I kind of feel like her not singing Being Alive is like a little bit like they're not really like owning themselves, you know.

[26:45] Ben Rimalower: Well, I mean I'm not sure. When I say they, I mean her and the producers of Company. Yeah. Like, like, they chose to cast her. Like, they could have had Sutton, you know? Like, they chose her. And I'm not, you know, God knows I didn't want to, even that, even after last night falling in love with Sutton, and not wanting her to play Bobby. You know, but I'm just saying they could have had, you know, whoever, Stephanie J. Block. They could have had whoever they wanted, and they chose, you know, a Silver Lake, whatever. And so, like, I feel like they needed to like be like, okay, it's a Sondheim 90th, and she's gonna fucking do it, you know. But I don't know, maybe they were like, well, without the orchestra, blah, blah, blah.

But it I would have felt better if she would have come out and done "Being Alive" and I could have like been won over, you know. But anyway, but I did love her Joanna. I thought it was really wonderful. Um if there was ever a time to break out the guitar that you can play, sort of. I mean, she plays great, but I'm saying, like, you know, what you gain from supplying your own live accompaniment outweighs anything that you may lose by not having, like, you know, we can't all live, I mean, we can't all live across the hall from Billy Stritch like Linda Lavin does. Right, literally. And I'm not someone who usually gets into like um like stripped down, like soft, quiet versions of song. Like all those YouTube versions of like "Creep" online that people share, I'm like, next.

But like for some reason this really worked for me. And um anyway. So then we had um another treat for the eyes and the ears, Aaron Tveit, uh singing "Marry Me a Little," which I'm so glad he sang this because um I by the way, number two that was on my list.

[28:36] Daniel Nolen: What uh your predictions?

[28:39] Ben Rimalower: They weren't predictions, they were a wish list.

[28:42] Daniel Nolen: Oh, so and you this was the one you chose for him?

[28:44] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[28:45] Daniel Nolen: Oh, yes.

[28:46] Ben Rimalower: Well, I love this song so much. Um this this song, the older I get, this song from Company really has become one of my faves.

[28:55] Daniel Nolen: And me too.

[28:56] Ben Rimalower: I'm so glad he chose this and not "Being Alive." Like that's such it's just so much more interesting hearing uh this song and not "Being Alive." And he's just so nice to look at. And I I mean, some parts of his performance, I mean, yeah, some of the tweets I was seeing were so uh not safe for working from home. But um, you know, this song, uh, some parts of it seemed a little like music theater senior showcase to me, but for the most part, I loved it so much, and I thought he delivered, and um, yeah, he just has such a lovely voice.

[29:38] Daniel Nolen: Um, yeah, I agree with all that. Um I uh I mean I think he his performance in a way explains why Katrina was exactly right to sing Joanna. Because, you know, it's a very neat trick that Sutton Foster can do to be intimate enough for the camera and get to the heights of belting and still be giving us the feeling you know and you know Katrina avoided that challenge by doing something completely intimate and yeah I and Aaron took the challenge and it for me it didn't work.

[30:20] Ben Rimalower: It felt very music it felt like a self-tape for like a musical theater showcase or something you know and um I it didn't i I've been a fan of his always but I really I was not into it um I wish I'd wished I wished I'd chosen a different song for him it's your fault also I mean I don't know if this is okay to say but like it's our pod like I just like really think he's gay um I I mean I would I would guess that as well I mean there's no there's no indication otherwise for me you know I mean just besides the fact that he hasn't said it yeah um also he's getting old he is but you know what I'm he's someone who I think I'm like more into him now that he's getting older like I think I'm not I think I liked him better as a Twinkie yeah I I don't know I I like like the little crow's feet around his eyes I'm just like let me just I would like them on someone else yeah I mean I whatever I still wouldn't kick him out of bed for eating crackers but although his hair is getting it's he needs a little trim trim trim.

[31:33] Daniel Nolen: Don't we all though?

[31:35] Ben Rimalower: I mean coming up next is um Beanie Feldstein and Feldstein and I think Steen.

[31:42] Daniel Nolen: Steen and Ben Platt.

[31:44] Ben Rimalower: And I have such specific thoughts on this, but I don't want to I just feel like I'm being so negative, so why don't you go first?

[31:55] Daniel Nolen: Would that I could. Um no, I mean, well, I will say this, you know, Beanie, um uh the only musical I've seen her in was um Hello Dolly, where we didn't really get to hear much of her singing, you know.

[32:11] Ben Rimalower: Right.

[32:11] Daniel Nolen: Um and I thought she sang great. I was like really I really was ready for her to be a musical theater star wherever you want to put her, you know. Um and uh I you know their number felt to me like the ultimate in like musical theater like presentational like cutesiness.

[32:31] Ben Rimalower: Um I uh, you know, I had dug myself a grave because I uh my wish list that Chip would sing "No More," so I couldn't exactly sit there watching Beanie and Ben being like it should be Chip and Joanna, you know.

[32:47] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[32:47] Ben Rimalower: Um and I don't I didn't need it to be Chip and Joanna, but like it just felt it felt I don't know. I just it didn't do anything for me. They were good, but it's fine, whatever.

[33:00] Daniel Nolen: I I love I loved Beanie.

[33:03] Ben Rimalower: I thought I don't know, she seemed like she was actually kind of like acting and and really engaged.

[33:11] Daniel Nolen: And I and I just really like her and I've liked her in all the movies I've seen her in.

[33:16] Ben Rimalower: But Ben Platt, I was so I was like, the baker shouldn't sound like he's. I mean, it auto obviously it wasn't, but Ben Platt has this little like built-in auto-tune to his voice. And like he was doing those little like uh I don't know, like those those little uh mannerisms like he's seeing at a concert, you know, where he kind of like throws his head to the side and closes his eyes and like puts his finger in his ear or whatever, and it's like that's not like this is not like Ben Platt is the baker at you know, Moral Place and yeah, yeah. It's like I mean, and and it felt a little weird because I thought Beanie was doing such a good job of like uh connecting with him or the camera and whatever, and um I was like, oh, I can see her playing the baker's wife, but Ben, I was like, it seems a yeah, it was just a little too like yeah, concert-y.

[34:21] Ben Rimalower: But um then, okay, so next up, uh Brandon Uranowitz singing famously one of my favorite Sondheim songs with "So Little to Be Sure Of" from Anyone Can Whistle, which I mean loved it, loved it.

[34:38] Daniel Nolen: Nothing, nothing bad to say.

[34:41] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, same.

[34:42] Daniel Nolen: So totally loved it.

[34:44] Ben Rimalower: And I'm also so I mean, Anyone Can Whistle, uh um a lot of a lot of the um lesser known uh Sondheims or the lesser uh mainstream Sondheims got a lot of attention last night, which was fun.

[35:01] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[35:02] Ben Rimalower: Um then Melissa Errico, "Children in Art," which I also loved.

[35:07] Daniel Nolen: And by the end of it, I was like, I'm listening, mama.

[35:13] Ben Rimalower: Oh.

[35:14] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[35:15] Ben Rimalower: I mean, it did have that energy for me, and I was I was here for it.

[35:19] Daniel Nolen: I will say, um, I uh when I was Patty tweeted before the show started those um the Zoom of uh the pit screen grab of the Zoom and her Zoom had uh yeah and it had four chat messages.

[35:36] Ben Rimalower: Uh-huh.

[35:36] Daniel Nolen: Um and you know, I was I said I would I tweeted that I would like to believe that you know, one of Patty's is a DM from Bernadette saying, like, when this is all over, let's have that lunch for real, Patty.

[35:47] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, you know, that was just the speculation, but I would bet good money that one of those chat four chat messages was to everyone, as we say on Zoom, uh, from Melissa Errico, just offering a free download of her Sondheim album, Soundtime Sublime on Broadway Records.

[36:08] Daniel Nolen: You're probably right.

[36:11] Ben Rimalower: I was literally wishing she didn't follow me so I could tweet that.

[36:16] Daniel Nolen: That's you should still tweet it, just block her from it.

[36:19] Ben Rimalower: Is that possible?

[36:21] Daniel Nolen: No, I already feel I'm having so this is another thing I was having an anxiety attack about last night. I was like, I was like, I feel like I'm leaning too hard into being like bitchy, you know.

[36:33] Ben Rimalower: Um like uh, you know, on like our live stream and everything, like um uh Tim uh Fetterly, brilliant writer who wrote Better Nate Than Ever and all those great books.

[36:45] Daniel Nolen: Um he tweeted something like uh making things is greater than making fun of things.

[36:53] Ben Rimalower: Um and I was like, oh god, I'm just like all I'm doing in this quarantine is like making fun of things.

[36:59] Daniel Nolen: And the, and then I sort of, you know, I do I saw that.

[37:02] Ben Rimalower: I saw that tweet, but no, it's a great tweet, and it wasn't about me or anything, you know.

[37:07] Daniel Nolen: No, no, no, I know. I'm not talking about him. I'm just saying like that was one thing that was in my head when I was feeling like, you know, uh, I still stand by what I said to you and uh friend of the pod, Michael Kushner last week, which is like, you know, I don't know, like I'm, you know, I you might some people might it might rub them wrong if like I say something like edgy, you know not edgy, the edgy is too self-congratulatory, you know, but like if I say something bitchy about something, you know, but I'm I you know, I don't work on Broadway, I'm not friends with those people, and like I'm a fan, and I'm just like having, you know, my opinion about the entertainment that I want to consume, you know, and I think that's good for the industry.

[37:49] Ben Rimalower: I wish people, you know, if more people did that about my work, I'd have more money and fame, you know.

[37:54] Daniel Nolen: So I, you know, I think if I say something, you know, about Vicky Clark or Kelly O'Hara, like, you know, they can suck it up, you know. Although, like I said, I lived for Kelly last night.

[38:04] Ben Rimalower: However, I've been having extreme guilt because I said something slightly untoward on one of the live streams about uh Christina Bianco.

[38:15] Daniel Nolen: Did you?

[38:16] Ben Rimalower: I don't even remember this.

[38:17] Daniel Nolen: It wasn't so bad. We I was talking about Liza Minnelli impressions that I don't like.

[38:21] Ben Rimalower: Oh, yes, and I said, you know, and I said, uh or maybe or Bernadette impressions, and I was like, you know, I was like, and I don't want to plump her up anymore, but Christina Bianco does a pretty good one, you know.

[38:32] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[38:33] Ben Rimalower: Um, and like I've been feeling like really like Christina Bianco is like, first of all, obviously extremely talented, and has been like nothing but like lovely and sweet and kind to me, and like I know her personally.

[38:45] Daniel Nolen: And like I feel I'm sure she doesn't watch our thing, and I doubt anyone gives a fuck.

[38:51] Ben Rimalower: But like I just feel like it's a very bad road to be on for me to just be like literally just like taking a time to like to say anything negative that pops into my head about anyone ever.

[39:02] Daniel Nolen: Um so uh all that said, I was like, I do not need to be like just like offending Melissa Errico.

[39:11] Ben Rimalower: Although, frankly, you know what? Her work has been offending me my whole life.

[39:15] Daniel Nolen: So well, I mean, I think what you're saying, you know, it's not like it's like that uh uh Brene, not not to bring in my girl, but Brene Brown has that book Daring Greatly, and there's that Theodore Roosevelt quote she says about like, you know, it's not about it's not the critic who counts, it's the one who's in the arena actually fighting and sweating and bleeding and stuff.

[39:39] Ben Rimalower: So like basically saying like don't pay attention to people who criticize because they're not the ones doing the work.

[39:45] Daniel Nolen: However, I think there is so that's you know, I understand that, and there there is this, there is a lot of truth and value to that idea of like, you know, whatever that Tim tweet was, like making art is better than making fun of it or whatever.

[40:00] Ben Rimalower: But yeah, I I do think though there is, I mean, not to get into a whole conversation about the role of the critic, but there is a uh a value as well to questioning things, and and if that's in the form of jest, I mean, I don't think what you said about Christina Bianco is uh mean, you know.

[40:24] Ben Rimalower: You know, I think I mean, obviously she's gotten a lot of acclaim, rightfully so, because she's very talented and um you know it's uh what you said was it wasn't hateful, you know, it was it wasn't fun, and it was um the tone of it was it had an inherent appreciation or an inherent um acknowledgement of you know her contributions and whatnot.

[40:47] Daniel Nolen: Anyway.

[40:48] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, anyway. With that said, I'm I'm guessing you didn't love Melissa.

[40:54] Daniel Nolen: No, the truth is I I actually liked her fine. Um I it was probably one of my favorite Melissa Erico things I've ever seen.

[41:03] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. I thought that I thought it was just a little bit more.

[41:05] Daniel Nolen: Which is not saying very much. Um so then Randy Rainbow did uh Mrs. Love It. Which was not just like the song. I mean, he didn't like Randy Rainbow it much.

[41:23] Ben Rimalower: Um he Randy Rainbowed it a little bit. I thought it was pretty fun.

[41:27] Daniel Nolen: Yeah. I would have liked it if it went into a medley of like five more Sondheim songs. I wanted Randy to like audition for all the Sondheim leading lady roles.

[41:38] Ben Rimalower: I was glad no, I was glad it was, you know, uh expedited. I mean it was fine, but you know, I was uh anyway. Elizabeth Stanley, oh, here we go.

[41:52] Daniel Nolen: So Elizabeth Stanley doing The Miller's Son. Another just I I didn't expect anyone to do this song, and it's one that I love so much, and it's so fun when someone does it. And she I loved this song. I thought she killed it. Um, I was like pretty much on board with it. I think she's extremely talented. I thought she was spectacular in um uh pill.

[42:05] Ben Rimalower: Oh.

[42:18] Daniel Nolen: Well, and and on the town, too. Yeah, so funny. Um, and I thought she was spectacular in Merrily We Roll Along.

[42:25] Ben Rimalower: Mm-hmm.

[42:27] Daniel Nolen: But it but it wasn't my favorite version of um uh The Miller's Son. You know what she did? She did uh at the end, she distorted one of the vowels. Um, it just because like, you know, there other people have sung the song as Belty or even beltier. Uh I'm not saying it's a belting contest, but the reason to distort the vowel is to belt. And I'm saying like Patti LuPone and Sarah Ramirez and Rachel York and Liz Callaway all managed to be not to mention in the original cast, Dee Henn and Bartlett, all managed to be equally or more uh, you know, belty and yet sang pure vowels, you know.

[43:16] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I mean, I don't remember the that moment you're talking about, but I didn't know.

[43:22] Daniel Nolen: It was like um uh it was like that'll not have been dead when I die. And a person should celebrate, and she was like, everything.

[43:33] Ben Rimalower: Oh yeah, the thing. And it just really it took me out of it, you know. And I guess the truth is like I couldn't have been that deeply into it if that took me out of it, you know. So I don't know, it wasn't my favorite.

[43:46] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I got that. Um I think she should have sang the song that I put on my list for her, which is uh this do you know the song The Girls of Summer?

[43:58] Ben Rimalower: Uh-uh.

[43:59] Daniel Nolen: It's random. It's a single song that Sondheim wrote for some uh I think it was for an Arthur Lawrence play that was maybe even like a flop in like the 50s or 60s. Um but it's but it's like uh it's almost like the like teenage girl version of the ladies who lunch. Like it's um it's about uh it's about like the girls who go to the beach and like have the like leisurely summer and like what happens to them like in the fall.

[44:30] Ben Rimalower: I don't know. I mean I feel like my understanding of it maybe worked too, but but it's very like cool and I don't know. I just thought she I would I would love to hear someone should sing that again. It's been too long and it's a great song.

[44:40] Daniel Nolen: That sounds great. Um actually that might be a good if we ever have a summer, that might be a good one for you.

[44:46] Ben Rimalower: Oh yes. That was so funny. I was um I'll get to this, but there were so many times in this in this uh broadcast that I was like reminded of potential summer activities. Um Aaron Tveit was singing.

[45:01] Daniel Nolen: Oh, honey. Um okay, so Mandy Patinkin next, singing Lesson Eight.

[45:10] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. Um, first of all, when they showed him in that park with the dog, I thought he was gonna sing Finishing the Hat and start with the part of like, you know, like, yeah. I was like, I am here for this guy.

[45:20] Daniel Nolen: I wish.

[45:24] Ben Rimalower: Um I mean, this is whatever. I mean, I really loved it. I I think it was worth it what he got being in that open field. But I felt like maybe there was a little bit of a sacrifice of like sound quality or intimacy or something. Like I I all I wanted was to like look into Mandy's eyes and have him be like, well, the people out strolling on Sunday. You know, I just I I wanted to feel that, you know.

[45:56] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[45:56] Ben Rimalower: And it was like it was a I somehow it felt a little bit drowned somehow. Um but it was still it was still incredibly poignant and uh and lovely. And you know, I mean and I I forget where Mandy has his country house. I I keep thinking the obvious place would be like Vermont or something, but uh, but I for some reason in my head I have this idea that he lives in Colorado.

[46:20] Daniel Nolen: Um and like he uh his son uh had posted uh some funny video. You should you should totally watch it. It's very you and me. It's um him quizzing Mandy and Catherine about like B R B and L O L and L M A O and T T Y L.

[46:38] Ben Rimalower: Oh I love it.

[46:39] Daniel Nolen: It's so fucking funny. Like it's it's really amazing. Um but anyway, but I so I saw that they were like in some like woodsy cabin somewhere. Um but uh I don't know what I was gonna say. Just uh I I don't know, it was I mean to me, Mandy Patinkin for a Sondheim thing, it's almost like he could there's nothing that could not be good about it, you know.

[47:05] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah.

[47:06] Daniel Nolen: I mean, that's not if it was if it was a excuse me, if it was a proper Sondheim thing, it you know, a proper venue, I could have I'm sure I could have lots of complaints. But like Mandy in the pandemic, like coming to me from the cabin in the woods. I'm just like, take me away, whatever you have, you know.

[47:22] Ben Rimalower: You know, right, right. Um, so next up, Maria Friedman singing Broadway Baby.

[47:29] Daniel Nolen: Maria Friedman. Maria, one of the great, great stars of British musical theater in the 90s. Um, and she uh has also directed big productions of Sondheim shows in London. And she starred on Broadway in Andrew Lloyd Webber's The Woman in White.

[47:45] Ben Rimalower: And she uh she was nominated for a Tony for that. Uh, I think for that, the same year that Patti was nominated for uh Sweeney Todd.

[47:56] Daniel Nolen: And I remember Patti was saying, oh, and Maria had recently survived cancer. And I remember like Patti had said something like you can't beat cancer or something like that. Like, like why Maria, like why Maria was gonna get the Tony and not her. Uh of course, LaChanze got it. Um, but anyway, um Maria also on the Donny Osmond like DVD now streaming of Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, she's the narrator.

[48:23] Ben Rimalower: I've never gotten Maria Friedman. Like to me, I never I it always bothered me that she was the narrator in the Joseph on video and not Lori Beachman. Of course, Lori Beachman was already like dead by the time they made that video, but but I mean, I uh, you know, and little people that grew up with like Maria Friedman's like fake British, not really belting version of Joseph instead of like the real belting, like Lori Beachman who's like Andrea McArdle, but like with an acting talent, you know. And like, I'm like, I don't understand, you know, the big deal.

[48:56] Daniel Nolen: I mean, even if you're going for like British Sondheim fanatics who also direct, why not get Julia McKenzie? You know? So, like, I've never gotten Maria Friedman, and uh I understand that she's someone that is like smart and loves Sondheim, and like maybe she's a great director, but it's just never worked for me.

[49:15] Ben Rimalower: Um, and last night was no exception.

[49:18] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, uh, I mean, it was I I don't know if her voice is gone and she could only afford to do a little shouty belt at the very end, or if that was all completely a choice. And you know, and and to be fair, it would be a smart choice in the neighborhood of like what I was saying about Sutton, like you know, you you need to have a certain intimacy to actually make the song work in this context singing to the camera, you know.

[49:40] Ben Rimalower: But uh, you know, and she's obviously a good enough actor that doing her little like at my tiny fat, there's just my cat, a bed, and a chair. Still, I'll stick it till. You know, it worked in the context of her telling the story she was gonna tell. But for my money, that should not be the Broadway Baby on the Sondheim birthday.

[50:06] Daniel Nolen: But like I agree completely. It felt a little too mild, it wasn't big and brassy enough. Um, but I did I did like there was a uh thing she said before the song that I appreciated. She said, if you have a lyric like Sondheim's, you're safe, when she was telling that story about uh people wanting Elaine Stritch, but her going on stage to sing that song instead.

[50:29] Ben Rimalower: Yes.

[50:30] Daniel Nolen: Um I still wanted Elaine Stritch, but yes, it was a nice story.

[50:37] Ben Rimalower: Um okay, so then we had Lin-Manuel doing Giants in the Sky.

[50:45] Daniel Nolen: I mean, it was I, you know, it wasn't my favorite Lin-Manuel performance, but I thought it was uh, or my favorite Giants in the Sky, but I thought it was poignant and sweet, and I thought it was very intimate. And that song is so special to me that my sister and I always talk about like shortly after September 11th, we had like a long email chain between the two of us that must have gone on for like a month or something, just me and her.

[51:08] Ben Rimalower: And uh, and Into the Woods is very special to us because we grew up watching it, of course, on video. And then we did the show together. I directed it in college and she played the baker's wife.

[51:18] Daniel Nolen: So, you know, we have a very like, as many people do with different Sondheim shows, especially Into the Woods, you know, it's a very special thing to our relationship. And the subject line of the, because I think the email was like um, you know, about how hard it was to be apart at that difficult time, you know, which is of course very resonant now. And the subject line of the email thread was uh the roof, the house, and your mother at the door.

[51:42] Ben Rimalower: Um, like it makes me cry just thinking about it. And that feels to me, you know, uh that's what's so beautiful and poignant about that song, and it's really the heart of Into the Woods in some ways. And, you know, whatever Lin-Manuel lacks in sort of like uh performative prowess. Uh, you know, there was a Broadway star a generation ago who was the cover of every magazine and became a pop culture icon, and her name was Liza Minnelli, you know.

[52:12] Daniel Nolen: And uh, the one for this generation has been Lin-Manuel Miranda, you know.

[52:18] Ben Rimalower: And uh, and so I'd rather have Lin, who is that icon, sing that song for me in a way that is so uh immediately transporting because of who he is and what his voice means to me, than have somebody with like a better voice or more like musical theater panache just kind of sell it, you know.

[52:42] Daniel Nolen: Mm-hmm.

[52:44] Ben Rimalower: Um yeah, I love that song as well. And in that moment at the end. When we saw um one of my favorite uh times I've seen that song performed was when we saw that uh all Asian production of it a couple years ago.

[53:01] Daniel Nolen: And the guy who sang who was Jack in that production, the way he sang that song, it made me cry.

[53:09] Ben Rimalower: Um I mean, that song always kind of makes me cry, but in this moment, he did something with it that was so different.

[53:15] Daniel Nolen: Uh and I really, really love that. I wish I could think of his name.

[53:19] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I wish I could too. My favorite version of that song is actually in the movie. I think that kid, he was also Gavroche in the Les Mis movie. I think he's brilliant, absolutely brilliant, like the best child actor I've ever seen.

[53:31] Ben Rimalower: I just I don't like that song sung by a kid. I want like like an adult Jack.

[53:36] Daniel Nolen: Well, not an adult, but you know, like You want Elaine Stritch.

[53:39] Ben Rimalower: Totally. No, I want like, you know, like in the original one please tune in next Sunday for my live stream of Elaine Stritch sings Giants in the Sky.

[53:51] Daniel Nolen: Um okay, then, oh my god, then Leah Salonga singing Loving You. This was one of the moments I was talking about where it's like, should we build a production of Passion around Leah?

[54:04] Ben Rimalower: Leia.

[54:05] Daniel Nolen: I mean, maybe so, because that was absolutely thrilling. And uh, I mean, first of all, I don't know if this is like, you know, I know this is like not the point, but you know, I saw Donna, I saw Patty, I saw Judy, and uh, you know, Patty and Donna both have two Tony Awards, you know. And uh, you know, and Judy is arguably the best Broadway belter of the 1980s, you know. But I think Leah Salonga did the beltiest Loving You that's ever been.

[54:36] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally, totally. I but I mean, but anyway, but it was it was so moving and so beautiful. And so much. I always have to say, Leah Salonga, you know, it's easy to forget what's so special about her when you're not watching her. Because, you know, you start to think like, well, she was wonderful in Miss Saigon, but so is so and so, and so is so and so, and she was wonderful in Les Mis, but so is so and so and so is so and so, you know, and of course, anyway, Les Mis for me, Frances Rafael is the only Éponine. But um, but it reminds me of seeing Leah in um uh what do you call it? Uh Once on This Island. And uh it's there's she really has such like an emotional directness, um that's that's undeniable and really powerful, and and and it and it's so directly connected to her voice, which is just absolutely you know, the beauty and the strength of her voice are are one and the same, and that's so rare.

[55:44] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I think that's what you're saying is spot on. Like it's directly connected to her voice because it's seamless and it's that voice is so evocative and um also not the point, but fabulous home decor.

[56:01] Ben Rimalower: Yes, and like the is it like three point perspective? I don't know what that's called, like whenever it's it's like the it's like filming in right in front of the corner of the room, like yeah it just it created this perspective and this depth and I was like as a designer I was like that is a nice shot and a nice uh layout lay all I want to do is sit on that couch and just like have like appetizers I mean it's very uh all those pillows it reminded me of our couch in Fire Island last summer which I that's basically what we did yeah totally um okay then we have and then the next setup was Laura Benanti in her bathtub okay I need to talk about this I think I might be straight I literally folks I was so attracted to Laura Benanti uh gorgeous more than gorgeous I get it I wanted to make love to her she was just showing a little you know I'm a leg man she was just showing a she was showing a little bit of knee I wanted to ravage her I want Laura Benanti and I I want to like run through the moors I want to star in like a production of like the moors weathering heights I want to like I want to like lay her down on like the autumnal leaves like I want to feel her like curly hair cascading over my face while I cover her with kisses I just I was just just immediately just like just transfixed by her.

[57:46] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah, she's so beautiful. And she's someone who um she, the older she gets, I just think the more beautiful she gets.

[57:54] Ben Rimalower: The more beautiful, the more beautiful, the more beautiful. She's she and beautiful is the word because lots of people can be pretty or sexy, and of course she is very pretty. And as I've just pointed out, you know, if a woman is sexy enough to reach me, that's like 10 blocks of sexiness, you know. But but she's beautiful, like you want to paint her, you know.

[58:15] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, and and I mean, she said, I think on our pod or another interview I heard, she's like, um, she talks about, you know, when she was playing Liesl in Sound of Music, then she took over for Maria, right? And so it's like she always had this um uh she was born older, you know. She was she had a face, a face that was like and she also talks about playing Fosca, you know, or being you know, being Fosca for Halloween.

[58:42] Ben Rimalower: But I'm glad you said Liesl, because uh she wasn't playing Liesl though, she was just the understudy to Maria, but she was the age of Liesl. Um but it's glad you brought up Liesl because Evening Primrose originally the the film, the TV movie, whatever you want to call it, was starred uh Anthony Hopkins, and not Anthony Hopkins, Anthony Perkins, and um close and and Charmian, how do you pronounce her name?

[59:08] Daniel Nolen: Charmian Carr.

[59:10] Ben Rimalower: Charmian Carr, who was Liesl in the movie of Sound of Music. Can I tell you a story about Charmian Carr?

[59:15] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[59:16] Ben Rimalower: Um when I was uh when I was very young, uh my whole family, we bought that book that she wrote, Forever Liesl, about her days uh working on the Sound of Music, and we all read it, and I was so into it that I wrote her an email telling her how much I loved her book and asking her like a weird fan questions about the movie, and she emailed me back.

[59:41] Daniel Nolen: And we had like a little email combo.

[59:45] Ben Rimalower: Well, uh, she's another one that I think is absolutely ravishingly beautiful. Um but but but Laura's performance, it was the perfect song for Laura. It is by far the best version of I Remember that has ever been seen. I mean I'm so Laura gives you so much because she on one hand, she's so old school musical theater. Like she almost could be like in a black and white video of like a Rodgers and Hammerstein show, like from like the original production in 1941, you know.

[1:00:26] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:00:27] Ben Rimalower: But on the other hand, she's like Tori Amos in like an emo 90s music video.

[1:00:32] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah.

[1:00:33] Ben Rimalower: And she's like, she's and it those things just came together so flawlessly. And she that song is so perfect for her, too, because nobody better exemplifies than Laura. Just that like emo angsty longing.

[1:00:53] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, you know, and that is what we're all feeling. We are all right now, we are all that high school girl looking out the window, wishing that it was a different time or place that we could be somewhere else that we're trapped inside this thing, you know.

[1:01:07] Ben Rimalower: Yes, there is an angst to Laura, and I that's so thrilling to watch. Thrilling. I mean, it's it was so it was just, it was the perfect performance of that song. It was the perfect Laura Benanti performance.

[1:01:22] Daniel Nolen: It was, it was so shock. I mean, Laura Benanti, she fucking knows how to do it. Like, you know, she the the color of her bathroom with her hair and her eyes and her makeup and what she was wearing, and like you know, it earned fucking sexy, beautiful, fabulous, perfect knee. It was just it was so exquisite.

[1:01:44] Ben Rimalower: It was just exquisite.

[1:01:46] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, absolutely. I agree. Um, and then Chip Zien singing signature song.

[1:01:53] Ben Rimalower: Another one from my list, another one from my wish list, Chip to Sing No More. This was definitely uh the hardest I cried during the show. Um, this was too much for me. I actually was like, I was like back in your yoga pose.

[1:02:08] Daniel Nolen: I l I literally did. I was like, this is like I will watch this later. Right now, it's enough for me just to like let it wash over me because I am overwhelmed.

[1:02:18] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. I mean, this one, I felt like he was singing this only to me, directly. Only to me. Only to me. I was like, do I want him to be my therapist? Like this this relationship that we've created in the past four minutes is uh, you know, very meaningful to me.

[1:02:39] Daniel Nolen: It was too hard because I see his distinctive Chip Zien quote unquote wiry body type, and I see his distinctive Chip Zien hair and and facial structure, and I hear his timeless Chip Zien, like brassy slash rye voice, you know, and I hear him singing these familiar words and music. And so immediately I'm taken into this comforting, soothing place of this father figure who was not only the baker in Into the Woods, but was Mendel, the in Falsettos, who was not only the therapist, as you say.

[1:03:15] Ben Rimalower: That's right.

[1:03:16] Daniel Nolen: I didn't think that's it. But was also, but was also Jason's stepfather, which is like, you know, that's so comforting to me as the little boy whose like father was gay and divorced his mother at his bar mitzvah, the whole thing, you know. So I was like, so immediately I'm like soothed and comforted, but then it's like goes in closer, or my eyes fake a close-up, and I'm zooming in, I'm connecting with Chip's eyes as he's singing the song. And it's like red light, red light, emergency 911. This is not soothing. This is not comforting. This is not a blast from the past of nostalgia. This is Chip talking to me about the reality of like not enough hospital beds or tests for COVID-19. This is like Chip talking to me about, as he said, the giant, you know.

[1:03:57] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[1:03:58] Daniel Nolen: And it was like too hard. It hurt too much. I couldn't take it.

[1:04:03] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally. I get that. Uh yeah. I mean, the song definitely has new meaning for all of us. And then, but then at the end, when he, I mean, the we all saw the hat just waiting back there on deck. And I was just like, uh-oh, uh-oh, uh-oh. And then when he got it and he like hugged it to him like a little, like that little baby that they work so hard to get in the show. I was just like, no. Chip, don't.

[1:04:29] Daniel Nolen: It was too much.

[1:04:32] Ben Rimalower: It really, it floored me. It drove a just a big stake straight through my heart. Um, then next up, uh, well, next up was Joanna Gleason, but she did not, I was so sad she did not sing Moments in the Woods.

[1:04:50] Daniel Nolen: And you know, you should watch. I just watched her yesterday on Stars in the House from like a old one. It's like from two months ago.

[1:04:58] Ben Rimalower: Oh, I didn't even know.

[1:04:59] Daniel Nolen: Um and on that same episode, Chip uh actually they're gonna auction off the green hat. So I'd already seen the hat.

[1:05:06] Ben Rimalower: Oh but uh, but Joanna sang, not the whole song, but she sang part of Moments in the Woods, and it was lovely. Um I actually wouldn't mind Joanna singing Send in the Clowns, but anyway.

[1:05:20] Daniel Nolen: And I also uh I'll say about Joanna, she told like my like sh I everyone did this little intros, you know, and most of them I were I was not that into, but Joanna's I was actually like living for.

[1:05:34] Ben Rimalower: I don’t even remember what she said.

[1:05:36] Daniel Nolen: It was something of, oh, I think it was about Into the Woods, but I just I just wrote down like this is an intro I'm actually like totally here for.

[1:05:44] Ben Rimalower: I mean, but then of course she didn't sing a song. Joanna is just like so smart and cool and like funny and warm and real and down to earth, but like just awesome. I mean, like I I would be happy, like they could have canceled the whole concert and just had Joanna Gleason tell stories, and I would have been right there for it.

[1:06:02] Daniel Nolen: Yes, totally. Um then this okay, the next song is when I took a bathroom break.

[1:06:09] Ben Rimalower: But uh Josh Groban singing Children Will Listen slash Not While I'm Around.

[1:06:16] Daniel Nolen: Which I mean, he sounded great from, you know, the peanut butter at the back of his throat.

[1:06:21] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah, totally. He sounded great from, you know, the various places in the house I was going at this point.

[1:06:23] Daniel Nolen: The various places in his in his resonance that he was utilizing.

[1:06:33] Ben Rimalower: I did like at the end how he did his little Josh Groban trick and and took it up at uh in his to his uh head voice at the end. I enjoyed that.

[1:06:44] Daniel Nolen: But um I don't know, whatever. I'm like, I don't really care about JG.

[1:06:53] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, not into it.

[1:06:56] Ben Rimalower: Uh well the thing I was into was next uh Brian Stokes Mitchell.

[1:07:02] Daniel Nolen: Yes, please God, yes.

[1:07:03] Ben Rimalower: The flag song, which is a cut song from Assassins, right?

[1:07:08] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[1:07:09] Ben Rimalower: And this one I wrote, the note I wrote down was uh Pixie Aventura, tell the story.

[1:07:16] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:07:17] Ben Rimalower: Because he was telling the story.

[1:07:21] Daniel Nolen: So wonderful.

[1:07:24] Ben Rimalower: Um Michael Cerverus singing, finishing the hat, uh, which seemed so like right by the window in his denim looking out.

[1:07:33] Daniel Nolen: It seemed very like 90s Christian music video to me, like just the setup of the whole thing.

[1:07:40] Ben Rimalower: Um but I thought it was fine. I mean, it was very it was very intimate.

[1:07:46] Daniel Nolen: And um he works for me sometimes. I mean, he's obviously so skilled. Sometimes I really when I saw him in Hedwig uh 100 years ago, I thought he was absolutely spectacular. Um and I saw him in Tommy actually, and he was spectacular in that. But but Tommy's a weird character, you know. But but Hedwig, he was really just brilliant. Um, but I I don't know about him in something like that. I you know, I I just I maybe I was just exhausted or closed-minded, but it I couldn't really go there. It was very um straight. Unlike the gay, the gay finishing the hat we've come to love from Mandy Patinkin.

[1:08:32] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally.

[1:08:34] Ben Rimalower: Totally. I mean, I I do like it when it's a little more um, it's not quite so emo, it's a little more like, well, how do you want it's turning back too late? I feel like um in Mandy's contract negotiation for this, um, they were like, uh, so we assume you want to sing finishing the hat. He was like, No, I don't. I I I want to sing uh lesson number eight. And they were like, uh, oh, okay. And he's like, I want Jake to sing Move On. And I want Ja, and I want Cerverus to do finishing the hat. That's what I want.

[1:09:13] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally.

[1:09:16] Ben Rimalower: Uh okay, so next up, Linda Lavin singing uh an album, singing from an album that we've actually talked about on the podcast with Varla Jean Merman.

[1:09:28] Daniel Nolen: Yes, mad show.

[1:09:29] Ben Rimalower: Uh singing The Boy From, which what did she say? Like it's a Brazilian Pastiche, no takeoff parody, something like that.

[1:09:32] Daniel Nolen: Parody, something like that. She might have just said it's a Brazilian number.

[1:09:43] Ben Rimalower: I mean, she her her uh comedic chops.

[1:09:49] Daniel Nolen: 82 years old bitch.

[1:09:51] Ben Rimalower: I was so into it. Although a lot of gays seem to be not gays, I just associate Twitter with gays, but like a lot of people on Twitter were coming for her because they were like, uh oh, is she gonna get Sondheim cancelled for his 90th birthday? Because I guess you know, the song is a little um, what's the word? Uh appropriation appropriate not appropriation, but it's like a little uh um I I feel like those people are missing like the layers. I mean, it's it's actually like a parody of a kind of Brazilian appropriation that was being done in the 60s. I mean, it's like, you know, uh it's it's so I I don't know, I I don't I don't buy that. Um but uh you know um the worst thing for Linda Lavin is how good she looks because she doesn't get credit for how old she is, you know.

[1:10:46] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, she does look amazing.

[1:10:48] Ben Rimalower: I mean, she looks the same age as Patty, right?

[1:10:54] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:10:55] Ben Rimalower: Well, she's you know, over 10 years older.

[1:10:58] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:10:59] Ben Rimalower: Um the one thing I also thought, and this is no shade to Linda, but I really wish Carol Channing had performed this song at some point.

[1:11:08] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally.

[1:11:09] Ben Rimalower: I can see it's the great, it's the great Carol Channing Sondheim number that never happened. Um then uh next up, Alexander Gemignani, Buddies Blues. I mean, this was like as good as you could possibly hope for in like a full out like musical theater performance for this gig. Um and uh I I never quite get the whole journey with Alex. Like I always like start to go there, and in the end I'm just kind of like almost, you know. But but it was very good, and he worked so hard, and like, you know, I mean, he's got I love his dad so much. How can I not love him?

[1:11:52] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah, totally.

[1:11:53] Ben Rimalower: Um he he did do something that um it reminded me of something you said in Fire Island last summer whenever we were all um doing our little karaoke performance night, and I remember you you stopped and you stopped everyone, and you were like, listen, this is for everyone. Like, it's your job to be your own director, stage manager, use the space, use whatever props you need. And I felt like he was very good at that, like using his space, like he used his chair for a lot of uh movement choices. Uh, and so I did appreciate that. Like, he really committed it and used what he had. I love that, unlike most straight men, when he did uh Margie and Sally's voices, uh, you know, for Margie, he did the typical straight man's version of a woman, which was like, you know, I love him, you know. But when he did Sally, she was like furs, fur. I mean, Sally was like as played by like Roz Russell or Lauren Bacall or something. And yeah, that that is my kind of uh aping a woman, you know.

[1:13:01] Daniel Nolen: Um okay, then uh Anna Hirata and I just wrote down Anne because I didn't realize then everyone else was coming in, so I don't remember the other ones, but Ann Harada and company singing someone in a tree.

[1:13:15] Ben Rimalower: So great.

[1:13:17] Daniel Nolen: So good, and I'm so glad Pacific Overtures uh had some you know play. Uh so so glad. And like I um I just uh I I I feel like I appreciated that song in a new way, having it sort of like dumbed down into like this version for me, as opposed to like when I saw Pacific Overtures at 54 Below 100 years ago. I was really drunk when I saw it, so no wonder I didn't understand it. But I um this really helped me to finally understand. And I loved having a woman's voice in the song. I I love I always love hearing Ann's voice anyway, but yeah.

[1:14:02] Ben Rimalower: I I really thought it was great.

[1:14:04] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I did too. And I woke up this morning um still in my Sondheim uh hangover, and uh I wanted to immediately put this song on because I was like, that's this is the song I remember from last night, and I want to listen to it more and take a journey with it.

[1:14:22] Ben Rimalower: Um so I will be doing that today. Um someone else I'd like to take a journey with uh sexually is Raul Esparza, who came up next with singing the the title the title song, Take Me to the World. And I mean, as as as you know, annoyed with him as I was at the beginning of the show for like not knowing how to work his microphone and like Which I'm which I'm sure by the way, I don't think I don't blame him for that.

[1:14:51] Daniel Nolen: No, no, no, no, of course not.

[1:14:52] Ben Rimalower: But like of course, um, you know, I I I felt bad for him because I I was like he's probably so like mad and uh irritated right now. But he he is first of all, I love his voice. And I actually loved his um I never saw it, but I mean I've seen it online, but I I listened to his uh company a lot in college. That was really the first company I I knew. And uh I loved it. And um yeah, his voice, uh it's so good and and he's so fucking hot I just can't stand it that's it okay you're not into it um I've never been a big fan of his really yeah I love him so much I don't know I mean I just think he has he's so beautiful and he also just has like this I first of all I don't find him attractive I don't know I've never really yeah oh my god I am like do you know there's a whole do you know have you ever been to the website Data Lounge I'm sure I have I I there's this website Data Lounge it's like a gossip chat board not chat board gossip message board and um for everything um uh you know from politics pop culture whatever um but there's always uh a long theater thread on it and most people on data lounge you know posting to data lounge are not talking about theater but there's always one thread that's about Broadway musicals and stuff you know and there's all these funny memes that just last for years on data lounge um like there's this woman Marianne Lepinto who uh she like writes for talk in Broadway and um I'm sure she's never been to Data Lounge in her life.

She's like this really kooky eccentric like old lady who like you know like writes like reviews for talk in Broadway of like cabaret shows like at like the duplex you know, but but there's a whole meme on talk on Data Lounge of like people pretending to be her and like making the same kinds of typos she would make.

[1:17:10] Ben Rimalower: Um so there's like all these weird things that just last for years.

[1:17:14] Daniel Nolen: Um and there's one of them was that back in the day when Raul Esparza was not like out as gay in the gossip thread, they would be like Raul Esparza and his bisexual cock.

[1:17:26] Ben Rimalower: Um and then that changed to uh the initials of Raul Esparza.

[1:17:32] Daniel Nolen: Um, and it was like A B S C and in parentheses, and then that changed to the parentheses got longer because it became and his bisexual cock that shoots loads of Cuban poppy cum.

[1:17:49] Ben Rimalower: My god.

[1:17:51] Daniel Nolen: I'm telling you, it's so random. But so for years, and now like nobody would type his name on Data Lounge without putting a parentheses, like it's like LGBTQIA, you know, there's just like a lot, yes, yes, yes. It's so funny.

[1:18:05] Ben Rimalower: Um that's my favorite thing about Raul Esparza.

[1:18:11] Daniel Nolen: I mean, that's so shocking to me. Like, I just find him so uh captivating, and like I just I mean, I'm so attracted to him.

[1:18:20] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[1:18:22] Daniel Nolen: Um yeah, and I and I loved, I mean, even though he is um is he gay or bi, or what is his actual I think he identifies as gay, but you know.

[1:18:34] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[1:18:34] Daniel Nolen: Um, but he does, I mean, he's someone to me, like as Bobby and company, I like bought him as like mask, you know, like a like a masculine bachelor.

[1:18:44] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, no, I think he's very talented. I mean, I I thought he was very good in company. I didn't I didn't love that production, and ultimately I did not enjoy his being alive, but like I I did think he was good in that show.

[1:18:58] Daniel Nolen: Um, okay, so here we go. We're in the final stretch, and this is when things really yeah, crack that can, baby, because this is when things really went up to the next level.

[1:19:13] Ben Rimalower: I mean, this was like the 11 o'clock. This was literally the 11 o'clock number, but like this is when all the 11 o'clock numbers started. This is when um I don't even know. It was just like things got elevated to the next level of stardom and choices and performance. I mean, every I mean, I this is this these next performances will be talked about for years to come. First of all first of all, starting with Donna Murphy singing Send in the Clowns with like a complete set behind her.

[1:19:55] Daniel Nolen: Um, the art direction, the hair and makeup, the tits.

[1:19:59] Ben Rimalower: I mean, everything was so perfect, including, of course, her performance of Send in the Clowns.

[1:20:08] Daniel Nolen: Uh-oh.

[1:20:09] Ben Rimalower: Why are you being quiet?

[1:20:11] Daniel Nolen: I didn't love it. You know, I was very I was very excited when it started.

[1:20:16] Daniel Nolen: I was very excited that she was doing it. I loved the presentation. Um, and I liked how it began because I was watching all this Sondheim stuff, you know, and I was thinking the thing about Send in the Clowns is like we've talked about this before. Like, um, I mean she did have the kind of accompaniment that I love. You know, what we talked about that, how I what was the version that I hated because it didn't have the accompaniment I like, you know.

[1:20:41] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I don't remember.

[1:20:43] Daniel Nolen: I've gotta have that like dun dun dun dun dun dun dun dun. Yes, thank you, exactly that. And um, you know, my uh my favorite is like the Elaine Stritch, you know, or you know, yes, that is my favorite. But I also like big vocal ones. I love the Judy Collins, I even like the Frank Sinatra, you know, and and the thing about it, and I like the Barbara Streisand, you know, and I like the Betty Buckley. And when uh I always had like the Glenn Close one, although I realize now if you're gonna go for that, you might as well go for Judy Dench, who just acts it so much better, you know.

[1:21:20] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, um yeah, but you know, Orline Stritch. Uh, but I I remember like laughing at Patty when we did it when I I assisted Lonnie Price on the Ravinia Festival concert version of night music where Patty was Desiree and uh George Hearn and Sarah Miras and all these people. And um, and I remember thinking, like, you know, here Patty was like, you know, sort of unhappy that she didn't have a lot to sing as Desiree. Um, as a matter of fact, they added for her at the start of the second act for the night waltz, they used the arrangement of that that had been done in the Houston Grand Opera for Frederica von Stade as Desiree.

[1:21:56] Daniel Nolen: So the act two of night music at Ravinia opened with the Libus Leaders singing The Sun Won't Set, but also Patty coming down the stairs, you know, the san, you know, just like literally so funny. Clave o'clock, stylight, o'clock, you know. No joke. All of a sudden it was like, it was like we were watching Matters of the Heart. But um so funny. And yet, despite that, when she sang Send in the Clowns, you know, the thing is when you get someone like Glenn Close or Catherine Zeta Jones, who's like not really a singer, and this is like their one big chance to sing with the big kids, you know, you know, they get to the end of the song and they're like, maybe next year. You know, they really want to like belt it out for you, you know.

[1:22:51] Ben Rimalower: Whereas like, you know, Patty, and I have to say I felt the same about Bernadette and the in the Broadway production, you know, they're very like, well, maybe next year. You know, they or they don't even go up, you know, maybe next year. I mean, they're just like, they're not looking to make it a vocal showcase. And I remember being like, come on, Patty, you know, give it a little gas, you know. So that said, I really appreciate, you know, when someone like Judy Collins is really like, no, like I'm not Judy Dench, but I am a real singer, and this is one of the most beautiful melodies written by one of the most brilliant composers that ever lived, and I'm going to sing the shit out of it, you know.

[1:23:30] Daniel Nolen: Or, you know, and Barbara Cook does a beautiful version because she gives it all of her voice, you know. And so I really like that in the beginning, Donna was very like, isn't it rich? Are we a pair? You know, just really singing the notes, you know. But then it was like very Bernadette losing my mind at the end, where she was like wimping out and like not, you know, and she was letting her emotions get the best of her, which, you know, I'm sure were overwhelming her. But it felt the thing about I love Donna Murphy because I truly believe she is the Meryl Streep of musical theater.

[1:24:05] Ben Rimalower: Mm-hmm.

[1:24:06] Daniel Nolen: But when you're the Meryl Streep whose forte is your craft, you don't get to just be emotionally overwhelmed, you know, because you're always coming across a little calculated, which is okay, you are calculated. It's art, it's artifice, you know, but therefore you don't get to be overwhelmed. I need you to like always be living in the craft, you know. And so for me, it just at the end when she was like a little choked up and like speaking some of the lyrics, I was just kind of like, what's the Ariana Grande song?

[1:24:40] Ben Rimalower: Thank you, next.

[1:24:41] Daniel Nolen: Yes. Um I don't know. I didn't really even, I mean, I was just so like not paying attention to that. Like I I see what you're saying, but I didn't even really notice that. I I was just so um into the whole like uh scene that she was creating. I mean, I wasn't trying to notice it. I wasn't sitting there with like a notebook being like check mark on this, failure on that, B on this. I mean, I started off just wanting to be like Donna Murphy, take me away. You know?

[1:25:15] Ben Rimalower: I yeah.

[1:25:15] Daniel Nolen: But by the way, when you choose send in the clowns, you invite that, you know.

[1:25:20] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[1:25:20] Daniel Nolen: If you're like, I'm singing a song that was cut from Assassins, it's all you, baby. You know, right? You could do whatever you want, and I'm just like in your hands, you know. But when you sing send in the clowns, you like have a little bit of an uphill battle, and you like gotta bring it. I I feel.

[1:25:38] Ben Rimalower: Um, so Donna saying that, and I uh, you know, I thought it was was good. And then uh next up, we had okay. So next up, you know, before each person, they had uh some little illustration, and then they had the name of the person and the song they were singing. But for this one, it was just the title of the song, Ladies Who Lunch. So I was already suspicious of what was coming. Cause I was like, uh oh. Because I thought it was gonna be Patty.

[1:26:10] Daniel Nolen: And then it was Christine Baranski. I was like, oh, okay. So like they wanted to surprise us by not telling us who it was, because we thought it would be Patty, and now it's Christine. What a nice surprise.

[1:26:21] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, well, and then she started saying I knew it wasn't gonna be Patty because she'd said in that Daily Beast article that she was singing a ballad and she was already.

[1:26:28] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, that's right. She was already regretting that she didn't do a comedy number. Um with Christine, uh, I was pretty happy that it was Christine because I was like, I mean, I have very low expectations of her voice since she sucked so badly in the City Center Encores Follies. Um, like I was just like not expecting much, but nonetheless, I would I wouldn't care if she was off key and like just like a broke down dirty hoe. Like I just I just think Christine Baranski is so brilliant and so perfect for Joanne.

[1:27:07] Daniel Nolen: I was like ready to live, ready to live with her. And the fact that she was in a bathrobe with like a glass of red wine and like a weird angle, like her iPad just like sitting on the table in front of her. That was a bad angle. I was like, you are a star and I am here for you.

[1:27:23] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, that's I mean that's how you know the people who are the true stars uh in these live streams is because they're like, they've only ever been photographed in their lives. They've never been behind the camera. They've never worked it themselves. So, like them not knowing their angles really, like not knowing where to put the camera, somebody tweeted, somebody tweeted, like, all these offer-only stars, not knowing how to do a self-tape.

[1:27:47] Daniel Nolen: Absolutely. 100% that. So just Christine literally like propping up her iPad against, you know, this wine bottle or whatever. And then No, not the wine. Maybe against the empty wine bottle she had earlier in the evening.

[1:28:02] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, the case. So anyway, she, I was like, you know, I'm here for this. I can't wait. And then when it cut over to Meryl motherfucking Streep, shaking. My brain exploded. Sh I screamed, uh, as did every other gay watching. And it was like, I cannot even remember the last time I felt such joy and elation, and I just I was so thrilled and I need to re-watch it.

[1:28:36] Daniel Nolen: I literally just jumped out the window. I I am dead on the street. I I I couldn't, I was just like farting glitter balls. I could not, I was bouncing off, I was literally jumping up and running around the room, just like I couldn't even watch. I was just too, it was too much for my little head. Too much. And then the Audra of it all, uh joining in. I mean And Audra, by the way, it's like she listened to our pod, and she decided to give you the kind of belting she hadn't done since I had never said I love you.

[1:29:06] Ben Rimalower: Totally.

[1:29:07] Daniel Nolen: Totally. And um It was almost like a fuck you to Patty, and I was glad for it.

[1:29:13] Ben Rimalower: Totally, absolutely.

[1:29:14] Daniel Nolen: I was She was like, she's like, hey Patty, remember when you could do a straight tone on this note? Ah. I mean, this. I mean, this was like um this this will be played for for years to come. And this is another thing that made me think of summer plans. I was like, I cannot wait to re-watch this over and over at Sunday Show Tunes in the Pines because you know this will be one of those videos like um, you know, Patty Anything Goes, Jennifer Holliday at the Tony's, uh, you know, You Don't Own Me from the First Wives Club.

[1:29:50] Ben Rimalower: This will be a video that's played at gay bars for years and years to come.

[1:29:54] Daniel Nolen: Listen, COVID 19 is only for now. But the Christine Meryl Audra Ladies Who Lunch is forever.

[1:30:05] Ben Rimalower: Totally.

[1:30:06] Daniel Nolen: So I mean, this was like um, you know, uh uh You Don't Own Me or like the the white dress trio from uh the leading ladies concert. I mean, this this this will go on the artwork for this week. This will go on the t-shirt.

[1:30:20] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah.

[1:30:22] Daniel Nolen: So we need t-shirts or a bathrobe, maybe. Um if Sondheim lives to be a hundred, they need to do this number live.

[1:30:32] Ben Rimalower: 100%.

[1:30:33] Daniel Nolen: Maybe even if he just lives to be 91.

[1:30:35] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally.

[1:30:37] Daniel Nolen: Um, but I have to say, Meryl, I mean, she is just so dependable and always delivers. And this was no exception. Her specific acting choices and her use of props was a genius. I mean, I I was transfixed, and you know, at this point, I'm like, of course, Meryl Streep's the greatest actress of our time, but like she still impressed me and like took it to a next the next level that I was not expecting.

[1:31:09] Ben Rimalower: And totally shaking that cocktail shaker and then like drinking from that bottle of bourbon or whatever and Scotch, bottle of scotch.

[1:31:09] Daniel Nolen: Scotch, bottle of scotch, and um uh yeah, and then just her little like Meryl like thinking moment that she had, like, it was all just working, working, working. Divine.

[1:31:35] Ben Rimalower: So divine.

[1:31:36] Daniel Nolen: Um P. S. Nothing makes me happier than Audra McDonald being not one of the Broadway people doing a solo.

[1:31:46] Ben Rimalower: Yes.

[1:31:47] Daniel Nolen: But one of the one of the one of the movie stars in this little like novelty number.

[1:31:53] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally.

[1:31:54] Daniel Nolen: I was so happy for that as well. I was like, you know what? Audra's not gonna sing, you know, not a day goes by.

[1:32:02] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally.

[1:32:03] Daniel Nolen: Audra has earned the right to be Christine Baranski.

[1:32:07] Ben Rimalower: Yes, she's earned the right to sing like uh a trio comedic bit with with uh Baranski and and Streep. By the way, if that's not casting for a meme revival, I don't know what is totally.

[1:32:21] Ben Rimalower: Oh my god. We could do a whole other episode on that.

[1:32:25] Daniel Nolen: Um anyway, so then okay, so then we had a nice little B side uh to this, which was uh Jake and Annalie Ashford singing move on. Which again, I was like, this is like another level. This is like another caliber of like again, like Jake is such a movie star, but like this is such another caliber of acting, and like I I just felt so like I wasn't just watching like a concert or like when I was it's like chip.

[1:32:57] Ben Rimalower: I mean, they this they've done this song. This is their real history in this performance, and and Jake was good, but I have to say Annalie I I just am I'm in on Annalie Ashford. Hook line and sinker like she I feel like if anybody else had been playing Dot whenever I watch anybody else play dot, all I do is think you don't sing it as well as Bernadette, or even if you sing it as well as Bernadette, you're not as special as Bernadette.

[1:33:35] Daniel Nolen: And it it never works for me because I feel like you're not special like Bernadette.

[1:33:40] Ben Rimalower: And I watch Anna Lee, and I feel like she is special.

[1:33:46] Daniel Nolen: Yes, 100%.

[1:33:47] Ben Rimalower: I couldn't have said it better.

[1:33:48] Daniel Nolen: It's like there is something about her so special. She has um that star quality, she has um her unique take on the role that's original, but also um when her voice, when her voice does things that Bernadette's uh when she can't when she doesn't do it the way Bernadette did, if for half a second you start to miss Bernadette, then Anna Lee does something new that's wonderful.

[1:34:13] Ben Rimalower: She gives us something, she gives us more to see.

[1:34:16] Daniel Nolen: Absolut yes, yeah.

[1:34:17] Ben Rimalower: Anything you do, let it come from Ann Lee Ashford.

[1:34:20] Daniel Nolen: Yes, and I would love that.

[1:34:23] Ben Rimalower: Um we do not belong.

[1:34:27] Daniel Nolen: She does these little like swoops that I live for, and I actually listened to this track. Whenever I listen to Move On, I usually listen to this version because uh I love her her vocals. It's um those little slides are so delicious, and she's someone who I feel like there's so many um Broadway leading ladies of her kind of class, if you will.

[1:34:51] Ben Rimalower: Like I don't mean I mean like graduating class, like her generation.

[1:34:55] Daniel Nolen: Yes, yes.

[1:34:56] Ben Rimalower: Um who I'm I don't care about. I could, you know, or I I think they're talented and and great to watch, but like I don't, you know, obsess about like dreamcasting them or where their career will go or like what roles I want to see them in when they get older. Annalie is is different. She's like um, like I want her to be the one who the torch is past to, you know, totally with the Bernadett's and the Paddies and um Audra, you know.

[1:35:12] Daniel Nolen: I want her to be the next big Broadway lady of our, you know, next generation or whatever.

[1:35:31] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[1:35:32] Daniel Nolen: Um so yeah, I love that. And I and I I don't always love Jake, but I I just thought he was he just seemed so like open and and uh receptive and and and um he was perfect looking that song that if he had done finishing the hat, I probably would have been annoyed with him. But but move on is about her, and he delivers, you know, he he delivered what he needed to deliver beautifully.

[1:36:00] Ben Rimalower: That's a very good point.

[1:36:02] Daniel Nolen: Um okay, so next up was uh Patty's aforementioned ballad.

[1:36:08] Ben Rimalower: Anyone can whistle.

[1:36:10] Daniel Nolen: And with a very short intro.

[1:36:12] Ben Rimalower: Classy, it was very it was very classy, Patty.

[1:36:15] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:36:16] Ben Rimalower: Um, in front of her bookcase, uh wearing like a beautiful like uh jacket um blouse.

[1:36:26] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, like what'd you call me?

[1:36:28] Ben Rimalower: Um yeah, and I loved it. I mean, you know, we all want the big belty number from Patty or the comedic number, but um, you know, I was into it.

[1:36:40] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, me too. I mean, I um I uh I I actually rewatched Patty's the only one I've watched a second time. I rewatched her this morning.

[1:36:50] Ben Rimalower: Um and uh and I liked it much better this morning than I did last night. Um it really got good by the end. I I feel like in the beginning she does a little bit of that, I don't know if it's a rhythm thing or just like her fucked up diction. You know, people are so critical of Patty's bad diction, and that never bothers me, you know. Uh because I feel like when Patty's diction is bad, she's actually still really like in a very like good acting moment. You know, when she's just sort of like feeling herself and like hurling out the vocal line. I love that.

[1:37:27] Daniel Nolen: But to me, I I don't like when, you know, it's like um, you know, I feel like I want someone to be like, anyone can whistle, you know, and Patty's like, anyone can whistle. Like I there's something awkward about the way her diction is when she sings some of these sometimes songs, you know.

[1:37:45] Ben Rimalower: And she's like, uh it it it bugs me. And also, I don't know if it's I we need to I need to research this, but I'm pretty sure she sings the wrong lyric. I think it's supposed to be like maybe you could show me how to let go, not maybe you can show me how to let go. Maybe you and I could be wrong. Maybe Patty's singing what Steve told her to sing, you know. But for some reason, every time that happens, something in my brain goes, wrong words, Patty. This is why they wouldn't put you in Sunday in the park with George. God.

[1:38:15] Daniel Nolen: Oh my God.

[1:38:18] Ben Rimalower: And I I just uh, you know, I I thought she she sounded beautiful and there was real genuine emotion behind it. And like I said, this morning it won me over much more than it did last night. And I certainly was not disappointed in it. I just it it wasn't my heart didn't really soar. It was not one of my favorite things of the night.

[1:38:39] Daniel Nolen: Right.

[1:38:40] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[1:38:40] Daniel Nolen: I agree with that. Um, and then closing out the show was my favorite thing of the night.

[1:38:50] Ben Rimalower: Really?

[1:38:52] Daniel Nolen: Okay. Now this was another one that was on my wish list was for Bernadette to sing No One is Alone.

[1:38:57] Ben Rimalower: Yes.

[1:38:58] Daniel Nolen: And I was so transported. It was like what I said about Chip Zion, but like a thousand times more, and like even better. It was like Bernadette singing No One is Alone, Acapella, and now when she used to sing No one is I guess she probably still does. When she does that song, of course she still does it in concert, she never fucking changes her goddamn concerts. But you know, but but when Bernadette does it in concert, it's like insanely slow, it's like impossibly slow. It's like if Cola Scola did that as a Bernadette parody, people would be like, that's too far, that's over the top. She doesn't really sing it that slow. Come on.

[1:39:40] Ben Rimalower: But like she sings it so goddamn slow. And I love it, but it's very, very, very, very, very, very, very slow. And this was the opposite. This was almost like sped up, you know. And so at first I was like, I was like, she's going too too fast. It's like gonna, you know, but but no, that was like the whole thing. It had an urgency, you know. It was like it was so intimate. It was like Bernadette delivering this thing right to me, you know.

[1:40:05] Daniel Nolen: And her like broke down, damaged voice that's been like stampeded on by a herd of elephants, you know, she just stays right in it, and she just she figures out how to place that next note. And sometimes it's like a real leap of faith. And and and last night, except for one time when she cracked, which made it even that much more it just felt like Bernadette was so in this moment, and she was singing a song that she knows so deeply down in her toes, and yet every single lyric, she was like finding a new application for it in this moment, you know, and like like with the Chip Zion No More performance, it was like on one hand, so familiar and comforting and soothing, but on the other hand, so real and dark and stark and you know, just heartbreaking, but but in a way that was just so everything I needed it to be, and I just I felt less alone when Bernadette sang that to me, it felt like it was to me, and it felt like this entire experience of the last six weeks and the last six hours since I first sat down and waited to watch the you know it it felt like it all came together, and like I just I I've never in it honestly, like I wasn't like this is good for Bernadette now, but obviously I still like her better in Sunday Park with George.

I was like, this is the greatest. This was to me, this was the top of the mountain of all my years of watching Sondheim, listening to Angela and Elaine and seeing Bernadette and all the Sondheim experiences I've had have all built up to this one moment that was like the Ten Commandments coming down the mountain and like God. I literally I felt like there was God in Bernadette last night.

[1:42:06] Daniel Nolen: Well, I need to maybe I need to rewatch it because I was like not feeling it at the time. Um I think I I think I'm just a greedy little bitch, and I was like, ugh, I don't want her to sing an a cappella. I want her to sing it with like, you know, accompaniment so I can feel like this is an actual like performance, and um, you know, I want I don't know. I I I was I I was just not feeling it, but I need I want to. I want to feel the Ten Commandments.

[1:42:29] Daniel Nolen: I don't love when people do a cappella anyway, but like I don't know. I feel bad for saying this now because I feel like I'm everyone else, is what you were saying. It's like everyone else was living for it and was saying this was the highlight. So um I think I need to revisit, but in the moment I was just like, no, I want her to, you know, have uh have her proper, her proper number, you know, with like music.

[1:43:01] Ben Rimalower: If I saw Bernadette on the street, I would walk up to six feet away from her exactly. And I would fall down and take off my face mask, and I would put my naked lips on the pavement.

[1:43:09] Daniel Nolen: Naked lips.

[1:43:22] Ben Rimalower: Anyway, is that it? Um, there was the insulting Andre de Shields relegated to the I'm still here over the credits.

[1:43:31] Daniel Nolen: Oh, really? I didn't even know.

[1:43:32] Ben Rimalower: Uh I was like, I thought it was over, so like I had already like started getting ready for bed at that point. I didn't realize he was in that. I mean, it's not fair to call it insulting because they had all the people that were in Broadway shows on hold, you know, or a lot of people from Broadway Shows on Hold singing, of which he is one. And because he's Andre de Shields, they featured him more than a lot of those people as well.

[1:43:54] Daniel Nolen: They should.

[1:43:55] Ben Rimalower: But what it wound up feeling like was like he didn't get a real solo. And you know, granted, he has no Sondheim association.

[1:44:00] Daniel Nolen: Right.

[1:44:03] Ben Rimalower: Um, I mean, I think he probably did do Sondheim at some point in his career in you know, regional or whatever. But you know, but he's not a Sondheim associate. But um, but you know, neither is Josh Groban, you know. I don't know. And you know, people were talking about representation, and I I don't want to get into all that. I don't even, you know, have a perspective on that, but but it it did feel a little weird. Um, but the I'm still here was fun, and it was cute to have all those people. I I maybe I'll go back and watch it.

[1:44:33] Daniel Nolen: Um anyway, okay. Well, that was fun, and uh truly what a uh an emotional journey last night from even this morning. In this morning. I mean, like I said, I was I I was so tired last night. Like we were gonna record last night, and I just like couldn't do it. And I got in bed and I felt so like I my brain would not stop buzzing. Like I could not stop thinking about everything. Um, even when I woke up in the middle of the night, I was still thinking about it. Um so yeah, I mean, it was so much pretty special.

[1:45:09] Ben Rimalower: Well, tune in to our live streams on Tuesday and Thursday, 10 30 a.m., but then continuing on the internet forever. I'm sure we'll still be talking about this.

[1:45:18] Daniel Nolen: As we will on next week's episode of QuaranStreams, when we quarantine stream the 1992 concert, Sondheim, a celebration at Carnegie Hall.

[1:45:28] Ben Rimalower: Yes, yes. A nice little um uh what's the uh follow-up?

[1:45:33] Daniel Nolen: Companion piece, yes.

[1:45:36] Ben Rimalower: All right, say goodbye, Ben.

[1:45:38] Daniel Nolen: Goodbye, Ben.

[1:45:43] Ben Rimalower: Thanks for listening to Ben Rimalower's Broken Records on Broadway World. For more episodes, visit Broadway World, iTunes, Stitcher, or wherever podcasts do be. Come back next week for our QuaranStream of Sondheim, a celebration at Carnegie Hall, an all-star event for the ages featuring Betty Buckley, Bernadette Peters, Patti LuPone, Liza Minnelli, Dorothy Loudon, and Glenn Close.

[1:46:05] Daniel Nolen: Findable on YouTube via our broken records QuaranStreams playlist, as uploaded under the veiled title Musical Theater Master Serenaded by the Greats in 1992.

[1:46:15] Ben Rimalower: What Queen came up with that?

[1:46:17] Daniel Nolen: This one! It's on my YouTube channel. And be sure to check out our new twice-weekly live stream video chat. Tuesday, Thursday, April, August. Available on the Broadway World Facebook page and the Broadway Podcast Network YouTube channel, Tuesdays and Thursdays at 10:30 a.m.

[1:46:33] Ben Rimalower: This episode was edited by me, Daniel Nolen. Thanks to Emmy winning composer and lyricist Lance Horn for the broken records theme song. Follow us both, Ben Rimalower and Daniel Nolen on all y'all socials. That's Ben Rimalower, B-E-N-R-I-M-A-L-O-W-E-R.

[1:46:50] Daniel Nolen: And that's Nolan with an E, not Nolan with an A.

[1:46:53] Ben Rimalower: Because Nolan with an A, is an A.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred